The Vajra Samādhi
Having spent three entire fascicles on the first of ten merits, the sūtra now moves briskly through the second, third, fourth, fifth, and sixth: powers and perceptions a bodhisattva never had before, mind and body no longer bound to each other, a compassion that arises without any cause at all, ten vows so complete they purify an entire future buddha-land, and the famous vajra samādhi — a concentration that shatters every dharma without diminishing itself in the slightest, exactly as a diamond can cut anything and never be cut.
Powers Never Had Before
「復次善男子!云何菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃,成就具足第二功德?善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃,昔所不得而今得之,昔所不見而今見之,昔所不聞而今聞之,昔所不到而今得到,昔所不知而今知之。云何名為昔所不得而今得之?所謂神通,昔所不得而今乃得。通有二種:一者內,二者外。所言外者與外道共。內復有二:一者二乘,二者菩薩。菩薩修行大涅槃經所得神通,不與聲聞辟支佛共。云何名為不與聲聞辟支佛共?二乘所作神通變化,一心作一,不得眾多。菩薩不爾,於一心中,則能具足現五趣身。所以者何?以得如是大涅槃經之勢力故,是則名為昔所不得而今得之。又復云何昔所不得而今得之?所謂身得自在、心得自在。何以故?一切凡夫所有身心不得自在,或心隨身,或身隨心。」
"Furthermore, good son, how does the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa accomplish and fully complete the second merit? Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa comes to attain what he had never attained before, to see what he had never seen before, to hear what he had never heard before, to arrive at what he had never arrived at before, and to know what he had never known before. What is meant by 'attaining what was never attained before'? Namely, the supernormal powers, never attained before and now finally attained. These powers are of two kinds: external, and internal. What is called 'external' is shared with the followers of other paths. The internal, further, is of two kinds: that of the two lesser vehicles, and that of the bodhisattva. The supernormal power the bodhisattva attains through practicing this great Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra is shared with no śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha at all. What is meant by 'shared with no śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha'? The supernormal transformations performed by the two lesser vehicles allow a single mind to produce only a single result, never many at once. The bodhisattva is not like this: within a single mind, he is able to manifest bodies in all five destinies simultaneously, fully complete. Why is this? Because he has attained the very power of this great Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra — this is what is meant by attaining what was never attained before. And, further, what else is meant by 'attaining what was never attained before'? Namely, attaining mastery of the body, and mastery of the mind. Why is this? Because every ordinary being's own body and mind lack any such mastery at all — either the mind follows the body, or the body follows the mind."
「云何名為心隨於身?譬如醉人,酒在身中,爾時身動,心亦隨動,亦如身懶,心亦隨懶,是則名為心隨於身。又如嬰兒,其身稚小,心亦隨小,大人身大,心亦隨大。又如有人,身體麁澁,心常思念,欲得膏油潤漬令軟,是則名為心隨於身。云何名為身隨於心?所謂去來坐臥,修行施、戒、忍辱、精進,愁惱之人身則羸悴,歡喜之人身則肥鮮,恐怖之人身體戰動,專心聽法身則怡悅,悲泣之人涕淚橫流,是則名為身隨於心。菩薩不爾,於身心中俱得自在,是則名為昔所不得而今得之。復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩所現身相,猶如微塵,以此微身,悉能遍至無量無邊恒河沙等諸佛世界,無所障礙,而心常定,初不移動,是則名為心不隨身。」
"What is meant by 'the mind following the body'? It is like a drunken man, wine coursing through his own body — at that time, his body sways, and his mind sways along with it; and it is likewise when the body grows lazy, the mind, too, grows lazy along with it — this is what is meant by the mind following the body. It is also like an infant, whose body is small and immature, and whose mind, too, is correspondingly small; while a grown adult's body is large, and his mind, too, is correspondingly large. It is also like a person whose body is coarse and rough, whose mind forever longs to obtain oil and ointment to soften and moisten it — this, too, is what is meant by the mind following the body. What is meant by 'the body following the mind'? Namely, going, coming, sitting, and lying down, and practicing giving, moral discipline, patience, and diligence — a sorrowful person's body grows gaunt and haggard; a joyful person's body grows plump and radiant; a fearful person's body trembles and shakes; one who listens to the Dharma with a single-pointed mind finds his body at ease and content; and a weeping person's own tears stream freely down his face — this is what is meant by the body following the mind. The bodhisattva is not like this: within both body and mind alike, he attains complete mastery — this is what is meant by attaining what was never attained before. Furthermore, good son, the bodily form the bodhisattva manifests may be as small as a single mote of dust, and yet, with this very subtle body, he is able to reach every immeasurable, boundless buddha-world, as numerous as the sands of the Gaṅgā, entirely without obstruction, while his mind remains forever settled, never stirring in the slightest — this is what is meant by the mind not following the body."
Huiyuan reads the second merit's own five-part structure ("attaining, seeing, hearing, arriving, knowing what was never attained, seen, heard, arrived at, or known before") as a deliberate escalation through the traditional six supernormal powers, treated here not as a checklist of magic tricks but as evidence of a specifically Mahāyāna capacity distinguished from the two lesser vehicles' own attainment of the identical powers by name: where a śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha's own mind can produce only one transformation at a time, the bodhisattva's single mind produces simultaneous manifestation across all five destinies at once — a difference of kind, on his reading, not merely of degree, since it reflects the bodhisattva's freedom from the very body-mind interdependence the sūtra spends the bulk of this section illustrating through six ordinary examples (a drunken man, an infant, a person craving softening oil, and the correlations between emotional state and physical bearing).
He reads the closing image — a body the size of a mote of dust reaching every buddha-world in the universe while the mind remains utterly unmoved — as the section's own precise definition of "mastery": not merely doing something impossible by ordinary physical standards, but doing so without the mind being dragged along by the action the way an ordinary being's mind is dragged by his own body's fatigue or growth. This distinction between an action's scale and the mind's own stability during it becomes the technical thread the fascicle's remaining sections on the second merit will keep pulling — first through hearing, then through sight, then through knowledge itself.
Sounds Without Fixed Nature
「復次善男子!云何菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃,昔所不聞而今得聞?菩薩摩訶薩先取聲相,所謂象聲馬聲、車聲人聲、貝聲鼓聲、簫笛等聲、歌聲哭聲而修習之,以修習故,能聞無量三千大千世界所有地獄音聲。復轉修習得異耳根,異於聲聞緣覺天耳。何以故?二乘所得清淨耳通,若依初禪淨妙四大,唯聞初禪不聞二禪,乃至四禪亦復如是,雖可一時得聞三千大千世界所有音聲,而不能聞無量無邊恒河沙等世界音聲。以是義故,菩薩所得異於聲聞緣覺耳根,以是異故,昔所不聞而今得聞。雖聞音聲,而心初無聞聲之相,不作有相、常相、樂相、我相、淨相、主相依相、作相因相、定相果相,以是義故,諸菩薩等昔所不聞而今得聞。」
"Furthermore, good son, how does the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa come to hear what he had never heard before? The bodhisattva-mahāsattva first takes hold of every kind of sound-mark — the sound of an elephant, of a horse, of a chariot, of a person, of a conch, of a drum, of a flute or pipe, of song, and of weeping — and cultivates himself upon them, and, through this very cultivation, becomes able to hear the sounds of hell throughout an immeasurable trichiliocosm. He then cultivates further still, and attains an ear-faculty entirely distinct from that of the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha's own heavenly ear. Why is this? The pure ear-power attained by the two lesser vehicles, should it depend on the pure, subtle four elements of the first meditative absorption, hears only the first absorption's own sounds, not the second's; and it is exactly the same, up through the fourth absorption — though it may, at one time, come to hear every sound throughout an entire trichiliocosm, it is unable to hear the sounds of worlds as numerous and boundless as the sands of the Gaṅgā. It is for this very reason that the power the bodhisattva attains is distinct from the ear-faculty of the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha — and it is on account of this very distinction that he comes to hear what he had never heard before. Though he hears these sounds, his mind never, in the end, holds any mark of 'hearing a sound' at all — giving rise to no mark of existence, no mark of permanence, no mark of pleasure, no mark of self, no mark of purity, no mark of a governing subject or its dependent, no mark of an agent, no mark of a cause, no mark of anything fixed, and no mark of any fruit. It is for this very reason that every bodhisattva comes to hear what he had never heard before."
爾時光明遍照高貴德王菩薩摩訶薩言:「若佛所說,不作定相、不作果相,是義不然。何以故?如來先說,若人聞是大涅槃經一句一字,必定得成阿耨多羅三藐三菩提;如來於今,云何復言無定、無果?若得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提,即是定相,即是果相;云何而言無定、無果?聞惡聲故則生惡心,生惡心故則至三塗,若至三塗則是定果;云何而言無定、無果?」爾時如來讚言:「善哉,善哉!善男子!能作是問。若使諸佛說諸音聲有定果相者,則非諸佛世尊之相,是魔王相、生死之相、遠涅槃相。何以故?一切諸佛凡所演說無定果相。善男子!譬如刀中見人面像,竪則見長,橫則見闊,若有定相,云何而得竪則見長、橫則見闊?以是義故,諸佛世尊凡所演說無定果相。善男子!夫涅槃者實非聲果,若使涅槃是聲果者,當知涅槃非是常法。善男子!譬如世間從因生法,有因則有果,無因則無果。因無常故,果亦無常。所以者何?因亦作果,果亦作因,以是義故,一切諸法無有定相。若使涅槃從因生者,因無常故,果亦無常;而是涅槃不從因生,體非是果,是故為常。善男子!以是義故,涅槃之體無定無果。」
At that time, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva Bright Virtuous King of Universal Illumination said: "Should the Buddha say that no fixed mark and no fruit-mark are formed at all, this does not seem correct. Why is this? The Tathāgata has said before that should a person hear even a single phrase or a single word of this great Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra, he shall most certainly attain unsurpassed, complete awakening — how, then, can the Tathāgata now say there is no fixed mark and no fruit at all? Should one attain unsurpassed, complete awakening, this is itself a fixed mark, itself a fruit-mark — how, then, can it be said there is no fixed mark and no fruit? And should hearing an evil sound give rise to an evil mind, and this evil mind lead to the three evil destinies, arriving at the three evil destinies is itself a fixed fruit — how, then, can it be said there is no fixed mark and no fruit?" At that time, the Tathāgata praised him: "Excellent, excellent, good son, that you are able to ask such a question! Should any buddha teach that sounds possess a fixed fruit-mark, this would not be the mark of any buddha, any world-honored one, at all — it would be the mark of the demon king, the mark of birth-and-death, a mark far removed from nirvāṇa. Why is this? Whatever every buddha expounds is entirely without any fixed fruit-mark. Good son, it is like seeing a person's own reflected face in a blade — held upright, it appears elongated; held sideways, it appears widened. Were there a fixed mark to it, how could it appear elongated when held upright and widened when held sideways? It is for this very reason that whatever every buddha, every world-honored one, expounds is entirely without any fixed fruit-mark. Good son, nirvāṇa, in truth, is not the fruit of any sound at all — should nirvāṇa be the fruit of a sound, you should know that nirvāṇa would then not be an ever-abiding dharma at all. Good son, it is like how, in this world, a dharma arising from a cause has a fruit only where it has a cause, and no fruit where it has no cause — and, the cause being impermanent, the fruit, too, is impermanent. Why is this? Because a cause can itself become a fruit, and a fruit can itself become a cause — it is for this very reason that not a single dharma has any fixed mark at all. Should nirvāṇa arise from a cause, then, the cause being impermanent, its fruit, too, would be impermanent — but this nirvāṇa does not arise from any cause at all; its very substance is not a fruit, and it is for this reason that it is permanent. Good son, it is for this very reason that the substance of nirvāṇa is without any fixed mark and without any fruit at all."
「善男子!夫涅槃者,亦可言定,亦可言果。云何為定?一切諸佛所有涅槃常樂我淨,是故為定,無生老壞是故為定,一闡提等、犯四重禁、誹謗方等、作五逆罪,捨除本心,必定得故,是故為定。善男子!如汝所言,若人聞我說大涅槃一字一句,得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提者。汝於是義,猶未了了。汝當諦聽,吾當為汝更分別之。善男子!若有善男子、善女人,聞大涅槃一字一句,不作字相、不作句相、不作聞相、不作佛相、不作說相,如是義者名無相相,以無相相故,得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。善男子!如汝所言,聞惡聲故到三塗者,是義不然。何以故?非以惡聲而至三塗,當知是果乃是惡心。所以者何?有善男子、善女人等,雖聞惡聲心不生惡,是故當知,非因惡聲生三塗中。而諸眾生因煩惱結,惡心滋多,生三惡趣,非因惡聲。若聲有定相,諸有聞者一切悉應生於惡心。或有生者,有不生者,是故當知聲無定相。以無定故,雖復因之,不生惡心。」「世尊!聲若無定,云何菩薩昔所不聞而今得聞?」「善男子!聲無定相,昔所不聞,令諸菩薩而今得聞,以是義故,我作是說,昔所不聞而今得聞。」
"Good son, nirvāṇa can, indeed, also be spoken of as fixed, and can, indeed, also be spoken of as a fruit. What is meant by this fixedness? Every buddha's own nirvāṇa possesses permanence, bliss, self, and purity — it is for this reason that it is fixed; it is free of birth, aging, and decay — it is for this reason that it is fixed; and, should the icchantika and the rest, guilty of the four gravest offenses, of slandering the Vaipulya teachings, or of the five gravest offenses, cast off their own original mind, they most certainly attain it — it is for this reason, too, that it is fixed. Good son, as for what you have said — that should a person hear a single word or phrase of my own teaching of this great nirvāṇa, he attains unsurpassed, complete awakening — you have not yet fully grasped the meaning of this. Listen closely, and I shall distinguish it further for your sake. Good son, should any good son or good daughter hear a single word or phrase of this great nirvāṇa, giving rise to no mark of a word, no mark of a phrase, no mark of hearing, no mark of a buddha, and no mark of speaking at all, a meaning of this kind is named the markless mark — and it is through this very markless mark that he attains unsurpassed, complete awakening. Good son, as for what you have said, that hearing an evil sound leads to the three evil destinies — this is not quite correct. Why is this? It is not on account of the evil sound itself that one arrives at the three evil destinies; you should know that this fruit is, in fact, produced by an evil mind. Why is this? There are good sons and good daughters who, though they hear an evil sound, give rise to no evil mind on that account — you should therefore know that it is not the evil sound itself that produces rebirth among the three evil destinies. Rather, it is on account of the fetter of affliction that beings' own evil minds proliferate, producing rebirth among the three evil destinies — not on account of the evil sound. Were sound to possess a fixed mark, then everyone who hears it should, without exception, give rise to an evil mind — and yet some do, and some do not; you should therefore know that sound has no fixed mark at all. It is precisely because it has no fixed mark that, though one may depend upon it, one need not give rise to any evil mind on that account." "World-Honored One, if sound has no fixed nature, how, then, does the bodhisattva come to hear what he had never heard before?" "Good son, it is precisely because sound has no fixed mark that what was never heard before can now be heard by every bodhisattva — it is for this very reason that I speak of hearing what was never heard before."
Huiyuan reads Bright Virtuous King's objection as pressing a real tension the sūtra has created for itself: having just said sounds bear no fixed fruit-mark at all, the Buddha appears to contradict his own earlier promise, stated elsewhere in this very sūtra, that hearing even a single word of this teaching guarantees eventual awakening. His gloss on the Buddha's answer distinguishes two senses of "fixed" that must not be conflated: sound as such (any sound, taken as a bare physical or auditory phenomenon) bears no fixed, automatic causal power to produce any particular result — the same evil word spoken to two different listeners produces an evil mind in one and nothing at all in the other, since the actual cause of what follows is the listener's own mental state, not the sound itself, which is why the mirror-in-a-blade simile works: the same object of reflection genuinely does look different depending on how the blade is held, without this proving the reflected face itself is unstable or unreal.
Yet nirvāṇa, and the specific teaching of this sūtra, are "fixed" in an entirely different sense — not as an automatic causal guarantee attached to the bare act of hearing sound, but as an unconditioned reality that does not arise from a cause and therefore cannot decay the way anything caused eventually must. The reconciling move, on Huiyuan's reading, is the "markless mark": one who hears this sūtra's words without clinging to any fixed notion of a word, a phrase, a speaker, or an act of hearing at all — precisely the same non-clinging quality this whole second merit has been describing through the bodhisattva's freedom from body-mind interdependence — is the one for whom hearing genuinely does guarantee awakening, not because the sound itself possesses magical fixed power, but because a mind free of every fixed mark is already the condition awakening requires. The guarantee was never about the sound; it was always about the quality of the hearing.
Seeing the Buddhas of Every World
「善男子!云何昔所不見而今得見?善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,先取明相,所謂日月星宿、燈燎燈燭、珠火之明、藥草等光,以修習故得異眼根,異於聲聞緣覺所得。云何為異?二乘所得清淨天眼,若依欲界四大眼根,不見初禪,若依初禪不見上地,乃至自眼猶不能見,若欲多見,極至三千大千世界。菩薩摩訶薩不修天眼,見妙色身悉是骨相,雖見他方恒河沙等世界色相,不作色相、不作常相、有相、物相、名字等相,作因緣相,不作見相。不言是眼微妙淨相,唯見因緣、非因緣相。……以是義故,菩薩所得清淨天眼,異於聲聞緣覺所得。以是異故,一時遍見十方世界現在諸佛,是名菩薩昔所不見而今得見。以是異故,能見微塵,聲聞緣覺所不能見。以是異故,雖見自眼,初無見相,見無常相。見凡夫身三十六物不淨充滿,如於掌中觀阿摩勒果,以是義故,昔所不見而今得見。若見眾生所有色相,則知其人大小乘根,一觸衣故,亦知是人善惡諸根差別之相,以是義故,昔所不知而今得知。以一見故,昔所不知而今得知,以此知故,昔所不見而今得見。」
"Good son, what is meant by 'seeing what he had never seen before'? Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa first takes hold of every kind of luminous mark — the sun, moon, and stars, torch, lamp, and candle, the light of gems and fire, and the glow of medicinal herbs — and, through cultivating himself upon them, attains an eye-faculty entirely distinct from that of the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha. How is it distinct? The pure heavenly eye attained by the two lesser vehicles, should it depend on the four elements of the eye-faculty in the desire realm, cannot see the first meditative absorption; should it depend on the first absorption, it cannot see any higher stage; and, in the end, it is even unable to see its own eye — and, should it wish to see as much as possible, it can reach, at the very most, an entire trichiliocosm. The bodhisattva-mahāsattva does not cultivate the heavenly eye in this way at all: he sees even the finest, most excellent form as nothing but a skeleton's own mark, and, though he sees the very forms of worlds as numerous as the sands of the Gaṅgā in every other direction, he gives rise to no mark of form, no mark of permanence, no mark of existence, no mark of a thing, and no mark of a name — he forms only the mark of a cause and condition, never the mark of an act of seeing itself. He does not say that this eye possesses any subtle, pure mark of its own; he sees only the mark of what is a cause and condition, and what is not… It is for this very reason that the pure heavenly eye the bodhisattva attains is distinct from that attained by the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha. On account of this very distinction, he sees, in a single moment, every present buddha throughout the worlds of the ten directions — this is what is meant by seeing what he had never seen before. On account of this very distinction, he is able to see even the finest mote of dust, which the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha are unable to see. On account of this very distinction, though he sees his own eye, he never, in the end, holds any mark of 'seeing' at all, seeing only the mark of impermanence. He sees an ordinary being's own body as filled entirely with its thirty-six impure substances, as clearly as viewing a myrobalan fruit held in the palm of his own hand — it is for this very reason that he comes to see what he had never seen before. Should he see any being's own bodily form, he thereby knows whether that person's faculties belong to the greater or the lesser vehicle, and, merely by touching that person's own clothing, he likewise knows the distinguishing marks of that person's own wholesome and unwholesome faculties — it is for this very reason that he comes to know what he had never known before. Through this single act of seeing, he comes to know what he had never known before; and through this very knowing, he comes to see what he had never seen before."
「復次善男子!云何菩薩昔所不知而今得知?菩薩摩訶薩雖知凡夫貪恚癡心,初不作心及心數相,不作眾生及以物相,修第一義畢竟空相。何以故?一切菩薩常善修習空性相故。以修空故,昔所不知而今得知。云何為知?知無有我、無有我所,知諸眾生皆有佛性,以佛性故,一闡提等捨離本心,悉當得成阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。如此皆是聲聞緣覺所不能知,菩薩能知,以是義故,昔所不知而今得知。復次善男子!云何昔所不知而今得知?菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,念過去世一切眾生所生種姓、父母兄弟、妻子眷屬、知識怨憎,於一念中得殊異智,異於聲聞緣覺智慧。云何為異?聲聞緣覺所有智慧,念過去世所有眾生種姓、父母乃至怨憎,而作種姓至怨憎相。菩薩不爾,雖念過去種姓、父母乃至怨憎,終不生於種姓父母怨憎等相,常作法相、空寂之相,是名菩薩昔所不知而今得知。復次善男子!云何昔所不知而今得知?菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,得他心智,異於聲聞緣覺所得。云何為異?聲聞緣覺以一念智,知人心時,則不能知地獄、畜生、餓鬼、天心。菩薩不爾,於一念中遍知六趣眾生之心,是名菩薩昔所不知而今得知。復次善男子!復有異知,菩薩摩訶薩於一心中,知須陀洹初心,次第至十六心,以是義故,昔所不知而今得知。是為菩薩修大涅槃具足成就第二功德。」
"Furthermore, good son, what is meant by 'knowing what he had never known before'? The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, though he knows an ordinary being's own mind of craving, anger, and delusion, never, in the end, forms any mark of a mind or its mental factors, nor any mark of a being or an object at all, but cultivates the mark of the ultimate meaning's own final emptiness. Why is this? Because every bodhisattva forever skillfully cultivates himself upon the very mark of emptiness's own nature. Through cultivating this emptiness, he comes to know what he had never known before. What, then, is this knowing? Knowing that there is no self and nothing belonging to a self; knowing that every being possesses buddha-nature, and that, on account of this buddha-nature, the icchantika and the rest, having cast off their own original mind, shall all, without exception, come to attain unsurpassed, complete awakening. All of this is something the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha are unable to know, while the bodhisattva is able to know it — it is for this very reason that he comes to know what he had never known before. Furthermore, good son, what else is meant by 'knowing what he had never known before'? The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, recollects the caste, parents, brothers, wife, children, kin, friends, and enemies of every being throughout every past life, and, in a single moment of thought, attains a wisdom entirely distinct from that of the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha. How is it distinct? Whatever wisdom the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha possess, recollecting the caste, parents, and even enemies of beings in past lives, still forms the very mark of caste, parents, and enemies as such. The bodhisattva is not like this: though he, too, recollects past caste, parents, and even enemies, he never, in the end, gives rise to any mark of caste, parents, or enemies at all, but forever forms only the mark of the nature of dharmas, the mark of empty stillness — this is what is meant by the bodhisattva coming to know what he had never known before. Furthermore, good son, what else is meant by 'knowing what he had never known before'? The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, attains the knowledge of others' minds, distinct from that attained by the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha. How is it distinct? The śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha, with a single moment of wisdom, knowing a human mind, are thereby unable to know the mind of a being in hell, among animals, hungry ghosts, or gods, all at the same time. The bodhisattva is not like this: in a single moment of thought, he fully knows the minds of beings throughout all six destinies at once — this is what is meant by the bodhisattva coming to know what he had never known before. Furthermore, good son, there is, further, a distinct kind of knowing: the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, within a single mind, knows the stream-enterer's own very first mind, and, in sequence, all the way to his sixteenth mind — it is for this very reason that he comes to know what he had never known before. This is what is meant by the bodhisattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa accomplishing and fully completing the second merit."
Huiyuan reads the seeing-merit's own governing distinction as identical in structure to the hearing-merit just completed: the bodhisattva's heavenly eye differs from the two lesser vehicles' own not merely in range (seeing every world rather than a single trichiliocosm) but in kind, since it perceives without ever forming the very mark of "seeing" itself — the object seen (a mote of dust, a body's thirty-six impure constituents, a being's own past-life relations) is genuinely perceived in full detail, and yet the perceiving mind clings to none of the fixed marks (form, permanence, existence, a governing self) an ordinary act of seeing generates automatically. He reads the closing four sub-varieties of the knowing-merit — knowing emptiness and buddha-nature itself, knowing past lives without forming marks of caste or kinship, knowing every realm's minds simultaneously rather than one at a time, and knowing the stream-enterer's own sixteen successive moments of insight — as together demonstrating that the bodhisattva's superiority over the two lesser vehicles is not superior magnitude of the same kind of knowledge, but knowledge purified of the very clinging that ordinarily accompanies knowing anything at all.
On the sixteen minds of the stream-enterer specifically, Huiyuan glosses this as the classical Abhidharma sequence of momentary insights (the alternating "patient acceptance" and "knowledge" moments regarding each of the four noble truths, across both the desire realm and the two higher realms together) through which the path of seeing unfolds — a technical detail the bodhisattva is said to grasp all at once, within a single mind, where the stream-enterer himself experiences it only sequentially, moment by moment, as his own path actually unfolds.
Compassion That Needs No Cause
「復次善男子!云何菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃成就具足第三功德?善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃,捨慈得慈,得慈之時,不從因緣。云何名為捨慈得慈?善男子!慈名世諦。菩薩摩訶薩捨世諦慈,得第一義慈,第一義慈不從緣得。復次云何捨慈得慈?慈若可捨,名凡夫慈;慈若可得,即名菩薩無緣之慈。捨一闡提慈、犯四重禁慈、謗方等慈、作五逆慈,得憐愍慈、得如來慈、世尊之慈、無因緣慈。云何復名捨慈得慈?捨黃門慈、無根、二根、女人之慈,屠、膾、獵師、畜養鷄猪如是等慈,亦捨聲聞緣覺之慈,得諸菩薩無緣之慈。不見自慈,不見他慈,不見持戒,不見破戒。雖自見悲,不見眾生。雖有苦受,不見受者。何以故?以修第一真實義故。是名菩薩修大涅槃成就具足第三功德。」
"Furthermore, good son, how does the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa accomplish and fully complete the third merit? Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa casts off compassion and attains compassion — and, at the very moment he attains it, it does not arise from any cause or condition at all. What is meant by 'casting off compassion and attaining compassion'? Good son, ordinary compassion is named worldly truth. The bodhisattva-mahāsattva casts off this compassion of worldly truth, and attains the compassion of the ultimate meaning — and this compassion of the ultimate meaning does not arise from any cause or condition at all. What else, further, is meant by 'casting off compassion and attaining compassion'? Should compassion be capable of being cast off, it is named the ordinary being's own compassion; should compassion be capable of being genuinely attained, it is named the bodhisattva's own compassion without any cause or condition at all. He casts off the compassion felt toward the icchantika, toward one guilty of the four gravest offenses, toward one who slanders the Vaipulya teachings, and toward one guilty of the five gravest offenses, and attains instead a compassion of true pity, the compassion of the Tathāgata himself, the compassion of the World-Honored One, a compassion without any cause or condition at all. What further is meant by 'casting off compassion and attaining compassion'? He casts off the compassion felt toward a eunuch, toward one without male organs, toward one of both sexes, and toward a woman, and toward a butcher, a fisherman, a hunter, or one who raises chickens and pigs for slaughter — and casts off, too, the compassion of the śrāvaka and pratyekabuddha — and attains instead the bodhisattva's own compassion without any cause or condition at all. He sees no compassion of his own, and no compassion of another's; he sees no one who upholds the precepts, and no one who breaks them. Though he himself perceives suffering, he sees no being at all; and though there is suffering felt, he sees no one who feels it. Why is this? Because he cultivates the very ultimate, true meaning itself. This is what is meant by the bodhisattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa accomplishing and fully completing the third merit."
Huiyuan reads "casting off compassion to attain compassion" as describing a single continuous transformation rather than two separate acts performed in sequence: the compassion cast off is defined by its dependence on a specific, worldly object (a particular class of person judged especially deserving or undeserving of pity — the icchantika, the grave offender, but also, on the list's more uncomfortable second half, eunuchs, women, and those in stigmatized trades), while the compassion attained arises independent of any such classification at all, which is precisely why it "does not arise from any cause or condition" — it is not compassion caused by encountering a pitiable object, but an unconditioned disposition that simply is, prior to and regardless of any particular being's own circumstances.
He reads the section's closing four "non-seeings" (no compassion of one's own, no compassion of another's, no precept-keeper, no precept-breaker; and, further, perceiving suffering yet seeing no being, feeling pain yet seeing no one who feels it) as this merit's own version of the same emptiness-of-fixed-marks principle running through the second merit's treatment of hearing, seeing, and knowing: genuine, unconditioned compassion is not compassion that has been purified of feeling anything, but compassion that no longer superimposes a fixed self, a fixed sufferer, or a fixed moral category onto what it responds to — which is why it can extend, without discrimination or exception, to every being the ordinary, worldly compassion this section catalogues would instinctively withhold it from.
A Root Too Deep to Uproot
「復次善男子!云何菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃成就具足第四功德?善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃具足成就第四功德,有十事。何等為十?一者根深難可傾拔,二者自身生決定想,三者不觀福田及非福田,四者修淨佛土,五者滅除有餘,六者斷除業緣,七者修清淨身,八者了知諸緣,九者離諸怨敵,十者斷除二邊。云何根深難可傾拔?所言根者,名不放逸。不放逸者為是何根?所謂阿耨多羅三藐三菩提根。善男子!一切諸佛諸善根本,皆不放逸,不放逸故,諸餘善根轉轉增長,以能增長諸善根故,於諸善中最為殊勝。善男子!如諸跡中象跡為上;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法最為殊勝。善男子!如諸明中,日光為最;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法最為殊勝。善男子!如諸王中轉輪聖王為最第一;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法為最第一。善男子!如諸流中四河為最;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法為上為最。善男子!如諸山中,須彌山王為最第一;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法為最第一。善男子!如水生花中,青蓮花為最;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法為最為上。善男子!如陸生花中,婆利師花為最為上;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法為最為上。善男子!如諸獸中,師子為最;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法為最為上。善男子!如飛鳥中,金翅鳥王為最為上;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法為最為上。」
"Furthermore, good son, how does the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa accomplish and fully complete the fourth merit? Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa, in accomplishing and fully completing the fourth merit, has ten matters. What are these ten? First, a root so deep it is difficult indeed to overturn or uproot; second, giving rise to a resolute conviction regarding his own body; third, no longer discriminating between a field of merit and one that is not; fourth, purifying a buddha-land; fifth, eliminating what still remains; sixth, severing the conditions of karma; seventh, cultivating a pure body; eighth, fully understanding every condition; ninth, leaving behind every enemy; and tenth, cutting off the two extremes. What is meant by 'a root so deep it is difficult indeed to overturn or uproot'? This root is named heedfulness. Of what, exactly, is heedfulness the root? Namely, the very root of unsurpassed, complete awakening. Good son, the wholesome root at the very foundation of every buddha is, without exception, heedfulness — and, through this very heedfulness, every other wholesome root grows and increases further still; and, being able to cause every wholesome root to grow and increase in this way, it is the most excellent among every wholesome thing. Good son, it is like how, among every kind of footprint, the elephant's own footprint is supreme — heedfulness is exactly the same, the most excellent among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every kind of light, the sun's own light is supreme — heedfulness is exactly the same, the most excellent among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every kind of king, the wheel-turning sage-king is foremost of all — heedfulness is exactly the same, foremost of all among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every kind of flowing water, the four great rivers are supreme — heedfulness is exactly the same, the highest and most excellent among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every kind of mountain, Mount Sumeru, king of mountains, is foremost of all — heedfulness is exactly the same, foremost of all among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every flower born of water, the blue lotus is supreme — heedfulness is exactly the same, the most excellent and highest among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every flower born of land, the vārṣika flower is highest and most excellent — heedfulness is exactly the same, highest and most excellent among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every kind of beast, the lion is supreme — heedfulness is exactly the same, most excellent and highest among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every kind of bird in flight, the golden-winged garuḍa king is highest and most excellent — heedfulness is exactly the same, highest and most excellent among every wholesome dharma."
「善男子!如大身中,羅睺阿修羅王為最為上;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法為最為上。善男子!如一切眾生,若二足、四足、多足、無足中,如來為最;不放逸法亦復如是,於善法中為最為上。善男子!如諸眾中,佛、僧為上;不放逸法亦復如是,於善法中為最為上。善男子!如佛法中,大涅槃法為最為上;不放逸法亦復如是,於諸善法為最為上。善男子!以是義故,不放逸根,深固難拔。云何不放逸故而得增長?所謂信根、戒根、施根、慧根、忍根、聞根、進根、念根、定根、善知識根,如是諸根,不放逸故而得增長,以增長故深固難拔。以是義故,名為菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃根深難拔。云何於身作決定想?於自身所生決定心:『我今此身於未來世,定當為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提器。心亦如是,不作狹小,不作變易,不作聲聞、辟支佛心,不作魔心及自樂心、樂生死心,常為眾生求慈悲心。』是名菩薩於自身中生決定心,我於來世當為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提器,以是義故,菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃,於自身中生決定想。」
"Good son, it is like how, among every kind of vast body, the asura king Rāhu is highest and most excellent — heedfulness is exactly the same, highest and most excellent among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every being, whether two-footed, four-footed, many-footed, or footless, the Tathāgata is supreme — heedfulness is exactly the same, most excellent and highest among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every assembly, the Buddha and the Saṅgha are highest — heedfulness is exactly the same, most excellent and highest among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is like how, among every one of the Buddha's own teachings, this great nirvāṇa teaching is highest and most excellent — heedfulness is exactly the same, most excellent and highest among every wholesome dharma. Good son, it is for this very reason that the root of heedfulness is deep and firm, difficult indeed to uproot. How is it, through heedfulness, that growth actually occurs? Namely, the root of faith, the root of moral discipline, the root of giving, the root of wisdom, the root of patience, the root of learning, the root of diligence, the root of mindfulness, the root of concentration, and the root of a good and wise friend — every one of these roots, through heedfulness, comes to grow and increase, and, through this very growth, becomes deep and firm, difficult indeed to uproot. It is for this very reason that this is named the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa possessing a root too deep to uproot. What is meant by 'giving rise to a resolute conviction regarding his own body'? Giving rise, with regard to his own body, to this very resolute mind: 'This body of mine shall, in a future age, most certainly become a vessel of unsurpassed, complete awakening.' His mind, too, is exactly the same — never narrow or small, never subject to change, never taking on the mind of the śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha, never taking on the mind of Māra, nor a mind of personal pleasure, nor a mind that delights in birth-and-death, but forever seeking, for the sake of beings, a mind of loving-kindness and compassion. This is what is meant by the bodhisattva giving rise, with regard to his own body, to this resolute mind — 'I shall, in a future age, become a vessel of unsurpassed, complete awakening' — and it is for this very reason that the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa gives rise, with regard to his own body, to this resolute conviction."
Huiyuan reads the fourth merit's own list of ten items as organized around a bodhisattva's growing self-establishment — beginning with the foundational root (heedfulness) that all further cultivation depends on, before moving through an increasingly outward-facing sequence culminating in the purification of an entire future world. His gloss on why heedfulness specifically earns this foundational status, illustrated through some fourteen similes (the elephant's footprint, the sun, the wheel-turning king, the four great rivers, Mount Sumeru, the blue lotus, the vārṣika flower, the lion, the garuḍa, the asura king Rāhu, the Tathāgata among all beings, the Buddha and Saṅgha among every assembly, and this sūtra itself among every teaching): heedfulness is not one wholesome quality among others to be weighed against them, but the specific condition under which every other wholesome root — faith, moral discipline, giving, wisdom, patience, learning, diligence, mindfulness, concentration, and good companionship — is actually able to grow at all, which is why its own root runs deeper than any of theirs individually.
On the resolute conviction regarding one's own body, he reads the specific formulation — "this body of mine shall become a vessel of awakening" — as distinguished sharply from mere aspiration or hope: a settled certainty about one's own eventual attainment that simultaneously excludes five specific alternative directions the mind could otherwise drift toward (narrowness, instability, the two lesser vehicles' own more limited goal, Māra's influence, and simple self-indulgent enjoyment of either pleasure or continued rebirth) — the conviction functions less as a prediction than as a a standing commitment that forecloses these five paths in advance, which is why it belongs among the concrete accomplishments constituting this fourth merit rather than among mere wishes for the future.
Ten Vows for a Pure Land
「云何菩薩不觀福田及非福田?云何福田?外道、持戒,上至諸佛,是名福田。若有念言:『如是等輩是真福田。』當知是心則為狹劣。菩薩摩訶薩悉觀一切無量眾生無非福田。何以故?以善修習異念處故。……常觀諸佛世尊所說,施雖四種,俱得清淨報。何等為四?一者施主清淨、受者不淨,二者施主不淨、受者清淨,三者施、受俱淨。四者施、受二俱不淨。……善男子!若有不見施及施報,當知是人不名破戒、專著邪見。若依聲聞,言不見施及施果報,是則名為破戒邪見。若依如是大涅槃經,不見惠施及施果報,是則名為持戒正見。菩薩摩訶薩有異念處,以修習故,不見眾生持戒、破戒、施者、受者及施果報,是故得名持戒正見。以是義故,菩薩摩訶薩不觀福田及非福田。」
"What is meant by 'the bodhisattva no longer discriminating between a field of merit and one that is not'? What is meant by a field of merit? A follower of another path, one who upholds the precepts, and so on, up through every buddha — these are named a field of merit. Should anyone think: 'Beings of this kind alone are a true field of merit,' one should know that a mind of this kind is narrow and inferior. The bodhisattva-mahāsattva sees every single one of the immeasurable beings there are as, without exception, a field of merit. Why is this? Because he skillfully cultivates himself upon a distinct kind of mindfulness… He forever contemplates what every buddha, every world-honored one, has taught: that giving, though of four kinds, in every case yields a pure fruit. What are these four? First, a pure giver and an impure receiver; second, an impure giver and a pure receiver; third, both giver and receiver pure; and fourth, both giver and receiver impure… Good son, should there be one who does not perceive giving or its fruit, one should know that this person is not, on that account, named one who breaks the precepts or clings to wrong view. Should one, following the śrāvaka's own teaching, say that he does not perceive giving or its fruit, this is indeed named breaking the precepts and wrong view; but should one, following this great Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra, not perceive giving or its fruit, this is, instead, named upholding the precepts and right view. The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, possessed of this distinct kind of mindfulness, through this very cultivation, perceives no being as one who upholds or breaks the precepts, no giver, no receiver, and no fruit of giving at all — it is for this reason that he is named one who upholds the precepts and holds right view. It is for this very reason that the bodhisattva-mahāsattva no longer discriminates between a field of merit and one that is not."
「云何名為淨佛國土?菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,離殺害心,以此善根,願與一切眾生共之,願諸眾生得壽命長,有大勢力,獲大神通。以是誓願因緣力故,於未來世成佛之時,國土所有一切眾生,得壽命長,有大勢力,獲大神通。復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,離偷盜心,以此善根,願與一切眾生共之,願諸佛國土地所有純是七寶,眾生富足,所欲自恣。以此誓願因緣力故,於未來世成佛之時,所得國土純是七寶,眾生富足,所欲自恣。復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,離婬欲心,以此善根,願與一切眾生共之,願諸佛土所有眾生,無有貪欲瞋恚癡心,亦無飢渴苦惱之者。以是誓願因緣力故,於未來世成佛之時,國土眾生遠離貪婬、瞋恚、癡心,一切無有飢渴苦惱。復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,離妄語心,以此善根,願與一切眾生共之,願諸佛土常有花樹、果樹、香樹,所有眾生得妙音聲。以是誓願因緣力故,於未來世成佛之時,所有國土常有花樹、果樹、香樹,其中眾生悉得清淨上妙音聲。」
"What is meant by 'purifying a buddha-land'? The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from any thought of killing or harming — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that every being attain a long lifespan, possess great strength, and obtain great supernormal power. Through the very power of this vow's own cause and condition, when he becomes a buddha in a future age, every being throughout his own land shall attain a long lifespan, possess great strength, and obtain great supernormal power. Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from any thought of stealing — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that the ground of his own future buddha-land be made purely of the seven treasures, its beings wealthy and abundant, obtaining whatever they wish freely. Through the very power of this vow's own cause and condition, when he becomes a buddha in a future age, the land he attains shall be made purely of the seven treasures, its beings wealthy and abundant, obtaining whatever they wish freely. Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from any thought of sexual misconduct — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that every being throughout his own future buddha-land be free of craving, anger, and delusion, and free, too, of hunger, thirst, and every affliction. Through the very power of this vow's own cause and condition, when he becomes a buddha in a future age, the beings of his own land shall keep far from craving, sexual desire, anger, and delusion, entirely free of hunger, thirst, and affliction. Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from any thought of false speech — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that his own future buddha-land forever possess trees of flowers, trees of fruit, and trees of fragrance, and that every being there attain a wondrous, subtle voice. Through the very power of this vow's own cause and condition, when he becomes a buddha in a future age, his own land shall forever possess trees of flowers, fruit, and fragrance, and every being there shall attain a pure, sublime, and wondrous voice."
「復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,遠離兩舌,以此善根,願與一切眾生共之,願諸佛土所有眾生,常共和合,講說正法。……復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,遠離惡口,以此善根,願與一切眾生共之,願諸佛土地平如掌,無有沙礫瓦石之屬、荊蕀惡刺,所有眾生其心平等。……復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,離無義語,以此善根,願與一切眾生共之,願諸佛土所有眾生,無有苦惱。……復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,遠離貪嫉,以此善根願與一切眾生共之,願諸佛土一切眾生無有貪嫉、惱害、邪見。……復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,遠離惱害,以此善根,願與一切眾生共之,願諸佛土所有眾生,悉共修習大慈大悲,得一子地。……復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,為阿耨多羅三藐三菩提、度眾生故,遠離邪見,以此善根,願與一切眾生共之,願諸佛土所有眾生,悉得摩訶般若波羅蜜。以是誓願因緣力故,於未來世成佛之時,世界眾生悉得受持摩訶般若波羅蜜,是名菩薩修淨佛土。」
"Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from divisive speech — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that every being throughout his own future buddha-land forever dwell together in harmony, expounding the true Dharma together… Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from harsh speech — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that the ground of his own future buddha-land be level as the palm of a hand, entirely free of sand, gravel, tile, stone, thorns, or brambles, and that every being there hold an equal, impartial mind… Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from idle speech — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that every being throughout his own future buddha-land be entirely free of suffering and affliction… Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from craving and envy — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that every being throughout his own future buddha-land be entirely free of craving, envy, malice, and wrong view… Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from malice — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that every being throughout his own future buddha-land together cultivate great loving-kindness and great compassion, attaining the ground of an only child… Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa, for the sake of unsurpassed, complete awakening and the salvation of beings, keeps far from wrong view — and, with this very wholesome root, vows to share it with every being, wishing that every being throughout his own future buddha-land attain the great perfection of wisdom entirely. Through the very power of this vow's own cause and condition, when he becomes a buddha in a future age, the beings of his own world shall all, without exception, attain and uphold the great perfection of wisdom — this is what is meant by the bodhisattva purifying a buddha-land."
Huiyuan reads the field-of-merit teaching as extending the third merit's own "no fixed compassion" principle into the domain of giving specifically: the sūtra's own four-part classification of giving (pure giver/impure receiver, and the reverse, and both pure, and both impure) is offered precisely to demonstrate that purity of the resulting merit never depends on correctly sorting beings in advance into "worthy" and "unworthy" recipients — a bodhisattva who has genuinely internalized this teaching stops performing that sorting altogether, not out of indifference to moral distinctions, but because clinging to any fixed category of "true field of merit" is itself, on his reading, a subtler form of the same discrimination this whole chapter has been dismantling since Part 22's opening argument that nothing is fixed.
He reads the ten vows purifying a future buddha-land as mapped with exact precision onto the ten traditional wholesome courses of action (freedom from killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, false speech, divisive speech, harsh speech, idle speech, craving, malice, and wrong view), each vow taking the specific quality of restraint practiced now and projecting it forward as a specific, concrete feature of an entire future world — long life and strength from non-killing, material abundance from non-stealing, freedom from affliction from sexual restraint, beautiful sound from truthful speech, social harmony from non-divisive speech, a land literally free of every obstacle from gentle speech, freedom from suffering from meaningful speech, freedom from envy from non-craving, universal loving-kindness from non-malice, and universal wisdom from right view. His point in tracing this precise one-to-one correspondence is that a pure land, on this sūtra's own account, is never a supernatural reward bestowed independently of conduct, but the direct, world-scale expression of exactly which ordinary ethical restraints a bodhisattva actually practiced on the way there — a systematic causal structure this collection has not seen laid out with this degree of precision since the parallel-world narrative of Acala in Part 21.
What Still Remains
「云何菩薩摩訶薩滅除有餘?有餘有三:一者煩惱餘報,二者餘業,三者餘有。善男子!云何名為煩惱餘報?若有眾生習近貪欲,是報熟故,墮於地獄。從地獄出,受畜生身,所謂鴿雀、鴛鴦鸚鵡、耆婆耆婆舍利伽鳥、青雀魚鼈、獼猴麞鹿,若得人身,受黃門形、女人、二根、無根、婬女,若得出家犯初重戒,是名餘報。復次善男子!若有眾生以殷重心習近瞋恚,是報熟故,墮於地獄。從地獄出,受畜生身,所謂毒蛇——具四種毒,見毒、觸毒、齧毒、歔毒——師子虎狼、熊羆猫狸、鷹鷂之屬,若得人身,具足十六諸惡律儀,若得出家犯第二重戒,是名餘報。復次善男子!若有修習愚癡之人,是報熟時,墮於地獄。從地獄出,受畜生身,所謂象猪、牛羊水牛、蚤虱蚊虻、蟻子等形,若得人身,聾、盲、瘖啞、癃殘背瘻,諸根不具,不能受法,若得出家諸根闇鈍,憙犯重戒乃至五錢,是名餘報。復次善男子!若有修習憍慢之人,是報熟時,墮於地獄。從地獄出、受畜生身,所謂糞虫、駝驢犬馬,若生人中,受奴婢身、貧窮乞匃,或得出家,常為眾生之所輕賤,破第四戒,是名餘報。如是等名煩惱餘報。如是餘報,菩薩摩訶薩以能修習大涅槃故,悉得除滅。云何餘業?謂一切凡夫業,一切聲聞業。須陀洹人受七有業,斯陀含人受二有業,阿那含人受色有業,是名餘業。如是餘業,菩薩摩訶薩以能修習大涅槃故,悉得斷除。云何餘有?阿羅漢得阿羅漢果,辟支佛得辟支佛果,無業無結而轉二果,是名餘有。如是三種有餘之法,菩薩摩訶薩修習大乘大涅槃經,故得滅除,是名菩薩摩訶薩滅除有餘。」
"What is meant by 'the bodhisattva-mahāsattva eliminating what still remains'? What still remains is of three kinds: the residual fruit of affliction, residual karma, and residual existence. Good son, what is meant by 'the residual fruit of affliction'? Should any being habitually indulge in craving, once this fruit has ripened, he falls into hell — and, emerging from hell, receives an animal's own body, becoming a dove, a sparrow, a mandarin duck, a parrot, a jīvañjīva bird, a śārikā bird, a blue sparrow, a fish, a turtle, a monkey, a river deer, or a spotted deer; and, should he attain a human body, he becomes a eunuch, a woman, one of both sexes, one of neither, or a prostitute; and, should he become a renunciant, he transgresses the very first of the gravest precepts — this is what is meant by residual fruit. Furthermore, good son, should any being habitually indulge in anger with a deeply held mind, once this fruit has ripened, he falls into hell — and, emerging from hell, receives an animal's own body, becoming a poisonous snake, possessed of four kinds of poison (poison by sight, by touch, by bite, and by breath), a lion, a tiger, a wolf, a bear, a wildcat, or a hawk; and, should he attain a human body, he becomes fully possessed of the sixteen kinds of evil conduct; and, should he become a renunciant, he transgresses the second of the gravest precepts — this, too, is what is meant by residual fruit. Furthermore, good son, should any being cultivate delusion, once this fruit has ripened, he falls into hell — and, emerging from hell, receives an animal's own body, becoming an elephant, a pig, an ox, a sheep, a water buffalo, a flea, a louse, a mosquito, a horsefly, or an ant; and, should he attain a human body, he becomes deaf, blind, mute, crippled, or hunchbacked, his every faculty incomplete, unable to receive the Dharma; and, should he become a renunciant, his every faculty dull and slow, he delights in transgressing even the gravest precept over as little as five coins — this, too, is what is meant by residual fruit. Furthermore, good son, should any being cultivate arrogance, once this fruit has ripened, he falls into hell — and, emerging from hell, receives an animal's own body, becoming a dung-beetle, a camel, a donkey, a dog, or a horse; and, should he be born among humans, he becomes a slave or servant, poverty-stricken, a beggar; or, should he become a renunciant, he is forever held in contempt by every being, and transgresses the fourth of the gravest precepts — this, too, is what is meant by residual fruit. Matters of this kind are named the residual fruit of affliction. Residual fruit of this kind, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, through his very cultivation of this great nirvāṇa, comes to eliminate entirely. What is meant by 'residual karma'? Namely, the karma of every ordinary being, and the karma of every śrāvaka. The stream-enterer still carries the karma of seven further existences; the once-returner still carries the karma of two further existences; and the non-returner still carries the karma of a single existence within the form realm — this is what is meant by residual karma. Residual karma of this kind, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, through his very cultivation of this great nirvāṇa, comes to sever entirely. What is meant by 'residual existence'? The arhat attains the fruit of arhatship, and the pratyekabuddha attains the fruit of pratyekabuddhahood — with no further karma and no further fetter remaining, and yet each still turning within these two fruits themselves — this is what is meant by residual existence. Dharmas of these three kinds of remainder, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, through cultivating this great Mahāyāna Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra, comes to eliminate entirely — this is what is meant by the bodhisattva-mahāsattva eliminating what still remains."
「云何菩薩修清淨身?菩薩摩訶薩修不殺戒,有五種心,謂下、中、上、上中、上上,乃至正見亦復如是。是五十心,名初發心;具足決定成五十心,是名滿足。如是百心,名百福德。具足百福成於一相。如是展轉具足成就三十二相,名清淨身。……善男子!譬如有人欲請大王,要當莊嚴所有舍宅,極令清淨,辦具種種百味餚饍,然後王當就其所請。菩薩摩訶薩亦復如是,欲請阿耨多羅三藐三菩提法輪王故,先當修身極令清淨,無上法王乃當處之。……云何菩薩摩訶薩善知諸緣?菩薩摩訶薩不見色相、不見色緣、不見色體、不見色生、不見色滅、不見一相、不見異相、不見見者、不見相貌、不見受者。何以故?了因緣故。如色,一切法亦如是,是名菩薩了知諸緣。云何菩薩離諸怨敵?一切煩惱是菩薩怨敵,菩薩摩訶薩常遠離故,是名菩薩壞諸怨敵。五住菩薩視諸煩惱不名為怨。所以者何?因煩惱故,菩薩有生,以有生故,故能展轉教化眾生。以是義故,不名為怨。何等為怨?所謂誹謗方等經者。菩薩隨生,不畏地獄、畜生、餓鬼,唯畏如是謗方等者。一切菩薩有八種魔,名為怨家,遠是八魔,名離怨家,是名菩薩離諸怨家。云何菩薩遠離二邊?言二邊者,謂二十五有及愛煩惱。菩薩常離二十五有及愛煩惱,是名菩薩遠離二邊。是名菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃具足成就第四功德。」
"What is meant by 'the bodhisattva cultivating a pure body'? The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, cultivating the precept against killing, does so with five kinds of mind — lower, middling, upper, upper-middling, and utmost upper — and it is exactly the same, up through right view itself. These fifty minds together are named the first arising of the mind; their full and resolute completion constitutes these fifty minds, and this is named their fulfillment. A hundred minds of this kind are named a hundred merits, and, fully complete, these hundred merits together constitute a single mark; and, unfolding and accumulating in this way, he comes to accomplish the thirty-two marks in full, and this is what is named a pure body… Good son, it is like a person who wishes to invite a great king to his home: he must first adorn his own dwelling, making it entirely pure and clean, and prepare every kind of fine delicacy, a hundred flavors in all, and only then will the king come to accept his invitation. The bodhisattva-mahāsattva is exactly the same: wishing to invite the Dharma-wheel-turning king of unsurpassed, complete awakening, he must first cultivate his own body, making it entirely pure, and only then will this unsurpassed king of the Dharma come to dwell within it… What is meant by 'the bodhisattva fully understanding every condition'? The bodhisattva-mahāsattva sees no mark of form, no condition of form, no substance of form, no arising of form, and no ceasing of form; sees no mark of sameness, no mark of difference; sees no seer, no describable appearance, and no one who receives it. Why is this? Because he fully understands cause and condition. And it is exactly the same with form as with every other dharma — this is what is meant by the bodhisattva fully understanding every condition. What is meant by 'the bodhisattva leaving behind every enemy'? Every affliction is itself the bodhisattva's own enemy, and, because the bodhisattva-mahāsattva forever keeps himself far from it, this is what is meant by the bodhisattva destroying every enemy. And yet the bodhisattva of the fifth abiding does not regard affliction itself as an enemy at all. Why is this? It is precisely on account of affliction that the bodhisattva continues to be born, and it is precisely because he continues to be born that he is able to teach and transform beings, one after another. It is for this very reason that affliction itself is not named an enemy. What, then, is named an enemy? Namely, one who slanders the Vaipulya teachings. The bodhisattva, wherever he is born, fears neither hell, nor the animal realm, nor the realm of hungry ghosts — he fears only one who slanders the Vaipulya teachings in this way. Every bodhisattva has eight kinds of demon, named his own enemies — keeping far from these eight demons is what is named leaving behind one's enemies, and this is what is meant by the bodhisattva leaving behind every enemy. What is meant by 'the bodhisattva keeping far from the two extremes'? These two extremes are the twenty-five states of existence, and the affliction of craving. The bodhisattva forever keeps far from both the twenty-five states of existence and the affliction of craving — this is what is meant by the bodhisattva keeping far from the two extremes. This is what is meant by the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa accomplishing and fully completing the fourth merit."
爾時光明遍照高貴德王菩薩摩訶薩言:「如佛所說,若有菩薩修大涅槃,悉作如是十事功德。如來何故唯修九事,不修淨土?」佛言:「善男子!我於往昔亦常具修如是十事。一切菩薩及諸如來無有不修是十事者,若使世界不淨充滿,諸佛世尊於中出者,無有是處。善男子。汝今莫謂諸佛出於不淨世界,當知是心不善狹劣。汝今當知,我實不出閻浮提界。譬如有人說言此界獨有日月,他方世界無有日月,如是之言無有義理。若有菩薩發如是言,此佛世界穢惡不淨,他方佛土清淨嚴麗,亦復如是。善男子!西方去此娑婆世界,度三十二恒河沙等諸佛國土,彼有世界名曰無勝。彼土何故名曰無勝?其土所有嚴麗之事,皆悉平等無有差別,猶如西方安樂世界,亦如東方滿月世界。我於彼土出現於世,為化眾生故,於此界閻浮提中現轉法輪。非但我身獨於此中現轉法輪,一切諸佛亦於此中而轉法輪。以是義故,諸佛世尊非不修行如是十事。善男子!慈氏菩薩以誓願故,當來之世,令此世界清淨莊嚴。以是義故,一切諸佛所有世界無不嚴淨。」
At that time, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva Bright Virtuous King of Universal Illumination said: "As the Buddha has taught, should any bodhisattva cultivate this great nirvāṇa, he accomplishes every one of these ten merits in full. Why, then, does the Tathāgata cultivate only nine of them, and not the purification of a buddha-land?" The Buddha said: "Good son, I myself, in ages past, likewise forever cultivated all ten of these matters in full. There is not a single bodhisattva or tathāgata who fails to cultivate every one of these ten — should a world be filled entirely with impurity, it could not possibly be the world any buddha, any world-honored one, appears within. Good son, you should not now think that any buddha appears within an impure world at all — know that a thought of this kind is unwholesome and narrow. You should now know that I, in reality, have never actually appeared within this very Jambudvīpa at all. It is like someone who says that only this world possesses the sun and moon, and that no other world at all possesses them — words of this kind have no basis in reason whatsoever. Should any bodhisattva say that this present buddha-world is foul and impure, while some other buddha-land is pure and resplendent, this is exactly the same kind of error. Good son, to the west of this Sahā world, past buddha-lands as numerous as thirty-two times the sands of the Gaṅgā, there is a world named Unsurpassed. Why is that land named Unsurpassed? Every resplendent feature of that land is entirely equal, without the slightest difference between them, just like the western Land of Peace and Bliss, and just like the eastern world of Full-Moon Light. I myself have appeared in the world from that very land — and, for the sake of transforming beings, I now manifest the turning of the Dharma-wheel here, within this Jambudvīpa. And it is not I alone who manifests the turning of the Dharma-wheel here — every buddha, likewise, turns the Dharma-wheel here as well. It is for this very reason that every buddha, every world-honored one, has, without exception, cultivated all ten of these matters. Good son, the bodhisattva Maitreya, through the power of his own vow, shall, in an age to come, cause this very world to become pure and resplendent — it is for this very reason that not a single one of every buddha's own worlds fails to be resplendent and pure."
Huiyuan reads the three kinds of "what still remains" as forming a hierarchy of increasingly subtle residue: the residual fruit of affliction describes karmic consequences that persist across lifetimes even after the original unwholesome mental state has passed, mapped precisely onto four specific afflictions (craving, anger, delusion, arrogance) each yielding its own distinct catalogue of animal rebirths, human deformities, and, for a renunciant, a specific one of the four gravest precepts he becomes prone to transgressing; residual karma describes what remains binding even a stream-enterer, once-returner, or non-returner to a fixed, if diminishing, number of further rebirths; and residual existence describes the subtlest remainder of all — an arhat or pratyekabuddha who has genuinely exhausted every karmic cause and fetter, and yet still "turns" within the fixed, static fruit of his own attainment, unable to progress further toward the greater completion a bodhisattva pursues. Only the bodhisattva who cultivates this sūtra, on his reading, eliminates residue at all three levels simultaneously.
On Bright Virtuous King's closing question — why does the Buddha, having cultivated all ten items himself, appear to have skipped the fourth (purifying a buddha-land), teaching instead within this manifestly impure Sahā world — Huiyuan reads the Buddha's answer as resting on a single point already established across this whole chapter: the very premise of the question (that this present world is simply, straightforwardly impure) mistakes a skillful, deliberately chosen manifestation for the Buddha's own actual, underlying reality, exactly as Part 22's extended catalogue of paired negations warned against fixing the Tathāgata's nature to any single observable feature. The Buddha's own true land of attainment, the world Unsurpassed, is every bit as pure as any other buddha's own land; what appears here in Jambudvīpa is a deliberate manifestation for the specific purpose of teaching beings suited to exactly this kind of world — with Maitreya's own future vow to purify this same world eventually demonstrating, within the narrative's own terms, that its impurity was never a fixed, permanent feature to begin with, but simply the present stage of a trajectory every buddha's own teaching activity is already steering toward its opposite.
The Fifth Merit: Five Things Beyond What Giving Gives
「復次善男子!云何菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,具足成就第五功德?善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃具足成就第五功德,有五事。何等為五?一者諸根完具,二者不生邊地,三者諸天愛念,四者常為天魔、沙門、剎利、婆羅門等之所恭敬,五者得宿命智。菩薩以是大涅槃經因緣力故,具足如是五事功德。」光明遍照高貴德王菩薩言:「如佛所說,若有善男子、善女人修於布施,則得具成五事功德,今云何言因大涅槃得是五事?」佛言:「善哉,善哉!善男子!如是之事其義各異,今當為汝分別解說。施得五事,不定、不常、不淨、不勝、不異、非無漏、不能利益安樂憐愍一切眾生。若依如是大涅槃經所得五事,是定、是常、是淨、是勝、是異、是無漏,則能利益安樂憐愍一切眾生。善男子!夫布施者則離飢渴,大涅槃經能令眾生悉得遠離二十五有渴愛之病。布施因緣令生死相續,大涅槃經能令生死斷不相續。因布施故受凡夫法,因大涅槃得作菩薩。布施因緣能斷一切貧窮苦惱,大涅槃經能斷一切貧善法者。布施因緣有分有果,因大涅槃得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提,無分無果。是名菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃微妙經典,具足成就第五功德。」
"Furthermore, good son, how does the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa accomplish and fully complete the fifth merit? Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa, in accomplishing and fully completing the fifth merit, has five matters. What are these five? First, every one of his faculties is fully complete; second, he is not born in any border region; third, he is beloved and cherished by every god; fourth, he is forever revered by the gods, Māra, śramaṇas, kṣatriyas, and brahmins alike; and fifth, he attains the knowledge of past lives. The bodhisattva, through the very power of this great Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra's own cause and condition, fully accomplishes these five matters." Bright Virtuous King of Universal Illumination said: "As the Buddha has taught, should any good son or good daughter practice giving, he thereby fully accomplishes these same five merits — why, then, does the Buddha say that these five matters are attained on account of this great nirvāṇa?" The Buddha said: "Excellent, excellent, good son! Matters of this kind differ in their own underlying meaning — I shall now distinguish and explain this for your sake. The five matters attained through giving are not fixed, not permanent, not pure, not supreme, and not distinct in kind, nor are they free of outflow, nor are they able to benefit, bring peace to, and hold compassion for every being. Should these same five matters be attained, instead, in dependence on this great Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra, they are fixed, permanent, pure, supreme, and distinct in kind, and are free of outflow, and are able to benefit, bring peace to, and hold compassion for every being. Good son, giving alone merely relieves hunger and thirst; this great Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra is able to cause every being to keep entirely far from the very disease of thirsting craving within the twenty-five states of existence. The cause and condition of giving alone causes birth-and-death to continue unbroken; this great nirvāṇa sūtra is able to sever birth-and-death entirely, so that it no longer continues at all. On account of giving alone, one receives the dharma of an ordinary being; on account of this great nirvāṇa, one comes to become a bodhisattva. The cause and condition of giving alone is able to sever poverty and its attendant suffering; this great nirvāṇa sūtra is able to sever the very poverty of wholesome dharmas themselves. The cause and condition of giving alone has its own portion and its own fruit; on account of this great nirvāṇa, one attains unsurpassed, complete awakening, which has neither portion nor fruit at all. This is what is meant by the bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa accomplishing and fully completing the fifth merit."
Huiyuan reads Bright Virtuous King's question as pressing a genuine puzzle: the five outcomes named here (complete faculties, freedom from birth in a border region, the gods' own affection, universal reverence, knowledge of past lives) are, in fact, classical, well-attested fruits of ordinary generosity elsewhere in the canon, so crediting them instead to this sūtra specifically requires some real distinction to be drawn. His gloss on the Buddha's answer traces five paired contrasts, each identical in outward description yet different in kind: giving's own version of each fruit remains contingent, temporary, mixed with residual impurity, unremarkable relative to a buddha's own attainment, indistinguishable from an ordinary being's fortune, still subject to outflow, and incapable of extending genuine benefit to all beings universally — while the same five fruits, attained through this sūtra, are each secured absolutely, permanently, purely, supremely, distinctively, free of outflow, and universally beneficial.
The closing formula — giving alone relieves hunger, but only this teaching relieves the craving underlying all twenty-five states of existence; giving alone continues the ordinary cycle of birth-and-death, but only this teaching severs it — is, on his reading, this fascicle's own most economical restatement of a distinction it has been building since the very first merit in Part 21: ordinary virtuous practice, however genuinely wholesome, still operates within the categories of cause and effect, portion and fruit, that this sūtra's own teaching transcends entirely, which is why identical-looking outcomes can nonetheless differ in what actually produces and sustains them.
The Vajra Samādhi
「善男子!云何菩薩修大涅槃微妙經典,具足成就第六功德?菩薩摩訶薩修大涅槃,得金剛三昧,安住是中,悉能破散一切諸法。見一切法皆是無常、皆是動相、恐怖因緣、病苦劫盜、念念滅壞、無有真實,一切皆是魔之境界,無可見相。菩薩摩訶薩住是三昧,雖施眾生,乃至不見一眾生。實為眾生故,精勤修習尸波羅蜜,乃至修習般若波羅蜜,亦復如是。菩薩若見有一眾生,不能畢竟具足成就檀波羅蜜乃至具足般若波羅蜜。善男子!譬如金剛,所擬之處無不碎壞,而是金剛無有折損。金剛三昧亦復如是,所擬之法無不碎壞,而是三昧無有折損。善男子!如諸寶中金剛最勝,菩薩所得金剛三昧亦復如是,於諸三昧為最第一。何以故?菩薩摩訶薩修是三昧,一切三昧悉來歸屬。善男子!如諸小王悉來歸屬轉輪聖王,一切三昧亦復如是,悉來歸屬金剛三昧。善男子!譬如有人為國怨讎,人所厭患,有人殺之,一切世人無不稱讚是人功德。金剛三昧亦復如是,菩薩修習,能壞一切眾生怨敵,是故常為一切三昧之所宗敬。」
"Good son, how does the bodhisattva who cultivates this subtle and wondrous scripture of the great nirvāṇa accomplish and fully complete the sixth merit? The bodhisattva-mahāsattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa attains the vajra samādhi, and, abiding securely within it, is able to shatter and scatter every single dharma entirely. He sees that every dharma is impermanent, that every dharma bears the mark of instability, is a cause and condition of terror, of sickness, suffering, and plunder, perishing thought after thought, without any true reality at all — every one of them nothing but Māra's own domain, with nothing at all that can genuinely be seen there. The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, abiding in this very samādhi, though he gives generously to beings, sees, in the end, not a single being at all. And yet, genuinely for the sake of beings, he diligently and vigorously cultivates the perfection of moral discipline, and, exactly the same, cultivates the perfection of wisdom as well. Should the bodhisattva see even a single being as truly existing, he would be unable, in the end, to accomplish and fully complete the perfection of giving, up through the perfection of wisdom, at all. Good son, it is like vajra, which shatters whatever it is directed against without exception, and yet the vajra itself suffers not the slightest damage — the vajra samādhi is exactly the same: whatever dharma it is directed against is shattered without exception, and yet this samādhi itself suffers not the slightest damage. Good son, just as vajra is supreme among every kind of treasure, the vajra samādhi the bodhisattva attains is exactly the same, foremost of all among every samādhi. Why is this? Because, once the bodhisattva-mahāsattva cultivates this samādhi, every other samādhi comes, without exception, to belong to it. Good son, just as every lesser king comes, without exception, to belong to a wheel-turning sage-king, every samādhi is exactly the same, coming, without exception, to belong to the vajra samādhi. Good son, it is like a person who has become an enemy of the whole kingdom, loathed and despised by everyone — should someone kill him, there is not a single person in the whole world who does not praise the merit of the one who did it. The vajra samādhi is exactly the same: the bodhisattva who cultivates it is able to destroy every enemy of every being, and it is for this very reason that it is forever revered and honored by every other samādhi."
「善男子!若有菩薩安住如是金剛三昧,見一切法無有障礙,如於掌中觀阿摩勒果,菩薩雖復得如是見,終不作想見一切法。……善男子!譬如高山,有人登之遠望,諸方皆悉明了。金剛定山亦復如是,菩薩登之,遠望諸法無不明了。善男子!譬如春月,天降甘雨,其渧微緻間無空處,明眼之人見之了了。菩薩亦爾,得金剛定清淨之目,遠見東方所有世界,其中或有國土成壞,一切皆見了了無障,乃至十方亦復如是。善男子!如由乾陀山七日竝出,其山所有樹木叢林一切燒盡。菩薩修習金剛三昧亦復如是,所有一切煩惱叢林即時消滅。善男子!譬如金剛雖能摧破一切有物,終不生念我能摧破。金剛三昧亦復如是,菩薩修已能破煩惱,終不生念我能壞結。善男子!譬如大地能持萬物,終不生念我力能持,火亦不念我能燒物,水亦不念我能潤漬,風亦不念我能動物,空亦不念我能容受,涅槃亦復不生念言,我令眾生而得滅度。金剛三昧亦復如是,雖能滅除一切煩惱,而初無心言我能滅。」
"Good son, should any bodhisattva abide securely in this vajra samādhi, he sees every dharma without the slightest obstruction, as clearly as viewing a myrobalan fruit held in the palm of his own hand — and yet, though the bodhisattva attains a seeing of exactly this kind, he never, in the end, forms the notion of 'seeing every dharma' at all… Good son, it is like a high mountain: a person who climbs it and gazes into the distance sees every direction with perfect clarity. The mountain of vajra concentration is exactly the same: the bodhisattva who climbs it sees every dharma in the distance with nothing at all left unclear. Good son, it is like the spring rains, sent down from the sky, each drop so fine and dense that not the slightest gap remains between them, seen with perfect clarity by anyone with clear eyes. The bodhisattva is exactly the same: attaining the pure eye of vajra concentration, he sees, in the distance, every world throughout the eastern direction, including whatever lands there are coming into being or passing away, seeing every one of them with perfect clarity, without the slightest obstruction — and it is exactly the same throughout the other nine directions as well. Good son, it is like Mount Cakravāḍa, when its seven suns rise together, and every tree and thicket upon that mountain is entirely burned away — the bodhisattva who cultivates the vajra samādhi is exactly the same: every single thicket of affliction is extinguished in that very instant. Good son, it is like vajra, which, though able to crush and destroy anything that exists, never, in the end, gives rise to the thought, 'I am able to crush and destroy this' — the vajra samādhi is exactly the same: the bodhisattva who has cultivated it is able to destroy affliction, and yet never, in the end, gives rise to the thought, 'I am able to destroy this fetter.' Good son, it is like the great earth, which is able to support the ten thousand things, and yet never gives rise to the thought, 'I have the strength to support them'; fire, likewise, never thinks, 'I am able to burn things'; water never thinks, 'I am able to moisten and soak them'; wind never thinks, 'I am able to move things'; space never thinks, 'I am able to contain and receive them'; and nirvāṇa, too, never gives rise to the thought, 'I cause beings to attain liberation.' The vajra samādhi is exactly the same: though it is able to extinguish every affliction entirely, it never, from the very start, holds any thought at all that says, 'I am able to extinguish this.'"
「若有菩薩安住如是金剛三昧,於一念中變身如佛,其數無量遍滿十方恒河沙等諸佛世界。而是菩薩雖作是化,其心初無憍慢之想。……菩薩摩訶薩安住如是金剛三昧,於一念中遍到十方恒河沙等諸佛世界,還其本處。雖有是力,亦不念言,我能如是。……菩薩摩訶薩安住如是金剛三昧,於一念中能斷十方恒河沙等世界眾生所有煩惱,而心初無斷諸眾生煩惱之想。……菩薩住是金剛三昧,以一音聲有所演說,一切眾生各隨種類而得解了。示現一色,一切眾生,各各皆見種種色相。安住一處,身不移易,能令眾生隨其方面各各而見。演說一法,若界、若入,一切眾生各隨本解而得聞之。菩薩安住如是三昧,雖見眾生,而心初無眾生之相,雖見男女無男女相,雖見色法無有色相,乃至見識亦無識相,雖見晝夜無晝夜相,雖見一切無一切相,雖見一切煩惱諸結亦無一切煩惱之相,雖見八聖道無聖道相,雖見菩提無菩提相,雖見於涅槃無涅槃相。何以故?善男子!一切諸法本無相故。菩薩以是三昧力故,見一切法如本無相。何故名為金剛三昧?善男子!譬如金剛,若在日中色則不定,金剛三昧亦復如是,在於大眾色亦不定,是故名為金剛三昧。善男子!譬如金剛,一切世人不能評價,金剛三昧亦復如是,所有功德一切人天不能評量,是故復名金剛三昧。善男子!譬如貧人得金剛寶,則得遠離貧窮困苦、惡鬼邪毒。菩薩摩訶薩亦復如是,得是三昧,則能遠離煩惱諸苦、諸魔邪毒,是故復名金剛三昧。是名菩薩修大涅槃具足成就第六功德。」
"Should any bodhisattva abide securely in this vajra samādhi, he may, within a single moment of thought, transform his own body into the likeness of a buddha, its number immeasurable, filling worlds as numerous as the sands of the Gaṅgā throughout the ten directions — and yet, though this bodhisattva performs a transformation of this kind, his mind never, in the end, holds the slightest notion of arrogance about it… The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, abiding securely in this vajra samādhi, is able, within a single moment of thought, to reach fully every buddha-world throughout the ten directions, as numerous as the sands of the Gaṅgā, and return again to his own original place — and yet, though he possesses power of exactly this kind, he never thinks, 'I am able to do this'… The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, abiding securely in this vajra samādhi, is able, within a single moment of thought, to sever the affliction of every being throughout worlds as numerous as the sands of the Gaṅgā in every one of the ten directions — and yet his mind never, in the end, holds the slightest notion of 'severing the affliction of every being.' The bodhisattva, abiding in this vajra samādhi, with a single sound, expounds the Dharma, and every being, each according to his own kind, comes to understand it fully. Manifesting a single form, every being, each in his own way, sees it as an entirely different form. Abiding securely within a single place, his body never moving at all, he causes every being, wherever they may be, each to see him there fully. Expounding a single dharma — whether an element or a sense-field — every being, each according to his own prior understanding, comes to hear it fully. The bodhisattva, abiding in this samādhi, though he sees every being, his mind never, in the end, holds the mark of a being at all; though he sees man and woman, he holds no mark of man or woman; though he sees form, he holds no mark of form; and it is exactly the same, up through consciousness, holding no mark of consciousness at all; though he sees day and night, he holds no mark of day or night; though he sees everything, he holds no mark of anything at all; though he sees every affliction and every fetter, he holds no mark of any affliction at all; though he sees the eightfold noble path, he holds no mark of the noble path; though he sees bodhi, he holds no mark of bodhi; and though he sees nirvāṇa, he holds no mark of nirvāṇa at all. Why is this? Good son, because every single dharma is, from its very origin, without any mark at all. The bodhisattva, through the very power of this samādhi, sees every dharma exactly as it originally is, without any mark whatsoever. Why is this named the vajra samādhi? Good son, it is like vajra itself, whose color, when placed in sunlight, is never fixed at all — the vajra samādhi is exactly the same: amid the great assembly, its own color, too, is never fixed — it is for this reason that it is named the vajra samādhi. Good son, it is like vajra, whose value no person in the world is able to appraise — the vajra samādhi is exactly the same: its own merit, no human or god at all is able to appraise or measure — it is for this reason, too, that it is named the vajra samādhi. Good son, it is like a poor man who obtains a vajra jewel, and thereby comes to keep far from poverty, hardship, evil spirits, and every poison — the bodhisattva-mahāsattva is exactly the same: attaining this very samādhi, he thereby comes to keep far from affliction, every suffering, and the poison of every demon — it is for this reason, too, that it is named the vajra samādhi. This is what is meant by the bodhisattva who cultivates this great nirvāṇa accomplishing and fully completing the sixth merit."
Huiyuan reads the vajra samādhi's own extended catalogue of similes (an indestructible jewel able to cut anything, the supreme treasure to which every lesser samādhi "belongs" as a lesser king belongs to a wheel-turning sovereign, a mountain from whose summit every direction is seen with perfect clarity, spring rain so dense no gap remains uncovered, seven suns burning away an entire mountain's own forest) as together illustrating one central claim: the vajra samādhi's own destructive power — shattering the fixed mark of every single dharma, without exception — is total and unlimited, and yet, remarkably, this totality never diminishes the samādhi itself, exactly as a diamond used to cut every other substance never grows blunt through the cutting. His sharpest point concerns the recurring refrain — the bodhisattva multiplies bodies, travels to countless worlds, severs the affliction of innumerable beings, and yet, at every step, "never gives rise to the thought that he has done so" — which he reads as this fascicle's own final, most technically precise statement of the non-attainment principle first introduced through the eight kinds of mastery in Part 23: an accomplishment performed without the accompanying thought "I have accomplished this" is not a lesser or incomplete accomplishment, but the very thing that keeps the vajra samādhi's own destructive power from generating a new, subtler form of clinging (pride in one's own power to destroy clinging) in its place.
On the closing three etymological similes for "vajra" itself (color unfixed in sunlight, value beyond appraisal, a poor man's fortune transformed), Huiyuan reads these as returning, one final time, to the "nothing is fixed" argument that has organized this entire chapter since Part 22 — even the name of the sūtra's own most powerful named samādhi is chosen specifically because vajra itself, among ordinary objects, is the one whose very appearance famously refuses to hold a single fixed color under changing light, making it the perfect image for a concentration whose entire function is to reveal that no dharma anywhere possesses the fixed mark ordinary perception assigns to it. This closes the sixth merit, and with it, the fascicle's own extended run through five of the chapter's ten merits in relatively rapid succession, compared to the three full fascicles the first merit alone required.
Part 24 Complete
This closes Part 24 (fascicle 24 of 40) and continues 光明遍照高貴德王菩薩品. Having spent three entire fascicles on the first of the chapter's ten merits, the sūtra moves briskly through the second (powers, hearing, sight, and knowledge never had before, each distinguished from the two lesser vehicles' own attainment by a shared freedom from every fixed mark), the third (compassion that arises without any cause, extended without discrimination to precisely those beings ordinary compassion would withhold it from), the fourth (ten concrete accomplishments culminating in ten vows that purify an entire future buddha-land, mapped one-to-one onto the ten wholesome courses of action), the fifth (five outcomes shared in name with ordinary giving's own fruits, yet differing entirely in whether they are fixed, permanent, and universal), and the sixth — the famous vajra samādhi, a concentration that shatters the fixed mark of every dharma without ever diminishing itself, its every accomplishment performed without the accompanying thought that anything has been accomplished at all. Part 25 continues 光明遍照高貴德王菩薩品第十之五, turning to the chapter's remaining merits.
Continue to Part 25 →