What Distinguishes the Path to Buddhahood from Every Lesser Vehicle
Which practitioners the ten wholesome paths lead specifically to the pratyekabuddha ground — deep contemplation, love of solitude, becoming a genuine field of merit. Then, at far greater length, the treatise turns to the bodhisattva's own practice of these identical ten paths: roughly two dozen qualities of vow, compassion, skillful means, and valiant effort, each explained through its own fivefold structure, that mark the difference between walking toward liberation for oneself and walking toward buddhahood for the sake of every being.
Which Practitioners the Ten Wholesome Paths Lead to the Pratyekabuddha Ground
分別聲聞辟支佛品之餘
問曰:十善道令何等人至辟支佛地?
答曰:於聲聞所行,十善道轉勝,深禪不隨他,常憙於遠離。
恒樂善修習,甚深因緣法,遠離方便力,及以大悲心。
少欲及少事,惡賤憒閙語,常樂遠離處,威德深重人。
喜為福田地,常觀於出性,成辦有理事,恭敬於諸主。
已成就繫心,知心在所緣,常樂於禪定,中人之勢力。
樂於出家法,善心不縮沒,得慧光明者,或從二勝處,
或三勝處來,十善之業道,能令如是人,至於緣覺地。
於聲聞所行,十善道轉勝者,過聲聞人所行十善道,而不及菩薩所行;作是念:「聲聞人應隨他聞而行道,然後得自證智慧。我則不然,不樂隨他人。以是故,我應令十善道轉勝。以是因緣故,我樂不隨他,十善道令我至辟支佛地。」如是思惟已,常樂於遠離。
作是念:「若我常樂憒閙,則為集諸惡不善法,以近可染、可瞋、可癡事故;於是遠離中,應修習甚深因緣法。」
復作是念:「若我不修習甚深因緣法者,則不得不隨他智。我今何故不常修習甚深因緣,然後可得不隨他智?」
甚深者,難得其底,不可通達。一切凡夫從無始生死中,所有經書及其技藝,皆可得其邊底,唯甚深因緣不可得底。如兔等小虫,不能得大海邊底。若人有方便、大悲心及修集甚深因緣,即得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。若離此二事,修集甚深因緣智,則成辟支佛。
方便名於成就教化眾生中,種種思惟而不錯謬,亦於甚深法不取相。
大悲名深憐愍眾生,勝聲聞、辟支佛,何況凡夫!
少欲、少事,惡賤憒鬧語,如是則得辟支佛地。
若大欲、大事、好聚眾人,為方便、大悲所護者,阿耨多羅三藐三菩提則為易得。
何以故?求辟支佛人,少欲者作是念:「但自度身」;少事者,「但自成就善根,不及餘人」。是人捨離教化眾生事故,不親近眾閙。
菩薩大欲、大事,作是念:「我應度一切眾生。」以此大欲因緣故,則為大事教化眾生。教化眾生,此非小事,若憎惡憒鬧語,則不成此事。是故菩薩入憒鬧中,亦用憒鬧之語,但無所著。
復次,覆真實功德故,是為少欲;少事務故,名為少事。
惡賤憒鬧,名少欲;樂獨處故,名為少事。如是之人,少欲、少事,不樂眾鬧語。
樂於親近遠離、可畏、深邃之處,其心深大。是人作是念:「若我住遠離、可畏、深邃之處,人則不來。」以遠離處住故,心亦深遠。
若人自不深遠,喜戲調者,外人往來,則不為難。
如是人不與眾生和合,雖捨眾生,亦欲令眾生種諸善根,為大利益;作是念:「我云何不與眾生和合,亦能利益眾生?」如是思惟知已,我當為眾生作福田之利,受其供養;如是雖不與眾生和合,而能作大利益。
是人復思惟:「我云何當得福田地?」即自見知:「若我深樂為福田地,常觀出性,然後福田地法,自然而來;乃至出性之法,亦自然而來——所謂:持戒、禪定、智慧等。」
復作是念:「我當云何疾至福田地及出性法?我當為正觀者,於諸現有理趣事中,皆悉成辦,供養、恭敬諸主——如是福田地及出性法,不久疾得。
「何以故?我當成辦有理之事,正觀諸法,能得不隨他智。
「又供養、恭敬諸主故,令善根增厚;善根增厚故,智慧深厚;智慧深厚故,能通達實事;能通達實事故,能生厭;從厭則生離,從離得解脫,得解脫故,前後所集善根得為福田,然後得證出性之法。
「諸主者,諸佛世尊;是種諸善根時,是最大因緣。」
是人復思惟:「我云何能疾成有理趣事?」是人即自知見:「若我集繫心一處,知其所緣,常樂禪定。」
是人能繫心一處,則能得三昧。得三昧故,有理事皆能成辦。如《經》中說:「得禪定能如實知、如實見。若人已行繫心,則疾入三昧。疾入三昧故,名禪定者、常定者。」
若能如是修集諸法,則為供養、恭敬諸佛。若人以香華、四事供養佛,不名供養佛。若能一心不放逸,親近、修集聖道,是名供養、恭敬諸佛。如《經》說:「般涅槃時,佛告阿難:天雨文陀羅華及栴檀末香,作天伎樂,不名供養、恭敬如來也。阿難!若比丘、比丘尼、優婆塞、優婆夷,一心不放逸,親近修集聖法,是名真供養佛。是故阿難!汝當修學真供養佛。」
如是眾功德,皆是中勢力人。
樂出家、善心不縮沒者,最上勢力,能得成佛;下勢力者,作聲聞;以是故,中勢力人作辟支佛。樂出家故,能成眾功德。
何以故?若在居家,則不能少欲、少事,不能身心遠離,亦不能禪定。若心縮沒,不清淨者,不能成辦眾事,不能知甚深因緣法,不能證出性,不能如法真供養、恭敬諸佛。
如是眾生是中勢力,作是念:「我中勢力人,常樂出家,心不縮沒。諸所願功德事,皆自然來。」復作是思惟:「是中勢力樂為得何果?」即知當得智慧果。何以故?智慧能為照明。如《經》中說:「諸比丘!一切光明中,智慧光為勝。」
復作是念:「我所樂慧光,云何當得?」即知若從二勝處來、若三勝處來。
二勝處者,先已說。三勝處者,所謂諦、捨、寂滅;或諦、捨、慧;或諦、寂滅、慧。
以是故,我當修集如是諸勝處。我修集是已,得智慧光明。所願智慧,自然而至。如是相、如是修集助道法者,十善道能令至辟支佛地。
Distinguishing the Śrāvaka and the Pratyekabuddha Chapter, Continued
Question: What kind of person do the ten wholesome paths bring to the ground of the pratyekabuddha?
Answer: "One whose own practice of the ten wholesome paths grows ever more supreme beyond the śrāvaka's own practice, whose meditation runs deep and follows no other, constantly delighting in dwelling apart.
"Constantly delighting in skillfully cultivating and studying the exceedingly profound dharma of causal origination, the power of skillful means in dwelling apart, together with a mind of great compassion.
"Few desires and few affairs, holding in contempt every clamorous, idle word, constantly delighting in a place apart, a person of deep and weighty majesty.
"Delighting in becoming a field of merit, constantly contemplating the very nature of transcendence, accomplishing every reasonable matter, showing reverence toward every lord.
"Already accomplished in binding the mind, knowing where this mind rests upon its object, constantly delighting in meditative concentration — this is the power of the middling person.
"Delighting in the dharma of going forth from home, a wholesome mind never sinking or shrinking, one who attains the very radiance of wisdom, whether coming from two of the excellent places,
"Or coming from three of the excellent places — this very karmic path of the ten wholesome deeds is able to bring a person such as this to the ground of the pratyekabuddha."
As for "one whose own practice of the ten wholesome paths grows ever more supreme beyond the śrāvaka's own practice": this surpasses the śrāvaka's own practice of the ten wholesome paths, and yet does not reach the bodhisattva's own practice; reflecting thus: "The śrāvaka ought to follow what they hear from another in practicing the path, and only afterward attain their own personally realized wisdom. I myself am not so — I take no delight in following another. It is for this reason that I ought to cause my own practice of the ten wholesome paths to grow ever more supreme. Through this very cause and condition, delighting in following no other, these ten wholesome paths shall bring me to the ground of the pratyekabuddha." Having reflected in this way, they constantly delight in dwelling apart.
They reflect thus: "Should I constantly delight in clamor and crowds, this would only gather every evil, unwholesome dharma, since I would draw near to matters capable of defiling, provoking anger, and provoking delusion; it is within this very dwelling apart, then, that I ought to cultivate and study the exceedingly profound dharma of causal origination."
They further reflect: "Should I fail to cultivate and study this exceedingly profound dharma of causal origination, I would then be unable to attain wisdom that follows no other. Why, then, ought I not constantly cultivate and study this exceedingly profound causal origination, so that I might afterward attain this very wisdom that follows no other?"
As for "exceedingly profound": this refers to something whose own depth is difficult to fathom, unable to be fully penetrated. Every ordinary being, throughout beginningless birth and death, is able to reach the very outer limit of whatever scripture or skill they study — only this exceedingly profound causal origination admits of no such limit whatsoever. Just as a rabbit or some other small creature is unable to reach the very edge of the great ocean. Should a person possess skillful means, a mind of great compassion, and the cultivation of this exceedingly profound causal origination together, they thereby attain unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. Should they depart from these first two matters, cultivating and studying only this exceedingly profound wisdom of causal origination alone, they thereby become a pratyekabuddha instead.
"Skillful means" refers to, within accomplishing the teaching and transformation of sentient beings, reflecting upon every matter without error, and further, toward this exceedingly profound dharma, never grasping at its own mark.
"Great compassion" refers to a deep pity for sentient beings, surpassing even the śrāvaka and the pratyekabuddha — how much more so, then, the ordinary being!
Few desires and few affairs, holding in contempt every clamorous, idle word — through this alone, one attains the ground of the pratyekabuddha.
Should one possess great desire, great affairs, delighting in gathering many people, and be protected by skillful means and great compassion, unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening then becomes easy to attain.
And why is this so? One who seeks the ground of the pratyekabuddha, being of few desires, reflects thus: "I need only liberate myself alone"; being of few affairs, they reflect: "I need only accomplish my own roots of goodness, and need not concern myself with others." This person, having relinquished and departed from the very matter of teaching and transforming sentient beings, does not draw near to the clamor of the crowd.
The bodhisattva's own great desire and great affairs consist in reflecting thus: "I ought to liberate every sentient being." Through the very cause and condition of this great desire, they thereby take up the great affair of teaching and transforming sentient beings. Teaching and transforming sentient beings is no trifling matter — should one hold contempt for clamorous, idle speech, this very matter could never be accomplished. It is for this reason that the bodhisattva enters into the very clamor of the crowd, and further makes use of clamorous speech themselves, while remaining attached to none of it.
Furthermore, concealing one's own genuine merit is what is called "few desires"; being free of excessive activity is what is called "few affairs."
Holding clamor and crowds in contempt is called "few desires"; delighting in solitude is called "few affairs." A person such as this, of few desires and few affairs, takes no delight in the clamorous speech of the crowd.
Delighting in drawing near to a place apart, fearsome and deep, their own mind becomes profound and vast. This person reflects thus: "Should I dwell within a place apart, fearsome and deep, others shall not come there." Through dwelling within this very place apart, their own mind likewise becomes profound and far-reaching.
Should a person themselves lack this profundity, delighting instead in frivolous jesting, others coming and going presents no difficulty for them at all.
A person such as this, though not joining together with sentient beings, still wishes, even while relinquishing them, to cause sentient beings to plant every root of goodness, for their own great benefit; reflecting thus: "How might I, without joining together with sentient beings, still be able to benefit them?" Having reflected and known this, they resolve: "I shall become, for the benefit of sentient beings, a field of merit, receiving their own offerings" — in this way, though not joining together with sentient beings, they are nonetheless able to bring about great benefit.
This person further reflects: "How, then, might I attain this very ground of a field of merit?" They thereupon behold and know for themselves: "Should I deeply delight in becoming this very field of merit, constantly contemplating the nature of transcendence, this very dharma of a field of merit shall then naturally arrive of its own accord; and even the very dharma of transcendence itself shall likewise naturally arrive of its own accord — namely, upholding the precepts, meditative concentration, wisdom, and the rest."
They further reflect: "How, then, might I swiftly attain this very ground of a field of merit, and this very dharma of transcendence? I ought to become one of right contemplation, accomplishing every reasonable matter presently at hand in full, making offering and showing reverence to every lord — this very ground of a field of merit, and this dharma of transcendence, shall thereby soon be swiftly attained.
"And why is this so? I shall accomplish every reasonable matter, rightly contemplating every dharma, and thereby attain wisdom that follows no other.
"And further, through making offering and showing reverence to every lord, my own roots of goodness thereby grow ever thicker; through these roots of goodness growing thicker, my own wisdom thereby grows ever deeper; through this wisdom growing deeper, I am thereby able to penetrate genuine reality; through this ability to penetrate genuine reality, I am thereby able to give rise to weariness; from this weariness arises detachment, and from this detachment I attain liberation; through attaining this liberation, every root of goodness gathered before and after this attainment becomes a genuine field of merit, and only then do I attain realization of this very dharma of transcendence.
"'Every lord' refers to every buddha, every world-honored one — at the very moment of planting every root of goodness, this is the very greatest cause and condition of all."
This person further reflects: "How, then, might I swiftly accomplish every reasonable matter?" This person thereupon knows and beholds for themselves: "Should I gather and bind my own mind to a single place, knowing precisely where it rests upon its object, constantly delighting in meditative concentration."
This person, being able to bind their own mind to a single place, is thereby able to attain samādhi. Through attaining this samādhi, every reasonable matter is thereby able to be accomplished. As the sūtra states: "One who attains meditative concentration is able to know truly, and see truly. Should a person already practice binding their own mind in this way, they thereby swiftly enter samādhi. Through swiftly entering samādhi, they are called one of meditative concentration, one of constant concentration."
Should one be able to cultivate and gather every dharma in this way, this itself constitutes making offering and showing reverence to every buddha. Should a person make offering to the Buddha merely through incense, flowers, and the fourfold material offering, this cannot be called genuine offering to the Buddha. Should one be able, with a single-pointed mind, free of heedlessness, to draw near to and cultivate the very noble path, this alone is called making offering and showing reverence to every buddha. As the sūtra states: "At the very moment of entering parinirvāṇa, the Buddha told Ānanda: though the devas rain down mandārava flowers and powdered sandalwood incense, and perform heavenly music, this cannot be called making offering and showing reverence to the Thus Come One. Ānanda! Should a monk, a nun, a layman, or a laywoman, with a single-pointed mind, free of heedlessness, draw near to and cultivate the very noble dharma, this alone is called genuine offering to the Buddha. It is for this reason, Ānanda, that you ought to cultivate and study this genuine offering to the Buddha."
Every merit such as this belongs entirely to the person of middling power.
As for "delighting in going forth from home, a wholesome mind never sinking or shrinking": this is the very highest power, able to attain buddhahood; the very lowest power becomes a śrāvaka; it is for this reason that the person of middling power becomes a pratyekabuddha. Delighting in going forth from home, one is thereby able to accomplish every merit.
And why is this so? Should one remain within the household, one is unable to attain few desires and few affairs, unable to remain apart in both body and mind, and further unable to attain meditative concentration. Should one's own mind sink and shrink, remaining impure, one is unable to accomplish every matter, unable to know this exceedingly profound dharma of causal origination, unable to realize transcendence, and unable to make a genuine offering, in accordance with the Dharma, to every buddha.
A sentient being such as this, of middling power, reflects thus: "I, a person of middling power, constantly delight in going forth from home, my own mind never sinking or shrinking. Every meritorious matter I wish for shall come to me naturally, of its own accord." They further reflect: "What fruit does this very middling power delight in attaining?" They thereupon know that they shall attain the very fruit of wisdom. And why is this so? Because wisdom is able to serve as this very illumination. As the sūtra states: "Monks! Among every radiance whatsoever, the very radiance of wisdom is supreme."
They further reflect: "This very radiance of wisdom I delight in — how, then, shall I attain it?" They thereupon know that they shall come either from two of the excellent places, or from three of the excellent places.
"The two excellent places" have already been explained above. "The three excellent places" refers to truth, relinquishment, and tranquil cessation; or truth, relinquishment, and wisdom; or truth, tranquil cessation, and wisdom.
It is for this reason: "I ought now to cultivate and gather excellent places such as these. Having cultivated and gathered them, I shall attain this very radiance of wisdom. The very wisdom I have wished for shall naturally arrive of its own accord." A mark such as this, and a cultivation of the dharmas that assist the path such as this — these very ten wholesome paths are able to bring one to the ground of the pratyekabuddha.
The pratyekabuddha's own reasoning here — withdrawing from ordinary engagement with sentient beings while still wishing to benefit them, and resolving this tension by becoming "a field of merit" that others may draw near to and give to — offers a genuinely coherent account of how solitary practice can remain oriented toward others without direct social engagement: benefit flows not through teaching or companionship but through the very presence of a purified practitioner worth making offerings to. This differs sharply from the bodhisattva's own resolution described just before it, entering the clamor of the crowd directly rather than working around it — the same underlying wish to benefit sentient beings, expressed through two structurally opposite strategies.
The Bodhisattva's Own Practice Surpasses Both Lesser Vehicles
大乘品第三十
問曰:如仁已說,十善道能令人至聲聞、辟支佛地,十善業道復令何等眾生至於佛地?
答曰:所行十善道,勝於二種人,無量希有修,勝一切世間。
發堅善二願,成大悲無礙,善受行方便,忍辱諸苦惱。
不捨諸眾生,深愛諸佛慧,於佛力自在,樂盡遍行者。
能破邪見意,愛護佛正法,健堪受精進,堅心化眾生。
不貪著自樂,及無量身命,一切事中上,所作無過咎。
一切種清淨,一切勝處來,善道令此人,至十力世尊。
所修十善道勝二種人者,菩薩修十善道,於求聲聞、辟支佛者為轉勝。
轉勝者,一心修行、常修行,為自利故修行,為他利故修行,清淨修行。
一心行者,用意修行;常修行者,不中休息。
為自利故修行者,生天人因緣、泥洹因緣。
為他利修行者,菩薩修行十善道,迴向利安一切眾生故。以是因緣故,能度過算數眾生。
清淨修行者,不壞行、無雜行、不濁行、自在行、具足行、不貪著行,智者所讚行。
壞者,有行有不行,與此相違,名不壞行。
雜者,自不作令他作,與此相違,名不雜行。
濁者,與煩惱罪業合行,與此相違,名為不濁行。
自在者,破戒人為田業、妻子、財物所繫,不得自在;持戒者,無如是事,隨意自在,無所繫屬。
具足者,盡行一切大小戒,遮止諸煩惱,常憶念守護,為禪定作因緣,迴向佛道,能令同真際法性,是名具足。
不貪著者,不向世間不取戒相自高卑他。
智者所讚者,聲聞法中不隨生死,但為涅槃故,名智者所讚;此大乘法中,尚不迴向聲聞、辟支佛乘,何況生死!但向阿耨多羅三藐三菩提,是名智者所讚十善道。
The Great Vehicle Chapter
Question: As you yourself have already explained, the ten wholesome paths are able to bring a person to the ground of the śrāvaka or the pratyekabuddha — what kind of sentient being, then, do these very ten wholesome karmic paths bring to the very ground of buddhahood?
Answer: "One's own practice of the ten wholesome paths surpasses both of these two kinds of person, this immeasurable, rare and marvelous cultivation surpassing every world.
"Giving rise to a firm vow and a good vow together, accomplishing great compassion unobstructed, skillfully receiving and practicing skillful means, patiently enduring every suffering and affliction.
"Never abandoning any sentient being, deeply loving the wisdom of every buddha, delighting in exhaustively practicing every buddha's own power and mastery.
"Able to break through every wrong intent, cherishing and protecting the Buddha's own true Dharma, valiantly bearing diligent effort, a firm mind in teaching and transforming sentient beings.
"Never craving one's own pleasure, nor one's own immeasurable body and life, foremost in every matter, whatever is done free of any fault.
"Pure in every respect, coming from every excellent place — this wholesome path brings a person such as this to the World-Honored One of the ten powers."
As for "one's own practice of the ten wholesome paths surpassing both of these two kinds of person": the bodhisattva's own practice of the ten wholesome paths grows ever more supreme beyond that of one who seeks the śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha vehicle.
As for "growing ever more supreme": practicing with a single-pointed mind, constantly practicing, practicing for the sake of one's own benefit, practicing for the sake of another's benefit, and practicing in purity.
"Practicing with a single-pointed mind" refers to practicing with one's own intent fully applied; "constantly practicing" refers to never resting midway.
"Practicing for the sake of one's own benefit" refers to the very cause and condition of rebirth among humans and devas, and the very cause and condition of nirvāṇa.
"Practicing for the sake of another's benefit" refers to the bodhisattva's own practice of the ten wholesome paths, dedicating it toward the benefit and peace of every sentient being. Through this very cause and condition, they are able to liberate sentient beings beyond any count.
"Practicing in purity" refers to conduct that is never broken, never mixed, never turbid, free and unhindered, complete and thorough, and free of craving attachment, conduct praised by the wise.
"Broken" refers to practicing at times and not practicing at other times; contrary to this is called unbroken conduct.
"Mixed" refers to never doing something oneself, yet causing another to do it; contrary to this is called unmixed conduct.
"Turbid" refers to conduct joined together with the afflictions and offensive karma; contrary to this is called untarnished conduct.
"Free and unhindered" refers to how one who has broken the precepts is bound by their own field and estate, their own spouse and children, and their own wealth, unable to attain this very freedom; one who upholds the precepts has no such entanglement, remaining free and unhindered exactly as they wish, bound to nothing whatsoever.
"Complete and thorough" refers to fully practicing every major and minor precept, restraining every affliction, constantly holding it in mind and guarding it, making it the very cause and condition of meditative concentration, dedicating it toward the path to buddhahood, able to cause it to accord with the very true nature of reality itself — this is called complete and thorough.
"Free of craving attachment" refers to never turning toward this world, and never grasping at the very mark of the precepts to exalt oneself while demeaning another.
"Praised by the wise" refers to, within the śrāvaka's own dharma, never following birth and death, seeking only nirvāṇa — this alone is called praised by the wise; within this Great Vehicle's own dharma, one does not even dedicate this practice toward the śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha vehicle, let alone toward birth and death itself! Directing it only toward unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening — this alone is called the ten wholesome paths praised by the wise.
This chapter's own opening verse names roughly two dozen distinct qualities in rapid succession — vow, compassion, skillful means, patience, non-abandonment, love of wisdom, mastery, breaking wrong views, guarding the Dharma, valor, capacity, diligence, firm resolve, freedom from craving, foremost conduct, faultlessness, and purity — each of which the prose that follows will unpack one at a time, typically through its own fivefold analysis. The scale of this undertaking mirrors the treatise's own earlier account of the forty unshared dharmas: rather than claim the bodhisattva's superiority through a single sweeping statement, the text builds it up through an exhaustive accumulation of specific, nameable distinctions.
Five Kinds of Immeasurable Cultivation
問曰:修有何相,名為善修?
答曰:以無量希有修十善道,勝一切世間,是名善修。
問曰:云何菩薩以此修勝一切世間?
答曰:諸菩薩以五事修故,勝一切世間:一、願,二、堅心,三、深心,四、善清淨,五、方便。
願者,菩薩所行願,一切凡夫人及聲聞、辟支佛人所無;以是故,菩薩所行願,勝一切世間。如《大智經》〈毘摩羅達多女問〉中,佛因目揵連說:「菩薩從初發願乃至道場,能為一切世間天及人作福田,又勝一切聲聞、辟支佛。」
又如《淨毘尼》中,摩訶迦葉於佛前說:「世尊善說希有!所謂菩薩,初一發願勝一切聲聞、辟支佛。」
又如〈偈〉中說:「菩薩初發心,與大慈悲合,為於無上道,即是心為勝,是故以此願,住於世間上。」
堅心者,菩薩於諸苦惱,所謂活地獄、黑繩地獄、合會地獄、小叫喚地獄、大叫喚地獄、小炙地獄、大炙地獄、阿鼻地獄、沸屎、劍林、灰河、阿浮陀、尼羅浮陀、阿波簸、阿羅邏、休休、欝鉢羅、拘勿陀、須曼那、分陀利、鉢頭摩、寒熱地獄中種種拷掠。如是苦惱,畜生、餓鬼、阿修羅、人、天,共相食噉互相恐怖,飢餓穀貴,從天退失。慳妬瞋惱,恩愛別離,怨憎合會,生老病死憂悲惱等。此六道中,所有諸苦若見若聞若受,修十善道,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提時,心終不壞,以是故此菩薩以堅心修十善道,勝一切世間。如說:地獄及畜生,餓鬼阿修羅,天人六趣苦,不能動其心。
是故諸菩薩,以此堅固心,所修十善道,勝一切世間。
深心者,大心、用心、愛心、念心,諸菩薩以如是等心修十善道,勝一切世間,除諸佛世尊及久行菩薩。如說:深心及用心,利益世間心,菩薩以是心,勝一切世間。
善清淨者,菩薩修十善業道三種清淨,餘人所無;以是故,勝一切世間。如說:菩薩人中寶,具深心淨心,以是善法力,世間所不及。
方便者,菩薩以方便力,修於善法,餘人所無;是故勝一切世間無量修者。
菩薩以五因緣故,名無量修:一、時無量,二、善根無量,三、緣無量,四、究竟無量,五、迴向無量。
時無量者,謂菩薩修行善業道,過於時量,時量過故,所修善業道亦無量,是故勝一切世間。如說:諸菩薩師子,所修善業道,過諸算數時,故修善最勝。
善根無量者,諸菩薩修無量無邊善根,從是善根所修善業道亦無量,是故勝一切世間。如大乘法中《淨毘尼經》:佛告迦葉:「譬如生酥,滿四大海,菩薩有為善根資糧亦如是,是福德迴向無為智。」則大利益一切眾生,是故菩薩雖處有為,能勝一切世間。如說:為一切眾生,及求佛道故,善根則無量,以是勝世間。
緣無量者,菩薩不緣有量眾生故修集善根。而所修善根,不言為利益若干眾生,菩薩但緣一切眾生故修集善根,是故菩薩緣無量眾生所修善業道亦無量,勝一切世間。如《淨毘尼經》中:佛告諸天子:「如大菩薩薄有慈悲心,求利益他,是心能令無量眾生得利樂。深發心菩薩勤行精進亦如是,能教化無量阿僧祇眾生,令得涅槃樂。」如說:菩薩無量善,功德自莊嚴,皆為度眾生,無量之大苦。
究竟無量者,初地中為發願故,已說十究竟,是究竟無量故,菩薩所修善業道亦無量,是故勝一切世間。如說:菩薩修善道,從十究竟生,是故勝一切,無有能壞者。
迴向無量者,如初地中說,菩薩迴向果報無量,以是迴向果報無量,所修善業亦無量,是故勝一切世間。如說:以無量因緣,修於善業道,迴向佛乘故,是以為最上。
Question: What mark does this very cultivation possess, that it is called "skillful cultivation"?
Answer: Through this immeasurable, rare and marvelous cultivation of the ten wholesome paths, surpassing every world — this alone is called skillful cultivation.
Question: How, then, does the bodhisattva, through this very cultivation, surpass every world?
Answer: Every bodhisattva, through five matters of cultivation, surpasses every world: first, vow; second, a firm mind; third, a deep mind; fourth, skillful purity; fifth, skillful means.
As for "vow": the very vow the bodhisattva practices is possessed by no ordinary being, nor by any śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha whatsoever — it is for this reason that the very vow the bodhisattva practices surpasses every world. As within the Great Wisdom Sūtra's own Questions of Vimaladattā, the Buddha, addressing Maudgalyāyana, states: "The bodhisattva, from the very first giving rise of this vow right up until the seat of awakening, is able to serve as a field of merit for every deva and human throughout every world, and further surpasses every śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha."
And further, as within the Pure Vinaya, Mahākāśyapa states before the Buddha: "World-Honored One, how well you have spoken of this rare and marvelous matter! Namely, the bodhisattva's own very first giving rise of this vow already surpasses every śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha."
And further, as the verse states: "The bodhisattva's own very first giving rise of this mind, joined together with great loving-kindness and compassion, directed toward the unsurpassed path — this very mind is itself supreme; it is for this reason that, through this very vow, one abides above every world."
As for "a firm mind": the bodhisattva, toward every suffering and affliction — namely, the Reviving hell, the Black-Rope hell, the Crushing hell, the Lesser Wailing hell, the Great Wailing hell, the Lesser Roasting hell, the Great Roasting hell, the Avīci hell, the Boiling Excrement hell, the Sword-Forest hell, the River of Ashes hell, and the cold hells of Arbuda, Nirarbuda, Aṭaṭa, Hahava, Huhuva, Utpala, Padma, Mahāpadma, Puṇḍarīka, and Mahāpuṇḍarīka, and every kind of torture within the hot and cold hells — toward suffering and affliction such as this, and toward the animal realm, the realm of hungry ghosts, the asuras, humans, and devas, all devouring one another and terrifying one another, famine and the scarcity of grain, and decline and loss even among the devas; stinginess, envy, anger, and affliction, separation from what one loves, encountering what one hates, birth, old age, sickness, death, sorrow, grief, and affliction, and every other such matter — toward every suffering found within these six destinies, whether seen, heard, or personally undergone, while practicing the ten wholesome paths for the sake of unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening, this very mind never once breaks. It is for this reason that this bodhisattva, through this very firm mind, in practicing the ten wholesome paths, surpasses every world. As it is said: "Hell, and the animal realm, the hungry ghosts and the asuras, the suffering of the six destinies of devas and humans alike — none of this is able to shake this very mind.
"It is for this reason that every bodhisattva, through this very firm and resolute mind, in their own practice of the ten wholesome paths, surpasses every world."
As for "a deep mind": a great mind, an applied mind, a loving mind, a mindful mind — every bodhisattva, through minds such as these, in practicing the ten wholesome paths, surpasses every world, apart only from every buddha, every world-honored one, and every bodhisattva of long practice. As it is said: "A deep mind and an applied mind, a mind that benefits this world — the bodhisattva, through this very mind, surpasses every world."
As for "skillful purity": the bodhisattva, in practicing the ten wholesome karmic paths, possesses this threefold purity, which no other being possesses — it is for this reason that they surpass every world. As it is said: "The bodhisattva is the very jewel among humanity, complete with a deep and pure mind; through the very power of this wholesome dharma, this world is unable to match them."
As for "skillful means": the bodhisattva, through the power of skillful means, practices the wholesome dharma in a way no other being can — it is for this reason that they surpass every world's own immeasurable cultivation.
The bodhisattva, through five causes and conditions, is called one of immeasurable cultivation: first, immeasurable time; second, immeasurable roots of goodness; third, immeasurable objects; fourth, immeasurable ultimacy; fifth, immeasurable dedication.
As for "immeasurable time": this refers to the bodhisattva's own practice of the wholesome karmic path exceeding every measure of time — since this measure of time is exceeded, the wholesome karmic path thereby practiced is likewise immeasurable, and it is for this reason that they surpass every world. As it is said: "Every bodhisattva, a very lion among beings, in their own practice of the wholesome karmic path, exceeds every count of time — it is for this reason that this practice of what is wholesome is the very foremost of all."
As for "immeasurable roots of goodness": every bodhisattva cultivates immeasurable, boundless roots of goodness, and, from these very roots of goodness, the wholesome karmic path thereby practiced is likewise immeasurable — it is for this reason that they surpass every world. As the Pure Vinaya Sūtra, within the Great Vehicle's own teaching, states: the Buddha told Kāśyapa: "Just as freshly churned butter might fill the four great oceans, the bodhisattva's own conditioned roots of goodness and provisions are likewise so — this very merit is dedicated toward unconditioned wisdom." This thereby brings great benefit to every sentient being — it is for this reason that the bodhisattva, though dwelling within the conditioned, is able to surpass every world. As it is said: "For the sake of every sentient being, and for the sake of seeking the path to buddhahood, these very roots of goodness are thereby immeasurable — through this, they surpass this world."
As for "immeasurable objects": the bodhisattva does not take a merely limited number of sentient beings as their own object in cultivating and gathering roots of goodness. Whatever roots of goodness are thereby cultivated are never said to be for the benefit of only so many sentient beings — the bodhisattva takes every sentient being whatsoever as their own object in cultivating and gathering roots of goodness; it is for this reason that the wholesome karmic path the bodhisattva practices, taking immeasurable sentient beings as its own object, is likewise immeasurable, surpassing every world. As within the Pure Vinaya Sūtra: the Buddha told the sons of the devas: "Just as a great bodhisattva, possessing even a slight mind of loving-kindness and compassion, seeking to benefit another, this very mind is able to cause immeasurable sentient beings to attain benefit and joy — a bodhisattva of deep aspiration, diligently applying effort, is likewise so, able to teach and transform immeasurable asaṃkhyeya sentient beings, causing them to attain the joy of nirvāṇa." As it is said: "The bodhisattva's own immeasurable wholesomeness, this merit adorning themselves — all of it is for the sake of liberating sentient beings from their own immeasurable, great suffering."
As for "immeasurable ultimacy": within the first ground, for the sake of this very vow, the ten kinds of ultimacy have already been explained; since this very ultimacy is immeasurable, the wholesome karmic path the bodhisattva thereby practices is likewise immeasurable — it is for this reason that they surpass every world. As it is said: "The bodhisattva's own practice of the wholesome path arises from these ten kinds of ultimacy — it is for this reason that they surpass all, with none whatsoever able to destroy it."
As for "immeasurable dedication": as explained within the first ground, the bodhisattva's own dedication of this fruit and recompense is immeasurable; through this very immeasurable dedication of fruit and recompense, the wholesome karma thereby practiced is likewise immeasurable — it is for this reason that they surpass every world. As it is said: "Through immeasurable causes and conditions, practicing this wholesome karmic path, dedicating it toward the buddha vehicle — it is through this that it becomes the very foremost of all."
The catalogue of hells here — the eight great hot hells named in sequence, followed by the eight cold hells with their own increasingly severe Sanskrit-derived names (Arbuda through Mahāpuṇḍarīka, each traditionally describing the progressive freezing and cracking of the body) — is among the most complete such lists in this treatise, and its function is rhetorical as much as cosmological: the firm mind that never breaks even confronted with every one of these specific horrors, named individually rather than gestured at collectively, demonstrates a resolve this treatise wants measured against the fullest possible weight of what could shake it.
Five Reasons for Being Rare, and Five for a Firm Vow
希有者,諸菩薩修善道,以五因緣故名希有:一、堪受故,二、精進故,三、心堅故,四、慧故,五、果故。
堪受者,我當作天人中尊一切智慧者,能如是堪受,是為希有。
若人以指舉三千大千世界,於虛空中令住百千萬劫,是事可成,不足為難。若發願言「我當作佛」,是為希有甚難。如說:為無量佛法,立誓當作佛,是人無有比,何況有勝者。
精進者,多有人堪受發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心,不能精進行六波羅蜜。若人以堪受發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心,能精進行六波羅蜜,是名實堪受無量功德。精進希有故,所修善業道亦希有,如說:希有大精進,凡人念已怖,菩薩實行之,何得不希有。
心堅者,有人發精進心修集佛道,若有障礙心不堅固則不能成;是故發精進安住希有,堅心中則成其事。壞諸障礙,是為菩薩修善業道第一希有,如說:若人無堅心,尚不成小事,何況成佛道,世間無上者。
慧者,是堪受、精進、堅心皆以慧為根本,是故菩薩慧為第一希有,能生如是堪受、精進、堅心故,以慧為希有;以慧為希有故,所修善業亦希有。如說:如有人堪受,欲得於佛法,精進得堅心,皆以慧為本。
果者,修善業故得無量無邊諸佛之法,是故希有。如說:行此善道得,無量功德力,為諸眾生師,誰聞而不行。
堅願者,菩薩以五因緣故名為堅願:一、於聲聞乘心不轉,二、於辟支佛乘不轉,三、於外道事不轉,四、於一切魔事不轉,五、無因緣不轉。如說:聞二乘解脫,何不為此道?
若未入於位,則失菩薩道。
又貪外道事,或為魔所壞,或復無因緣,自捨菩薩道。
As for "rare and marvelous": every bodhisattva, in practicing the wholesome path, is called rare and marvelous through five causes and conditions: first, capacity; second, diligence; third, firmness of mind; fourth, wisdom; fifth, fruit.
As for "capacity": "I shall become the very honored one among devas and humans, the omniscient one" — being able to bear such a claim as this is itself what is rare and marvelous.
Should a person, with a single finger, lift an entire great trichiliocosm, and cause it to remain suspended within empty space for hundreds of thousands of myriads of kalpas — this very matter, though it might be accomplished, is not sufficiently difficult to be remarkable. Should one give rise to this vow, saying "I shall become a buddha," this is rare and exceedingly difficult indeed. As it is said: "For the sake of every buddha's own immeasurable Dharma, establishing this very vow to become a buddha — this person has no equal whatsoever, let alone anyone more supreme."
As for "diligence": there are many who are capable of giving rise to the mind of unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening, and yet unable to diligently practice the six pāramitās. Should a person be capable of giving rise to this very mind of unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening, and further able diligently to practice the six pāramitās, this alone is called genuinely bearing immeasurable merit. Since this very diligence is rare and marvelous, the wholesome karmic path thereby practiced is likewise rare and marvelous, as it is said: "This rare and marvelous great diligence — an ordinary person, merely thinking of it, already feels dread; the bodhisattva genuinely practices it — how could this not be rare and marvelous?"
As for "firmness of mind": there are those who give rise to a diligent mind, cultivating and gathering the path to buddhahood, and yet, should some obstruction arise, their own mind, not being firm, is thereby unable to accomplish it; it is for this reason that giving rise to diligence and securely abiding within this very rare and marvelous state, only within a firm mind is this very matter accomplished. Breaking through every obstruction — this is the bodhisattva's own very foremost rare and marvelous quality in practicing the wholesome karmic path, as it is said: "Should a person lack a firm mind, they cannot accomplish even the smallest matter — how much less, then, accomplish buddhahood, the very unsurpassed of this world!"
As for "wisdom": this very capacity, diligence, and firmness of mind all take wisdom as their own root — it is for this reason that the bodhisattva's own wisdom is the very foremost rare and marvelous quality, since it is able to give rise to this very capacity, diligence, and firmness of mind, wisdom is thereby rare and marvelous; and since wisdom is rare and marvelous, the wholesome karma thereby practiced is likewise rare and marvelous. As it is said: "Just as a person's own capacity, wishing to attain the Buddhadharma, and their own diligence in attaining a firm mind, all take wisdom as their own root."
As for "fruit": through practicing this wholesome karma, one attains every buddha's own immeasurable, boundless dharma — it is for this reason that this is rare and marvelous. As it is said: "Practicing this wholesome path, one attains this immeasurable power of merit, becoming a teacher for every sentient being — who, having heard of this, would fail to practice it?"
As for "a firm vow": the bodhisattva, through five causes and conditions, is called one of a firm vow: first, their own mind never turns toward the śrāvaka vehicle; second, never turns toward the pratyekabuddha vehicle; third, never turns toward the matters of the outside paths; fourth, never turns toward any activity of māra whatsoever; fifth, never turns away without any cause or condition. As it is said: "Having heard of the liberation of the two lesser vehicles, why should one not instead practice this very path?
"Should one not yet have entered this very station of certainty, one might well lose the bodhisattva's own path.
"Or, craving the matters of the outside paths, or being destroyed by māra, or, further still, without any cause or condition whatsoever, relinquishing the bodhisattva's own path of one's own accord."
The comparison drawn here — an act of supernormal power so vast it could suspend an entire trichiliocosm in space for hundreds of thousands of kalpas, dismissed as "not sufficiently difficult to be remarkable" against the mere vow to become a buddha — makes a deliberate point about where this treatise locates genuine difficulty. Physical feats, however cosmically scaled, remain within the category of things that can simply be accomplished through sufficient power; a vow that commits an entire future across immeasurable time to the benefit of others is a different order of undertaking altogether, one that power alone, without this specific resolve, could never produce.
A Good Vow, and Great Compassion Unobstructed
善願者,菩薩以五因緣故名善願:一、先籌量得失者,二、知道者,三、知道果者,四、不貪惜自樂者,五、欲滅眾生大苦者。
如是作願,名為善願,如說:先見世過患,佛道大利益,知行無上道,及其無量果。
捨自寂滅樂,欲除眾生苦,發是無比願,為諸佛所讚。
大悲、無礙者,以五因緣故,知菩薩有大悲:一、利安無量眾生故,於資生之物不生貪惜;二、不惜身;三、不惜命;四、不觀時久遠;五、於怨、親、中,等心利益。如說:內外所愛物,於中不貪著,為利眾生故,及捨於身命。
生死無量劫,猶如一眴頃,怨親中平等,名菩薩大悲。
無礙者,菩薩以五因緣故,悲心有礙:一、以地獄苦故,二、以畜生苦故,三、以餓鬼苦故,四、以惡人無返復故,五、以生死過惡故。
若此五事不障其心,是名無礙、大悲。如說:第一地獄苦,畜生餓鬼苦,惡人及生死,不障名大悲。
菩薩能如是,佛說無礙悲。
As for "a good vow": the bodhisattva, through five causes and conditions, is called one of a good vow: first, first weighing carefully what is gained and what is lost; second, knowing the path; third, knowing the fruit of the path; fourth, never craving or begrudging one's own pleasure; fifth, wishing to extinguish sentient beings' own great suffering.
Making a vow in this way is called a good vow, as it is said: "First beholding this world's own faults and afflictions, and the great benefit of the path to buddhahood, knowing the practice of this unsurpassed path, and its own immeasurable fruit.
"Relinquishing one's own peaceful, tranquil pleasure, wishing to remove sentient beings' own suffering, giving rise to this vow beyond compare — this is what every buddha praises."
As for "great compassion, unobstructed": through five causes and conditions, one knows that the bodhisattva possesses great compassion: first, for the sake of benefiting and bringing peace to immeasurable sentient beings, never giving rise to craving or reluctance toward one's own article of livelihood; second, never sparing one's own body; third, never sparing one's own life; fourth, never regarding the vast span of time required; fifth, holding an equal mind of benefit toward the hostile, the intimate, and the neutral alike. As it is said: "Toward every beloved object, whether internal or external, holding no craving attachment whatsoever, for the sake of benefiting sentient beings, and further relinquishing one's own body and life.
"Undergoing birth and death across immeasurable kalpas, as though but the span of a single blink, holding an equal mind toward the hostile, the intimate, and the neutral alike — this is what is called the bodhisattva's own great compassion."
As for "unobstructed": the bodhisattva, through five causes and conditions, might find this very mind of compassion obstructed: first, through the very suffering of hell; second, through the very suffering of the animal realm; third, through the very suffering of the hungry ghosts; fourth, through an evil person's own failure to repay a kindness; fifth, through the very faults and evils of birth and death itself.
Should these very five matters fail to obstruct this mind, this alone is called unobstructed, great compassion. As it is said: "The very foremost suffering of hell, the suffering of the animal realm and the hungry ghosts, the evil person, and birth and death itself — none of these obstructing it is what is called great compassion.
"The bodhisattva, being able to remain so, is what the Buddha calls unobstructed compassion."
Naming the five specific things capable of obstructing compassion — the sheer horror of hell, the degradation of the animal and ghost realms, an ingrate's own failure to reciprocate kindness, and the general futility of birth and death itself — before declaring compassion genuinely unobstructed only when none of these five succeed, gives this quality a testable content rather than leaving it as an unqualified ideal: a compassion that would flinch before witnessing hell's own suffering, or curdle when a rescued person shows no gratitude, has not yet met this treatise's own bar for "great compassion, unobstructed."
Skillful Means: Knowing Place, Time, and Another's Mind
善受行方便者,菩薩以五因緣故,名善受行方便:一、知方時,二、知他心所樂,三、知轉入道,四、知事次第,五、知引導眾生。
知方時者,知是方處,應以如是說法;知是時中,應以如是說法。知是方處,應以如是因緣度眾生;知是時中,應以如是因緣度眾生。菩薩先知是事已,隨順而行。如說:若以世尊意,為他人解說,先應知二事,後隨時方說。
若不知時方,而欲說佛意,不得所為利,而更有過咎。
知他心所樂者,知他深心為在何事?為何所樂?菩薩先知已,入眾生所知、所樂,隨順起發度脫方便,如是則不虛也。如說:菩薩知眾生,深心難測意,先知其意已,漸令住佛意。
遍知世間事,自利亦利他,若能如是者,說名善方便。
知轉入道者,能轉外道、凡夫意,令入佛道;亦轉眾生惡事,令住善事中;亦知轉聲聞、辟支佛道,令入大乘中;已在佛法者,不令入外道。先知是事已,隨順而修行,如說:若人令眾生,遠離外道法,及諸不善者,入佛上寂滅。
若知諸眾生,上中下之心,知已能引導,是名善方便。
As for "skillfully receiving and practicing skillful means": the bodhisattva, through five causes and conditions, is called one who skillfully receives and practices skillful means: first, knowing the proper place and time; second, knowing what another delights in within their own mind; third, knowing how to convert others onto the path; fourth, knowing the proper sequence of a matter; fifth, knowing how to guide sentient beings.
As for "knowing the proper place and time": knowing that, within this very place, one ought to expound the Dharma in just this way; knowing that, within this very time, one ought to expound the Dharma in just this way. Knowing that, within this very place, one ought to liberate sentient beings through just this cause and condition; knowing that, within this very time, one ought to liberate sentient beings through just this cause and condition. The bodhisattva, first knowing this very matter, thereupon practices accordingly. As it is said: "Should one wish to explain the World-Honored One's own intent for the sake of another, one ought first to know these two matters, and only afterward speak according to the proper time and place.
"Should one fail to know the proper time and place, and yet wish to expound the Buddha's own intent, one fails to obtain the very benefit intended, and further incurs a fault in doing so."
As for "knowing what another delights in within their own mind": knowing where another's own deep mind truly rests, and what they genuinely delight in. The bodhisattva, first knowing this, thereupon enters into what sentient beings themselves already know and delight in, and, according with this, gives rise to the very skillful means of liberation — practiced in this way, this is never in vain. As it is said: "The bodhisattva knows sentient beings' own deep mind, an intent difficult to fathom; first knowing this very intent, they gradually cause it to abide within the Buddha's own intent instead.
"Fully knowing every matter of this world, benefiting both themselves and others — should one be able to do this, this alone is called skillful means."
As for "knowing how to convert others onto the path": being able to convert the very intent of the outside path and the ordinary being, causing them to enter the path to buddhahood; and further converting sentient beings' own evil conduct, causing them to abide within wholesome conduct instead; and further knowing how to convert the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha path, causing them to enter the Great Vehicle instead; and, for one already within the Buddhadharma, never causing them to enter an outside path. First knowing this very matter, one thereupon cultivates and practices accordingly, as it is said: "Should a person cause sentient beings to depart far from the dharma of the outside paths, and every other unwholesome thing, entering the Buddha's own supreme tranquil cessation instead.
"Should one know every sentient being's own superior, middling, or inferior mind, and, knowing this, be able to guide them accordingly — this alone is called skillful means."
This section opens the treatise's own account of skillful means specifically as a teacher's craft, distinct from the compassion and firm vow discussed in the sections before it: knowing the right place and time, reading another's own genuine inclination, and knowing how to redirect a mind already moving in some direction rather than simply opposing it. The next section continues into the fourth and fifth of these five — the proper sequence for teaching each vehicle in turn, laid out at considerable length — and the specific means of guiding different kinds of listener.
Skillful Means Continued: The Proper Sequence of Teaching Each Vehicle
知事次第者:如聲聞乘中,初說布施、次持戒、次生天、次五欲過患、次在家苦惱、次出家利樂、次說苦諦、次集諦、次滅諦、次道諦、次須陀洹果、次斯陀含果、次阿那含果、次阿羅漢果、次不壞解脫、次說諸無礙。
辟支佛乘中亦說:我、我所物,多有過患、捨此過患之物得大利益;在家為過惡、出家為利益;次眾鬧亂語為過惡、獨行為善利;聚落為過惡、阿練若處為善利;厭離多欲多事、樂於少欲少事;守護諸根、飲食知節、初夜後夜隨時覺悟、觀緣取相、樂住空舍、貴於持戒禪定智慧,不現奇異令他歡喜,但自利益樂於深法、不隨他智。
如大乘中次第者,初說檀波羅蜜、次尸羅波羅蜜、羼提波羅蜜、毘梨耶波羅蜜、禪波羅蜜、般若波羅蜜。
初說諦勝處,次說捨勝處、滅勝處、慧勝處。
復次,初讚歎發菩提心、次十種願、次十究竟、次讚歎遠離退失菩提心法、次修集不退失菩提心法、次堅心精進、次堅固堪受、次堅誓。
復次,初說能得諸地法、次說能住諸地法、次說能得諸地底法、次說遠離諸地垢法、次說能作淨地法、次說諸地久住法、次說能到諸地邊法、次說能作不退失諸地法、次說諸地果、次說諸地果勢力。
復次,或初說歡喜地、次說離垢地、次說明地、次說炎地、次說難勝地、次說現前地、次說深遠地、次說不動地、次說善慧地、次說法雲地。如說:初施次持戒,果報得生天,無常在家過,出家為大利。
次無上四諦,斷結證四果,是方便次第,令人住初乘。
初說生死過,次說涅槃利,守護於諸根,持戒及禪定。
不隨他智慧,功德樂獨處,自依不依他,樂求自利樂。
亦不捨他人,深行頭陀法,其求中乘者,教法相如是。
以四十不共,說佛無量德,亦說菩薩時,一切所行法。
為利眾生故,次第說是法,自利及利他,說種種功德。
亦說諸佛子,所樂十種地,求於大乘者,如是次第度。
引導者,隨眾生所樂門,知是門已,以是門引導眾生,隨其所樂,任其勢力而令得度,如說:或有諸眾生,可以深經書,難事及工巧,呪術以愛語。
善說及資財,布施戒定慧,如是籌量已,引來入大乘。
或現於女身,引導諸男子,復現男子身,引導於女人。
示眾五欲樂,然後說欲過,而令一切人,得離於五欲。
善行是五事,是名菩薩善受行方便。
As for "knowing the proper sequence of a matter": as within the śrāvaka vehicle, first expounding giving, then the precepts, then rebirth among the devas, then the faults and afflictions of the five desires, then the suffering of household life, then the benefit and joy of going forth from home, then expounding the truth of suffering, then the truth of its origin, then the truth of its cessation, then the truth of the path, then the fruit of stream-entry, then the fruit of once-returning, then the fruit of non-returning, then the fruit of arhatship, then unbreakable liberation, then expounding every unobstructed dharma.
Within the pratyekabuddha vehicle, it is likewise expounded: that "self" and "what belongs to self" possess many faults and afflictions, and that relinquishing this very object of fault and affliction brings great benefit; that household life is a fault and evil, while going forth from home is a benefit; then that clamorous, disordered speech is a fault and evil, while solitary conduct is a genuine benefit; that the settlement is a fault and evil, while the forest hermitage is a genuine benefit; weariness and renunciation toward abundant desire and abundant affairs, delighting instead in few desires and few affairs; guarding every faculty, moderation in food and drink, awakening at the proper time in the first and last watch of the night, contemplating conditions and taking up their own mark, delighting in dwelling within an empty dwelling, valuing upholding the precepts, meditative concentration, and wisdom, never displaying anything extraordinary to please others, but benefiting only oneself, delighting in the profound dharma, and following no other's own wisdom.
As for the sequence within the Great Vehicle: first expounding the pāramitā of giving, then the pāramitā of moral discipline, the pāramitā of patient endurance, the pāramitā of diligent effort, the pāramitā of meditative concentration, and the pāramitā of wisdom.
First expounding the excellent place of truth, then expounding the excellent place of relinquishment, the excellent place of cessation, and the excellent place of wisdom.
Furthermore, first praising the giving rise of bodhicitta, then the ten kinds of vow, then the ten kinds of ultimacy, then praising departing far from the dharma of losing bodhicitta, then cultivating and gathering the dharma of never losing bodhicitta, then a firm mind and diligent effort, then firm and secure capacity, then a firm vow.
Furthermore, first expounding the dharma of attaining every ground, then expounding the dharma of abiding within every ground, then expounding the dharma of reaching the very depths of every ground, then expounding the dharma of departing from the defilement of every ground, then expounding the dharma of purifying every ground, then expounding the dharma of abiding long within every ground, then expounding the dharma of reaching the very border of every ground, then expounding the dharma of never retrogressing from every ground, then expounding the fruit of every ground, then expounding the very power of the fruit of every ground.
Furthermore, first expounding the Ground of Joy, then expounding the Ground Free of Defilement, then expounding the Ground of Radiance, then expounding the Ground of Blazing Wisdom, then expounding the Ground of Difficult Mastery, then expounding the Ground of Manifestation, then expounding the Far-Reaching Ground, then expounding the Immovable Ground, then expounding the Ground of Excellent Wisdom, then expounding the Ground of the Dharma Cloud. As it is said: "First giving, then upholding the precepts, this fruit and recompense attaining rebirth among the devas; impermanence, and the very faults of household life, while going forth from home brings great benefit.
"Then the unsurpassed four noble truths, severing the fetters and realizing the four fruits — this very sequence of skillful means causes a person to abide within the first vehicle.
"First expounding the very faults of birth and death, then expounding the benefit of nirvāṇa, guarding every faculty, upholding the precepts, and meditative concentration.
"Following no other's own wisdom, delighting in this merit of solitary dwelling, relying on oneself, never relying on another, delighting in seeking one's own benefit and joy.
"And yet never abandoning others, deeply practicing the dharma of ascetic observance — for one who seeks the middle vehicle, the very mark of this teaching's own dharma is exactly so.
"Through these forty unshared dharmas, expounding the Buddha's own immeasurable merit, and further expounding, during the bodhisattva's own lifetimes, every dharma practiced throughout.
"For the sake of benefiting sentient beings, expounding this very dharma in due sequence, benefiting both oneself and others, expounding every kind of merit.
"And further expounding every child of the Buddha's own delight in these ten kinds of ground — one who seeks the Great Vehicle is liberated in just this same sequence."
As for "guiding": according with whatever gateway sentient beings themselves delight in, and, knowing this very gateway, guiding sentient beings through this same gateway, according with what they themselves delight in, and, relying upon their own capacity, causing them to be liberated, as it is said: "There exist sentient beings who might be reached through profound scriptures, through difficult tasks and skilled crafts, through spells and incantations, or through kind speech.
"Through skillful discourse, and through material wealth, through giving, the precepts, concentration, and wisdom — having weighed all of this carefully, one draws them in, bringing them into the Great Vehicle.
"Or manifesting a woman's own body, to guide men accordingly; or further manifesting a man's own body, to guide women accordingly.
"Showing the crowd the very pleasure of the five desires, and only afterward expounding the fault of these desires, so as to cause every person to attain freedom from the five desires."
Skillfully practicing these five matters is what is called the bodhisattva's own skillful reception and practice of skillful means.
The passage on guiding "according to whatever gateway sentient beings themselves delight in" — including manifesting a woman's own body to guide men, or a man's own body to guide women — reflects a well-attested strand of Mahāyāna skillful-means literature in which a bodhisattva's own form is understood as itself provisional, adopted according to what will actually reach a given listener rather than fixed by any inherent necessity. Read alongside the treatise's own earlier account of Ugra's household teaching in Fascicle 7, and the graduated sequence for śrāvaka, pratyekabuddha, and bodhisattva teaching laid out immediately before it here, this closes the fivefold account of skillful means with its own most concrete illustration: a teacher's own outward form, no less than their own words, is itself an instrument shaped entirely by what the listener in front of them actually needs.
Bearing Suffering, Never Abandoning Anyone, and Delighting in Buddha-Wisdom
能忍苦惱者,若有人過算數劫於生死中能忍諸苦惱,十善業道能令此人住於阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。
問曰:一切人皆樂樂惡苦,是人云何能忍苦惱?
答曰:以五因緣故:一、樂無我,二、信樂空,三、籌量世法,四、觀業果報,五、念過算數劫唐受苦惱。如說:樂無我空法,又知業果報,利衰等八法,處世必應受。
亦念過去世,空受無量苦,何況為佛道,而當不受耶。
不捨於一切者,或有眾生第一弊惡,無有功德不可利益,菩薩於此,終不生捨心。
問曰:若是惡人不可度者,云何不捨?
答曰:以五因緣故:一、賤小人法故,二、貴大人法故,三、畏誑諸佛故,四、知恩故,五、為是世間事故出世間。如說:欲度眾生故,生心持重擔,於惡怨賊中,心常不應捨。
賤小貴大人,是小大差別,不應眾生中,愍憐心還息。
於諸急難中,無事而利益,擔於重擔時,而不中懈廢。
若發無上心,或有捨眾生,若自心疲苦,及惡人所害。
即為欺誑於,十方三世佛,諸佛世中尊,為利益眾生。
行種種苦行,修集於佛道,佛於恒沙劫,捨樂作福業。
若捨一惡人,則為背佛恩,是故惡眾生,不應於中捨。
若人於無量,阿僧祇劫中,所修集佛道,大悲為根本。
若以貪欲心,瞋恚怖畏心,捨一可度者,是斷佛道根。
是故善業道,能令不捨者至阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。
深樂佛慧者,若人深樂佛慧,便疾得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。以五因緣故,深樂佛慧:一、佛慧無與等,二、佛智能令人為世中尊,三、佛以佛智自度其身,四、佛智亦度他人,五、佛智是一切功德住處。如說:諸佛之智慧,天上及世間,一切無與等,何況而得勝。
諸佛以此智,為天阿修羅,一切世間人,恭敬而作禮。
佛以智自度,亦度於他人,若得是佛智,是功德藏者。
As for "able to bear suffering and affliction": should there exist a person able, across kalpas beyond any count, to bear every suffering and affliction within birth and death, these ten wholesome karmic paths are able to cause this person to abide within unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening.
Question: Every person delights in pleasure and despises suffering — how, then, is this person able to bear suffering and affliction?
Answer: Through five causes and conditions: first, delighting in non-self; second, holding faith and delight in emptiness; third, carefully weighing every worldly dharma; fourth, contemplating the fruit and recompense of karma; fifth, being mindful that, across kalpas beyond any count, suffering and affliction has already been undergone in vain. As it is said: "Delighting in the dharma of non-self and emptiness, and further knowing the fruit and recompense of karma, gain and loss and these eight worldly dharmas — dwelling within this world, one must necessarily undergo them.
"And further being mindful that, in ages past, one has already undergone immeasurable suffering in vain — how much more so, then, for the sake of the path to buddhahood, ought one not undergo it now!"
As for "never abandoning anyone whatsoever": there may exist a sentient being of the very worst corruption and evil, possessing no merit whatsoever, incapable of being benefited — the bodhisattva, toward this very being, never gives rise to a mind of abandonment.
Question: Should this evil person be incapable of being liberated, why, then, ought one never abandon them?
Answer: Through five causes and conditions: first, holding in contempt the dharma of the small person; second, valuing the dharma of the great person; third, dreading the very deception of every buddha; fourth, knowing gratitude; fifth, for the sake of this very worldly matter, transcending this world. As it is said: "For the sake of liberating sentient beings, giving rise to a mind that bears this heavy burden — toward every evil, hostile enemy, this mind ought never, under any circumstance, be abandoned.
"Holding the small person in contempt, and valuing the great person — this is itself the very distinction between the small and the great; one ought never, amid sentient beings, allow this mind of pity and compassion to cease and rest.
"Amid every urgent difficulty, bringing benefit though it costs nothing, bearing this heavy burden without ever growing indolent or abandoning it midway.
"Should one, having given rise to this unsurpassed mind, nonetheless abandon sentient beings, whether through one's own mind growing weary and pained, or through being harmed by an evil person —
"This is itself deceiving every buddha of the ten directions and the three times, every buddha, the very honored one of this world, existing entirely for the benefit of sentient beings.
"Practicing every kind of ascetic austerity, cultivating and gathering the path to buddhahood, the Buddha, across kalpas as numerous as the sands of the Ganges, relinquished his own pleasure to perform this very meritorious deed.
"Should one abandon even a single evil person, this is itself turning one's back on the Buddha's own kindness — it is for this reason that, toward even an evil sentient being, one ought never to abandon them.
"Should a person, across immeasurable asaṃkhyeya kalpas, cultivate and gather the path to buddhahood, great compassion is itself its own root.
"Should one, through a mind of craving, anger, or dread, abandon even a single being capable of being liberated, this is itself severing the very root of the path to buddhahood."
It is for this reason that this wholesome karmic path is able to bring one who never abandons anyone to unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening.
As for "deeply delighting in buddha-wisdom": should a person deeply delight in buddha-wisdom, they thereby swiftly attain unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. Through five causes and conditions, one deeply delights in buddha-wisdom: first, buddha-wisdom is without equal; second, buddha-wisdom is able to cause a person to become the very honored one of this world; third, the Buddha, through this very wisdom, liberates himself; fourth, buddha-wisdom likewise liberates every other person; fifth, buddha-wisdom is the very dwelling-place of every merit whatsoever. As it is said: "Every buddha's own wisdom, throughout the heavens and this world, has no equal whatsoever — how much less, then, could anything surpass it!
"Every buddha, through this very wisdom, is shown reverence and prostrated before by the devas, the asuras, and every person throughout this world.
"The Buddha, through this wisdom, liberates himself, and further liberates every other person — should one attain this very buddha-wisdom, this is itself the very treasury of every merit."
The argument against abandoning even the worst person turns, in its own closing lines, on an unusual ground: not merely that the person might still be reformed, but that abandoning them would itself constitute an act of ingratitude toward the Buddha, whose own kalpas of austerity were undertaken precisely for beings such as this one. The logic runs backward from the Buddha's own sacrifice to the present obligation it creates — refusing a single difficult being is reframed not as a private failure of patience but as a betrayal of a debt every bodhisattva already owes.
Delighting in the Ten Powers and Mastery
於諸佛力及自在法中樂盡遍行者,遍行名久習,一切行力名十種智力,自在名隨意所作。若人深樂佛十力及自在法中盡遍行,如是人阿耨多羅三藐三菩提不久疾得。以五因緣故樂盡遍行:一、尊重諸佛教勅,二、諸佛有大弟子故,三、身證一切法故,四、攝取墮落者,五、已墮落者能拔濟之。如說:尊佛教無比,佛子有四八,及以六三種,堪為諸天師。
以佛智慧眼,見諸法現前,逆惡斷善根,及諸破戒等。
如是墜落人,攝取而濟度,若人於佛力,自在中遍行。
涅槃及天福,常在此人手。
於是中,諸佛以佛力能為五種事:一、令眾生學聲聞乘,二、令眾生學辟支佛乘,三、令眾生學大乘法,四、力具足者令得解脫,五、力劣者令住世樂。如說:諸佛以神力,令厭離眾生,或令學小乘,中乘及大乘。
有力具足者,令其得解脫,力不具足者,生天令世樂。
自在者,諸佛於五事中自在:一、諸神通自在,二、自心中得自在,三、滅盡中得自在,四、聖如意中得自在,五、壽命中得自在。如說:飛行等自在,自心得自在,於滅禪定中,如入出自舍。
一切淨不淨,隨心而能轉,命不為他害,自緣亦無盡。
如是等自在,一切法亦爾,是故人師子,名為自在者。
As for "delighting in exhaustively and thoroughly practicing every buddha's own power and dharma of mastery": "thoroughly practicing" refers to long cultivation, and "the power of every conduct" refers to the ten kinds of power of wisdom; "mastery" refers to accomplishing whatever one wishes exactly as one wishes. Should a person deeply delight in the Buddha's own ten powers, and this very exhaustive, thorough practice within the dharma of mastery, a person such as this shall, before long, swiftly attain unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. Through five causes and conditions, one delights in this exhaustive, thorough practice: first, revering every buddha's own teaching and command; second, since every buddha possesses great disciples; third, personally realizing every dharma directly; fourth, drawing in one who has fallen; fifth, being able to rescue and deliver one who has already fallen. As it is said: "Revering the Buddha's own teaching, beyond compare, the Buddha's own children number four times eight, and further six times three kinds, fit to serve as teachers for every deva.
"Through the very eye of the Buddha's own wisdom, beholding every dharma directly present, those who rebel, who are evil, who have severed their own roots of goodness, and every one who has broken the precepts —
"Persons such as these, who have fallen, are drawn in and delivered; should a person, within the Buddha's own power and mastery, practice this exhaustively and thoroughly,
"Nirvāṇa, and the very merit of the devas, remain constantly within this very person's own hand."
Within this very matter, every buddha, through this very buddha-power, is able to accomplish five kinds of matter: first, causing sentient beings to study the śrāvaka vehicle; second, causing sentient beings to study the pratyekabuddha vehicle; third, causing sentient beings to study the dharma of the Great Vehicle; fourth, causing one whose own power is complete to attain liberation; fifth, causing one whose own power is inferior to abide within worldly joy. As it is said: "Every buddha, through this very spiritual power, causes sentient beings to give rise to weariness and renunciation, whether causing them to study the lesser vehicle, the middle vehicle, or the Great Vehicle.
"One whose own power is complete is caused to attain liberation; one whose own power is not yet complete is caused to be reborn among the devas, granted worldly joy."
As for "mastery": every buddha attains mastery within five matters: first, mastery of every spiritual power; second, attaining mastery within one's own mind; third, attaining mastery within the very cessation of every dharma; fourth, attaining mastery within noble wish-fulfillment; fifth, attaining mastery within one's own lifespan. As it is said: "Mastery of flight and every such power, mastery attained within one's own mind, within the meditative absorption of cessation, entering and emerging as freely as one's own household.
"Every pure and impure thing turning exactly according to one's own mind, one's own life never harmed by another, one's own object of contemplation likewise inexhaustible.
"Mastery such as this, extending to every dharma whatsoever, is why this very lion among humanity is called one of mastery."
The verse's own compressed reference to "four times eight, and further six times three kinds" of the Buddha's own disciples points toward the traditional enumeration of the noble Saṅgha — the four pairs and eight kinds of noble one this treatise has referenced since Fascicle 6, here counted in a slightly different arrangement — used as shorthand within verse to gesture at a body of teaching too extensive to spell out again in full. This is a recurring feature of this treatise's own verse sections: technical enumerations already explained at length elsewhere are compressed into brief numerical tags, trusting the reader to recall the underlying content from earlier fascicles.
Breaking Wrong Views
能破惡意者,所謂遠離正道,凡夫九十六種外道等,略說惡意者,說五陰為我;或言我有五陰;或言五陰中有我;或言我中有五陰;或言離五陰有我。如說:若五陰是我,即為墮斷滅,則失業因緣,無功而解脫。
餘殘有四種,異陰無有相,無相無有法,皆應如是破。
復次,五邪見名為惡意,所謂邪見、身見、邊見、見取、戒取,如說:破因果邪見,二十種身見,有見及無見,下事以為最。
但以戒力故,而得於解脫,如先一異破,此見如是破。
正意八道破,說名得解脫。
As for "able to break through every wrong intent": this refers to those who have departed far from the right path, the ordinary being, and the ninety-six kinds of outside path, and the like; to speak briefly of "wrong intent," this refers to claiming that the five aggregates are the self; or claiming that the self possesses the five aggregates; or claiming that the self exists within the five aggregates; or claiming that the five aggregates exist within the self; or claiming that the self exists apart from the five aggregates. As it is said: "Should the five aggregates be the self, this thereby falls into annihilationism, thereby losing the very cause and condition of karma, and attaining liberation without any genuine merit whatsoever.
"The remaining four kinds — the self as distinct from the aggregates, possessing no mark whatsoever, being without a mark and without any dharma at all — every one of these ought likewise to be refuted in just this way."
Furthermore, these five wrong views are what is called wrong intent — namely, wrong view itself, the view of self, the view of extremes, the grasping of views, and the grasping of precepts and vows, as it is said: "Refuting the wrong view that denies cause and effect, the twenty kinds of the view of self, the view of existence and the view of non-existence — these lesser matters are held to be supreme.
"Believing that liberation is attained solely through the power of the precepts alone — just as the view of identity and the view of difference were refuted earlier, this very view is refuted in just the same way.
"Refuting this through the eightfold path of right intent — this alone is what is called attaining genuine liberation."
The fivefold analysis of a possible relationship between self and the five aggregates — identical with them, possessing them, contained within them, containing them, or existing apart from them — is one of the classic Madhyamaka arguments against a substantial self, exhaustively covering every logically available position and refuting each in turn, a technique this treatise's own attributed author, Nāgārjuna, is famous for deploying at length elsewhere. Compressed here into a few brief verses rather than developed at full argumentative length, it functions as a condensed reminder of reasoning this treatise assumes its reader already knows from the broader Madhyamaka tradition.
Guarding the True Dharma
守護諸佛正法者,若人能守護諸佛所教法,所謂十二部經,以其心能信、能受;十善業道,能令此人至阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。以五因緣故,應愛護正法:一、知報諸佛恩故;二、令法久住故;三、以最上供養,供養諸佛故;四、利益無量眾生故;五、正法第一難得故。如說:若人欲施作,諸佛所愛事,亦令法久住,以上供養佛。
若欲療治於,眾生之重病,亦知諸世尊,從苦得是法。
以是因緣故,知法為難得,是故有智者,應當愛護法。
於是中,以五因緣故名為愛護正法:一、如所說行,二、令他人如法行,三、除破佛法刺蕀故,四、離四黑印,五、行四大印。
如說:自於佛法中,如佛所教住,悲心不悋法,亦令他得住。
又破於魔眾,及外道論師,若憎佛法者,以無瞋心破。
遠離四黑印,受行四大印,如是則名為,愛護於正法。
As for "guarding and protecting every buddha's own true Dharma": should a person be able to guard and protect the very dharma every buddha has taught — namely, the twelvefold division of the scriptural teaching — with a mind able to believe and able to accept it, these ten wholesome karmic paths are able to bring this person to unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. Through five causes and conditions, one ought to cherish and protect the true Dharma: first, knowing how to repay every buddha's own kindness; second, causing this Dharma to endure for a long time; third, through the very highest offering, making offering to every buddha; fourth, benefiting immeasurable sentient beings; fifth, the true Dharma being the very foremost thing difficult to obtain. As it is said: "Should a person wish to carry out every matter every buddha loves, and further cause this Dharma to endure for a long time, this is itself the very highest offering made to the Buddha.
"Should one wish to treat and cure sentient beings' own grave illness, one ought further to know that every world-honored one attained this very dharma only through suffering themselves.
"Through this very cause and condition, knowing this Dharma to be difficult to obtain — it is for this reason that one of wisdom ought to cherish and protect this Dharma."
Within this very matter, through five causes and conditions, one is called one who cherishes and protects the true Dharma: first, practicing exactly as it has been taught; second, causing others likewise to practice in accordance with the Dharma; third, removing and destroying every thorn and bramble that obstructs the Buddhadharma; fourth, departing from the four black seals; fifth, practicing the four great seals.
As it is said: "Abiding, within the Buddhadharma itself, exactly as the Buddha has taught, a mind of compassion never begrudging this Dharma, and further causing others likewise to abide within it.
"And further breaking through the very host of māra, and every outside-path teacher, and, should there be one who hates the Buddhadharma, breaking through this with a mind free of anger.
"Departing far from the four black seals, receiving and practicing the four great seals — this alone is what is called cherishing and protecting the true Dharma."
The instruction to refute māra's own host and every hostile outside-path teacher "with a mind free of anger" is easy to pass over but carries real weight given this treatise's own repeated warnings elsewhere against anger as one of the three poisons: even the defense of the true Dharma against active hatred is not exempted from the same discipline of mind applied everywhere else in this treatise — the refutation itself may be forceful, but the mind carrying it out must remain as free of anger as the compassion this same section elsewhere insists on holding toward every being without exception.
Valiant: Breaking the Four Enemies
勇健者,菩薩以五因緣故名為勇健:一、破魔賊故,二、破外道賊故,三、破煩惱賊故,四、破諸根賊故,五、破五陰賊故。如說:惡魔起兵眾,道樹欲害佛,常求於佛便,嬈亂聽者心。
佛日出世間,魔請令涅槃,常亂受學者,破於解脫道。
乃至於今日,其心猶不息,是憎涅槃者,善人之大賊。
應以戒定慧,摧破魔力怨。
自謂有智慧,常輕慢於佛,以種種因緣,滅佛法故出,常憎佛弟子,自失教他失。
是諸外道輩,世間之大賊。
當以無瞋心,應以多聞慧,及以大心力,摧破外道怨。
煩惱力起業,輪轉墮惡道,煩惱力障故,不能行大道。
以煩惱力故,墮種種邪見,以煩惱力故,不行甘露道。
以是因緣故,煩惱最大賊,以正念、定、慧,破此煩惱賊。
若為根賊牽,令人墮惡道、又墮天人中,不得至涅槃。
今此諸根賊,何不以慚愧、正念及智慧,摧破諸根賊。
譬如世間人,以軟語欺誑、財物及刀矟,以此四除賊。
以此五陰故,受生老病死,亦墮大怖畏,得諸急苦惱。
五陰因緣故,憂悲及啼哭;五陰因緣故,受種種諸苦。
是故汝當知:應以知見法,摧破此五陰,猶如破怨賊。
As for "valiant": the bodhisattva, through five causes and conditions, is called valiant: first, breaking through the very bandit of māra; second, breaking through the very bandit of the outside paths; third, breaking through the very bandit of the afflictions; fourth, breaking through the very bandit of every faculty; fifth, breaking through the very bandit of the five aggregates. As it is said: "The evil māra raised his own army, beneath the very tree of awakening, wishing to harm the Buddha, constantly seeking some opening against the Buddha, disturbing and confounding every listener's own mind.
"The Buddha, the very sun rising within this world — māra sought to hasten his own extinction, constantly disturbing every student, breaking through the very path of liberation.
"Right up until this very day, this very mind has still not ceased — this hater of nirvāṇa is the very great bandit of every good person.
"One ought, through the precepts, meditative concentration, and wisdom, to break through this very power of māra, this hostile enemy.
"Believing themselves to possess wisdom, constantly showing contempt toward the Buddha, through causes and conditions of every kind emerging to destroy the Buddhadharma, constantly hating the Buddha's own disciples, themselves lost and causing others to become lost as well.
"These very followers of the outside paths are the great bandit of this world.
"One ought, through a mind free of anger, through the very wisdom of vast learning, and through the power of this great mind, to break through this very enemy of the outside paths.
"The power of the afflictions gives rise to karma, revolving and falling into an evil destiny; through the very obstruction of this power of the afflictions, one is unable to walk the great path.
"Through this very power of the afflictions, one falls into every kind of wrong view; through this very power of the afflictions, one fails to walk the very path of the nectar of immortality.
"Through this very cause and condition, the afflictions are the very greatest bandit of all — through right mindfulness, concentration, and wisdom, one breaks through this very bandit of the afflictions.
"Should one be dragged along by this very bandit of the faculties, this causes a person to fall into an evil destiny, or further to fall among the devas and humans, unable to reach nirvāṇa.
"Now, toward this very bandit of the faculties, why should one not, through conscience and shame, right mindfulness, and wisdom, break through this very bandit of the faculties?
"Just as an ordinary person of this world, through gentle words, deception, wealth, or a blade and spear — through these very four means, drives off a bandit.
"Through these very five aggregates, one undergoes birth, old age, sickness, and death, and further falls into great dread, encountering every urgent suffering and affliction.
"Through the very cause and condition of the five aggregates, sorrow, grief, and weeping and wailing; through the very cause and condition of the five aggregates, undergoing every kind of suffering.
"It is for this reason that you ought to know: through the very dharma of knowledge and vision, one breaks through these five aggregates, just as one breaks through a hostile bandit."
The closing simile — an ordinary person driving off a bandit through gentle words, deception, wealth, or a blade — supplies an unexpectedly practical frame for the four enemies just enumerated: each of māra, the outside paths, the afflictions, and the faculties is met with its own matched countermeasure (the precepts and wisdom against māra, a mind free of anger and vast learning against rival teachers, mindfulness and concentration against the afflictions, conscience and shame against the faculties), just as a traveler facing a bandit chooses whichever of the four available tactics actually fits the threat in front of them rather than applying identical force to every case.
Capacity to Bear, and the Four Right Efforts
堪受者,心志力強有大人相,見事深遠。以五因緣故,名為堪受者:一、所願事成其心不高;二、所願不成心亦不下;三、苦惱切己其心不動;四、樂事加身心亦不異;五、其心深遠,若瞋若喜,難可得知。如說:身心新苦至,其意亦不動,隨意樂事至,大智心不異。
若瞋喜怖畏,他人不能測,如是深心相,是說堪受者。
勤精進者,於五事中勤行精進:一、未生惡法,為不生故勤行精進。二、已生惡法,為斷滅故勤行精進。三、未生善法,為令生故勤行精進。四、已生善法,為增長故勤行精進。五、於世間事中有所作,無能障礙故勤行精進。如說:斷已生惡法,猶如除毒蛇;斷未生惡法,如預斷流水。
增長於善法,如溉甘果栽;未生善為生,如攢木出火。
世間善事中,精進無障礙,諸佛說是人,名為勤精進。
As for "capacity to bear": one whose own resolve and power are strong, possessing the very mark of a great person, seeing every matter deeply and far. Through five causes and conditions, one is called one of this very capacity to bear: first, should whatever is wished for be accomplished, their own mind never grows exalted; second, should whatever is wished for fail to be accomplished, their own mind never grows dejected; third, though suffering and affliction press directly upon them, their own mind remains unmoved; fourth, though a matter of joy comes upon their own body, their own mind likewise never changes; fifth, their own mind is so profound and far-reaching that whether it holds anger or joy is difficult indeed to determine. As it is said: "Should suffering newly arise, in body and mind alike, their own intent likewise remains unmoved; should a matter of joy arrive exactly as wished, this great wisdom's own mind likewise never changes.
"Whether holding anger, joy, or dread, no other person is able to fathom it — a mark of this very deep mind is what is called one of this capacity to bear."
As for "diligently applying effort": diligently applying effort within five matters: first, toward an unwholesome dharma not yet arisen, applying diligent effort so that it does not arise; second, toward an unwholesome dharma already arisen, applying diligent effort so as to sever and extinguish it; third, toward a wholesome dharma not yet arisen, applying diligent effort so as to cause it to arise; fourth, toward a wholesome dharma already arisen, applying diligent effort so as to increase it; fifth, toward whatever one undertakes within the affairs of this world, applying diligent effort so that nothing is able to obstruct it. As it is said: "Severing an unwholesome dharma already arisen is just like removing a venomous serpent; severing an unwholesome dharma not yet arisen is like damming a flowing stream in advance.
"Increasing a wholesome dharma is like watering a sweet fruit tree's own sapling; causing a wholesome dharma not yet arisen to arise is like rubbing wood together to produce fire.
"Applying diligent effort without any obstruction whatsoever, within every wholesome matter of this world — every buddha calls this person one of diligent effort."
The fivefold diligent effort here closely mirrors the classical four right efforts (samyak-pradhāna) found throughout the canon — preventing unarisen unwholesome states, abandoning arisen ones, cultivating unarisen wholesome states, and maintaining arisen ones — with a fifth item added specifically for worldly undertakings, extending this canonical fourfold framework into the bodhisattva's own broader engagement with ordinary affairs beyond purely inward cultivation.
A Firm Mind Teaching Across Five Vehicles, and Freedom from Craving
堅心化眾生者,若菩薩於五乘中教化眾生時,供養、輕慢、憎、愛、怖畏、苦、樂、疲極等事中,其心不轉,是名堅心化眾生。
五乘者:一者、佛乘,二者、辟支佛乘,三者、聲聞乘,四者、天乘,五者、人乘。如說:如應以一心,一切諸力勢,依種種方便,離於憎愛心。
教化諸眾生,離垢心清淨,令得無量世,難得無上乘。
若人無勢力,不堪住大乘,次教辟支佛,聲聞天人乘。
不貪自樂者,所謂不著一切諸樂,菩薩以五因緣故不貪自樂:一、樂無常如水泡,二、世樂變苦,三、從眾緣生故,四、從渴愛起故,五、少樂如蜜渧故。如說:樂少住如泡,變苦如毒食,三合從觸有,貪欲㽿故生。
若離於貪愛,更無有別樂,如枯井蜜渧,樂少而苦多,利益眾生者,不應有貪著。
及無量身命者,菩薩以五因緣故不貪惜身:一、身不從先世來,二、不去至後世,三、不堅牢,四、是身無我,五、無我所。如說:汝身眾穢聚,不淨遍充滿,不從先世來,不持至後世。
雖久好供事,而破大恩分,是身不堅固,如沫不久壞。
緣生無定性,無性不自在,是故應當知,非我非我所,是身無量過,不應有貪惜。
菩薩以五因緣故不貪惜壽命:一、樂慧命故,二、怖畏罪故,三、念無始生死中無量死故,四、與一切眾生共受故,五、不可免故。如說:從多聞正論,生貪慧命故,怖畏失命時,而起於罪惡。
又見一切人,無脫死王者,不可以財智,方便力所免,修集善法者,何得惜是命。
As for "a firm mind in teaching and transforming sentient beings": should the bodhisattva, in teaching and transforming sentient beings across these five vehicles, encounter offering, contempt, hatred, love, dread, suffering, joy, or utter exhaustion, and their own mind never turns from this task regardless — this alone is called a firm mind in teaching and transforming sentient beings.
The five vehicles are: first, the buddha vehicle; second, the pratyekabuddha vehicle; third, the śrāvaka vehicle; fourth, the deva vehicle; fifth, the human vehicle. As it is said: "According with what is fitting, with a single-pointed mind, and every power at one's disposal, relying upon skillful means of every kind, departing from a mind of both hatred and love.
"Teaching and transforming every sentient being, this mind free of defilement and pure, causing them to attain, across immeasurable ages, this vehicle unsurpassed and difficult to attain.
"Should a person lack sufficient power, unable to abide within the Great Vehicle, one next teaches them the pratyekabuddha, śrāvaka, deva, or human vehicle instead."
As for "never craving one's own pleasure": this refers to never being attached to any pleasure whatsoever. The bodhisattva, through five causes and conditions, never craves their own pleasure: first, pleasure is impermanent, like a bubble upon water; second, worldly pleasure turns into suffering; third, it arises from a convergence of conditions; fourth, it arises from thirsting craving; fifth, this pleasure is slight, like a single drop of honey. As it is said: "Pleasure abides but briefly, like a bubble, turning into suffering like a poisoned meal; arising from the threefold convergence of contact, it arises through the very itch of craving and desire.
"Should one depart from this very craving, there exists no further, separate pleasure at all — like a drop of honey at the bottom of a dry well, its pleasure slight and its suffering abundant; one who benefits sentient beings ought never to hold any craving attachment toward it."
As for "and toward one's own immeasurable body and life": the bodhisattva, through five causes and conditions, never craves or begrudges their own body: first, this body has not come from a former life; second, it does not go on to a life to come; third, it is not firm or secure; fourth, this very body is without self; fifth, it is without anything belonging to self. As it is said: "Your own body, a mere gathering of manifold filth, entirely filled with impurity, has not come from a former life, and shall not be carried on to a life to come.
"Though attended to well for a long time, it nonetheless breaks this very debt of gratitude owed it — this body is not firm or secure, and, like foam, is destroyed before long.
"Arising from conditions, it possesses no fixed nature of its own; possessing no fixed nature, it is not self-governing — it is for this reason that one ought to know: it is neither self, nor anything belonging to self; this very body possesses immeasurable faults, and one ought never to hold any craving or reluctance toward it."
The bodhisattva, through five causes and conditions, never craves or begrudges their own lifespan: first, delighting in the very life of wisdom; second, dreading offense; third, being mindful of the immeasurable deaths already undergone throughout beginningless birth and death; fourth, sharing this very experience together with every sentient being; fifth, since it cannot be avoided regardless. As it is said: "From vast learning and right discourse, giving rise to a craving for this very life of wisdom, dreading the very moment of losing one's own life, and thereby giving rise to offense and evil.
"And further beholding that every person whatsoever is unable to escape the very king of death, unable to be spared through wealth, cleverness, or the power of any skillful means whatsoever — one who cultivates and gathers the wholesome dharma, how could they possibly begrudge this very life?"
The striking claim that a well-tended body, however long attended to, "nonetheless breaks this very debt of gratitude owed it" personifies the body as a debtor who ultimately defaults regardless of how much care is invested in it — every meal, every comfort given to it across a lifetime is a kind of loan the body's own impermanence guarantees it can never fully repay. This sits alongside the treatise's own repeated insistence, since Fascicle 6's account of giving, that the body is not something to be indulged, yet the emphasis here falls less on renunciation for its own sake than on simple realism about what any amount of care can actually secure.
Foremost in Every Matter, Faultless Action, and Purity from Every Excellent Place
一切事中上者,若人有所作事必能究竟,是名為上人。菩薩以五事發必得究竟:一者、財物,二者、布施,三、持戒,四、修定,五、道德。如說:勤求聚財利,慇懃行布施,次第淨持戒,精進求禪定,行種種方便,生八道解脫,是名諸事中,名之為上人。
所作無過咎者,是菩薩所作智者不呵,以五因緣故,所作無過,智者不呵:一、作可作事,二、大果利,三、不壞法,四、次後無過,五、大名聲。如說:先種種籌量,自作易作事,從是事所得,無量大果利。
不妨於善法,作已無惡隨,善人所讚歎,名聞廣流布。
智者所起業,名為無過咎,可作及易作,自屬於己身。
無量大功德,疾得果利益,智者如是知,後無有過咎。
應加勤精進,而作如是事。
一切種清淨、一切勝處來者,以五因緣故諸勝處、一切種清淨:一、深心清淨,二、迴向清淨,三、自如說行勝處,四、令他人行,五、離諸勝處相違法——所謂妄語、慳貪、戲調、愚癡。如說:菩薩深淨心,遠離於諂曲,皆以四勝處,迴向於佛道。
先自修善法,後令他人行,菩薩如是者,四勝處清淨。
As for "foremost in every matter": should a person, in whatever they undertake, necessarily be able to bring it to completion, this alone is called a foremost person. The bodhisattva, through five matters, gives rise to what necessarily reaches completion: first, material wealth; second, giving; third, upholding the precepts; fourth, cultivating meditative concentration; fifth, moral virtue. As it is said: "Diligently seeking to gather wealth and benefit, earnestly practicing giving, purely upholding the precepts in due sequence, diligently seeking meditative concentration, practicing skillful means of every kind, giving rise to liberation through the eightfold path — this alone is called, among every matter, what is named a foremost person."
As for "whatever is done, free of any fault": whatever this bodhisattva undertakes, the wise never reproach it. Through five causes and conditions, whatever is done is free of fault, and the wise never reproach it: first, undertaking only what genuinely ought to be undertaken; second, this act's own great fruit and benefit; third, never destroying any dharma whatsoever; fourth, incurring no fault whatsoever afterward; fifth, this act's own great renown. As it is said: "First carefully weighing every consideration, oneself undertaking only what is genuinely easy to undertake, from this very matter obtaining an immeasurable, great fruit and benefit.
"Never obstructing any wholesome dharma, and, once done, followed by no evil whatsoever, praised and extolled by every good person, this very renown spreading abroad far and wide.
"Karma arising from one of wisdom is what is called free of any fault, undertaken only where it genuinely ought to be undertaken, and easy to undertake, belonging entirely to oneself alone.
"Immeasurable, great merit, its own fruit and benefit swiftly attained — one of wisdom, knowing this, incurs no fault whatsoever afterward.
"One ought to apply further diligent effort, and undertake matters exactly in this way."
As for "pure in every respect, coming from every excellent place": through five causes and conditions, every one of these excellent places is pure in every respect: first, a deep mind that is pure; second, a dedication that is pure; third, personally practicing exactly as taught within this very excellent place; fourth, causing others likewise to practice it; fifth, departing from every dharma contrary to these excellent places — namely, false speech, stinginess and craving, frivolity, and delusion. As it is said: "The bodhisattva's own deep, pure mind, departing far from flattery and crookedness, dedicates all four of these excellent places toward the path to buddhahood.
"First cultivating this wholesome dharma oneself, and only afterward causing others to practice it — the bodhisattva who is so is pure within these very four excellent places."
The final two qualities in this list — faultless action and purity flowing from the four excellent places — return explicitly to the fourfold framework of truth, relinquishment, cessation, and wisdom this treatise has used as an organizing structure since Fascicle 13's own road simile, closing this long catalogue of roughly two dozen bodhisattva qualities with the same foundational categories it opened toward earlier in this very chapter. The list has now covered vow, firmness, depth of mind, purity, skillful means, compassion, endurance, non-abandonment, wisdom, mastery, valor, and faultless conduct — the remaining section closes the chapter by naming exactly what all of this together produces.
The Ten Powers, and What "World-Honored One" Means
十善道能令至十力世尊者,如是修習十善業道,能令人至十力。
十力者,名為正遍知,正遍知者則是佛。
以五因緣故名世尊:一、斷過去世疑,二、斷未來世疑,三、斷現在世疑,四、斷過三世法疑,五、斷不可說法疑。如說:無始過去世,通達無有疑,無邊未來世,智通達無疑。
十方無有邊,現在一切世,出過於三世,無為微妙法。
十四不可說,亦通無有疑,是故功德藏,諸佛名世尊。
如是功德成就者,十善業道能令菩薩至阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。是故求佛道者,應如是修十善業。
As for "these ten wholesome paths are able to bring one to the World-Honored One of the ten powers": cultivating and studying the ten wholesome karmic paths in this very way, one is thereby able to bring a person to these very ten powers.
"The ten powers" refers to perfect, universal knowledge; and one who possesses this perfect, universal knowledge is precisely the Buddha himself.
Through five causes and conditions, one is called "world-honored one": first, severing every doubt regarding the past; second, severing every doubt regarding the future; third, severing every doubt regarding the present; fourth, severing every doubt regarding the dharma that transcends the three times; fifth, severing every doubt regarding the dharma that cannot be expressed. As it is said: "Throughout beginningless ages past, penetrating them fully, without any doubt whatsoever; throughout the boundless ages yet to come, this very wisdom penetrates them fully, without any doubt whatsoever.
"Throughout the ten directions, without any boundary whatsoever, throughout every world presently existing, and transcending even these three times altogether, this unconditioned, subtle and sublime dharma —
"And these fourteen matters that cannot be expressed — this too is penetrated fully, without any doubt whatsoever; it is for this very reason that this treasury of merit, every buddha, is named the world-honored one."
Merit such as this, once accomplished, these ten wholesome karmic paths are thereby able to bring the bodhisattva to unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. It is for this reason that one who seeks the path to buddhahood ought, in just this way, to cultivate these ten wholesome karmic deeds.
This closing definition of "world-honored one" as freedom from doubt across every temporal and even atemporal category — past, future, present, what transcends the three times, and what cannot be expressed at all — brings the fascicle full circle back to the five treasuries of dharma this treatise first named in Fascicle 10's own account of the vajra samādhi, confirming that the entire roughly two-dozen-quality portrait of the bodhisattva just completed converges on precisely the same omniscience the treatise spent its own most sustained debate defending. The chapter's closing line states plainly what every section since the beginning of this fascicle has been building toward: this same practice of the ten wholesome paths, walked by three different practitioners with three different underlying dispositions, produces three entirely different destinations — the śrāvaka's own liberation, the pratyekabuddha's own solitary realization, or buddhahood itself.
Fascicle 15 Complete
This closes Fascicle 15: which practitioners the ten wholesome paths bring specifically to the pratyekabuddha ground, and, at far greater length, the roughly two dozen qualities — vow, firm mind, deep mind, purity, skillful means, endurance of suffering, never abandoning any being, love of buddha-wisdom, mastery of the ten powers, breaking wrong views, guarding the true Dharma, valiant effort against the four enemies, capacity to bear, diligent effort, teaching across five vehicles, freedom from craving toward pleasure and even one's own body and life, faultless action, and purity flowing from the four excellent places — that distinguish the bodhisattva's own practice of these same ten paths, closing with the very definition of the World-Honored One these qualities converge upon. Fascicle 16 continues the treatise's own account of the bodhisattva path.
Continue to Fascicle 16 →