Saṃyutta Nikāya · Discourse 35.91

Turbulence (2nd)

Dutiyaejāsutta — Channavagga

Setting
Not restated in this discourse
Speakers
The Buddha, addressing the mendicants directly
Form
The same non-conceiving teaching as SN 35.90, with an added refrain after each field-group and a closing clause naming three analytical frameworks together
Length
~2 minutes to read
Northern parallel
A rough counterpart may exist in the Chinese Saṃyukta-āgama (T99), though this reading guide does not assert a specific matching sutra number
Difficulty
★★★☆☆ — the same teaching as SN 35.90, with a genuinely new closing move

Why this discourse

This discourse repeats SN 35.90's own non-conceiving formula almost verbatim, but interpolates a couplet after each field-group: “whatever you conceive it to be, whatever you conceive it in, whatever you conceive it as, and whatever you conceive to be 'mine': that becomes something else. The world is attached to being, taking pleasure only in being, yet it becomes something else.” This names the instability of conceiving itself, not only its object. The discourse then closes with a clause this vagga has not offered before: “as far as the aggregates, elements, and sense fields extend” — the first place in Channavagga where khandhā (aggregates), dhātuyo (elements), and āyatanāni (sense fields) are named together, gathering up in one line the three major analytical frameworks this book, and this project's own Book III (Khandhavagga) before it, have each explored on their own separate terms.

Reading guide

The same formula, an added refrain

Word for word, the non-conceiving teaching of SN 35.90 repeats here — but after each field-group, a new couplet appears, naming what happens to anything conceived at all.

“It becomes something else”

“For whatever you conceive it to be...that becomes something else. The world is attached to being, taking pleasure only in being, yet it becomes something else” — the instability named directly, twice over, once for the eye's own chain and once for the mind's.

Aggregates, elements, and sense fields named together

This discourse's own closing clause — “as far as the aggregates, elements, and sense fields extend” — is the first place in this vagga where all three of this project's own major analytical frameworks appear side by side in a single line, rather than each explored separately across its own saṃyutta.

Key terms

aññathā bhavati — “becomes something else” — the refrain added twice over in this discourse, absent from its twin at SN 35.90
bhavarato — delighting only in being — how “the world” is characterized in the same added refrain
khandhā — aggregates — the first of three analytical frameworks named together in this discourse's own closing clause
dhātuyo — elements — the second of the three, alongside khandhā and āyatanāni
āyatanāni — sense fields — the third framework, and this book's own primary concern throughout

The text

The complete discourse: the non-conceiving teaching repeated with an added refrain, closing with aggregates, elements, and sense fields named together. Translation: Bhikkhu Sujato (CC0, SuttaCentral).

§1“Mendicants, turbulence is a disease, a boil, a dart. That’s why the Realized One lives unperturbed, with dart drawn out. Now, a mendicant might wish: ‘May I live unperturbed, with dart drawn out.’ So let them not conceive anything to be the eye, let them not conceive it in the eye, let them not conceive it as the eye, let them not conceive that ‘the eye is mine.’ Let them not conceive sights … eye consciousness … eye contact … Let them not conceive anything to be the pleasant, painful, or neutral feeling that arises dependent on eye contact. Let them not conceive it in that, let them not conceive it as that, and let them not conceive that ‘that is mine.’ For whatever you conceive it to be, whatever you conceive it in, whatever you conceive it as, and whatever you conceive to be ‘mine’: that becomes something else. The world is attached to being, taking pleasure only in being, yet it becomes something else.

§2Let them not conceive anything to be the ear … nose … tongue … body … Let them not conceive anything to be the mind … mind consciousness … mind contact … Let them not conceive anything to be the pleasant, painful, or neutral feeling that arises dependent on mind contact. Let them not conceive it in that, let them not conceive it as that, and let them not conceive that ‘that is mine.’ For whatever you conceive it to be, whatever you conceive it in, whatever you conceive it as, and whatever you conceive to be ‘mine’: that becomes something else. The world is attached to being, taking pleasure only in being, yet it becomes something else.

§3As far as the aggregates, elements, and sense fields extend, they don’t conceive anything to be that, they don’t conceive it in that, they don’t conceive it as that, and they don’t conceive that ‘that is mine.’Not conceiving, they don’t grasp at anything in the world. Not grasping, they’re not anxious. Not being anxious, they personally become extinguished. They understand: ‘Rebirth is ended, the spiritual journey has been completed, what had to be done has been done, there is nothing further for this place.’”

· · ·

Self-check quiz

5 questions. Click an answer to see immediate feedback. No score is recorded — this is for your own checking.

Question 1 of 5
How does this discourse's own non-conceiving formula relate to SN 35.90's?
Correct: A. This vagga's own second half of the turbulence pair.
Question 2 of 5
What does the added refrain say happens to whatever is conceived?
Correct: A. “Aññathā bhavati” — naming instability in conceiving itself, not only its object.
Question 3 of 5
How is “the world” characterized in this same added refrain?
Correct: A. A restless attachment to being that does not hold still.
Question 4 of 5
What three frameworks does this discourse's own closing clause name together, for the first time in this vagga?
Correct: A. Khandhā, dhātuyo, and āyatanāni, gathered in a single line.
Question 5 of 5
Why is this closing clause notable within this project's own larger structure?
Correct: A. Frameworks this project has otherwise explored one saṃyutta at a time.
Answered 0 of 5 · Correct 0