Part 1 of 40 · Fascicle 1 · 大般涅槃經 T0374 (Northern Edition)

The Buddha's Last Announcement, and the World's Final Offering

The sūtra opens at Kuśinagara, among the twin sāla trees, on the day the Buddha will enter parinirvāṇa. A great voice goes out to every realm, inviting last questions; a healing light goes out after it, and the whole of existence — monks, nuns, bodhisattvas, kings, nāgas, gods up through the Brahmā heavens, even Māra himself — converges on the sāla forest bearing offerings without number. Every single offering is silently refused. The chapter closes with the arrival of a bodhisattva from a buddha-land in the east, Mañjuśrī's reassurance to a frightened assembly, and the Buddha's light withdrawing back into his own mouth — the last and most ominous of six signs that fascicles ahead will draw to their conclusion in Cunda's own offering, the one gift this sūtra's opening was already refusing every other in order to receive.

Translator: Ru-Yi Meditation Center Status: Part 1 of 40 Source: Taishō T0374, 大般涅槃經 (tr. Dharmakṣema, 421 CE) Reading notes after Huiyuan's 大般涅槃經義記 (T1764)

The Buddha's Final Announcement

Chinese Source

如是我聞:一時佛在拘尸那國力士生地阿利羅跋提河邊娑羅雙樹間。爾時世尊與大比丘八十億百千人俱,前後圍遶。二月十五日臨涅槃時,以佛神力出大音聲,其聲遍滿乃至有頂,隨其類音普告眾生:「今日如來、應、正遍知,憐愍眾生,覆護眾生,等視眾生如羅睺羅,為作歸依屋舍室宅。大覺世尊將欲涅槃,一切眾生若有所疑,今悉可問,為最後問。」爾時世尊於晨朝時,從其面門放種種光,其明雜色,青、黃、赤、白、頗梨、馬瑙,光遍照此三千大千佛之世界,乃至十方亦復如是。其中所有六趣眾生遇斯光者,罪垢煩惱一切消除。

Ru-Yi Translation

Thus have I heard. At one time the Buddha was dwelling among the twin sāla trees on the bank of the Ajitavatī River, in the land of the Mallas at Kuśinagara, together with a great assembly of eight hundred thousand million monks surrounding him on every side. On the fifteenth day of the second month, as he drew near his parinirvāṇa, the Buddha, by his own spiritual power, sent forth a great voice that filled every realm up to the summit of existence, proclaiming to beings of every kind, each in the voice proper to its kind: "Today the Tathāgata, Worthy One, Perfectly Awakened One, out of pity for all beings and to shelter and protect them — regarding every being as he regards his own son Rāhula — becomes for them a refuge, a house, a home. The Great Awakened World-Honored One is about to enter parinirvāṇa; let any being who still has a doubt ask it now, for this is the last chance to ask." Then, in the early morning, the World-Honored One sent forth from his face rays of many colors — blue, yellow, red, white, crystal, and agate — light that shone throughout this trichiliocosm, this three-thousandfold great-thousandfold Buddha-world, and likewise through all the ten directions. Every being of the six destinies touched by that light had every sin, defilement, and affliction wiped away.

Reading note — after Huiyuan

Huiyuan's commentary reads what follows as six successive signs the Buddha gives of his own parinirvāṇa — sound, light, the earthquake, the whitening forest, the appearance of a pure land, and finally the light's withdrawal back into his mouth — and groups them in pairs: the first three summon the assembly, the last three press the teaching home. The voice tells beings when and who is dying, so that they will come out of longing for him; the light shows them where to come, and burns away the very afflictions that would keep them from making the journey — "the text says beings touched by this light have every sin and defilement removed," Huiyuan notes, precisely because grief-stricken beings setting out to see a dying teacher need that obstruction cleared first. Two further signs are still to come in this fascicle, and Huiyuan is explicit that all six point at the same single fact — parinirvāṇa — from different sides, not that each carries some separate private meaning; he singles out and refutes, one by one, several rival readings that try to find a distinct hidden message in each individual sign.

Earthquake, and the First Wave of Grief

Chinese Source

是諸眾生見聞是已,心大憂愁,同時舉聲悲啼號哭:「嗚呼慈父,痛哉苦哉。」舉手拍頭搥胸叫喚,其中或有身體戰慄、涕泣、哽咽。

爾時大地諸山大海,皆悉震動,時諸眾生共相謂言:「且各裁抑,莫大愁苦。當疾往詣拘尸那城力士生處,至如來所,頭面禮敬,勸請如來莫般涅槃,住世一劫若減一劫。」互相執手復作是言:「世間空虛,眾生福盡,不善諸業,增長出世。仁等今當速往速往,如來不久必入涅槃。」復作是言:「世間空虛,世間空虛,我等從今無有救護,無所宗仰,貧窮孤露。一旦遠離無上世尊,設有疑惑當復問誰?」

時有無量諸大弟子,尊者摩訶迦旃延、尊者薄俱羅、尊者優波難陀,如是等諸大比丘,遇佛光者,其身戰掉,乃至大動不能自持,心濁迷悶,發聲大喚,生如是等種種苦惱。

爾時復有八十百千諸比丘等,皆阿羅漢,心得自在,所作已辦,離諸煩惱,調伏諸根,如大龍王有大威德,成就空慧,逮得己利,如栴檀林栴檀圍遶,如師子王師子圍遶,成就如是無量功德,一切皆是佛之真子。於其晨朝,日始初出,離常住處,嚼楊枝時,遇佛光明,并相謂言:「仁等,速疾漱口澡手。」作是言已,舉身毛竪,遍體血現如波羅奢花,涕泣盈目生大苦惱。為欲利益安樂眾生,成就大乘第一空行,顯發如來方便密教,為不斷絕種種說法,為諸眾生調伏因緣故,疾至佛所稽首佛足,繞百千匝,合掌恭敬,却坐一面。

Ru-Yi Translation

Seeing and hearing this, all these beings were overcome with grief, and together raised their voices in weeping and lamentation: "Ah, our compassionate father — how painful, how bitter!" Some struck their own heads and beat their breasts, crying aloud; others trembled in their bodies, weeping and choking on their own sobs.

Then the whole earth, every mountain, and the great ocean all quaked and shook. The beings said to one another: "Let each of us restrain ourselves a little, and not give way to excessive grief. Let us go quickly to the birthplace of the Mallas in the city of Kuśinagara, to where the Tathāgata is, bow our heads to his feet in reverence, and beg him not to enter parinirvāṇa, but to remain in the world for a kalpa, or at least for less than a kalpa." Taking one another's hands, they said further: "The world is empty, empty. The merit of beings is exhausted, and unwholesome deeds are increasing and spreading through the world. All of you, go now, go quickly — the Tathāgata will surely enter parinirvāṇa before long." And they said again: "The world is empty, the world is empty. From this day we shall have no one to save or protect us, nothing to rely on or revere; we shall be poor, destitute, and alone. Once we are parted from the Peerless World-Honored One, if any doubt should arise in us, whom shall we ask?"

At that time there were countless great disciples — the venerable Mahākātyāyana, the venerable Bakkula, the venerable Upananda, and other great monks like them — who, touched by the Buddha's light, trembled so violently in their bodies that they could not compose themselves; their minds grew clouded and distressed, and they cried out, giving rise to every kind of anguish.

At that time there were also eighty hundred-thousand monks, every one an arhat, minds that had attained mastery, their work already done, free of every affliction, their faculties well-tamed — like great nāga kings of great majestic virtue, they had accomplished the wisdom of emptiness and attained their own true benefit; like a sandalwood forest surrounded by sandalwood, like a lion king surrounded by lions, they had accomplished immeasurable virtues of this kind, and every one of them was a true child of the Buddha. In the early morning, just as the sun was rising, while they were still at their dwelling places chewing their tooth-cleaning twigs, they were touched by the Buddha's light, and said to one another: "Friends, quickly rinse your mouths and wash your hands." No sooner had they said this than the hair on their bodies stood on end, and blood appeared all over their skin like the palāśa flower; tears filled their eyes, and they were overcome with great anguish. Wishing to benefit and bring peace to beings, to accomplish the Great Vehicle's foremost practice of emptiness, to reveal the Tathāgata's skillful and hidden teaching, and, for the sake of beings still to be tamed, to keep the teaching of the Dharma from ever ceasing, they hastened to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, joined their palms in reverence, and withdrew to sit to one side.

Reading note — after Huiyuan

Huiyuan is struck by a question a casual reading would pass over: these eighty hundred-thousand monks are already described as arhats — beings who, by definition, have finished the work that produces grief. Why do they weep and tremble at all? His answer draws a line between two kinds of sorrow: the ordinary suffering born of unresolved craving, which an arhat has genuinely extinguished, and the specific anguish of losing a teacher, which even a mind free of affliction can still feel — "an arhat has cut off suffering with respect to worldly things, but before the Buddha's own presence he cannot fully compose himself." Huiyuan reaches for a well-known image to make the same point: Mahākāśyapa and Ānanda were famously immovable before the ordinary five desires, and yet when the bodhisattva Mahākinnara played his lute of lapis lazuli, Mahākāśyapa found himself dancing without noticing it, and Ānanda singing along — a pleasure pitched at a register only bodhisattvas can fully bear, before which even the steadiest arhat's composure gives way. Grief at a teacher's parinirvāṇa, on this reading, belongs to the same register: not a lapse back into affliction, but a response scaled to what is actually being lost.

The Nuns, and a Ganges-Sand of Bodhisattvas

Chinese Source

爾時復有拘陀羅女、善賢比丘尼、優波難陀比丘尼、海意比丘尼,與六十億比丘尼等,一切亦是大阿羅漢,諸漏已盡,心得自在,所作已辦,離諸煩惱,調伏諸根,猶如大龍有大威德,成就空慧。亦於晨朝,日初出時,舉身毛竪,遍體血現如波羅奢花,涕泣盈目生大苦惱。亦欲利益安樂眾生,成就大乘第一空行,顯發如來方便密教,為不斷絕種種說法,為諸眾生調伏因緣故,疾至佛所稽首佛足,遶百千匝,合掌恭敬,却坐一面。

於比丘尼眾中復有諸比丘尼,皆是菩薩,人中之龍,位階十地安住不動,為化眾生現受女身,而常修集四無量心,得自在力,能化作佛。

爾時復有一恒河沙菩薩摩訶薩,人中之龍,位階十地安住不動,方便現身。其名曰:海德菩薩、無盡意菩薩,如是等菩薩摩訶薩而為上首。其心皆悉敬重大乘,安住大乘,深解大乘,愛樂大乘,守護大乘,善能隨順一切世間,作是誓言:「諸未度者,當令得度。」已於過世無數劫中,修持淨戒,善持所行,解未解者,紹三寶種使不斷絕,於未來世當轉法輪,以大莊嚴而自莊嚴,成就如是無量功德,等觀眾生如視一子。亦於晨朝,日初出時遇佛光明,舉身毛竪,遍體血現如波羅奢花,涕泣盈目生大苦惱。亦為利益安樂眾生,成就大乘第一空行,顯發如來方便密教,為不斷絕種種說法,為諸眾生調伏因緣故,疾至佛所稽首佛足,繞百千匝,合掌恭敬,却坐一面。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time there were also the woman Kuṇḍalā, the nun Bhadrā, the nun Upananda, the nun Sāgaramati, and sixty million other nuns, every one of them likewise a great arhat, every affliction already exhausted, minds that had attained mastery, their work already done, free of every affliction, their faculties well-tamed — like great nāgas of great majestic virtue, they had accomplished the wisdom of emptiness. They too, in the early morning as the sun was rising, felt the hair on their bodies stand on end, blood appearing all over their skin like the palāśa flower, tears filling their eyes, overcome with great anguish. Wishing likewise to benefit and bring peace to beings, to accomplish the Great Vehicle's foremost practice of emptiness, to reveal the Tathāgata's skillful and hidden teaching, and, for the sake of beings still to be tamed, to keep the teaching of the Dharma from ever ceasing, they hastened to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, joined their palms in reverence, and withdrew to sit to one side.

Among these nuns there were others who were in truth bodhisattvas, dragons among humankind, abiding unshaken at the tenth ground, who had taken on a woman's body only to teach beings, while constantly cultivating the four immeasurable minds, and who had gained the power to manifest as buddhas at will.

At that time there was also a bodhisattva-mahāsattva assembly numbering a Ganges-sand, dragons among humankind, abiding unshaken at the tenth ground, present there by their own skillful manifestation. Among them the bodhisattva Sāgaraguṇa and the bodhisattva Akṣayamati were foremost. Their minds all revered the Great Vehicle, abided in the Great Vehicle, deeply understood the Great Vehicle, delighted in the Great Vehicle, and guarded the Great Vehicle; skillfully according with every kind of being in the world, they had made this vow: "Whoever has not yet crossed over, we will bring across." Through countless past kalpas they had upheld pure precepts and kept well to their practice, freeing those not yet freed, so that the seed of the Three Jewels would never be cut off; in ages to come they would turn the wheel of the Dharma, adorning themselves with great adornment, and had accomplished immeasurable virtues of this kind, regarding every being with the same care a parent gives an only child. They too, in the early morning as the sun was rising, were touched by the Buddha's light, and felt the hair on their bodies stand on end, blood appearing all over their skin like the palāśa flower, tears filling their eyes, overcome with great anguish. Wishing likewise to benefit and bring peace to beings, to accomplish the Great Vehicle's foremost practice of emptiness, to reveal the Tathāgata's skillful and hidden teaching, and, for the sake of beings still to be tamed, to keep the teaching of the Dharma from ever ceasing, they hastened to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, joined their palms in reverence, and withdrew to sit to one side.

The Upāsakas' Funeral Offerings

Chinese Source

爾時復有二恒河沙諸優婆塞,受持五戒,威儀具足,其名曰:威德無垢稱王優婆塞、善德優婆塞等而為上首,深樂觀察諸對治門,所謂苦樂、常無常、淨不淨、我無我、實不實、歸依非歸依、眾生非眾生、恒非恒、安非安、為無為、斷不斷、涅槃非涅槃、增上非增上,常樂觀察如是等法對治之門,亦欲樂聞無上大乘,如所聞已,能為他說。善持淨戒,渴仰大乘,既自充足,復能充足餘渴仰者。善能攝取無上智慧,愛樂大乘,守護大乘。善能隨順一切世間,度未度者,解未解者。紹三寶種使不斷絕,於未來世當轉法輪,以大莊嚴而自莊嚴,心常深味清淨戒行,悉能成就如是功德,於諸眾生生大悲心,平等無二如視一子。

亦於晨朝日初出時,為欲闍毘如來身故,人人各取香木萬束、栴檀沈水、牛頭栴檀、天木香等,是一一木,文理及附,皆有七寶微妙光明,譬如種種雜彩畫飾,以佛力故有是妙色,青黃赤白,為諸眾生之所樂見。諸木皆以種種香塗,欝金沈水及膠香等,散以諸花而為莊嚴,優鉢羅花、拘物頭花、波頭摩花、分陀利花。諸香木上懸五色幡,柔軟微妙猶如天衣,憍奢耶衣芻摩繒綵。是諸香木載以寶車,是諸寶車出種種光,青黃赤白。轅轢皆以七寶廁填,是一一車駕以四馬,是一一馬駿疾如風。一一車前竪立五十七寶妙幢,真金羅網彌覆其上,一一寶車復有五十微妙寶蓋,一一車上垂諸花鬘,優鉢羅花、拘物頭花、波頭摩花、分陀利花,其花純以真金為葉,金剛為臺。是花臺中多有黑蜂,遊集其中歡娛受樂,又出妙音,所謂無常、苦、空、無我,是音聲中,復說菩薩本所行道。復有種種歌舞伎樂、箏笛、箜篌、簫瑟、鼓吹,是樂音中復出是言:「苦哉,苦哉,世間空虛。」一一車前,有優婆塞擎四寶案,是諸案上有種種花,優鉢羅花、拘物頭花、波頭摩花、分陀利花,欝金諸香及餘薰香,微妙第一。

諸優婆塞為佛及僧,辦諸食具,種種備足,皆是栴檀沈水香薪,八功德水之所成熟,其食甘美有六種味:一苦、二醋、三甘、四辛、五醎、六淡。復有三德:一者輕軟、二者淨潔、三者如法,作如是等種種莊嚴。至力士生處娑羅雙樹間,復以金沙遍布其地,以加陵伽衣、欽婆羅衣及繒綵衣而覆沙上,周匝遍滿十二由旬。為佛及僧敷置七寶師子之座,其座高大如須彌山,是諸座上皆有寶帳,垂諸瓔珞。諸娑羅樹,悉懸種種微妙幡蓋,種種好香以塗樹身,種種名花以散樹間。諸優婆塞各作是念:「一切眾生若有所乏,須食與食、須飲與飲、須頭與頭、須目與目,隨諸眾生所須之物,皆悉給與。」作是施時,離欲瞋恚、穢濁毒心,無餘思惟求世福樂,唯期無上清淨菩提。

是優婆塞等,皆已安住於菩薩道,復作是念:「如來今者受我食已,當入涅槃。」作是念已,身毛皆竪,遍體血現如波羅奢花,涕泣盈目生大苦惱,各各齎持供養之具,載以寶車、香木、幢幡、寶蓋、飲食,疾至佛所稽首佛足,以其所持供養之具,供養如來,遶百千匝,舉聲號泣,哀動天地,搥胸大叫,淚下如雨,復相謂言:「苦哉,仁者!世間空虛,世間空虛。」便自舉身,投如來前,而白佛言:「唯願如來,哀受我等最後供養。」世尊知時默然不受。

如是三請,悉皆不許。諸優婆塞不果所願,心懷悲惱,默然而住。

猶如慈父唯有一子,卒病喪亡,送其屍骸置於塚間,歸還悵悢,愁憂苦惱。諸優婆塞憂愁苦惱亦復如是,以諸供具安置一處,却在一面,默然而坐。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time there were also two Ganges-sands of upāsakas, holding the five precepts, their conduct fully accomplished, among whom the upāsaka King Vimalakīrti of Majestic Virtue and the upāsaka Sudatta were foremost. They delighted in examining the gateways that counter attachment — suffering and happiness, permanence and impermanence, purity and impurity, self and no-self, the real and the unreal, refuge and its absence, being a sentient being and not being one, the constant and the inconstant, safety and its absence, the conditioned and the unconditioned, what is to be cut off and what is not, nirvāṇa and its absence, the surpassing and the unsurpassing — constantly delighting in examining these dharma-gateways that counter attachment, and wishing also to hear the peerless Great Vehicle, so that, once having heard it, they could teach it to others. Well upholding pure precepts, thirsting after the Great Vehicle, having satisfied themselves they could satisfy others still thirsting. Skillfully gathering peerless wisdom, delighting in the Great Vehicle, guarding the Great Vehicle. Skillfully according with every kind of being in the world, freeing those not yet freed, releasing those not yet released. So that the seed of the Three Jewels would never be cut off, in ages to come they would turn the wheel of the Dharma, adorning themselves with great adornment, their minds forever savoring pure conduct, having accomplished virtues of this kind, giving rise to great compassion for every being, regarding each one equally, without exception, as an only child.

Also in the early morning, as the sun was rising, wishing to cremate the Tathāgata's body, each of them gathered ten thousand bundles of fragrant wood — sandalwood, aloeswood, ox-head sandalwood, and heavenly wood-incense — every single piece of which, in its very grain, carried the fine luster of the seven treasures, as though painted over in every color, made so by the Buddha's own power, blue, yellow, red, and white, delightful for every being to see. Every piece of wood was smeared with every kind of fragrance — saffron, aloeswood, resin-incense — and adorned further with scattered flowers: blue lotus, red lotus, white lotus, and the great white lotus. Banners of five colors, soft and fine as a garment of the gods, silk brocade of every weave, were hung above the fragrant wood. This fragrant wood was loaded onto jeweled carriages, and these jeweled carriages sent out light of every color, blue, yellow, red, and white; their shafts and wheel-rims were inlaid throughout with the seven treasures, and each carriage was drawn by four horses, each horse as swift as the wind. Before each carriage stood fifty-seven exquisite jeweled banner-poles, draped over in a net of true gold; each jeweled carriage also carried fifty fine jeweled canopies, and from each carriage hung garlands of flowers — blue lotus, red lotus, white lotus, and the great white lotus — their petals wrought purely of true gold, their calyxes of diamond. Within these flower-calyxes gathered many black bees, roaming there in delight, and sending out a wondrous sound — the sound of impermanence, suffering, emptiness, and no-self — a sound in which, further, the bodhisattva path once practiced was proclaimed. There was also every kind of song and dance and music — zithers, flutes, harps, panpipes, and drums — and within this music, further, came the words: "How bitter, how bitter — the world is empty." Before each carriage stood an upāsaka bearing a stand of the four treasures, laden with every kind of flower — blue lotus, red lotus, white lotus, and the great white lotus — with saffron and every other fragrance, of the finest and rarest kind.

The upāsakas also prepared every kind of food for the Buddha and the saṅgha, complete in every respect, all cooked over fragrant sandalwood and aloeswood fuel and matured in water of the eight virtues; the food was delicious, of six flavors — bitter, sour, sweet, pungent, salty, and bland — and possessed further of three qualities: it was light and soft, it was pure and clean, and it accorded with the Dharma. Having arranged every adornment of this kind, they came to the birthplace of the Mallas among the twin sāla trees, and spread the ground there over with golden sand, covering the sand with garments of kālinga-cloth, of fine wool, and of silk brocade, extending all around for a full twelve yojanas. For the Buddha and the saṅgha they laid out lion-thrones of the seven treasures, seats as tall and great as Mount Sumeru, over which hung jeweled canopies draped with strings of jewels. Every sāla tree was hung with fine banners and canopies of every kind, its trunk smeared with every fragrance, and every kind of famous flower scattered among the branches. Each upāsaka thought to himself: "Whatever any being still lacks, if they need food let them have food, if they need drink let them have drink, if they need a head let them have my head, if they need eyes let them have my eyes — whatever any being needs, let it all be given." And in giving this way, they were free of desire, of anger, and of any defiled or poisonous thought, seeking nothing further for worldly happiness, aspiring only to the peerless, pure awakening.

These upāsakas, all of them already established on the bodhisattva path, thought further: "Once the Tathāgata has accepted our food, he will enter parinirvāṇa." Having had this thought, the hair on their bodies all stood on end, blood appeared all over their skin like the palāśa flower, tears filled their eyes, and they were overcome with great anguish; each carrying his own offerings, they loaded the jeweled carriages with the fragrant wood, banners, jeweled canopies, and food, and hastened to where the Buddha was. Bowing their heads to his feet, they offered these things to the Tathāgata, circling him a hundred thousand times, raising their voices in wailing loud enough to move heaven and earth, beating their breasts and crying aloud, tears falling like rain, saying to one another: "How bitter, friends! The world is empty, the world is empty." Then, throwing themselves bodily down before the Tathāgata, they said to the Buddha: "We beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The World-Honored One, knowing that the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept it.

Though they asked three times in this way, he refused every time. The upāsakas, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and fell silent.

It was like a loving father whose only son has suddenly sickened and died: having carried the body to the burial ground and returned home, he is left disconsolate, sunk in grief and anguish. The sorrow and anguish of these upāsakas were just the same; setting their offerings all down together in one place, they withdrew to one side and sat there in silence.

Reading note — after Huiyuan

Huiyuan pauses over a detail easy to read past: why do black bees, of all creatures, gather in the golden flower-calyxes on these funeral carriages? He records that some readers take the color itself as a deliberate sign — black standing for beings still clouded in ignorance, drawn even here to the flowers of an offering they cannot yet understand — but declines to settle the question, since the sūtra itself never glosses the detail, and he will not assert a symbolism the text does not state outright. He is considerably more confident, a few lines earlier, about a structural point: this whole assembly is being listed in a deliberate order — renunciants before laypeople, because the ordained carry less worldly rank but are fewer in number and thus listed first; śrāvakas before bodhisattvas, for reasons he traces through four different rationales (proximity to the Buddha, dignity of outward bearing, doctrinal register, and sheer numbers) — so that what can look like an arbitrary parade of donors is in fact organized throughout by consistent, statable principles, the same care Huiyuan brings to nearly every verse of this text.

The Upāsikās' Meditation on the Body

Chinese Source

爾時復有三恒河沙諸優婆夷,受持五戒,威儀具足。其名曰:壽德優婆夷、德鬘優婆夷、毘舍佉優婆夷等八萬四千,而為上首。悉能堪任護持正法,為度無量百千眾生故,現女身呵責家法。自觀己身如四毒蛇,是身常為無量諸虫之所唼食,是身臭穢、貪欲、獄縛,是身可惡猶如死狗,是身不淨九孔常流。是身如城,血肉筋骨皮裹其上,手足以為却敵樓櫓,目為竅孔,頭為殿堂,心王處中,如是身城,諸佛世尊之所棄捨,凡夫愚人常所味著,貪婬、瞋恚、愚癡羅剎止住其中。是身不堅,猶如蘆葦、伊蘭、水泡、芭蕉之樹。是身無常,念念不住,猶如電光、暴水、幻炎,亦如畫水,隨畫隨合。是身易壞,猶如河岸臨峻大樹。是身不久當為狐狼、鵄梟、鵰鷲、烏鵲、餓狗,之所食噉。誰有智者,當樂此身?寧以牛跡盛大海水,不能具說是身無常、不淨、臭穢。寧丸大地使如棗等,漸漸轉小猶葶藶子乃至微塵,不能具說是身過患。是故當捨,如棄涕唾。以是因緣,諸優婆夷,以空、無相、無願之法,常修其心。深樂諮受大乘經典,聞已亦能為他演說,護持本願,毀呰女身,甚可患厭,性不堅牢,心常修集如是正觀,破壞生死無際輪轉。渴仰大乘,既自充足,復能充足餘渴仰者。深樂大乘,守護大乘,雖現女身,實是菩薩,善能隨順一切世間,度未度者,解未解者,紹三寶種使不斷絕,於未來世當轉法輪,以大莊嚴而自莊嚴,堅持禁戒,皆悉成就如是功德,於諸眾生生大悲心,平等無二,如視一子。

亦於晨朝,日初出時各相謂言:「今日宜應至雙樹間。」諸優婆夷所設供具,倍勝於前,持至佛所,稽首佛足,遶百千匝,而白佛言:「世尊!我等今者,為佛及僧辦諸供具,唯願如來,哀受我供。」如來默然而不許可。諸優婆夷不果所願,心懷惆悵,却坐一面。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time there were also three Ganges-sands of upāsikās, holding the five precepts, their conduct fully accomplished, among whom the upāsikā Āyuśrī, the upāsikā Mālāguṇā, the upāsikā Viśākhā, and eighty-four thousand others were foremost. Every one of them was able to bear the responsibility of upholding the true Dharma, and, in order to save countless hundreds of thousands of beings, had taken on a woman's body precisely to reproach the life of the household. Each contemplated her own body as four poisonous snakes: this body is forever being devoured by countless worms; this body is foul, bound by craving as though shackled; this body is repulsive, like a dead dog; this body is impure, its nine openings forever flowing. This body is like a fortress-city — flesh, blood, sinew, and bone wrapped in skin, hands and feet its watchtowers, the eyes its window-slits, the head its palace hall, with the mind as sovereign seated within — and this fortress-city of a body is precisely what every buddha and world-honored one has cast aside, yet what the foolish and unlearned forever cling to and savor, a fortress in which the rākṣasas of lust, anger, and delusion make their dwelling. This body is not solid, like a reed, like the ricinus plant, like a bubble on water, like the trunk of a plantain tree. This body is impermanent, never abiding from one instant to the next, like a flash of lightning, like a raging flood, like a mirage, or like a picture drawn on water, closing over the instant it is drawn. This body is easily destroyed, like a great tree leaning over a steep riverbank. Before long this body will be devoured by foxes, wolves, owls, vultures, crows, and starving dogs. What wise person, then, could delight in such a body? One could sooner scoop up the whole ocean in a single hoofprint than fully describe this body's impermanence, impurity, and foulness. One could sooner roll the whole earth down to the size of a jujube, and smaller still, down to a mustard seed, and smaller still, down to a mote of dust, than fully describe this body's faults. It should therefore be cast off, the way one spits out phlegm. For this reason these upāsikās constantly cultivated their minds with the dharma of emptiness, signlessness, and wishlessness. They delighted deeply in receiving instruction in the scriptures of the Great Vehicle, and, once having heard them, could expound them to others in turn; upholding their original vow, they held the female body in the deepest reproach, as something greatly to be wearied of, without any solid nature of its own, and constantly cultivated in their minds this correct contemplation, breaking apart the boundless cycle of birth and death. Thirsting after the Great Vehicle, having satisfied themselves they could satisfy others still thirsting. Delighting deeply in the Great Vehicle, guarding the Great Vehicle — though manifesting a woman's body, they were in truth bodhisattvas — skillfully according with every kind of being in the world, freeing those not yet freed, releasing those not yet released, so that the seed of the Three Jewels would never be cut off, in ages to come they would turn the wheel of the Dharma, adorning themselves with great adornment, firmly upholding the moral precepts, having accomplished every virtue of this kind, giving rise to great compassion for every being, regarding each one equally, without exception, as an only child.

Also in the early morning, as the sun was rising, they said to one another: "Today we too should go to the place between the twin trees." The offerings the upāsikās had prepared surpassed those that came before them twice over; carrying them to where the Buddha was, they bowed their heads to his feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we have now prepared these offerings for the Buddha and the saṅgha; we beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our offering." The Tathāgata remained silent and did not consent. The upāsikās, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrowful longing, and withdrew to sit to one side.

Reading note — after Huiyuan

Huiyuan takes care to separate this passage from a simple denunciation of women as such. His gloss on "taking on a woman's body precisely to reproach the life of the household" (現女身呵責家法) reads these upāsikās as bodhisattvas who have deliberately chosen female rebirth as the more effective platform from which to deliver a teaching aimed at the household life in general, using their own bodies as the example precisely because a body already burdened by a culture's low regard is the sharpest possible text for a meditation everyone, regardless of their own body, is meant to draw the same conclusion from. He organizes the discourse itself into three components matched to three faults he finds named in the sūtra's own language — the body's suffering (compared to four vipers and countless devouring worms), its impurity (traced through five classical sources of impurity: the impure origin in the parents' fluids, the impure dwelling-place in the womb, the impure substance of its thirty-six parts, the impure marks of its nine ever-flowing openings, and its impure end in decay), and its lack of any fixed self (unpacked through the fortress-city simile, mapped organ by organ) — and notes that the sūtra states only three of these five classical categories of impurity explicitly, leaving the enumeration itself, not just its content, as something the careful reader has to reconstruct.

The Licchavis, Ministers, and the Kings of Jambudvīpa

Chinese Source

爾時復有四恒河沙毘耶離城諸離車等,男女、大小、妻子眷屬,及閻浮提諸王眷屬,為求法故,善修戒行,威儀具足,摧伏異學壞正法者,常相謂言:「我等當以金銀倉庫,為令甘露、無盡正法、深奧之藏久住於世。願令我等常得修學,若有誹謗佛正法者,當斷其舌。」復作是願:「若有出家毀禁戒者,我當罷令還俗策使。有能深樂、護持正法,我當敬重如事父母。若有眾僧能修正法,我當隨喜令得勢力。」常欲樂聞大乘經典,聞已亦能為人廣說,皆悉成就如是功德。其名曰:淨無垢藏離車子、淨不放逸離車子、恒水無垢淨德離車子,如是等各相謂言:「仁等,今可速往佛所。」所辦供養,種種具足,一一離車,各嚴八萬四千大象,八萬四千駟馬寶車,八萬四千明月寶珠,天木、栴檀沈水、薪束,種種各有八萬四千。一一象前,有寶幢幡蓋,其蓋小者,周匝縱廣滿一由旬,幡最短者長三十二由旬,寶幢卑者高百由旬。持如是等供養之具,往至佛所,稽首佛足,遶百千匝,而白佛言:「世尊!我等今者,為佛及僧辦諸供具,唯願如來哀受我供。」如來默然而不許可。諸離車等,不果所願,心懷愁惱。以佛神力,去地七多羅樹,於虛空中默然而住。

爾時復有五恒河沙大臣、長者,敬重大乘,若有異學謗正法者,是諸人等力能摧伏,猶如雹雨摧折草木。其名曰:日光長者、護世長者、護法長者,如是之等而為上首。所設供具,五倍於前,俱共往詣娑羅雙樹間,稽首佛足,遶百千匝,而白佛言:「世尊!我等今者,為佛及僧設諸供具,唯願哀愍,受我等供。」如來默然而不受之。諸長者等,不果所願,心懷愁惱。以佛神力,去地七多羅樹,於虛空中默然而住。

爾時復有(應有六恒河沙)毘舍離王,及其後宮夫人眷屬,閻浮提內所有諸王,除阿闍世并及城邑聚落人民。其名曰月無垢王等,各嚴四兵,欲往佛所。是一一王,各有一百八十萬億人民眷屬。是諸車兵,駕以象馬,象有六牙,馬疾如風,莊嚴供具六倍於前。寶蓋之中有極小者,周匝縱廣滿八由旬,幡極短者十六由旬,寶幢卑者三十六由旬。是諸王等,皆悉安住於正法中,惡賤邪法,敬重大乘,深樂大乘,憐愍眾生,等如一子,所持飲食,香氣流布滿四由旬。亦於晨朝日初出時,持是種種上妙甘饍,詣雙樹間,至如來所,而白佛言:「世尊!我等為佛及比丘僧設是供具,唯願如來,哀愍受我最後供養。」如來知時,亦不許可。是諸王等,不果所願,心懷愁惱,却住一面。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time there were also four Ganges-sands of Licchavis from the city of Vaiśālī — men and women, old and young, with their wives and dependents — together with the retinues of the kings of Jambudvīpa, who, for the sake of the Dharma, had cultivated moral conduct well and were fully accomplished in their bearing, and who could subdue any heterodox teacher bent on destroying the true Dharma. They constantly said to one another: "We should give of our own gold and silver treasuries, so that the deathless, inexhaustible true Dharma, this profound and hidden treasury, may long abide in the world. May we be granted to study and practice it always; and should anyone slander the Buddha's true Dharma, let that person's tongue be cut out." They made this vow further: "Should any renunciant break the moral precepts, we will have that person unfrocked and put to labor. Whoever can delight deeply in the true Dharma and uphold it, we will honor and revere as we would our own parents. Should any member of the saṅgha be able to practice the true Dharma, we will rejoice for that person and see that they gain influence." They constantly wished to hear the scriptures of the Great Vehicle, and, once having heard them, could expound them widely to others; all of them had accomplished virtues of this kind. Among them the Licchavi son Vimalagarbha the Pure, the Licchavi son Apramāda the Pure, and the Licchavi son Amalaguṇa of the Ever-Flowing Waters said to one another: "Friends, let us now go quickly to where the Buddha is." The offerings they had prepared were complete in every kind: each Licchavi outfitted eighty-four thousand great elephants, eighty-four thousand jeweled chariots drawn by four horses each, eighty-four thousand bright moon-jewels, and eighty-four thousand bundles each of heavenly incense-wood, sandalwood, and aloeswood. Before each elephant stood a jeweled banner-pole hung with canopies, the smallest canopy a full yojana across, the shortest banner thirty-two yojanas long, the lowest jeweled pole a hundred yojanas high. Bearing offerings of this kind, they went to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we have now prepared these offerings for the Buddha and the saṅgha; we beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our offering." The Tathāgata remained silent and did not consent. The Licchavis, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow; by the Buddha's own spiritual power they were raised seven tāla-trees' height above the ground, and remained there suspended in the air, silent.

At that time there were also five Ganges-sands of great ministers and elders, who revered the Great Vehicle and had the strength, should any heterodox teacher slander the true Dharma, to subdue them as hail beats down grass and trees. Among them the elder Sūryaprabha, the elder Lokapāla, and the elder Dharmapāla were foremost. The offerings they had prepared were five times those that came before; together they went to the twin sāla trees, bowed their heads to the Buddha's feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we have now arranged these offerings for the Buddha and the saṅgha; we beg only, out of compassion, that you accept our offering." The Tathāgata remained silent and did not accept it. These elders, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow; by the Buddha's own spiritual power they too were raised seven tāla-trees' height above the ground, and remained there suspended in the air, silent.

At that time there were also — it should read six Ganges-sands of — the king of Vaiśālī and the ladies and dependents of his inner palace, together with every king of Jambudvīpa and their cities, towns, and villages, save only Ajātaśatru. Among them King Candravimala was foremost; each had readied four divisions of troops, wishing to go to where the Buddha was. Each of these kings commanded a retinue of one million eight hundred thousand people. Their chariot-troops were drawn by elephants and horses — elephants with six tusks, horses swift as the wind — and their ceremonial offerings surpassed those before them sixfold; the smallest of their jeweled canopies was a full eight yojanas across, the shortest banner sixteen yojanas, the lowest jeweled pole thirty-six yojanas, and the fragrance of the food they carried spread out over a full four yojanas. Also in the early morning, as the sun was rising, they carried these many fine and wondrous delicacies to the place between the twin trees, to where the Tathāgata was, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we have arranged these offerings for the Buddha and the assembly of monks; we beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, likewise did not consent. These kings, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and withdrew to one side.

The Queens, and the Heavenly Goddesses

Chinese Source

爾時復有七恒河沙諸王夫人,唯除阿闍世王夫人,為度眾生,現受女身。常觀身行,以空、無相、無願之法,薰修其心。其名曰:三界妙夫人、愛德夫人。如是等諸王夫人,皆悉安住於正法中,修行禁戒,威儀具足,憐愍眾生,等如一子,各相謂言:「今宜速往,詣世尊所。」諸王夫人,所設供養,七倍於前,香花、寶幢、繒綵、幡蓋、上妙飲食,寶蓋小者周匝縱廣十六由旬,幡最短者三十六由旬,寶幢卑者六十八由旬,飲食香氣,周遍流布滿八由旬。持如是等供養之具,往如來所,稽首佛足,遶百千匝,而白佛言:「世尊!我等為佛及比丘僧設是供具,唯願如來,哀愍受我最後供養。」如來知時,默然不受。時諸夫人,不果所願,心懷愁惱,自拔頭髮,搥胸大哭,猶如新喪所愛之子,却在一面,默然而住。

爾時復有八恒河沙諸天女等,其名曰廣目天女而為上首,作如是言:「汝等諸姊!諦觀,諦觀,是諸人眾,所設種種上妙供具,欲供如來及比丘僧。我等亦當如是,嚴設微妙供具,供養如來,如來受已,當入涅槃。諸姊!諸佛如來,出世甚難,最後供養亦復倍難;若佛涅槃,世間空虛。」是諸天女,愛樂大乘,欲聞大乘,聞已亦能為人廣說。渴仰大乘既自充足,復能充足餘渴仰者,守護大乘,若有異學,憎嫉大乘,勢能摧滅,如雹摧草。護持戒行,威儀具足,善能隨順一切世間,度未度者,脫未脫者,於未來世當轉法輪、紹三寶種,使不斷絕,修學大乘,以大莊嚴而自莊嚴,成就如是無量功德,等慈眾生,如視一子。亦於晨朝日初出時,各取種種天木香等,倍於人間所有香木,其木香氣,能滅人中種種臭穢。白車白蓋,駕四白馬,一一車上,皆張白帳,其帳四邊懸諸金鈴、種種香花、寶幢幡蓋,上妙甘饍,種種伎樂,敷師子座,其座四足純紺琉璃,於其座後,各各皆有七寶倚床,一一座前,復有金机,復以七寶而為燈樹,種種寶珠以為燈明,微妙天花遍布其地。是諸天女設是供已,心懷哀感,涕淚交流,生大苦惱。亦為利益、安樂眾生,成就大乘第一空行,顯發如來方便密教,亦為不斷種種說法,往詣佛所,稽首佛足,遶百千匝,而白佛言:「世尊!唯願如來,哀受我等最後供養。」如來知時,默然不受。諸天女等,不果所願,心懷憂惱。却在一面,默然而坐。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time there were also seven Ganges-sands of royal consorts, save only the consort of King Ajātaśatru, who, in order to save beings, had taken on a woman's body, constantly contemplating the body's conduct and steeping their minds in the dharma of emptiness, signlessness, and wishlessness. Among them Queen Trailokyasundarī and Queen Guṇapriyā were foremost. All these royal consorts abided in the true Dharma, practicing the moral precepts, fully accomplished in their bearing, caring for beings as though each were an only child. They said to one another: "We should go now, quickly, to where the World-Honored One is." The offerings these queens prepared surpassed those before them sevenfold — incense, flowers, jeweled banner-poles, silk brocade, canopies, and the finest food and drink; the smallest of their jeweled canopies measured sixteen yojanas across, the shortest banner thirty-six yojanas, the lowest jeweled pole sixty-eight yojanas, and the fragrance of their food and drink spread out over a full eight yojanas. Carrying offerings of this kind to where the Tathāgata was, they bowed their heads to his feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we have arranged these offerings for the Buddha and the assembly of monks; we beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept it. These queens, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow; tearing at their own hair and beating their breasts in loud weeping, like women who have just lost a beloved child, they withdrew to one side, and remained there in silence.

At that time there were also eight Ganges-sands of heavenly goddesses, among whom the goddess Vipulanetrā was foremost, who said: "Sisters, look — look carefully at these many fine and wondrous offerings prepared to honor the Tathāgata and the assembly of monks. We too should prepare offerings just as fine, to make offering to the Tathāgata; once the Tathāgata has accepted them, he will enter parinirvāṇa. Sisters, a buddha's appearance in the world is exceedingly rare, and the chance to make him a final offering rarer still; once the Buddha enters parinirvāṇa, the world will be empty." These goddesses delighted in the Great Vehicle and wished to hear it, and, once having heard it, could expound it widely to others; thirsting after the Great Vehicle, having satisfied themselves they could satisfy others still thirsting, and guarded the Great Vehicle, having the power, should any heterodox teacher hold the Great Vehicle in contempt, to destroy that teaching as hail destroys grass. Upholding the precepts, fully accomplished in their bearing, skillfully according with every kind of being in the world, freeing those not yet freed, releasing those not yet released, in ages to come they would turn the wheel of the Dharma and see that the seed of the Three Jewels was never cut off; studying and practicing the Great Vehicle, adorning themselves with great adornment, they had accomplished immeasurable virtues of this kind, showing the same loving-kindness to every being as to an only child. Also in the early morning, as the sun was rising, each of them gathered every kind of heavenly incense-wood, surpassing in quantity anything found among humans, wood whose fragrance alone could dispel every foulness found in the human world. In white chariots with white canopies, drawn by four white horses, each chariot hung with a white canopy whose four edges bore golden bells, every kind of fragrant flower, jeweled banner-poles and canopies, the finest delicacies, and every kind of music, they set out lion-thrones whose four legs were of pure dark-blue lapis lazuli, behind each throne a couch of the seven treasures, before each throne a golden table, and further set up lamp-trees of the seven treasures bearing every kind of jeweled lamplight, with fine heavenly flowers scattered over the whole ground. Having arranged this offering, these goddesses were overcome with sorrowful feeling, tears streaming down, filled with great anguish. Wishing likewise to benefit and bring peace to beings, to accomplish the Great Vehicle's foremost practice of emptiness, to reveal the Tathāgata's skillful and hidden teaching, and to keep the teaching of the Dharma from ceasing, they went to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept it. These goddesses, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and withdrew to one side, sitting there in silence.

Nāgas, Spirits, and the Lesser Assemblies

Chinese Source

爾時復有九恒河沙諸龍王等,住於四方,其名曰:和修吉龍王、難陀龍王、婆難陀龍王而為上首。是諸龍王,亦於晨朝日初出時,設諸供具,倍於人天,持至佛所,稽首佛足,遶百千匝,而白佛言:「唯願如來,哀受我等最後供養。」如來知時,默然不受。是諸龍王,不果所願,心懷愁惱,却坐一面。

爾時復有十恒河沙諸鬼神王,毘沙門王而為上首,各相謂言:「仁等,今者可速詣佛所。」設供具倍於諸龍,持往佛所,稽首佛足,遶百千匝,而白佛言:「唯願如來,哀受我等最後供養。」如來知時,默然不許。是諸鬼王,不果所願,心懷愁惱,却坐一面。

爾時復有二十恒河沙金翅鳥王,降怨鳥王而為上首。復有三十恒河沙乾闥婆王,那羅達王而為上首。復有四十恒河沙緊那羅王,善見王而為上首。復有五十恒河沙摩睺羅伽王,大善見王而為上首。復有六十恒河沙阿修羅王,睒婆利王而為上首。復有七十恒河沙陀那婆王,無垢河水王、跋提達多王等而為上首。復有八十恒河沙羅剎王,可畏王而為上首,捨離惡心,更不食人,於怨憎中生慈悲心,其形醜陋,以佛神力皆悉端正。復有九十恒河沙樹林神王,樂香王而為上首。復有千恒河沙持呪王,大幻持呪王而為上首。復有一億恒河沙貪色鬼魅,善見王而為上首。復有百億恒河沙天諸娙女,藍婆女、欝婆尸女、帝路沾女、毘舍佉女而為上首。復有千億恒河沙地諸鬼王,白濕王而為上首。復有十萬億恒河沙等諸天子及諸天王、四天王等。復有十萬億恒河沙等四方風神,吹諸樹上時非時花散雙樹間。復有十萬億恒河沙等主雲雨神,皆作是念:「如來涅槃焚身之時,我當注雨,令火時滅,眾中熱悶為作清涼。」

復有二十恒河沙大香象王,羅睺象王、金色象王、甘味象王、紺眼象王,欲香象王等而為上首,敬重大乘,愛樂大乘,知佛不久當般涅槃,各各拔取無量無邊諸妙蓮花,來至佛所,頭面禮佛,却住一面。復有二十恒河沙等師子獸王,師子吼王而為上首,施與一切眾生無畏。持諸花菓,來至佛所,稽首佛足,却住一面。復有二十恒河沙等諸飛鳥王,鳧鴈、鴛鴦、孔雀諸鳥,乾闥婆鳥、迦蘭陀鳥、鴝鵒鸚鵡、俱翅羅鳥、婆嘻伽鳥、迦陵頻伽鳥、耆婆耆婆鳥,如是等諸鳥,持諸花菓,來至佛所,稽首佛足,却住一面。復有二十恒河沙等水牛牛羊,往至佛所,出妙香乳,其乳流滿拘尸那城所有溝坑,色香美味悉皆具足,成是事已,却住一面。復有二十恒河沙等四天下中諸神仙人,忍辱仙等而為上首,持諸香花及諸甘果,來詣佛所,稽首佛足,遶佛三匝,而白佛言:「唯願世尊,哀受我等最後供養。」如來知時默然不許。時諸仙人,不果所願。心懷愁惱,却住一面。閻浮提中一切蜂王,妙音蜂王而為上首,持種種花來詣佛所,稽首佛足,遶佛一匝,却住一面。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time there were also nine Ganges-sands of nāga kings dwelling in the four directions, among whom the nāga king Vāsuki, the nāga king Nanda, and the nāga king Upananda were foremost. These nāga kings, also in the early morning as the sun was rising, prepared offerings surpassing those of humans and gods, carried them to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, and said to the Buddha: "We beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept it. These nāga kings, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and withdrew to sit to one side.

At that time there were also ten Ganges-sands of spirit kings, among whom Vaiśravaṇa was foremost, who said to one another: "Friends, let us go quickly now to where the Buddha is." Preparing offerings surpassing those of the nāgas, they carried them to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, circled him a hundred thousand times, and said to the Buddha: "We beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not consent. These spirit kings, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and withdrew to sit to one side.

At that time there were also twenty Ganges-sands of garuḍa kings, with the garuḍa king Vairocanavat foremost; thirty Ganges-sands of gandharva kings, with the gandharva king Naradatta foremost; forty Ganges-sands of kinnara kings, with the kinnara king Sudṛṣṭi foremost; fifty Ganges-sands of mahoraga kings, with the mahoraga king Mahāsudṛṣṭi foremost; sixty Ganges-sands of asura kings, with the asura king Śambara foremost; seventy Ganges-sands of dānava kings, with the dānava king Vimalajala and King Bhadradatta foremost; eighty Ganges-sands of rākṣasa kings, with the rākṣasa king Bhīṣaṇa foremost, who had abandoned their cruelty and no longer devoured men, giving rise to compassion even toward those they once hated, and whose forms — once hideous — were, by the Buddha's own spiritual power, made handsome; ninety Ganges-sands of forest-spirit kings, with the forest-spirit king Gandhābhirata foremost; a thousand Ganges-sands of spell-holding kings, with the spell-holding king Mahāmāyā foremost; a hundred million Ganges-sands of desire-clouded demons, with King Sudṛṣṭi foremost; ten billion Ganges-sands of heavenly maidens, with the maiden Lambā, the maiden Utpalā, the maiden Trapuṣā, and the maiden Viśākhā foremost; a trillion Ganges-sands of earth-spirit kings, with the earth-spirit king Avakīrṇa foremost; and a hundred thousand million Ganges-sands of devas, deva-kings, and the four heavenly kings. There were also a hundred thousand million Ganges-sands of wind spirits of the four directions, blowing flowers in and out of season down from the trees to scatter them between the twin sāla trees; and a hundred thousand million Ganges-sands of cloud-and-rain spirits, every one thinking: "When the Tathāgata's body is cremated at his parinirvāṇa, I will pour down rain to quench the flames in time, and bring coolness to the assembly overcome by the heat."

There were also twenty Ganges-sands of great fragrant elephant kings — the elephant king Rāhu, the elephant king Suvarṇa, the elephant king Madhurarasa, the elephant king Añjananetra, and the elephant king Kāmagandha foremost among them — who, revering and delighting in the Great Vehicle and knowing the Buddha would soon enter parinirvāṇa, each gathered countless fine lotus flowers and came to where the Buddha was, bowing their heads to the ground in reverence, and withdrew to one side. There were also twenty Ganges-sands of lion kings among the beasts, with the lion king Siṃhanāda foremost, granters of fearlessness to every being, who brought flowers and fruit to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, and withdrew to one side. There were also twenty Ganges-sands of kings among the birds — wild geese, mandarin ducks, peacocks, gandharva-birds, kalandaka-birds, mynahs, parrots, kokila-birds, jīvaṃjīvaka-birds, and kaḷaviṅka-birds, and birds like these — who brought flowers and fruit to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, and withdrew to one side. There were also twenty Ganges-sands of water buffalo, cattle, and sheep, who came to where the Buddha was and gave forth fragrant milk, flowing enough to fill every ditch and hollow in the city of Kuśinagara, complete in color, fragrance, and flavor; having done this, they withdrew to one side. There were also twenty Ganges-sands of sages and seers throughout the four continents, with the seer Kṣāntivādin foremost, who brought fragrant flowers and sweet fruit to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, circled the Buddha three times, and said to the Buddha: "We beg only that the World-Honored One, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not consent. These seers, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and withdrew to one side. And every bee-king throughout Jambudvīpa, with the bee-king Madhurasvara foremost, brought every kind of flower to where the Buddha was, bowed his head to the Buddha's feet, circled the Buddha once, and withdrew to one side.

The Saṅgha Gathers, and the Forest Turns White

Chinese Source

爾時閻浮提中比丘、比丘尼一切皆集,唯除尊者摩訶迦葉、阿難二眾。

復有無量阿僧祇恒河沙等世界中間,及閻浮提所有諸山,須彌山王而為上首,其山莊嚴,叢林蓊欝,諸樹茂盛,枝條扶踈,蔭蔽日光,種種妙花周遍而有,龍泉流水清淨香潔。諸天、龍、神、乾闥婆、阿修羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽,神仙呪術,作倡伎樂,如是等眾,彌滿其中。是諸山神,亦來詣佛,稽首佛足,却住一面。

復有阿僧祇恒河沙等四大海神及諸河神,有大威德,具大神足,所設供養,倍勝於前。諸神身光伎樂燈明,悉蔽日月令不復現。以占婆花散熙連河,來至佛所,稽首佛足,却住一面。

爾時拘尸那城娑羅樹林,其林變白,猶如白鶴。於虛空中,自然而有七寶堂閣,彫文刻鏤,綺飾分明,周匝欄楯,眾寶雜廁。堂下多有流泉浴池,上妙蓮花彌滿其中,猶如北方欝單越國,亦如忉利歡喜之園。爾時娑羅樹林中間,種種莊嚴,甚可愛樂,亦復如是。是諸天、人、阿修羅等,咸覩如來涅槃之相,皆悉悲感,愁憂不樂。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time every monk and nun throughout Jambudvīpa had gathered, save only the venerable Mahākāśyapa and Ānanda.

There were also, among countless asaṃkhyeya Ganges-sands of worlds and throughout every mountain of Jambudvīpa, with Mount Sumeru foremost, mountains adorned with dense forest, trees flourishing with spreading branches shading the sunlight, every kind of fine flower blooming throughout, and springs and streams pure and fragrant, filled everywhere with devas, nāgas, spirits, gandharvas, asuras, garuḍas, kinnaras, mahoragas, sages skilled in spells, and players of every kind of music. The spirits of these mountains also came to the Buddha, bowed their heads to his feet, and withdrew to one side.

There were also asaṃkhyeya Ganges-sands of spirits of the four great oceans and of every river, of great majestic virtue and great spiritual power, whose offerings surpassed all those before them; the light of their bodies and their music and lamps outshone the sun and moon entirely. Scattering campaka flowers over the Nairañjanā River, they came to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, and withdrew to one side.

At that time the sāla forest at the city of Kuśinagara turned white, like a flock of white cranes. In the sky above there naturally appeared pavilions of the seven treasures, carved and engraved, brightly adorned, railed all around, inlaid with every kind of jewel. Beneath these pavilions were many flowing springs and bathing pools, filled everywhere with the finest lotus flowers, like the northern continent of Uttarakuru, or like the Garden of Delight in the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven. The sāla forest all around, adorned in every way, was likewise a scene of the greatest beauty. Every deva, human, and asura who beheld this sign of the Tathāgata's parinirvāṇa was overcome with sorrow, grieving and disconsolate.

Reading note — after Huiyuan

Huiyuan raises, and answers, the plainest objection a reader could bring to this whole scene: if the whitened forest and the jeweled pure land are meant as further signs of the Buddha's approaching death, why does the sūtra later go on to call this same forest "delightful," rather than a mark of dying and decay? He rejects the reading that the forest's white color signifies death by comparison to a corpse's pallor — noting that the text itself calls the whitened forest "delightful, like a flock of cranes," language no one would use of a death-mark — and rejects equally the claim that the jeweled pure land is unrelated to the parinirvāṇa signs because its beauty is produced by the purified minds of the assembled beings rather than by the Buddha himself: the very next line, he points out, states plainly that "by the Buddha's own spiritual power the ground became soft," crediting the transformation to the Buddha, not the crowd. His resolution is that a forest changing its very appearance, and a whole land turning into something like Amitābha's own pure land, serve exactly the same rhetorical purpose as the sound and the light that opened the chapter: this-worldly beings, still hoping their teacher has not really left them, need to be shown unmistakably that departure is imminent — and a landscape transforming under their own eyes accomplishes that more forcefully than any further announcement could.

The Heavens Bring Their Utmost, and Māra's Spell

Chinese Source

爾時四天王釋提桓因,各相謂言:「汝等觀察,諸天、世人及阿修羅,大設供養,欲於最後供養如來。我等亦當如是供養,若我最後得供養者,檀波羅蜜則為成就滿足不難。」爾時四天王所設供養,倍勝於前,持曼陀羅花、摩訶曼陀羅花、迦枳樓伽花、摩訶迦枳樓伽花、曼殊沙花、摩訶曼殊沙花、散多尼迦花、摩訶散多尼迦花、愛樂花、大愛樂花、普賢花、大普賢花、時花、大時花、香城花、大香城花、歡喜花、大歡喜花、發欲花、大發欲花、香醉花、大香醉花、普香花、大普香花、天金葉花、龍華、波利質多樹花、拘毘羅樹花,復持種種上妙甘饍,來至佛所,稽首佛足。是諸天人所有光明,能覆日月,令不復現。以是供具,欲供養佛。如來知時,默然不受。爾時諸天,不果所願,愁憂苦惱,却住一面。

爾時釋提桓因及三十三天,設諸供具亦倍勝前,及所持花亦復如是,香氣微妙甚可愛樂,持得勝堂并諸小堂,來至佛所,稽首佛足,而白佛言:「世尊,我等深樂、愛護大乘,唯願如來哀受我食。」如來知時,默然不受。時諸釋天,不果所願,心懷愁惱,却住一面。

乃至第六天,所設供養展轉勝前,寶幢幡蓋。寶蓋小者覆四天下,幡最短者周圍四海,幢最卑者至自在天,微風吹幡,出妙音聲。持上甘饍,來詣佛所,稽首佛足,白佛言:「世尊,唯願如來哀受我等最後供養。」如來知時默然不受。是諸天等,不果所願,心懷愁惱,却住一面。

上至有頂,其餘梵眾,一切來集。爾時大梵天王及餘梵眾,放身光明,遍四天下。欲界、人、天,日月光明,悉不復現。持諸寶幢、繒綵、幡蓋,幡極短者懸於梵宮至娑羅樹間,來詣佛所,稽首佛足,白佛言:「世尊!唯願如來,哀受我等最後供養。」如來知時,默然不受。爾時諸梵不果所願,心懷愁惱,却住一面。

爾時毘摩質多阿修羅王,與無量阿修羅大眷屬俱,身諸光明,勝於梵天,持諸寶幢、繒綵、幡蓋,其蓋小者覆千世界,上妙甘饍,來詣佛所,稽首佛足,而白佛言:「唯願如來,哀受我等最後供養。」如來知時,默然不受。諸阿修羅,不果所願,心懷愁惱,却住一面。

爾時欲界魔王波旬與其眷屬、諸天婇女,無量無邊阿僧祇眾,開地獄門,施清冷水,因而告曰:「汝等今者,無所能為,唯當專念如來、應、正遍知,建立最後隨喜供養,當令汝等長夜獲安。」時魔波旬於地獄中,悉除刀劍無量苦毒,熾然炎火注雨滅之。以佛神力,復發是心,令諸眷屬,皆捨刀劍、弓弩、鎧仗、鉾槊、長鉤、金鎚、鉞斧、鬪輪、羂索,所持供養,倍勝一切人天所設,其蓋小者覆中千界,來至佛所,稽首佛足,而白佛言:「我等今者,愛樂大乘,守護大乘。世尊!若有善男子善女人,為供養故、為怖畏故、為誑他故、為財利故、為隨他故受是大乘,或真或偽,我等爾時當為是人,除滅怖畏,說如是呪:「『啅抧 吒吒羅啅抧 盧呵隷 摩訶盧呵隷 阿羅 遮羅 多羅 莎呵』「是呪能令諸失心者、怖畏者、說法者、不斷正法者,為伏外道故、護己身故、護正法故、護大乘故,說如是呪。若有能持如是呪者,無惡象怖,若至曠野、空澤、嶮處不生怖畏,亦無水火、師子虎狼、盜賊王難。世尊!若有能持如是呪者,悉能除滅如是等怖。世尊!持是呪者,我當護之,如龜藏六。世尊!我等今者,不以諭諂說如是事,持是呪者,我當至誠,益其勢力。唯願如來,哀受我等最後供養。」爾時佛告魔波旬言:「我不受汝飲食供養,我已受汝所說神呪,為欲安樂一切眾生、四部眾故。」佛說是已,默然不受。如是三請,皆亦不受。時魔波旬,不果所願,心懷愁惱,却住一面。

爾時大自在天王與其眷屬無量無邊,及諸天眾,所設供具,悉覆梵、釋、護世四王、人天八部、及非人等所有供具。梵釋所設,猶如聚墨在珂貝邊,悉不復現。寶蓋小者能覆三千大千世界。持如是等供養之具,來詣佛所,稽首佛足,遶無數匝,白佛言:「世尊!我等所獻微末供具,喻如蚊子供養於我,亦如有人以一掬水投於大海,然一小燈助百千日,春夏之月眾花茂盛,有持一花益於眾花,以亭歷子益須彌山,豈當有益大海、日明、眾花、須彌。世尊!我今所奉微末供具,亦復如是。若以三千大千世界滿中香花、伎樂、幡蓋,供養如來,尚不足言。何以故?如來為諸眾生,常於地獄、餓鬼、畜生諸惡趣中,受諸苦惱。是故世尊!應見哀愍,受我等供。」

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time the Four Heavenly Kings and Śakra said to one another: "Look — the gods, the people of the world, and the asuras have all prepared great offerings, wishing to make a final offering to the Tathāgata. We too should offer in just this way; if we can be the ones to make the very last offering, the perfection of giving will be fulfilled for us without any difficulty." The offerings the Four Heavenly Kings then prepared surpassed all those before, mandārava and great mandārava flowers, kakāravaka and great kakāravaka flowers, mañjūṣaka and great mañjūṣaka flowers, santānaka and great santānaka flowers, "beloved" and "greatly beloved" flowers, samantabhadra and great samantabhadra flowers, seasonal and great seasonal flowers, "fragrant-city" and "great fragrant-city" flowers, joyful and greatly joyful flowers, desire-arousing and greatly desire-arousing flowers, fragrance-intoxicating and greatly fragrance-intoxicating flowers, universally fragrant and greatly universally fragrant flowers, heavenly golden-leaved flowers, dragon-flowers, pārijāta blossoms, and kovidāra blossoms — and, further bearing every kind of fine delicacy, they came to where the Buddha was and bowed their heads to his feet. The light shining from these gods and their retinues was bright enough to eclipse the sun and moon entirely. With these offerings they wished to honor the Buddha. The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept them. These gods, their wish ungranted, were sorrowful and distressed, and withdrew to one side.

At that time Śakra and the gods of the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven prepared offerings likewise surpassing all those before, their flowers just as fine, their fragrance subtle and altogether delightful; bringing both the Hall of Total Victory and its lesser halls, they came to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we delight deeply in the Great Vehicle and cherish it; we beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our food." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept it. These gods of Śakra's heaven, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and withdrew to one side.

And so on up through the sixth heaven, each offering surpassing the one before it further still — jeweled banner-poles and canopies, the smallest canopy covering all four continents, the shortest banner encircling the four seas, the lowest banner-pole reaching to the Heaven of Freely Enjoying Others' Creations, a faint breeze stirring the banners to send out a wondrous sound. Bearing the finest delicacies, they came to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept it. These gods, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and withdrew to one side.

Up to the very summit of existence, all the remaining hosts of the Brahmā heavens now gathered as well. The Great Brahmā King and the rest of the Brahmā host sent forth from their bodies a light that spread throughout the four continents, so that the light of sun and moon in the desire realm, among humans and gods alike, was entirely eclipsed. Bearing jeweled banner-poles, silk brocade, and canopies, the shortest banner stretching all the way from the Brahmā palace down to the sāla trees, they came to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept it. These Brahmā gods, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and withdrew to one side.

At that time the asura king Vemacitra, together with his immeasurable great retinue of asuras, their bodies giving off a light surpassing even the Brahmā heavens, bearing jeweled banner-poles, silk brocade, canopies — the smallest canopy covering a thousand worlds — and the finest delicacies, came to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, and said to the Buddha: "We beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept it. These asuras, their wish ungranted, were filled with sorrow, and withdrew to one side.

At that time Māra Pāpīyas, lord of the desire realm, together with his retinue and the heavenly maidens of his court — an assembly numbering immeasurable, boundless asaṃkhyeyas — threw open the gates of hell and poured out cool, refreshing water, saying to the beings there: "There is nothing more you yourselves can do; you need only fix your minds wholly on the Tathāgata, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Awakened One, and join in this final offering with a rejoicing heart, and you will find ease through the long night to come." Māra Pāpīyas then removed from hell every knife and sword and every measure of agony, and put out the blazing flames with pouring rain. Moved further by the Buddha's own spiritual power, he resolved as well to have all his retinue lay down their swords, bows and arrows, armor and weapons, spears, hooked lances, iron maces, battle-axes, war-discs, and snares. The offerings he then brought surpassed everything offered by every human and god before him, the smallest of his canopies covering a middling-thousand world-system; coming to where the Buddha was, he bowed his head to the Buddha's feet, and said to the Buddha: "We now delight in the Great Vehicle and guard the Great Vehicle. World-Honored One, should any good son or good daughter take up this Great Vehicle for the sake of gain, out of fear, to deceive others, for profit, or merely because someone else insisted — whether their motive be genuine or false — we will, for the sake of such a person, dispel their fear, and speak this spell: 'Ḍākṣi, ṭaṭara-ḍākṣi, lohile, mahālohile, ara, cara, tara, svāhā.' This spell can free anyone who has lost heart, anyone who is afraid, anyone who teaches the Dharma, and anyone who has not abandoned the true Dharma — we speak it in order to subdue heterodox teachers, to protect that person's own body, to protect the true Dharma, and to protect the Great Vehicle. Whoever is able to uphold this spell will have no fear of a savage elephant; journeying through the wilderness, an empty marsh, or dangerous terrain, they will feel no fear, nor will they fear flood or fire, lion or tiger or wolf, bandits, or the danger of kings. World-Honored One, whoever is able to uphold this spell will have every fear of this kind entirely dispelled. World-Honored One, whoever upholds this spell, I myself will protect, the way a tortoise draws in all six of its limbs. World-Honored One, we do not say this now out of flattery; whoever upholds this spell, we will, in all sincerity, add to their strength. We beg only that the Tathāgata, out of compassion, accept our final offering." The Buddha then said to Māra Pāpīyas: "I do not accept your offering of food and drink, but I have already accepted the sacred spell you have spoken, for the sake of bringing peace and happiness to all beings, to the fourfold assembly." Having said this, the Buddha remained silent and did not accept the offering. Though asked three times in this way, he refused every time. Māra Pāpīyas, his wish ungranted, was filled with sorrow, and withdrew to one side.

At that time the great god Maheśvara, together with his immeasurable, boundless retinue and the host of gods with him, brought offerings that eclipsed entirely those of Brahmā, Śakra, the Four Heavenly Kings who guard the world, the eightfold host of gods and men, and every non-human being besides — set beside his, their offerings vanished like a smudge of ink beside a shell of mother-of-pearl. The smallest of his jeweled canopies was able to cover the whole trichiliocosm. Bringing offerings of this kind, he came to where the Buddha was, bowed his head to the Buddha's feet, circled him countless times, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, the paltry offering we present is like a mosquito's tribute brought to me; it is like a single handful of water thrown into the great ocean, a single small lamp added to a hundred thousand suns, a single flower added to the flourishing blossoms of spring and summer, a single mustard seed added to Mount Sumeru — how could such a thing add anything at all to the great ocean, to the light of the sun, to a wealth of flowers, to Mount Sumeru? World-Honored One, the paltry offering I now present is just the same. Even were the whole trichiliocosm filled with incense, flowers, music, and canopies and offered to the Tathāgata, it would still not be enough to speak of. Why is this? Because the Tathāgata, for the sake of every being, forever endures suffering on their behalf within hell, among the hungry ghosts, among the animals, and in every other evil destiny. For this reason, World-Honored One, you should look on us with compassion, and accept our offering."

Reading note — after Huiyuan

Huiyuan reads this entire escalating sequence of refusals as building toward a single deferred payoff still several fascicles away. He gives four distinct reasons the Buddha declines every offering here, none of them a matter of the food or flowers themselves being unworthy: first, accepting any one group's gift now would signal to every other group waiting its turn that further offering is pointless, cutting the assembly's collective generosity short; second, and most pointed, accepting anyone's offering before Cunda's own would rob Cunda specifically of the chance to be the one whose gift the Buddha finally receives, and this sūtra's own theology of the Buddha's constant, eternal body is going to be taught precisely through that acceptance; third, refusal keeps every donor's mind focused on the weight of what they are trying to give, rather than settling into satisfaction once some other party's gift succeeds; and fourth — the reason Huiyuan calls decisive — the Buddha has not yet, at this point in the text, actually taught Cunda the doctrine of the permanent Dharma-body, and accepting an ordinary offering now, before that teaching is given, would let the assembly mistake the acceptance for confirmation of an ordinary, impermanent death rather than what the sūtra is building toward. Every refusal in this fascicle, on Huiyuan's reading, is holding a place open for one specific meal still to come.

On Māra's appearance in this scene — an episode many readers find startling on its own terms, since Māra is elsewhere in the canon this sūtra's assembly's most reliable adversary — Huiyuan reads him here as one of the "inconceivable bodhisattvas" (不思議菩薩) who periodically take on Māra's own form and function as a kind of expedient teaching device, citing this same principle to explain how Maheśvara, similarly, can appear both as an ordinary god paying homage and, per Nāgārjuna's testimony that he elsewhere cites, as a tenth-ground bodhisattva residing among the pure abodes. Nothing about the sūtra's plain language forces this reading, Huiyuan concedes, but it resolves what would otherwise be a jarring inconsistency: a figure defined throughout the tradition by opposition to the Dharma, shown here freeing beings from hell and composing a protective spell explicitly to safeguard the Great Vehicle he supposedly despises.

The Bodhisattva from the East, and Mañjuśrī's Reassurance

Chinese Source

爾時東方去此無量無數阿僧祇恒河沙數微塵等世界,彼有佛土,名意樂美音,佛號虛空等如來、應供、正遍知、明行足、善逝、世間解、無上士、調御丈夫、天人師、佛、世尊。爾時彼佛即告第一大弟子言:「善男子!汝今宜往西方娑婆世界,彼土有佛,號釋迦牟尼如來、應供、正遍知、明行足、善逝、世間解、無上士、調御丈夫、天人師、佛、世尊,彼佛不久當般涅槃。善男子!汝可持此世界香飯——其飯香美,食之安隱——可以此食,奉獻彼佛世尊,世尊食已,入般涅槃。善男子!并可禮敬,請決所疑。」

爾時無邊身菩薩摩訶薩即受佛教,從座而起,稽首佛足,右遶三匝,與無量阿僧祇菩薩俱,從彼國發,來至此娑婆世界。應時此間三千大千世界大地,六種震動。於是眾中,梵、釋、四天王、魔王波旬、摩醯首羅,如是大眾,見是地動,舉身毛竪,喉舌枯燥,驚怖戰慄,各欲四散。自見其身,無復光明,所有威德,殄滅無餘。

是時文殊師利法王子,即從座起,告諸大眾:「諸善男子!汝等勿怖,汝等勿怖。何以故?東方去此無量無數阿僧祇恒河沙微塵等世界,有世界名意樂美音,佛號虛空等如來、應、正遍知,十號具足,彼有菩薩名無邊身,與無量菩薩,欲來至此供養如來。以彼菩薩威德力故,令汝身光悉不復現。是故汝等應生歡喜,勿懷恐怖。」爾時大眾,悉皆遙見彼佛大眾,如明鏡中自觀己身。

時文殊師利復告大眾:「汝今所見彼佛大眾,如見此佛。以佛神力,復當如是得見九方無量諸佛。」爾時大眾各相謂言:「苦哉,苦哉!世間空虛,如來不久當般涅槃。」

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time, in a direction to the east, past worlds as numerous as the motes of dust in incalculable asaṃkhyeya Ganges-sands, there was a buddha-land called Delightful and Beautiful Sound, whose buddha was named Ākāśasama Tathāgata, Worthy One, Perfectly Awakened One, Perfect in Wisdom and Conduct, Well-Gone One, Knower of the World, Peerless Guide, Tamer of Beings, Teacher of Gods and Humans, Buddha, World-Honored One. This buddha said to his foremost great disciple: "Good son, you should now go west to the Sahā world; there is a buddha there named Śākyamuni Tathāgata, Worthy One, Perfectly Awakened One, Perfect in Wisdom and Conduct, Well-Gone One, Knower of the World, Peerless Guide, Tamer of Beings, Teacher of Gods and Humans, Buddha, World-Honored One, who will before long enter parinirvāṇa. Good son, take with you the fragrant rice of this world — its fragrance and flavor bring perfect ease to whoever eats it — and offer this food to that World-Honored One; once he has eaten it, he will enter parinirvāṇa. Good son, pay him homage as well, and ask him to resolve whatever doubts remain."

At that time the bodhisattva-mahāsattva named Boundless Body received this instruction, rose from his seat, bowed his head to the Buddha's feet, circled him three times to the right, and, together with countless asaṃkhyeya bodhisattvas, set out from that land and arrived in this Sahā world. At that very moment, the great earth of this trichiliocosm quaked in six ways. Among the assembly here, Brahmā, Śakra, the Four Heavenly Kings, Māra Pāpīyas, and Maheśvara — all these great beings, seeing the earth quake, felt the hair stand up on their whole bodies, their throats and tongues run dry, and, terrified and trembling, each wished to flee in every direction; they saw their own bodies had lost all light, their majestic virtue entirely extinguished, with nothing left of it at all.

At that moment the Dharma-prince Mañjuśrī rose from his seat and said to the whole assembly: "Good sons, do not be afraid — do not be afraid. Why is this? In a direction to the east, past worlds as numerous as the motes of dust in incalculable asaṃkhyeya Ganges-sands, there is a world called Delightful and Beautiful Sound, whose buddha is named Ākāśasama Tathāgata, Worthy One, Perfectly Awakened One, complete with all ten epithets. There is a bodhisattva there named Boundless Body, who, together with countless bodhisattvas, wishes to come here to make offering to the Tathāgata. It is by that bodhisattva's own majestic power that your own bodies' light has entirely vanished. You should therefore feel joy, and hold no fear." At that moment the whole assembly could see, from far off, that buddha's own assembly, as clearly as seeing their own reflection in a bright mirror.

Mañjuśrī then said further to the assembly: "What you now see of that buddha's assembly is exactly as you now see this Buddha before you. By the Buddha's own spiritual power, you will likewise come to see, in just this way, the immeasurable buddhas of the nine other directions." At that moment the whole assembly said to one another: "How bitter, how bitter! The world is empty — the Tathāgata will before long enter parinirvāṇa."

The Cities Within Every Pore

Chinese Source

是時大眾一切悉見無邊身菩薩及其眷屬,是菩薩身,一一毛孔,各各出生一大蓮花,一一蓮花各有七萬八千城邑,縱廣正等如毘耶離城,牆壁諸塹七寶雜廁,多羅寶樹七重行列,人民熾盛安隱豐樂,閻浮檀金以為却敵,一一却敵,各有種種七寶,林樹花果茂盛,微風吹動出微妙音,其聲和雅,猶如天樂。城中人民,聞是音聲,即得受於上妙快樂。是諸塹中,妙水盈滿,清淨香潔如真琉璃。是諸水中有七寶船,諸人乘之遊戲澡浴,共相娛樂,快樂無極。復有無量雜色蓮花,優鉢羅花、拘物頭花、波頭摩花、分陀利花,其花縱廣猶如車輪。其塹岸上,多有園林,一一園中有五泉池,是諸池中復有諸花,優鉢羅花、拘物頭花、波頭摩花、分陀利花,其花縱廣亦如車輪,香氣馚馥,甚可愛樂。其水清淨柔軟第一,鳧鴈鴛鴦遊戲其中。其園各有眾寶宮宅,一一宮宅縱廣正等滿四由旬,所有牆壁四寶所成,所謂金銀琉璃頗梨,真金為嚮,周匝欄楯,玫瑰為地,金沙布上。是宮宅中,多有七寶流泉浴池,一一池邊,各有十八黃金梯陛,閻浮檀金為芭蕉樹,如忉利天歡喜之園。是一一城,各有八萬四千人王,一一諸王,各有無量夫人、婇女,共相娛樂,歡喜受樂。其餘人民,亦復如是,各於住處,共相娛樂。是中眾生,不聞餘名,純聞無上大乘之聲。是諸花中,一一各有師子之座,其座四足皆紺琉璃,柔軟素衣以布座上,其衣微妙出過三界。一一座上,有一王坐,以大乘法教化眾生,或有眾生書持、讀誦,如說修行,如是流布大乘經典。爾時無邊身菩薩,安止如是無量眾生,於自身已令捨世樂,皆作是言:「苦哉,苦哉!世間空虛,如來不久當般涅槃。」

爾時無邊身菩薩,與無量菩薩周匝圍遶,示現如是神通力已,持是種種無量供具,及以上妙香美飲食,若有得聞是食香氣,煩惱諸垢皆悉消滅。以是菩薩神通力故,一切大眾悉皆得見如是變化。無邊身菩薩身大無邊、量同虛空,唯除諸佛,餘無能見是菩薩身其量邊際。爾時無邊身菩薩及其眷屬,所設供養倍勝於前,來至佛所,稽首佛足,合掌恭敬白佛言:「世尊!唯願哀愍,受我等食。」如來知時,默然不受。如是三請,悉亦不受。爾時無邊身菩薩及其眷屬,却住一面。

南西北方諸佛世界,亦有無量無邊身菩薩,所持供養倍勝於前,來至佛所,乃至却住一面,皆亦如是。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that moment the whole assembly could see, in full, the bodhisattva Boundless Body together with his retinue. From every single pore of this bodhisattva's body there sprang forth a great lotus flower, and within every lotus flower were seventy-eight thousand cities, each equal in size to the city of Vaiśālī, its walls and moats inlaid throughout with the seven treasures, lined with seven rows of jeweled tāla trees, its people thriving, at ease, and prosperous, its ramparts made of Jambūnada gold, each rampart adorned with every kind of the seven treasures, its groves and flowering trees flourishing, a faint breeze stirring them to send out a subtle, harmonious sound like heavenly music. The people of these cities, on hearing this sound, at once experienced the finest happiness. These moats were filled with fine water, pure and fragrant as true lapis lazuli, and upon this water floated boats of the seven treasures, on which people rode about, bathing and playing together, in boundless delight. There were also countless lotus flowers of every color — blue, red, white, and the great white lotus — each as broad as a chariot wheel. On the banks of these moats were many gardens, each garden with five springs and pools, and within these pools further lotus flowers of every color, each as broad as a chariot wheel, richly fragrant and entirely delightful. The water there was pure, soft, and of the finest quality, and wild geese and mandarin ducks played upon it. Each garden had jeweled palaces, every palace exactly four yojanas across, its walls made of the four treasures — gold, silver, lapis lazuli, and crystal — with railings of true gold running all around, its ground of rose-colored gems overlaid with golden sand. Within these palaces were many flowing springs and bathing pools of the seven treasures, each pool with eighteen golden steps leading down to it, and plantain trees of Jambūnada gold, just like the Garden of Delight in the Trāyastriṃśa Heaven. Each of these cities had eighty-four thousand human kings, and each king had countless queens and court ladies, delighting together in joy and pleasure; the rest of the people likewise delighted together, each in their own dwelling. The beings there heard no name at all besides the sound of the peerless Great Vehicle. Within each of these lotus flowers stood a lion-throne, its four legs of dark-blue lapis lazuli, spread over with a soft white garment finer than anything found in the three realms; on each throne sat a king, teaching beings with the Dharma of the Great Vehicle, and some beings there copied, upheld, read, and recited it, practicing as it taught, so that the scriptures of the Great Vehicle spread everywhere. The bodhisattva Boundless Body, having settled these countless beings and led them to give up worldly pleasure, made them all say together: "How bitter, how bitter! The world is empty — the Tathāgata will before long enter parinirvāṇa."

The bodhisattva Boundless Body, surrounded on every side by countless bodhisattvas, having manifested this display of spiritual power, then brought forward every kind of countless offering, together with the finest and most fragrant food and drink — anyone who so much as caught the scent of this food had every affliction and defilement wiped away entirely. By this bodhisattva's own spiritual power, the whole assembly was able to see this entire transformation. The bodhisattva Boundless Body's own body was vast and without limit, equal in measure to space itself; save for the buddhas, no one else could perceive the outer limit of this bodhisattva's body. The bodhisattva Boundless Body and his retinue then brought offerings surpassing all those before, came to where the Buddha was, bowed their heads to his feet, joined their palms in reverence, and said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, we beg only that you, out of compassion, accept our food." The Tathāgata, knowing the time had not come, remained silent and did not accept it. Though asked three times in this way, he refused every time. The bodhisattva Boundless Body and his retinue then withdrew to one side.

From the buddha-worlds of the south, west, and north there likewise came countless bodhisattvas named Boundless Body, bearing offerings surpassing all those before them, coming to where the Buddha was and withdrawing to one side in just the same way.

The Assembly Complete, Save One

Chinese Source

爾時娑羅雙樹吉祥福地,縱廣三十二由旬,大眾充滿,間無空缺。

爾時四方無邊身菩薩及其眷屬所坐之處,或如錐頭、針鋒、微塵,十方如微塵等諸佛世界諸大菩薩,悉來集會,及閻浮提一切大眾,亦悉來集——唯除尊者摩訶迦葉、阿難二眾,阿闍世王及其眷屬——乃至毒蛇,視能殺人蜣蜋、蝮蝎,及十六種行惡業者,一切來集。陀那婆神、阿修羅等,悉捨惡念,皆生慈心,如父、如母、如姊、如妹;三千大千世界眾生,慈心相向,亦復如是,除一闡提。

爾時三千大千世界,以佛神力故,地皆柔軟,無有丘墟、土沙、礫石、荊棘、毒草,眾寶莊嚴,猶如西方無量壽佛極樂世界。是時大眾悉見十方如微塵等諸佛世界,如於明鏡自觀己身,見諸佛土亦復如是。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time the auspicious ground between the twin sāla trees, thirty-two yojanas across, was filled entirely with the assembly, without a single empty space remaining.

At that time the places where the bodhisattvas Boundless Body from the four directions and their retinues had taken their seats were pressed so close together they were like the point of an awl, the tip of a needle, a mote of dust — and yet every great bodhisattva from buddha-worlds as numerous as motes of dust throughout the ten directions had come and gathered there, together with the whole assembly of Jambudvīpa, all likewise gathered — save only the venerable Mahākāśyapa and Ānanda, and King Ajātaśatru and his retinue. Even venomous snakes, dung beetles whose gaze alone can kill, vipers and scorpions, and beings who commit the sixteen kinds of evil deed — every one of them had come and gathered there. The dānava spirits and the asuras had all abandoned their malice and given rise to loving-kindness, regarding one another as father, mother, elder sister, younger sister; and every being throughout the trichiliocosm turned toward every other with this same loving-kindness — every being, that is, except the icchantika.

At that time, throughout the trichiliocosm, by the Buddha's own spiritual power, the ground everywhere became soft, free of hills, dust, gravel, thorns, and poisonous plants, adorned throughout with every kind of jewel, just like Amitāyus's own Pure Land of Ultimate Bliss in the west. At that moment the whole assembly could see every buddha-world throughout the ten directions, as numerous as motes of dust, as clearly as seeing their own reflection in a bright mirror, and saw that every one of these buddha-lands appeared in just this same way.

Reading note — Ru-Yi Meditation Center

This single clause — "every being throughout the trichiliocosm turned toward every other with this same loving-kindness, except the icchantika" — is the first appearance in this sūtra of a term that will become one of its most consequential and most contested. An icchantika, in the tradition this sūtra inherits, is a being whose roots of goodness are said to be so thoroughly severed that liberation is permanently closed to them; here, at the very threshold of the text, that exclusion is total enough to reach even venomous snakes and beings guilty of the most severe transgressions, all of whom are folded into the assembly's universal tenderness, while the icchantika alone stands outside it. Readers who know where this sūtra is headed will recognize the tension this single word is quietly setting up: it is precisely this text, in the fascicles ahead treating the tathāgatagarbha and buddha-nature, that will become the classical source for the claim — associated above all with the fifth-century monk Zhu Daosheng, who defended it against the consensus of his own contemporaries before a more complete version of this sūtra vindicated him — that even the icchantika possesses buddha-nature and will one day attain buddhahood. Bao Liang's sixth-century compilation of commentary on this sūtra, the Compilation of Explanations of the Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra (T1763), preserves some of the only surviving traces of Daosheng's own reasoning on this very point, and this collection will return to it when the text itself takes up the question directly.

The Buddha's Light Returns

Chinese Source

爾時如來面門所出五色光明,其光明曜覆諸大會,令彼身光,悉不復現;所應作已,還從口入。時諸天人及諸會眾,阿修羅等,見佛光明,還從口入,皆大恐怖,身毛為竪,復作是言:「如來光明出已還入,非無因緣,必於十方所作已辦,將是最後涅槃之相。何期苦哉,何期苦哉!如何?世尊一旦捨離四無量心,不受人天所奉供養,聖慧日光從今永滅,無上法船於斯沈沒。嗚呼痛哉,世間大苦。」舉手搥胸,悲號啼哭,支節戰動,不能自持,身諸毛孔流血灑地。

Ru-Yi Translation

At that time the five-colored light streaming from the Tathāgata's face shone so brightly that it eclipsed the light of every being in the whole assembly, until, its work accomplished, it withdrew back into his mouth. When the devas, humans, and every being in the assembly, the asuras among them, saw the Buddha's light return into his mouth, they were seized with great terror, the hair standing up on their bodies, and they said to one another: "The Tathāgata's light, having gone out, has now returned — this cannot be without a reason. He must have accomplished everything he needed to throughout the ten directions, and this must be the last sign before his final parinirvāṇa. How bitter this is, how bitter! What can we do? The World-Honored One is about to cast aside the four immeasurable minds all at once, and will no longer accept the offerings of humans and gods; the sun of holy wisdom is about to be extinguished forever, and the peerless ship of the Dharma is about to sink beneath the waves. Ah, how painful — this is the great suffering of the world." Raising their hands, they beat their breasts, wailing and weeping aloud, their limbs shaking so violently they could not steady themselves, and blood flowed from every pore of their bodies, spattering the ground.

Reading note — after Huiyuan

This is the sixth and last of the signs Huiyuan traces across the whole of this opening scene, and he pairs it deliberately with the very first: the great voice at the chapter's opening told the assembly when the Buddha would die and summoned them to come; this closing sign, the light's withdrawal, tells them the summons is now complete and presses the same urgency home a final time. Huiyuan reads the assembly's terror here as itself diagnostic — despite everything already shown them, the earthquake, the transfigured forest, the pure land, the arrival of bodhisattvas from every direction, this frightened crowd still has not fully absorbed that the Buddha is actually about to die, and needs one unmistakable, wordless sign to finally drive the fact home before they can receive, with anything like readiness, the teaching this sūtra exists to deliver. That teaching — beginning with the offering this whole fascicle's chain of refusals has been holding open a place for — is where Part 2 will pick up the story.

Part 1 Complete

This closes Part 1 (fascicle 1 of 40): the Buddha's final voice and healing light, the earthquake and the assembly's grief, the great chain of offerings from monks and nuns through kings, gods, and Māra himself — every one silently refused — the bodhisattva Boundless Body's arrival from the east with its vision of cities nested in every pore of his body, Mañjuśrī's reassurance, and the light's final withdrawal into the Buddha's mouth. Part 2 continues fascicle 2 of the sūtra, still within 壽命品 ("The Chapter on the Buddha's Lifespan"), where the assembly's grief finally finds a voice and the offering this chapter has been withholding draws near.

Continue to Part 2 →