Reading guide
Two questions, addressed to 'Gotama' directly
Both rounds of this discourse address the Buddha by his clan name, Gotama, the same informal address already met at SN 1.23 — and both explicitly acknowledge understanding the previous answer before asking a further question, giving this exchange a genuinely conversational, step-by-step quality unusual for this collection.
Specific realms, not a generalized 'bad rebirth'
The first answer doesn't simply say the stingy suffer; it names three specific possible destinations — hell, the animal realm, or Yama's world — before describing what happens if they do return to human life: birth into poverty where even hoped-for help from others doesn't materialize.
Illuminating the heavens, and abundance if reborn human
The second answer is structured as a precise mirror of the first: the generous illuminate the heavens wherever reborn, and if they return to human life, it is into wealth where clothes, food, pleasure, and play — the same four items named as lacking for the stingy — are instead easy to find.
Present and future consequence, both named explicitly
Both answers close with the same structural claim: 'this is the result in the present life, and in the next, a good' or 'bad destination' — making explicit that the consequences described aren't confined to some distant future rebirth alone, but shape the present life as well.
Key terms
The text
The stingy: a question, and its answer
§1“Those folk in the world who are stingy, miserly and abusive, setting up obstacles for others who give. What kind of result do they reap? What kind of future life? We’ve come to ask you, worthy sir: how are we to understand this?”
§2“Those folk in the world who are stingy, miserly and abusive, setting up obstacles for others who give: they’re reborn in hell, the animal realm, or Yama’s world. If they return to the human state, they’re born in a poor family, where clothes, food, pleasure, and play are hard to find. They don’t even get what they hope for from others. This is the result in the present life, and in the next, a bad destination.”
The generous: a second question, and its answer
§3“We understand what you’re saying, and ask another question, Gotama. What about those who’ve gained the human state, who are bountiful and rid of stinginess, confident in the Buddha and the teaching, with keen respect for the Saṅgha? What kind of result do they reap? What kind of future life? We’ve come to ask you, worthy sir: how are we to understand this?”
§4“Those who’ve gained the human state who are bountiful and rid of stinginess, confident in the Buddha and the teaching, with keen respect for the Saṅgha: they illuminate the heavens wherever they’re reborn. If they return to the human state, they’re reborn in a rich family, where clothes, food, pleasure, and play are easy to find. They rejoice like those who control the possessions of others. This is the result in the present life, and in the next, a good destination.”
Self-check quiz
Ten questions. Click an answer to see immediate feedback. No score is recorded — this is for your own checking.