Fascicle 13 · 經律異相卷第十三(聲聞無學僧第一僧部第二) · Complete

Arhat Śrāvaka Monks

This page carries Ru-Yi's complete translation of fascicle 13 of the Jīng Lǜ Yì Xiàng (經律異相): "Arhat Śrāvaka Monks, Part 2" (聲聞無學僧部第二) — fifteen entries centered on named disciples of the Buddha: Mahākāśyapa's marriage to a fellow golden-skinned ascetic and their shared renunciation, his begging from a dying beggar woman, his own leadership of the First Council and expulsion of Ānanda until his defilements were exhausted, the taming of the three Kāśyapa brothers' fire-breathing dragon at Uruvilvā, Subhūti's birth and past life, and several episodes from Aniruddha's own past lives and present teaching.

Translator: Ru-Yi Meditation Center Status: fascicle 13 complete Source: Taishō T2121, vol. 53, fascicle 13 Compiled by: Bǎochàng and others, 516 CE

Translation Method

Fascicle 13 opens a new topical section — arhat śrāvaka monks, named disciples of the Buddha who reached the exhaustion of outflows in this very life — as distinct from the bodhisattvas of the preceding fascicles. It carries fifteen entries organized loosely around individual figures: Mahākāśyapa, Piṇḍola, Kauṇḍinya, the three Kāśyapa brothers of Uruvilvā, Subhūti, and Aniruddha. Two pairs of entries sharing a single figure and near-identical framing are grouped together here despite minor separation in the original sequence, while every entry's full text remains intact.

Fascicle Contents

  • 1. Kāśyapa's Golden Marriage 迦葉身黃金色婦亦同姿出家得道
  • 2. Kāśyapa Begs from a Poor Old Woman 迦葉從貧母乞食
  • 3. The First Council 迦葉結集三藏黜斥阿難使盡餘漏
  • 4. Kāśyapa Enters Kukkuṭapāda to Await Maitreya 迦葉結法藏竟入鷄足山待彌勒佛
  • 5. Four Elders Who Vowed to Wait for the Dharma's End 大迦葉賓頭盧君屠鉢歎羅云不般涅槃至佛法滅盡
  • 6. Piṇḍola's Banishment 賓頭盧以神力取樹提鉢被擯拘耶尼
  • 7. Two Causes Behind Kauṇḍinya's Priority 憍陳如拘隣等五人先得道二緣
  • 8. The Three Kāśyapa Brothers of Uruvilvā 欝鞞羅那提伽耶三迦葉受佛化悟道
  • 9. Subhūti's Past Life of Giving 須菩提前身割口施僧得生天上
  • 10. Subhūti's Birth and Going Forth 須菩提初生及出家
  • 11. Aniruddha Mistaken for a Woman 阿那律端正或謂美女欲意往向自成女
  • 12. Aniruddha Converts a Prostitute 阿那律化一婬女令得正信
  • 13. Aniruddha's Past Life as a Reformed Thief 阿那律先身為劫以箭挑佛燈得報無量
  • 14. Aniruddha's Past Life as a Poor Laborer 阿那律前生貧窮施緣覺食七生得道
  • 15. Piṇḍola and the Elder's Sister 阿那律等共化跋提長者及姊

1. Kāśyapa's Golden Marriage

A young ascetic, hoping to make marriage impossible, tells his parents he will accept only a bride with skin the color of pure gold — and finds, to his own dismay, that such a woman actually exists, setting up a marriage neither partner wanted that becomes, through a single misunderstood act of compassion, the path by which both eventually go forth together.

Chinese Source

迦葉父者。曰尼俱律陀。摩竭國人也。出自婆羅門種。宿命福德生世大富。珍奇寶物國中第一。財比國王。千分少一。夫婦孤獨乏無兒息。近在舍側有大樹神。時彼夫婦為欲有兒。三牲祭祠累歲不遂。其人大忿便與期七日。若復無驗當剪罰汝。棄都道頭以火燒之。神聞驚怖。上告息意天王。天王即將神。告天帝釋。帝釋即以天眼觀欲界中。未有堪任為彼子者。乃告梵王。梵遍觀見。一梵天臨當壽終。便告之曰。汝可生閻浮提。為尼俱律陀作子。梵天對曰。婆羅門者多諸邪見。我若下生不能為其作子。梵王答曰。彼婆羅門宿時大德。欲界眾生無有堪任為作子者。汝若往生。吾當勅天帝釋令擁護汝。不使中道墮邪見也。梵天曰唯。帝釋即以告樹神。樹神還告長者。勿見瞋恨。却後七日必令有子。七日已滿婦便有娠。十月乃生。身黃金色而有光明。相師占曰。此兒宿福有大威德。志力清遠不貪世務。若後出家必登聖道。父母聞之復大愁。憂恐兒出家至年十五。欲為娶婦。迦葉聞之累啟父母。我志樂清淨不須婦也。父母不聽迦葉又言。若然不用凡女人。得紫金色女端正無比。乃當取之。欲令此事不可辦也。父母令其國中推覓之。諸婆羅門即為設策。鑄金作神女。顏貌端正光色微妙。如眾天像。從國至國高聲大唱。諸有女人得見金神。禮拜供養者後出嫁時。當得好婿。體黃金色顏貌姝妙。智慧無比。聚落國邑諸有女人。聞此唱者莫不虛心。皆出奉迎禮拜供養。唯有一女軀體金色。端正姝好獨處閑室不肯出迎。諸女諫曰。其有見金神者。皆得如願。汝何以獨不出迎。答曰。吾志閑靜不好餘願也。諸女復曰。雖無所願暫共一觀。當復何損。諸女相携遂共出看。金女光色乃映金神。婆羅門還報長者具。即遣媒人到其女家。宣長者意。其女父母先亦聞迦葉名。敬承往意遂相然可彼女聞之甚大愁憒。父母所逼事不獲已。遂適迦葉。二人相對志各凝結。雖為夫婦了無恩情。便共結誓。我與君等各處異床。要不相觸。爾時夫婦各處一床。其父母聞迦葉雖共同室。而復異床。其父尋復遣人持床去。於是夫婦唯共一床。其婦更與夫誓。我若眠時。君當經行。時其婦臥。一臂垂地。有大毒蛇欲來嚙之。迦葉見已有慈愍心。持衣裹手舉著床上。尋時驚覺便大瞋怒。語迦葉言。我先有要。如何相犯。迦葉報言。汝臂落地毒蛇欲嚙。是故相救非故觸也。指蛇示之。其婦乃悟。於是夫婦自相與議。我等何不出家修道。遂辭父母。俱共出家。入山行道。時有婆羅門。將五百弟子。亦住此山。見迦葉夫婦共相隨逐。於時迦葉便捨其婦。以五百兩金。貿緻納衣別處一林。其婦即依止婆羅門。求為弟子。婆羅門五百弟子。見此女人形色端正。日日行婬。女人不得自在。遂不能堪。便告其師。師便為之。戒約弟子。令節所欲。迦葉後值佛出世。聞法受化。即得羅漢。聞其本婦在梵志邊。便將詣佛。佛為說法。得阿羅漢。頭髮自落法服在身。成比丘尼。遊行教化。正值波斯匿王大會。諸比丘尼便得入王宮裏。教化諸夫人。皆令持一日齋。王暮還宮。命諸夫人。皆云持齋。無肯來者。王便大瞋。語使人言。誰教諸夫人齋。使人答言。某甲比丘尼。王便呼來。令九十日代諸夫人受淫欲。此皆是昔日之因緣。誓願所造。故雖得羅漢。不能相免也(出雜譬喻經第四卷)。

Ru-Yi Translation

Kāśyapa's own father, Nyagrodha, was a man of Magadha, born into a brahmin family, blessed with such wealth through past merit that his treasures ranked first in the whole kingdom — a fortune falling short of the king's own by only a thousandth part. He and his wife, alone and childless, lived beside a great tree inhabited by a spirit; for years the couple offered animal sacrifices there seeking a child, without success, until, enraged, the husband gave the spirit seven more days, threatening to cut it down and burn it at the crossroads if it failed him again. Terrified, the tree spirit reported this to the heavenly king Praśāntamanas, who in turn told Śakra. Śakra, surveying the desire realm with his own heavenly eye, found no being there fit to become this couple's child, and so appealed to Brahmā, who, searching further, found a Brahmā-heaven deva about to die, and told him he should be reborn in Jambudvīpa as Nyagrodha's own son. The deva protested that brahmins hold many false views, and that he feared being unable to remain their true son if reborn among them — but Brahmā answered that this particular brahmin's own past virtue was great, and that among beings of the desire realm none but this deva was fit to be his son; should he go, Brahmā himself would have Śakra protect him from falling into false views along the way. The deva agreed, and Śakra relayed word to the tree spirit, who told the couple not to be angry — within seven days they would surely have a son.

The seven days passed, and the wife conceived; after ten months, she bore a son whose body shone golden. A physiognomist, examining him, declared that this child, blessed by past merit with great and majestic virtue, held so pure and remote a resolve, free of worldly ambition, that should he ever go forth, he would surely attain the sagely path — news that only deepened his parents' own worry, fearing he might indeed leave the household life. When he turned fifteen, they wished to arrange his marriage; hearing this, Kāśyapa repeatedly told them that his own resolve was set on purity, and that he needed no wife at all. When they would not relent, he told them that, if he must marry, he would accept only a woman of unmatched beauty with skin the color of pure gold — thinking this condition impossible to satisfy and thereby avoid the marriage entirely.

His parents had the whole kingdom searched, and the brahmins, devising a plan, cast a golden statue of surpassing, radiant beauty, like an image of the gods themselves, and proclaimed from country to country that any woman who came to venerate and make offerings to this golden goddess would, upon marrying, receive a husband of matching golden beauty and unmatched wisdom. Women everywhere, hearing this, flocked eagerly to bow and make offerings — save one woman, herself golden-skinned and of unmatched beauty, who remained alone in her own quiet chamber and would not go out. Her companions urged her, saying that everyone who saw the golden goddess had her wish fulfilled — why should she alone refuse to go? She answered that her own resolve was set on tranquility and wanted nothing else — but, pressed further that a single glance could cost her nothing, she finally went along with them to see it, and her own golden radiance outshone the goddess itself.

The brahmins reported this fully to Kāśyapa's father, who sent a matchmaker to her family, declaring his own intentions; her parents, having already heard of Kāśyapa's own reputation, respectfully agreed to the match. The woman herself, hearing this, was deeply distressed, but, pressed by her parents and unable to refuse, married Kāśyapa regardless. The two of them, facing each other, each held their own resolve firm — and though now husband and wife, felt no affection between them at all, and together vowed to sleep in separate beds, never to touch one another. When their parents learned that, though sharing a room, the couple slept apart, Kāśyapa's father had the second bed removed, forcing them to share a single bed — at which the wife made a further vow with her husband: that while she slept, he would remain awake, walking in meditation.

One night, as she slept with one arm hanging off the bed's edge, a great venomous snake approached to bite her — and Kāśyapa, moved to compassion, wrapped his own hand in cloth and lifted her arm back onto the bed. Startled awake, she grew furious, accusing him of breaking their own vow — but Kāśyapa explained that her arm had fallen and a venomous snake threatened to bite it, and that he had acted only to save her, not to touch her out of desire, pointing to the snake as proof. Understanding then, the two of them agreed together: why should they not simply go forth and cultivate the path instead? They took leave of their parents and together renounced the household life, entering the mountains to practice.

A brahmin teacher with five hundred disciples also dwelt in that same mountain, and, seeing Kāśyapa and his wife traveling together, Kāśyapa resolved to part from her, exchanging five hundred taels of gold for a patched robe and settling apart in a separate grove. His wife then took refuge with this same brahmin teacher, seeking to become his disciple — but his five hundred students, seeing this woman's own fine appearance, pursued her daily with lustful advances she could not escape, until, unable to bear it further, she reported this to the teacher, who then admonished his own students to restrain their desires.

Kāśyapa later encountered the Buddha's own appearance in the world, and, hearing the Dharma and receiving his teaching, attained arhatship at once. Learning that his former wife still dwelt among the brahmins, he brought her to the Buddha as well; the Buddha taught her the Dharma, and she too attained arhatship, her hair falling away of itself and a monastic robe appearing upon her body, becoming a nun who traveled and taught widely.

It happened that King Prasenajit was holding a great assembly, and the nuns, gaining entry into the palace itself, taught the king's own consorts to keep a single day's fast. When the king returned to his palace that evening and summoned his consorts, all of them declared they were keeping the fast and none would come to him. Furious, the king demanded of his attendants who had taught his consorts this fast, and, told it was a certain nun, summoned her and forced her, for ninety days, to take the consorts' own place in serving his desire. All of this was the fruit of a karmic bond and a vow made in a past life — for though she had already attained arhatship, she could not thereby escape it (Source: Miscellaneous Similes Sūtra, fascicle 4).

Reading note — Ru-Yi

The compendium's own final line is the doctrinal point of the whole entry, and it is a hard one: arhatship, in this account, ends the arising of any new craving but does not retroactively cancel the ripening of a debt already set in motion by an earlier vow. The story is careful to locate that debt at a specific, earlier moment — the couple's own youthful pact to marry in form only — rather than anywhere in her conduct as a nun, and equally careful to record the king's own act as a grave wrong rather than a fitting consequence the text endorses. Read this way, the entry is less a story about the ending than a hard case built to test a claim the compendium takes seriously elsewhere: that karmic causes, once set, work themselves out on their own timeline, indifferent to how far a person has otherwise progressed on the path.

2. Kāśyapa Begs from a Poor Old Woman

Kāśyapa deliberately seeks out the poorest beggar in the city to give her the chance to make an offering — and, once Śakra himself tries to repay her kindness on her behalf by trickery, flies off in open annoyance at being deceived.

Chinese Source

迦葉捨豪富而從貧乞。入王舍城見一孤獨母。最甚貧困。街巷大糞聚上。傍鑿糞聚以為巖窟。羸劣疾病常臥其中。無有衣食。施一小籬以障五形。壽命將終。長者青衣。行棄米汁臭惡難言。母從乞之。即以破瓦盛著左右。迦葉哀之往乞多少。老母說偈。言其臭惡。迦葉猶以慈悲。忍而乞之。老母歡喜即以施。迦葉恐母不信豈能食之。即於母前飲畢盪鉢。示現神力。母大踊躍。一心遙視。迦葉告曰。母今何願。時母厭世苦。聞天上樂願生天上。數日壽終。即生第二忉利天宮。即念故恩求欲供養。釋提桓因聞是事已。即與天后持百味食盛小瓶中。下詣漏室。變其形狀。似于老人。織席貧窮。迦葉分衛見而往乞。夫妻告言。我今貧苦輒自割損。以施賢者。令吾得福。迦葉下鉢。乃開小瓶。香熏大城。迦葉即嫌。便入三昧。復身飛去。彈指歡喜(出摩訶迦葉度貧母經)。

Ru-Yi Translation

Kāśyapa, giving up begging from the wealthy in favor of the poor, once entered Rājagṛha and came upon a lone, destitute woman, the poorest of the poor, who had dug a shelter into a great heap of refuse in the street and lay there, weak and sick, without clothing or food, save a small screen of woven reed shielding her own body. Near death, she received only foul, discarded rice-water that a rich household's servant threw out, catching it in a broken shard. Kāśyapa, moved to pity, went and begged from her whatever she had. The old woman, in verse, protested that it was too foul to offer — but Kāśyapa, in his own compassion, insisted and accepted it regardless. Delighted, she gave it to him; and, fearing she might doubt whether he could truly eat such filth, he drank it before her at once and rinsed his own bowl clean, displaying his supernormal power. Overjoyed, the woman watched him intently, and Kāśyapa asked what she now wished for. Weary of this world's suffering and longing for heaven's own joys, she wished to be reborn there — and, within days, her life ended, and she was reborn at once in the second heaven, Trāyastriṃśa.

Remembering this kindness, she wished to repay it with an offering, and Śakra, hearing of this, went with his own queen, filling a small vessel with a hundred delicacies, and descended to the poor woman's own former dwelling, transformed in appearance as an old, poverty-stricken couple weaving mats. Kāśyapa, begging there, came upon them, and they told him: "We are poor and suffering ourselves, yet gladly give up what little we have to a worthy man such as you, that we might gain merit." As Kāśyapa lowered his bowl, they opened the small vessel, and its fragrance filled the entire city. Kāśyapa, displeased at being deceived, entered samādhi and flew away, snapping his fingers in joy nonetheless (Source: Sūtra of Mahākāśyapa's Deliverance of the Poor Old Woman).

3. The First Council

Warned by the devas that the Dharma itself is about to collapse without the Buddha's own presence, Kāśyapa summons every arhat to compile the Three Baskets — barring Ānanda alone from the assembly until his own remaining defilements are exhausted, which happens only in the instant his head fails to reach the pillow.

Chinese Source

諸天禮迦葉足。說偈讚歎。大德知不。法船欲破。法城欲頹。法海欲竭。法幢欲倒。法燈欲滅。說法人欲去。行道人漸少。惡人轉盛。當以大慈建立佛法。迦葉心如大海。澄清不動。久而答曰。世間不久。無智盲冥。迦葉思惟。我今云何。使三僧祇劫難得佛法而得久住。唯當結集三藏。可得久住耳。未來世人可得受行。佛世世勤苦。慈悲眾生學得是法。為人顯說。我等亦應承用開化。昇須彌山頂。鳴鍾揵搥。而說偈言。
諸佛弟子 若念於佛 當報佛恩
莫入涅槃
是揵搥音。及迦葉語。聲遍至三千大千世界。皆悉聞知。諸有弟子得神力者。集迦葉所。迦葉以天語告言。佛般涅槃諸知法弟子。皆隨滅度。佛法欲滅。未來眾生甚可怜愍。失智慧眼。愚癡盲冥。我等應當承用佛教。待結集法藏竟。隨意滅度。迦葉選得千人。唯除阿難皆得羅漢。頻婆娑羅王。得道常勅宮中飯食千人。阿闍世王不斷是法。迦葉思惟。若常乞食。當有外道強來難問。廢闕法事。到王舍城以事告王。王當給食。日日送來。夏三月安居。迦葉觀誰有煩惱。唯有阿難。大迦葉即數之云。犯六突吉羅罪。盡應僧中懺悔。阿難即隨教。長跪合手。偏袒右肩脫革屣懺悔。迦葉於僧中起。牽手出之。語言。汝宜盡漏。若殘結未亡。汝勿來也。便自閉門。與諸羅漢共議。誰能結集毘尼法藏者。長老阿泥盧豆言。舍利弗是第二佛。憍梵波提柔軟和雅。閑居燕寂皆能知毘尼藏。今在天上尸利沙樹園。使下座比丘往傳。迦葉意云。漏盡羅漢皆會閻浮提。僧有大法事。今可疾來。憍梵波提心疑。問曰。為鬪諍破僧耶。佛日滅度耶。答曰。大師滅度。我和上舍利弗今在何所。答曰。先入涅槃。憍梵波提問曰。目連阿難羅睺今何所作。答曰。目連已滅度。阿難由有憂結。愁苦啼哭不能自喻。羅睺已得羅漢無復憂苦。憍梵波提言。我和上大師皆已滅度。我今不能復下。即入涅槃。阿難思惟諸法求盡殘漏。坐禪經行定力少不時得道。後夜疲極欲息臥。頭未至枕廓然得悟。作大力羅漢。其夜到僧堂敲門。喚大迦葉。大迦葉言。汝何以來。答言。我今夜盡漏。迦葉言。我不與開門。汝從門鑰孔中來。阿難即從鑰孔中入懺悔。大迦葉莫復見責。迦葉手摩其頭。我故使汝得道耳。汝無嫌恨。我亦如是。大迦葉語阿難言。從轉法輪經。至大般涅槃。集作四阿含。增一中長相應。是名修妬路法藏。諸羅漢更問。誰能明了集毘尼法藏皆言。長老優波離。於五百羅漢中。持律第一。我等今請。優波離受教。坐師子座言。佛在何處。說毘尼結戒。時須提陀迦蘭陀長者子。初犯淫欲法。始結大罪。諸羅漢思惟。誰能明了。學阿毘曇藏。念。長老阿難於五百羅漢中。解修多羅義第一。我等今請。阿難受請。佛在舍婆提城。說五怖五罪五除五滅。以是因緣。此生身心受無量喜。復墮惡道中。如是等名阿毘曇藏(出大智論第二卷)。

Ru-Yi Translation

The devas bowed at Kāśyapa's own feet and spoke a verse in praise: "Great one, do you know? The Dharma-boat is about to break apart; the Dharma-city is about to crumble; the Dharma-ocean is about to run dry; the Dharma-banner is about to fall; the Dharma-lamp is about to go out; those who teach the Dharma are about to depart, and those who practice it grow ever fewer, while evil people only multiply — with great compassion, you must now establish the Buddha's own teaching firmly." Kāśyapa's own mind, calm and unmoved as the great ocean, answered only after a long while: "This world will not last much longer, sunk in ignorant darkness." Reflecting that the Buddha's own teaching, so hard to attain across three incalculable kalpas, must somehow be made to endure, Kāśyapa resolved that only by compiling the Three Baskets could it be preserved for future generations to receive and practice — for the Buddha himself, across lifetime after lifetime, had labored with compassion for beings to attain this very teaching and proclaim it to others, and they themselves ought now to carry it forward in turn. Ascending to the summit of Mount Sumeru, he struck the bell and gong, and spoke this verse:

"All you disciples of the buddhas, if you remember the Buddha, repay his own kindness now — do not yet enter nirvāṇa."

The sound of that gong, together with Kāśyapa's own words, reached throughout the whole trichiliocosm, heard by all; every disciple possessing supernormal power gathered at once to Kāśyapa's side. Kāśyapa told them, through his own heavenly voice: the Buddha has entered his own final nirvāṇa, and every disciple who truly knew the Dharma has likewise passed away or will soon do so; the Buddha's own teaching is about to perish, and future beings, deeply to be pitied, will lose the very eye of wisdom, sunk in ignorance and darkness — we ourselves must therefore uphold the Buddha's own teaching, and only once the compilation of the Dharma-treasury is complete may each of us enter final nirvāṇa as we wish.

Kāśyapa selected a thousand participants, every one already an arhat save Ānanda alone. King Bimbisāra, having attained the path himself, had always ordered his own palace to feed a thousand monks daily, and King Ajātaśatru continued this same practice unbroken. Reflecting that if the assembly went out begging as usual, heretics might come to challenge and disrupt their work, Kāśyapa reported the matter to the king at Rājagṛha, who agreed to provide their food, delivered daily, throughout the three months of the rains retreat.

Kāśyapa then examined who among them still harbored any affliction, and found only Ānanda. Enumerating six offenses of minor wrongdoing against him, Kāśyapa required him to confess these before the assembled sangha. Ānanda obeyed, kneeling with joined palms, baring his right shoulder, removing his sandals, and confessing — whereupon Kāśyapa rose within the assembly, took him by the hand, and led him out, telling him: "You must now exhaust your own remaining defilements entirely — do not return to us until you have done so," and shut the door behind him.

Kāśyapa then consulted with the assembled arhats over who might compile the Vinaya-treasury. The elder Aniruddha suggested Śāriputra, "a second buddha" — though he had already entered nirvāṇa — or the gentle and refined Gavāmpati, who, dwelling in quiet retreat, thoroughly knew the Vinaya-treasury, and was presently in the heavenly grove of the Śirīṣa tree; a junior monk was sent to summon him. Kāśyapa's own message explained that every arhat with exhausted defilements had now gathered in Jambudvīpa for a great matter of the sangha, and that he should come quickly. Gavāmpati, suspicious, asked whether some dispute had split the sangha, or whether the Buddha himself, the sun of the Dharma, had set — and, told that the great teacher had indeed entered nirvāṇa, asked where his own preceptor Śāriputra now was, and was told he had already entered nirvāṇa as well. Asking further after Maudgalyāyana, Ānanda, and Rāhula, he was told Maudgalyāyana had likewise passed away, that Ānanda, still bound by grief, wept without consolation, and that Rāhula, having attained arhatship, was now free of such sorrow. Gavāmpati said: "My own preceptor and great teacher have both already entered nirvāṇa — I too shall not now descend," and entered nirvāṇa himself on the spot.

Ānanda, meanwhile, reflecting on all dharmas in search of his own remaining defilements' exhaustion, sat in meditation and walked in contemplation, yet his own concentration proved too weak to attain the path in time. Exhausted late into the night, he wished only to rest and lie down — and, before his head even touched the pillow, was suddenly, completely awakened, becoming a great and powerful arhat on the spot. That same night he went to the assembly hall and knocked, calling out to Kāśyapa. Kāśyapa asked why he had come, and, told that his own defilements were now exhausted, said: "I will not open the door for you — come in through the keyhole instead." Ānanda entered through the very keyhole and confessed once more. Kāśyapa, no longer holding any reproach, stroked his head, saying: "I did this only to bring you to the path — bear me no resentment for it; I too was treated so in my own time."

Kāśyapa then told Ānanda: "Beginning from the Sūtra of the Turning of the Dharma-Wheel through to the Great Nirvāṇa Sūtra, compile these into the four Āgamas — the Ekottarika, the Madhyama, and the Saṃyukta among them — and this shall be called the Sūtra-Piṭaka." The arhats then asked who could clearly compile the Vinaya-Piṭaka, and all agreed: the elder Upāli, foremost in upholding the Vinaya among the five hundred arhats — and requested him accordingly. Upāli, accepting, took the lion's seat and asked: where was the Buddha, and what precept did he establish, on the occasion when the elder's son Sudinna of Kalandaka first committed the offense of sexual misconduct, thereby establishing the first grave transgression? The arhats then further asked who could clearly compile the Abhidharma-Piṭaka, and, recalling that Ānanda, among the five hundred arhats, was foremost in understanding the meaning of the sūtras, requested him in turn. Ānanda, accepting, recounted: the Buddha, in the city of Śrāvastī, taught the five fears, the five offenses, the five eliminations, and the five cessations — through which, in this very life, one experiences boundless joy in body and mind, yet may still fall into an evil rebirth if these are not upheld — and such teachings together came to be called the Abhidharma-Piṭaka (Source: Mahāprajñāpāramitā-śāstra, fascicle 2).

Reading note — Ru-Yi

Kāśyapa's own treatment of Ānanda is deliberately harsh by the standard of ordinary courtesy — barred from the compilation, made to confess minor faults before the assembly, then locked out entirely — and the story does not soften this into an unfortunate necessity; Kāśyapa says outright, afterward, that he did it "to bring you to the path," a stated method rather than an apology. Ānanda's own awakening arriving in the single instant between standing and lying down, neither sitting in formal meditation nor yet asleep, reads as the story's own quiet argument that realization does not always reward the effort aimed directly at it — sometimes it arrives only once striving itself, including the striving to attain it in time for the council, has been set down.

4. Kāśyapa Enters Kukkuṭapāda to Await Maitreya

Having finished compiling the Dharma, Kāśyapa does not simply die but seals himself inside a mountain that closes around him like a womb, preserving his own body and the Buddha's own discarded robe intact until Maitreya himself comes to claim them.

Chinese Source

迦葉結法藏竟。入鷄足山。破為三分。於中鋪草布地。即自思惟。而語身言。如來昔以糞掃衣。覆蔽於汝。乃至為彌勒法藏應住於此。因說偈言。
我以神通力 當知於此身
以糞掃衣覆 至彌勒出世
時我為彌勒 教化諸弟子
即起三三昧。如一入涅槃以三山覆身。如子入母腹。而自不失壞。二若阿闍世王來。先約相見。來者山應當開。阿闍世若不見我。當吐熱血死。三阿難來山開。彌勒與九十六千萬弟子來此。取迦葉身以示眷屬。令悉學我持戒功德(出阿育王經第七卷)。

Ru-Yi Translation

Having completed the compilation of the Dharma-treasury, Kāśyapa entered Mount Kukkuṭapāda, "Cock's Foot," which split into three peaks around him; spreading grass upon the ground within, he reflected and spoke to his own body: "The Tathāgata once covered you with a discarded, patched robe — you must now remain here until Maitreya's own Dharma-treasury arises," and spoke this verse:

"By my own supernormal power, I shall preserve this body,
covered still in this discarded robe, until Maitreya appears in the world;
I shall then, on his behalf, teach and convert his disciples."

He then entered the threefold samādhi, and, as though passing into his own nirvāṇa, the three peaks closed over his body, as a child returns unharmed into its own mother's womb. Should King Ajātaśatru come first to see him, by prior agreement, the mountain would open for him alone — and, should he fail to see Kāśyapa there, he would vomit hot blood and die. Should Ānanda come, the mountain would likewise open. When Maitreya himself arrives, together with ninety-six hundred million disciples, he will come to this very place and take up Kāśyapa's own body to show his own followers, that they might all learn from the merit of his upheld precepts (Source: Sūtra of King Aśoka, fascicle 7).

5. Four Elders Who Vowed to Wait for the Dharma's End

Four great disciples vow not to enter final nirvāṇa until the Buddha's own teaching has entirely perished from the world — Kāśyapa alone remaining sealed inside a mountain until Maitreya arrives to take up his robe and body in front of an entirely new age of disciples.

Chinese Source

彌勒佛。亦以三乘法。教我弟子。大迦葉者。當佐彌勒勸化。又君屠鉢歎比丘。賓頭盧比丘。羅云比丘。四大聲聞。約不般涅槃。須佛法沒盡。然後乃般涅槃。大迦葉住摩竭國界毘提村中山。彌勒當與數千人往至其所。諸鬼神等。當為開石門見其禪窟。時彌勒佛。申右手指。以示迦葉。告諸民人。過去久遠釋迦佛弟子。名曰迦葉。頭陀第一。今故現在。彌勒佛。當取迦葉僧伽梨著之。迦葉身體奄忽星散。彌勒取種種花。當供養迦葉。有敬心故(出彌勒下生經)。

Ru-Yi Translation

Maitreya Buddha, teaching his own disciples likewise through the three vehicles, will be assisted by Mahākāśyapa in this task of conversion. Besides him, the monks Kuṇḍopadhānīya, Piṇḍola, and Rāhula — four great śrāvakas in all — have vowed not to enter final nirvāṇa until the Buddha's own teaching has entirely perished, only then to do so. Mahākāśyapa dwells within a mountain in the village of Videha, in the kingdom of Magadha; Maitreya, together with several thousand followers, will go to that very place, where spirits will open the stone gate to reveal his own meditation cave. Maitreya Buddha will then extend his right hand to point out Kāśyapa, telling the assembled people: "Long, long ago, a disciple of Śākyamuni Buddha, named Kāśyapa, foremost in ascetic practice, is still present even now" — and, taking up Kāśyapa's own patched robe, will put it on himself. Kāśyapa's own body will then suddenly scatter like stars, and Maitreya, gathering flowers of every kind, will make offerings to him out of reverence (Source: Sūtra of Maitreya's Descent and Birth).

6. Piṇḍola's Banishment

Piṇḍola wins a householder's own showy challenge by retrieving a bowl through samādhi alone — and is banished for life from Jambudvīpa by the Buddha himself for the very feat, on the grounds that displaying such power before the uninitiated is itself a fault, whatever the provocation.

Chinese Source

王舍城中樹提居士。入海客還。餉一栴檀作鉢。置絡囊中。懸高杙上言。若沙門婆羅門。能不以梯杖得者。便取。富樓那等皆言。欲見神力掉頭而去。賓頭盧。姓頗羅墮詣樹提。樹提言。善來頗羅墮。能不以梯杖取鉢者與。賓頭盧入定。伸手取鉢。居士以盛滿飯授之。食已持去。有一比丘。少欲知足。問從何處得。賓頭盧具說上事。少欲比丘訶責言。為受赤裸外道物。云何名比丘。於未受大戒人前。現過人聖法。訶已白佛。佛集僧。問賓頭盧。汝實作是事不。答言。實爾。佛語頗羅墮。盡形擯汝。不應得在閻浮提住。賓頭盧。奉教還房。付臥具床榻還僧。持衣鉢。從閻浮提沒。現瞿耶尼。教化四眾廣興佛事(出十誦律六誦第二卷僧祇彌沙塞四分大同小異)。

Ru-Yi Translation

A householder in Rājagṛha named Jyotiṣka, returning from a sea voyage, was given a sandalwood bowl, which he placed in a net bag and hung high atop a pole, declaring that any monk or brahmin who could retrieve it without ladder or pole might keep it. Pūrṇa and others, though wishing to see such a feat performed, merely shook their heads and left. Piṇḍola, of the Bhāradvāja clan, went to Jyotiṣka, who told him: "Welcome, Bhāradvāja — whoever retrieves this bowl without ladder or pole may have it." Piṇḍola entered samādhi and, reaching out his hand, took the bowl at once; the householder filled it with rice and gave it to him, and, having eaten, he departed with it.

A certain monk of few desires and easy contentment asked him where he had obtained it, and, told the whole story, rebuked him severely: "To accept an object from an outsider's own naked challenge — how does this befit a monk? To display a superhuman, sagely feat before those who have not even received full ordination is improper" — and reported the matter to the Buddha. The Buddha assembled the sangha and asked Piṇḍola whether he had truly done this, and, told yes, said to him: "Bhāradvāja, you are banished for life — you may no longer dwell in Jambudvīpa." Piṇḍola, accepting this teaching, returned to his quarters, handed over his bedding and couch to the sangha, and, taking up his robe and bowl, vanished from Jambudvīpa, appearing instead in Godānīya, where he continued to teach and convert the fourfold assembly, widely furthering the Buddha's own work (Source: Sarvāstivāda Vinaya, sixth recitation, fascicle 2; largely the same, with minor variations, in the Mahāsāṃghika, Mahīśāsaka, and Dharmaguptaka Vinayas).

Reading note — Ru-Yi

The Buddha's verdict makes no reference at all to Piṇḍola's own motive or the outsider's own provocation — the offense is treated as located entirely in the act of display itself, occurring in front of the not-yet-ordained, regardless of who issued the challenge or why. Piṇḍola's banishment reads less as a punishment ending his own usefulness than as a permanent field promotion: exiled from Jambudvīpa, he simply continues the very same work of teaching and conversion in Godānīya instead, suggesting the rule being enforced here is about where and to whom such power may be shown, not whether a monk of his own ability should keep teaching at all.

7. Two Causes Behind Kauṇḍinya's Priority

Two separate past lives explain why Kauṇḍinya and his four companions were the very first to hear the Buddha's own teaching: once, they were merchants he ransomed by giving his own life at sea; another time, they were woodcutters who ate the flesh of a fish-king who threw his own body into a river to end a famine.

Chinese Source

佛在迦毘羅衛國。尼拘盧陀僧伽藍。諸釋問佛。憍陳如等。宿有何緣。如來出世法鼓初振。最先得聞甘露始降便蒙沾澤。異口同音稱讚無量。比丘聞之。以事白佛。佛言。非獨今日先度五人。我於久遠亦濟此等。以身為船。救彼沒溺全其生命。吾今成佛先拔濟之。比丘白佛。此事云何。佛言。過去閻浮提。波羅㮈國王。名梵摩達。時有薩薄。名勒那闍耶。遊外林間見有一人。涕泣悲切。以索繫樹。以頭入羅。自殺取死。便前問之。汝何以爾。喻令捨索。報言。貧窮負債。債主剝奪。日夜催切。天地雖曠容身無處。故避此苦。爾時薩薄。即語之曰。卿但自釋。所負多少悉代汝償。作是語已。彼人便休。歡喜踊躍。隨從薩薄俱至市中。宣令一切云。欲償債。時諸債主。競共雲集來者無限。空竭其財猶不畢價。妻子窮凍乞匃自活。時有眾賈。勸進薩薄。欲共入海。即答之曰。我今窮困無所復有。何緣得從。眾人報言。我等眾人凡有五百。出錢開分共辦船具。眾人投合獲金三千兩。薩薄以金千兩辦船。千兩辦糧。千兩用待船上所須餘給妻子。便於海邊。施作大船船成馳去。便於道中。卒遇黑風。破碎船舫。眾人無依。中有五人。共白薩薄。依汝來此。今當沒死。危險垂至。願見拔度。薩薄答曰。吾聞大海不宿死屍。汝等今者悉各捉我。當殺身以濟爾厄。誓求作佛。後成佛時。當以無上法船度汝生死。作是語已。以刀自刎。命斷之後。海神起風吹至彼岸。得度大海皆獲安隱。欲知爾時勒那闍耶者。今我身是。時五人者。拘隣等是(其一出賢愚經第十卷)。

佛在羅閱祇竹園中。阿難又以問佛。阿若憍陳如伴黨五人。宿有何緣。法鼓初震獨先得聞。佛言。先世之時食噉我肉致得安隱。是故今日先得法食用致解脫。過去劫時此閻浮提。有大國王。名曰設頭羅健寧。領閻浮提八萬四千國。有火星現。相師白王。當旱。天遂不雨經十二年。王大憂愁。計現民口。算數倉庫一切人民日得一升。猶尚不足死亡者眾。王自念曰。當設何計濟活人民。即立誓言。今此國人飢羸無食。我捨此身願為大魚。以我身肉充濟一切。即上樹端自投於地。即時命終。於大河中為化生魚。其身長大五百由旬。時有木工五人。各齎斤斧往至河邊。規斫林木。魚曰。汝等須食。來取我肉飽齎還去。後成佛時當以法食濟脫汝等。汝告國人須食者來。五人歡喜具如其語。語於國人展轉相報遍閻浮提悉皆來集。噉食其肉一脇肉盡。即自轉身復取一脇。食盡還生。如是翻覆。恒以身肉給濟一切。經十二年。其諸眾生食肉者皆生慈心。命終生天。時設頭羅健寧王者。則我身是。時五伐木人。憍陳如等是。其諸人民後食肉者。今八萬諸天。及諸弟子得度者是(其二出賢愚經第四卷)。

Ru-Yi Translation

The Buddha dwelt at the Nyagrodha Monastery in Kapilavastu. The Śākyas asked the Buddha what past karmic bond caused Kauṇḍinya and his companions to be the very first to hear the Dharma-drum sound at his own awakening, first to receive the nectar of his teaching as it descended, praised by all with one voice beyond measure. The monks, hearing this, reported it to the Buddha, who said: it is not only in this present life that I first delivered these five — long ago, too, I rescued them, using my own body as a boat to save them from drowning and preserve their lives; now that I have become a buddha, I have delivered them first once again.

The monks asked how this had come about, and the Buddha explained: long ago, in Jambudvīpa, under King Brahmadatta of Vārāṇasī, there lived a caravan-leader named Ratnajaya, who, wandering in a forest outside the city, came upon a man weeping bitterly, a rope tied to a tree, his own head placed in the noose, about to hang himself. Asked why, the man explained that, deep in debt and hounded day and night by his creditors, he found no place left in the whole world to escape this suffering. The caravan-leader told him to release the rope at once — he would repay the man's entire debt himself. Overjoyed, the man followed him to the marketplace, where the caravan-leader announced to everyone that he intended to settle this man's debts — and creditors gathered from every side, so many that his entire fortune was exhausted and still could not cover it all, leaving his own wife and children to beg for their survival.

A group of merchants then urged the caravan-leader to join them on a sea voyage — but he answered that, now utterly destitute, he had nothing left to invest. They told him that among their own five hundred number, each would contribute a share to outfit a ship together, and, pooling their funds, they raised three thousand taels of gold, of which the caravan-leader used a thousand to build the ship, a thousand for provisions, and the remaining thousand to support his own wife and children during the voyage. The ship, built by the shore, set sail — but, partway through the journey, met a sudden black storm that wrecked the vessel entirely, leaving everyone stranded with nothing to hold onto.

Five men among them appealed to the caravan-leader, saying they had trusted him and followed him this far, and now, facing certain death, begged him to save them. The caravan-leader answered: "I have heard that the great ocean never keeps a dead body afloat — take hold of me now, every one of you, and I shall give my own life to save you from this peril," vowing that, should he attain buddhahood, he would deliver them from birth and death itself by the unsurpassed Dharma-boat. Having spoken this, he cut his own throat with a knife — and, once his life had ended, the sea spirits raised a wind that carried the survivors safely to shore, every one of them delivered from the sea in peace. Know that this caravan-leader Ratnajaya was my own former self, and that those five men were Kauṇḍinya and his companions (this first account drawn from the Sūtra of the Wise and the Foolish, fascicle 10).

The Buddha, dwelling in the Bamboo Grove at Rājagṛha, was asked again by Ānanda what past karmic bond caused Ājñātakauṇḍinya and his four companions to be first to hear the Dharma-drum at his own awakening. The Buddha answered: in a past life, they once ate my own flesh and thereby found peace and safety — and it is for this very reason that they are now first to receive the food of the Dharma and attain liberation through it.

Long ago, in Jambudvīpa, there ruled a great king named Shètóuluó Jiànníng, governing eighty-four thousand kingdoms of Jambudvīpa. When a fiery star appeared in the sky, court astrologers warned the king of coming drought, and indeed no rain fell for twelve years. The king, deeply troubled, calculated his own people's numbers against his granaries' own stores, and found that even at a single pint of grain per person daily, supplies would still run short, and many would die of starvation. Reflecting on how he might save his own people, the king made a vow: "My country's people are starving with nothing to eat — I shall give up this very body and become a great fish, that my own flesh might feed them all." He then climbed a tree and threw himself down, dying at once — and, transforming, was reborn in a great river as a fish five hundred yojanas in length.

Five woodcutters, each carrying an axe, came to that riverbank to cut timber, and the fish spoke to them: "If you need food, come take my own flesh and eat your fill, then carry the rest home — and when I attain buddhahood in a future life, I shall feed and deliver you with the food of the Dharma itself. Tell your own countrymen, too, that whoever needs food may come." The five, overjoyed, did exactly as told, spreading word throughout the whole kingdom until people gathered from every corner of Jambudvīpa to eat of its flesh. Once one flank was eaten bare, the fish would simply turn its body to offer the other side, which would then grow back once consumed — and so, turning again and again, it fed everyone continuously for twelve full years, during which time all who ate its flesh gave rise to compassionate hearts, and, at the end of their own lives, were reborn in heaven. That King Shètóuluó Jiànníng of the story was myself; those five woodcutters were Kauṇḍinya and his companions; and the people who later ate of its flesh are now the eighty thousand devas and disciples who have since attained liberation (this second account drawn from the Sūtra of the Wise and the Foolish, fascicle 4).

Reading note — Ru-Yi

The compendium offers two unreconciled explanations for the same fact rather than choosing between them, and the two causes are strikingly different in kind: the first is a ransom, a life given directly to five people who trusted him and would otherwise have drowned; the second is a debt of food, incurred simply by eating flesh offered freely by a fish that never met them beforehand as individuals at all. Placed side by side without comment, they suggest a working assumption behind much of this compendium's own causal reasoning — that gratitude and consequence can be created either by a direct, personal act of rescue or by the much more diffuse fact of having once been sustained by someone else's body, and that the Jīng Lǜ Yì Xiàng sees no need to decide which kind of debt is the more binding.

8. The Three Kāśyapa Brothers of Uruvilvā

An ascetic leader with a thousand devoted disciples watches the Buddha calmly subdue a venomous dragon he himself had warned would kill him — and, even after repeated displays of far greater power, keeps insisting privately that his own attainment remains unsurpassed, until an entirely wordless night of fire finally breaks his resolve.

Chinese Source

欝鞞羅婆界有梵志。名鞞羅迦葉。將五百螺髻梵志。已為尊者。鴦伽摩竭國皆稱為羅漢。佛到迦葉所語言。我欲寄止一宿。答言。不惜。但此室有毒龍恐相害耳。佛言。無苦。迦葉言。隨意。佛即入石室。結加趺坐直身正意。龍見放烟佛亦放烟。龍復放火佛亦放火。時石室中烟火俱起。迦葉遙見。瞿曇可惜為毒龍所害。佛即降龍盛置鉢中。明旦將往至迦葉所。告言。毒龍今在鉢內。迦葉念言。瞿曇雖得羅漢有大神力。猶不如我。白佛言。可止我當給食。佛曰。汝能身自及日時到者我當受請迦葉言。我當自來佛住食。食竟還石室宿。其夜入火光三昧照彼石室。迦葉即與徒眾圍繞。白佛。今時已到。可還就食。沙門昨夜何故有此大火。佛告迦葉。我昨夜入火光三昧。令此石室洞然大明。迦葉歎大威德。猶言不如我得羅漢。佛食竟更宿一林。明日迦葉復迎還食。佛言。汝並在前吾尋後往。先詣閻浮提樹。取此樹菓坐迦葉座。迦葉後到曰。云何已在先至耶。佛言。此菓色好香美汝可食之。迦葉念。此沙門有大神足。猶不如我得阿羅漢。佛食竟還本林坐。更放種種神力。欲攝取迦葉。四天王天釋提桓因等。並齎供具來供養佛。迦葉并五百弟子。捨事火具淨衣澡瓶。擲尼連禪水中。往詣佛所。佛次第為五百人說法。即於座上諸塵垢盡得法眼淨。皆白佛言。願欲出家。佛言。善來比丘。快修梵行。得盡苦際。即為受具足戒。迦葉中弟名那提。居尼連禪水下流。有三百弟子。迦葉小弟名伽耶。居象頭山。有二百弟子。二弟見兄服道。俱往問言。從此大沙門。修學梵行勝耶。答曰。極為勝妙。各與眷屬同詣世尊。佛為說法。於坐悟道得法眼淨。白佛。我等欲於佛法中修習梵行。佛言。善來比丘快修梵行得盡苦際(出四分律二分第九卷)。

Ru-Yi Translation

In the region of Uruvilvā there lived a brahmin ascetic named Uruvilvā-Kāśyapa, leading five hundred disciples with matted hair, already revered as elders, considered arhats by the whole of Aṅga and Magadha. The Buddha came to Kāśyapa's own dwelling and asked to lodge there for one night. Kāśyapa answered that he did not mind, but warned that the room held a venomous dragon that might harm him — the Buddha said this was no trouble, and Kāśyapa granted him leave. The Buddha entered the stone chamber, sat cross-legged, his body upright and mind composed; the dragon, seeing him, breathed out smoke, and the Buddha likewise breathed out smoke; the dragon then breathed fire, and the Buddha likewise breathed fire, until the chamber filled with both smoke and flame together. Kāśyapa, watching from a distance, lamented: "What a pity — Gautama will surely be killed by that venomous dragon."

The Buddha then subdued the dragon and placed it, docile, within his own bowl, and the next morning brought it to Kāśyapa, telling him: "The venomous dragon is now here in my bowl." Kāśyapa reflected: "Though Gautama has indeed attained arhatship and great supernormal power, he is still not equal to my own attainment" — and told the Buddha he might stay, offering to provide his meals. The Buddha answered that he would accept the invitation only if Kāśyapa himself came in person at the appointed hour each day. Kāśyapa agreed to come himself.

After eating, the Buddha returned to lodge again in the stone chamber, and that night entered the samādhi of fire-radiance, illuminating the whole chamber; Kāśyapa, seeing this great blaze from a distance, gathered his own disciples and went to the Buddha, saying: "The time has come — please come and eat. Śramaṇa, why was there such a great fire last night?" The Buddha answered that he had simply entered the fire-radiance samādhi, causing the chamber to blaze with light. Kāśyapa, marveling at this great and majestic power, still maintained inwardly that he himself was not thereby surpassed, since he too had attained arhatship.

After eating, the Buddha lodged that night in a different grove; the next day, when Kāśyapa came again to fetch him for the meal, the Buddha told him to go ahead, that he would follow shortly — and, going first to the Jambudvīpa tree, took its fruit and sat in Kāśyapa's own seat, arriving there before him. Kāśyapa, arriving afterward, asked how he had gotten there first, and the Buddha, offering him the fruit, said its color and fragrance were fine and that he should eat of it. Kāśyapa reflected once more on this great supernormal power, still maintaining that he himself was not thereby surpassed.

After eating, the Buddha returned to his own grove and sat, unleashing yet further displays of supernormal power meant to draw Kāśyapa toward the truth. The Four Heavenly Kings, then Śakra himself, each came bearing offerings to make to the Buddha — and Kāśyapa, together with his five hundred disciples, at last gave up their own fire-worship implements, along with their pure garments and water vessels, casting them into the Nairañjanā River, and came to the Buddha. The Buddha then taught the Dharma to all five hundred in turn, and, seated there, every defilement dissolved and they attained the pure Dharma-eye, declaring their wish to go forth. The Buddha said: "Welcome, monks — practice the pure conduct diligently, and reach the very limit of suffering," and conferred upon them the full monastic precepts at once.

Kāśyapa's own middle brother, Nadī-Kāśyapa, dwelling downstream along the Nairañjanā River, had three hundred disciples of his own; his youngest brother, Gayā-Kāśyapa, dwelling at Gayāśīrṣa, had two hundred disciples. Seeing their elder brother take up the path, the two younger brothers went to ask him whether following this great śramaṇa's own pure conduct was truly superior — and, told that it was indeed superior and wondrous, each went with his own followers to the World-Honored One. The Buddha taught them the Dharma, and, seated there, they too awakened and attained the pure Dharma-eye, declaring: "We too wish to cultivate pure conduct within the Buddha's own teaching." The Buddha said: "Welcome, monks — practice the pure conduct diligently, and reach the very limit of suffering" (Source: Dharmaguptaka Vinaya, second division, fascicle 9).

Reading note — Ru-Yi

Kāśyapa's own repeated verdict — "still not equal to my own attainment" — survives three consecutive, escalating demonstrations of power he cannot match: taming the dragon, illuminating an entire chamber with a body of fire, and simply arriving somewhere before him without being seen to travel. What finally moves him is not a fourth, still greater display, but the arrival of the Four Heavenly Kings and Śakra himself as witnesses — suggesting that Kāśyapa's own resistance was never really about the scale of what he saw, but about maintaining his own status before his five hundred disciples, a position that becomes impossible to hold only once devas themselves are seen paying homage to someone else.

9. Subhūti's Past Life of Giving

The past life behind Subhūti's attainment: flesh cut from his own mouth and given to the saṅgha, and a birth in the heavens as its result.

Chinese Source
須菩提前身割口施僧得生天上九

舍衛國有長者。名曰拘留。無有兒子。禱神求之。天於空中而語之曰。長者福多無堪生者。是以無子。有天王壽終應生君家。後生兒名須菩提。端正聰辯慈仁博愛。白其父母。今欲請佛。父母聽許。即便請佛廣設供養。復白父母求作沙門。父母聽之。即隨如來還至祇洹便作沙門。應時得阿惟顏。神通具足隨俗教化。在弟子中現作羅漢。阿難白佛言。此須菩提本修何功德。佛言。此人無數世時作貧家子。逢一比丘入城分衛遍無所得。爾時年少見其鉢空。作禮白言。願隨我歸當相供養。即隨到家取己食分供養道人。而自不食。道人食竟現飛而去。年少歡喜即發道意。緣是功德。後生天上九十一劫。今復來生長者家。爾時年少者今須菩提也。一施之福尚乃如此。況復多乎(出福報經)。

Ru-Yi Translation
Subhūti's Past Life of Giving

In Śrāvastī there lived an elder named Kuru, without any son, who prayed to the spirits for one. A voice from the sky told him: your own merit is so great that no ordinary being could be born to you — that is why you have no son as yet; but a certain heavenly king, near the end of his own life, shall be reborn into your household. A son was later born to him, named Subhūti, of fine appearance, eloquent, compassionate, and broadly loving. Subhūti told his own parents he wished to invite the Buddha, and they consented; he then made lavish offerings, and further asked to become a monk himself, which they also allowed. He followed the Tathāgata back to Jetavana and became a monk at once, immediately attaining the stage of a bodhisattva of one more birth, complete with every supernormal power, teaching and converting according to the needs of the world, manifesting among the disciples as an arhat.

Ānanda asked the Buddha what merit Subhūti had originally cultivated to attain this — and the Buddha answered: countless lifetimes ago, this man was born the son of a poor household, and once met a monk who had gone begging throughout the city without receiving anything at all. Seeing the monk's own empty bowl, the young man bowed and said: "Please come home with me, and I will provide for you" — and, bringing him home, took his own portion of food and offered it entirely to the monk, eating nothing himself. Once the monk had eaten, he rose and flew away — and the young man, overjoyed, gave rise to the resolve for the path at once. Through the merit of this single act, he was reborn in heaven for ninety-one kalpas, and has now been born once more into an elder's own household. That young man of the past was Subhūti himself. Such is the merit of even a single act of giving — how much more, then, of many such acts (Source: Sūtra of the Fruits of Blessing).

10. Subhūti's Birth and Going Forth

Subhūti's birth — the storehouses found empty and then full — and his going forth.

須菩提初生及出家十

昔舍衛國有大長者。名曰鳩留。財富無數無有子息。遍禱諸神了不能得。空中天曰。卿當得福子。有一天王垂應命終生長者家。長者大喜。却後七日第一夫人即覺有娠。月滿生男名須菩提。色像第一聰明辯才。博愛多曉貴賤推敬。其見聞者有所作為。轉以法樂勸益一切。諸父兄弟共嫉恚之。語其母言。此兒不念。治家遊蕩無度。母言。此兒福德不與凡同。後須菩提索食母令婢預洗空器。答其無有。須菩提發器視之。自然百味飯香美。一切共食皆得安隱。諸父兄弟方知非凡。請佛及菩薩大眾設食。食畢兒從父母求作沙門。父即聽之。隨佛還祇洹。即作沙門。應時得阿惟顏。在弟子中現作羅漢(出十卷譬喻經第一卷)。

Subhūti's Birth and Going Forth

Long ago, in Śrāvastī, there lived a great elder named Kuru, of boundless wealth yet without any son, who prayed to every spirit without success. A voice from the sky told him he would be blessed with a son — for a certain heavenly king, near the end of his own life, would be reborn into his own household. The elder, overjoyed, found that within seven days his principal wife had indeed conceived, and, when her term was complete, bore a son named Subhūti, of finest appearance, intelligent, eloquent, broadly loving, and honored by high and low alike; all who saw or heard of him found themselves drawn, through him, toward the joy of the Dharma, benefiting everyone around him.

His own uncles and brothers, growing jealous and resentful, told his mother that this child paid no mind to managing the household and wandered about without restraint — but she answered that this child's own merit was no ordinary thing. Later, when Subhūti asked for food, his mother had a servant girl wash an empty vessel in advance and tell him there was nothing in it — yet, when Subhūti opened the vessel to look, it was found filled of itself with a hundred fragrant, delicious kinds of food, which everyone present ate together and found themselves at peace. Only then did his uncles and brothers realize he was no ordinary child, and invited the Buddha and the great assembly of bodhisattvas to a meal. After the meal, the boy asked his parents to let him become a monk, and his father consented; he followed the Buddha back to Jetavana and became a monk at once, immediately attaining the stage of a bodhisattva of one more birth, and manifesting among the disciples as an arhat (Source: Sūtra of Similes and Parables, in ten fascicles, fascicle 1).

Reading note — Ru-Yi

The two versions divide the same underlying claim in two directions rather than repeating it outright: the first entry explains why Subhūti was born so blessed, tracing it to a single, specific act of giving in a former life; the second describes what that blessing actually looked like once he arrived, dwelling on the sky's own prophecy, the miraculous vessel, and his skeptical uncles' own change of heart. Neither telling explains the other's own missing half, and the compendium's decision to preserve both, six entries apart rather than fused into one continuous account, again reflects its own character as an anthology of independently transmitted sources rather than a single harmonized biography.

11. Aniruddha Mistaken for a Woman

A stranger, mistaking the fine-featured Aniruddha for a woman and moving to assault him, finds his own body suddenly transformed into a woman's the instant he discovers his mistake — a punishment lifted only once genuine remorse, sought out by Aniruddha himself, has taken hold.

Chinese Source

阿那律已得羅漢。有美顏容似於女人。獨行草中。時有年少見之。謂是女人。邪心既動欲往犯之。知是男子。自視其形變成女人。慚愧欝毒。自放深山遂不敢歸。經踰數年。其家妻子生不知處。謂已死亡。阿那律行分衛往至其家。婦人涕泣自說其夫不歸。乞與福力使得生活。阿那律默然不應。有哀念故乃至山中求與相見。此人便悔過自責。其身還成男子。遂得歸家家室相見也(出舊譬喻經下卷)。

Ru-Yi Translation

Aniruddha, having already attained arhatship, possessed such fine features that he resembled a woman. Walking alone through the grass one day, a young man, seeing him from a distance and mistaking him for a woman, felt desire stir within him and approached to violate her — only to discover Aniruddha was in fact a man. Looking down at his own body in shame, the young man found it had transformed into a woman's, and, overcome with such deep humiliation and distress that he could not bear to return home, fled into the deep mountains and remained there for several years. His own wife and children, not knowing where he had gone, believed him dead.

Aniruddha, out begging one day, happened to arrive at this very household, where the wife, weeping, told him of her husband's disappearance and begged him for whatever merit might restore her own fortune. Aniruddha said nothing in reply, but, moved by compassion, went into the mountains himself to seek the man out. Finding him, the man repented and reproached himself bitterly — and his own body was restored to that of a man once more, allowing him at last to return home and be reunited with his family (Source: Old Collection of Similes, lower fascicle).

12. Aniruddha Converts a Prostitute

Given shelter for the night by a prostitute who repeatedly propositions him, Aniruddha simply rises into the air rather than answer — a wordless refusal that shames her into genuine repentance and, within a single conversation afterward, into the Dharma itself.

Chinese Source

佛在祇樹園。時阿那律。往拘薩羅國。路無比丘住處。有一年少婬女安止賓客。阿那律即往語言。大姊欲寄止一宿。女答言。爾時有長者居士。亦投彼宿。住處既迫。女請阿那律入其內舍。爾時尊者在其坐處。結加趺坐繫念在前。時不淨行女然燈竟。於初夜末往阿那律所語言。近有諸長者婆羅門種。多諸財寶。皆來語我言。可為我作婦。我即語彼。汝等醜陋。不能為汝作婦。我觀尊者形貌端正可為我夫。時阿那律默然不答。女到後夜又復如是。由故默然。時此婬女既脫衣來欲抱持之。時阿那律以神足力。踊身空中。婬女見之生慚愧。即疾著衣叉手合掌。仰向懺悔如是至三。願尊者還坐本處。時阿那律即下本坐。此女人禮足却坐一面。阿那律為說種種妙法訶欲不淨稱讚離欲。女人即坐諸塵垢盡得法眼淨。時女見法既得法已。唯願聽許為優婆夷。即受五戒為佛弟子。仰願尊者受我供養。默然受之。施設種種甘饍食竟。說法令心歡喜(出四分律初分第八卷)。

Ru-Yi Translation

The Buddha dwelt in the Jetavana Grove. Aniruddha, traveling to the kingdom of Kosala, found no monastic lodging along the road, and came upon a young prostitute's house where travelers were received as guests. Aniruddha asked her: "Elder sister, might I lodge here one night?" She agreed. At that time an elder-householder had also come seeking lodging there, and, the space being cramped, the woman invited Aniruddha into her own inner chamber instead. The venerable one sat there cross-legged, his mind fixed in mindfulness before him.

Once the woman of unchaste conduct had finished lighting her own lamps, she came to Aniruddha in the early part of the night and said: "There are elders and brahmins of great wealth nearby who have all asked me to become their wife, but I told them: you are all too plain and unworthy — I have observed the venerable one's own fine bearing, and wish instead to make you my husband." Aniruddha said nothing in reply. She returned again in the latter part of the night and repeated the same request, and again he remained silent. The woman, having by now undressed, came to embrace him — at which Aniruddha, through his own supernormal power, rose bodily into the air. Seeing this, the woman, filled with shame, quickly dressed herself, joined her palms, and, bowing in repentance three times, begged the venerable one to return to his own seat.

Aniruddha then descended, and the woman bowed at his feet and sat to one side, whereupon he taught her the wondrous Dharma at length, admonishing her against desire and impurity and praising the freedom found in renouncing it. Hearing this, the woman's every defilement dissolved on the spot, and she attained the pure Dharma-eye. Having seen the Dharma and attained it, she asked only to be permitted as a lay follower, and received the five precepts as a disciple of the Buddha, further asking the venerable one to accept her own offering. He consented in silence, and she prepared a meal of every fine delicacy; once he had eaten, he taught her the Dharma further, leaving her heart filled with joy (Source: Dharmaguptaka Vinaya, first division, fascicle 8).

13. Aniruddha's Past Life as a Reformed Thief

Aniruddha's divine eye traced back to a life as a robber who trimmed a lamp before the Buddha with the point of his arrow.

Chinese Source
阿那律先身為劫以箭挑佛燈得報無量十三

阿難白佛。阿那律天眼所見。與佛何異。佛謂阿難。如來所見。非羅漢辟支佛所知。況汝生死比丘。何能知我如來徹視從此東去恒沙等剎。恒者謂江河耨池至于大海。廣四十里。中沙辟方下至底。百二十斛。過一剎置一沙盡爾所沙。佛土所有人物之類。幽邃之處曚昧之物。眾生微形皆悉見之。周匝十方皆亦如是。阿那律所見。何足言持比佛乎。阿難白言。阿那律宿有何緣所見乃爾。佛言。往昔惟衛佛泥洹後。有劫賊行劫所得過佛圖中。欲盜神寺中物。時佛前燈火欲滅闇無所見。賊以箭正燈炷。使明燈明。見威光曜目㱇然毛竪。心自念言。眾人尚持寶物求福。我云何盜取乎。即便捨去。九十一劫諸惡漸滅。福祐日增。爾時賊者阿那律是。緣正燈福恒生善處。值遇見佛出家得道徹視第一。何況至心割所珍愛。然燈佛前福難量也(出譬喻經第二卷)。

Ru-Yi Translation
Aniruddha's Past Life as a Reformed Thief

Ānanda asked the Buddha: how does what Aniruddha sees with his own heavenly eye differ from what the Buddha himself sees? The Buddha told Ānanda: what the Tathāgata sees is beyond the knowledge of even an arhat or pratyekabuddha, let alone a monk still bound to birth and death such as yourself — how could you possibly know the full reach of my own penetrating sight? Going east from here across buddha-lands as numerous as the sands of the Ganges — where "Ganges" means the great river flowing from Lake Anavatapta to the ocean, forty li wide, its sandy bed reaching down a hundred twenty measures deep — and, for every such sand-grain, imagining a further buddha-land: throughout the whole of such lands, every being, every hidden place, every obscure and shadowy thing, every creature of the most minute form, I see them all entirely — and the same holds true throughout the ten directions equally. How, then, could what Aniruddha sees possibly be compared to what a buddha sees?

Ānanda asked what past karmic bond had given Aniruddha such sight. The Buddha answered: long ago, after the buddha Vipaśyin's own nirvāṇa, a bandit, having just committed a robbery, passed through a stūpa and, wishing to steal the sacred objects within its own shrine, found the lamp before the Buddha's own image about to go out, the darkness leaving him unable to see. The bandit used his own arrow to trim the lamp's wick, restoring its light — and, seeing by that same light the image's own dazzling, awe-inspiring radiance, felt every hair on his body stand on end, and reflected: "Even ordinary people give their own treasures seeking blessing — how could I possibly steal from this place instead?" He abandoned his intent and departed at once. Across ninety-one kalpas thereafter, his own evil gradually diminished and his blessings daily increased. That bandit was Aniruddha himself — and it was through the merit of merely straightening a lamp that he was reborn continually into good circumstances, until at last he encountered the Buddha, went forth, attained the path, and gained the foremost sight among all disciples. How much greater, then, is the merit of one who, with a truly sincere heart, gives up what is most precious to them and lights a lamp before a buddha himself — a merit beyond all measure (Source: Sūtra of Similes and Parables, fascicle 2).

14. Aniruddha's Past Life as a Poor Laborer

A second past life: a poor labourer who gave his own meal to a pratyekabuddha, and seven lives of reward before the path.

阿那律前生貧窮施緣覺食七生得道十四

佛在鹿野苑中。阿那律語諸比丘。我念過去。在此波羅奈為貧窮人。客作荷擔以自存活。時世穀貴飢餓多有終者。乞食難得。有辟支佛。名披栗吒。亦依此住。時辟支佛早起乞食。時我早起出欲荷擔。見辟支佛。我荷擔還又復見之。便作是念。是人早起時我見之。今又見出必未得食。便隨我後至于我家。即作此念。意欲請之。即便分食持至其所。到已語言仙人。此是我分。當慈愍我故納此食。時辟支佛以鉢受半。汝自食半可為俱足。答言。仙人。我有家居得隨時食。汝仙人見慈盡受此施。此辟支佛以慈愍故。而盡受之。我因此施七生天上。得為天王。七生人間亦為人王。今生釋種財富無量。棄此出家學道得證(出中阿含經第十二卷)。

Aniruddha's Past Life as a Poor Laborer

The Buddha dwelt in the Deer Park at Sarnath. Aniruddha told the monks: I recall that, long ago, in this very Vārāṇasī, I was a poor man, hired to carry loads for others to sustain myself. In that age, grain grew scarce and people starved, many dying, and alms were hard to come by. A pratyekabuddha named Pilizhà also dwelt there at that time, going out early each morning to beg. One morning, as I too went out early to take up my own load, I saw this pratyekabuddha, and, returning later with my load, saw him again — and reflected: I saw him go out early this same morning, and now, seeing him again, he surely has not yet eaten.

He then followed me back to my own home, and I resolved to invite him in, taking my own portion of food to offer him, saying: "Sage, this is my own share — please accept it out of compassion for me." The pratyekabuddha took only half into his own bowl, telling me to eat the other half myself and be satisfied — but I answered: "Sage, I have my own household and may eat at any time; you, sage, out of compassion, should accept this offering in full" — and the pratyekabuddha, moved by compassion, accepted it entirely.

Through the merit of this single act of giving, I was reborn in heaven seven times, becoming a heavenly king each time, and reborn among humans seven times more, becoming a human king each time; and now, born into the Śākya clan itself, possessed of boundless wealth, I have renounced this life to study the path and attained realization (Source: Madhyama Āgama, fascicle 12).

Reading note — Ru-Yi

The two stories locate merit in opposite places along the scale of sacrifice — one in a bandit's own restraint, giving up nothing he had actually planned to keep for himself, and the other in a poor laborer's own insistence on giving away food he genuinely needed. Read side by side, they suggest the compendium's own view that a single lamp trimmed almost by accident and a starving man's entire meal, given away on purpose, can both function as seeds of the same eventual harvest — foremost sight among all the Buddha's disciples — provided the moment itself was genuine, whatever its own scale.

15. Piṇḍola and the Elder's Sister

The fascicle closes with four arhats setting out to convert the one household in Rājagṛha still resistant to the Three Jewels — Aniruddha and Kāśyapa slipping past seven locked gates unseen, and Piṇḍola escalating through fire, flight, and a flying boulder before the elder's own sister finally relents.

Chinese Source

阿那律。大迦葉。目連。賓頭盧共議。今王舍城。有不信樂佛法僧者。我等當共令其信樂。作是議已。遍觀遠近。唯見跋提長者及其姊不信三寶。上三聲聞言。能化跋提。時彼長者作七重門。有三部伎。若欲食時七門皆閉。一食作一部伎。阿那律於其食時在其前乞。長者問言。從何處入。答從門入。即問守門。門閉如故。不見人入。長者便以一片麻餅著其鉢中。得已即去。於後食時。迦葉復乞亦復如是。得一片魚著其鉢中。其姊問言。意謂比丘不能得而來乞耶答言如是。姊言。前來比丘名阿那律。釋種之子。捨三時殿五欲之樂。出家學道。後來比丘是畢波羅延。摩納大姓之子。捨九百九十田宅犁牛。出家學道。愍念君故來乞食耳。長者聞已內懷敬伏。於是目連。飛空說法示教利喜。即於坐上遠塵離垢得法眼淨見法得果。即受歸戒。上三聲聞語賓頭盧。我等今者。已化跋提令其信法。汝今宜行次化其姊。時賓頭盧晨朝持鉢往到其舍。時長者姊手自作餅。忽見來乞便。語之言。不與汝。一心視鉢欲以何為。賓頭盧便身中烟出。復語言。舉身煙出亦不與汝。賓頭盧便舉身火然。復語言。舉身火然亦不與汝。賓頭盧便飛騰虛空。復語言。飛騰虛空亦不與汝。賓頭盧便倒懸空中。復語言。倒懸空中亦不與汝。賓頭盧作是念。世尊不聽我等強從人乞。便自出去。王舍城不遠有大石。賓頭盧坐其上。合石飛入王舍城。城中人見皆大怖懼。恐石落地莫不馳走。至長者姊上便住不去。彼見是已即大恐怖。白言。願施我命反石於先。我當與食。賓頭盧便持石還著故處至其前住。長者姊作是念。我不能以大䴵施之。當更作小者與之。便作小丸輒反成大。如是三反轉大於前。乃作念言。我欲作小皆反成大。我今便可趣與一餅。即以一餅而授與之。諸餅相連并至餅器。以手捉器手亦著之。便語賓頭盧言。汝若須餅盡以相與。全出與不惜。何須我為。而令我手著。答言。我不須餅。亦不須器。亦不須汝。我等四人共議。度汝及第二人。已化汝弟。我應度汝。所以爾耳。問言。今欲令我何所施作。答言。姊妹可戴此餅。隨我施佛及千二百五十比丘。皆悉飽滿猶故不盡。持往白佛。我此少餅。供佛及僧。皆悉飽滿。猶故不盡。今當持此著於何處。佛言。可著無生草地。若無蟲水中。彼女人便持著無蟲水中。水沸作聲如以熱鐵投于小水。便生恐怖。還至佛所。佛為說法得法眼淨。即受歸戒如弟子無異。諸長老等以是白佛。佛即訶責諸比丘。從今不聽復現神足(出彌沙塞律第三十卷)。

Ru-Yi Translation

Aniruddha, Mahākāśyapa, Maudgalyāyana, and Piṇḍola conferred together: among the people of Rājagṛha who did not yet believe in or delight in the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, we ourselves ought to bring them to faith. Having agreed on this, they surveyed the area near and far, and found only the elder Bhadrika and his own sister who did not yet believe in the Three Jewels. The first three śrāvakas said: we can convert Bhadrika ourselves.

This elder had built a house with seven successive gates, and kept three troupes of musicians; whenever it was mealtime, all seven gates would be shut, and one troupe would perform. Aniruddha, at mealtime, appeared begging directly in front of him. The elder asked how he had entered, and, told through the gate, questioned the gatekeepers, who insisted the gates remained shut throughout and no one had passed. The elder then placed a single piece of hemp-cake into Aniruddha's bowl, who took it and left. At the next meal, Kāśyapa came begging in exactly the same way, and was given a single piece of fish, which he likewise took.

The elder's sister then asked him: did you think these monks incapable of finding food elsewhere, that they came begging here specifically? He answered yes. She told him: the first monk who came was named Aniruddha, a son of the Śākya clan, who gave up the pleasures of his own three seasonal palaces and five sensory delights to go forth and study the path; the later monk was Pippalāyana, of the great Māṇava clan, who gave up nine hundred ninety fields, houses, and plow-oxen to go forth and study the path; both, out of compassion for you, came specifically to beg from you. Hearing this, the elder was inwardly moved to reverence — at which Maudgalyāyana, flying through the air, taught the Dharma, instructing and delighting him, and, seated there, his every defilement dissolved and he attained the pure Dharma-eye, seeing the Dharma and its fruit, and took the refuges and precepts at once.

The first three śrāvakas then told Piṇḍola: we have now converted Bhadrika and brought him to faith in the Dharma — it is now your turn to convert his sister. Piṇḍola, early one morning, took his bowl and went to her house; the elder's own sister was at that moment making cakes herself, and, seeing him suddenly come begging, said: "I will not give you any," fixing her eyes on his bowl as though wondering what he intended. Piṇḍola then made smoke rise from his own body, and she said: "Even with smoke rising from your whole body, I still will not give you any." Piṇḍola then made his whole body burst into flame, and she said: "Even with your whole body ablaze, I still will not give you any." Piṇḍola then rose and floated in the air, and she said: "Even floating in the air, I still will not give you any." Piṇḍola then hung upside-down in midair, and she said: "Even hanging upside-down in the air, I still will not give you any."

Piṇḍola reflected: the World-Honored One does not permit us to force alms from anyone against their will — and so departed of his own accord. Not far from Rājagṛha stood a great boulder; Piṇḍola sat upon it, and the whole boulder flew, with him seated on it, into the city of Rājagṛha. The people of the city, seeing this, were terrified, fearing the stone would fall and crush them, and fled in every direction — until it came to rest directly above the elder's sister, and stopped there. She, seeing this, was overcome with terror, and cried out: "Please spare my life, and set the stone back where it was — I will give you food." Piṇḍola then carried the stone back to its original place and came to stand before her once more.

The elder's sister then reflected that she could hardly offer him the large cake she had been making, and resolved to make a smaller one instead — but however small she tried to make it, it kept turning out large regardless; she tried three times over, each cake turning out larger than the last. Reflecting that whatever she tried to make small turned out large anyway, she resolved simply to give him the one cake as it was — but the moment she tried to hand it to him, every cake in the container stuck together, and, reaching for the container itself, found her own hand stuck fast to it as well. She said to Piṇḍola: "If you want cakes, take them all — I freely give every one, and do not begrudge them; why then do you make my hand stick like this?" He answered: "I do not want your cakes, nor your container, nor even you yourself — the four of us conferred together that we would deliver you and one other person; having already converted your own younger brother, it now falls to me to deliver you, and this is simply why I have done as I have."

She asked what he now wished her to do. He answered: "Sister, carry this container of cakes, and follow me to offer it to the Buddha and his twelve hundred fifty monks." She did so, and, remarkably, the offering satisfied the Buddha and the entire assembly completely, with cakes still remaining afterward. She asked the Buddha what she should do with what was left, and the Buddha told her to set it upon ground where nothing grows, or in water free of living creatures. She placed it in such water, which at once boiled and hissed as though red-hot iron had been thrown into a shallow pool — and, terrified, she returned to the Buddha, who taught her the Dharma; hearing it, she attained the pure Dharma-eye and took the refuges and precepts, becoming a disciple no different from any other.

The elders reported all of this to the Buddha, who then rebuked the monks, declaring that from this day forward, no monk was to display such supernormal feats again (Source: Mahīśāsaka Vinaya, fascicle 30).

Reading note — Ru-Yi

Aniruddha and Kāśyapa's approach to Bhadrika succeeds through modesty — passing unseen through locked gates, accepting whatever meager scrap is offered, and letting his own sister's account of their sacrifices do the actual persuading. Piṇḍola's escalating campaign against the sister does the opposite, piling spectacle upon spectacle, and notably fails on every one of its own terms: smoke, fire, flight, and a flying boulder each provoke only refusal or terror, never faith, until he stops trying to overwhelm her and simply explains, plainly, why he came at all. The Buddha's own closing rebuke, banning such displays outright, reads as this fascicle's final verdict on a method it has tested repeatedly across many entries and found wanting compared to plain explanation, sincere need, and the willingness to be refused.