Fascicle 8 of 17 · 入寺品第十七、共行品第十八 · 十住毘婆沙論 T1521

Entering the Temple, and Practices Shared by Householder and Renunciant

Why the householder bodhisattva must never judge a monk who has broken the precepts — only the Buddha's own omniscience can measure another's inner state. An extraordinary line-by-line catalogue sets household life against renunciant life in every conceivable respect. And the thirty-two marks of a great being are named one by one, each paired with the specific karma that produces it.

Translator: Ru-Yi Meditation Center Source: Taishō T1521, 十住毘婆沙論, attributed to Nāgārjuna, tr. Kumārajīva 17 fascicles, 35 chapters

Not Clinging to What Is Requested

Chinese Source

入寺品第十七

如是在家菩薩,不應於諸事中生貪著心、我我所心,何以故?隨所貪著難捨之物、法應施與,若能施與,則除此過。菩薩如是無有貪著慳惜之心,可以處家。

問曰:在家菩薩,或有貪惜愛著之物,有來求者,此應云何?

答曰:於所貪著物,有來求索者,當自勸喻心,即施勿慳惜。

菩薩所貪惜物,若有乞人,急從求索:「汝以此物,施與我者,速得成佛菩薩。」即時,應自勸喻,而施與之。如是思惟:「若我今者,不捨此物,此物必當遠離於我。設至死時,不隨我去,此物則是遠離之相,今為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提,具足檀波羅蜜故施與,後至死時,心無有悔。」

經說:「不悔心死,必生善處,是得大利,云何不捨!」

如是自勸,猶貪惜者,應辭謝乞者言:「我今是新學,善根未成就,心未得自在,願後當相與。」

應辭謝乞者言:「勿生瞋恨,我新發意,善根未具,於菩薩行法,未得勢力,是以未能捨於此物,後得勢力,善根成就,心得堅固,當以相與。」

復次——若眾不和合,斷於經法事,菩薩應隨力,方便令不絕。

眾僧或以事緣,諍競乖散,法事有廢;在家菩薩應勤心方便,彼此之間,心無所偏;若以財物,若以言說,禮敬求請,令還和合。

或以乏少衣食因緣;或邪見者,橫作障礙;或說法者,欲求利養;或聽法者,心不恭敬。

在家菩薩,於此事中,隨宜方便——若以財物,若以言說;下意求請,使法事不廢。法事不廢者,是為然佛法燈,供養十方三世諸佛。

Ru-Yi Translation

Entering the Temple Chapter

The householder bodhisattva, in this way, ought never, within any matter whatsoever, give rise to a mind of craving attachment, or a mind of "I" and "mine." And why is this so? Whatever object or dharma is craved and clinged to and difficult to relinquish ought to be given away; should one be able to give it away, this very fault is thereby removed. The bodhisattva, being in this way free of a mind of craving attachment and stinginess, is thereby fit to dwell within the household.

Question: Should the householder bodhisattva possess some object of craving, attachment, and fondness, and should one come to request it of them, how ought this be handled?

Answer: "Toward an object one craves and clings to, should one come to request and seek it, one ought to encourage and persuade one's own mind at once, and give it away without any stinginess."

Should there be an object the bodhisattva craves and clings to, and should a beggar come urgently requesting it, saying: "Should you give this object to me, you shall swiftly accomplish buddhahood" — one ought, at that very moment, to encourage and persuade oneself, and give it to them. One reflects thus: "Should I, at this moment, fail to relinquish this object, this object shall inevitably depart from me regardless. Should I reach the moment of death, it shall not follow me there either — this object bears, in any case, the very mark of departing from me. Now, for the sake of unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening, completing the pāramitā of giving, I give it away — so that, when I later reach the moment of death, my own mind shall hold no regret."

The sūtra states: "A mind free of regret at the moment of death necessarily leads to rebirth in a good place — this itself is a great benefit, so why would one not relinquish it!"

Should one, having encouraged oneself in this way, still remain unable to overcome this craving and stinginess, one ought to decline the beggar's request, saying: "I am now still a new learner, my own roots of goodness not yet accomplished, my own mind not yet having attained mastery — I hope that, later on, I may be able to give it to you."

One ought to decline the beggar's request, saying: "Give rise to no anger or resentment toward me — I have only newly given rise to this aspiration, my own roots of goodness not yet complete, and, within the bodhisattva's own practice, I have not yet attained sufficient strength; it is for this reason that I am not yet able to relinquish this object. Once I have attained sufficient strength, my roots of goodness accomplished, my mind firm and resolute, I shall certainly give it to you."

Furthermore: "Should the assembly fall into discord, severing the very affairs of the scriptural teaching, the bodhisattva ought, according to their own capacity, to apply skillful means so that it is not utterly severed."

Should the assembly of monks, through some matter or circumstance, fall into contention and scatter apart, so that the affairs of the Dharma fall into neglect, the householder bodhisattva ought diligently to apply skillful means, holding no partiality between either side; whether through material wealth or through speech, showing reverence and making a respectful request, so as to restore this very harmony.

This may arise through the cause and condition of a lack of clothing or food; or through one holding wrong views, who wrongly creates an obstruction; or through one who expounds the Dharma, who seeks gain and support; or through one who listens to the Dharma, whose own mind lacks reverence.

The householder bodhisattva, amid a matter such as this, applies whatever skillful means are fitting — whether through material wealth or through speech; lowering their own mind and making a respectful request, so that the affairs of the Dharma are not neglected. That the affairs of the Dharma are not neglected is itself the very kindling of the lamp of the Buddhadharma, making offering to every buddha of the ten directions and the three times.

A note on declining honestly

The permission to decline a request when genuinely unable to give without regret — offered here as an honest alternative to forcing a gift one would later resent — sits alongside the treatise's own repeated insistence elsewhere that giving ought to be immediate and unhesitating. The distinction is candor: a gift given through gritted teeth, later regretted, undermines the very purity of giving described in earlier fascicles, while an honest "not yet" that names one's own current limitation preserves the relationship and leaves room for genuine giving later.

The Fasting Day and the Eight Precepts

Chinese Source

復次——齋日受八戒,親近淨戒者,以戒善因緣,深心行愛敬。

齋日者:月八日,十四日,十五日,二十三日,二十九日,三十日,及遮三忌。三忌者,十五日為一忌,從冬至後四十五日。

此諸惡日,多有鬼神,侵剋縱暴;世人為守護日故,過中不食。

佛因教令受一日戒,既得福德,諸天來下,觀察世間,見之歡喜,則便護念。在家菩薩於諸小事,猶尚增益,何況先有此齋,而不隨順?是故應行一日齋法,既得自利,亦能利人。

問曰:齋法云何?

答曰:應作是言——如諸聖人,常離殺生,棄捨刀杖,常無瞋恚,有慚愧心,慈悲眾生。我某甲今一日一夜,遠離殺生,棄捨刀杖,無有瞋恚,有慚愧心,慈悲眾生,以如是法,隨學聖人。

如諸聖人,常離「不與取」,身行清淨,受而知足。我今一日一夜,遠離劫盜、不與取,求受清淨自活,以如是法,隨學聖人。

如諸聖人,常斷婬泆,遠離世樂。我今一日一夜,除斷婬泆,遠離世樂,淨修梵行,以如是法,隨學聖人。

如諸聖人,常離妄語。真實語,正直語。我今一日一夜遠離妄語。真實語,正直語,以如是法,隨學聖人。

如諸聖人,常遠離酒,酒是放逸處,我今一日一夜,遠離於酒,以如是法,隨學聖人。

如諸聖人,常遠離歌舞作樂,花香瓔珞,嚴身之具。我今一日一夜,遠離歌舞作樂,華香瓔珞,嚴身之具,以如是法,隨學聖人。

如諸聖人,常遠離高廣大床處,在小榻草蓐為座。我今一日一夜,遠離高廣大床,處在小榻草蓐為座,以如是法,隨學聖人。

如諸聖人,常過中不食,遠離非時行非時食。我今一日一夜,過中不食,遠離非時行非時食,以如是法,隨學聖人。

如說:「殺盜淫妄語,飲酒及華香、瓔珞歌舞等,高床過中食;聖人所捨離,我今亦如是,以此福因緣,一切共成佛。」

親近持淨戒比丘者,在家菩薩應親近諸比丘,盡能護持清淨禁戒、成就功德防遠眾惡者。

以戒善因緣者,又應親近持戒比丘身口業淨、心行直善無眾惡者。

深心愛敬者,於上直心、善行、持戒比丘、成就諸功德者,應生最上恭敬、深心愛樂。

Ru-Yi Translation

Furthermore: "On a fasting day, one receives the eight precepts, drawing near to those who uphold pure precepts, and, through the very causes and conditions of the goodness of the precepts, practicing love and reverence with a deep mind."

The "fasting days" are: the eighth day of the month, the fourteenth, the fifteenth, the twenty-third, the twenty-ninth, the thirtieth, and the three restraint days. The three restraint days are: the fifteenth day counted as one such day, and again forty-five days after the winter solstice.

On these very inauspicious days, ghosts and spirits abound, encroaching and running rampant; ordinary people, in order to guard against this day, refrain from eating past midday.

The Buddha, on account of this, taught people to receive the precepts for a single day; having thereby obtained this merit, the devas descend to observe this world, and, beholding it, feel delight, and thereupon extend their own protective mindfulness. The householder bodhisattva, even toward the smallest of matters, still seeks to increase their own benefit all the more — how much more so, then, when this very fasting observance already exists, should they fail to accord with it? It is for this reason that one ought to practice this one-day fasting observance, thereby obtaining both one's own benefit and the ability to benefit others as well.

Question: What, then, is the method of this fasting observance?

Answer: One ought to speak thus: "Just as the noble ones constantly depart from the taking of life, relinquishing blade and club, forever free of anger, possessing a mind of conscience and shame, showing loving-kindness and compassion to sentient beings — I, so-and-so, for this one day and one night, depart from the taking of life, relinquishing blade and club, free of anger, possessing a mind of conscience and shame, showing loving-kindness and compassion to sentient beings, and, through this very dharma, follow and study the noble ones."

"Just as the noble ones constantly depart from 'taking what is not given,' their own bodily conduct pure, receiving only what is needed and knowing contentment — I, for this one day and one night, depart far from robbery and theft, from taking what is not given, seeking only a pure livelihood, and, through this very dharma, follow and study the noble ones."

"Just as the noble ones constantly sever sexual excess, departing far from worldly pleasure — I, for this one day and one night, sever and cut off sexual excess, departing far from worldly pleasure, purely cultivating the holy life, and, through this very dharma, follow and study the noble ones."

"Just as the noble ones constantly depart from false speech, speaking only what is true, speaking only what is upright — I, for this one day and one night, depart far from false speech, speaking only what is true, speaking only what is upright, and, through this very dharma, follow and study the noble ones."

"Just as the noble ones constantly depart far from wine, since wine is itself the very locus of heedlessness — I, for this one day and one night, depart far from wine, and, through this very dharma, follow and study the noble ones."

"Just as the noble ones constantly depart far from song, dance, and music, from flowers, fragrance, and garlands, from every ornament that adorns the body — I, for this one day and one night, depart far from song, dance, and music, from flowers, fragrance, and garlands, from every ornament that adorns the body, and, through this very dharma, follow and study the noble ones."

"Just as the noble ones constantly depart far from high, broad, and grand beds, sitting instead upon a small couch or a mat of grass — I, for this one day and one night, depart far from high, broad, and grand beds, sitting instead upon a small couch or a mat of grass, and, through this very dharma, follow and study the noble ones."

"Just as the noble ones constantly refrain from eating past midday, departing far from eating at an improper time — I, for this one day and one night, refrain from eating past midday, departing far from eating at an improper time, and, through this very dharma, follow and study the noble ones."

As the verse says: "Killing, theft, sexual misconduct, false speech, drinking wine, and flowers and fragrance, garlands and dance and the like, a high bed, and eating past midday — these the noble ones have relinquished, and I, too, do likewise now; through the causes and conditions of this very merit, may every being together accomplish buddhahood."

"Drawing near to monks who uphold pure precepts" means the householder bodhisattva ought to draw near to every monk fully able to guard and uphold the pure precepts, accomplishing merit and keeping far from every evil.

"Through the causes and conditions of the goodness of the precepts" means further drawing near to precept-upholding monks whose own conduct of body and speech is pure, whose mind and conduct are upright and good, free of every evil.

"Practicing love and reverence with a deep mind" means, toward monks of upright mind, wholesome conduct, and precept-upholding, who have accomplished every merit as described above, giving rise to the very highest reverence, and love and delight with a deep mind.

A note on the eight precepts

This fasting observance (poṣadha, 齋) is the lay tradition's own periodic taste of monastic life: for a single day and night, a householder voluntarily takes on precepts that exceed the ordinary five — full celibacy rather than mere avoidance of misconduct, no eating past noon, no music or adornment, no high beds — before returning the next morning to ordinary lay conduct. The closing dedication verse frames this brief discipline explicitly as a shared path toward buddhahood rather than a private austerity.

Compassion, Not Contempt, for a Monk Who Has Broken the Precepts

Chinese Source

問曰:在家菩薩若於持戒比丘成就功德生愛敬心者,應於破戒比丘生輕恚心耶?

答曰:若見破戒者,不應起輕恚。

在家菩薩,若見破戒雜行比丘,威儀不具,所行穢濁,覆藏瑕疵,無有梵行自稱梵行;於此比丘,不應輕慢、有瞋恚心。

問曰:若不瞋恨,應生何心?

答曰:應生憐愍心,訶責諸煩惱。

在家菩薩,若見破戒比丘,不應生瞋恨、輕慢,應生憐愍、利益之心。

作是念:「咄哉!此人遇佛妙法,得離地獄、畜生、餓鬼、色無色界、邊地生處。諸根具足,不聾啞,不頑鈍,值佛妙法;別識好醜,心存正見,解知義理。

「人身難得,如大海中,有一眼鼈,頭入板孔;生在人中,倍難於此。既聞佛法,能滅諸惡,度諸苦惱,得至正智。

「捨諸資生,所有多少,永割親族,無所顧戀。若生凡庶,或在種姓,信佛語故,能捨出家。

「常聞破戒之罪,所謂自賤其身,智所訶責,惡名流布,常懷疑悔,死墮惡道;得聞此事,而猶破戒。

「行十善道,乃得人身,而不能如法善用,以自利益。

「咄哉!三毒其力甚惡,常陵眾生,難得捨離。諸佛種種呵罵煩惱惡賊、惡行,如實有理。」

如是思惟,不應輕賤破戒之人。

又作是念:若我不能都離瞋恚、輕慢心者,應自思惟:「佛法無量,猶如大海,或有開通而我不知。」

Ru-Yi Translation

Question: Should the householder bodhisattva give rise to a mind of love and reverence toward a monk who upholds the precepts and has accomplished merit, ought they then give rise to a mind of contempt and anger toward a monk who has broken the precepts?

Answer: "Should one behold one who has broken the precepts, one ought never to give rise to contempt or anger."

Should the householder bodhisattva behold a monk of broken precepts and mixed conduct, their own bearing incomplete, their own conduct impure and turbid, concealing their own faults, lacking the holy life yet calling themselves one who lives it — toward this monk, one ought never to give rise to contempt or a mind of anger.

Question: Should one not give rise to anger and resentment, what mind ought one then give rise to?

Answer: "One ought to give rise to a mind of pity, reproaching only the afflictions themselves."

Should the householder bodhisattva behold a monk who has broken the precepts, they ought never to give rise to anger, resentment, or contempt, but ought to give rise to a mind of pity and benefit instead.

One reflects thus: "Alas! This person has encountered the Buddha's own sublime Dharma, able to depart from hell, the animal realm, the realm of hungry ghosts, the formless and form realms, and rebirth in a borderland. Their own faculties are complete, neither deaf nor mute, neither dull nor obtuse, having encountered the Buddha's own sublime Dharma; able to distinguish the fine from the foul, their own mind holding right view, understanding and knowing its true meaning.

"A human birth is difficult to obtain, just as, within the great ocean, a one-eyed turtle's head might chance to pass through the hole of a floating plank; being born among humans is more difficult still than even this. Having already heard the Buddhadharma, able to extinguish every evil, to cross beyond every suffering and affliction, and to reach right wisdom.

"Relinquishing every article of livelihood, whatever their quantity, forever severing themselves from their own kin, holding no attachment or longing for them. Whether born among the common people, or within a noble lineage, through faith in the Buddha's own words, able to relinquish it all and go forth from home.

"Having constantly heard of the offense of breaking the precepts — namely, debasing oneself, being reproached by the wise, one's own evil reputation spreading abroad, constantly harboring doubt and regret, and, at death, falling into an evil destiny — having heard this very matter, and yet still breaking the precepts nonetheless.

"Practicing the ten wholesome paths, one thereby attains a human birth, and yet is unable to make proper use of it in accordance with the Dharma, for their own benefit.

"Alas! The threefold poison's own power is exceedingly evil, constantly overpowering sentient beings, difficult indeed to relinquish and depart from. Every buddha reproaches, in every manner, this evil bandit of the afflictions, and this evil conduct — and this is genuinely, truly so."

Reflecting in this way, one ought never to hold this person, who has broken the precepts, in contempt.

One further reflects: should I be unable to depart entirely from a mind of anger and contempt, I ought to reflect for myself: "The Buddhadharma is immeasurable, just like the great ocean itself — there may be some opening or passage within it that I myself do not yet know."

A note on the blind turtle

The image of a one-eyed sea turtle chancing to surface with its head through the single hole of a drifting plank is one of the most widely repeated similes in the Buddhist canon for the rarity of human birth, appearing across multiple early sūtras in slightly different forms. Its function here is precise: the passage does not excuse breaking the precepts, but insists that the very rarity of the birth in which this failure occurred is itself grounds for pity rather than contempt — a person who received so improbable an opportunity and still fell short is tragic, not merely blameworthy.

Only the Buddha Can Measure Another's Mind

Chinese Source

如《大乘決定王經》中,佛告阿難:「或有比丘,根鈍闇塞,心不明了,不達諸法相,常念有想。無想法中,而取有想——生男女想、生罪礙想、生垢想、生淨想——生如是想者,名為鈍根,心不明了,則為有罪。

「阿難!若人一切法中,不能善解,名為不了一切諸法,從初以來,本體、性、相常不可得。是人不知如是之事,生是諸想,則與外道無有差別。

「阿難!我所說法,皆有開通,明了清淨,此中無罪,亦無罪者。阿難!罪,名疑悔、愚癡、闇冥;罪者,名生眾生想、我想、命想、人想;皆因身見,名為罪者。

「於我法中,無如此人。

「若我法中,定實有我、眾生、命、人、身見等者,不言:『我法有開』,非是不開;我法從本已來,常清淨明了。

「復次,阿難!若決定有罪、有受罪者,則身即是神,即墮常見,則無佛道;若身異於神,即墮斷見,亦無佛道。

「如是六十二見,皆可是菩提,但是事不然。

「是故,阿難!我於大眾中師子吼說而無所畏,言:我法有開,非不有開,從本已來,常清淨明了。

「阿難!若罪定有,則畢竟無涅槃,我則不言:我法有開。

「阿難!我法實從本已來,清淨明了,是故我弟子降心安隱,無有疑悔,無諸罪惡,清淨行道。」

菩薩應如是思惟,不應瞋恚破戒者。

又作是念:是戒必定得住阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。何以故?

曾聞必定菩薩有起罪者:如過去十萬劫,有菩薩誹謗漏盡阿羅漢名為阿羅漢;又聞必定菩薩於此劫前三十一劫,以矛刺須陀洹;又此賢劫中,聞有菩薩誹謗劬樓孫佛言:「何有禿人,而當得道?」

如是等眾生,難可得知,是故我於此事,何用知為?得失好惡,彼自作自受,何豫於我?我今若欲實知彼事,或自傷害,籌量眾生,佛所不許。如《經》中說:佛告阿難:「若人籌量於他,即自傷身,唯我可得籌量眾生,與我等者亦應籌量。」

如說:有瓶蓋亦空,無蓋亦復空,有瓶蓋亦滿,無蓋亦復滿。

當知諸世間,有此四種人。

威儀及功德,有無亦如是。

若非一切智,何能籌量人?

寧以見威儀,而便知其德?

正智有善心,名為賢人相,但見外威儀,何由知其內?

內有功德慧,外現無威儀,遊行無知者,如以灰覆火。

若以外量內,而生輕賤心,敗身及善根,命終墮惡道。

外詐現威儀,遊行似賢聖,但有口言說,如雷而無雨。

諸心所行處,錯謬難得知。

是故諸眾生,不可妄度量;唯有一切智,悉知諸心心。

微密所行處,是故量眾生;佛言與我等,乃能量眾生。

若佛如是說,誰能籌量人?

若見外威儀,稱量其內德。

自敗其善根,如水自崩岸,若於此錯謬,則起大業障。

是故於此人,不應起輕賤。

是故在家菩薩,不應於破戒人起輕慢瞋恚。

又持戒、破戒,白衣之人,不與同住,何由得知?我若欲於此事分別明了者,則起罪障,罪障因緣故,於千萬劫受諸苦分,如《無行經》中說。

又大乘《經》中,佛告郁伽羅長者:「如是在家菩薩應於破戒比丘,生憐愍心:是人垢行,惡行不善。何以故?是人披如來善寂滅聖主法衣,自不善軟,不能調伏諸根,行敗壞行。」

又佛《經》中說:「不輕未學,此非人罪,是煩惱罪,此人以是煩惱,起不善事。」

又佛法有開,是人或能自除過罪。正念因緣,得入法位,若入必定,在於阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。又如佛言:「唯有智慧可破煩惱。」

又復說言:「不應妄稱量人,若稱量者,則為自傷。」唯佛智慧,乃能明了,如此事者,非我所知。

即於破戒人中,不生瞋恚、輕慢之心。

Ru-Yi Translation

As, within the Sūtra of the Resolute King's Great Vehicle, the Buddha told Ānanda: "There may be a monk of dull faculties, obscured and blocked, whose own mind is not clear, unable to penetrate the very mark of any dharma, constantly holding a conception of existence. Within a dharma that is without any conception, they seize instead upon a conception of existence — giving rise to a conception of male and female, a conception of offense and obstruction, a conception of defilement, a conception of purity — one who gives rise to conceptions such as these is called one of dull faculties, whose own mind is unclear, and this itself constitutes an offense.

"Ānanda! Should a person, within every dharma, be unable to skillfully understand it, this is called failing to comprehend every dharma — that, from the very outset, their own essence, nature, and mark can never truly be apprehended at all. Such a person, not knowing this very matter, gives rise to conceptions such as these, and is thereby no different at all from an outside path.

"Ānanda! The Dharma I myself expound is, in every case, open and unobstructed, clear and pure — within it there is no offense, and no one who commits an offense either. Ānanda! 'Offense' refers to doubt and regret, delusion, and obscurity; 'one who commits an offense' refers to one who gives rise to a conception of a sentient being, a conception of self, a conception of a life-force, a conception of a person — all arising through the very view of a self, and it is this that is called 'one who commits an offense.'

"Within my own Dharma, there is no such person at all.

"Should there truly and definitely exist, within my own Dharma, a self, a sentient being, a life-force, a person, a view of self, and the like, I would not say: 'My own Dharma is open' — it is not that it fails to be open; my own Dharma, from the very outset, has forever been pure and clear.

"Furthermore, Ānanda! Should there definitely exist an offense, and one who undergoes this offense, then the body itself would be identical with the soul, thereby falling into the view of eternalism, and there would then be no path to buddhahood at all; should the body be different from the soul, one would then fall into the view of annihilationism, and there would likewise be no path to buddhahood at all.

"The sixty-two views of this kind might all be thought capable of leading to bodhi, yet this matter is simply not so.

"It is for this reason, Ānanda, that I, within the great assembly, roar the lion's roar, speaking without any fear whatsoever, saying: my own Dharma is open, and is not without this very opening — from the very outset, it has forever been pure and clear.

"Ānanda! Should offense truly and definitely exist, there would, in the end, be no nirvāṇa at all, and I would then never say: my own Dharma is open.

"Ānanda! My own Dharma, truly, from the very outset, has been pure and clear — it is for this reason that my own disciples subdue their own mind and attain peace and security, free of doubt and regret, free of every offense and evil, practicing the path in purity."

The bodhisattva ought to reflect in this very way, never giving rise to anger toward one who has broken the precepts.

One further reflects: this very precept shall certainly lead, in the end, to abiding within unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. And why is this so?

It has been heard that even a bodhisattva certain of buddhahood has, at times, given rise to an offense: as, in a hundred thousand kalpas past, there was a bodhisattva who slandered an arhat free of every outflow, denying that they were truly an arhat at all; and it has further been heard that a bodhisattva certain of buddhahood, thirty-one kalpas before this present kalpa, once pierced a stream-enterer with a spear; and, within this present fortunate kalpa, it has been heard that there was a bodhisattva who slandered the Buddha Krakucchanda, saying: "How could such a bald-headed person possibly attain the path?"

Sentient beings such as this are difficult indeed to truly know — it is for this reason that, in this very matter, of what use would it be for me to seek such knowledge? Gain and loss, the fine and the foul, are what each being brings about for themselves and undergoes for themselves — what business is this of mine? Should I now wish to truly know such a matter, I might well harm myself in the process; the very weighing and measuring of other sentient beings is something the Buddha himself has not permitted. As the sūtra states: the Buddha told Ānanda: "Should a person weigh and measure another, they thereby harm themselves — only I myself am able to weigh and measure sentient beings, and those equal to me are likewise able to weigh and measure them."

As the verse says: "A vessel with a lid may still be empty; one without a lid may likewise be empty. A vessel with a lid may still be full; one without a lid may likewise be full.

"One should know that, within this world, there exist these very four kinds of person.

"Outward bearing and inward merit — their presence and absence are likewise so.

"Should one lack omniscience itself, how could one possibly weigh and measure another person?

"How could one, merely by beholding an outward bearing, thereby come to know their own inward merit?

"Right wisdom, possessed of a wholesome mind, is what is truly called the mark of a worthy person; yet, beholding only an outward bearing, how could one possibly know what lies within?

"One possessed within of merit and wisdom, yet outwardly showing no such bearing, wandering about unrecognized, is like fire covered over with ash.

"Should one measure what lies within by what appears outwardly, and thereby give rise to a mind of contempt, one destroys one's own body and one's own roots of goodness, and, at the end of life, falls into an evil destiny.

"One who outwardly feigns and displays a fine bearing, wandering about appearing as a worthy or a noble one, possesses only words spoken from the mouth, like thunder without any rain.

"The very place where every mind carries out its own activity is confused and mistaken, difficult indeed to truly know.

"It is for this reason that sentient beings cannot be wrongly measured and weighed; only omniscience itself is able fully to know every mind and every mental state.

"The subtle and hidden place where this activity occurs — it is for this reason that, in measuring sentient beings, the Buddha alone declares that those equal to himself alone are able to measure sentient beings.

"If the Buddha has spoken thus, who else could possibly weigh and measure another person?

"Should one behold only an outward bearing, and thereby weigh and measure their own inward merit —

"One destroys one's own roots of goodness by this very act, just as water erodes its own bank; should one fall into this very error, one thereby gives rise to a great karmic obstruction.

"It is for this reason that, toward this person, one ought never to give rise to contempt."

It is for this reason that the householder bodhisattva ought never to give rise to contempt and anger toward one who has broken the precepts.

And further, whether one upholds the precepts or has broken them, a person in white robes, not dwelling together with them, how could they possibly come to know this at all? Should I wish, in this very matter, to distinguish it with certainty, I would thereby give rise to a karmic obstruction of offense; and through the very causes and conditions of this obstruction of offense, I would undergo suffering across a thousand myriad kalpas, just as is stated within the Sūtra of No Activity.

And further, within a Great Vehicle sūtra, the Buddha told the Elder Ugra: "The householder bodhisattva, in this way, ought, toward a monk who has broken the precepts, give rise to a mind of pity: this person's own conduct is defiled, their own conduct evil and unwholesome. And why is this so? This person wears the very robe of the Thus Come One, the good, tranquil, and cessation-attaining sovereign teacher's own robe, and yet, themselves neither good nor gentle, is unable to tame their own faculties, carrying out conduct that is corrupt and destructive."

And further, the Buddha states within the sūtra: "Never hold in contempt one who has not yet studied — this is not that person's own offense, but the offense of the afflictions themselves; this person, through these very afflictions, gives rise to an unwholesome deed."

And further, the Buddhadharma possesses this very opening, and this person may yet be able to remove their own transgression and offense by themselves. Through the causes and conditions of right mindfulness, they may attain entry into the very station of the Dharma, and, having entered this certainty, abide within unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. And as the Buddha has said: "Only wisdom itself is able to break through the afflictions."

And it is further said: "One ought never wrongly to weigh and measure another person; should one weigh and measure them, one thereby harms oneself." Only the Buddha's own wisdom is able truly to comprehend a matter such as this — it is not something I myself am able to know.

Thus, toward one who has broken the precepts, one gives rise to no mind of anger or contempt whatsoever.

A note on the vessel with and without a lid

The four-part image — a lidded vessel that may be empty or full, an unlidded vessel that may likewise be empty or full — collapses the intuitive assumption that outward appearance reliably signals inward content, in either direction. A closed, formal bearing might conceal genuine attainment or nothing at all; an open, unimpressive bearing might likewise conceal either. This chapter's own repeated citation of the sixty-two views, the Sūtra of No Activity, and named historical lapses by bodhisattvas otherwise certain of buddhahood builds toward a single practical conclusion stated plainly at the end: judgment of another's inner state is categorically beyond a householder's competence, whatever their own certainty might feel like from the inside.

Entering the Temple, and the Wish for Ordination

Chinese Source

復次——菩薩若入寺,應行諸威儀,恭敬而禮拜,供養諸比丘。

是在家菩薩,若入佛寺,初欲入時,於寺門外五體投地,應作是念:「此是善人住處,是空行者住處、無相行者住處、無願行者住處,此是行慈悲喜捨者住處,此是正行、正念者住處。」

若見諸比丘,威儀具足——視瞻安詳、攝持衣鉢、坐臥行止、寤寐飲食、言說寂默,容儀進止,皆可觀察。

若見比丘,修行四念,聖所行處,持戒清淨,誦讀經法,精思坐禪,見已恭肅。敬心禮拜,親近問訊。應作是念:「若我恒沙劫,常於天祠中,大施不休廢,不如一出家。」

是菩薩爾時應作是念:「我如法求財,於恒河沙等劫,常行大施,是諸施福,猶尚不如發心出家,何況有實?」何以故?

在家則有無量過惡,出家能成無量功德——在家則潰閙,出家則閑靜。在家則屬垢,出家則無屬。

Ru-Yi Translation

Furthermore: "The bodhisattva, upon entering a temple, ought to conduct themselves with every mark of proper bearing, showing reverence and prostrating, making offerings to the assembled monks."

Should the householder bodhisattva, upon entering a Buddhist temple, first wish to enter, they prostrate their entire body upon the ground outside the temple gate, and ought to reflect thus: "This is the dwelling-place of good persons, the dwelling-place of those who practice emptiness, the dwelling-place of those who practice signlessness, the dwelling-place of those who practice wishlessness; this is the dwelling-place of those who practice loving-kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy, and equanimity; this is the dwelling-place of those of right conduct and right mindfulness."

Should they behold the assembled monks, complete in every mark of proper bearing — their gaze calm and composed, holding fast their own robe and bowl, whether sitting, lying down, walking, or standing still, whether waking, sleeping, eating, or drinking, whether speaking or maintaining silence, their every outward bearing and movement all worthy of careful observation.

Should they behold a monk who cultivates and practices the four foundations of mindfulness, the very domain of the noble ones, upholding the precepts in purity, reciting and studying the scriptural teaching, diligently contemplating and sitting in meditation, having beheld them, one shows deep reverence. With a reverent mind, one prostrates, drawing near and offering greeting. One ought to reflect thus: "Should I, across kalpas as numerous as the sands of the Ganges, constantly give great gifts without ever ceasing at the shrines of the devas, this would still not equal even a single act of going forth from home."

The bodhisattva, at that very moment, ought to reflect thus: "Though I might, in accordance with the Dharma, seek wealth, and, across kalpas as numerous as the sands of the Ganges, constantly practice great giving, this very merit of giving would still not equal even giving rise to the aspiration to go forth from home — how much less, then, could it equal the reality of going forth itself?" And why is this so?

Household life possesses immeasurable faults and evils, while going forth from home is able to accomplish immeasurable merit — household life is clamorous and turbulent, while going forth from home is quiet and tranquil. Household life belongs to defilement, while going forth from home belongs to nothing at all.

A note on this opening comparison

The very first pairing here — household life as clamorous and belonging to defilement, going forth as tranquil and belonging to nothing — opens what becomes, in the next section, one of the longest sustained parallel structures in the entire treatise. The scale of the claim in the preceding paragraph is worth pausing on: giving alone, however vast and sustained across inconceivable spans of time, is explicitly ranked below the mere aspiration to renounce, let alone renunciation itself — a striking statement given how much of this treatise, up through the previous fascicle, has been devoted to praising the bodhisattva's own practice of giving.

Household and Renunciant Life, Compared Line by Line

Chinese Source

在家是惡行處,出家是善行處。在家則染諸塵垢,出家則離諸塵垢。

在家則沒五欲泥,出家則出五欲泥。在家難得淨命,出家易得淨命。

在家則多怨賊,出家則無怨賊。在家則多惱礙,出家則無惱礙。

在家是憂處,出家是喜處。在家是惡道門,出家是利益門。

在家是繫縛,出家是解脫。在家則雜畏,出家則無畏。

在家有鞭杖,出家無鞭杖。在家有刀矟,出家無刀矟。

在家有悔熱,出家無悔熱。在家多求故苦,出家無求故樂。

在家則戲調,出家則寂滅。在家是可愍,出家無可愍。

在家則愁悴,出家無愁悴。在家則卑下,出家則高顯。

在家則熾然,出家則寂滅。在家則為他,出家則自為。

在家少勢力,出家多勢力。在家隨順垢門,出家隨順淨門。

在家增刺棘,出家破刺棘。在家成就小法,出家成就大法。

在家作不善,出家則修善。在家則有悔,出家則無悔。

在家增淚乳血海,出家竭淚乳血海。

在家則為諸佛、辟支佛、聲聞所呵賤;出家則為諸佛、辟支佛、聲聞所稱歎。

在家則不知足,出家則知足。在家則魔喜,出家則魔憂。

在家後有衰,出家後無衰。在家則易破,出家則難破。

在家是奴僕,出家則為主。在家永在生死,出家究竟涅槃。

在家則墮坑,出家則出坑。在家則黑闇,出家則明顯。

在家不能降伏諸根,出家則能降伏諸根。

在家則傲誕,出家則謙遜。在家則鄙陋,出家則尊貴。

在家有所由,出家無所由。在家則多務,出家則少務。

在家則果小,出家則果大。在家則諂曲,出家則質直。

在家則多憂,出家則多喜。在家如箭在身,出家如身離箭。

在家則有病,出家則病愈。在家行惡法故速老,出家行善法故少壯。

在家放逸為死,出家有智慧命。在家則欺誑,出家則真實。

在家則多求,出家則少求。在家則飲雜毒漿,出家則飲甘露漿。

在家多侵害,出家無侵害。在家則衰耗,出家無衰耗。

在家如毒樹果,出家如甘露果。在家則怨憎和合,出家則離怨憎會苦。

在家則愛別離苦,出家則親愛和合。在家則癡重,出家則癡輕。

在家則失淨行,出家則得淨行。在家則破深心,出家則成深心。

在家則無救,出家則有救。在家則孤窮,出家不孤窮。

在家則無舍,出家則有舍。在家則無歸,出家則有歸。

在家則多瞋,出家則多慈。在家則重擔,出家則捨擔。

在家則事務無盡,出家則無有事務。在家則罪會,出家則福會。

在家則苦惱,出家則無苦惱。在家則有熱,出家則無熱。

在家則有諍,出家則無諍。在家則染著,出家無染著。

在家有我慢,出家無我慢。在家貴財物,出家貴功德。

在家有災害,出家滅災害。在家則減失,出家則增益。

在家則易得,出家則難遇,千萬劫中,時乃一得。

在家則易行,出家則難行。在家則順流,出家則逆流。

在家則漂流,出家則乘栰。

在家則為煩惱所㵱,出家則有橋樑自度。

在家是此岸,出家是彼岸。在家則纏縛,出家離纏縛。

在家懷結恨,出家離結恨。在家隨官法,出家隨佛法。

在家有事故,出家無事故。在家有苦果,出家有樂果。

在家則輕躁,出家則威重。在家伴易得,出家伴難得。

在家以婦為伴,出家堅心為伴。在家則入圍,出家則解圍。

在家則以侵惱他為貴,出家則以利益他為貴。

在家則貴財施,出家則貴法施。

在家則持魔幢,出家則持佛幢。在家有歸處,出家壞諸歸處。

在家增長身,出家則離身。在家入深榛,出家出深榛。

Ru-Yi Translation

Household life is the domain of evil conduct; going forth from home is the domain of wholesome conduct. Household life is defiled with every worldly dust; going forth from home departs from every worldly dust.

Household life sinks into the mire of the five desires; going forth from home emerges from the mire of the five desires. Household life makes a pure livelihood difficult to attain; going forth from home makes it easy to attain.

Household life abounds with hostile enemies; going forth from home has no hostile enemies. Household life abounds with affliction and obstruction; going forth from home has none.

Household life is a place of sorrow; going forth from home is a place of joy. Household life is the gateway to an evil destiny; going forth from home is the gateway to benefit.

Household life is bondage; going forth from home is liberation. Household life is beset with fear; going forth from home is free of fear.

Household life has the whip and the rod; going forth from home has neither. Household life has the blade and the spear; going forth from home has neither.

Household life has the heat of regret; going forth from home has none. Household life, through much seeking, brings suffering; going forth from home, through seeking little, brings joy.

Household life is frivolous amusement; going forth from home is tranquil cessation. Household life is pitiable; going forth from home has nothing pitiable in it.

Household life is sorrow and weariness; going forth from home has none. Household life is lowly; going forth from home is lofty and manifest.

Household life is a raging blaze; going forth from home is tranquil cessation. Household life is lived for the sake of another; going forth from home is lived for oneself.

Household life has little strength; going forth from home has great strength. Household life follows the gateway of defilement; going forth from home follows the gateway of purity.

Household life increases thorns and brambles; going forth from home breaks through these thorns and brambles. Household life accomplishes only a lesser dharma; going forth from home accomplishes a great dharma.

Household life produces unwholesome deeds; going forth from home cultivates wholesome ones. Household life brings regret; going forth from home is free of regret.

Household life adds to the very sea of tears, milk, and blood; going forth from home exhausts this very sea.

Household life is held in contempt by every buddha, pratyekabuddha, and śrāvaka; going forth from home is praised by every buddha, pratyekabuddha, and śrāvaka.

Household life knows no contentment; going forth from home knows contentment. Household life delights māra; going forth from home troubles māra.

Household life brings decline afterward; going forth from home brings no decline afterward. Household life is easily broken; going forth from home is difficult to break.

Household life is servitude; going forth from home is mastery. Household life remains forever within birth and death; going forth from home reaches nirvāṇa ultimately.

Household life falls into a pit; going forth from home emerges from the pit. Household life is dark obscurity; going forth from home is bright manifestation.

Household life is unable to tame its own faculties; going forth from home is able to tame them.

Household life is arrogant and boastful; going forth from home is humble and yielding. Household life is base and vulgar; going forth from home is noble and worthy of honor.

Household life has its own causes to answer to; going forth from home has none. Household life has many affairs; going forth from home has few.

Household life's own fruit is small; going forth from home's own fruit is great. Household life is flattering and crooked; going forth from home is honest and upright.

Household life abounds in sorrow; going forth from home abounds in joy. Household life is like an arrow lodged in the body; going forth from home is like the body freed of the arrow.

Household life brings sickness; going forth from home brings recovery from sickness. Household life, practicing unwholesome dharmas, ages quickly; going forth from home, practicing wholesome dharmas, remains youthful and vigorous.

Household life, through heedlessness, is death; going forth from home has the very life of wisdom. Household life is deceptive; going forth from home is truthful.

Household life seeks much; going forth from home seeks little. Household life drinks a mingled, poisoned draught; going forth from home drinks the nectar of immortality.

Household life abounds in encroachment and harm; going forth from home has none. Household life brings decline and loss; going forth from home has none.

Household life is like the fruit of a poisonous tree; going forth from home is like the fruit of nectar. Household life is a convergence of resentment and hatred; going forth from home departs from the suffering of encountering what one resents.

Household life brings the suffering of separation from what one loves; going forth from home brings the convergence of true affection. Household life's own delusion is heavy; going forth from home's own delusion is light.

Household life loses a pure conduct; going forth from home attains a pure conduct. Household life breaks a deep and resolute mind; going forth from home accomplishes it.

Household life has no rescue; going forth from home has rescue. Household life is solitary and destitute; going forth from home is not solitary or destitute.

Household life has no shelter; going forth from home has shelter. Household life has no refuge; going forth from home has refuge.

Household life abounds in anger; going forth from home abounds in loving-kindness. Household life is a heavy burden; going forth from home relinquishes this burden.

Household life's own affairs are endless; going forth from home has no such affairs. Household life is a convergence of offense; going forth from home is a convergence of merit.

Household life is affliction and suffering; going forth from home is free of it. Household life has heat; going forth from home has none.

Household life has contention; going forth from home has none. Household life is defiled attachment; going forth from home has no such attachment.

Household life has pride of self; going forth from home has none. Household life values material wealth; going forth from home values merit.

Household life has calamity; going forth from home extinguishes calamity. Household life brings diminishment and loss; going forth from home brings increase and benefit.

Household life is easily obtained; going forth from home is difficult to encounter, attained but once even across a thousand myriad kalpas.

Household life is easy to practice; going forth from home is difficult to practice. Household life follows the current downstream; going forth from home goes against the current.

Household life is adrift upon the water; going forth from home rides upon a raft.

Household life is submerged by the afflictions; going forth from home has a bridge by which to cross over on its own.

Household life is this shore; going forth from home is the far shore. Household life is entanglement and bondage; going forth from home departs from this entanglement and bondage.

Household life harbors resentment and hatred; going forth from home departs from this resentment and hatred. Household life follows the laws of the state; going forth from home follows the Buddhadharma.

Household life has its own entanglements; going forth from home has none. Household life bears a bitter fruit; going forth from home bears a joyful fruit.

Household life is restless and frivolous; going forth from home is dignified and weighty. Household life's own companions are easily found; going forth from home's own companions are difficult to find.

Household life takes a spouse as its own companion; going forth from home takes a firm and resolute mind as its own companion. Household life is surrounded and besieged; going forth from home breaks free of this siege.

Household life values encroaching upon and troubling another; going forth from home values benefiting another.

Household life values the giving of material wealth; going forth from home values the giving of the Dharma.

Household life holds aloft māra's own banner; going forth from home holds aloft the Buddha's own banner. Household life has a place of refuge; going forth from home destroys every such refuge entirely.

Household life increases attachment to the body; going forth from home departs from the body. Household life enters a deep thicket; going forth from home emerges from this deep thicket.

A note on this catalogue's own scale

This unbroken sequence of roughly sixty paired contrasts is the longest sustained parallel structure anywhere in the treatise so far, exceeding even Fascicle 7's fifteen-item comparison of giving against keeping. Reading it in bulk risks flattening what is, on closer attention, a carefully varied set of registers: some pairs are frankly practical (whip and rod, blade and spear), some psychological (regret, contentment, pride), some cosmic in scale (this shore and the far shore, māra's banner and the Buddha's banner), and a few startlingly intimate (a spouse as companion versus a resolute mind as companion). The cumulative effect is less a single argument than an exhaustive inventory meant to leave no possible angle of comparison unexamined.

Longing for Ordination

Chinese Source

復次——又於出家者,心應深貪慕。

是在家菩薩,如是思惟出家功德,於出家者,心應貪慕:「我何時當得出家,得有如是功德!

「我何時當得出家,次第具行沙門法,則說戒、布薩、安居、自恣、次第而坐!

「我何時當得聖人所著戒、定、慧、解脫、解脫知見熏修法衣!

「何時當得持聖人相!

「何時當得閑林靜住!

「何時當得持鉢乞食,得與不得,若多若少,若美若惡,若冷若熱,次第而受。趣以支身,如塗瘡、膏車!

「何時當得於世八法,心無憂喜!

「何時當得關閉六情,如縶狗、鹿、魚、蛇、猴、鳥!

「狗樂聚落,鹿樂山澤,魚樂池沼,蛇好穴處,猴樂深林,鳥依虛空。

「眼、耳、鼻、舌、身、意,常樂色、聲、香、味、觸、法,非是凡夫淺智弱志所能降伏,唯有智慧堅心、正念,乃能摧伏六情寇賊,不令為患,自在無畏。

「何時當得樂欲坐禪,誦讀經法,樂斷煩惱,樂修善法,樂著弊衣,趣足障體,念昔在俗多行放逸,今得自利又利他故,當勤精進!

「何時當得隨順菩薩所行道法!

「何時當得亦為世間作無上福田!

「何時當得離恩愛奴!

「何時當得脫是家獄!」

如說:禮敬諸塔寺,因佛生三心。

是在家菩薩既已慕尚出家,若入塔寺,敬禮佛時,應生三心,何等為三?

我當何時得於天龍、夜叉、乾闥婆、阿修羅、迦樓羅、摩睺羅伽、人、非人中受諸供養!何時當得神力,舍利流布世間,利益眾生!我今深心行大精進,當得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提,我作佛已,入無餘涅槃!

Ru-Yi Translation

Furthermore: "And, toward one who has gone forth from home, one's own mind ought to hold a deep longing and admiration."

The householder bodhisattva, having reflected in this way upon the merit of going forth from home, ought to hold, toward one who has gone forth, a mind of longing and admiration: "When shall I be able to go forth from home, and possess merit such as this!

"When shall I be able to go forth from home, fully practicing, in due order, the dharma of the ascetic — reciting the precepts, holding the poṣadha observance, the rains retreat, the pravāraṇā ceremony, and taking my own seat in due order!

"When shall I be able to wear the very robe steeped in the precepts, meditative concentration, wisdom, liberation, and the knowledge and vision of liberation, worn by the noble ones!

"When shall I be able to bear the very mark of the noble ones!

"When shall I be able to dwell quietly within a tranquil forest!

"When shall I be able to hold the almsbowl and go begging for food, whether receiving it or not, whether much or little, whether fine or foul, whether cold or hot, receiving it in due order. Taking only enough to sustain the body, as one applies salve to a wound, or grease to a cart!

"When shall I be able, toward these eight worldly dharmas, to hold a mind free of both sorrow and joy!

"When shall I be able to close off the six faculties, as one restrains a dog, a deer, a fish, a snake, a monkey, and a bird!

"A dog delights in a settlement, a deer delights in the mountains and marshes, a fish delights in a pool or pond, a snake favors a burrow, a monkey delights in a deep forest, a bird relies upon the open sky.

"The eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mind constantly delight in form, sound, fragrance, taste, touch, and mental objects — this is not something the ordinary being's own shallow wisdom and weak resolve is able to subdue; only wisdom, a firm mind, and right mindfulness are able to overcome these six faculties' own bandit-thieves, so that they cause no further affliction, and one attains mastery and fearlessness.

"When shall I be able to delight in sitting in meditation, in reciting and studying the scriptural teaching, to delight in severing the afflictions, to delight in cultivating wholesome dharmas, to delight in wearing a coarse robe, taking only enough to cover the body, recalling my own past heedlessness while still a layperson, and now, having obtained both my own benefit and the ability to benefit others, applying diligent effort accordingly!

"When shall I be able to accord with the very path and dharma the bodhisattva practices!

"When shall I be able likewise to become, for this world, an unsurpassed field of merit!

"When shall I be able to depart from this very bondage of affection!

"When shall I be able to escape this very prison of household life!"

As the verse says: "Showing reverence to every stūpa and temple, on account of the Buddha, gives rise to three minds."

This householder bodhisattva, having already come to long for and admire going forth from home, upon entering a stūpa or temple, at the moment of showing reverence to the Buddha, ought to give rise to these three minds — what are these three?

"When shall I be able to receive offerings from devas, nāgas, yakṣas, gandharvas, asuras, garuḍas, mahoragas, humans, and non-humans alike! When shall I be able to attain spiritual power, my own relics spreading throughout this world, benefiting sentient beings! I now, with a deep mind, apply great diligence, that I might attain unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening; and, having accomplished buddhahood, enter nirvāṇa without residue!"

A note on the salve and the grease

The simile of taking food only "as one applies salve to a wound, or grease to a cart" captures a specific attitude toward eating that recurs across monastic literature: food as bare functional maintenance of a vehicle, applied only enough to keep it moving, rather than as a source of pleasure to be pursued for its own sake. The six-faculties-as-six-animals image works the same way — a dog, deer, fish, snake, monkey, and bird each pulling toward its own favored terrain is a vivid picture of a mind scattered across six simultaneous cravings, each faculty tugging in its own direction, and the discipline required to bring all six to rest in one place at once.

Serving the Monks, and Guarding the Dharma

Chinese Source

復次——詣諸比丘時,隨所行奉事,默然順所誨,濟乏無所惜。

是在家菩薩敬禮塔已,求造諸比丘——說法者、所持律者、讀修多羅者、讀摩多羅迦者、讀菩薩藏者、作阿練若者、著納衣者、乞食者、一食者、常坐者、過中不飲漿者、但三衣者、著褐衣者、隨敷坐者、在樹下者、在塚間者、在空地者、少欲者、知足者、遠離者、坐禪者、勸化者,應各隨諸比丘所行奉事。

若至讀阿毘曇者所,隨其所說諸法性相,相應、不相應等,請問所疑,問已習學。

若遇持律者,應當請問起罪因緣、罪之輕重、滅罪之法,及阿波陀那事,問已修學行。

若遇讀修多羅者,應當請問諸阿含、諸部中義,習學多聞。

若遇讀摩多羅迦,應《利眾經》、《憂陀那》、《波羅延》、《法句》者,應當學習如是等經。

若遇讀菩薩藏者,應當請問六波羅蜜及方便事,問已修學。

若遇阿練若,應學其遠離法。

若遇坐禪者,應學其坐禪法。

餘諸比丘,亦應如是隨其所行,請問修學,無所違逆。

攝護口者,詣諸比丘,應善攝口,安詳默然,觀時觀土,隨事思惟,心不錯亂,少於語言。

又於說法者所,諸比丘等,隨所乏少——若衣、若鉢、若尼師壇資生之物,隨力而施,無所匱惜。

所以者何?菩薩尚應施諸惡人,何況比丘有功德者。乃至身肉,猶當不惜,況復外物助道因緣。

復次——若行布施時,莫生他煩惱。

行布施時,若與一人,一人不得,便生恚惱,應善籌量而行布施,勿使他人生於恚惱。何以故?

將護凡夫心,應勝阿羅漢。

是在家菩薩,施諸比丘衣服、飲食、醫藥、臥具,供養迎送,敬禮親近。

將護凡夫心,應勝將護阿羅漢。何以故?諸阿羅漢於利、衰、毀、譽、稱、譏、苦、樂,心無有異;凡夫有愛恚慳嫉故,能起罪業,以是罪業,墮在地獄、畜生、餓鬼。是故應深將護凡夫。

菩薩事者,皆為利益一切眾生布施,非為自樂,不為自得後世果報,非如市易。

復次——因以財施故,可以法施攝,隨所欲利益,教發無上心。

是在家菩薩,為自利故隨所利益比丘——若以衣施,若以鉢施,如是等種種餘財物施。如是比丘,未入法位,未得道果,應勸令發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提願。何以故?因財施攝故,得以法施攝。

或於所施檀越,有愛敬心,信受其語。

復次——為欲護持法,捨命而不惜,療治病比丘,乃至以身施。

是在家菩薩,為欲護持法故,乃至自捨身命,勤行精進,摧破六十二種外道,及諸魔民、憎嫉佛法者;佛弟子中或有邪行、詭異佛法,如是之人,如法摧破,名為護持法。

又應於諸多聞說法者,加信敬心,四事供養,亦名護持法。

若自讀誦、解說、書寫修多羅、毘尼、阿毘曇、摩多羅迦、菩薩藏者,亦教他人,讀誦解說書寫,以是因緣,法得久住,利益一切。在家出家,稱揚歎說,法久住利。若法疾滅說有過惡。

又念如來久遠已來行菩薩道、行諸難行,乃得是法;以是因緣,於諸在家、出家,勤心精進示教利喜,若令得道、若令入阿惟越致,略說護法因緣,令得一切安樂之具,亦復自能如說修行,皆名護持法。

復次,是在家菩薩法,若有病比丘應須療治,是菩薩乃至捨身為治其病而不愛惜,是最為要。出家之人應於在家求此要事,所謂身自瞻視疾病、供給醫藥。

復次——決定心布施,施已而無悔。

是菩薩若為護持正法,若為瞻視病人,應時供施,心無有悔,是名清淨施;若不求果報,不分別是應受、是不應受,但以憐愍利益心與,是名清淨施。

如說:若人悲心施,是名清淨施,不言是福田,不言非福田。

若人行布施,無所為故與,若人為果報,是名為出息。

是故說施已,心無有悔恨,乃至微小福,皆向無上道。

以是布施因緣所得福德,皆應迴向阿耨多羅三藐三菩提,不求今世後世利樂及小乘果;但為眾生求阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。

如我先說在家菩薩餘行,當說者今已說竟,皆於大乘經中處處抄集,隨順經法。菩薩住是行中,疾得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。

第二地中多說出家菩薩所行,在家、出家菩薩共行,今當復說。

Ru-Yi Translation

Furthermore: "When one goes to attend the monks, according with whatever service is needed, remaining silent and according with whatever they teach, relieving their want without any stinginess."

This householder bodhisattva, having already shown reverence at the stūpa, seeks out and approaches the assembled monks — those who expound the Dharma, those who uphold the Vinaya, those who recite the sūtras, those who recite the mātṛkā, those who recite the bodhisattva basket, those who dwell in forest hermitages, those who wear rag robes, those who beg for food, those who eat but a single meal, those who constantly remain seated, those who drink no beverage past midday, those who wear only three robes, those who wear only coarse cloth, those who sit wherever a seat is spread, those who dwell beneath trees, those who dwell among graves, those who dwell in open ground, those of few desires, those of contentment, those who dwell apart, those who sit in meditation, and those who encourage and transform others — one ought, according to each monk's own practice, to render service to them.

Should one come before one who recites the Abhidharma, one ought, according to whatever they expound concerning the nature and mark of every dharma, whether corresponding or not corresponding to one another, to inquire respectfully of whatever doubt one holds, and, having inquired, study and learn it.

Should one encounter one who upholds the Vinaya, one ought to inquire respectfully concerning the causes and conditions giving rise to an offense, the gravity or lightness of an offense, the dharma for extinguishing an offense, and matters of avadāna, and, having inquired, cultivate and practice it.

Should one encounter one who recites the sūtras, one ought to inquire respectfully concerning the meaning within the various āgamas and divisions of the canon, studying and learning them extensively.

Should one encounter one who recites the mātṛkā, or the Sūtra of Benefiting the Multitude, the Udāna, the Pārāyaṇa, or the Dharmapada, one ought to study and learn scriptures such as these.

Should one encounter one who recites the bodhisattva basket, one ought to inquire respectfully concerning the six pāramitās and their skillful means, and, having inquired, cultivate and study them.

Should one encounter a forest-dwelling monk, one ought to study their own dharma of dwelling apart.

Should one encounter one who sits in meditation, one ought to study their own dharma of meditative sitting.

Toward every remaining monk, one likewise ought, according to their own practice, to inquire respectfully and study and learn from them, without any contrary resistance.

As for "guarding one's own speech": when going to attend the monks, one ought skillfully to guard one's own speech, remaining calm and composed and silent, observing the proper time and place, reflecting according to the matter at hand, one's own mind free of confusion, speaking but little.

And further, toward those who expound the Dharma, and the assembled monks, according to whatever they lack — whether robe, bowl, sitting-cloth, or any article of livelihood — one gives according to one's own capacity, without any stinginess or reluctance.

And why is this so? The bodhisattva ought still to give even to evil persons — how much more so, then, to a monk who possesses genuine merit! Even one's own flesh and body ought not to be spared — how much less, then, an external object that assists the very path!

Furthermore: "When practicing giving, one ought never to give rise to affliction in another."

When practicing giving, should one give to one person while another fails to receive anything, this latter person may give rise to anger and affliction; one ought skillfully to weigh and consider before giving, so as never to cause another to give rise to anger and affliction. And why is this so?

"Guarding and protecting the mind of the ordinary being ought to surpass even that shown toward an arhat."

This householder bodhisattva, giving robes, food and drink, medicine, and bedding to the assembled monks, making offerings, welcoming and seeing them off, showing reverence and drawing near to them —

Guarding and protecting the mind of the ordinary being ought to surpass even the guarding and protection shown toward an arhat. And why is this so? Every arhat, toward gain and loss, disgrace and honor, praise and blame, suffering and joy, holds no difference of mind whatsoever; the ordinary being, possessing craving, anger, stinginess, and envy, is capable of giving rise to karmic offense, and, through this very karmic offense, falls into hell, the animal realm, or the realm of hungry ghosts. It is for this reason that one ought to guard and protect the ordinary being's own mind all the more deeply.

The bodhisattva's own affairs are, in every case, giving for the benefit of every sentient being, never for their own pleasure, never seeking their own fruit and recompense in a future life — this is nothing at all like a mere commercial exchange.

Furthermore: "Through the very giving of material wealth, one is able to draw them in through the giving of the Dharma as well, benefiting them according to what they themselves wish, teaching them to give rise to the unsurpassed mind."

This householder bodhisattva, for the sake of their own benefit, benefits monks according to their own need — whether giving a robe, or giving a bowl, or every other kind of material object besides. A monk such as this, not yet having entered the very station of the Dharma, not yet having attained the fruit of the path, ought to be encouraged to give rise to the vow of unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. And why is this so? Through the very drawing-in accomplished by the giving of material wealth, one is able to draw them in further through the giving of the Dharma.

And this may cause the very donor of this gift to hold a mind of love and reverence, accepting with trust whatever is then spoken to them.

Furthermore: "For the sake of guarding and protecting the Dharma, relinquishing one's own life without any regret; treating and healing a sick monk, even to the point of giving one's own body."

This householder bodhisattva, for the sake of guarding and protecting the Dharma, goes so far as to relinquish their own body and life, diligently applying effort, breaking through the sixty-two kinds of outside path, and every follower of māra who hates and envies the Buddhadharma; among the Buddha's own disciples, there may be some of deviant conduct, who distort the Buddhadharma — persons such as this, broken through in accordance with the Dharma, is what is called guarding and protecting the Dharma.

And further, toward those of vast learning who expound the Dharma, adding a mind of faith and reverence, making the fourfold offering to them, is likewise called guarding and protecting the Dharma.

Should one personally recite, explain, and copy out the sūtras, the Vinaya, the Abhidharma, the mātṛkā, and the bodhisattva basket, and further teach others to recite, explain, and copy them, through this very cause and condition the Dharma endures for a long time, benefiting all. Whether householder or renunciant, praising and extolling it, the Dharma endures long and to great benefit. Should the Dharma be spoken of as swiftly perishing, this is itself a fault and an evil.

And further, being mindful that the Thus Come One, across a vast span of time, practiced the bodhisattva path, carrying out every difficult practice, only thereby attaining this very Dharma; through this very cause and condition, toward every householder and renunciant, applying diligent effort, revealing, teaching, benefiting, and delighting them, whether causing them to attain the path, or causing them to enter irreversibility — to speak briefly of the causes and conditions of guarding the Dharma, causing all to obtain every implement of peace and joy, and further being personally able to practice exactly as one has spoken — all of this is called guarding and protecting the Dharma.

Furthermore, this is the very dharma of the householder bodhisattva: should there be a sick monk requiring treatment, this bodhisattva, even to the point of relinquishing their own body to treat this illness, holds nothing back — this is of the very greatest importance. The renunciant ought to seek this essential matter from the householder — namely, personally attending to their illness, and providing medicine.

Furthermore: "Giving with a resolute mind, and, having given, holding no regret."

Should this bodhisattva, whether for the sake of guarding and protecting the true Dharma, or for the sake of attending a sick person, give in a timely manner, their own mind free of any regret, this is called pure giving; should one seek no fruit in recompense, making no distinction between one who ought to receive and one who ought not, but give solely through a mind of pity and benefit, this too is called pure giving.

As the verse says: "Should a person give with a mind of compassion, this is called pure giving — one speaks neither of this as a field of merit, nor as not a field of merit.

"Should a person practice giving, giving for no purpose whatsoever, and should a person give for the sake of a fruit in recompense, this latter is called an investment expecting return.

"It is for this reason that it is said: having given, one's own mind holds no regret or resentment whatsoever; even the smallest merit is, in every case, directed toward the unsurpassed path."

Through the very merit obtained from the causes and conditions of this giving, one ought, in every case, to dedicate it toward unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening, seeking neither benefit nor joy in this present life or lives to come, nor the fruit of the lesser vehicle; but seeking, for the sake of sentient beings, unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening alone.

Just as I have already explained above every remaining practice of the householder bodhisattva, what needed to be explained has now been explained in full, all gathered from various passages scattered throughout the Great Vehicle sūtras, according with the scriptural teaching. The bodhisattva, abiding within this very practice, swiftly attains unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening.

Within the second ground, much has already been said of the renunciant bodhisattva's own practice; the practice shared in common by both householder and renunciant bodhisattvas shall now further be explained.

A note on this chapter's close

The closing line of this section marks a formal transition within the treatise itself — everything specific to the householder bodhisattva's own path is now complete, and the text explicitly signals a shift toward material common to both lay and monastic practitioners alike. The final image of pure giving, defined by the giver holding no distinction whatsoever between a worthy and unworthy recipient, revisits a theme introduced in Fascicle 6's own extended treatment of the "purity of the giver, the gift, and the recipient" — the same standard reappearing here in its most condensed form.

Practices Shared by Householder and Renunciant

Chinese Source

共行品第十八

問曰:汝言當說在家、出家菩薩共行法,今可說之。

答曰:忍辱,法施,法忍,思惟,不曲法,尊重法,不障法,供養法,信解,修空,不貪嫉,隨所說行,燈明施,伎樂施,乘施,正願,攝法,思量利安眾生,等心於一切。此是在家、出家共行要法。

是故偈說:行忍身端嚴,法施知宿命,法忍得總持,思惟獲智慧,於諸法不曲,常得正憶念。

「行忍得端嚴」者,能忍惡言、罵詈、呪誓、繫縛、刀杖、考掠、搒笞,心不動異,悉能堪受。如是忍辱,所獲果報,生於人天,常得端正;後成佛時,相好無比。

「法施知宿命」者,行法施者,能知過去無量劫事。「法施」名為種種分別聲聞乘、辟支佛乘、佛乘,解說義理。

法施果報雖有三十五,要者,知宿命。說法因緣,斷人所疑,是故得「知宿命」。

「法忍得總持」者,「法」名應「空、無相、無願」、應六波羅蜜。菩薩諸地、一切菩薩所行之法,曉了明解,心能忍持,名為「法忍」。行是忍者,則得總持。「總持」,名為如所聞經,如所讀誦,其中義趣乃至百千萬劫,終不忘失。

「思惟得智慧」者,「思惟」,名為籌量善法,分別義趣。是故,能得今世後世利益。

「不曲心得正念」者,「不曲」,名為質直無諂。修行此法,則於一切法中,得堅固念。

復次——重法法則堅,不障得守護,供養法值佛,信解捨諸難。

「重法法則堅」者,若人尊重、恭敬於法,法則堅固。「堅法」,名為所受持、習學之法,自然牢堅,不可動轉。後成佛時,多有菩薩、聲聞弟子,住是堅固法,無能障其所受法者。

又,「堅」名為法得久住。

「不障得守護」者,若人說法及人聽法,不橫與作障礙之事,後成佛時,諸天世人,共守護法;未得佛道,常能護持諸佛正法;諸佛滅後,守護遺法,乃能至於後佛出世。以是因緣,菩薩、聲聞皆應盡心善守護法。

「供養法值佛」者,「供養」,名為恭敬諸法。法施法會,敬心供養說法之人,施設法座,起立禪坊,莊挍嚴飾講法之處;如是深心愛樂,供養法因緣故,得值諸佛。

「以信解捨諸難」者,「信」,名於諸善法深生欲樂;以是法故,得離八難。「解」者,能滅諸罪,能於諸善法中,以心力故隨意而解。如十「一切入」,隨意所解。

若人多有信解力者,能滅無始生死已來無量罪惡。如先〈悔過品〉中說。

復次——修空不放逸,不貪得成利,隨說滅煩惱,燈施得天眼。

「修空不放逸」者,「修」有二種:得修、行修。

修空力故,信有為法皆是虛誑,亦不住空。諸法無定,是故常自攝撿,心不放逸。

「不貪得成利」者,「貪」,名於他物中,生貪取心。若除是事,所求皆成,所願皆滿。

「隨說滅煩惱」者,隨有所說,身即行之,則斷煩惱,於諸事中,皆如說行。世世已來,諸煩惱氣常熏其心,則皆除滅,轉諸煩惱、惡氣習性。

「燈施得天眼」者,若人然燈供養佛、聲聞、辟支佛及塔像、舍利,以是因緣,得天眼報。

復次——樂施天耳報,以正願淨土;乘施獲神足,攝法得具僧。

「樂施得天耳報」者,於大會作諸音樂供養於佛,得天耳報。

「乘施得神足」者,「乘」名輦輿、象馬等乘。復有人言:以履屣等施,亦得神足。

「以正願淨土」者,隨以所願,取清淨土。若金、銀、頗梨、珊瑚、琥珀、車璩、碼瑙無量眾寶,清淨國土。

「攝法得具僧」者,若菩薩具足行四攝法得具足僧,以布施、愛語、利益、同事,攝取眾生故;後成佛時,得清淨具足無量菩薩僧及聲聞僧,如阿彌陀佛有二種僧清淨具足。願具足者,如先十願中說。

復次——利益眾生故,一切所愛敬,平等心無二,得為最勝者。

若菩薩以身口意業,有所作,皆為利益、安樂眾生。是故眾生,皆悉敬愛。

若菩薩於諸眾生怨親中人,行平等心,不捨一切眾生,以是業報,得為「最勝」。

「勝」名能勝貪欲、瞋恚、愚癡、一切煩惱惡法,故名為佛。

Ru-Yi Translation

Practices Shared in Common Chapter

Question: You have said that you would explain the dharma of the practice shared in common by both householder and renunciant bodhisattva — please explain this now.

Answer: "Patient endurance, the giving of the Dharma, forbearance with regard to the Dharma, contemplation, a dharma free of crookedness, reverence for the Dharma, a dharma that obstructs nothing, making offering to the Dharma, faith and understanding, cultivating emptiness, freedom from craving and envy, practicing exactly as one has spoken, the giving of lamplight, the giving of music, the giving of a vehicle, right vows, the dharma of gathering others, reflecting on benefiting and bringing peace to sentient beings, and an equal mind toward all. This is the essential dharma of the practice shared in common by householder and renunciant alike."

It is for this reason that the verse states: "Practicing patient endurance, the body becomes dignified and fine; giving the Dharma, one comes to know past lives; forbearance with the Dharma attains the dhāraṇī; contemplation obtains wisdom; toward every dharma, holding no crookedness, one constantly attains right mindfulness."

As for "practicing patient endurance, the body becomes dignified and fine": being able to endure harsh speech, reviling, cursing, bondage, blade and club, torture, and beating, one's own mind never wavering or changing, able to bear every one of these fully. Patient endurance such as this obtains, as its own fruit and recompense, rebirth among humans or devas, constantly possessing a dignified and fine bearing; and, upon later accomplishing buddhahood, one's own marks and signs become beyond compare.

As for "giving the Dharma, one comes to know past lives": one who practices the giving of the Dharma is able to know matters of immeasurable kalpas past. "The giving of the Dharma" refers to distinguishing, in every kind of way, the śrāvaka vehicle, the pratyekabuddha vehicle, and the buddha vehicle, and explaining their own true meaning.

Though the fruit and recompense of the giving of the Dharma is of thirty-five kinds, its essential one is knowing one's own past lives. Through the very cause and condition of expounding the Dharma, severing every doubt held by others, one thereby attains "knowledge of past lives."

As for "forbearance with the Dharma attains the dhāraṇī": "the Dharma" here refers to that which accords with emptiness, signlessness, and wishlessness, and that which accords with the six pāramitās. Fully comprehending and clearly understanding the bodhisattva's own grounds, and the very dharma practiced by every bodhisattva, one's own mind able to endure and uphold it, this is called "forbearance with the Dharma." One who practices this very forbearance thereby attains the dhāraṇī. "The dhāraṇī" refers to whatever sūtra one has heard, whatever one has recited, its own true meaning never forgotten even across a hundred thousand myriad kalpas.

As for "contemplation obtains wisdom": "contemplation" refers to weighing and considering wholesome dharmas, distinguishing their own true meaning. It is for this reason that one is able to obtain benefit in this present life and in lives to come.

As for "holding no crookedness of mind, one attains right mindfulness": "no crookedness" refers to being upright and honest, free of flattery. Cultivating and practicing this very dharma, one thereby attains, within every dharma, a firm and resolute mindfulness.

Furthermore: "Honoring the Dharma, the Dharma thereby becomes firm; obstructing nothing, one thereby attains its own protection; making offering to the Dharma, one thereby encounters the buddhas; through faith and understanding, one departs from every difficulty."

As for "honoring the Dharma, the Dharma thereby becomes firm": should a person honor and revere the Dharma, this very Dharma thereby becomes firm. "A firm dharma" refers to a dharma one has received, upheld, and studied that naturally becomes secure and firm, unable to be shaken or overturned. Upon later accomplishing buddhahood, there shall be many bodhisattva and śrāvaka disciples abiding within this very firm dharma, and none shall be able to obstruct the dharma they themselves have received.

And further, "firm" refers to this Dharma enduring for a long time.

As for "obstructing nothing, one thereby attains its own protection": should a person who expounds the Dharma, and a person who listens to the Dharma, never wrongly create any obstruction toward it, then, upon later accomplishing buddhahood, every deva and every person in this world shall together guard and protect this Dharma; and, not yet having attained buddhahood themselves, one shall constantly be able to guard and uphold the true Dharma of every buddha; and, after every buddha has passed into extinction, guarding and protecting the Dharma they have left behind, until the appearance of the next buddha in the world. Through this very cause and condition, both bodhisattva and śrāvaka alike ought, with their whole mind, skillfully to guard and protect the Dharma.

As for "making offering to the Dharma, one thereby encounters the buddhas": "offering" refers to showing reverence toward every dharma. Through the giving of the Dharma and Dharma assemblies, showing a reverent mind in making offering to one who expounds the Dharma, setting out a Dharma seat, erecting a meditation hall, adorning and decorating the very place where the Dharma is taught — through this deep mind of love and delight, and through the very cause and condition of this offering to the Dharma, one comes to encounter every buddha.

As for "through faith and understanding, one departs from every difficulty": "faith" refers to giving rise to a deep desire and delight toward every wholesome dharma; through this very dharma, one is able to depart from the eight difficulties. "Understanding" refers to being able to extinguish every offense, and, within every wholesome dharma, through the very power of one's own mind, understanding it according to one's own will — just as, with the ten totalities, one comes to understand each according to one's own will.

Should a person possess much power of faith and understanding, they are able to extinguish immeasurable offense and evil accumulated since beginningless birth and death, exactly as already explained within the earlier Chapter of Repentance.

Furthermore: "Cultivating emptiness, one is free of heedlessness; free of craving, one accomplishes benefit; practicing exactly as one has spoken, one extinguishes the afflictions; giving lamplight, one attains the heavenly eye."

As for "cultivating emptiness, one is free of heedlessness": "cultivation" is of two kinds — cultivation that attains, and cultivation that practices.

Through the very power of cultivating emptiness, one holds faith that every conditioned dharma is entirely illusory and false, and yet does not abide even within emptiness itself. Since no dharma is ever fixed or certain, one constantly restrains and examines oneself, one's own mind free of heedlessness.

As for "free of craving, one accomplishes benefit": "craving" refers to giving rise, toward another's own possessions, to a mind of craving and grasping. Should this very matter be removed, whatever one seeks is accomplished, and whatever one wishes is fulfilled.

As for "practicing exactly as one has spoken, one extinguishes the afflictions": whatever one has spoken, one's own body immediately carries it out, thereby severing the afflictions; within every matter, one practices exactly as one has spoken. Across every past lifetime, the very scent of the afflictions has constantly permeated one's own mind — through this practice, it is entirely extinguished and removed, transforming the afflictions and their own evil habitual nature.

As for "giving lamplight, one attains the heavenly eye": should a person kindle a lamp in offering to the Buddha, to the śrāvakas and pratyekabuddhas, and to a stūpa, an image, or relics, through this very cause and condition, one attains, as its recompense, the heavenly eye.

Furthermore: "Delighting in giving music, one attains, as its recompense, the heavenly ear; through right vows, one attains a pure land; giving a vehicle, one attains supernormal locomotion; gathering others through the four means, one attains a complete assembly."

As for "delighting in giving music, one attains, as its recompense, the heavenly ear": within a great assembly, performing every kind of music in offering to the Buddha, one attains, as its recompense, the heavenly ear.

As for "giving a vehicle, one attains supernormal locomotion": "a vehicle" refers to a palanquin, a carriage, an elephant, a horse, and every such conveyance. There are, further, those who say: giving even sandals and the like likewise attains this same supernormal locomotion.

As for "through right vows, one attains a pure land": according to whatever vow one makes, one thereby obtains this pure land. Whether of gold, silver, crystal, coral, amber, mother-of-pearl, or agate, and every kind of immeasurable jewel besides, one attains a pure and undefiled land.

As for "gathering others through the four means, one attains a complete assembly": should the bodhisattva fully practice the four means of gathering others, they thereby attain a complete assembly — through giving, kind speech, beneficial conduct, and cooperative engagement, gathering in sentient beings; upon later accomplishing buddhahood, one attains an assembly, pure and complete, of immeasurable bodhisattvas and śrāvakas, just as Amitābha Buddha possesses these two kinds of assembly, pure and complete. As for the completeness of one's own vows, this is as already explained within the earlier chapter on the ten vows.

Furthermore: "For the sake of benefiting sentient beings, one is loved and revered by all; holding an equal mind free of any duality, one attains the status of the very foremost."

Should the bodhisattva, through the karma of body, speech, and mind, undertake any action whatsoever, it is, in every case, for the benefit and peace of sentient beings. It is for this reason that sentient beings, in every case, hold this bodhisattva in reverence and love.

Should the bodhisattva, toward every sentient being, whether hostile or intimate, practice an equal mind, never abandoning any sentient being whatsoever, through this very karmic recompense, they attain the status of "the very foremost."

"Foremost" refers to being able to overcome craving, anger, delusion, and every evil dharma of the afflictions — it is for this reason that this status is called buddhahood.

A note on this catalogue's own structure

This chapter's own opening list of nineteen shared practices, each subsequently unpacked one item at a time and paired with its own specific karmic fruit, follows a compositional pattern familiar from earlier fascicles of this treatise — name the full set first, then work through it systematically. What distinguishes this particular list is the specificity of its pairings: giving a lamp yields the heavenly eye, giving music yields the heavenly ear, giving a vehicle yields supernormal locomotion — a symbolic logic in which the nature of the gift itself prefigures the nature of its eventual fruit, rather than an arbitrary system of reward.

The Thirty-Two Marks of a Great Being

Chinese Source

問曰:人皆俱有眼、耳、鼻、舌、口等無有異,云何得知是佛?

答曰:佛有三十二大人相。有是相者,當知是佛。

在家、出家,應當分別了知三十二相。是相以何法得是法?以何業得是相?是業亦應當知。何以故?欲得功德,當知是相;欲得是相,當知是業。

問曰:如此事者,於何得解?

答曰:於法相品中,一相三分別。

《阿毘曇》三十二相品中,一一相有三種分別,悉應當知。

問曰:云何為一一相有三種分別?

答曰:一、說相體,二、說相果,三、說得相業。

手足輪相等,先已說,轉輪聖王亦有是相,諸菩薩亦有是相,餘人亦有,但不如耳。手足輪者,手足掌中,有千輻輪,具足明了,如印文現。

足安住不動,名足安立相。

網縵軟薄,猶如鵝王;畫文明了,如真金縷故,名手足網相。

柔軟猶如兜羅樹綿、如嬰兒體,其色紅赤,勝身餘分,名為手足柔軟相。

手掌、足下、項上、兩腋,七處俱滿故,名七處滿相。

脩指纖傭故,名長指相。

足跟長廣故,名足跟廣相。

身長七肘不曲故,名身直大相。

足上隆起故,名足趺高相。

毛上向右旋故,名毛上旋相。

傭[跳-兆+專]漸麁,如伊泥鹿[跳-兆+專]故,名鹿[跳-兆+專]相。

平立兩手摩膝故,名長臂相。

如寶馬、寶象陰不現故,名陰藏相。

第一金色光明故,名金色相。

皮軟如成鍊金,不受塵垢故,名皮薄細密相。

一一孔一毛生故,名一一毛相。

眉間白毫光如珂雪故,為白毛相。

如師子前身,廣厚得所故,名師子上身相。

肩圓大故,名肩圓大相。

腋下平滿故,名腋下滿相。

舌根不為風寒熱所壞故,善分別諸味,餘人不爾故,名知味味相。

身縱廣等,如尼駒樓樹故,名圓身相。

肉髻團圓,髮右上旋故,名肉髻相。

舌如赤蓮華,廣長而薄故,名廣長舌相。

聲如梵王、迦陵頻伽鳥故,名梵音相。

頰圓廣如鏡故,名師子頰相。

齒白如珂雪、如君坻華故,名齒白相。

平齊不參差故,名齒齊相。

齒密緻不疎故,名具足齒相。

齒上下相當故,名四十齒相。

眼白黑分明,淨無赤脈故,名紺青眼相。

睫不交亂、上下俱眴、不長不短故,名為牛王睫相。

Ru-Yi Translation

Question: Every person alike possesses eyes, ears, nose, tongue, mouth, and the like, with no real difference among them — how, then, can one know that this is truly a buddha?

Answer: The Buddha possesses the thirty-two marks of a great being. Whoever possesses these marks, one should know, is truly a buddha.

Both householder and renunciant alike ought to distinguish and thoroughly understand these thirty-two marks. By what dharma is this mark itself attained? By what karma is this mark attained? This karma too ought to be known. And why is this so? Wishing to attain this merit, one ought to know this mark; wishing to attain this mark, one ought to know this karma.

Question: A matter such as this — where can it be understood?

Answer: "Within the chapter on the marks of the Dharma, each single mark receives a threefold analysis."

Within the Abhidharma's own chapter on the thirty-two marks, each and every mark receives a threefold analysis, all of which ought to be thoroughly known.

Question: What, then, is meant by each and every mark receiving a threefold analysis?

Answer: "First, explaining the very essence of the mark; second, explaining the fruit of the mark; third, explaining the karma by which the mark is attained."

As for the mark of the wheel upon the hand and foot, this has already been explained above — the wheel-turning sage king likewise possesses this mark, and every bodhisattva likewise possesses it, and even other persons possess it as well, though not to the same degree. As for the wheel upon the hand and foot, within the very palm of the hand and sole of the foot, there is a thousand-spoked wheel, complete and perfectly clear, as though appearing as a stamped impression.

The foot resting securely, unmoving, this is called the mark of a firmly planted foot.

Webbing, soft and thin, just like a royal goose; its own pattern clear and distinct, like threads of genuine gold, this is called the mark of webbed hands and feet.

Soft and pliant, just like the down of the tūla tree, or an infant's own body, its own color a rosy red, surpassing every other part of the body, this is called the mark of soft hands and feet.

The palm of the hand, the sole of the foot, the nape of the neck, and both armpits — these seven places all being full, this is called the mark of seven full places.

Long fingers, slender and even, this is called the mark of long fingers.

The heel long and broad, this is called the mark of a broad heel.

The body seven cubits in length, without any crookedness, this is called the mark of an upright, great body.

The instep of the foot raised and full, this is called the mark of a high instep.

The hair upon the body curling upward to the right, this is called the mark of hair curling upward.

The calves gradually tapering, just like those of the antelope, this is called the mark of antelope calves.

Standing upright, both hands able to touch the knees, this is called the mark of long arms.

Just as with a treasured horse or a treasured elephant, whose own private organ does not show outwardly, this is called the mark of a concealed organ.

A supreme, golden radiance, this is called the mark of golden color.

Skin soft as refined gold, receiving no dust or defilement, this is called the mark of thin, fine skin.

From each and every pore, a single hair grows, this is called the mark of a single hair per pore.

Between the eyebrows, a tuft of white hair radiant as snow upon a conch shell, this is the mark of white hair.

Like the foreparts of a lion's own body, broad and full in due proportion, this is called the mark of a lion's own upper body.

The shoulders round and full, this is called the mark of round, full shoulders.

The area beneath the arms, level and full, this is called the mark of full underarms.

The root of the tongue, unimpaired by wind, cold, or heat, skillfully distinguishing every flavor, unlike that of any other person, this is called the mark of tasting every flavor to the fullest.

The body's own height and breadth equal to one another, just like the nyagrodha tree, this is called the mark of a well-proportioned body.

The fleshy protuberance atop the head round and full, the hair curling upward to the right, this is called the mark of the uṣṇīṣa.

The tongue like a crimson lotus flower, broad and long yet thin, this is called the mark of a broad, long tongue.

The voice like Brahmā's own, or like the kalaviṅka bird, this is called the mark of a Brahmā-like voice.

The cheeks round and broad as a mirror, this is called the mark of a lion's own cheeks.

The teeth white as snow upon a conch shell, or like the kunda flower, this is called the mark of white teeth.

Even and level, without any irregularity, this is called the mark of even teeth.

Close-set and fine, without any gap, this is called the mark of complete teeth.

The upper and lower teeth corresponding to one another, this is called the mark of forty teeth.

The white and black of the eye clearly distinct, pure and free of any red vein, this is called the mark of eyes the deep blue-black of collyrium.

The eyelashes never tangled, upper and lower blinking together, neither too long nor too short, this is called the mark of eyelashes like a bull's own.

A note on the threefold analysis

The methodological framework announced here — essence, fruit, and the karma that produces it — is explicitly borrowed from the Abhidharma's own systematic treatment of the thirty-two marks, situating this treatise's own account within a shared scholastic vocabulary rather than presenting it as an original scheme. This section supplies the first component, the essence of each mark, in the traditional canonical order; the following section supplies the third, matching each mark to the specific karmic cause that produces it.

The Karma That Produces Each Mark

Chinese Source

於諸所尊迎送恭敬,於塔寺中、大法會處、說法處,供給人使故,得手足輪相。有是相故,在家作轉輪聖王,多得人民;出家學道,多得徒眾。

所受諸法,堅持不捨,故得安立足相。

有是相故,無能傾動。

常修四攝法:布施、愛語、利益、同事故,得手足網縵相。

有是相故,速攝人眾。

以諸香甘美濡飲食,供施於人及諸所尊,供給所須故,得手足柔軟相及七處隆滿相。

有是相故,多得香甘美軟飲食。

救免應死、及增壽命、又受不殺戒故,得纖長指相、足跟滿相、身大直相。

有是相故,壽命長遠。

所受善法增益不失故,得足趺高、毛上向右旋相。

有是相故,得諸功德不退失。

能以技藝及諸經書教授不惜,及履屣等施故,得伊尼鹿[跳-兆+專]相。

有是相故,諸所修學速疾如意。

有來求索,無所遺惜故,得傭長臂相。

有是相故,能得勢力、能大布施。

能善調人,不令眾生親里遠離;若有乖離,還令和合,故得陰藏相。

有是相故,多得弟子。

以好淨潔衣服、臥具、樓閣、房舍施故,得金色相及皮膚薄相。

有是相故,得好淨潔衣服、臥具、樓閣、房舍。

隨所應供養和尚、阿闍梨、父母、兄弟及所尊重善,能衛護故,得一一孔一毛生,毛右旋相、白毛莊嚴面相。

有是相故,無與等者。

慚愧語、隨順語、愛語,故得上身如師子相、肩圓大相。

有是相故,見者樂視,無有厭足。

供給疾病醫藥、飲食,身自看視,故得腋下滿相、得味味相。

有是相故,身少疾病。

布施園林、甘果、橋梁、茂樹、池井、飲食、華香、瓔珞、房舍、起塔福舍等及共眾施時,能出多物,故得身如尼俱樓樹相及肉髻相。

有是相故,得尊貴自在。

長夜修習實語、軟語,故得廣長舌相、梵音聲相。

有是相故,得五功德音聲。五功德音聲者,易解聲、聽者無厭聲、深遠聲、悅耳聲、不散聲。

長夜實語,不綺語故,得師子頰相。

有是相故,言必信受。

初既供養,後不輕慢,隨意供給,故得齒白相齒齊相。

有是相故,得清淨、和順、同心眷屬。

長夜實語,不讒謗故,得四十齒相、齒密緻相。

有是相故,眷屬和同,不可沮壞。

深心愛念,和顏視眾生,無愛恚癡故,得紺青眼相、睫如牛王相。

有是相故,一切見者,無不愛敬。

Ru-Yi Translation

Through welcoming, seeing off, and showing reverence toward every venerable person, and through providing service and attendance within a stūpa or temple, at a great Dharma assembly, or a place where the Dharma is expounded, one attains the mark of the wheel upon the hand and foot. Possessing this very mark, should one remain a householder, one becomes a wheel-turning sage king, gaining many subjects; should one go forth from home to study the path, one gains a great following of disciples.

Firmly upholding, without ever relinquishing, every dharma one has received, one thereby attains the mark of a firmly planted foot.

Possessing this very mark, none are able to overturn or shake one.

Constantly cultivating the four means of gathering others — giving, kind speech, beneficial conduct, and cooperative engagement — one thereby attains the mark of webbed hands and feet.

Possessing this very mark, one swiftly gathers a great assembly of people.

Through fragrant, delicious, and soft food and drink, given in offering to others and to every venerable person, providing whatever they require, one thereby attains the mark of soft hands and feet, and the mark of seven full places.

Possessing this very mark, one obtains much fragrant, delicious, and soft food and drink.

Through rescuing one who was to die, and increasing another's own lifespan, and further receiving the precept against killing, one thereby attains the mark of long, slender fingers, the mark of a full heel, and the mark of a great, upright body.

Possessing this very mark, one's own lifespan is long and enduring.

Through every wholesome dharma one has received continuing to increase without ever being lost, one thereby attains the mark of a high instep, and the mark of hair curling upward to the right.

Possessing this very mark, every merit one attains never retrogresses or is lost.

Through teaching one's own skill and every scripture to others without any reluctance, and through giving sandals and the like, one thereby attains the mark of antelope calves.

Possessing this very mark, whatever one studies and cultivates is accomplished swiftly, exactly as one wishes.

Through, when one comes to make a request, holding back nothing whatsoever, one thereby attains the mark of long, even arms.

Possessing this very mark, one is able to attain great strength, and able to give greatly.

Through being skillfully able to reconcile others, never allowing sentient beings to become estranged from their own kin, and, should estrangement occur, restoring this very harmony, one thereby attains the mark of a concealed organ.

Possessing this very mark, one gains many disciples.

Through giving fine, pure and clean clothing, bedding, towers, and dwellings, one thereby attains the mark of golden color, and the mark of thin skin.

Possessing this very mark, one obtains fine, pure and clean clothing, bedding, towers, and dwellings.

Through, according to what is fitting, making offering to one's own preceptor, one's own instructor, one's own parents and siblings, and every venerable and worthy person, being able to protect and guard them, one thereby attains the mark of a single hair growing from each and every pore, the mark of hair curling to the right, and the mark of white hair adorning the face.

Possessing this very mark, none are equal to oneself.

Through speech marked by conscience and shame, speech that accords with others, and kind speech, one thereby attains the mark of an upper body like a lion's own, and the mark of round, full shoulders.

Possessing this very mark, whoever beholds one delights in the sight, never growing weary of it.

Through providing medicine and food and drink to the sick, personally attending to them, one thereby attains the mark of full underarms, and the mark of tasting every flavor to the fullest.

Possessing this very mark, one's own body suffers little illness.

Through giving gardens and groves, sweet fruit, bridges, flourishing trees, pools and wells, food and drink, flowers and fragrance, garlands, dwellings, and the erecting of stūpas and rest-houses of merit, and, in giving alongside the assembly, being able to bring forth much in the way of goods, one thereby attains the mark of a body like the nyagrodha tree, and the mark of the uṣṇīṣa.

Possessing this very mark, one attains nobility and mastery.

Through cultivating, across a vast span of time, truthful speech and gentle speech, one thereby attains the mark of a broad, long tongue, and the mark of a Brahmā-like voice.

Possessing this very mark, one attains the five meritorious qualities of voice. These five meritorious qualities of voice are: a voice easily understood, a voice that never wearies the listener, a voice deep and far-reaching, a voice pleasing to the ear, and a voice that never scatters.

Through, across a vast span of time, speaking truthfully and never speaking idle, frivolous words, one thereby attains the mark of a lion's own cheeks.

Possessing this very mark, whatever one says is certainly believed and accepted.

Through, having once made an offering, never afterward showing contempt, providing according to what is needed, one thereby attains the mark of white teeth, and the mark of even teeth.

Possessing this very mark, one attains a pure, harmonious, and like-minded following.

Through, across a vast span of time, speaking truthfully, never slandering or defaming, one thereby attains the mark of forty teeth, and the mark of close-set teeth.

Possessing this very mark, one's own following remains harmonious and united, unable to be broken apart.

Through a deep mind of love and affection, beholding sentient beings with a gentle countenance, free of craving, anger, and delusion, one thereby attains the mark of eyes the deep blue-black of collyrium, and the mark of eyelashes like a bull's own.

Possessing this very mark, everyone who beholds oneself feels nothing but love and reverence.

A note on this correspondence

The pairing of each mark with its own specific cause makes a claim that runs through much of this treatise: nothing about a buddha's appearance is arbitrary or merely decorative. A concealed, well-proportioned body results from reconciling estranged relatives; a golden radiance results from giving fine clothing and shelter; a voice with five distinct qualities results from a lifetime of truthful, gentle speech. The thirty-two marks, read this way, are less a checklist for recognizing a buddha than a complete portrait of an entire life of specific, nameable conduct, made visible on the body itself.

Fascicle 8 Complete

This closes Fascicle 8: the closing of the householder bodhisattva's own practice with the temple visit, the sixty-item catalogue contrasting household and renunciant life, the longing for ordination, guarding and protecting the Dharma, and the opening of the chapter on practices shared by householder and renunciant alike — patient endurance, the giving of the Dharma, and the thirty-two marks of a great being together with the karma that produces each one. Fascicle 9 continues within this shared-practice material.

Continue to Fascicle 9 →