The Ground of Joy
Nāgārjuna opens by justifying the entire undertaking twice over — first why the bodhisattva path takes the immeasurably longer road of the ten grounds rather than the swifter release available to the lesser vehicles, then why this treatise itself needed to be written at all. Only then does he name the ten grounds in full, and explain what it takes to enter the very first of them.
Why the Ten Grounds, and Not a Swifter Release
敬禮一切佛,無上之大道,及諸菩薩眾,堅心住十地;聲聞辟支佛,無我我所者。今解十地義,隨順佛所說。
問曰:汝欲解菩薩十地義,以何因緣故說?
答曰:地獄、畜生、餓鬼、人、天、阿修羅,六趣險難,恐怖大畏,是眾生生死大海旋流洄澓。隨業往來,是其濤波;涕淚、乳汁、流汗、膿血是惡水聚;瘡癩乾枯,嘔血淋瀝,上氣熱病,瘭疽癰漏,吐逆脹滿,如是等種種惡病,為惡羅剎;憂悲苦惱為水;嬈動、啼哭、悲號為波浪聲;苦惱諸受以為沃焦;死為崖岸,無能越者;諸結煩惱,有漏業風,鼓扇不定,諸四顛倒以為欺誑;愚癡無明,為大黑闇,隨愛凡夫,無始已來常行其中。如是往來生死大海,未曾有得到於彼岸。或有到者,兼能濟渡無量眾生。以是因緣說菩薩十地義。
問曰:若人不能修行菩薩十地,不得度生死大海耶?
答曰:若有人行聲聞、辟支佛乘者,是人得度生死大海。若人欲以無上大乘度生死大海者,是人必當具足修行十地。
問曰:行聲聞、辟支佛乘者,幾時得度生死大海?
答曰:行聲聞乘者,或以一世得度;或以二世;或過是數,隨根利、鈍,又以先世宿行因緣。行辟支佛乘者,或以七世得度;或以八世。若行大乘者,或一恒河沙大劫;或二、三、四至十百、千、萬、億;或過是數,然後乃得具足修行菩薩十地而成佛道,亦隨根之利鈍。又以先世宿行因緣。
問曰:聲聞、辟支佛、佛,俱到彼岸,於解脫中有差別不?
答曰:是事應當分別。於諸煩惱得解脫是中無差別,因是解脫入無餘涅槃,是中亦無差別,無有相故。但諸佛甚深禪定障解脫、一切法障解脫。於諸聲聞、辟支佛有差別,非說所盡,亦不可以譬喻為比。
問曰:三乘所學皆為無餘涅槃,若無餘涅槃中無差別者,我等何用於恒河沙等大劫,往來生死具足十地,不如以聲聞、辟支佛乘速滅諸苦?
答曰:是語弱劣,非是大悲有益之言。若諸菩薩効汝小心,無慈悲意,不能精勤修十地者,諸聲聞、辟支佛何由得度?亦復無有三乘差別。所以者何?一切聲聞、辟支佛皆由佛出,若無諸佛,何由而出?若不修十地,何有諸佛?若無諸佛,亦無法、僧。是故汝所說者,則斷三寶種,非是大人有智之言,不可聽察。
所以者何?世間有四種人:一者、自利。二者、利他。三者、共利。四者、不共利。是中共利者,能行慈悲饒益於他,名為上人。如說:
世間可愍傷,常背於自利,一心求富樂,墮於邪見網;常懷於死畏,流轉六道中,大悲諸菩薩,能極為希有。
眾生死至時,無能救護者,沒在深黑闇,煩惱網所纏。
若有能發行,大悲之心者,荷負眾生故,為之作重任。
若人決定心,獨受諸勤苦,所獲安隱果,而與一切共。
諸佛所稱歎,第一最上人,亦是希有者,功德之大藏。
世間有常言,家不生惡子,但能成己利,不能利於人;若生於善子,能利於人者,是則如滿月,照明於其家。
有諸福德人,以種種因緣,饒益如大海,又亦如大地。
無求於世間,以慈愍故住,此人生為貴,壽命第一最。
如是聲聞、辟支佛、佛,煩惱解脫雖無差別,以度無量眾生,久住生死,多所利益具足菩薩十地故,有大差別。
Homage to all buddhas, the unsurpassed great path, and the assembly of bodhisattvas, whose firm minds abide upon the ten grounds; to śrāvakas and pratyekabuddhas, who are free of self and what belongs to self. Now I shall explain the meaning of the ten grounds, following what the Buddha himself has taught.
Question: You wish to explain the meaning of the bodhisattva's ten grounds — for what reason do you set out to expound it?
Answer: Hell-beings, animals, hungry ghosts, humans, devas, and asuras — these six perilous destinies, places of great terror and dread, are the whirling eddies and swirling currents of the great ocean of birth and death in which sentient beings are caught. Coming and going according to karma, these are its surging waves; tears, mother's milk, flowing sweat, pus and blood are the pooled foul waters within it; sores and leprosy, wasting and desiccation, vomiting blood without cease, feverish illness rising through the body, festering boils and running sores, retching and bloating — every manner of such grave disease is its malevolent rākṣasa; grief, sorrow, and affliction are its waters; agitation, weeping, and mournful cries are the sound of its crashing waves; the feelings of suffering and distress are its boiling shoals; death is its shore, which none can cross beyond; the fetters and afflictions, the winds of contaminated karma, blow and churn without settling; the four inversions serve as its deceptions; ignorance and delusion form its vast darkness — and ordinary beings, bound by craving, have wandered within it constantly since beginningless time. Coming and going in this way through the great ocean of birth and death, they have never once reached its farther shore. Yet there are some who do reach it, and who are further able to ferry across immeasurable sentient beings besides. It is for this very reason that I explain the meaning of the bodhisattva's ten grounds.
Question: If a person is unable to cultivate the bodhisattva's ten grounds, does this mean they cannot cross the great ocean of birth and death?
Answer: Should a person practice the vehicle of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha, such a person can indeed cross the great ocean of birth and death. But should a person wish to cross this great ocean by means of the unsurpassed Great Vehicle, such a person must necessarily cultivate the ten grounds in their entirety.
Question: For one who practices the vehicle of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha, how long does it take to cross this great ocean of birth and death?
Answer: One who practices the vehicle of the śrāvaka may cross it within a single lifetime, or within two, or across even more than this number, depending on whether their own faculties are sharp or dull, and on the karmic causes of their own former lives. One who practices the vehicle of the pratyekabuddha may cross it within seven lifetimes, or within eight. But one who practices the Great Vehicle may take a single great kalpa equal to the sands of the Ganges, or two, three, four, up to ten, a hundred, a thousand, ten thousand, a hundred million — or even beyond this number — before finally cultivating the ten grounds in their entirety and accomplishing the path to buddhahood; and this too depends on their own faculties, sharp or dull, and on the causes of their own former lives.
Question: The śrāvaka, the pratyekabuddha, and the buddha all alike reach the farther shore — within their liberation itself, is there any difference between them?
Answer: This matter must be distinguished carefully. In the liberation attained from the afflictions, there is no difference among them; and in entering the nirvāṇa without remainder by means of this liberation, there is likewise no difference, since this state itself is without any mark. But the buddhas alone are liberated from the obstruction to the most profound absorptions, and liberated from the obstruction covering all dharmas — in this there is a difference between them and the śrāvakas and pratyekabuddhas, a difference that cannot be exhausted in words, nor captured by any comparison.
Question: The three vehicles all study toward the very same nirvāṇa without remainder; if there is truly no difference within that nirvāṇa, then of what use is it for us to wander through birth and death across kalpas as numerous as the sands of the Ganges, cultivating the ten grounds in their entirety? Would it not be better to extinguish suffering swiftly instead, by means of the vehicle of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha?
Answer: This is a feeble and inferior thing to say, not the beneficial speech of great compassion. Were every bodhisattva to imitate your own petty-minded thinking, lacking any compassionate intent, and were none of them able to diligently cultivate the ten grounds, then by what means would any śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha ever come to cross over at all? Nor would there be any difference among the three vehicles to speak of. And why is this so? Every śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha comes forth by means of a buddha; were there no buddhas, by what means could they come forth at all? And were the ten grounds never cultivated, how could there be any buddhas? Were there no buddhas, there would likewise be no Dharma and no Saṅgha. What you have said, then, would sever the very seed of the Three Jewels — this is not the wise speech of a great person, and it ought not to be heeded.
And why is this so? In this world there are four kinds of persons: first, those who benefit only themselves; second, those who benefit only others; third, those who benefit both together; fourth, those who benefit neither. Among these, the one who benefits both together, able to act with compassion and bring genuine good to others, is called a superior person. As the verse says:
"Pitiable indeed is the world, forever turning its back on its own true benefit, seeking wealth and pleasure with a single mind, and falling into the net of wrong views; ever harboring the fear of death, it revolves through the six destinies — how truly rare, then, are bodhisattvas of great compassion.
"When death comes upon sentient beings, none are able to save or protect them; they sink into deep and utter darkness, bound fast within the net of the afflictions.
"Should there be one able to give rise to and carry out a mind of great compassion, they bear the weight of all sentient beings, and take up this heavy burden on their behalf.
"If a person, with a resolute mind, alone endures every hardship and toil, the fruit of peace and security thereby gained is shared together with all beings.
"Such a one is praised by all the buddhas as the very first and most supreme of persons, one who is likewise rare indeed, a great treasury of merit.
"It is commonly said in this world that a household does not produce an evil son merely because he seeks only his own benefit and cannot benefit others; but should a household produce a good son, one able to benefit others, he is then like the full moon, illuminating that entire household.
"There are those of great merit and virtue who, through causes and conditions of every kind, bring benefit as vast as the great ocean, and likewise as vast as the great earth itself.
"Seeking nothing from this world, dwelling instead in compassion and pity, such a person's life is noble indeed, their span of life the very finest of all."
Thus, though the liberation from the afflictions is no different among the śrāvaka, the pratyekabuddha, and the buddha, there remains a great difference between them, on account of the buddha's crossing over immeasurable sentient beings, dwelling long within birth and death, bringing benefit far and wide, and fully cultivating the bodhisattva's ten grounds.
Nāgārjuna begins not with the ten grounds themselves, but with the objection any reader might reasonably raise first: if liberation from the afflictions is identical across the three vehicles, why choose the vastly longer bodhisattva path at all? His answer turns on the difference between an act of individual escape and an act that keeps producing buddhas, and therefore keeps producing every subsequent liberation downstream of it — a debt-of-origin argument that recurs throughout Mahāyāna literature, but rarely stated with this much blunt arithmetic (a single lifetime against kalpas beyond counting) before the payoff is even named.
Why This Treatise Needed to Be Written
問曰:佛有大悲,汝為弟子種種稱讚,慈愍眾生,誠如所說。汝以種種因緣,明了分別開悟引導,行慈悲者,聞則心淨,我甚欣悅。汝先偈說十地之義,願為解釋。
答曰:敬名恭敬心,禮名曲身接足,一切諸佛者,三世十方佛;無上大道者,一切諸法如實知見,通達無餘,更無勝者,故曰無上;大人所行,故曰大道。菩薩眾者,為無上道發心,名曰菩薩。
問曰:但發心便是菩薩耶?
答曰:何有但發心而為菩薩!若人發心,必能成無上道,乃名菩薩。或有但發心亦名菩薩。何以故?若離初發心,則不成無上道。如《大經》說:「新發意者名為菩薩。」猶如比丘,雖未得道,亦名道人;是名字菩薩,漸漸修習,轉成實法。後釋〈歡喜地〉中,當廣說如實菩薩相。眾者,從初發心至金剛無礙解脫道,於其中間,過去、未來、現在菩薩,名之為眾。堅心者,心如須彌山王,不可沮壞;亦如大地,不可傾動。住十地者,歡喜等十地,後當廣說。
問曰:若菩薩更有殊勝功德,何故但稱堅心?
答曰:菩薩有堅心功德能成大業,不墮二乘。軟心者,怖畏生死。自念:「何為久在生死,受諸苦惱!不如疾以聲聞、辟支佛乘速滅諸苦。」又軟心者,於——活地獄、黑繩地獄、眾合地獄、叫喚地獄、大叫喚地獄、燒炙地獄、大燒炙地獄、無間大地獄,及眷屬:炭火地獄、沸屎地獄、燒林地獄、劍樹地獄、刀道地獄、銅柱地獄、刺棘地獄、鹹河地獄——其中,斧鉞刀矟、矛戟弓箭、鐵剗椎棒、鐵鏘鏫、鐵䂎刀、鐵臼、鐵杵、鐵輪,以如是等治罪器物,斬、斫、割、刺,打、棒、剝、裂;繫縛枷鎖,燒煮考掠,磨碎其身,擣令爛熟;狐狗虎狼,師子惡獸,競來䶥掣,食噉其身;烏鵄鵰鷲,鐵所啄;惡鬼驅逼,令緣劍樹,上下火山;以鐵火車,加其頸領;以熱鐵杖,而隨捶之;千釘鏒身,剗刀刮削;入黑闇中,熢勃臭處;熱鐵鍱身,臠割其肉,剝其身皮;還繫手足,鑊湯涌沸,炮煮其身;鐵棒棒頭,腦壞眼出,貫著鐵丳,舉身火燃,血流澆地;或沒屎河,行於刀劍鏘刺惡道,自然刀劍從空而下,猶如駛雨割截支體;辛鹹苦臭,穢惡之河浸漬其身,肌肉爛壞,舉身墮落,唯有骨在;獄卒牽抴,蹴蹋搥撲。有如是等,無量苦毒。壽命極長,求死不得,若見若聞如是之事,何得不怖求聲聞、辟支佛乘。
又於寒氷地獄:頞浮陀地獄、尼羅浮陀地獄、阿波波地獄、阿羅羅地獄、阿睺睺地獄;青蓮華地獄、白蓮華地獄、雜色蓮華地獄、紅蓮華地獄、赤蓮華地獄,常在幽闇,大怖畏處。謗毀賢聖,生在其中,形如屋舍,山陵埠阜、麁惡冷風,聲猛可畏。悲激吹身如轉枯草,肌肉墮落猶如冬葉,凍剝創夷膿血流出,身體不淨臭處難忍,寒風切裂苦毒辛酸。唯有憂悲啼哭更無餘心,號咷煢獨無所依恃,斯罪皆由誹謗賢聖。其軟心者,見聞此事,何得不怖求聲聞、辟支佛乘。
又於畜生:猪狗野干、猫狸狖鼠、獼猴㹢玃、虎狼師子、兕豹熊羆、象馬牛羊;蜈蚣蚰蜒、蚖蛇蝮蝎、黿龜魚鼈、蛟虬螺蜯;烏鵲、鵄梟、鷹鴿之類。如是鳥獸,共相殘害。又弶網伺捕,屠割不一。生則羇絆,穿鼻絡首,負乘捶杖,鉤刺其身,皮肉破裂,痛不可忍!煙熏火燒苦毒萬端。死則剝皮,食噉其肉。有如是等無量苦痛。其軟心者,聞見此事,何得不怖求聲聞、辟支佛乘。
又於鍼頸餓鬼、火口餓鬼、火癭餓鬼;食吐餓鬼、食盪滌餓鬼、食膿餓鬼、食屎餓鬼;浮陀鬼、鳩槃茶鬼、夜叉鬼、羅剎鬼、毘舍闍鬼、富單那鬼、迦羅富單那鬼等諸鬼。鬚髮蓬亂,長爪大鼻,身中多虫,臭穢可畏。眾惱所切,常有慳嫉,飢渴苦患,未曾得食,得不能咽。常求膿血,屎尿涕唾盪滌不淨,有力者奪而不得食;裸形無衣寒熱倍甚,惡風吹身宛轉苦痛,蚊虻毒虫唼食其體,腹中飢熱常如火然。其軟心者,見聞此事,何得不怖求聲聞、辟支佛乘。
又於人中恩愛別苦、怨憎會苦、老病死苦、貧窮求苦,有如是等無量眾苦,及諸天、阿修羅退沒時苦。其軟心者,見此諸苦,何得不怖求聲聞、辟支佛乘。
若堅心者,見地獄、畜生、餓鬼、天、人、阿修羅中,受諸苦惱,生大悲心,無有怖畏。作是願言:「是諸眾生深入衰惱,無有救護、無所歸依,我得滅度當度此等。」以大悲心,勤行精進,不久得成所願。是故我說,菩薩諸功德中堅心第一。
復次,菩薩有八法,能集一切功德:一者、大悲,二者、堅心,三者、智慧,四者、方便,五者、不放逸,六者、勤精進,七者、常攝念,八者、善知識。是故初發心者,疾行八法,如救頭然,然後當修諸餘功德。又依此八法故,有一切「聲聞」眾四雙八輩。所謂須陀洹向、須陀洹等。「辟支佛,無我、我所」者,世間無佛、無佛法時,有得道者名「辟支佛」。諸賢聖離我、我所貪著故,名為「無我、我所者」。「今解十地義,隨順佛所說」者,《十地經》中次第說,今當隨次具解。
問曰:汝所說者,不異於經,經義已成,何須更說;為欲自現所能求名利耶?
答曰:我不為自現,莊嚴於文辭;亦不貪利養,而造於此論。
問曰:若不爾者,何以造此論?
答曰:我為欲慈悲,饒益於眾生,不以餘因緣,而造於此論。見眾生於六道受苦,無有救護,為欲度此等故,以智慧力而造此論。不為自現智力,求於名利;亦無嫉妬、自高之心,求於供養。
問曰:慈愍饒益眾生事,經中已說,何須復解,徒自疲苦?
答曰:有但見佛經,通達第一義;有得善解釋,而解實義者。有利根深智之人,聞佛所說諸深經,即能通達第一義。所謂深經者,即是菩薩十地。第一義者,即是十地如實義。有諸論師有慈悲心,隨佛所說,造作論議,莊嚴辭句。有人因是而得通達十地義者。如說:有人好文飾,莊嚴章句者;有好於偈頌,有好雜句者;有好於譬喻、因緣而得解。所好各不同,我隨而不捨。章句名莊嚴句義,不為偈頌。偈名義趣言辭在諸句中,或四言、五言、七言等。偈有二種:一者、四句偈,名為波蔗。二者、六句偈,名祇夜。雜句者,名直說語言。譬喻者,以人不解深義故,假喻令解;喻有或實、或假。因緣者,推尋所由。隨其所好,而不捨之。
問曰:眾生自所樂不同,於汝何事?
答曰:我發無上道心故,不捨一切,隨力饒益,或以財或以法。如說:若有大智人,得聞如是經,不復須解釋,則解十地義!若有福德利根者,但直聞是《十地經》,即解其義,不須解釋,不為是人,而造此論。
問曰:云何為善人?
答曰:若聞佛語,即能自解。如丈夫能服苦藥,小兒則以蜜和。善人者,略說有十法,何等為十?一者、信,二者、精進,三者、念,四者、定,五者、善身業,六者、善口業,七者、善意業,八者、無貪,九者、無恚,十者、無癡。如說:若人以經文,難可得讀誦;若作毘婆沙,於此人大益。若人鈍根懈慢,以經文難故,不能讀誦。難者,文多難誦、難說、難諳。若有好樂莊嚴語言、雜飾、譬喻、諸偈頌等,為利益此等,故造此論。是故汝先說:「但佛經,便足利益眾生,何須解釋」者,是語不然!
如說:思惟造此論,深發於善心,以然此法故,無比供養佛。我造此論時,思惟分別,多念三寶及菩薩眾;又念布施、持戒、忍辱、精進、禪定、智慧,故深發善心,則是自利;又演說照明此正法,故名為無比供養諸佛,則是利他。如說:說法然法燈,建立於法幢;此幢是賢聖,妙法之印相。我今造此論,諦捨及滅慧,是四功德處,自然而修集。今造此論,是四種功德,自然修集。是故,心無有倦。諦者,一切真實,名之為諦;一切實中,佛語為真實,不變壞故。我解說此佛法,即集諦處。捨名布施。施有二種:法施、財施。二種施中,法施為勝。如佛告諸比丘:「一當法施,二當財施;二施之中,法施為勝。」是故我法施時,即集捨處。我若義說十地時,無有身、口、意惡業;又亦不起欲、恚、癡念及諸餘結。障此罪故,即名集滅處。為他解說法,得大智報,以是說法故,即集慧處。如是造此論,集此四功德處。
復次——我說十地論,其心得清淨;深貪是心故,精勤而不倦。若人聞受持,心有清淨者,我亦深樂此,一心造此論。此二偈,其義已顯,不須復說。但以自心、他心清淨故,造此十地義。清淨心至所應至處,得大果報。如佛語迦留陀夷:「勿恨阿難!若我不記阿難於我滅後作阿羅漢者,以是清淨心,業因緣故,當於他化自在天七反為王。」如《經》中廣說。
Question: The Buddha possesses great compassion, and you, as his disciple, have praised this in every way, showing compassion and pity for sentient beings exactly as you have said. Through causes and conditions of every kind, you have made this clear and opened understanding, guiding those who practice compassion — hearing this, my own mind becomes pure, and I am deeply delighted. You have already spoken, in verse, of the meaning of the ten grounds; I now ask that you explain it.
Answer: "Homage" means a mind of reverence; "obeisance" means bowing the body and touching the feet. "All buddhas" refers to the buddhas of the three times and the ten directions. As for "the unsurpassed great path": it is the true seeing and knowing of all dharmas exactly as they are, penetrated in their entirety, with nothing further that could surpass it — hence "unsurpassed"; and it is what a great person practices, hence "the great path." "The assembly of bodhisattvas": one who has given rise to the aspiration for the unsurpassed path is called a bodhisattva.
Question: Does merely giving rise to this aspiration already make one a bodhisattva?
Answer: How could merely giving rise to this aspiration alone make one a bodhisattva! Only when a person gives rise to this aspiration and is certain to accomplish the unsurpassed path is one called a bodhisattva. Yet there are also those who are called bodhisattvas merely upon giving rise to this aspiration. Why is this so? Because, apart from this very first arising of the aspiration, the unsurpassed path could never be accomplished at all. As the Great Sūtra says: "One who has newly given rise to this intent is called a bodhisattva." It is just as a monk, though not yet having attained the path, is nonetheless called a person of the path; such a one is a bodhisattva in name only, who gradually cultivates practice until it turns into the true dharma itself. Later, within the explanation of the Ground of Joy, the true mark of the bodhisattva as it actually is will be expounded at length. "Assembly": from the very first arising of the aspiration up to the vajra-like path of unobstructed liberation, all bodhisattvas within this span — past, future, and present — are together called this assembly. "Firm mind": a mind like Mount Sumeru, king of mountains, which cannot be shaken or destroyed; and likewise like the great earth, which cannot be toppled or moved. "Abiding upon the ten grounds": the ten grounds beginning with the Ground of Joy will be expounded at length later.
Question: If the bodhisattva possesses still further sublime qualities, why does the verse speak only of a "firm mind"?
Answer: It is precisely through the quality of a firm mind that the bodhisattva is able to accomplish this great undertaking, and does not fall into the two lesser vehicles. One of "faint-hearted mind," by contrast, is afraid of birth and death, and thinks to themselves: "Why should I remain so long within birth and death, enduring every suffering! Better to swiftly extinguish all suffering instead, by means of the vehicle of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha." Also, one of faint-hearted mind, reflecting upon the Hell of Repeated Life, the Hell of the Black Rope, the Hell of Crushing Assembly, the Hell of Wailing, the Hell of Great Wailing, the Hell of Burning, the Hell of Great Burning, and the Great Hell of Uninterrupted Suffering, together with their surrounding realms — the Hell of Burning Charcoal, the Hell of Boiling Excrement, the Hell of the Burning Forest, the Hell of the Sword-Leaf Trees, the Hell of the Blade-Path, the Hell of the Bronze Pillar, the Hell of Thorns, and the Hell of the Brackish River — within which axes and blades, spears and halberds, bows and arrows, iron rakes, mallets and clubs, iron pincers and hooks, iron mortars, pestles, and wheels, and every such instrument of punishment are used to hack, hew, cut, and pierce, to beat, club, flay, and rend; where beings are bound in chains, burned, boiled, tortured, and scourged, their bodies ground into pulp; where foxes, dogs, tigers, wolves, lions, and every fierce beast come rushing to devour their flesh; where crows, owls, hawks, and vultures peck at them with beaks of iron; where malevolent demons force them to climb trees of swords, up and down mountains of fire; where carts of iron and fire are yoked about their necks, and rods of burning iron strike them without pause; where a thousand nails are driven into their bodies and blades pare their flesh; where they are cast into utter darkness thick with foul stench; where sheets of burning iron slice their flesh and strip their very skin; where, bound once more, they are boiled within seething cauldrons; where clubs of iron shatter their skulls until their eyes burst forth, where they are impaled upon iron stakes, their whole bodies ablaze; or where they sink into rivers of excrement, walking paths lined with swords that pierce them, while swords fall of their own accord from the sky like driving rain, severing every limb; where rivers of foul, bitter filth soak into their bodies until their flesh rots away, leaving only bare bone; and where the wardens of hell drag and trample them without end. There are torments of this kind, immeasurable in number. Their lifespan there is exceedingly long, and even seeking death, they cannot attain it. Upon seeing or hearing of matters such as these, how could one not be terrified into seeking the vehicle of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha?
Also, within the cold ice hells — the Hell of Blisters, the Hell of Burst Blisters, the Hell of Chattering Teeth, the Hell of Groaning, the Hell of Great Groaning, the Hell of the Blue Lotus, the Hell of the White Lotus, the Hell of the Mottled Lotus, the Hell of the Crimson Lotus, and the Hell of the Red Lotus, always shrouded in gloom, places of the greatest dread — those who have slandered and reviled the worthy and the noble are reborn within them, their forms like collapsing houses or crumbling hillocks, where a harsh, bitter wind, howling fiercely, is a terror to behold. This wind hurls their bodies about like withered grass, their flesh falling away like leaves in winter; frozen and split open, their wounds seep with pus and blood; their bodies foul, their stench unbearable, the freezing wind cuts and rends them with bitter, searing pain. There is nothing left in their minds but grief and lamentation; they wail alone, utterly without refuge — and every one of these offenses stems from having slandered the worthy and the noble. One of faint-hearted mind, seeing and hearing of these matters, how could they not be terrified into seeking the vehicle of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha?
Also, among the animals — pigs, dogs, jackals, cats, civets, monkeys, rats, macaques, gibbons, tigers, wolves, lions, rhinoceroses, leopards, bears, elephants, horses, cattle, and sheep; centipedes, millipedes, lizards, snakes, vipers, scorpions, turtles, fish, and soft-shelled turtles, dragons and hornless dragons, snails and clams; crows and magpies, owls, hawks and doves, and every such kind — these birds and beasts prey upon and destroy one another. They are further caught by snares and nets, lying in wait, and butchered in every different way. While alive, they are hobbled, their noses pierced and their heads bridled, made to bear burdens and struck with whips, hooked and pierced through their bodies until skin and flesh split open — pain unbearable to endure! They are smoked and burned by fire, suffering torments of every sort. Once dead, their skins are stripped and their flesh devoured. There are sufferings of this kind, immeasurable in number. One of faint-hearted mind, hearing and seeing of these matters, how could they not be terrified into seeking the vehicle of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha?
Also, among the Needle-Necked hungry ghosts, the Fire-Mouthed hungry ghosts, the Fire-Goiter hungry ghosts; the Vomit-Eating hungry ghosts, the Rinse-Water-Eating hungry ghosts, the Pus-Eating hungry ghosts, the Excrement-Eating hungry ghosts; and the pūtana ghosts, kumbhāṇḍa ghosts, yakṣa ghosts, rākṣasa ghosts, piśāca ghosts, pūtana, and kaṭapūtana ghosts, and every such spirit — their hair and beards are disheveled, their nails long, their noses huge, their bodies teeming with worms, foul and dreadful to behold. Cut through with every torment, ever consumed by stinginess and envy, tormented by hunger and thirst, they never once obtain food; and when they do, they cannot swallow it. They constantly seek out pus and blood, urine and spittle, filthy rinse-water — and even this, the stronger among them seize away. Naked, without clothing, the cold and the heat afflict them doubly; a foul wind twists their bodies in agony; mosquitoes and venomous insects gnaw at their flesh; and within their bellies, hunger burns constantly like fire. One of faint-hearted mind, seeing and hearing of these matters, how could they not be terrified into seeking the vehicle of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha?
Also, among human beings, there is the suffering of separation from those one loves, the suffering of encountering those one resents, the suffering of old age, sickness, and death, and the suffering of poverty and unfulfilled desire — sufferings of this kind, immeasurable in number — together with the suffering that devas and asuras face at the moment of their own decline and fall. One of faint-hearted mind, beholding all these sufferings, how could they not be terrified into seeking the vehicle of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha?
But one of firm mind, beholding these sufferings endured within hell, among animals, hungry ghosts, devas, humans, and asuras, gives rise instead to a mind of great compassion, entirely without fear, and makes this very vow: "These sentient beings have sunk deep into decline and affliction, having neither protector nor refuge to rely upon — once I myself attain liberation, I shall liberate them all." With this mind of great compassion, diligently exerting themselves, they will not be long before accomplishing this very vow. It is for this reason that I say: among all the qualities of the bodhisattva, a firm mind is foremost.
Furthermore, the bodhisattva possesses eight dharmas capable of gathering every quality of merit: first, great compassion; second, a firm mind; third, wisdom; fourth, skillful means; fifth, freedom from heedlessness; sixth, diligent effort; seventh, constant mindfulness; eighth, good and virtuous friends. It is for this reason that one who has newly given rise to the aspiration should swiftly practice these eight dharmas, as though extinguishing a fire upon one's own head, and only then go on to cultivate every other quality of merit. And it is likewise in reliance upon these eight dharmas that the entire assembly of "śrāvakas," the four pairs and eight classes of persons, comes to be — namely, those approaching stream-entry, those who have attained stream-entry, and so forth. As for "the pratyekabuddha, who is free of self and what belongs to self": at a time when the world is without any buddha and without the Buddhadharma, one who nonetheless attains the path is called a "pratyekabuddha." All the worthy and the noble, having departed from craving attachment to self and to what belongs to self, are therefore called "those free of self and what belongs to self." As for "now I shall explain the meaning of the ten grounds, following what the Buddha himself has taught": the Ten Grounds Sūtra expounds this in due sequence, and I shall now explain it fully, following that very same sequence.
Question: What you have just said is no different from the sūtra itself; the sūtra's own meaning is already complete — why is any further explanation needed? Is this not simply to display your own ability, seeking fame and gain for yourself?
Answer: "It is not to display myself, adorning my own words with fine phrasing, nor out of any craving for gain, that I compose this treatise."
Question: If this is not the reason, then why have you composed this treatise?
Answer: "It is out of a wish for compassion, to bring true benefit to sentient beings, and for no other cause, that I compose this treatise." Seeing sentient beings suffering throughout the six destinies, without protector or refuge, and wishing to save them, I compose this treatise by the power of wisdom alone — not to display my own intellectual power in seeking fame or gain, nor with any mind of envy or self-exaltation, seeking offerings for myself.
Question: The matter of compassionately benefiting sentient beings has already been spoken of within the sūtra itself — why explain it further, wearing yourself out for nothing?
Answer: "There are those who, merely upon seeing the Buddha's own sūtra, penetrate its ultimate meaning directly; and there are others who require a skillful explanation before they can understand its true meaning." There are those of sharp faculties and profound wisdom who, upon hearing the profound sūtras spoken by the Buddha, are immediately able to penetrate their ultimate meaning. As for "the profound sūtras," these are precisely the bodhisattva's ten grounds. As for "the ultimate meaning," this is precisely the true meaning of these ten grounds exactly as it is. There are treatise-masters, moved by compassion, who, following what the Buddha has spoken, compose treatises, adorning their words and phrases; and there are those who, through this very means, come to penetrate the meaning of the ten grounds. As the verse says: "Some delight in ornamented prose, in adorned sections; some delight in verse, some in plain language; some come to understanding only through similes and causal explanations. Since what each delights in differs, I follow each in turn, abandoning none." "Sections and phrases" refers to prose that adorns the meaning of its own sentences, not composed as verse. "Verse" refers to meaning expressed in words arranged within fixed lines, whether of four, five, or seven syllables. Verse is of two kinds: first, the four-line verse, called pāda; second, the six-line verse, called geya. "Plain language" refers to speech stated directly, without ornament. "Simile" means that, since people cannot grasp a profound meaning directly, a comparison is borrowed to make it understood; such comparisons may be either real or merely hypothetical. "Causal explanation" means tracing back the reason from which something arises. Following what each person delights in, I abandon none of these approaches.
Question: Sentient beings each delight in different things of their own accord — what business is this of yours?
Answer: "Because I have given rise to the aspiration for the unsurpassed path, I abandon none of them, but benefit them according to my own ability, whether through material wealth or through the Dharma itself." As the verse says: "Should there be a person of great wisdom, upon hearing a sūtra such as this, no further explanation would be needed at all — the meaning of the ten grounds would already be understood!" Should there be one of great merit and sharp faculties who, merely upon hearing this Ten Grounds Sūtra directly, understands its meaning without any need for further explanation — it is not for such a person that I compose this treatise.
Question: What, then, constitutes a good person?
Answer: "One who, upon hearing the Buddha's own words, is immediately able to understand them on their own. It is just as a grown man is able to swallow bitter medicine directly, while a small child requires it mixed together with honey." To speak briefly, the good person possesses ten qualities. What are these ten? First, faith; second, diligent effort; third, mindfulness; fourth, concentration; fifth, wholesome bodily conduct; sixth, wholesome verbal conduct; seventh, wholesome mental conduct; eighth, freedom from greed; ninth, freedom from anger; tenth, freedom from delusion. As the verse says: "Should a person find the sūtra's own text difficult to recite, then the composing of a vibhāṣā, an explanatory treatise, brings great benefit to just such a person." Should a person be of dull faculties and inclined to laziness, they may be unable to recite the sūtra's own text simply because it is difficult. As for "difficult": the text is lengthy, hard to recite, hard to expound, and hard to commit to memory. Should there be those who delight in adorned language, in varied ornamentation, in similes and verses of every kind, it is for the benefit of just such people that I compose this treatise. This is why what you said earlier — that the Buddha's sūtra alone is already sufficient, and that no further explanation is needed — is simply not so!
As the verse says: "In reflecting upon and composing this treatise, a profound and wholesome mind is given rise to; and by kindling this very Dharma, an offering unequaled is thereby made to the Buddha." While composing this treatise, I am constantly mindful of the Three Jewels and of the assembly of bodhisattvas; and I am mindful, too, of giving, of upholding the precepts, of patient endurance, of diligent effort, of meditative concentration, and of wisdom — and it is through this that a profound and wholesome mind arises, which is itself a benefit to myself. And in expounding and illuminating this true Dharma, this is called an offering unequaled, made to all the buddhas — which is itself a benefit to others. As the verse says: "In expounding the Dharma, one kindles the lamp of the Dharma, and raises up the banner of the Dharma; this banner is the seal and mark of the wondrous Dharma held by the worthy and the noble. In composing this treatise now, truth, generosity, cessation, and wisdom — these four abodes of merit — are, of their own accord, thereby cultivated and gathered together." In composing this treatise now, these four kinds of merit are gathered together of their own accord; it is for this reason that my mind knows no weariness. "Truth": that which is entirely real is called truth; and among all things that are real, the Buddha's own word is the truest of all, being subject to neither change nor decay. In explaining this Buddhadharma, I thereby gather the abode of truth. "Generosity" means giving. Giving is of two kinds: the giving of the Dharma, and the giving of material wealth. Between these two, the giving of the Dharma is superior. As the Buddha told the monks: "First, one should give the Dharma; second, one should give material wealth — and between these two, the giving of the Dharma is superior." It is for this reason that, in giving the Dharma in this way, I thereby gather the abode of generosity. When I expound the meaning of the ten grounds, there is no unwholesome conduct of body, speech, or mind; nor do any thoughts of desire, anger, or delusion arise. In thus obstructing these offenses, this is called gathering the abode of cessation. In explaining the Dharma on behalf of others, one obtains the recompense of great wisdom; and it is through this very act that I thereby gather the abode of wisdom. Thus, in composing this treatise, these four abodes of merit are gathered together.
Furthermore: "In expounding this treatise on the ten grounds, my own mind attains purity; and because I deeply cherish this very mind, I remain diligent and untiring." "Should there be a person who, hearing and upholding this treatise, thereby attains a pure mind, I too deeply delight in this, and compose this treatise with a single, undivided mind." The meaning of these two verses is already evident, and requires no further explanation. It is simply for the sake of purifying both my own mind and the minds of others that I compose this explanation of the ten grounds. A pure mind arrives at precisely the destination it should reach, and obtains a great recompense. Just as the Buddha said to Kālodāyin: "Do not resent Ānanda! Even were I not to prophesy that Ānanda will become an arhat after my own passing, then, by the very causes and conditions of this same pure mind, he would still become the king of the Heaven of Free Enjoyment of Transformations seven times over." This is expounded at length within the sūtra itself.
Nāgārjuna spends far more space defending his own act of writing than he will spend, in the pages immediately following, actually naming the ten grounds — a proportion that says something about the genre itself. A commentary written to make a difficult root text accessible has to answer, before anything else, why a "grown man's medicine" needed to be sweetened for anyone at all; the extended hell-and-hungry-ghost catalogue is not a digression but the argument's own evidence, showing exactly what a "faint-hearted mind" is afraid of when it reaches for the swifter vehicles instead of the ten grounds.
The Ten Grounds Named
問曰:汝說此語開悟,我心甚以欣悅,今解十地必多所利益。何等為十?
答曰:此中十地法,去來今諸佛,為諸佛子故,已說今當說:初地名歡喜,第二離垢地,三名為明地,第四名焰地,五名難勝地,六名現前地,第七深遠地,第八不動地,九名善慧地,十名法雲地。分別十地相,次後當廣說。
此中者,大乘義中。十者,數法。地者,菩薩善根,階級住處。諸佛者,十方三世諸如來。說者,開示、解釋。諸佛子者,諸佛真實子,諸菩薩是,是故菩薩名為佛子。過去、未來、現在諸佛皆說此十地,是故言「已說、今說、當說」。
菩薩在初地,始得善法味,心多歡喜故,名歡喜地。第二地中,行十善道,離諸垢故,名離垢地。第三地中,廣博多學,為眾說法,能作照明故,名為明地。第四地中,布施、持戒、多聞轉增,威德熾盛故,名為炎地。第五地中,功德力盛,一切諸魔,不能壞故,名難勝地。第六地中,障魔事已,諸菩薩道法,皆現在前故,名現前地。第七地中,去三界遠,近法王位故,名深遠地。第八地中,若天、魔、梵、沙門、婆羅門無能動其願故,名不動地。第九地中,其慧轉明,調柔增上故,名善慧地。第十地中,菩薩於十方無量世界,能一時雨法雨。如劫燒已普澍大雨,名法雲地。
Question: What you have said has opened my understanding, and my mind is deeply delighted; now, in explaining the ten grounds, this will surely bring great benefit. What, then, are these ten?
Answer: "This very Dharma of the ten grounds has been spoken, is spoken, and will be spoken by the buddhas of the past, future, and present, for the sake of all the sons of the buddhas: the first ground is named the Ground of Joy; the second, the Ground of Freedom from Defilement; the third, the Ground of Light; the fourth, the Ground of Radiance; the fifth, the Ground Difficult to Conquer; the sixth, the Ground of Direct Presence; the seventh, the Ground Gone Far Beyond; the eighth, the Immovable Ground; the ninth, the Ground of Excellent Wisdom; the tenth, the Ground of the Dharma Cloud. The distinguishing marks of these ten grounds will be expounded at length hereafter."
"Herein": within the meaning of the Great Vehicle. "Ten": a numbered dharma. "Ground": the graduated dwelling-place of the bodhisattva's own roots of goodness. "The buddhas": the Thus Come Ones of the ten directions and the three times. "Spoken": opened, revealed, and explained. "The sons of the buddhas": the true sons of all buddhas are the bodhisattvas themselves; it is for this reason that a bodhisattva is called a son of the buddhas. The buddhas of the past, the future, and the present have all alike spoken this teaching of the ten grounds — it is for this reason that it is said, "has been spoken, is spoken, and will be spoken."
When the bodhisattva abides upon the first ground, they first taste the flavor of the wholesome Dharma, and their mind is filled with great joy — it is for this reason that it is named the Ground of Joy. Within the second ground, one practices the ten wholesome paths of action, and thereby departs from every defilement — it is for this reason that it is named the Ground of Freedom from Defilement. Within the third ground, one becomes vastly learned, expounding the Dharma for the assembly, and is able to shine forth illumination — it is for this reason that it is named the Ground of Light. Within the fourth ground, giving, upholding the precepts, and vast learning increase further still, and one's own majestic virtue blazes forth — it is for this reason that it is named the Ground of Radiance. Within the fifth ground, the power of one's own merit grows abundant, and no māra whatsoever is able to destroy it — it is for this reason that it is named the Ground Difficult to Conquer. Within the sixth ground, having already obstructed the deeds of māra, every dharma of the bodhisattva path stands directly present before one — it is for this reason that it is named the Ground of Direct Presence. Within the seventh ground, one has departed far from the three realms, drawing near instead to the very throne of the Dharma King — it is for this reason that it is named the Ground Gone Far Beyond. Within the eighth ground, not even devas, māras, Brahmā, ascetics, or brahmins are able to shake one's own vow — it is for this reason that it is named the Immovable Ground. Within the ninth ground, one's own wisdom grows ever more luminous, gentle and supremely refined — it is for this reason that it is named the Ground of Excellent Wisdom. Within the tenth ground, the bodhisattva is able, throughout the immeasurable worlds of the ten directions, to rain down the rain of the Dharma all at once — just as, once the fire that consumes a kalpa has burned itself out, a great rain then pours down universally — it is for this reason that it is named the Ground of the Dharma Cloud.
This list of ten names, common across the entire Daśabhūmika literature, would become one of the most widely cited maps of the bodhisattva path in all of Mahāyāna Buddhism — the same ten grounds that Vasubandhu's own commentary on the Avataṃsaka's Ten Grounds chapter, already translated on this site, works through independently. What Nāgārjuna offers here that differs from that later, more systematic treatment is the plain etymology attached to each name: joy at a first genuine taste, radiance as virtue "blazes," a cloud of Dharma-rain following a kalpa's own fire — images drawn from ordinary experience rather than technical classification.
Entering the First Ground: Eight Dharmas and the Ten Powers
問曰:已聞十地名,今云何入初地,得地相貌,及修習地?
答曰:若厚種善根,善行於諸行,善集諸資用,善供養諸佛;善知識所護,具足於深心,悲心念眾生,信解無上法。具此八法已,當自發願言:我得自度已,當復度眾生;為得十力故,入於必定聚,則生如來家,無有諸過咎。即轉世間道,入出世上道,是以得初地,此地名歡喜。
厚種善根者,如法修集諸功德,名為厚種善根。善根者,不貪、不恚、不癡,一切善法,從此三生,故名為善根。如一切惡法,皆從貪、恚、癡生,是故此三,名不善根。《阿毘曇》中種種分別:欲界繫、色界繫、無色界繫、不繫,合為十二;有心相應、有心不相應,合二十四。此中無漏善根,得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提時修集;餘九,菩薩地中修集;又未發心時久修集。或一心中有三,或一心中有六,或一心中有九,或一心中有十二。或但集心相應,不集心不相應;或集心不相應,不集心相應。或集心相應,亦心不相應;或不集心相應,心不相應。是諸善根分別,如《阿毘曇》中廣說。此中善根:為眾生求無上道故所行諸善法,皆名善根;能生薩婆若智故,名為善根。
行於諸行者,善行名清淨,諸行名持戒,清淨持戒次第而行。是持戒與七法和合故,名為善行。何等為七?一、慚;二、愧;三、多聞;四、精進;五、念;六、慧;七、淨命,淨身、口業。行此七法,具持諸戒,是名善行諸行。又經說:諸禪為行處,是故得禪者,名為善行諸行。此論中不必以禪乃得發心。所以者何?佛在世時,無量眾生皆亦發心,不必有禪。又白衣在家,亦名為行。
善集資用者,上偈中所說「厚種善根、善行諸行、多供養佛、善知識護、具足深心、悲念眾生、信解上法」,是名資用。又本行善法,必應修行,亦名資用。所謂:布施、忍辱、質直不諂心、柔和同止樂、無慍恨性、殫盡不隱過、不偏執、不佷戾、不諍訟、不自恃、不放逸、捨憍慢、離矯異、不讚身、堪忍事、決定心、能果敢、受不捨、易教授、少欲知足、樂於獨處。如是等諸法隨行已,漸能具足殊勝功德,是法味堅牢故,名為本行。若離是法,不能進得勝妙功德。是故此本行法與八法和合故,為初地資用。
善供養諸佛者,若菩薩世世如法,常多供養諸佛。供養有二種:一者:善聽大乘正法,若廣、若略。二者:四事供養、恭敬、禮侍等。具此二法供養諸佛,名為善供養諸佛。
善知識者,菩薩雖有四種善知識,此中所說——能教入大乘,具諸波羅蜜,能令住十地者。所謂:諸佛菩薩及諸聲聞,能示教利喜大乘之法,令不退轉。守護者,常能慈愍教誨,令得增長善根,是名守護。
具足深心者,深樂佛乘、無上大乘、一切智乘,名為具足深心。
問曰:無盡意菩薩於〈和合品〉中告舍利弗:諸菩薩所有發心,皆名深心。從一地至一地故,名為趣心。增益功德故,名為過心。得無上事故,名為頂心。攝取上法故,名為上心。現前得諸佛法故,名為現前心。集利益法故,名為緣心。通達一切法故,名為度心。所願不倦故,名為決定心。滿所願故,名為喜心。身自成辦故,名無侶心。離敗壞相故,名調和心。無諸惡故,名為善心。遠離惡人故,名不雜心。以頭施故,名難捨心。救破戒人故,名持難戒心。能受下劣加惡故,名難忍心。得涅槃能捨故,名難精進心。不貪禪故,名難禪定心。助道善根無厭足故,名難慧心。能成一切事故,名度諸行心。智慧善思惟故,名離慢、大慢、我慢心。不望報故,是一切眾生福田心。觀諸佛深法故,名無畏心。不障閡故,名增功德心。常發精進故,名無盡心。能荷受重擔故,名不悶心。又深心義者,等念眾生,普慈一切,供養賢善,悲念惡人,尊敬師長。救無救者,無歸作歸、無洲作洲;無究竟者,為作究竟;無有侶者,能為作侶。曲人中,行於直心;敗壞人中,行真正心;諛諂人中,行無諂心;不知恩中,行於知恩;不知作中,而行知作;無利益中,能行利益;邪眾生中,行於正行;憍慢人中,行無慢行;不隨教中,而不慍恚;罪眾生中,常作守護。眾生所有過,不見其失,供養福田,隨順教誨,受化不難。阿練若處,一心精進,不求利養,不惜身命。復次,內心清淨故,無有誑惑;善口業故,不自稱歎;知止足故,不行威迫;心無垢故,行於柔和;集善根故,能入生死;為眾生故,忍一切苦。菩薩有如是等深心相故,不可窮盡。汝今但說深心相,何得不少?
答曰:不少也!〈無盡意〉總一切深心相在一處說;而此中分布諸地。此《十住經》地地別說深心相,是故菩薩隨諸地中皆得深心,深心之義即在其地。今初地中說二深心:一者、發大願。二者、在必定地。是故當知,隨在十地善說深心。汝說:「何得不少」,是事不然!
悲心於眾生者,成就悲故,名為悲者。何謂為悲?悼愍眾生,救濟苦難。信解諸上法者,於諸佛法信力通達。發願:「我得自度已,當度眾生」者,一切諸法,願為其本,離願則不成,是故發願。
問曰:何故不言我當度眾生,而言自得度已當度眾生?
答曰:自未得度,不能度彼。如人自沒淤泥,何能拯拔餘人?又如為水所㵱,不能濟溺,是故說我度已當度彼。如說:若人自度畏,能度歸依者,自未度疑悔,何能度所歸?若人自不善,不能令人善,若不自寂滅,安能令人寂?是故先自善寂而後化人。又如《法句》偈說:若能自安身,在於善處者,然後安餘人,自同於所利。凡物皆先自利,後能利人。何以故?如說:若自成己利,乃能利於彼;自捨欲利他,失利後憂悔!是故說自度已,當度眾生。
問曰:得何利故,能成此事入必定地?又以何心,能發是願?
答曰:得佛十力,能成此事入必定地,能發是願。
問曰:何等是佛十力?
答曰:佛悉了達一切法因果,名為初力。如實知去、來、今所起業果、報處,名為二力。如實知諸禪定三昧,分別垢、淨、入、出相,名為三力。如實知眾生諸根利、鈍,名為四力。如實知眾生所樂不同,名為五力。如實知世間種種異性,名為六力。如實知至一切處道,名為七力。如實知宿命事,名為八力。如實知生死事,名為九力。如實知漏盡事,名為十力。為得如是佛十力故,大心發願,即入必定聚。
Question: Having now heard the names of the ten grounds, how does one enter the first ground, attain the mark proper to this ground, and cultivate this ground in practice?
Answer: "One who has abundantly planted roots of goodness, skillfully practiced every conduct, skillfully gathered every resource and provision, and skillfully made offerings to the buddhas; who is protected by good and virtuous friends, who possesses a mind of full depth, who is compassionate and mindful of sentient beings, and who has faith in and understanding of the unsurpassed Dharma — having fulfilled these eight dharmas, one should then give rise, of one's own accord, to this very vow: 'Having attained liberation myself, I shall then liberate all sentient beings.' In order to attain the ten powers, one enters the assembly of those certain to attain awakening, and is thereby born into the household of the Thus Come One, free of every fault. It is precisely this that transforms the mundane path into the supreme path transcending the world — and it is by this means that the first ground is attained, this ground being named the Ground of Joy."
"Abundantly planted roots of goodness": to cultivate and gather every quality of merit in accordance with the Dharma is called abundantly planting roots of goodness. "Roots of goodness": non-greed, non-anger, and non-delusion — every wholesome dharma arises from these three, and it is for this reason that they are called roots of goodness. Just as every unwholesome dharma arises from greed, anger, and delusion, these three are called the unwholesome roots. Within the Abhidharma, these are distinguished in various ways: those bound to the desire realm, those bound to the form realm, those bound to the formless realm, and those unbound — together making twelve; and each of these as associated with mind or dissociated from mind — together making twenty-four. Among these, the uncontaminated roots of goodness are cultivated at the moment of attaining unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening; the remaining nine are cultivated within the bodhisattva grounds, and also over a long span even before the aspiration first arises. There may be three present within a single mind, or six, or nine, or twelve. Sometimes only those associated with mind are gathered, and not those dissociated from mind, or the reverse; sometimes both are gathered together, or neither. These distinctions are expounded at length within the Abhidharma. Here, "roots of goodness" refers to this: every wholesome dharma practiced for the sake of seeking the unsurpassed path on behalf of sentient beings is called a root of goodness; and because it is able to give rise to the wisdom of omniscience, it is called a root of goodness.
"Skillfully practiced every conduct": "skillful practice" means purity; "every conduct" means upholding the precepts; and one practices, in due sequence, the pure upholding of these precepts. It is through this upholding of the precepts, combined with seven further dharmas, that it is called skillful practice. What are these seven? First, a sense of shame before oneself; second, a sense of shame before others; third, vast learning; fourth, diligent effort; fifth, mindfulness; sixth, wisdom; seventh, a pure livelihood, purifying one's own conduct of body and speech. In practicing these seven dharmas, fully upholding every precept, this is called skillful practice of every conduct. The sūtra further states that the meditative absorptions themselves are this very field of practice; it is for this reason that one who has attained these absorptions is likewise called one who has skillfully practiced every conduct. Within this treatise, however, it is not necessarily the case that this aspiration can only be given rise to by means of the absorptions. And why is this so? Because, while the Buddha was still in the world, immeasurable sentient beings likewise gave rise to this same aspiration without necessarily possessing these absorptions at all; and even a layperson dwelling at home in white robes is likewise said to be engaged in this very practice.
"Skillfully gathered every resource and provision": what the verse above described — abundantly planting roots of goodness, skillfully practicing every conduct, extensively making offerings to the buddhas, being protected by good friends, possessing a mind of full depth, being compassionate and mindful of sentient beings, and having faith in and understanding of the supreme Dharma — this is what is meant by resource and provision. Furthermore, the fundamental wholesome dharmas that must necessarily be cultivated are likewise called resource and provision — namely: giving; patient endurance; a straightforward mind free of flattery; gentleness and the shared joy of dwelling together with others; a nature free of resentment; exhausting one's own faults without concealing them; freedom from partisan attachment; freedom from obstinacy; freedom from contentious dispute; freedom from self-reliance alone; freedom from heedlessness; abandoning arrogance and conceit; departing from pretense; not praising oneself; the capacity to bear with circumstances; a resolute mind; the ability to act with courage; accepting what one receives without abandoning it; being easy to instruct; having few desires and knowing contentment; and delighting in solitude. Having practiced, in accordance with these, every such dharma, one gradually becomes able to fully possess sublime qualities of merit, and because the flavor of this Dharma is firm and enduring, it is called the fundamental practice. Apart from this Dharma, one cannot advance to attain sublime and wondrous qualities of merit. It is for this reason that this fundamental practice, combined with the eight dharmas, constitutes the resource and provision for the first ground.
"Skillfully made offerings to the buddhas": should the bodhisattva, life after life, in accordance with the Dharma, constantly and extensively make offerings to the buddhas. Such offerings are of two kinds: first, skillfully listening to the true Dharma of the Great Vehicle, whether at length or in brief; second, offerings of the four material necessities, reverence, and attendance in homage. Fulfilling both these kinds of offering is called skillfully making offerings to the buddhas.
"Good and virtuous friends": though the bodhisattva has four kinds of good and virtuous friends, what is spoken of here refers specifically to those able to teach one to enter the Great Vehicle, to fully possess the pāramitās, and to enable one to abide upon the ten grounds — namely, the buddhas and bodhisattvas, and the śrāvakas as well, who are able to instruct, benefit, and delight one in the Dharma of the Great Vehicle, causing one never to regress from it. "Protected": to be constantly compassionate and instructive, causing one's own roots of goodness to grow and increase — this is called being protected.
"Possessing a mind of full depth": to deeply delight in the buddha-vehicle, the unsurpassed Great Vehicle, the vehicle of omniscience — this is called possessing a mind of full depth.
Question: Within the Chapter of Harmonious Union, the Bodhisattva Akṣayamati told Śāriputra: "Every arising of the aspiration possessed by bodhisattvas is called a profound mind." Because it advances from ground to ground, it is called the mind that progresses. Because it increases merit, it is called the mind that surpasses. Because it attains the unsurpassed matter, it is called the summit mind. Because it takes hold of the supreme Dharma, it is called the superior mind. Because it attains the dharmas of all buddhas directly before it, it is called the mind of direct presence. Because it gathers every beneficial dharma, it is called the mind of causal connection. Because it penetrates every dharma, it is called the mind that ferries across. Because its vow knows no weariness, it is called the resolute mind. Because it fulfills its own vow, it is called the joyful mind. Because it accomplishes its own task by itself, it is called the mind without companion. Because it departs from every mark of ruin, it is called the harmonious mind. Because it is free of every evil, it is called the wholesome mind. Because it departs far from evil persons, it is called the unmixed mind. Because it gives away even its own head, it is called the mind difficult to relinquish. Because it rescues those who have broken the precepts, it is called the mind that upholds the difficult precept. Because it bears even the addition of the basest evil, it is called the mind difficult to endure. Because, having attained nirvāṇa, it is nonetheless able to relinquish it, it is called the mind of difficult diligence. Because it does not crave the absorptions themselves, it is called the mind of difficult concentration. Because it is never satiated in the roots of goodness that assist the path, it is called the mind of difficult wisdom. Because it is able to accomplish every task, it is called the mind that ferries across every conduct. Because its wisdom reflects skillfully, it is called the mind free of conceit, of great conceit, and of the conceit of self. Because it expects no recompense, it is the mind that serves as a field of merit for all sentient beings. Because it contemplates the profound Dharma of the buddhas, it is called the fearless mind. Because it is free of any obstruction, it is called the mind that increases merit. Because it constantly gives rise to diligent effort, it is called the inexhaustible mind. Because it is able to bear a heavy burden, it is called the mind free of distress. Furthermore, as for the meaning of this profound mind: it thinks equally of all sentient beings, extends its compassion universally, makes offerings to the worthy and the good, holds compassionate thought even for evil persons, and honors one's own teachers. It saves those who have no other savior; it becomes a refuge for those without refuge, an island for those without an island; it becomes an ultimate resting-place for those who have none; it becomes a companion for those who have no companion at all. Among those who are crooked, it practices a straightforward mind; among the corrupt, a mind that is true; among the flattering, a mind free of flattery; among the ungrateful, gratitude itself; among those who do not know how to act, knowing how to act; where there is no benefit at all, it is still able to bring about benefit; among sentient beings gone astray, right conduct; among the arrogant, conduct free of arrogance; among those who do not follow instruction, it remains free of resentment; and among sinful sentient beings, it constantly acts as their protector. Whatever faults sentient beings may possess, it does not dwell upon their shortcomings; it makes offerings to fields of merit, follows instruction with ease, and readily accepts transformation. Dwelling in solitary places of practice, it exerts itself with a single mind, seeking neither gain nor support, and begrudging neither its own body nor its own life. Furthermore, because its inner mind is pure, it engages in no deception; because its verbal conduct is wholesome, it never praises itself; because it knows how to be satisfied, it never resorts to intimidation; because its mind is free of defilement, it acts with gentleness; because it gathers roots of goodness, it is able to enter into birth and death; and for the sake of sentient beings, it endures every form of suffering. Since the bodhisattva possesses marks of this profound mind such as these, they can never be exhausted. Yet you have now spoken of the marks of this profound mind only briefly — how could this not be too few?
Answer: It is not too few! The Chapter of Akṣayamati gathers together every mark of this profound mind and speaks of them all in a single place, whereas here, they are distributed across the several grounds instead. This Sūtra of the Ten Abodes speaks of the marks of this profound mind separately, ground by ground; it is for this reason that the bodhisattva attains this profound mind within each and every ground in turn, the meaning of this profound mind residing precisely within that particular ground. Here, within the first ground, only two aspects of this profound mind are spoken of: first, giving rise to the great vow; second, abiding within the stage of certainty. One should therefore understand that this profound mind is skillfully explained according to each of the ten grounds in turn. What you have said — "how could this not be too few" — is simply not so!
"A mind of compassion toward sentient beings": one who has accomplished compassion is called compassionate. What, then, is meant by compassion? To grieve for and pity sentient beings, and to rescue and relieve them from suffering and hardship. "Having faith in and understanding of the supreme Dharma": to penetrate the Dharma of all buddhas through the power of faith. As for giving rise to the vow, "having attained liberation myself, I shall then liberate sentient beings": among all dharmas, the vow is their very root; apart from this vow, nothing could ever be accomplished — it is for this reason that this vow is given rise to.
Question: Why does it not simply say, "I shall liberate sentient beings," but instead says, "having attained liberation myself, I shall then liberate sentient beings"?
Answer: One who has not yet attained their own liberation cannot liberate another. It is just as a person sunk in mud themselves cannot possibly pull another person out; or just as one who is themselves being swept away by water cannot rescue another from drowning. It is for this very reason that it is said, "having liberated myself, I shall then liberate others." As the verse says: "If a person, still fearing for their own liberation, wishes to liberate those who take refuge in them — while still doubting and regretting their own liberation, how could they possibly liberate those who have taken refuge? If a person is not themselves virtuous, they cannot cause another to become virtuous; if they have not themselves attained tranquility, how could they possibly bring tranquility to another?" It is for this reason that one must first become virtuous and tranquil oneself, and only afterward transform others. And as the Dharmapada verse likewise says: "If one is able to first settle one's own body within a wholesome state, one may then settle others as well, oneself sharing equally in the very benefit bestowed." In every matter, one must first benefit oneself before being able to benefit others. And why is this so? As the verse says: "Only once one has accomplished one's own benefit is one then able to benefit another; should one abandon this and seek to benefit others first, one loses this benefit and comes afterward to regret and sorrow!" It is for this very reason that it is said, "having liberated myself, I shall then liberate sentient beings."
Question: By obtaining what benefit is one able to accomplish this task and enter the stage of certainty? And with what mind is one able to give rise to this very vow?
Answer: It is by obtaining the buddha's ten powers that one is able to accomplish this task, enter the stage of certainty, and give rise to this very vow.
Question: What, then, are the buddha's ten powers?
Answer: The buddha fully comprehends the causes and effects of every dharma without exception — this is called the first power. He knows exactly as it is the karmic effects that arise, and the places of their retribution, throughout the past, the future, and the present — this is called the second power. He knows exactly as it is every meditative absorption and samādhi, distinguishing the marks of their defilement, their purity, their entry, and their emergence — this is called the third power. He knows exactly as it is whether the faculties of sentient beings are sharp or dull — this is called the fourth power. He knows exactly as it is the differing inclinations of sentient beings — this is called the fifth power. He knows exactly as it is the manifold and differing natures found throughout the world — this is called the sixth power. He knows exactly as it is the path that leads to every possible destination — this is called the seventh power. He knows exactly as it is the matters of past lives — this is called the eighth power. He knows exactly as it is the matters of birth and death — this is called the ninth power. He knows exactly as it is the extinction of every outflow — this is called the tenth power. It is in order to obtain these very ten powers that this great mind gives rise to this vow, and thereby enters the assembly of those certain to attain awakening.
The forty-clause catalogue of "deep mind" qualities that Nāgārjuna cites from Akṣayamati's own chapter, and then explicitly declines to reproduce in full, illustrates a structural principle he states outright: rather than exhausting every mark of the bodhisattva's mind in a single place, the Ten Grounds Sūtra distributes them one or two at a time across all ten grounds, so that "the meaning of this profound mind resides precisely within that particular ground." The first ground receives only two — a great vow, and abiding in certainty — precisely because the remaining thirty-eight or more are being saved for later.
The Mind That Enters Certainty, and Birth into the Tathāgata's Household
問曰:凡初發心皆有如是相耶?
答曰:或有人說:「初發心便有如是相。」而實不爾!何以故?是事應分別,不應定答。所以者何?一切菩薩初發心時,不應悉入於必定。或有初發心時,即入必定。或有漸修功德,如釋迦牟尼佛初發心時,不入必定;後修集功德,值燃燈佛,得入必定。是故汝說:「一切菩薩初發心,便入必定」,是為邪論。
問曰:若是邪論者,何故汝說:「以是心,入必定」?
答曰:有菩薩初發心,即入必定。以是心,能得初地,因是人故,說:「初發心入必定中。」
問曰:是菩薩初心,釋迦牟尼佛初發心,是心云何?
答曰:是心不雜一切煩惱。是心相續,不貪異乘。是心堅牢,一切外道無能勝者。是心一切眾魔不能破壞。是心為常,能集善根。是心能知有為無常。是心無動,能攝佛法。是心無覆,離諸邪行。是心安住,不可動故。是心無比,無相違故。是心如金剛,通達諸法故。是心不盡,集無盡福德故。是心平等,等一切眾生故。是心無高下,無差別故。是心清淨,性無垢故。是心離垢,慧炤明故。是心無垢,不捨深心故。是心為廣,慈如虛空故。是心為大,受一切眾生故。是心無閡,至無障智故。是心遍到,不斷大悲故。是心不斷,能正迴向故。是心眾所趣向,智者所讚故。是心可觀,小乘瞻仰故。是心難見,一切眾生不能覩故。是心難破,能善入佛法故。是心為住,一切樂具所住處故。是心莊嚴,福德資用故。是心選擇,智慧資用故。是心淳厚,以布施為資用故。是心大願,持戒資用故。是心難沮,忍辱資用故。是心難勝,精進資用故。是心寂滅,禪定資用故。是心無惱害,慧資用故。是心無瞋閡,慈心深故。是心根深,悲心厚故。是心悅樂,喜心厚故。是心苦樂不動,捨心厚故。是心護念,諸佛神力故。是心相續,三寶不斷故。
如是等無量功德莊嚴初必定心,如〈無盡意品〉中廣說。是心不雜一切煩惱者,見諦、思惟所斷二百九十四煩惱,不與心和合故,名為不雜。是心相續不貪異乘者,從初心相續來,不貪聲聞、辟支佛乘,但為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提故,名為相續,不貪異乘。如是等四十句論,應如是知。
問曰:汝說是心常!一切有為法皆無常,如《法印經》中說:「行者觀世間空,無有常而不變壞」。是事何得不相違耶?
答曰:汝於是義不得正理,故作此難!是中不說心為常。此中雖口說常,常義名必定;初心生,必能常集諸善根,不休、不息,故名為常。
生如來家者,如來家則是佛家。如來者,「如」名為實,「來」名為至;至真實中故,名為如來。何等為真實?所謂涅槃不虛誑故,是名如實。如《經》中說:「佛告比丘:第一聖諦無有虛誑,涅槃是也。」復次「如」名不壞相,所謂諸法實相是。「來」名智慧到實相中。通達其義故,名為如來。復次,空、無相、無作名為如;諸佛來至三解脫門,亦令眾生到此門故,名為如來。復次,如名四諦;以一切種見四諦,故名為如來。復次,如名六波羅蜜,所謂布施、持戒、忍辱、精進、禪定、智慧;以是六法來至佛地故,名為如來。復次,諦、捨、滅、慧四功德處,名為如來;以是四法來至佛地故,名為如來。復次,一切佛法名為如;是如來至諸佛故,名為如來。復次,一切菩薩地:喜、淨、明、炎、難勝、現前、深遠、不動、善慧、法雲名為如;諸菩薩以是十地,來至阿耨多羅三藐三菩提故,名為如來。又以如實八聖道分來故,名為如來。復次,權、智二足來至佛故,名為如來。如去不還故,名為如來。如來者,所謂十方三世諸佛是。是諸佛家名為如來家。今是菩薩行如來道,相續不斷故,名為生如來家。又是菩薩必成如來故,名為生如來家。譬如生轉輪聖王家,有轉輪聖王相,是人必作轉輪聖王;是菩薩亦如是,生如來家發是心故,必成如來,是名生如來家。
如來家者,有人言:是四功德處,所謂諦、捨、滅、慧;諸如來從此中生,故名為如來家。有人言:般若波羅蜜及方便,是如來家。如《助道經》中說:智度無極母,善權方便父,生故名為父,養育故名母。一切世間以父母為家,是二似父母故,名之為家。有人言:善、慧名諸佛家,從是二法出生諸佛,是二則是一切善法之根本。如《經》中說:「是二法俱行能成正法。」善是父,慧是母,是二和合,名為諸佛家。如說:菩薩善法父,智慧以為母;一切諸如來,皆從是二生。有人言:般舟三昧及大悲,名諸佛家。從此二法生諸如來,此中般舟三昧為父,大悲為母。復次,般舟三昧是父,無生法忍是母。如《助菩提》中說:般舟三昧父,大悲無生母;一切諸如來,從是二法生。
家無過咎者,家清淨故。清淨者,六波羅蜜、四功德處、方便、般若波羅蜜、善、慧、般舟三昧、大悲、諸忍,是諸法清淨無有過故,名家清淨。是菩薩以此諸法為家故,無有過咎,轉於過咎。轉於世間道、入出世上道者,世間道名,即是凡夫所行道。轉名休息。凡夫道者,不能究竟至涅槃,常往來生死,是名凡夫道。出世間者,因是道,得出三界,故名出世間道。上者,妙故名為上。入者,正行道故名為入。以是心入初地名歡喜地。
Question: Does every initial arising of the aspiration possess a mark such as this?
Answer: There are some who say: "The very first arising of the aspiration already possesses a mark such as this." But this is, in truth, not so! And why is this so? This matter must be carefully distinguished, and cannot be answered with a single fixed reply. And why is this? Because it is not the case that every bodhisattva, at the moment their aspiration first arises, necessarily enters the stage of certainty. There are some who, at the very moment their aspiration first arises, enter this stage of certainty at once. And there are others who gradually cultivate merit — just as Śākyamuni Buddha himself, at the moment his own aspiration first arose, did not yet enter this stage of certainty; only later, having cultivated merit, and having encountered Dīpaṃkara Buddha, did he come to enter this stage of certainty. It is for this reason that what you have said — that every bodhisattva enters this stage of certainty at the very moment their aspiration first arises — is a mistaken view.
Question: If this is indeed a mistaken view, then why did you yourself say, "with this very mind, one enters the stage of certainty"?
Answer: There are indeed bodhisattvas who, at the very moment their aspiration first arises, enter this stage of certainty at once; it is by means of this very mind that they are able to attain the first ground. It is on account of just such persons that it is said, "at the very moment the aspiration first arises, one enters the stage of certainty."
Question: As for this initial mind of the bodhisattva, and Śākyamuni Buddha's own initial arising of the aspiration — what, then, is this mind actually like?
Answer: "This mind is unmixed with any affliction whatsoever. This mind is sustained in unbroken continuity, craving no other vehicle. This mind is firm and unshakeable, so that no adherent of any outside path can overcome it. This mind cannot be destroyed by any host of māras whatsoever. This mind is constant, able to gather roots of goodness continuously. This mind is able to know that all conditioned things are impermanent. This mind is unmoving, able to hold fast to the Buddhadharma. This mind is unconcealed, departed from every deviant conduct. This mind abides in stability, for it cannot be shaken. This mind is beyond compare, for it contradicts nothing. This mind is like vajra, for it penetrates every dharma. This mind is inexhaustible, for it gathers merit that can never be exhausted. This mind is equal, for it regards all sentient beings equally. This mind knows no higher or lower, for it makes no distinction at all. This mind is pure, for its very nature is free of defilement. This mind is free of defilement, for its wisdom shines with clarity. This mind is undefiled, for it never abandons this profound mind. This mind is vast, for its compassion is like empty space itself. This mind is great, for it embraces every sentient being. This mind is unobstructed, for it arrives at wisdom free of every hindrance. This mind reaches everywhere, for its great compassion never ceases. This mind is unbroken, for it dedicates its merit rightly and without fail. This mind is the destination all beings turn toward, for it is praised by the wise. This mind can be beheld, for even the Lesser Vehicle looks up to it in reverence. This mind is difficult to see, for no sentient being is able to perceive it fully. This mind is difficult to destroy, for it is able to enter skillfully into the Buddhadharma. This mind provides a dwelling, for it is the very abode of every joyful provision. This mind is adorned, for merit is its resource. This mind discerns rightly, for wisdom is its resource. This mind is deep and full, for giving is its resource. This mind holds a great vow, for upholding the precepts is its resource. This mind is difficult to obstruct, for patient endurance is its resource. This mind is difficult to conquer, for diligent effort is its resource. This mind is tranquil and still, for meditative concentration is its resource. This mind causes no harm, for wisdom is its resource. This mind holds no obstruction of anger, for its compassion runs deep. This mind is deeply rooted, for its pity runs profound. This mind delights and rejoices, for its joy runs profound. This mind remains unmoved by suffering or pleasure, for its equanimity runs profound. This mind is guarded and protected, for it is upheld by the spiritual power of all buddhas. This mind is sustained in unbroken continuity, for the Three Jewels themselves are never severed."
Immeasurable qualities of merit such as these adorn this initial mind of certainty, as is expounded at length within the Chapter of Akṣayamati. As for "this mind is unmixed with any affliction whatsoever": the two hundred and ninety-four afflictions eliminated through the seeing of truth and through cultivated reflection do not intermingle together with this mind — it is for this reason that it is called unmixed. As for "this mind is sustained in unbroken continuity, craving no other vehicle": from the very moment this initial mind arises in unbroken continuity onward, it craves neither the vehicle of the śrāvaka nor that of the pratyekabuddha, but seeks only unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening — it is for this reason that it is called sustained in unbroken continuity, craving no other vehicle. The remaining forty clauses of this treatise should likewise be understood in just this same manner.
Question: You have said that this mind is constant! Yet every conditioned dharma is impermanent, just as the Dharma-Seal Sūtra states: "The practitioner contemplates the world as empty, with nothing constant that does not change and decay." How could this not be a contradiction?
Answer: You have failed to grasp the correct principle of this meaning, and it is for this reason that you raise this objection! It is not said, within this passage, that this mind is permanent in the ordinary sense. Though the word "constant" is spoken here, the meaning of "constant" refers instead to certainty: once this initial mind arises, it is certain to constantly gather every root of goodness, without ever resting or ceasing — it is for this reason that it is called constant.
"Born into the household of the Tathāgata": the household of the Tathāgata is itself the household of the Buddha. "Tathāgata": "thus" means the real and the true; "come" means to arrive; because one arrives within the very truth itself, it is called Tathāgata. What, then, is this truth and reality? It is nirvāṇa itself, being free of any falsehood, that is called truth and reality. As the sūtra states: "The Buddha told the monks: the first noble truth, free of any falsehood, is precisely this — nirvāṇa itself." Furthermore, "thus" refers to the mark that cannot be destroyed — namely, the true mark of all dharmas itself. "Come" means that wisdom arrives within this very true mark. Because one penetrates this meaning fully, it is called Tathāgata. Furthermore, emptiness, signlessness, and wishlessness are together called "thus"; because the buddhas arrive at these three gates of liberation, and likewise cause sentient beings to reach these very gates, they are called Tathāgata. Furthermore, "thus" refers to the four noble truths; because they behold these four truths in every respect, they are called Tathāgata. Furthermore, "thus" refers to the six pāramitās — namely, giving, upholding the precepts, patient endurance, diligent effort, meditative concentration, and wisdom; because it is by means of these six dharmas that one arrives at the very ground of buddhahood, they are called Tathāgata. Furthermore, the four abodes of merit — truth, generosity, cessation, and wisdom — are called "thus"; because it is by means of these four dharmas that one arrives at buddhahood, they are called Tathāgata. Furthermore, the entirety of the Buddhadharma is called "thus"; because one arrives, by means of this "thus," at all the buddhas themselves, they are called Tathāgata. Furthermore, every one of the bodhisattva's grounds — Joy, Freedom from Defilement, Light, Radiance, Difficult to Conquer, Direct Presence, Gone Far Beyond, Immovable, Excellent Wisdom, and the Dharma Cloud — are called "thus"; because the bodhisattvas, by means of these ten grounds, arrive at unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening, they are called Tathāgata. And because they arrive by means of the eightfold noble path exactly as it is, they are likewise called Tathāgata. Furthermore, because they arrive at buddhahood by means of the two feet of skillful means and wisdom, they are called Tathāgata. And because they go, in this manner of "thus," without ever returning again, they are called Tathāgata. "Tathāgata," then, refers precisely to the buddhas of the ten directions and the three times. The household of all these buddhas is called the household of the Tathāgata. Now, because this bodhisattva practices the very path of the Tathāgata in unbroken continuity, it is said that they are born into the household of the Tathāgata. And because this bodhisattva is certain to become a Tathāgata, it is likewise said that they are born into the household of the Tathāgata. It is just as one born into the household of a wheel-turning sage-king, possessing the very mark of a wheel-turning sage-king, is certain to become a wheel-turning sage-king in turn; the bodhisattva is likewise so — having been born into the household of the Tathāgata and having given rise to this very mind, they are certain to become a Tathāgata — this is what is meant by being born into the household of the Tathāgata.
As for "the household of the Tathāgata": some say that it is these four abodes of merit — namely, truth, generosity, cessation, and wisdom; since every Tathāgata is born from within these very abodes, they are called the household of the Tathāgata. Some say that the perfection of wisdom together with skillful means is itself the household of the Tathāgata. As the Sūtra on Aids to the Path states: "The perfection of wisdom, boundless, is the mother; skillful and expedient means is the father — for begetting, it is called father; for nurturing, it is called mother." Since everyone in the world takes their father and mother as their own household, and these two are likened to father and mother, they are called this household. Some say that goodness and wisdom are called the household of the buddhas, since it is from these two dharmas that every buddha comes forth, and these two are the very root of every wholesome dharma. As the sūtra states: "It is by these two dharmas practiced together that the true Dharma is accomplished." Goodness is the father, wisdom is the mother; the union of these two is called the household of the buddhas. As the verse says: "The bodhisattva's wholesome dharma is the father, and wisdom serves as the mother; every single Tathāgata is born from these two alone." Some say that the pratyutpanna samādhi together with great compassion is called the household of the buddhas. Every Tathāgata is born from these two dharmas; here, the pratyutpanna samādhi is the father, and great compassion is the mother. Furthermore, the pratyutpanna samādhi is the father, and the acceptance of the non-arising of all dharmas is the mother. As the Aids to Awakening states: "The pratyutpanna samādhi is the father, great compassion and the acceptance of non-arising the mother; every single Tathāgata is born from these two dharmas alone."
"A household free of every fault": because this household is itself pure. "Pure": the six pāramitās, the four abodes of merit, skillful means, the perfection of wisdom, goodness, wisdom, the pratyutpanna samādhi, great compassion, and every form of acceptance — since these dharmas are themselves pure and free of any fault, this household is called pure. Since this bodhisattva takes these very dharmas as their own household, they are free of every fault, and transform every fault that might arise. As for "transforming the mundane path and entering the supreme path transcending the world": "the mundane path" refers to the very path that ordinary beings travel; "transforming" means bringing it to rest. "The path of the ordinary being": one who is unable to reach nirvāṇa ultimately, but constantly comes and goes within birth and death — this is called the path of the ordinary being. "Transcending the world": because it is by means of this path that one is able to depart from the three realms, it is called the path transcending the world. "Supreme": because it is sublime, it is called supreme. "Entering": because one rightly practices this path, it is called entering. It is by means of this very mind that one enters the first ground, named the Ground of Joy.
Nāgārjuna's own resolution of the apparent contradiction between "this mind is constant" and the basic Buddhist premise that all conditioned things are impermanent turns on a redefinition worth noticing: "constant" here does not mean "unchanging," but "certain never to stop gathering goodness" — a claim about the reliability of a trajectory, not the fixity of a state. The same move recurs throughout Mahāyāna scholastic literature whenever ordinary vocabulary threatens to smuggle in a permanence the doctrine cannot allow.
Why Called "Joy"
問曰:初地何故名為歡喜?
答曰:如得於初果,究竟至涅槃;菩薩得是地,心常多歡喜。自然得增長,諸佛如來種,是故如此人,得名賢善者。
如得初果者,如人得須陀洹道,善閉三惡道門;見法、入法、得法、住堅牢法,不可傾動,究竟至涅槃。斷見諦所斷法故,心大歡喜——設使睡眠嬾惰,不至二十九有。如以一毛為百分,以一分毛分取大海水,若二、三渧;苦已滅者,如大海水,餘未滅者,如二、三渧,心大歡喜。
菩薩如是得初地已,名生如來家。一切天、龍、夜叉、乾闥婆、阿修羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽,天王、梵王,沙門、婆羅門,一切聲聞、辟支佛等,所共供養恭敬。何以故?是家無有過咎故,轉世間道,入出世間道。但樂敬佛,得四功德處,得六波羅蜜果報滋味,不斷諸佛種故,心大歡喜。是菩薩所有餘苦,如二、三水渧。雖百千億劫得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提,於無始生死苦,如二、三水渧;所可滅苦,如大海水。是故此地名為歡喜。
十住毘婆沙論卷第一
Question: Why, then, is the first ground named the Ground of Joy?
Answer: "It is just as one who has attained the first fruit is certain to reach nirvāṇa in the end; the bodhisattva, having attained this ground, is likewise constant in great joy of mind. The seed of all buddhas and Tathāgatas naturally grows and increases within them — it is for this reason that such a person comes to be called worthy and good."
"As one who has attained the first fruit": it is just as a person who attains the path of stream-entry has thereby soundly closed the gate to the three evil destinies; they see the Dharma, enter the Dharma, attain the Dharma, and abide within a firm and unshakeable Dharma, certain to reach nirvāṇa in the end. Having severed the dharmas eliminated through the seeing of truth, their mind is filled with great joy — even should they fall into slumber or indolence thereafter, they will not extend beyond twenty-nine further states of existence. It is just as if a single hair were divided into a hundred parts, and with one such part, two or three drops of the great ocean's water were drawn out: the suffering already extinguished is like the great ocean itself, while what remains unextinguished is like these two or three mere drops — and it is for this reason that their mind is filled with great joy.
The bodhisattva, having thus attained the first ground, is said to be born into the household of the Tathāgata. All devas, nāgas, yakṣas, gandharvas, asuras, garuḍas, kiṃnaras, mahoragas, the kings of the devas, Brahmā kings, ascetics, brahmins, and every śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha alike come together to make offerings to them and revere them. And why is this so? Because this household is free of every fault, having transformed the mundane path and entered the path transcending the world. Delighting solely in reverence for the Buddha, having attained the four abodes of merit, having tasted the very fruit of the six pāramitās, and never severing the seed of the buddhas, their mind is filled with great joy. Whatever suffering remains for this bodhisattva is like these mere two or three drops of water. Though it may take a hundred thousand million kalpas to attain unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening, this remaining suffering, set against the beginningless suffering of birth and death, is like these two or three drops of water alone; while the suffering already extinguished is like the great ocean itself. It is for this very reason that this ground is named the Ground of Joy.
Fascicle 1 of the Daśabhūmika-vibhāṣā Śāstra
The image of one hundredth of a single hair, dipped into the ocean, drawing out two or three drops, is Nāgārjuna's own answer to an obvious objection: if the bodhisattva path still takes kalpas beyond counting even after the first ground is reached, in what sense is there anything to be joyful about yet? His answer inverts the usual way of measuring — not by the years still ahead, but by the proportion of suffering already behind. Set against beginningless birth and death, even a hundred thousand million future kalpas is the ocean already crossed, and only a few drops remain.
Fascicle 1 Complete
This closes Fascicle 1 — the treatise's own justification for undertaking the bodhisattva path, Nāgārjuna's reasons for composing this commentary, the ten grounds named in full, and the eight preparatory dharmas, the mind of certainty, and the birth into the Tathāgata's household that together open the first of them. Fascicle 2 continues within the Ground of Joy itself, turning to the marks and qualities that distinguish a bodhisattva who has genuinely attained this ground.
Continue to Fascicle 2 →