A Hundred Blessings for Every Mark
Fascicle 177 opens a new topic within the Non-Returner Nyāsa (不還納息第四之四): the karma that ripens into the Buddha's thirty-two excellent bodily marks — its nature and conditions, the full catalogue of the marks themselves, why the marks and their eighty minor companions never obscure one another, the hundred blessings said to adorn each single mark, and the story of how Śākyamuni's single unwavering verse before the ancient Buddha Tiṣya let him overtake nine entire eons, closing with the treatise's own reckoning of just how vast a single incalculable eon (asaṃkhyeya kalpa) really is. This page carries Ru-Yi's complete translation.
Translation Method
The Chinese source is Xuánzàng's seventh-century translation of the Abhidharma-mahāvibhāṣā-śāstra (阿毘達磨大毘婆沙論), preserved in the Taishō canon (T1545, vol. 27) via the CBETA digital edition — public domain text, translated directly from the Chinese. The English wording throughout is Ru-Yi's own, and the reading notes are original, grounded in standard Sarvāstivāda scholarship rather than a specific named commentator's lecture transcript.
Fascicle 177 opens a new topic within the Non-Returner Nyāsa (不還納息第四之四) inside the Concentration Aggregate (定蘊第七): the karma that ripens into the excellent bodily marks (相異熟業) of a great being. Terms established across fascicles 93–176 recur here and are not re-explained at each occurrence.
Classical text is set in the left-hand column below, our English in the right.
1. The Karma of the Excellent Marks: Its Nature and Conditions
Fascicle 177 opens a new topic within the Non-Returner Nyāsa (不還納息第四之四): the karma that ripens into the Buddha's thirty-two excellent bodily marks. The treatise first pins down this karma's basic coordinates — its nature (chiefly mental, though all three types of action contribute), its cognitive ground, and the fact that it can only be attained through effortful practice sustained across three incalculable eons, never innately or through the mere abandonment of affliction. It then tackles a genuine puzzle: since a single volition seems too small a cause for thirty-two distinct results, is each mark drawn forth by one volition or many — resolved through a two-stage model in which a single volition first draws a mark forth, sketch-like, and a multitude of further volitions then fill in and complete it.
問相異熟業以何為自性。為身業。為語業。為意業耶。答三業為自性然意業增上。有說。唯意業為自性。非身語業。所以者何。此業猛利。身語業鈍故。問相異熟業為在意地。為五識身耶。答在意地。非五識身。所以者何。此業有分別。要觀察已行。五識無分別。隨境界力起故。問相異熟業。為加行得為離染得。為生得耶。
Question: What is the intrinsic nature of the karma that ripens into the excellent bodily marks? Is it bodily karma, verbal karma, or mental karma? Answer: all three types of karma constitute its intrinsic nature, though mental karma predominates. Some say: only mental karma constitutes its intrinsic nature, not bodily or verbal karma. Why is this? Because this karma is intensely powerful, whereas bodily and verbal karma are comparatively dull. Question: does the karma that ripens into the excellent marks belong to the mental-consciousness ground, or to the five sense-consciousnesses? Answer: it belongs to the mental-consciousness ground, not to the five sense-consciousnesses. Why is this? Because this karma involves discrimination — it necessarily follows upon deliberate observation — whereas the five sense-consciousnesses lack discrimination, arising simply in accordance with the power of their objective sphere. Question: is the karma that ripens into the excellent marks attained through effortful practice, through the abandonment of afflictions, or is it innate?
答唯加行得。非離染得非生得。所以者何。此業必在三無數劫修諸波羅蜜多。圓滿身中加行功用作意後而得故。有說。此業加行得亦生得。但非離染得。問相異熟業為聞所成思所成修所成耶。答唯思所成。非聞非修。所以者何。此業勝故非聞所成。欲界繫故非修所成。有說。此業通聞思所成。但非修所成。問相異熟業何處起耶。
Answer: it is attained only through effortful practice, not through the abandonment of afflictions nor innately. Why is this? Because this karma is necessarily attained, over the three incalculable eons of cultivating the perfections, within a body that has perfected the exertion of effortful practice and volitional attention. Some say: this karma is attained both through effortful practice and innately, but not through the abandonment of afflictions. Question: is the karma that ripens into the excellent marks accomplished through hearing, through reflection, or through cultivation? Answer: it is accomplished only through reflection, not through hearing or cultivation. Why is this? Because this karma is superior, it is not accomplished through hearing; because it is bound to the desire realm, it is not accomplished through cultivation. Some say: this karma is accomplished through both hearing and reflection, but not through cultivation. Question: in which realm does the karma that ripens into the excellent marks arise?
答在欲界。非餘界。在人趣非餘趣在贍部洲非餘洲。依何身起者。
Answer: it arises in the desire realm, not in the other realms; in the human destiny, not in other destinies; on the continent of Jambudvīpa, not on the other continents. As for upon what kind of body it arises —
依男身起非女身等。於何時起者。佛出世時非無佛世。緣何境起者現前緣佛起勝思願。不緣餘境。問三十二大丈夫相。為一思所引。
— it arises upon a male body, not a female one, and so on. As for at what time it arises: it arises when a Buddha has appeared in the world, not during a Buddha-less age. As for what object it takes as its condition: it arises by directly taking a Buddha as its condition, giving rise to a supreme resolve and aspiration; it does not take any other object as its condition. Question: are the thirty-two marks of the great being brought about by a single volition,
為多思耶。若爾何失。若一思所引者。云何少業能引多果。施設論說復云何通。如說。如是類業能感足下平滿善住相。乃至如是類業能感頂上烏瑟膩沙相。若多思所引者。云何一眾同分不分分別引耶。答有說。一思所引。問云何少業能感多果。答先以一思牽引。
or by multiple volitions? Either way, what is the difficulty? If they are brought about by a single volition, how can a small amount of karma bring about many results — and how, then, is the statement in the Prajñaptiśāstra to be reconciled, where it says that a karma of such-and-such a kind brings about the mark of the flat, well-planted soles of the feet, and so on up to a karma of such-and-such a kind that brings about the mark of the fleshy protuberance on the crown of the head? If they are brought about by multiple volitions, then how, given that they belong to a single, undivided class of sentient being, can they be brought about as distinctly differentiated? Answer: some say: they are brought about by a single volition. Question: then how can a small amount of karma bring about many results? Answer: first it is drawn forth by a single volition,
後以多思圓滿。是故無過。譬如畫師先以一色作摸後填眾彩。問施設論說復云何通。答彼論說圓滿業不說牽引業。故無過。然三十二大丈夫相是眾同分圓滿業果。非眾同分牽引業果。有說。多思所引。問云何一眾同分不分分別引耶。答爾時菩薩能一注心於一所依所緣行相有多思轉。於中有思能感足下平滿善住相。乃至有思能感頂上烏瑟膩沙相。如是說者。三十二思引三十二大丈夫相。一一復以多業圓滿。問菩薩所起三十二思。於諸相中先引何相。答有說。
and afterward brought to completion by multiple volitions; hence there is no difficulty. It is like a painter who first sketches an outline in a single color and afterward fills it in with many colors. Question: then how is the statement in the Prajñaptiśāstra to be reconciled? Answer: that treatise speaks of the completing karma, not of the drawing-forth karma; hence there is no difficulty. The thirty-two marks of the great being are the fruit of the karma that completes that class of sentient being, not the fruit of the karma that draws it forth. Some say: they are brought about by multiple volitions. Question: then how, given a single, undivided class of sentient being, can they be brought about as distinctly differentiated? Answer: at that time the bodhisattva is able to fix his mind singly upon one basis and one objective-support, yet, with respect to its mode of activity, multiple volitions turn within it. Among these, there is a volition able to bring about the mark of the flat, well-planted soles of the feet, and so on up to a volition able to bring about the mark of the fleshy protuberance on the crown of the head. According to this view, thirty-two volitions bring about the thirty-two marks of the great being, and each mark is then further brought to completion by many further karmas. Question: among the marks, which does the bodhisattva's arising of the thirty-two volitions bring about first? Answer: some say:
先引足下平滿善住相。後引餘相。先安其足後及餘故。有說。先引目紺青相。先以慈眼觀世間故。如是說者。此則不定。隨此相緣合則引此相。
he first brings about the mark of the flat, well-planted soles of the feet, and afterward the other marks, because he first steadies his feet and only afterward extends to the rest. Some say: he first brings about the mark of the dark-blue eyes, because he first surveys the world with a compassionate gaze. According to this latter view: this is not fixed — whichever mark's conditions come together, that mark is brought about accordingly.
The painter's simile — a single color for the outline, many colors filling it in afterward — captures something the Abhidharma is often at pains to establish: that a small cause can be causally sufficient to fix an outcome's basic shape without being causally sufficient to produce its full richness, so that "drawing forth" and "completing" a result can be cleanly separated into two different kinds of karmic work.
2. The Thirty-Two Marks of the Great Being, Enumerated
The treatise now gives its full catalogue of the thirty-two marks of a great being (mahāpuruṣa-lakṣaṇa), from the flat, well-planted soles of the feet to the Brahmā-voice with its eight excellent qualities — the most extended single passage of physical description anywhere in the treatise. Each mark is paired with a brief gloss explaining what it looks like and, where relevant, what it means (the wheel-marked soles that even the deva of skilled craft cannot replicate; the golden skin whose splendor eclipses gold at every cosmic scale in succession, from human ironware up through the adornment-gold of the highest heavens; the single hair per pore, explained as a bodily echo of the bodhisattva's never having taught the Dharma in a confused or disorderly way).
三十二大丈夫相者。一足善住相。謂佛足下平滿不凹不凸。於踐躡時等按觸地。是故唯佛跡相分明。惡心欲去終不能滅。諸在家者若有此相。必為人王賓伏率土。諸出家者若有此相。必為法王化導一切。二者千輻輪相。謂佛於雙足下有文。如輪千輻具足轂輞圓滿分明巧妙。妙業天子雖極作意不能擬之而別化作。所以者何。妙業天子所化作事是無覆無記智所引。此相是純淨業所引故。復次彼天所作是生得智所引。此相是增上加行智所引故。復次彼天所作是一生所習智所引。此相是無量生所習智所引故。三者指纖長相。謂佛其指纖長傭而漸銳。節不麁現。並時無隙。安布得中光澤圓滿。四者足跟圓長相。謂佛足跟圓長端嚴廣直。五者手足細軟相。謂佛手足細軟如妬羅綿。六者手足網縵相。謂佛手足指間皆有網縵。猶如鵝王指。若合時網即不現而無皺緩。開時便現而無攣急。七者足趺端厚相。謂佛足趺圓厚向指傭寫兩邊端直。與跟相稱。躡時不廣。足下如紅蓮華色。網內邊如綵樹文爪甲如赤銅葉色。網外邊作真金色。細毛紺潤如吠琉璃故。佛雙足猶如寶履眾寶莊嚴光明微妙。八者翳泥耶[蹲-酋+(十/田/ㄙ)]相。謂佛[蹲-酋+(十/田/ㄙ)]脛圓直。漸下傭細。如翳泥耶鹿王[蹲-酋+(十/田/ㄙ)]。九者勢峯藏密相。謂佛勢峯藏密猶如馬王。若爾云何所化得見。有說。世尊愍所化故方便示之。有說。世尊化作象馬陰藏殊妙告所化言。如彼我亦爾。十者身分圓滿相。謂佛身分圓滿如諾瞿陀樹。如從臍至頂。如是從臍至足上下相稱。十一者身毛上靡相。十二者孔生一毛相。十三者身毛右旋相。謂佛身諸毛孔各生一毛。如吠琉璃其色紺潤宛轉右旋毛端上靡。所以一一毛孔唯一毛者。以菩薩時不亂說法故。十四者身真金色相。謂佛身真金色。映奪世間一切金光令不復現。如今時人所用鐵等。於今時所用金邊威光不現。今時所用金至佛在世時所用金邊威光不現。佛在世時所用金若至大海轉輪王路金砂贍部捺陀金邊威光不現。此金砂金若至七金山金邊威光不現。七金山金至妙高山王金邊威光不現。妙高山王金至三十三天莊嚴具金邊威光不現。如是展轉乃至樂變化天莊嚴具金至他化自在天莊嚴具金邊威光不現。此他化自在天莊嚴具金若至佛身金邊威光不現。是故佛身金色最勝。映奪一切世間金色。十五者常光一尋相。謂佛身分周匝常有光明。面各一尋晝夜恒照。十六者皮膚細滑相。謂佛皮膚細滑塵水不住。如吠琉璃及蓮華葉。設佛以足蹈於塵山。吠嵐婆風於中擊坌。欲令佛身及佛足下一塵染著無有是處。十七者七處充滿相。
The thirty-two marks of the great being are as follows. First, the mark of the well-planted feet: the soles of the Buddha's feet are flat, neither concave nor convex; when he walks, the sole touches the ground evenly all over. For this reason the Buddha's footprints alone are distinct and clear, and even one who wishes, out of ill will, to erase them can never obliterate them. Among householders, whoever has this mark will surely become a wheel-turning king before whom all submit, ruling over the whole land; among renunciants, whoever has this mark will surely become a Dharma-king who instructs and guides all beings.
Second, the mark of the thousand-spoked wheel: on the soles of both of the Buddha's feet there is a pattern like a wheel of a thousand spokes, complete with hub and rim, perfectly distinct and skillfully wrought. Even Viśvakarman, the deva of skilled craft, however much he exerted his mind, could not replicate it, and had to fashion something different instead. Why is this? Because what that deva fashions is drawn forth by an unobscured-neutral cognition, whereas this mark is drawn forth by a purely undefiled karma. Furthermore, what that deva makes is drawn forth by an innate cognition, whereas this mark is drawn forth by a cognition of superior, effortfully cultivated practice. Furthermore, what that deva makes is drawn forth by a cognition trained in a single lifetime, whereas this mark is drawn forth by a cognition trained over countless lifetimes.
Third, the mark of slender, long fingers: the Buddha's fingers are slender and long, rounded and gradually tapering, with joints that do not show coarsely, set close together without gaps, evenly and well arranged, lustrous and full.
Fourth, the mark of the round, long heel: the Buddha's heel is rounded, long, well-formed, broad, and straight.
Fifth, the mark of soft hands and feet: the Buddha's hands and feet are as soft as tūla-cotton.
Sixth, the mark of webbed hands and feet: between the Buddha's fingers and toes there is webbing, like the feet of a royal goose. When closed, the webbing does not show, yet there is no wrinkling or slackness; when spread open, it becomes visible, yet there is no cramping or tautness.
Seventh, the mark of the level, full instep: the Buddha's instep is rounded and full, sloping evenly toward the toes and straight on both sides, matching the heel in proportion; when he treads, the foot does not spread. The sole of his foot is the color of a red lotus; the inner edge of the webbing is patterned like a painted tree; the nails are the color of red-copper leaf; the outer edge of the webbing is the color of true gold; the fine hairs are dark-blue and glossy like vaiḍūrya. Thus the Buddha's two feet are like jeweled sandals, adorned with a multitude of gems, subtly luminous.
Eighth, the mark of aiṇeya, antelope-like calves: the Buddha's calves and shins are rounded and straight, tapering evenly downward, like the calves of an aiṇeya deer-king.
Ninth, the mark of the hidden, sheathed male organ: the Buddha's organ is hidden and sheathed like that of a stallion king. If this is so, how do those to be converted come to see it? Some say: the Blessed One, out of compassion for them, skillfully reveals it. Some say: the Blessed One conjures an elephant or a horse whose sheathed organ is especially wondrous and tells those to be converted, "Mine is like that one."
Tenth, the mark of the fully proportioned body: the Buddha's body is fully proportioned like a nyagrodha tree — the span from navel to crown matches the span from navel to feet.
Eleventh, the mark of body-hairs that lie slanting upward. Twelfth, the mark of a single hair growing from each pore. Thirteenth, the mark of body-hairs that curl to the right: each pore of the Buddha's body produces a single hair, dark-blue in color like vaiḍūrya, glossy, curling to the right, with the tip lying upward. The reason each single pore produces only a single hair is that, in his time as a bodhisattva, he never spoke the Dharma in a confused or disorderly way.
Fourteenth, the mark of the true-gold-colored body: the Buddha's body is the color of true gold, its splendor eclipsing every gold-light in the world so that it no longer appears — just as, in the present age, the light of the iron and such that ordinary people use is eclipsed beside the gold used in the present age; the gold used in the present age is eclipsed beside the gold used in the Buddha's own lifetime; the gold used in the Buddha's lifetime, brought beside the Jambūnada gold-dust found by the great ocean along the routes of wheel-turning kings, is eclipsed; that gold-dust, brought beside the gold of the seven gold mountains, is eclipsed; the gold of the seven gold mountains, brought beside the gold of Mount Sumeru, is eclipsed; the gold of Mount Sumeru, brought beside the adornment-gold of the Trāyastriṃśa heaven, is eclipsed; and so on in succession, up to the adornment-gold of the Nirmāṇarati heaven being eclipsed beside the adornment-gold of the Paranirmita-vaśavartin heaven; and that adornment-gold, brought beside the gold of the Buddha's own body, is likewise eclipsed and its splendor no longer appears. Therefore the golden color of the Buddha's body is supreme, eclipsing the golden color of the entire world.
Fifteenth, the mark of a constant halo one fathom across: a light is always present surrounding the Buddha's body, extending one fathom on every side, shining constantly day and night.
Sixteenth, the mark of fine, smooth skin: the Buddha's skin is so fine and smooth that dust and water do not cling to it, like vaiḍūrya or a lotus leaf. Even were the Buddha to tread upon a mountain of dust while the vairambhaka wind blew and scattered it about, there is no possibility that even a single speck of dust would adhere to the Buddha's body or to the soles of his feet.
Seventeenth, the mark of the seven full parts —
謂佛七處充滿。於餘身分此為少增。兩手兩足兩肩及項是為七處。
— namely, seven parts of the Buddha's body are full and slightly more rounded than the rest of the body: the two hands, the two feet, the two shoulders, and the nape of the neck — these are the seven parts.
十八者身廣洪直相。謂佛身廣洪直不偃不僂。亦不傍敧端雅充實。
Eighteenth, the mark of the broad, full, upright body: the Buddha's body is broad, full, and upright, neither stooped nor bent, nor leaning to either side; it is dignified, graceful, and full.
十九者師子上身相。謂佛胸臆分齊方廣威肅。如師子王上半身分。
Nineteenth, the mark of a lion's upper body: the Buddha's chest is well-proportioned, square, broad, and majestic, like the upper half of a lion king's body.
二十者肩髆圓滿相。謂佛肩髆圓滿。非諸捔力姝壯力士之所能及。
Twentieth, the mark of full, rounded shoulders: the Buddha's shoulders are full and rounded, beyond what any wrestler or mighty strongman could match.
二十一者立手摩膝相。謂佛平立舒手摩自膝輪。二十二者師子頷輪相。謂佛頷輪廣好如師子王。二十三者具四十齒相。二十四者齒齊平密相。二十五者牙齒鮮白有光明相。謂佛具四十齒皆悉齊平。中無間隙如毛髮許。其色鮮白光明晈映如雪山王。問餘人但有三十二齒。而說彼身中有一百三骨。佛具四十齒。何故亦言身中有一百三骨。而不增耶。答餘人頭骨九分合成。世尊頭骨但有一段。是以俱有一百三骨。二十六者得最上味相。謂佛舌根淨故。令所飲食變成上味。有說。佛舌根上有一切世間悅意美妙勝味種子。若諸苦酢等物至舌根時。此種雜變皆成上味。有說。如來舌根有如是勢力。若諸飲食來至舌根。於中悅意美妙性者便生舌識。麁鄙性者不生舌識。有說。佛咽喉中有二乳泉。若飲食時其乳流出。雜諸飲食皆成上味。然於此中舌根淨故令味殊勝。此理應然。二十七者廣長舌相。謂佛舌相薄軟。廣長出時覆面至耳髮際。若還入口而於口中無所妨礙。二十八者目紺青相。謂佛眼目脩廣。其色紺淨如蘇闍多青蓮花葉。二十九者牛王睫相。謂佛眼睫安布善好猶如牛王。三十者烏瑟膩沙相。謂佛頂髻骨肉合成。量如覆拳青圓殊妙。三十一者眉間白毫相。謂佛眉間白毫長半尋量。右旋宛轉光明清徹。三十二者得梵音聲相。謂佛於喉藏中有妙大種。能發悅意和雅梵音。如羯羅頻迦鳥。及發深遠雷震之聲。如帝釋鼓。如是音聲具八功德。一者深遠。二者和雅。三者分明。四者悅耳。五者入心。六者發喜。七者易了。八者無厭。
Twenty-first, the mark of standing upright with the hand able to touch the knee: standing evenly upright, the Buddha can extend his hand and touch the wheel of his own knee.
Twenty-second, the mark of a lion's jaw: the Buddha's jaw is broad and handsome like that of a lion king.
Twenty-third, the mark of having forty teeth. Twenty-fourth, the mark of teeth that are even and close-set. Twenty-fifth, the mark of bright white, lustrous teeth: the Buddha has forty teeth, all perfectly even, with gaps between them no wider than a hair's breadth; their color is bright white and radiant, gleaming like the Himalayan snow-king. Question: other people have only thirty-two teeth, yet it is said their bodies contain one hundred and three bones; the Buddha has forty teeth — why, then, is it also said that his body contains one hundred and three bones, with no increase? Answer: in other people the skull is formed of nine separate pieces joined together, whereas the Blessed One's skull is a single, continuous piece; hence both alike total one hundred and three bones.
Twenty-sixth, the mark of obtaining the supreme taste: because the Buddha's tongue-faculty is pure, whatever food or drink he takes is transformed into a supreme flavor. Some say: on the Buddha's tongue-faculty there are seeds of every delightful, exquisite, and supreme flavor found in the world; when bitter, sour, or similar substances reach the tongue-faculty, these seeds mix in and transform them so that all become supreme in flavor. Some say: the Tathāgata's tongue-faculty has such a power that, when food or drink reaches it, whatever in it is delightful and exquisite gives rise to tongue-consciousness, while whatever is coarse and unpleasant does not. Some say: within the Buddha's throat there are two founts like milk; whenever he eats or drinks, this "milk" flows out and mingles with the food, making it all supreme in flavor. Yet in every one of these accounts it is because the tongue-faculty is pure that the flavor is made superior — this explanation should be accepted as correct.
Twenty-seventh, the mark of the broad, long tongue: the Buddha's tongue is thin and soft; extended broad and long, it covers his face up to the hairline at the ears, and, drawn back into the mouth, it causes no obstruction there.
Twenty-eighth, the mark of dark-blue eyes: the Buddha's eyes are long and broad, their color a pure dark blue like the petal of a blue lotus.
Twenty-ninth, the mark of eyelashes like a royal bull's: the Buddha's eyelashes are arranged handsomely and well, like those of a bull-king.
Thirtieth, the mark of the uṣṇīṣa: the crown of the Buddha's head, formed of bone and flesh grown together, is the size of a closed fist, dark-blue, round, and of extraordinary beauty.
Thirty-first, the mark of the white ūrṇā between the brows: between the Buddha's brows there is a white curl of hair half a fathom in length, coiling to the right, luminous and translucent.
Thirty-second, the mark of the Brahmā-voice: within the Buddha's throat there is a wondrous great element able to produce a delightful, harmonious Brahmā-voice, like that of the kalaviṅka bird, together with a deep, resonant sound like the thunder of Indra's drum. Such a voice possesses eight excellent qualities: first, profundity; second, harmoniousness; third, clarity; fourth, pleasantness to the ear; fifth, penetrating the heart; sixth, evoking joy; seventh, ease of comprehension; eighth, freedom from causing weariness.
The mark-by-mark commentary keeps returning to a single explanatory move: a physical peculiarity is glossed not as an arbitrary miraculous embellishment but as the bodily residue of some specific virtue cultivated over countless lifetimes — the webbed fingers of universal generosity, the single hair per pore of orderly teaching, the eclipsing gold of merit outshining merit at every scale of the cosmos. The body, on this account, is not merely decorated with holiness; it is holiness's own accumulated signature.
3. Why Thirty-Two? Marks, Minor Marks, and the Vessel for Awakening
Having catalogued the marks, the treatise turns reflective: what does "mark" even mean, and why exactly thirty-two — no more, no fewer? The Venerable Pārśva's answer (either extreme would provoke doubt) sits alongside a more aesthetic one: thirty-two is simply the number that renders the Buddha's body most exquisite, exactly as his teaching itself admits of no possible improvement or subtraction. The section then places the eighty subsidiary marks (anuvyañjana) in the gaps between the thirty-two major ones, compares the whole ensemble to flowers setting off a forest or gems inlaid in a golden mountain, and reaches for the treatise's most vivid image yet: the Buddha's body as a mirror of Cīna polished to perfection, in which every object appears reflected, so that even hostile māras and tīrthikas cannot help but circle it in reverence. The section closes by insisting the bodhisattva adorns his own body from no personal vanity at all, but to subdue those who scorn the Dharma out of pride in their own looks, to display that every one of the Buddha's qualities is supreme, and to serve as a fit vessel for awakening itself — dramatized in the voice of that future awakening addressing the bodhisattva directly, insisting on a pure and adorned body before it will consent to arise within him.
問相是何義。答幖幟義是相義。殊勝義是相義。祥瑞義是相義。
Question: what is the meaning of "mark"? Answer: the meaning of "emblem" is the meaning of "mark"; the meaning of "excellence" is the meaning of "mark"; the meaning of "auspicious omen" is the meaning of "mark."
問何故大丈夫相唯三十二不增不減耶。脅尊者說曰。若增若減俱亦生疑。唯三十二亦不違法相。有說。三十二者世間共許是吉祥數。
Question: why are the marks of the great being exactly thirty-two, neither more nor fewer? The Venerable Pārśva said: were there either more or fewer, doubt would arise either way; thirty-two alone does not contradict the characteristic of the Dharma. Some say: thirty-two is a number universally acknowledged in the world as auspicious;
故不增減。有說。若三十二相莊嚴佛身則於世間最勝無比。若當減者便為闕少。若更增者則亦雜亂。皆非殊妙故唯爾所。如佛說法不可增減。佛相亦爾。無減可增無增可減故。問八十隨好為在何處。
hence there is neither increase nor decrease. Some say: if thirty-two marks adorn the Buddha's body, he is then supreme and without equal in the world; were there fewer, something would be lacking, and were there more, it would become disordered — either way it would no longer be exquisite, hence exactly this number. Just as the Buddha's teaching of the Dharma cannot be increased or decreased, so too are the Buddha's marks: there is nothing deficient that could be added, and nothing in excess that could be removed. Question: where are the eighty minor marks located?
答在諸相間隨諸相轉莊嚴佛身令極妙好。問相與隨好不相障奪耶。
Answer: they are located in the spaces between the marks, following and turning along with them, adorning the Buddha's body to make it utterly exquisite. Question: do the marks and the minor marks not obscure or overshadow one another?
答不爾。相與隨好更相顯發如林中花顯發諸樹。佛身如是相好莊嚴。又如金山眾寶雜飾。如是佛身威光奇特。以如來身極鑒淨故。
Answer: they do not. The marks and the minor marks bring each other out in turn, just as flowers in a forest bring out the beauty of the trees; the Buddha's body is adorned with marks and minor marks in just this way. It is also like a golden mountain inlaid with a multitude of gems — thus is the Buddha's body of extraordinary majestic splendor, because the Tathāgata's body is supremely clear and pure, like a mirror —
諸祥瑞物皆現其中。如至那鏡極磨瑩已。隨物遠近影像皆現。佛身亦爾。是故一切諸魔外道懷惡心者。至佛處時無不瞻仰。覩之無厭右繞而去。問菩薩於身為有愛慢而莊嚴耶。答不爾。問云何。答菩薩為欲降伏世間恃色憍慢不受化者令受化故。以諸相好而莊嚴身。
— all auspicious objects appear reflected within it. It is like a mirror of Cīna that has been polished to perfection: whatever objects, near or far, all appear reflected in it. The Buddha's body is just the same. For this reason, all māras and tīrthikas who harbor ill will, upon coming into the Buddha's presence, cannot but gaze up at him in reverence; beholding him, they never tire, and they depart circumambulating him to the right. Question: does the bodhisattva adorn his body out of attachment and conceit regarding it? Answer: it is not so. Question: how then should this be understood? Answer: the bodhisattva adorns his body with the marks and minor marks in order to subdue those in the world who, relying on arrogance over their own physical beauty, refuse to accept conversion, so as to cause them to accept it.
復次為顯佛所有法皆殊勝故。謂色力族姓眷屬名譽財富自在。智見功德皆悉殊勝。若不爾者。則所說法無人信受。是故菩薩莊嚴其身。復次欲與阿耨多羅三藐三菩提作所依器故。所以者何。殊勝功德決定依止殊勝之身。彼未來阿耨多羅三藐三菩提義。語菩薩言。
Furthermore, it is to make manifest that every dharma possessed by the Buddha is supreme — that is, his physical beauty, strength, lineage, retinue, renown, wealth, and mastery, together with his wisdom, insight, and virtues, are all supreme. Were it not so, no one would have faith in and accept the Dharma he teaches; hence the bodhisattva adorns his body. Furthermore, it is in order to serve as the supporting vessel for unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. Why is this? Because supreme merit and virtue must necessarily rely upon a supreme body. As it were, the future reality of that unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening itself speaks to the bodhisattva, saying:
Personifying the bodhisattva's own future awakening as a suitor who will not enter an unprepared house is a striking piece of theology dressed as domestic comedy: it converts what could sound like vanity — cultivating a supremely beautiful body — into a strict precondition of causality, on the principle that no merit, however great, can arise within, or be housed by, a vessel not yet made fit to receive it.
4. The King's Daughter and the Bodhisattva's Visible Signs
The parable of the future awakening as a bride who will not come to an unswept house is immediately doubled by a second, more worldly one — a suitor secretly warned by his intended that she will not enter his home until it has been cleansed, hung with banners, and perfumed with incense. The treatise then turns practical: when the bodhisattva becomes a wheel-turning king somewhere in the middle of his career, is it the very karma destined for his final excellent marks that produces that lesser royal splendor, or some other karma entirely? The majority view treats the mark-karma as reserved entirely for the final body, comparing it to a wealthy man's priceless jewel kept back while lesser goods are freely traded — and specifies exactly how the bodhisattva's own marks exceed even a wheel-king's, before cataloguing the visible signs — noble birth, recollection of past lives, tireless generosity, an unshakeable resolve — by which sentient beings can recognize a bodhisattva even before his final body.
汝欲令我在身中者。先令汝身清淨殊勝。以諸相好而莊嚴之。若不爾者。我亦不能於汝身生。譬如有人欲娉王女迎至室宅。彼密遣使而語之言。汝欲令我至舍宅者。先應灑掃除去鄙穢。懸繒幡蓋燒香散花種種莊嚴。吾乃可往。若不爾者。我亦不能至汝舍宅。是故菩薩莊嚴其身。問菩薩造作增長相異熟業已中間。或作轉輪王時。為即所修相異熟業。感彼相果。為餘業耶。答有說。即以所修相異熟業。以此業功能廣大。假設至今恒作輪王。而彼業勢亦不盡故。如是說者。彼以餘業。所以者何。菩薩修相異熟業皆為於最後身受殊勝果未便受用。然由彼業為增上造餘善業感輪王相果。譬如大富長者多諸珍寶。其中大價寶珠未便出用。餘輕價者隨時貿易。彼亦如是。問菩薩所得三十二相與輪王相有何差別。答菩薩所得有四事勝。一熾盛。二分明。三圓滿。四得處。復次有五事勝。一得處。
"If you wish me to dwell within your body, first make your body pure and supreme, adorning it with the marks and minor marks; if you do not, I too will be unable to arise within your body." It is like a man who wishes to take a king's daughter in marriage and welcome her into his house: she secretly sends a messenger to tell him, "If you wish me to come to your house, you must first sweep and cleanse it, removing all filth and impurity, and hang silk banners and canopies, burn incense, and scatter flowers in every kind of adornment — only then may I go there; if you do not, I too will be unable to come to your house." For this reason the bodhisattva adorns his body. Question: after the bodhisattva has created and augmented the karma that ripens into the excellent marks, in the interim — for instance, at a time when he becomes a wheel-turning king — is it the very karma he has cultivated that ripens into the excellent marks which brings about the fruit of those marks, or is it some other karma? Answer: some say: it is precisely the cultivated karma that ripens into the excellent marks, because the efficacy of this karma is so vast that, even were he to remain a wheel-turning king down to the present, the force of that karma would still not be exhausted. According to another view: it is some other karma. Why is this? Because the bodhisattva cultivates the karma that ripens into the excellent marks entirely in order to experience its supreme fruit in his final body, not to make use of it beforehand. Rather, it is by that karma serving as a dominant condition for the arising of other wholesome karmas that the fruit of the marks of a wheel-turning king is brought about. It is like a wealthy elder possessed of many treasures: the priceless jewel among them is not brought out for use beforehand, while the lesser-valued items are exchanged as occasion requires. It is the same in this case. Question: what difference is there between the thirty-two marks obtained by the bodhisattva and the marks of a wheel-turning king? Answer: what the bodhisattva obtains excels in four respects: first, it is more resplendent; second, more distinct; third, more complete; fourth, it is obtained in the proper location on the body. Furthermore, it excels in five respects: first, it is obtained in the proper location;
二極端嚴。三文象深。四隨順勝智。五隨順離染。問菩薩造作增長相異熟業已。未至最後身來。於諸有情有異相可識知不。答有。謂生貴族形貌端嚴具丈夫身諸根圓滿。得宿命念深信因果。憙樂多聞尊重正法。智見猛利有勝辯才。志性調柔言音和雅。所作決定終無退屈。見他受苦情不堪忍。要當拔濟。所修無不迴向菩提。樂與有情作饒益事。而不求報。此等名為彼菩薩相。
second, it is of the utmost beauty; third, its pattern-form is profound; fourth, it accords with supreme wisdom; fifth, it accords with the abandonment of afflictions. Question: after the bodhisattva has created and augmented the karma that ripens into the excellent marks, before he reaches his final body, are there distinguishing signs by which sentient beings can recognize him? Answer: there are. Namely: he is born into a noble family, of dignified and handsome appearance, possessed of a manly body with all faculties complete; he attains recollection of past lives and deep faith in cause and effect; he delights in extensive learning and reveres the true Dharma; his wisdom and insight are keen, and he possesses supreme eloquence; his disposition is gentle and pliant, his speech harmonious and refined; whatever he undertakes he carries through with resolve and never with retreat or discouragement; upon seeing others suffer, he cannot bear it and must go to their rescue; whatever he cultivates, there is nothing he does not dedicate to bodhi; he delights in acting for the benefit of sentient beings, without seeking any reward in return. These are called the marks of that bodhisattva.
Reserving the mark-producing karma exclusively for the final body, even while its bearer spends lifetime after lifetime as a wheel-turning king, treats spiritual capital rather like a fortune held in trust: it can visibly generate lesser returns along the way without ever being spent down, precisely because its real purpose lies in a single, far more consequential future disbursement.
5. The Hundred Blessings That Adorn Each Mark
Turning to a scriptural claim that each mark is "adorned by a hundred blessings," the treatise identifies these hundred blessings as a hundred discrete volitions — fifty preparing the ground, one that draws the mark forth, and fifty more completing it, likened to a farmer who tills, sows, and then waters and manures in turn. It then surveys a cascade of proposed units for measuring a single "blessing" — the merit needed to become a wheel-king, a Śakra, a Paranirmita-vaśavartin deva-king, a Brahmā — each larger than the last, climaxing in Mahābrahmā's own merit in entreating the Buddha to teach, itself immediately complicated by the objection that Brahmā's entreating mind is merely neutral and desire-realm-bound, and so seemingly incapable of counting as merit at all. A cluster of vivid analogies follows — curing universal blindness, universal poisoning, universal bondage, universal loss of precepts and right view, each in a single stroke — before the treatise pulls back to insist that all such measures, however evocative, remain approximations: a bodhisattva's actual merit, cultivated across three incalculable eons, is strictly immeasurable, knowable to a Buddha alone.
問如契經說佛一一相百福莊嚴。何謂百福。答此中百思名為百福。
Question: as the sūtras say, each single mark of the Buddha is adorned by a hundred blessings — what are these hundred blessings? Answer: here, a hundred distinct volitions are called the hundred blessings.
何謂百思。謂如菩薩造作增長足善住相業時。先起五十思。修治身器令淨調柔。次起一思正牽引彼。後復起五十思令其圓滿。譬如農夫先治畦壟次下種子後以糞水而覆溉之。彼亦如是。如足善住相業有如是百思莊嚴。乃至頂上烏瑟膩沙相業亦復如是。由此故說。佛一一相百福莊嚴。問何者是五十思耶。答依十業道各有五思。謂依離殺業道有五思。一離殺思。二勸導思。三讚美思。四隨喜思。五迴向思。謂迴所修向菩提故。乃至正見亦爾。是名五十思。有說。
What are the hundred volitions? That is, just as when the bodhisattva creates and augments the karma for the mark of the well-planted feet: first he gives rise to fifty volitions that cultivate and refine his bodily vessel, making it pure and pliant; next he gives rise to a single volition that properly draws it forth; and afterward he again gives rise to fifty volitions that bring it to completion. It is like a farmer who first prepares the furrows and ridges, then sows the seed, and afterward covers and irrigates it with manure and water — it is just the same in this case. Just as the karma for the mark of the well-planted feet is adorned by a hundred such volitions, so too is it for the karma of the mark of the fleshy protuberance on the crown of the head, and so on for all the rest. It is for this reason that it is said, each single mark of the Buddha is adorned by a hundred blessings. Question: what are the fifty volitions? Answer: based on each of the ten courses of karma there are five volitions. That is, based on the course of abstaining from killing there are five volitions: first, the volition of abstaining from killing; second, the volition of exhorting others to abstain; third, the volition of praising that abstention; fourth, the volition of rejoicing in it; fifth, the volition of dedication — that is, dedicating what one has cultivated toward bodhi. And so it is likewise up to right view. These are called the fifty volitions. Some say:
依十業道各起下中上上勝上極。五品善思如雜修靜慮。有說。依十業道各起五思。一加行淨。二根本淨。三後起淨。四非尋所害。五念攝受。有說。緣佛一相起五十剎那。未曾習思相續而轉。問如是百福一一量云何。答有說。若業能感轉輪王位。於四大洲自在而轉。是一福量。有說。若業能感天帝釋位。於二天眾自在而轉。是一福量。有說。若業能感他化自在天王位。於一切欲界天眾自在而轉。是一福量。有說。若業能感大梵天王位。於初靜慮及欲界天眾自在而轉。是一福量。有說。娑訶世界主大梵天王。勸請如來轉法輪福。是一福量。
based on each of the ten courses of karma, one gives rise to five grades of wholesome volition — inferior, middling, superior, surpassing-superior, and utmost-superior — just as in the mixed cultivation of dhyāna. Some say: based on each of the ten courses of karma one gives rise to five volitions: first, purity of the preparatory stage; second, purity of the fundamental stage; third, purity of the concluding stage; fourth, not being harmed by discursive thought; fifth, being sustained by mindfulness. Some say: taking a single mark of the Buddha as condition, one gives rise to fifty successive moments of a volition never before cultivated, arising in unbroken continuity. Question: as for these hundred blessings, what is the measure of each single one? Answer: some say: if a karma is able to bring about the position of wheel-turning king, exercising sovereign mastery over the four great continents — that is the measure of one blessing. Some say: if a karma is able to bring about the position of Śakra, lord of the devas, exercising sovereign mastery over the two heavenly hosts — that is the measure of one blessing. Some say: if a karma is able to bring about the position of the king of the Paranirmita-vaśavartin heaven, exercising sovereign mastery over all the heavenly hosts of the desire realm — that is the measure of one blessing. Some say: if a karma is able to bring about the position of the great Brahmā king, exercising sovereign mastery over the first dhyāna heaven together with the heavenly hosts of the desire realm — that is the measure of one blessing. Some say: the blessing of Mahābrahmā, lord of the Sahā world-system, in entreating the Tathāgata to turn the wheel of the Dharma — that is the measure of one blessing.
問彼請佛時是欲界繫無覆無記心。云何名福。答有說。彼住梵世。
Question: at the time he entreats the Buddha, Brahmā's mind is unobscured-neutral and bound to the desire realm — how then can this be called a blessing? Answer: some say: while dwelling in the Brahmā world,
欲來請時先起如是善心。我當為諸有情作大饒益請佛轉法輪。爾時即名得彼梵福。此不應理。所以者何。非未作時已成就故。如是說者。彼請佛已還至梵宮。後世尊轉法輪時地神先唱。如是展轉聲徹梵宮。梵王聞已歡喜自慶。發淳淨心而生隨喜。爾時乃名成就此福。有說。世界成時一切有情業增上力。能感三千大千世界。是一福量。有說。除近佛地菩薩餘一切有情。所有能感富樂果業。是一福量。有說。此中一一福量應以喻顯。假使一切有情皆悉生盲。有一有情以大方便令俱得眼。彼有情福是一福量。復次假使一切有情皆飲毒藥悶亂將死。有一有情令皆除毒心得醒悟。彼有情福是一福量。復次假使一切有情皆被縛錄臨當斷命。有一有情俱令解脫一時得命。彼有情福是一福量。復次假使一切有情壞戒壞見。有一有情能令俱時戒見具足。彼有情福是一福量。評曰。如是所說皆是淳淨意樂。方便讚美菩薩福量。然皆未得其實。如實義者。菩薩所起一一福量無量無邊。以菩薩三無數劫積集圓滿諸波羅蜜多已。所引思願極廣大故。唯佛能知。非餘所測。如是所說廣大。量福。具足滿百莊嚴一相。展轉乃至三十二相皆具百福。佛以如是三十二百福莊嚴相。及八十隨好莊嚴其身故於天上人中最尊最勝。
when about to come and make his entreaty, he first gives rise to a wholesome mind such as this: "I shall bring about great benefit for sentient beings by entreating the Buddha to turn the wheel of the Dharma" — at that very moment he is said to have attained that Brahmā-blessing. This should not be accepted as correct. Why is this? Because a thing is not already accomplished before it has been done. According to this other view: after Brahmā has made his entreaty to the Buddha, he returns to his Brahmā palace; later, when the Blessed One turns the wheel of the Dharma, the earth-deities are the first to proclaim it, and the sound travels on in succession until it reaches the Brahmā palace. Having heard it, the Brahmā king rejoices and congratulates himself, giving rise to a pure and sincere mind of rejoicing — it is only then that he is said to have accomplished this blessing. Some say: at the time a world-system comes into being, the dominant force of the karma of all sentient beings, able to bring about a trichiliocosm — that is the measure of one blessing. Some say: excepting bodhisattvas close to the stage of Buddhahood, the karma of all remaining sentient beings capable of bringing about the fruit of wealth and happiness — that is the measure of one blessing. Some say: each measure of blessing here should be illustrated by an analogy. Suppose that all sentient beings were born blind, and there were one sentient being who, through great skillful means, caused them all to gain sight — the blessing of that being is the measure of one blessing. Furthermore, suppose that all sentient beings had drunk poison and were confused and dying, and there were one sentient being who caused the poison to be removed from them all and their minds to awaken — the blessing of that being is the measure of one blessing. Furthermore, suppose that all sentient beings were bound and fettered, on the verge of having their lives cut off, and there were one sentient being who caused them all to be released and to obtain life at once — the blessing of that being is the measure of one blessing. Furthermore, suppose that all sentient beings had broken their precepts and corrupted their views, and there were one sentient being able to cause them all, at the same time, to be perfect in precepts and in view — the blessing of that being is the measure of one blessing. Comment: all such statements represent nothing but expressions of pure and sincere aspiration, skillful means for praising the measure of the bodhisattva's blessing, yet none of them attain the actual truth of the matter. As for the true meaning: each single measure of blessing that the bodhisattva gives rise to is immeasurable and boundless, because, once the bodhisattva has accumulated and perfected the pāramitās over three incalculable eons, the resolve and aspiration thereby drawn forth are supremely vast; only a Buddha can know this, and it is beyond the reckoning of anyone else. Such vast and measureless blessing, complete and full to a hundred, adorns a single mark, and so on in succession until all thirty-two marks are each complete with a hundred blessings. Because the Buddha adorns himself with these thirty-two marks, each with its hundred blessings, together with the eighty minor marks that adorn his body, he is therefore the most honored and supreme among gods and men.
The objection over Brahmā's entreaty — how can a neutral, desire-bound state of mind constitute genuine merit? — and its resolution, relocating the merit to a later moment of pure rejoicing once news of the Dharma-wheel's turning reaches him, shows this tradition refusing to let devotional storytelling override its own strict psychology of karma: a pious act only counts as merit at the precise moment a qualifying mental state actually arises, not merely wherever the narrative would find it most convenient.
6. Śākyamuni Overtakes Nine Eons
The treatise asks how long the mark-producing karma takes to perfect — a hundred great eons, ordinarily — except for Śākyamuni, who compressed it into ninety-one by sheer diligence, and tells the story behind the exception. Under the ancient Buddha Tiṣya, two bodhisattva disciples, Śākyamuni and Maitreya, were cultivating together; Tiṣya foresaw that Maitreya's own faculties would ripen first but that Śākyamuni's converts would ripen first, and, since ripening many beings at once is far harder than ripening one, engineered an encounter to accelerate Śākyamuni specifically — withdrawing into a mountain grotto in blazing meditative bliss, where Śākyamuni found him and, transfixed for seven days and nights, praised him with a single unvarying verse. That single verse of unwavering devotion, the treatise explains, let Śākyamuni leap over nine entire eons and overtake Maitreya to buddhahood first — the same singleness of purpose then explaining, more broadly, why Maitreya (who chiefly benefits himself) and Śākyamuni (who chiefly benefits others) end up so exactly inverted in whose faculties, and whose disciples', ripen first.
問此相異熟業經於幾時修習圓滿。答多分經百大劫。唯除釋迦菩薩。以釋迦菩薩極精進故超九大劫。但經九十一劫修習圓滿。便得無上正等菩提。其事云何。如契經說。過去有佛號曰底砂。或曰補砂。彼佛有二菩薩弟子勤修梵行。一名釋迦牟尼。二名梅怛儷藥。
Question: over how long a time is the karma that ripens into the excellent marks cultivated to completion? Answer: for the most part it is cultivated to completion over a hundred great eons, with the sole exception of the bodhisattva Śākyamuni. Because the bodhisattva Śākyamuni was of such extreme diligence, he leapt over nine great eons, so that he cultivated it to completion in only ninety-one eons, and thereby attained unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening. How did this come about? As the sūtra relates: in the past there was a Buddha named Tiṣya, also called Puṣya, who had two bodhisattva disciples diligently cultivating pure conduct — one named Śākyamuni, the other named Maitreya.
爾時彼佛觀二弟子誰先根熟。即如實知慈氏先熟。能寂後熟。復觀二士所化有情誰根先熟。又如實知釋迦所化應先根熟。知已即念。
At that time that Buddha observed which of the two disciples' faculties would ripen first, and truly knew that Maitreya's would ripen first and Śākyamuni's — "the Able and Silent One" — afterward. He further observed which of the two disciples' converted sentient beings' faculties would ripen first, and truly knew that those converted by Śākyamuni would ripen first. Having known this, he reflected:
我今云何令彼機感相會遇耶。然令一人速熟則易。非令多人。作是念已。便告釋迦。吾欲遊山汝可隨去。爾時彼佛取尼師檀。隨路先往既至山上。入吠琉璃龕敷尼師檀。結跏趺坐入火界定。經七晝夜受妙喜樂。威光熾然。釋迦須臾亦往山上處處尋佛。如犢求母。展轉遇至彼龕室前。欻然見佛威儀端肅光明照曜。專誠懇發喜歎不堪。於行無間忘下一足。瞻仰尊顏目不暫捨。經七晝夜。以一伽他讚彼佛曰。
"How, then, shall I bring it about that their capacities and occasions come together to meet? Yet to cause a single person to ripen swiftly is easy, whereas to cause many people to ripen at once is not." Having had this thought, he told Śākyamuni: "I wish to wander in the mountains; you may follow along." At that time the Buddha took up his sitting-mat and went on ahead along the path; having reached the mountain, he entered a grotto of vaiḍūrya, spread out his sitting-mat, sat cross-legged, and entered the concentration of the fire-element, experiencing wondrous joy and bliss for seven days and nights, his majestic radiance blazing forth. Śākyamuni, shortly after, likewise went up the mountain, searching everywhere for the Buddha, like a calf seeking its mother, wandering about, until at last he came before that grotto-chamber, and suddenly beheld the Buddha, his bearing dignified and solemn, his radiance blazing and brilliant. With single-minded sincerity and fervent devotion, his joy and admiration became unbearable; in the midst of walking he forgot to set down his raised foot, and gazed up reverently at the Blessed One's countenance without letting his eyes leave it for even a moment, for seven days and nights. With a single verse he praised that Buddha, saying:
天地此界多聞室 逝宮天處十方無丈夫牛王大沙門 尋地山林遍無等如是讚已便超九劫。於慈氏前得無上覺。問近佛地菩薩必於名句文身。得未曾得巧妙自在。應以別頌異門讚佛。何故經七晝夜唯以一頌而讚佛耶。答菩薩爾時思願勝故不重文頌。若改文頌則思願不淳。復次菩薩爾時怖畏散亂。如頌差別心亦異故。云何而得一心流注。復次菩薩顯己心無厭倦能於一頌新新發起勝思願故。問何故慈氏菩薩自根先熟所化後熟。釋迦菩薩則與此相違耶。答慈氏菩薩多自饒益少饒益他。釋迦菩薩多饒益他少自饒益。是故皆與所化不並。問如契經說。菩薩經三劫阿僧企耶。修行四波羅蜜多方得圓滿。此是何等劫耶。答有說是中劫。有說。是成劫。有說。是壞劫。如是說者此是大劫。積此大劫至一阿僧企耶。如是至三阿僧企耶修習圓滿。問此劫阿僧企耶量云何可知。答有說。以大劫為一。
"In heaven and earth, in this world's chamber of vast learning, in celestial palaces gone beyond, in the ten directions there is none like him; O foremost of men, bull among men, great renunciant — searching earth, mountain, and forest, everywhere, he has no equal."
Having praised him thus, Śākyamuni leapt over nine eons, and attained supreme awakening ahead of Maitreya. Question: a bodhisattva close to the stage of Buddhahood must surely have attained mastery, unprecedented and skillful, over names, phrases, and syllables — he ought to have praised the Buddha with a variety of verses and different modes of expression. Why, then, over seven days and nights, did he praise the Buddha with only a single verse? Answer: at that time the bodhisattva's resolve and aspiration were so intense that he did not attach importance to varying his verse; had he altered it, his resolve and aspiration would not have remained pure and undivided. Furthermore, at that time the bodhisattva feared distraction: were the verses to differ, his mind would likewise vary accordingly — how then could he attain a single, unbroken stream of mind? Furthermore, the bodhisattva wished to demonstrate that his mind was without weariness, able, within a single verse, to give rise ever anew to a supreme resolve and aspiration. Question: why is it that for the bodhisattva Maitreya his own faculties ripen first and those he converts ripen afterward, whereas for the bodhisattva Śākyamuni it is the reverse? Answer: the bodhisattva Maitreya greatly benefits himself and only slightly benefits others, whereas the bodhisattva Śākyamuni greatly benefits others and only slightly benefits himself; for this reason, in both cases, the ripening of their own faculties does not coincide with that of those they convert. Question: as the sūtra says, the bodhisattva cultivates the four pāramitās to completion only after passing through three incalculable eons — what kind of eon is meant here? Answer: some say it is an intermediate eon; some say it is the eon of formation; some say it is the eon of destruction. According to this latter view, it is a great eon — one accumulates such great eons up to a single asaṃkhyeya, and in this way cultivates to completion over three asaṃkhyeyas. Question: how can the measure of this eon-asaṃkhyeya be known? Answer: some say: taking a great eon as the unit,
Making the choice to repeat one unaltered verse for seven unbroken days and nights, rather than displaying his full command of eloquence, itself the very sign of his supreme resolve is a small but telling piece of religious psychology: the treatise treats variety of expression as a symptom of a divided mind, so that the discipline of saying exactly the same thing, undistracted, becomes proof of a devotion focused enough to overtake nine eons in a single sustained act.
7. Measuring the Three Incalculable Eons
The fascicle closes with the treatise's most technical passage: how large, exactly, is a single "incalculable eon" (asaṃkhyeya kalpa)? Two rival counting schemes are laid out in full, each compounding named units by a hundred thousand-fold, or by tenfold, at each step — from lakṣa and koṭi up through vagra and beyond, until the count exceeds the very reach of arithmetic and the term "asaṃkhyeya," incalculable, is applied to name exactly that point. Alternative measures follow — Śāriputra's own recollective range (rejected, since no arhat's memory can span so vast a period), and a giving-based scale keyed to whether the bodhisattva has learned to give every possession, then every field, then both at once. The fascicle's true center of gravity, though, is the story of the potter Prabhāsa: told through the vast wheel of time to a Buddha named Śākyamuni whose shoulders ached from ceaseless travel to help beings, the potter anointed and bathed him with sesame oil and warm water, and, moved to tears, vowed to become a Buddha with an identical name, retinue, and disciples — a vow the treatise reveals was Śākyamuni's own, its fulfillment marking the completion of the first of his three incalculable eons, with the second and third marked by later Buddhas encountered along the way.
積此一至百千名洛叉。至百百千名俱胝。百千俱胝名那庾多。百千那庾多名頻婆。百千頻婆名建他。此後非算數智所及。至此所不及位名一劫阿僧企耶量。第二第三劫阿僧企耶量亦爾。有說。以大劫為一。積此一至百千名洛叉。至百百千名俱胝。百千俱胝名俱胝俱胝。百千俱胝俱胝名阿哳哳俱胝。百千阿哳哳俱胝名阿吒吒俱胝。
one accumulates this unit up to a hundred thousand, which is called a lakṣa; up to a hundred times a hundred thousand, which is called a koṭi; a hundred thousand koṭi is called a nayuta; a hundred thousand nayuta is called a bimba; a hundred thousand bimba is called a kaṅkara — beyond this point the number exceeds the reach of arithmetical cognition, and it is at this point beyond reckoning that the measure of one eon-asaṃkhyeya is named. The measure of the second and third eon-asaṃkhyeyas is likewise. Some say: taking a great eon as a single unit, one accumulates this unit up to a hundred thousand, called a lakṣa; up to a hundred times a hundred thousand, called a koṭi; a hundred thousand koṭi is called a koṭi-koṭi; a hundred thousand koṭi-koṭi is called an aṭaṭa-koṭi; a hundred thousand aṭaṭa-koṭi is called an aṭṭaṭa-koṭi.
百千阿吒吒俱胝名阿庾多。百千阿庾多名阿庾多分。百千阿庾多分名那庾多。百千那庾多名那庾多分。百千那庾多分名俱物陀。百千俱物陀名俱物陀分。百千俱物陀分名鉢特摩。百千鉢特摩名鉢特摩分。百千鉢特摩分名迦末羅。百千迦末羅名迦末羅分。百千迦末羅分名捺稚那。百千捺稚那名捺稚那分。百千捺稚那分名覩胝。百千覩胝名覩胝分。百千覩胝分名阿波波。百千阿波波名阿波波分。百千阿波波分名吒吒。百千吒吒名吒吒分。百千吒吒分名鄔伽。百千鄔伽名鄔伽分。百千鄔伽分名跋羅。百千跋羅名跋羅分。百千跋羅分名婆揭羅。從此以後非算數智所及。至此所不及位名一劫阿僧企耶量。第二第三劫阿僧企耶量亦爾。有說。非算數智所不及故名阿僧企耶。然有契經說六十數。於中有一數名阿僧企耶積大劫數至此數時名一劫阿僧企耶。如彼經言。有一無餘數始為一。十一為十。
a hundred thousand aṭṭaṭa-koṭi is called an ayuta; a hundred thousand ayuta is called an 'ayuta-part'; a hundred thousand ayuta-parts is called a nayuta; a hundred thousand nayuta is called a 'nayuta-part'; a hundred thousand nayuta-parts is called a kumuda; a hundred thousand kumuda is called a 'kumuda-part'; a hundred thousand kumuda-parts is called a padma; a hundred thousand padma is called a 'padma-part'; a hundred thousand padma-parts is called a kamala; a hundred thousand kamala is called a 'kamala-part'; a hundred thousand kamala-parts is called a naḍita; a hundred thousand naḍita is called a 'naḍita-part'; a hundred thousand naḍita-parts is called a tuṭi; a hundred thousand tuṭi is called a 'tuṭi-part'; a hundred thousand tuṭi-parts is called an apapa; a hundred thousand apapa is called an 'apapa-part'; a hundred thousand apapa-parts is called an aṭaṭa; a hundred thousand aṭaṭa is called an 'aṭaṭa-part'; a hundred thousand aṭaṭa-parts is called an ugra; a hundred thousand ugra is called an 'ugra-part'; a hundred thousand ugra-parts is called a bala; a hundred thousand bala is called a 'bala-part'; a hundred thousand bala-parts is called a vagra. From this point onward the number exceeds the reach of arithmetical cognition, and it is at this point beyond reckoning that the measure of one eon-asaṃkhyeya is named; the measure of the second and third eon-asaṃkhyeyas is likewise. Some say: it is called 'asaṃkhyeya' precisely because it is beyond the reach of arithmetical cognition; yet there is a sūtra that speaks of sixty numerical terms, among which one term is named 'asaṃkhyeya' — when the accumulation of great eons reaches this term, it is called one eon-asaṃkhyeya. As that sūtra says: there is a number with nothing beyond it, which begins as 'one'; ten of these make 'ten';
十十為百。十百為千。十千為鉢羅薜陀。十鉢羅薜陀為洛叉。十洛叉為頞底洛叉。十頞底洛叉為俱胝。十俱胝為末陀。十末陀為阿庾多。十阿庾多為大阿庾多。十大阿庾多為那庾多。十那庾多為大那庾多。十大那庾多為鉢羅那庾多。十鉢羅那庾多為大鉢羅那庾多。
ten tens make a 'hundred'; ten hundreds make a 'thousand'; ten thousands make a pravāda; ten pravāda make a lakṣa; ten lakṣa make an atilakṣa; ten atilakṣa make a koṭi; ten koṭi make a madra; ten madra make an ayuta; ten ayuta make a 'great ayuta'; ten great ayuta make a nayuta; ten nayuta make a 'great nayuta'; ten great nayuta make a pranayuta; ten pranayuta make a 'great pranayuta';
十大鉢羅那庾多為矜羯羅。十矜羯羅為大矜羯羅。十大矜羯羅為頻跋羅。十頻跋羅為大頻跋羅。十大頻跋羅為阿芻婆。十阿芻婆為大阿芻婆。十大阿芻婆為毘婆訶。十毘婆訶為大毘婆訶。十大毘婆訶為嗢蹭伽。十嗢蹭伽為大嗢蹭伽。十大嗢蹭伽為婆喝那。十婆喝那為大婆喝那。十大婆喝那為地致婆。十地致婆為大地致婆。十大地致婆為醯都。十醯都為大醯都。十大醯都為羯臘婆。十羯臘婆為大羯臘婆。十大羯臘婆為印達羅。十印達羅為大印達羅。十大印達羅為三磨鉢耽。十三磨鉢耽為大三磨鉢耽。十大三磨鉢耽為揭底。十揭底為大揭底。十大揭底為拈筏羅闍。十拈筏羅闍為大拈筏羅闍。
ten great pranayuta make a kaṅkara; ten kaṅkara make a 'great kaṅkara'; ten great kaṅkara make a bindala; ten bindala make a 'great bindala'; ten great bindala make an akṣobhya; ten akṣobhya make a 'great akṣobhya'; ten great akṣobhya make a vivāha; ten vivāha make a 'great vivāha'; ten great vivāha make an utsaṅga; ten utsaṅga make a 'great utsaṅga'; ten great utsaṅga make a vāhana; ten vāhana make a 'great vāhana'; ten great vāhana make a tiṭibha; ten tiṭibha make a 'great tiṭibha'; ten great tiṭibha make a hetu; ten hetu make a 'great hetu'; ten great hetu make a karabha; ten karabha make a 'great karabha'; ten great karabha make an indra; ten indra make a 'great indra'; ten great indra make a samāpta; ten samāpta make a 'great samāpta'; ten great samāpta make a gati; ten gati make a 'great gati'; ten great gati make a nimbarajas; ten nimbarajas make a 'great nimbarajas';
十大拈筏羅闍為姥達羅。十姥達羅為大姥達羅。十大姥達羅為跋藍。十跋藍為大跋藍。十大跋藍為珊若。十珊若為大珊若。十大珊若為毘步多。十毘步多為大毘步多。十大毘步多為跋邏攙。十跋邏攙為大跋邏攙。十大跋邏攙為阿僧企耶。此後更有八數及前為六十數積一大劫。至此第五十二阿僧企耶數。時名一劫阿僧企耶。第二第三劫阿僧企耶亦復如是。有說。尊者舍利子依第四靜慮起宿住隨念智通。緣過去世齊所及劫為一劫阿僧企耶量。第二第三劫阿僧企耶量亦爾。彼不應作是說。以劫阿僧企耶量非舍利子等宿住智境故。此中或說三劫阿僧企耶量。皆是舍利子宿住智境故。不應言齊彼智所及劫為一劫阿僧企耶量有說。依一施行分別三劫阿僧企耶量。謂若時菩薩雖行惠施。而未能捨一切物施一切田。齊此名為初劫阿僧企耶。若時菩薩能行惠施。亦能捨一切物而未能施一切田。
ten great nimbarajas make a mudrā; ten mudrā make a 'great mudrā'; ten great mudrā make a bala; ten bala make a 'great bala'; ten great bala make a saṃjñā; ten saṃjñā make a 'great saṃjñā'; ten great saṃjñā make a vibhūta; ten vibhūta make a 'great vibhūta'; ten great vibhūta make a balākṣa; ten balākṣa make a 'great balākṣa'; ten great balākṣa make an asaṃkhyeya. Beyond this there are yet eight more numerical terms, which together with the foregoing make sixty terms in all; and it is when the accumulation of great eons reaches this fifty-second term, 'asaṃkhyeya,' that it is called one eon-asaṃkhyeya. The second and third eon-asaṃkhyeyas are likewise. Some say: the Venerable Śāriputra, by means of the fourth dhyāna, gave rise to the supernormal faculty of recollecting former abodes, and, taking as his condition as much of the past as this faculty could reach, that span constitutes the measure of one eon-asaṃkhyeya; the measure of the second and third eon-asaṃkhyeyas is likewise. This view should not be accepted. Why is this? Because the measure of an eon-asaṃkhyeya is not within the range of the recollective faculty of Śāriputra or others like him. Here, it may rather be said that the measure of the three eon-asaṃkhyeyas is entirely within the range of Śāriputra's recollective faculty; it should not be said that the extent of the eons his faculty can reach constitutes the measure of one eon-asaṃkhyeya. Some say: the measure of the three eon-asaṃkhyeyas is distinguished according to the practice of giving. That is: at the time when the bodhisattva, although practicing generosity, is not yet able to give up every possession or to give every field, up to that point is called the first eon-asaṃkhyeya. At the time when the bodhisattva is able to practice generosity and is also able to give up every possession, but not yet able to give every field,
或能施一切田而未能捨一切物。齊此名為第二劫阿僧企耶。若時菩薩能行惠施。亦能捨一切物及能施一切田。齊此名為第三劫阿僧企耶。有說。依所逢事佛分別三劫阿僧企耶量。謂過去久遠人壽百歲時。有佛名釋迦牟尼。出現於世。生剎帝利釋迦種中。母名摩訶摩耶。父名淨飯。子名羅怙羅。城名劫比羅筏窣覩多諸釋種。侍者弟子名阿難陀。第一雙弟子名舍利子大目揵連。爾時世間五濁增盛。
— or is able to give every field but not yet able to give up every possession — up to that point is called the second eon-asaṃkhyeya. At the time when the bodhisattva is able to practice generosity, and is able both to give up every possession and to give every field, up to that point is called the third eon-asaṃkhyeya. Some say: the measure of the three eon-asaṃkhyeyas is distinguished according to the Buddhas the bodhisattva encountered and served. That is: in the distant past, at a time when the human lifespan was a hundred years, there was a Buddha named Śākyamuni who appeared in the world, born into the kṣatriya Śākya clan. His mother was named Mahāmāyā, his father Śuddhodana, and his son Rāhula; his city was called Kapilavastu, home of all the Śākya clans; his attendant disciple was named Ānanda, and his foremost pair of disciples were named Śāriputra and Mahāmaudgalyāyana. At that time the world was rife with the five corruptions,
為生老死之所逼迫。愚癡盲瞑無將導者。彼佛世尊以悲願力於中出現。精進增上化導有情未曾暫息。由如此故為風所薄。肩背有疾。
and beings were oppressed by birth, old age, and death, benighted in folly and darkness, with none to guide them. That Buddha, the Blessed One, by the power of his compassionate vow, appeared in their midst, and with ever-increasing diligence converted and guided sentient beings without ever pausing to rest. Because of this, he was afflicted by wind, and had an ailment in his shoulders and back.
時有陶師名曰廣熾。佛知時至即告侍者阿難陀言。吾今身疾不安。
At that time there was a potter named Prabhāsa. The Buddha, knowing the time had come, said to his attendant Ānanda: "My body is now afflicted and unwell."
汝可往廣熾陶師家求胡麻油及煖水。為吾塗洗。侍者敬諾往陶師家。住廣熾前愛語問訊已。方便讚佛種種功德勝戒定慧。三十二相八十隨好圓光赫奕。智見無礙辯才無滯。復告廣熾。如是世尊若不出家。當為輪王王四洲界。我及汝等一切世間皆為僕使。然今棄捨如是王位出家苦行。得阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。具一切智見。斷一切疑網。施一切決定。能盡一切問論源底。視諸有情猶如一子。今者在此不遠而住。然為拔濟汝等苦故恒涉道路。為風所薄肩背勞積。
"You may go to the potter Prabhāsa's house and ask for sesame oil and warm water, to anoint and bathe me with." The attendant respectfully assented, and went to the potter's house. Standing before Prabhāsa, he greeted him with kind words and, by way of skillful approach, praised the Buddha's manifold virtues — his supreme moral discipline, concentration, and wisdom; his thirty-two marks and eighty minor marks; his perfect halo blazing with splendor; his unobstructed wisdom and insight; his unhindered eloquence. He further told Prabhāsa: "Such is the Blessed One that, had he not gone forth, he would have become a wheel-turning king ruling over the four continents, and I and all of you and all the world would be his servants. Yet now he has renounced such kingship, gone forth, and practiced austerities, and attained unsurpassed, perfect, complete awakening, endowed with omniscient wisdom and insight, having severed every net of doubt, and able to resolve every uncertainty and fathom the depths of every question and discourse. He regards all sentient beings as though they were his only child. At present he is dwelling not far from here; yet, for the sake of rescuing you and others from suffering, he ever travels the roads, and has been afflicted by wind, his shoulders and back grown weary and strained."
須油煖水故相造詣。頗能施耶。爾時廣熾聞已踊躍歎未曾有。如何人間有是功德。即報尊者。仁今且還。我當如命自往佛所。其去未久。廣熾即辦生胡麻油及煖香水持往佛所。佛遙見之。為令彼人種善根故脫去餘衣。唯留襯身踞机而待。廣熾到已發淳淨心。以所持油恭敬善巧。塗佛肩背種種摩搦。復以煖水香湯灌洗。佛時風疾釋然除愈。以慈軟音慰喻廣熾。彼聞歡喜即發願言。願我未來當得作佛。名號眷屬時處弟子。如今世尊等無有異。當知彼陶師者即釋迦菩薩。由本願故今名號等如昔不異。然從彼佛發是願後。乃至逢事寶髻如來。是名初劫阿僧企耶滿。從此以後乃至逢事然燈如來。是名第二劫阿僧企耶滿。復從此後乃至逢事勝觀如來。是名第三劫阿僧企耶滿。此後復經九十一劫修妙相業。至逢事迦葉波佛時方得圓滿。有說。有三種阿僧企耶。一劫阿僧企耶。二生阿僧企耶。三妙行阿僧企耶。劫阿僧企耶者。謂以大劫為一積至洛叉俱胝。展轉乃至過婆揭羅數。生阿僧企耶者。謂一一劫經無數生。妙行阿僧企耶者。謂一一劫修無數妙行。由此三種阿僧企耶證無上覺。此不應理。如實義者。此中但說經三劫阿僧企耶。修行圓滿。
It is for this reason — needing oil and warm water — that I have come to call upon you. Might you be willing to give some?" Upon hearing this, Prabhāsa leapt up in joy and exclaimed in wonder, "How can there be such virtue in the human world!" He replied at once to the venerable one: "Sir, please return for now; I shall myself go at once to the Buddha's place, as swiftly as life allows." Before long, Prabhāsa had prepared fresh sesame oil and warm, fragrant water and carried them to the Buddha. The Buddha, seeing him from afar, and in order to let him plant wholesome roots, removed his outer robes, keeping only his inner garment, and sat upon a stool awaiting him. When Prabhāsa arrived, he gave rise to a pure and sincere mind, and with reverent skill anointed the Buddha's shoulders and back with the oil he had brought, massaging and kneading them, and then bathed and washed them with the warm, fragrant water. The Buddha's affliction from the wind was thereupon released and cured. With a compassionate, gentle voice he comforted and reassured Prabhāsa. Hearing this, Prabhāsa rejoiced and made a vow, saying: "May I in the future attain Buddhahood, with a name, a retinue, a time, a place, and disciples exactly like those of the Blessed One now, without any difference." It should be understood that this potter was none other than the bodhisattva Śākyamuni; because of his original vow, his name and the rest are now unchanged from what they were then. From the time he made this vow before that Buddha, up until he encountered and served the Tathāgata Ratnaśikhin, is called the completion of the first eon-asaṃkhyeya. From this point onward, up until he encountered and served the Tathāgata Dīpaṃkara, is called the completion of the second eon-asaṃkhyeya. From this point onward again, up until he encountered and served the Tathāgata Viśiṣṭadarśin, is called the completion of the third eon-asaṃkhyeya. After this, he further cultivated the karma of the excellent marks for ninety-one eons, and it was only when he encountered and served the Buddha Kāśyapa that this was finally brought to completion.
Some say: there are three kinds of asaṃkhyeya: first, the eon-asaṃkhyeya; second, the birth-asaṃkhyeya; third, the wondrous-practice-asaṃkhyeya. The eon-asaṃkhyeya is: taking a great eon as a single unit, accumulating it up through lakṣa and koṭi, proceeding in succession until one passes beyond the count of vagra. The birth-asaṃkhyeya is the fact that within each single eon one passes through countless births. The wondrous-practice-asaṃkhyeya is the fact that within each single eon one cultivates countless wondrous practices. It is by means of these three kinds of asaṃkhyeya, on this account, that supreme awakening is realized. This view should not be accepted as correct. As for the true meaning: here it is said only that, having passed through three eon-asaṃkhyeyas, the cultivation of practice is brought to completion.
That the numerical scheme for "incalculable" is followed immediately by a fully human story of sore shoulders, borrowed oil, and a single grateful vow is exactly the rhetorical move this treatise favors throughout: it will not let the sheer scale of cosmic time remain an abstraction, insisting instead on anchoring even the vastest measure of practice to one intimate, nameable act of kindness that any listener could recognize and, in principle, repeat.
Fascicle 177 Complete
This closes fascicle 177 of Ru‑Yi's translation, drawn from the treatise's true CBETA boundary. Fascicle 177 opens a new topic within the Non-Returner Nyāsa (不還納息第四之四): the karma that ripens into the Buddha's thirty-two excellent bodily marks — its nature, ground, and the debate over whether one volition or many brings each mark forth, the full catalogue of the thirty-two marks themselves, why exactly thirty-two and how the eighty minor marks set them off without ever obscuring them, the parable of the future awakening as an unyielding bride, the hundred blessings said to adorn every single mark, and the story of Śākyamuni's single seven-day verse before the ancient Buddha Tiṣya that let him overtake nine entire eons — closing with the treatise's own careful reckoning of just how immense a single incalculable eon (asaṃkhyeya kalpa) truly is, anchored in the homely tale of the potter Prabhāsa. Fascicle 178 continues within this same Non-Returner Nyāsa.