The Man and the Rākṣasa's Floating Bag
This fascicle closes 現病品, the sūtra's chapter on the illness the Buddha has just manifested, with Kāśyapa's full case for why it cannot be real: an elaborate catalogue of what genuine sickness looks like, none of it applicable to a buddha, met by the Buddha rising, sending light from every pore of his body, and emptying the hells and hungry-ghost and animal realms of every being but the icchantika. The Buddha's own answer catalogues a string of paradoxical statements — that he is a lion, and not a lion; a parent, and not a parent — as this sūtra's own secret teaching, before naming the three conditions truly beyond any cure. The fascicle then opens 聖行品, the sūtra's chapter on noble conduct, with its most famous parable: a man crossing the ocean who will not surrender even a grain's worth of his own floating bag to a starving rākṣasa, however much is asked of him.
The Illness That Was Never There
爾時迦葉菩薩白佛言:「世尊!如來已免一切疾病,患苦悉除,無復怖畏。世尊!一切眾生有四毒箭,則為病因。何等為四?貪欲、瞋恚、愚癡、憍慢。若有病因,則有病生,所謂愛熱肺病、上氣吐逆、膚體㿇㿇、其心悶亂、下痢噦噎、小便淋瀝、眼耳疼痛、背滿腹脹、顛狂乾消鬼魅所著。如是種種身心諸病,諸佛世尊悉無復有。今日如來何緣顧命文殊師利,而作是言:『我今背痛,汝等當為大眾說法?』有二因緣,則無病苦。何等為二?一者憐愍一切眾生,二者給施病者醫藥。如來往昔已於無量萬億劫中修菩薩道,常行愛語,利益眾生不令苦惱,施疾病者種種醫藥,何緣於今自言有病?
「世尊!世有病人,或坐或臥不安處所,或索飲食,勅誡家屬,修治產業,何故如來默然而臥,不教弟子聲聞人等,尸波羅蜜、諸禪解脫、三摩跋提、修諸正勤?何緣不說如是甚深大乘經典?如來何故不以無量方便,教大迦葉、人中象王、諸大人等,令不退於阿耨多羅三藐三菩提?何故不治諸惡比丘受畜一切不淨物者?世尊實無有病,云何默然,右脇而臥?
「諸菩薩等,凡所給施病者醫藥,所得善根悉施眾生,而共迴向一切種智,為除眾生諸煩惱障、業障、報障。煩惱障者,貪欲、瞋恚、愚癡,忿怒、纏蓋、焦惱、嫉妬、慳悋、奸詐、諛諂、無慚無愧,慢慢慢、不如慢、增上慢、我慢、邪慢、憍慢,放逸貢高、懟恨諍訟、邪命諂媚、詐現異相、以利求利、惡求多求,無有恭敬、不隨教誨、親近惡友、貪利無厭、纏縛難解,欲於惡欲、貪於惡貪、身見有見及以無見、頻申憙睡、欠呿不樂、貪嗜飲食、其心瞢瞢、心緣異想、不善思惟、身口多惡、好憙多語,諸根闇鈍、發言多虛,常為欲覺、恚覺、害覺之所覆蓋,是名煩惱障。業障者,五無間罪,重惡之病。報障者,生在地獄、畜生、餓鬼,誹謗正法及一闡提,是名報障。如是三障名為大病。而諸菩薩於無量劫修菩提時,給施一切疾病醫藥,常作是願,令諸眾生永斷如是三障重病。
「復次世尊!菩薩摩訶薩修菩提時,給施一切病者醫藥,常作是願,願令眾生永斷諸病,得成如來金剛之身。又願一切無量眾生作妙藥王,斷除一切諸惡重病,願諸眾生得阿伽陀藥,以是藥力能除一切無量惡毒。又願眾生於阿耨多羅三藐三菩提無有退轉,速得成就無上佛藥,消除一切煩惱毒箭。又願眾生勤修精進,成就如來金剛之心,作微妙藥療治眾病,不令有人生諍訟想。亦願眾生作大藥樹,療治一切諸惡重病。又願眾生拔出毒箭,得成如來無上光明。又願眾生得入如來智慧大藥微密法藏。世尊!菩薩如是,已於無量百千萬億那由他劫發是誓願,令諸眾生悉無復病,何緣如來乃於今日唱言有病?
「復次世尊!世有病人,不能坐起、俯仰、進止,飲食不御,漿水不下,亦復不能教戒諸子,修治家業。爾時父母、妻子、兄弟、親屬、知識,各於是人生必死想。世尊!如來今日亦復如是,右脇而臥,無所論說,此閻浮提有諸愚人,當作是念:『如來正覺必當涅槃。』生滅盡想。而如來性實不畢竟入於涅槃。何以故?如來常住無變易故,以是因緣,不應說言我今背痛。
「復次世尊!世有病者,身體羸損,若偃若側,臥著床褥,爾時家室心生惡賤,起必死想。如來今者亦復如是,當為外道九十五種之所輕慢,生無常想。彼諸外道當作是言:『不如我等,以我性常,自在時節、微塵等法而為常住,無有變易。沙門瞿曇無常所遷,是變易法。』以是義故,世尊!今日不應默然,右脇而臥。
「復次世尊!世有病者,四大增損,互不調適,羸瘦乏極,是故不能隨意坐起,臥著床褥。如來四大無不和適,身力具足亦無羸損。世尊!如十小牛力不如一大牛力,十大牛力不如一青牛力,十青牛力不如一凡象力,十凡象力不如一野象力,十野象力不如一二牙象力,十二牙象力不如一四牙象力,十四牙象力不如雪山一白象力,十雪山白象力不如一香象力,十香象力不如一青象力,十青象力不如一黃象力,十黃象力不如一赤象力,十赤象力不如一白象力,十白象力不如一山象力,十山象力不如一優鉢羅象力,十優鉢羅象力不如一拘物頭象力,十拘物頭象力不如一分陀利象力,十分陀利象力不如人中一力士力,十人中力士力不如一鉢健提力,十鉢健提力不如一八臂那羅延力,十那羅延力不如一十住菩薩一節之力。一切凡夫,身中諸節,節不相到。人中力士,節頭相到。鉢健提身,諸節相接。那羅延身,節頭相拘。十住菩薩諸節骨解,盤龍相結,是故菩薩其力最大。世界成時,從金剛際起金剛座,上至道場菩提樹下,菩薩坐已,其心即時逮得十力。如來今者不應如彼嬰孩小兒,嬰孩小兒愚癡無智,無所能說,以是義故,隨意偃側,無人譏訶。
如來世尊有大智慧,照明一切;人中之龍,具大威德;成就神通無上仙人,永斷疑網,已拔毒箭,進止安詳,威儀具足,得無所畏。今者何故右脇而臥,令諸人天悲愁苦惱?」
At that time, the bodhisattva Kāśyapa said to the Buddha: "World-Honored One, the Tathāgata has already been freed from every illness, every affliction and suffering entirely removed, with nothing left to fear. World-Honored One, every being carries four poisoned arrows, which are the very cause of illness. What are these four? Craving, anger, delusion, and pride. Where there is a cause of illness, illness arises from it — feverish lung disease from craving, choking and vomiting from rising breath, skin eruptions, a mind thrown into confusion, dysentery and hiccupping, difficulty urinating, pain in the eyes and ears, a swollen back and distended belly, madness, wasting away, possession by evil spirits. Every buddha, every world-honored one, is entirely free of every such illness of body and mind. For what reason, then, does the Tathāgata today turn to instruct Mañjuśrī, saying: 'My back aches now — you should teach the Dharma for the great assembly in my place'? There are two causes and conditions through which one comes to be free of illness. What are these two? First, compassion for every being; second, giving medicine to the sick. The Tathāgata, in ages past, has already, throughout countless millions of kalpas, cultivated the bodhisattva path, forever speaking words of loving-kindness, benefiting beings so that they need not suffer, giving every kind of medicine to the sick — for what reason, then, does he now say of himself that he is ill?
"World-Honored One, when there is a sick person in the world, he sits or lies restlessly, unable to settle anywhere; he may call for food and drink, or instruct his household on the management of their affairs. Why, then, does the Tathāgata lie silent, teaching his disciples, the śrāvakas, none of the pāramitā of moral discipline, none of the dhyānas and liberations, none of the samāpattis, none of the right endeavors? For what reason does he not teach this very profound scripture of the Great Vehicle? Why does the Tathāgata not use his own countless skillful means to teach the great Kāśyapa, this elephant-king among humankind, and every great being, so that they never turn back from unsurpassed, complete awakening? Why does he not correct those wicked monks who keep and hoard every kind of improper possession? The World-Honored One, in truth, has no illness at all — why, then, does he lie silent, upon his right side?
"Every bodhisattva, whenever he gives medicine to the sick, gives entirely of the wholesome root thereby obtained to beings, dedicating it together toward the wisdom of all modes, for the sake of removing beings' own afflictive hindrance, karmic hindrance, and retributive hindrance. The afflictive hindrance is craving, anger, delusion, wrath, entanglement and covering, agitation, envy, stinginess, deceit, flattery, shamelessness and lack of conscience, the pride of pride, the pride of the inferior, overweening pride, the pride of self, wrong pride, arrogance, heedlessness and haughtiness, resentment and contentiousness, a crooked livelihood and obsequiousness, feigning what one is not, seeking gain through gain, seeking wrongfully and seeking too much, showing no reverence, refusing instruction, keeping company with wicked friends, an insatiable craving for gain, entanglements hard to loosen, desire for what is wrongfully desired, craving for what is wrongfully craved, the view of a fixed self, the view of existence and the view of non-existence, constant yawning and drowsiness, restless discontent, a craving appetite for food and drink, a mind clouded and confused, a mind given over to distracting notions, unwholesome reflection, much wrongdoing in body and speech, a fondness for excessive talk, faculties dull and clouded, speech given largely to falsehood, and being forever covered over by thoughts of desire, of malice, and of harm — this is called the afflictive hindrance. The karmic hindrance is the five heinous crimes, the gravest illness of wrongdoing. The retributive hindrance is being born in hell, among the animals, or among the hungry ghosts, slandering the true Dharma, or becoming an icchantika — this is called the retributive hindrance. These three hindrances together are called the great illness. And every bodhisattva, cultivating bodhi throughout countless kalpas, gives medicine to the sick of every kind, forever making this vow: that beings may forever cut off this grave illness of the three hindrances.
"Furthermore, World-Honored One, when the bodhisattva-mahāsattva cultivates bodhi, giving medicine of every kind to the sick, he forever makes this vow: that beings may forever cut off every illness, and come to accomplish the Tathāgata's own body of vajra. He further vows that every one of the countless beings may become a king among wondrous medicines, cutting off every grave illness of wrongdoing; he vows that beings may obtain the agada medicine, whose power is able to remove every one of the countless poisons there is. He further vows that beings, never turning back from unsurpassed, complete awakening, may swiftly come to accomplish the unsurpassed medicine of buddhahood, dissolving the very poisoned arrow of every affliction. He further vows that beings, diligently cultivating with all energy, may accomplish the Tathāgata's own vajra mind, becoming a subtle and wondrous medicine that heals every illness, never giving rise, in anyone, to a thought of contention. He also vows that beings may become a great medicinal tree, healing every grave illness of wrongdoing. He further vows that beings, drawing out the poisoned arrow, may come to accomplish the Tathāgata's own unsurpassed light. He further vows that beings may enter the Tathāgata's own great medicine of wisdom, the subtle and secret treasury of the Dharma. World-Honored One, the bodhisattva, in this way, has already, throughout countless hundreds of thousands of millions of nayutas of kalpas, made these very vows, that beings may be entirely free of illness — for what reason, then, does the Tathāgata today proclaim that he himself is ill?
"Furthermore, World-Honored One, when there is a sick person in the world, unable to sit up or rise, to bend or straighten, to move about, unable to take food or drink, unable even to swallow water, and unable, further, to instruct and admonish his own children, or manage his household affairs — at such a time, his parents, wife and children, brothers, relatives, and friends all form, of this person, the thought that he must surely die. World-Honored One, the Tathāgata today is just the same, lying upon his right side, saying nothing at all — and the foolish people of this Jambudvīpa will surely think to themselves: 'The Tathāgata, the Perfectly Awakened One, must now be about to enter nirvāṇa,' giving rise to a thought of his utter extinction. Yet the Tathāgata's own nature, in truth, never finally enters nirvāṇa at all. Why is this? Because the Tathāgata abides permanently, without change — and it is for this very reason that he should not say, 'My back now aches.'
"Furthermore, World-Honored One, when there is a sick person in the world whose body has grown emaciated and weak, lying flat or on his side, confined to his own bed — at such a time, his own household comes to regard him with contempt and disdain, giving rise to the thought that he must surely die. The Tathāgata today is just the same: he will surely be treated with contempt by every one of the ninety-five heterodox schools, who will give rise to the thought that he is impermanent. Those heterodox teachers will surely say: 'He is no match for us — for our own nature is permanent, whether we speak of mastery, of time, or of the atom, each of these abides permanently, without any change; but the ascetic Gautama is swept along by impermanence, a thing subject to change.' It is for this very reason, World-Honored One, that you should not today lie silent, upon your right side.
"Furthermore, World-Honored One, when there is a sick person in the world whose four great elements grow excessive or deficient, thrown out of balance with one another, exhausted and utterly spent, he is thereby unable to sit up or rise as he wishes, confined to his own bed. The Tathāgata's own four great elements are never anything but perfectly balanced, his bodily strength complete, never weak or exhausted at all. World-Honored One, the strength of ten small oxen does not match that of one large ox; the strength of ten large oxen does not match that of one blue-black ox; the strength of ten blue-black oxen does not match that of one ordinary elephant; the strength of ten ordinary elephants does not match that of one wild elephant; the strength of ten wild elephants does not match that of one two-tusked elephant; the strength of ten two-tusked elephants does not match that of one four-tusked elephant; the strength of ten four-tusked elephants does not match that of one white elephant of the Himalayas; the strength of ten Himalayan white elephants does not match that of one fragrant elephant; the strength of ten fragrant elephants does not match that of one blue-black elephant; the strength of ten blue-black elephants does not match that of one yellow elephant; the strength of ten yellow elephants does not match that of one red elephant; the strength of ten red elephants does not match that of one white elephant; the strength of ten white elephants does not match that of one mountain elephant; the strength of ten mountain elephants does not match that of one utpala elephant; the strength of ten utpala elephants does not match that of one kumuda elephant; the strength of ten kumuda elephants does not match that of one puṇḍarīka elephant; the strength of ten puṇḍarīka elephants does not match that of one human wrestler; the strength of ten human wrestlers does not match that of one prākhaṇḍin; the strength of ten prākhaṇḍins does not match that of one eight-armed Nārāyaṇa; and the strength of ten Nārāyaṇas does not match the strength of a single joint of one bodhisattva at the tenth abiding-stage. In every ordinary person, the body's own joints do not quite meet one another. In a human wrestler, the ends of the joints meet fully. In the body of a prākhaṇḍin, every joint connects. In the body of Nārāyaṇa, the ends of every joint interlock. In a bodhisattva at the tenth abiding-stage, every joint and bone is bound together like coiled dragons — and this is why a bodhisattva's own strength is the very greatest there is. When the world first comes into being, from the very edge of the vajra foundation there arises a vajra seat, reaching up to the bodhi tree at the seat of enlightenment; and once the bodhisattva is seated there, his mind at once attains the ten powers. The Tathāgata should not now be like a small infant — a small infant, foolish and without wisdom, unable to say anything at all, is for this very reason free to lie however he wishes, without anyone reproaching him for it.
"The Tathāgata, the World-Honored One, possesses great wisdom, illuminating everything; he is the very dragon among humankind, possessed of great, majestic virtue; he has accomplished the unsurpassed sage's own supernormal powers, forever cutting through the net of every doubt, having already drawn out the poisoned arrow, moving and resting with perfect composure, complete in every dignified bearing, having attained fearlessness in every respect. Why, then, does he now lie upon his right side, causing every god and human to grieve and suffer?"
No surviving portion of Huiyuan's commentary treats this opening speech line by line, though his later summary confirms that he read it as building seven distinct arguments, each answered in turn once the Buddha finally speaks — a structure this collection's next several reading notes will trace as each argument is taken up. Two features of the speech itself are worth flagging on their own terms. First, the three-hindrance taxonomy — an extended catalogue of affliction, then the single karmic hindrance of the five heinous crimes, then the retributive hindrance of hell, the animal realm, hungry ghosts, slandering the Dharma, and the icchantika — quietly folds the icchantika question this collection has tracked since Part 5 into the definition of illness itself: to be an icchantika just is, on this taxonomy, to suffer from an illness in its most acute, retributive form. Second, the escalating ladder of strength — nineteen doublings from a small ox up through nine grades of elephant to a human wrestler, a prākhaṇḍin, an eight-armed Nārāyaṇa, and finally a single joint of a bodhisattva at the tenth abiding-stage — is not really an argument about physical strength at all: its rhetorical function is to make Kāśyapa's underlying claim vivid by sheer accumulation, each rung making the next barely conceivable, so that a genuine buddha's own condition lands as something categorically off this entire scale rather than merely at its top.
The Buddha Rises
爾時迦葉菩薩即於佛前而說偈言:
「瞿曇大聖德, 願起演妙法,
不應如小兒, 病者臥床席。
調御天人師, 倚臥雙樹間,
下愚凡夫見, 當言必涅槃。
不知方等典, 甚深佛所行,
不見微密藏, 猶盲不見道。
惟有諸菩薩, 文殊師利等,
能解是甚深, 譬如善射者。
三世諸世尊, 大悲為根本,
如是大慈悲, 今為何所在?
若無大悲者, 是則不名佛,
佛若必涅槃, 是則不名常。
惟願無上尊, 哀受我等請,
利益於眾生, 摧伏諸外道。」
爾時世尊,大悲熏心,知諸眾生各各所念,將欲隨順畢竟利益,即從臥起,結跏趺坐,顏貌熈怡,如融金聚,面目端嚴,猶月盛滿,形容清淨,無諸垢穢,放大光明充遍虛空。其光大盛,過百千日,照于東方、南西北方、四維上下諸佛世界,惠施眾生大智之炬,悉令得滅無明黑闇,令百千億那由他眾生,安止不退菩提之心。爾時世尊,心無疑慮,如師子王,以三十二大人之相、八十種好莊嚴其身。於其身上一切毛孔,一一毛孔出一蓮花,其花微妙各具千葉,純真金色,琉璃為莖,金剛為鬚,玫瑰為臺,形大團圓猶如車輪,是諸蓮花,各出種種雜色光明,青黃赤白紫頗梨色。
是諸光明皆悉遍至阿鼻地獄、想地獄、黑繩地獄、眾合地獄、叫喚地獄、大叫喚地獄、焦熱地獄、大焦熱地獄,是八地獄其中眾生,常為諸苦之所逼切,所謂燒煮、火炙、斫刺、㓟剝,遇斯光已,如是眾苦悉滅無餘,安隱清涼,快樂無極。是光明中宣說如來祕密之藏,言諸眾生皆有佛性;眾生聞已,即便命終生人天中。乃至八種寒氷地獄,所謂阿波波地獄、阿吒吒地獄、阿羅羅地獄、阿婆婆地獄、優鉢羅地獄、波頭摩地獄、拘物頭地獄、分陀利地獄,是中眾生常為寒苦之所逼惱,所謂擘裂、身體碎壞、互相殘害。遇斯光已,如是等苦亦滅無餘,即得調和熅煖適身。是光明中亦說如來祕密之藏,言諸眾生皆有佛性;眾生聞已,即便命終生人天中。爾時於此閻浮提界及餘世界,所有地獄皆悉空虛,無受罪者,除一闡提。餓鬼眾生飢渴所逼,以髮纏身,於百千歲未曾得聞漿水之名。遇斯光已,飢渴即除。是光明中亦說如來微密祕藏,言諸眾生皆有佛性;眾生聞已,即便命終生人天中,令諸餓鬼亦悉空虛,除謗大乘方等正典。畜生眾生,互相殺害、共相殘食,遇斯光已,恚心悉滅。是光明中亦說如來祕密之藏,言諸眾生皆有佛性;眾生聞已,即便命終生人天中。當爾之時畜生亦盡,除謗正法。
是一一花各有一佛,圓光一尋,金色晃曜,微妙端嚴最上無比,三十二相、八十種好莊嚴其身。是諸世尊,或有坐者、或有行者、或有臥者、或有住者,或有震雷音者、或澍雨者、或放電光、或復興風,或出煙焰身如火聚,或復示現七寶諸山、池泉河水、山林樹木,或復示現七寶國土、城邑聚落、宮殿屋宅,或復示現象馬師子、虎狼孔雀、鳳凰諸鳥,或復示現令閻浮提所有眾生,悉見地獄、畜生、餓鬼,或復示現欲界六天。復有世尊,或說陰界諸入多諸過患,或復有說四聖諦法,或復有說諸法因緣,或復有說諸業煩惱皆因緣生,或復有說我與無我,或復有說苦樂二法,或復有說常無常等,或復有說淨與不淨。復有世尊為諸菩薩演說所行六波羅蜜,或復有說諸大菩薩所得功德,或復有說諸佛世尊所得功德,或復有說聲聞之人所得功德,或復有說隨順一乘,或復有說三乘成道。或有世尊左脇出水、右脇出火;或有示現初生出家,坐於道場菩提樹下,轉妙法輪,入于涅槃;或有世尊作師子吼,令此會中有得一果、二果、三果、至第四果;或復有說出離生死,無量因緣。
爾時於此閻浮提中,所有眾生遇斯光已,盲者見色,聾者聽聲,啞者能言,拘躄能行,貧者得財,慳者能施,恚者慈心,不信者信。如是世界,無一眾生修行惡法,除一闡提。
At that time, the bodhisattva Kāśyapa spoke this verse before the Buddha:
"Gautama, great and holy in virtue, please rise, and expound the wondrous Dharma —
you should not, like a small child, or one who is ill, remain lying upon your bed.
Tamer of gods and humans, reclining here between these paired trees —
foolish, lowly, ordinary people, seeing this, will surely say you must be entering nirvāṇa.
Not knowing the Vaipulya scriptures, the Buddha's own exceedingly profound conduct,
not seeing the subtle and secret treasury, they are like the blind, unable to see the path.
Only the bodhisattvas — Mañjuśrī, and others like him —
are able to understand this profound teaching, like a skilled archer striking his mark.
Every world-honored one of the three times has great compassion as his very root —
where, then, is this great compassion now?
Were there no great compassion, this could not be called Buddha at all;
were the Buddha truly to enter nirvāṇa, this could not be called permanent at all.
I ask only that the unsurpassed, honored one take pity, and accept our request,
for the benefit of all beings, and to subdue every heterodox teacher."
At that time, the World-Honored One, his heart steeped in great compassion, knowing every being's own particular thought, wishing to accord with what would ultimately benefit them, at once rose from his reclining position and sat in full lotus posture. His countenance grew radiant and joyful, like a mass of molten gold; his face and features were dignified and beautiful, like the moon at its very fullest; his whole form was pure, free of every stain and defilement, and he sent forth a great light, filling the whole of empty space. This light blazed forth, surpassing hundreds of thousands of suns, illuminating the buddha-worlds of the east, south, west, and north, and the four intermediate directions, above and below, bestowing upon beings the very torch of great wisdom, causing every dark cloud of ignorance to be entirely dispelled, and establishing hundreds of thousands of millions of nayutas of beings securely in a mind of bodhi that never turns back. At that time, the World-Honored One's mind held not a trace of doubt, and, like the lion king himself, he adorned his own body with the thirty-two marks of a great being and the eighty minor characteristics. From every single pore upon his body, a lotus flower emerged, each flower subtle and wondrous, each bearing a thousand petals, of purest golden color, its stem of lapis lazuli, its stamens of vajra, its receptacle of rose quartz, its form vast and perfectly round, like a cart-wheel — and every one of these lotus flowers sent forth light of every different color: blue, yellow, red, white, violet, and crystalline.
This light, in every ray, reached without exception into the Avīci hell, the hell of thought, the hell of the black rope, the hell of crushing assembly, the hell of screaming, the hell of great screaming, the hell of scorching heat, and the hell of great scorching heat — and the beings within these eight hells, forever pressed by every suffering there, being boiled, roasted by fire, hacked and pierced, flayed and stripped — upon encountering this very light, every such suffering was entirely extinguished, without exception, and they found peace, coolness, and boundless happiness. Within this light, the Tathāgata's own secret treasury was proclaimed, teaching that every being possesses buddha-nature; and these beings, hearing this, at once ended their lives there and were reborn among gods and humans. The light reached, further, into the eight cold-ice hells — the hell of Apapa, the hell of Aṭaṭa, the hell of Araraḥ, the hell of Ababa, the hell of Utpala, the hell of Padma, the hell of Kumuda, and the hell of Puṇḍarīka — and the beings within these, forever pressed and tormented by the suffering of cold, their bodies splitting apart, shattering, tearing at one another — upon encountering this light, every such suffering was likewise entirely extinguished, and their bodies at once found a comfortable, gentle warmth. Within this light, the Tathāgata's own secret treasury was likewise proclaimed, teaching that every being possesses buddha-nature; and these beings, hearing this, at once ended their lives there and were reborn among gods and humans. At that time, throughout this realm of Jambudvīpa and every other world, every hell was thereby left entirely empty, with no being left to receive its punishment — excepting only the icchantika. The hungry ghosts, tormented by hunger and thirst, their own hair wound about their bodies, had not, throughout hundreds of thousands of years, once heard even the word for water — yet, upon encountering this light, their hunger and thirst were at once removed. Within this light, the Tathāgata's own profound and secret treasury was likewise proclaimed, teaching that every being possesses buddha-nature; and these beings, hearing this, at once ended their lives there and were reborn among gods and humans, leaving every hungry ghost's own realm likewise entirely empty — excepting only those who slander the Vaipulya scriptures of the Great Vehicle. The animals, forever killing and devouring one another, upon encountering this light, had their every hostile thought entirely extinguished. Within this light, the Tathāgata's own secret treasury was likewise proclaimed, teaching that every being possesses buddha-nature; and these beings, hearing this, at once ended their lives there and were reborn among gods and humans — and, at that very time, the animal realm too was thereby emptied out — excepting only those who slander the true Dharma.
Within each and every one of these lotus flowers there was a single buddha, his own halo a full fathom across, his golden form gleaming brilliantly, subtle, wondrous, dignified, unsurpassed and beyond compare, his body adorned with the thirty-two marks and eighty minor characteristics. Some of these world-honored ones sat, some walked, some lay down, some stood still; some sent forth the sound of rolling thunder, some poured down rain, some sent forth flashes of lightning, some stirred up the wind; some sent forth smoke and flame, their bodies like a mass of fire; some manifested mountains of the seven treasures, ponds, springs, rivers, mountain forests and trees; some manifested lands of the seven treasures, cities, towns, villages, palaces and houses; some manifested elephants, horses, lions, tigers, wolves, peacocks, phoenixes, and every kind of bird; some manifested, for every being throughout Jambudvīpa, a vision of hell, of the animal realm, and of the hungry ghosts; some manifested the six heavens of the desire realm. Some world-honored ones taught the many faults of the aggregates, elements, and sense-fields; others taught the Four Noble Truths; others taught the causes and conditions of every dharma; others taught that every karma and affliction arises through cause and condition; others taught self and no-self; others taught the two dharmas of suffering and bliss; others taught permanence and impermanence; others taught purity and impurity. Some world-honored ones expounded, for the bodhisattvas, the practice of the six pāramitās; others taught the merit attained by the great bodhisattvas; others taught the merit attained by every buddha, every world-honored one; others taught the merit attained by the śrāvakas; others taught according with the single vehicle; others taught the accomplishment of the path through the three vehicles. Some world-honored ones sent forth water from their left side and fire from their right; some manifested their own first birth, their going forth, their sitting beneath the bodhi tree at the seat of enlightenment, their turning of the wondrous wheel of the Dharma, and their entering of nirvāṇa; some world-honored ones gave the lion's own roar, causing those in this very assembly to attain the first fruit, the second, the third, up to the fourth fruit; others taught the countless causes and conditions for departing from birth and death.
At that time, every being throughout this Jambudvīpa, upon encountering this light, found that the blind could see form, the deaf could hear sound, the mute could speak, the lame could walk, the poor obtained wealth, the stingy became able to give, the wrathful found a compassionate heart, and the faithless came to faith. In this world, at that time, not a single being cultivated any evil dharma at all — excepting only the icchantika.
Huiyuan reads this entire display as the sūtra's own answer to the assembly's unspoken inference — if the Buddha shows illness, does that mean his own power is beginning to fail? — answered not by argument but by demonstration: at the very moment he is supposedly too weak to rise, he sends forth a light that empties every hell, every realm of hungry ghosts, and the whole animal world at once. He structures the rescue in a consistent three-step pattern repeated for each realm — the light arrives, the immediate physical suffering particular to that realm is relieved, and only then is the tathāgatagarbha teaching itself spoken, the beings dying into a fortunate rebirth on hearing it — a sequence that keeps easing suffering and teaching liberation as two distinct, sequential acts of compassion rather than collapsing them into one. He is also careful to note that each realm empties with its own exception: the icchantika alone remains in hell, slanderers of the Vaipulya scriptures alone remain among the hungry ghosts, slanderers of the true Dharma alone remain among the animals — a variation in language, Huiyuan suggests, that maps roughly onto how directly each group has rejected the specific teaching that would otherwise have reached them, rather than naming three unrelated exceptions by accident.
The Gods' Praise, and the Secret Teaching
爾時一切天、龍、鬼神、乾闥婆、阿修羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽、羅剎、健陀、憂摩陀、阿婆魔羅、人非人等,悉共同聲唱如是言:「善哉,善哉!無上天尊,多所利益。」說是語已,踊躍歡喜,或歌或舞,或身動轉。以種種花散佛及僧,所謂天優鉢羅花、拘物頭花、波頭摩花、分陀利花、曼陀羅花、摩訶曼陀羅花、曼殊沙花、摩訶曼殊沙花、散陀那花、摩訶散陀那花、盧脂那花、摩訶盧脂那花、香花、大香花、適意花、大適意花、愛見花、大愛見花、端嚴花、第一端嚴花,復散諸香,所謂沈水、多伽樓香、栴檀、欝金、和合雜香、海岸聚香,復以天上寶幢、幡、蓋,諸天伎樂、箏笛、笙瑟、箜篌鼓吹,供養於佛,而說偈言:
「我今稽首大精進, 無上正覺兩足尊,
天人大眾所不知, 惟有瞿曇乃能了。
世尊往昔為我故, 於無量劫修苦行,
如何一旦放本誓, 而便捨命欲涅槃?
一切眾生不能見, 諸佛世尊祕密藏,
以是因緣難得出, 輪轉生死墜惡道。
如佛所說阿羅漢, 一切皆當至涅槃,
如是甚深佛行處, 凡夫下愚誰能知?
施諸眾生甘露法, 為欲斷除諸煩惱,
若有服此甘露已, 不復受生老病死。
如來世尊以療治, 百千無量諸眾生,
令其所有諸重病, 一切消滅無遺餘。
世尊久已捨病苦, 故得名為第七佛,
惟願今日雨法雨, 潤漬我等功德種。
是故大眾及人天, 如是請已默然住。」
說是偈時,蓮花臺中一切諸佛,從閻浮提遍至淨居,悉皆聞之。
爾時佛告迦葉菩薩:「善哉,善哉!善男子!汝已具足如是甚深微妙智慧,不為一切諸魔外道之所破壞。善男子!汝已安住,不為一切諸邪惡風之所傾動。善男子!汝已成就樂說辯才,已曾供養過去無量恒河沙等諸佛世尊,是故能問如來正覺如是之義。善男子!我於往昔,無量無邊億那由他百千萬劫,已除病根,永離倚臥。迦葉!過去無量阿僧祇劫,有佛出世,號無上勝如來、應供、正遍知、明行足、善逝、世間解、無上士、調御丈夫、天人師、佛、世尊,為諸聲聞說是大乘大涅槃經,開示分別,顯發其義。我於爾時,亦為彼佛而作聲聞,受持如是大涅槃典,讀誦通利、書寫經卷,廣為他人開示分別,解說其義;以是善根,迴向阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。善男子!我從是來,未曾有惡煩惱業緣,墮於惡道,誹謗正法,作一闡提,受黃門身無根二根,反逆父母,殺阿羅漢,破塔壞僧,出佛身血,犯四重禁。從是已來,身心安隱,無諸苦惱。迦葉!我今實無一切疾病。所以者何?諸佛世尊久已遠離一切病故。
「迦葉!是諸眾生不知大乘方等密教,便謂如來真實有疾。迦葉!如言如來人中師子,而如來者實非師子,如是之言即是如來祕密之教。迦葉!如言如來人中大龍,而我已於無量劫中捨離是業。迦葉!如言如來是人是天,而我真實非人非天,亦非鬼神、乾闥婆、阿修羅、迦樓羅、緊那羅、摩睺羅伽,非我、非命、非可養育、非人士夫、非作非不作、非受非不受、非世尊非聲聞、非說非不說。如是等語,皆是如來祕密之教。
「迦葉!如言如來猶如大海、須彌山王,而如來者實非鹹味、同於石山,當知是語亦是如來祕密之教。迦葉!如言如來如分陀利,而我實非分陀利也,如是之言即是如來祕密之教。迦葉!如言如來猶如父母,而如來者實非父母,如是之言亦是如來祕密之教。迦葉!如言如來是大船師,而如來者實非船師,如是之言亦是如來祕密之教。迦葉!如言如來猶如商主,而如來者實非商主,如是之言亦是如來祕密之教。迦葉!如言如來能摧伏魔,而如來者實無惡心欲令他伏,如是之言皆是如來祕密之教。迦葉!如言如來能治癰瘡,而我實非治癰師也,如是之言亦是如來祕密之教。
「迦葉!如我先說:『若有善男子、善女人,善能修治身、口、意業,捨命之時,雖有親族取其屍骸,或以火燒,或投大水,或棄塚間,狐狼禽獸競共食噉,然心意識即生善道。而是心法,實無去來,亦無所至。真是前後相似相續,相貌不異。』如是之言,即是如來祕密之教。迦葉!我今言病,亦復如是,亦是如來祕密之教。是故顧命文殊師利:『吾今背痛,汝等當為四眾說法。』迦葉!如來正覺實無有病,右脇而臥,亦不畢竟入於涅槃。迦葉!是大涅槃,即是諸佛甚深禪定,如是禪定,非是聲聞緣覺行處。
「迦葉!汝先所問,如來何故倚臥不起,不索飲食、戒勅家屬修治產業?迦葉!虛空之性,亦無坐起、求索飲食、勅戒家屬修治產業,亦無去來、生滅老壯、出沒傷破、解脫繫縛,亦不自說、亦不說他、亦不自解、亦不解他,非安非病。善男子!諸佛世尊亦復如是,猶如虛空,云何當有諸病苦耶?」
At that time, every god, nāga, spirit, gandharva, asura, garuḍa, kiṃnara, mahoraga, rākṣasa, kumbhāṇḍa, umāda, apasmāra, human, and non-human, all together, with a single voice, exclaimed: "Excellent, excellent! Unsurpassed, honored one of the heavens, so greatly beneficial to all!" Having spoken these words, they leapt with joy, some singing, some dancing, their bodies swaying with delight. They scattered every kind of flower upon the Buddha and the Saṅgha — heavenly utpala flowers, kumuda flowers, padma flowers, puṇḍarīka flowers, māndārava flowers, great māndārava flowers, mañjūṣaka flowers, great mañjūṣaka flowers, and flowers of delight, great delight, fragrance, great fragrance, pleasing scent, great pleasing scent, beloved sight, great beloved sight, dignified beauty, and foremost dignified beauty. They further scattered every kind of incense — aloeswood, tagara, sandalwood, saffron, every blended fragrance, and incense gathered from the seashore — and further offered heavenly jeweled banners, pennants, and canopies, heavenly music of zither and flute, mouth-organ and lute, harp, drum, and horn, in offering to the Buddha, and spoke this verse:
"I now bow my head to the one of great diligence, the unsurpassed, perfectly awakened one, honored among the two-footed,
known by neither the great assembly of gods nor of humans — only Gautama himself is able to fully understand it.
World-Honored One, in ages past, for our own sake, you cultivated ascetic practice throughout countless kalpas —
how, then, could you suddenly set aside your own original vow, and, in a single moment, relinquish your life, wishing to enter nirvāṇa?
No being is able to see this secret treasury of every buddha, every world-honored one —
and it is for this very cause and condition that they find it so hard to escape, turning through birth and death, falling into evil destinies.
As the Buddha himself has taught, every arhat is bound, without exception, to arrive at nirvāṇa —
but this exceedingly profound domain of the Buddha's own conduct, who among ordinary, lowly, and foolish people could ever know it?
You give the dharma of nectar to every being, wishing to cut off every affliction —
and whoever has drunk of this very nectar will never again undergo birth, old age, illness, and death.
The Tathāgata, the World-Honored One, has thereby healed hundreds of thousands, countless beings,
causing every one of their grave illnesses to be entirely dissolved, with nothing left behind.
The World-Honored One long ago already set aside every illness and suffering, and is for this reason called the seventh buddha —
we ask only that you, today, rain down the rain of the Dharma, moistening the very seed of our own merit."
For this very reason, the great assembly, together with gods and humans, having made this request, fell silent and waited.
As this verse was spoken, every buddha within the lotus-flower receptacles, from Jambudvīpa all the way up to the Pure Abodes, heard it entirely.
At that time, the Buddha said to the bodhisattva Kāśyapa: "Excellent, excellent, good son! You have already fully accomplished wisdom of this exceedingly profound and subtle kind, never to be destroyed by any māra or heterodox teacher. Good son, you have already come to abide securely, never to be shaken by any wicked, evil wind. Good son, you have already accomplished the eloquence of one who delights to speak, having already made offerings to countless buddhas, world-honored ones, as numerous as the sands of the Ganges, in ages past — and it is for this very reason that you are able to question the Tathāgata, the Perfectly Awakened One, about a meaning such as this. Good son, I myself, in ages past, throughout countless, boundless hundreds of millions of nayutas, of hundreds of thousands, of millions of kalpas, have already removed the very root of illness, and departed forever from ever lying down in sickness. Kāśyapa, in countless asaṃkhyeya kalpas past, there appeared in the world a buddha named Unsurpassed Victor, Tathāgata, Worthy of Offerings, Perfectly and Fully Awakened, Perfect in Knowledge and Conduct, Well-Gone, Knower of the World, Unsurpassed, Tamer of Beings, Teacher of Gods and Humans, Buddha, World-Honored One — and this buddha taught his own śrāvakas this very Mahāparinirvāṇa of the Great Vehicle, opening it up, distinguishing it, and revealing its meaning. I myself, at that time, was likewise a śrāvaka under that buddha, receiving and upholding this very Mahāparinirvāṇa, reciting it fluently, copying out the scripture, and, at length, opening it up and distinguishing it for the sake of others, explaining its meaning — and, through this very wholesome root, I dedicated it toward unsurpassed, complete awakening. Good son, from that time to this, I have never once had any wicked, afflictive karmic condition, never fallen into an evil destiny, never slandered the true Dharma, never become an icchantika, never received a eunuch's body, or a body without sexual organs, or with both, never turned against my own parents, never killed an arhat, never destroyed a stūpa or corrupted the Saṅgha, never drawn the Buddha's own blood, never committed one of the four gravest offenses. From that time onward, my body and mind have been at peace and ease, free of every affliction. Kāśyapa, I now, in truth, have no illness whatsoever. Why is this? Because every buddha, every world-honored one, has long ago already departed forever from every illness.
"Kāśyapa, it is because these beings do not know the secret teaching of the Vaipulya Great Vehicle that they suppose the Tathāgata to be truly ill. Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is the lion among humankind, the Tathāgata, in truth, is not a lion at all — a statement of this kind is itself the Tathāgata's own secret teaching. Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is the great dragon among humankind — I myself have already, throughout countless kalpas, forever set aside that very deed. Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is a human, or a god, I myself, in truth, am neither human nor god, nor am I a spirit, a gandharva, an asura, a garuḍa, a kiṃnara, or a mahoraga; I am not a self, not a life, not something to be nourished and raised, not a human person; I am neither an agent nor a non-agent, neither a receiver nor a non-receiver, neither a world-honored one nor a śrāvaka, neither one who teaches nor one who does not teach. Every statement of this kind is entirely the Tathāgata's own secret teaching.
"Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is like the great ocean, like Sumeru, king of mountains, the Tathāgata, in truth, is not of a salty flavor, nor the same as a mountain of stone — know that this statement, too, is the Tathāgata's own secret teaching. Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is like the puṇḍarīka lotus, I myself, in truth, am not a puṇḍarīka lotus at all — a statement of this kind is itself the Tathāgata's own secret teaching. Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is like a parent, the Tathāgata, in truth, is not a parent at all — a statement of this kind is likewise the Tathāgata's own secret teaching. Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is a great ship's captain, the Tathāgata, in truth, is not a ship's captain at all — a statement of this kind is likewise the Tathāgata's own secret teaching. Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is like a caravan's leader, the Tathāgata, in truth, is not a caravan's leader at all — a statement of this kind is likewise the Tathāgata's own secret teaching. Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is able to subdue Māra, the Tathāgata, in truth, harbors no wicked mind at all, wishing to make another submit — a statement of this kind is entirely the Tathāgata's own secret teaching. Kāśyapa, when it is said that the Tathāgata is able to treat a festering boil, I myself, in truth, am not a physician who treats boils at all — a statement of this kind is likewise the Tathāgata's own secret teaching.
"Kāśyapa, it is as I have already taught before: 'Should any good son or good daughter be well able to cultivate and discipline his own deeds of body, speech, and mind, then, at the moment he gives up his own life, though his relatives may take up his own corpse, whether burning it with fire, casting it into a great body of water, or abandoning it among the graves, where foxes, wolves, and birds of prey compete to devour it, his own mind, thought, and consciousness will nonetheless at once be reborn in a wholesome destiny. Yet this very mental process, in truth, neither comes nor goes, and arrives nowhere at all — it is truly only a succession of resembling states, one following upon another, its own character never actually differing.' A statement of this kind is itself the Tathāgata's own secret teaching. Kāśyapa, my speaking of illness now is likewise just the same — this too is the Tathāgata's own secret teaching. This is why I turned to instruct Mañjuśrī: 'My back aches now — you should teach the Dharma for the fourfold assembly in my place.' Kāśyapa, the Tathāgata, the Perfectly Awakened One, in truth has no illness at all; his lying upon his right side is likewise no final entering into nirvāṇa at all. Kāśyapa, this Mahāparinirvāṇa is itself the exceedingly profound meditative absorption of every buddha — a meditative absorption of this kind is not within the domain of any śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha at all.
"Kāśyapa, as for what you asked earlier — why does the Tathāgata recline without rising, without calling for food or drink, without instructing his household on the management of their affairs? Kāśyapa, the very nature of empty space likewise has no sitting or rising, no calling for food or drink, no instructing a household on the management of its affairs; it likewise has no coming or going, no birth or death, no youth or age, no emerging or vanishing, no injury or breaking, no bondage or liberation; it neither speaks of itself nor of another, neither understands itself nor another; it is neither at ease nor ill. Good son, every buddha, every world-honored one, is just the same, exactly like empty space — how, then, could there ever be any illness or suffering in him at all?"
Huiyuan reads the Buddha's past-life account — a śrāvaka under the buddha Unsurpassed Victor, studying this very sūtra there — as answering, point for point, Kāśyapa's earlier claim that a bodhisattva's vows over countless kalpas should already have secured him a body free of illness: this is the Buddha's own record of exactly that vow already fulfilled. On the catalogue of paradoxical statements that follows — ten items naming the Buddha (a lion who is not a lion, a dragon who has set that identity aside, neither human nor god nor any of the eight classes of spirit, an ocean and a Sumeru without salt or stone, a lotus that is not a lotus, a parent, a ship's captain, a caravan's leader, a subduer of Māra with no hostile intent, a healer of boils who is no physician) followed by a final, eleventh item about beings generally — Huiyuan reads all eleven as working by the same mechanism. Ordinary logic holds that body and mind alike perish entirely at death, yet the Buddha has also taught, elsewhere, that a virtuous person's own mind "goes" somewhere at the moment of death — a statement that does not fully accord with ultimate logic either, since nothing, strictly speaking, comes or goes at all; there is only a succession of resembling states, each following the last without any real transit between them. This is why Huiyuan reads the rebirth teaching as belonging to the very same category as "the Tathāgata is a lion, and yet not a lion": both are useful, practical descriptions that serve their purpose without being literally true in the way they sound, and "I am ill" belongs to this same family of secret teaching, spoken for Kāśyapa's own sake and for beings in ages to come, never a report of the Tathāgata's actual condition.
Three Illnesses No One Can Cure
「迦葉!世有三人,其病難治:一、謗大乘,二、五逆罪,三、一闡提。如是三病世中極重,悉非聲聞緣覺、菩薩之所能治。善男子!譬如有病必死難治,若有瞻病隨意醫藥,若無瞻病隨意醫藥,如是之病定不可治,當知是人必死不疑。善男子!是三種人亦復如是,若有聲聞、緣覺、菩薩,或有說法,或不說法,不能令其發阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心。
迦葉!譬如病人,若有瞻病隨意醫藥,則可令差,若無此三則不可差。聲聞緣覺亦復如是,從佛菩薩得聞法已,即能發於阿耨多羅三藐三菩提心,非不聞法能發心也。迦葉!譬如病人若有瞻病隨意醫藥,若無瞻病隨意醫藥,皆悉可差。有一種人亦復如是,或值聲聞、不值聲聞,或值緣覺、不值緣覺,或值菩薩、不值菩薩,或值如來、不值如來,或得聞法、或不聞法,自然得成阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。所謂有人,或為自身、或為他身、或為怖畏、或為利養、或為諛諂、或為誑他,書寫如是大涅槃經,受持讀誦,供養恭敬,為他說者。
「迦葉!有五種人於是大乘大涅槃典,有病行處,非如來也。何等為五?一斷三結,得須陀洹果,不墮地獄、畜生、餓鬼,人天七返,永斷諸苦,入於涅槃。迦葉!是名第一人有病行處,是人未來過八萬劫,便當得成阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。迦葉!第二人者,斷三結縛、薄貪恚癡,得斯陀含果,名一往來,永斷諸苦,入於涅槃。迦葉!是名第二人有病行處,是人未來過六萬劫,便當得成阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。迦葉!第三人者,斷五下結,得阿那含果,更不來此,永斷諸苦入於涅槃,是名第三人有病行處。是人未來過四萬劫,便當得成阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。迦葉!第四人者,永斷貪欲、瞋恚、愚癡,得阿羅漢果,煩惱無餘,入於涅槃,亦非騏驎獨一之行,是名第四人有病行處。是人未來過二萬劫,便當得成阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。迦葉!第五人者,永斷貪欲、瞋恚、愚癡,得辟支佛道,煩惱無餘,入於涅槃,真是騏驎獨一之行,是名第五人有病行處。是人未來過十千劫,便當得成阿耨多羅三藐三菩提。迦葉!是名第五人有病行處,非如來也。」
"Kāśyapa, there are three kinds of person in the world whose illness is hard to treat: first, one who slanders the Great Vehicle; second, one who commits one of the five heinous crimes; third, the icchantika. These three illnesses are the very gravest in the world, and none of them can be treated by any śrāvaka, pratyekabuddha, or bodhisattva at all. Good son, it is like an illness that is certainly fatal, hard to treat — whether or not one has an attendant to nurse the patient, and whatever medicine one might give, an illness of this kind is certainly incurable, and one may know without doubt that such a person will surely die. Good son, these three kinds of person are just the same: whether any śrāvaka, pratyekabuddha, or bodhisattva teaches the Dharma to them, or does not, none of them is able to cause such a person to give rise to the mind of unsurpassed, complete awakening.
"Kāśyapa, it is like a sick person who, having an attendant to nurse him and the right medicine given, may be cured — but who, lacking any of these three things, cannot be cured. Śrāvakas and pratyekabuddhas are just the same: having heard the Dharma from a buddha or a bodhisattva, they are thereby able to give rise to the mind of unsurpassed, complete awakening — it is not that they could give rise to this mind without ever hearing the Dharma at all. Kāśyapa, it is likewise like a sick person who may be cured whether or not he has an attendant to nurse him, whether or not he is given the right medicine. There is likewise a certain kind of person who is just the same: whether he encounters a śrāvaka or not, a pratyekabuddha or not, a bodhisattva or not, a tathāgata or not, whether he hears the Dharma or not, he naturally comes to accomplish unsurpassed, complete awakening of himself. This refers to a person who, whether for his own sake, or another's, or out of fear, or for personal gain, or out of flattery, or even to deceive another, copies out this very Mahāparinirvāṇa, receives and upholds it, recites it, makes offerings to it and reveres it, and explains it for the sake of others."
"Kāśyapa, there are five kinds of person who, with regard to this Mahāparinirvāṇa of the Great Vehicle, still have a place of 'sickness-conduct' — unlike the Tathāgata. What are these five? The first has cut off the three fetters, attaining the fruit of stream-entry, no longer falling into hell, among the animals, or among the hungry ghosts, and, passing seven more times through the human and heavenly realms, forever cuts off every suffering and enters nirvāṇa. Kāśyapa, this is called the first person's place of sickness-conduct — such a person will, in a future age, after eighty thousand kalpas, come to accomplish unsurpassed, complete awakening. Kāśyapa, the second person has cut off the bonds of the three fetters, and thinned out craving, anger, and delusion, attaining the fruit of once-returning, called 'one coming and going,' forever cutting off every suffering and entering nirvāṇa. Kāśyapa, this is called the second person's place of sickness-conduct — such a person will, in a future age, after sixty thousand kalpas, come to accomplish unsurpassed, complete awakening. Kāśyapa, the third person has cut off the five lower fetters, attaining the fruit of non-returning, never coming back to this world again, forever cutting off every suffering and entering nirvāṇa — this is called the third person's place of sickness-conduct. Such a person will, in a future age, after forty thousand kalpas, come to accomplish unsurpassed, complete awakening. Kāśyapa, the fourth person has forever cut off craving, anger, and delusion, attaining the fruit of arhatship, his affliction entirely exhausted, entering nirvāṇa — though not, like the solitary rhinoceros, walking a path entirely alone — this is called the fourth person's place of sickness-conduct. Such a person will, in a future age, after twenty thousand kalpas, come to accomplish unsurpassed, complete awakening. Kāśyapa, the fifth person has forever cut off craving, anger, and delusion, attaining the path of the pratyekabuddha, his affliction entirely exhausted, entering nirvāṇa — truly walking the path of the solitary rhinoceros, entirely alone — this is called the fifth person's place of sickness-conduct. Such a person will, in a future age, after ten thousand kalpas, come to accomplish unsurpassed, complete awakening. Kāśyapa, this is called the fifth person's place of sickness-conduct — unlike the Tathāgata at all."
Huiyuan reads this closing stretch of 現病品 as sorting three broad classes of person — ordinary beings, the two lesser vehicles, and bodhisattvas — and then, having named the three truly incurable conditions among ordinary beings, deliberately singling out the middle class, the two lesser vehicles, for the fascicle's most detailed treatment. His reasoning: the two lesser vehicles are the Great Vehicle's own natural point of comparison, so spelling out exactly where they stand illuminates, by contrast, where the Great Vehicle itself stands — small measured against great makes great legible in a way it would not be on its own. On the descending kalpa-counts attached to each of the five kinds of person — eighty thousand, sixty thousand, forty thousand, twenty thousand, ten thousand — he notes these track how many fetters remain uncut at each stage, and flags a technical point worth carrying forward: even a stream-enterer, barely past the first fetters, is already said to be moving toward "bodhi," which sounds premature until one recalls that this sūtra uses "bodhi" in five distinct senses elsewhere (the arising of the resolve, its subduing, its clarification, its full emergence, and its unsurpassed completion) — the first of these already present the moment a being enters the fortunate destinies, long before anything resembling full awakening. What every one of these five kinds of person shares, and what finally distinguishes every one of them from the Tathāgata, is simply that they still have a place where sickness-conduct — some remaining fetter, however fine — can be said to apply at all; the Tathāgata, this whole chapter has argued, does not.
The Man and the Rākṣasa's Floating Bag
Here the sūtra's seventh chapter, 聖行品 (Noble Conduct), begins.
爾時佛告迦葉菩薩:「善男子!菩薩摩訶薩應當於是大般涅槃經,專心思惟五種之行。何等為五?一者聖行、二者梵行、三者天行、四者嬰兒行、五者病行。善男子!菩薩摩訶薩常當修習是五種行,復有一行是如來行,所謂大乘大涅槃經。
「迦葉!云何菩薩摩訶薩所修聖行?菩薩摩訶薩若從聲聞、若從如來,得聞如是大涅槃經,聞已生信,信已應作如是思惟:『諸佛世尊有無上道,有大正法,大眾正行,復有方等大乘經典。我今當為愛樂貪求大乘經故,捨離所愛妻子、眷屬、所居舍宅、金銀珍寶、微妙瓔珞、香花伎樂、奴婢僕使、男女大小、象馬車乘、牛羊鷄犬、猪豕之屬。』復作是念:『居家迫迮,猶如牢獄,一切煩惱由之而生。出家寬曠,猶如虛空,一切善法因之增長。若在家居,不得盡壽淨修梵行,我今應當剃除鬚髮,出家學道。』作是念已,我今定當出家修學無上正真菩提之道。菩薩如是欲出家時,天魔波旬生大苦惱,言是菩薩復當與我興大戰諍。善男子!如是菩薩何處當復與人戰諍?是時菩薩即至僧坊,若見如來及佛弟子,威儀具足諸根寂靜,其心柔和,清淨寂滅,即至其所而求出家,剃除鬚髮,服三法衣。既出家已,奉持禁戒,威儀不缺,進止安詳,無所觸犯。乃至小罪,心生怖畏,護戒之心,猶如金剛。
「善男子!譬如有人帶持浮囊,欲渡大海。爾時海中有一羅剎,即從其人乞索浮囊。其人聞已即作是念:『我今若與必定沒死。』答言:『羅剎!汝寧殺我,浮囊叵得。』羅剎復言:『汝若不能全與我者,見惠其半。』是人猶故不肯與之。羅剎復言:『汝若不肯惠我半者,幸願與我三分之一。』是人不肯。羅剎復言:『若不能者,當施手許。』是人不肯。羅剎復言:『汝今若復不能與我如手許者,我今飢窮,眾苦所逼,願當濟我如微塵許。』是人復言:『汝今所索,誠復不多,然我今日方當渡海,不知前途近遠如何?若與汝者,氣當漸出,大海之難,何由得過?脫能中路,沒水而死。』善男子!菩薩摩訶薩護持禁戒,亦復如是,如彼渡人護惜浮囊。
「菩薩如是護戒之時,常有煩惱諸惡羅剎,語菩薩言:『汝當信我,終不相欺,但破四禁,護持餘戒,以是因緣,令汝安隱,得入涅槃。』菩薩爾時應作是言:『我今寧持如是禁戒墮阿鼻獄,終不毀犯而生天上。』煩惱羅剎復作是言:『卿若不能破四禁者,可破僧殘,以是因緣,令汝安隱得入涅槃。』菩薩亦應不隨其語。羅剎復言:『卿若不能犯僧殘者,亦可故犯偷蘭遮罪,以是因緣令汝安隱得入涅槃。』菩薩爾時亦復不隨。羅剎復言:『卿若不能犯偷蘭遮者,可犯捨墮,以是因緣可得安隱入於涅槃。』菩薩爾時亦不隨之。羅剎復言:『卿若不能犯捨墮者,可破波夜提,以是因緣令汝安隱得入涅槃。』菩薩爾時亦不隨之。羅剎復言:『卿若不能犯波夜提者,幸可毀破突吉羅戒,以是因緣可得安隱入於涅槃。』菩薩爾時心自念言:『我今若犯突吉羅罪,不發露者,則不能渡生死彼岸而得涅槃。』菩薩摩訶薩於是微小諸戒律中,護持堅固心如金剛。菩薩摩訶薩持四重禁及突吉羅,敬重堅固,等無差別。菩薩若能如是堅持,則為具足五根諸戒,所謂具足菩薩根本業清淨戒、前後眷屬餘清淨戒、非諸惡覺覺清淨戒、護持正念念清淨戒、迴向阿耨多羅三藐三菩提戒。
「迦葉!是菩薩摩訶薩復有二種戒:一者受世教戒,二者得正法戒。菩薩若受正法戒者終不為惡,受世教戒者,白四羯磨然後乃得。復次善男子!有二種戒:一者性重戒,二者息世譏嫌戒。性重戒者,謂四禁也。」
At that time, the Buddha said to the bodhisattva Kāśyapa: "Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva should, with regard to this Mahāparinirvāṇa, single-mindedly reflect upon five kinds of conduct. What are these five? First, noble conduct; second, pure conduct; third, heavenly conduct; fourth, infant-like conduct; fifth, sick conduct. Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva should forever cultivate and practice these five kinds of conduct — and there is, further, one conduct that is the Tathāgata's own conduct, namely this Mahāparinirvāṇa of the Great Vehicle itself.
"Kāśyapa, how does the bodhisattva-mahāsattva cultivate noble conduct? Should a bodhisattva-mahāsattva, whether from a śrāvaka or from the Tathāgata himself, come to hear this Mahāparinirvāṇa, and, having heard it, give rise to faith, he should, once he has faith, reflect in this way: 'Every buddha, every world-honored one, possesses the unsurpassed path, possesses the great, true Dharma, the great assembly's own true conduct, and further possesses the Vaipulya scriptures of the Great Vehicle. I shall now, for the sake of delighting in and earnestly seeking the scriptures of the Great Vehicle, set aside my beloved wife and children, my household, the house I dwell in, gold, silver, and every precious treasure, subtle and wondrous ornaments, incense, flowers, music, male and female servants, young and old alike, elephants, horses, and carriages, cattle, sheep, chickens, dogs, pigs, and every such possession.' He then thinks further: 'Household life is cramped and confined, like a prison, and every affliction arises on account of it. The homeless life is vast and open, like empty space, and every wholesome dharma grows and increases on account of it. Should I remain a householder, I could never, for the whole of my life, purely cultivate pure conduct — I should now shave my head and beard, and go forth to study the path.' Having thought this, he resolves: 'I shall now, without fail, go forth and cultivate the unsurpassed, true path of bodhi.' When a bodhisattva wishes to go forth in this way, the heavenly Māra Pāpīyas gives rise to great distress, saying: 'This bodhisattva will surely wage a great battle against me once more.' Good son, but where, in truth, would such a bodhisattva ever wage battle against anyone at all? At that time, the bodhisattva goes at once to a monastery, and, seeing the Tathāgata and the Buddha's own disciples, their conduct complete, their faculties tranquil, their minds gentle, pure, and still, goes at once to their own place and seeks to go forth, shaving his head and beard, and donning the three Dharma robes. Having gone forth, he upholds the precepts, his conduct never lacking, moving and resting with perfect composure, transgressing in nothing at all — and, even toward the smallest offense, his heart gives rise to dread, his mind guarding the precepts as firmly as vajra.
"Good son, it is like a person carrying an inflated floating bag, wishing to cross the great ocean. There is, at that time, within the ocean, a rākṣasa demon, who at once begs this person for his own floating bag. Hearing this, the person thinks to himself: 'Should I give this to him now, I would surely sink and die.' He answers: 'Rākṣasa, you may as well kill me — you shall not have this floating bag.' The rākṣasa says further: 'If you cannot give me the whole of it, then grant me at least half.' The person still refuses to give it. The rākṣasa says further: 'If you will not grant me half, I beg you, then, to give me a third of it.' The person refuses. The rākṣasa says further: 'If you cannot even do this, then give me as much as would fit in the palm of a hand.' The person refuses. The rākṣasa says further: 'If you cannot even give me that much, then I, now starving and desperate, pressed by every suffering, beg you to save me with even as much as a single mote of dust.' The person answers: 'What you now ask is, in truth, not very much at all — yet I am only now about to cross this ocean, and do not know how near or far the way ahead may be. Should I give even this much to you, the air would gradually leak out, and how, then, could I ever survive the peril of this great ocean? I might well, midway, sink into the water and die.' Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, upholding the precepts, is just the same, guarding his own floating bag exactly as that man crossing the ocean did.
"When a bodhisattva guards the precepts in this way, the many wicked rākṣasas of affliction constantly say to him: 'You should trust me — I would never deceive you. Only break the four gravest precepts, and keep the rest — through this very cause and condition, you shall find peace and ease, and attain nirvāṇa.' The bodhisattva should, at such a time, say this in reply: 'I would rather uphold these very precepts and fall into the Avīci hell than ever transgress them and be reborn in heaven instead.' The rākṣasa of affliction says further: 'If you cannot break the four gravest precepts, then break one of the offenses requiring temporary suspension — through this very cause and condition, you shall find peace and ease, and attain nirvāṇa.' The bodhisattva should likewise not follow these words. The rākṣasa says further: 'If you cannot commit an offense requiring temporary suspension, then you may at least deliberately commit an offense of gross wrongdoing — through this very cause and condition, you shall find peace and ease, and attain nirvāṇa.' The bodhisattva, at such a time, likewise does not follow this. The rākṣasa says further: 'If you cannot commit an offense of gross wrongdoing, then you may commit an offense requiring forfeiture — through this very cause and condition, you may find peace and ease, and enter nirvāṇa.' The bodhisattva, at such a time, likewise does not follow this. The rākṣasa says further: 'If you cannot commit an offense requiring forfeiture, then break an offense of simple expiation — through this very cause and condition, you shall find peace and ease, and attain nirvāṇa.' The bodhisattva, at such a time, likewise does not follow this. The rākṣasa says further: 'If you cannot commit an offense of simple expiation, then I beg you, at least, to transgress an offense of wrongful conduct — through this very cause and condition, you may find peace and ease, and enter nirvāṇa.' The bodhisattva, at such a time, thinks to himself: 'Should I now commit even an offense of wrongful conduct, and fail to confess it openly, I would then be unable to cross to the far shore of birth and death, and attain nirvāṇa at all.' The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, with regard to even the smallest of these disciplinary rules, guards them with a mind as firm as vajra. The bodhisattva-mahāsattva upholds the four gravest precepts and the offense of wrongful conduct with equal reverence and firmness, without any difference at all. Should a bodhisattva be able to hold to this so firmly, he thereby fully possesses the five roots of every precept — namely, the precept of purity in the very root of a bodhisattva's own karmic action, the precept of purity in every accompanying circumstance before and after, the precept of purity in awareness that guards against every wicked thought, the precept of purity in mindfulness that protects right recollection, and the precept of dedication toward unsurpassed, complete awakening.
"Kāśyapa, this bodhisattva-mahāsattva has, further, two kinds of precept: first, the precept received through worldly instruction; second, the precept attained through the true Dharma. Should a bodhisattva attain the precept of the true Dharma, he will never commit evil at all; the precept received through worldly instruction is obtained only through the formal procedure of announcement and threefold motion. Furthermore, good son, there are two kinds of precept: first, the precepts grave by their own nature; second, the precepts that avoid what the world finds shameful. The precepts grave by their own nature are the four gravest precepts."
Huiyuan glosses each of the five practices by how its own name is formed: "noble conduct" is named for its practitioners, since buddhas and bodhisattvas are together called noble; "pure conduct" (梵行) and "heavenly conduct" (天行) are both named for the quality they share, purity, at two different registers the Sanskrit distinguishes and Chinese collapses into one word; "sick conduct" is named by function, conduct that treats illness; "infant-like conduct" is named by simile, conduct as free of calculation as an infant who understands nothing at all. Of the five, this sūtra treats noble conduct in this chapter, pure conduct in the next, infant-like conduct later still, and heavenly conduct not at all here — Huiyuan points the reader to the Avataṃsaka Sūtra for it instead. Sick conduct's own textual home is more contested: some readers, he notes, take the five kinds of "sickness-conduct" person just described in 現病品 as fulfilling this fifth category — but Huiyuan disagrees, since those five are śrāvakas and pratyekabuddhas, not bodhisattvas, and the conduct described there is itself the disease, not the treatment of it. He locates true "sick conduct" further ahead, in 梵行品's account of King Ajātaśatru's repentance, where the Buddha treats both the king's psychological illness of guilt and his physical illness of boils at once — conduct that heals sickness, matching the category's own name, rather than conduct that merely exhibits it. He also notes that this same chapter names a sixth item, "the Tathāgata's own conduct," identified simply as this Mahāparinirvāṇa itself — not a sixth practice alongside the other five, but the already-accomplished ground the five practices are cultivated toward and depend upon.
On the floating-bag parable, Huiyuan's mapping is direct: the man is the bodhisattva, the floating bag is the precepts, the ocean is birth and death, and the rākṣasa is affliction itself, wanting nothing more than to talk the bodhisattva into surrendering some fraction of his own discipline. He flags one detail worth not over-reading: the rākṣasa's five successive demands (the whole bag, then half, a third, a handful, a single mote of dust) do not map one-to-one onto the six categories of precept the parallel dialogue that follows walks through (the four gravest offenses, offenses requiring temporary suspension, gross wrongdoing, forfeiture, simple expiation, and wrongful conduct) — the numbers were never meant to line up exactly. The point of both passages together is simply that grave and minor precepts alike are guarded with the very same unbending resolve, all the way down to the smallest rule a monastic keeps.
What the World Finds Shameful
「息世譏嫌戒者,不作販賣、輕秤小㪷、欺誑於人、因他形勢取人財物、害心繫縛破壞成功、然明而臥、田宅種植、家業坐肆,不畜象馬車乘、牛羊駝驢、鷄犬獼猴、孔雀鸚鵡、共命及拘枳羅、豺狼虎豹、猫狸猪豕及餘惡獸、童男童女、大男大女、奴婢僮僕、金銀琉璃、頗梨真珠、車璩馬瑙、珊瑚璧玉、珂貝諸寶、赤銅白鑞、鍮石盂器、氍毺㲩[毯-炎+登]、拘執毦衣、一切穀米、大小麥豆、穈粟稻麻、生熟食具,常受一食不曾再食、若行乞食及僧中食、常知止足不受別請、不食肉不飲酒、五辛能熏悉不食之,是故其身無有臭處,常為諸天一切世人恭敬供養、尊重讚歎,趣足而食終不長受。所受衣服纔足覆身,進止常與三衣鉢具,終不捨離,如鳥二翼。不畜根子、莖子、節子、椄子、子子,不畜寶藏,若金、若銀,飲食、厨庫、衣裳服飾、高廣大床、象牙金床、雜色編織、悉不用坐,不畜一切細軟諸蓆、不坐象薦馬薦、不以細軟上妙衣服用敷床臥,其床兩頭不置二枕,亦不受畜妙好丹枕、安黃木枕。終不觀看象鬪、馬鬪、車鬪、兵鬪、男鬪、女鬪、牛鬪、羊鬪、水牛鷄雉鸚鵡等鬪,亦不故往觀看軍陣,不應故聽吹貝、鼓角、琴瑟箏笛、箜篌歌叫、伎樂之聲,除供養佛。摴蒱圍碁波羅塞戲、師子象鬪、彈碁六愽、拍毱擲石、投壺牽道、八道行成、一切戲笑悉不觀作。終不瞻相手脚面目,不以抓鏡、蓍草、楊枝、鉢盂、髑髏而作卜筮,亦不仰觀虛空星宿,除欲解睡。不作王家往返使命,以此語彼,以彼語此。終不諛諂,邪命自活,亦不宣說王臣盜賊鬪諍、飲食國土、飢饉恐怖、豐樂安隱之事。善男子!是名菩薩摩訶薩息世譏嫌戒。善男子!菩薩摩訶薩堅持如是遮制之戒,與性重戒等無差別。」
"As for the precepts that avoid what the world finds shameful: never engaging in trade; never using light weights or small measures to cheat others; never taking another's property by relying on someone else's power or influence; never binding or destroying another's success out of malice; never lying about in bed once the day has dawned; never engaging in landholding, farming, planting, or running a household business or shop; never keeping elephants, horses, carriages, cattle, sheep, camels, donkeys, chickens, dogs, monkeys, peacocks, parrots, jīvaṃjīvaka birds, or the kokila bird, jackals, wolves, tigers, leopards, cats, civets, pigs, or any other wild beast; never keeping young boys or girls, grown men or women, male or female servants; never keeping gold, silver, lapis lazuli, crystal, pearls, coral shell, agate, coral, jade, or any other treasure; never keeping red copper, white pewter, brass vessels, fine woolen rugs or blankets, or garments trimmed with fur; never keeping grain of any kind — wheat, barley, beans, millet, rice, or sesame, whether raw or cooked — or the utensils for preparing them; always taking only a single meal, never a second; whether begging for alms or eating within the community, always knowing when he has had enough, never accepting a special invitation apart from the community; never eating meat, never drinking wine, never eating any of the five pungent, strong-smelling plants at all — and it is for this reason that his own body carries no foul odor, and he is forever revered, honored, and praised with offerings by every god and every person in the world — eating only enough to satisfy himself, never taking more than he needs. The clothing he receives is only enough to cover his body; in every movement, he always keeps his three robes and his bowl close at hand, never once setting them aside, as a bird never parts from its own two wings. He keeps no roots, stems, cuttings, grafts, or seeds for planting; he keeps no hoard of treasure, whether gold or silver; he never makes use of food and drink stores, fine clothing and ornaments, a high and spacious bed, an ivory or golden bedframe, or woven fabric of every mixed color to sit upon; he keeps no fine, soft mats of any kind; he does not sit upon a rug of elephant or horse hide; he does not spread fine, soft, exquisite garments upon his bed to lie on, nor does he place two pillows at either end of his bed, nor does he keep a fine, red-lacquered pillow, or one filled with yellow wood shavings. He never watches contests between elephants, horses, chariots, soldiers, men, women, cattle, sheep, buffalo, chickens, pheasants, or parrots, nor does he deliberately go to watch a military review; he should never deliberately listen to the blowing of conches, the beating of drums and horns, the sound of zither and lute, of pipe and flute, of harp and song, or any kind of music, except in offering to the Buddha. He never watches games of chance, board games, dice, wrestling matches between lions or elephants, checkers, gambling, ball games, stone-throwing, arrow-pitching, tug-of-war, the eight-path game, or any kind of frivolous entertainment at all. He never reads palms, feet, or faces to divine another's fortune; he never practices divination with a mirror and claws, with milfoil stalks, with willow branches, with a begging bowl, or with a skull; nor does he gaze up at the stars in the sky, except to relieve drowsiness. He never carries messages back and forth for a royal household, speaking this person's words to that one, and that one's words to this. He never flatters or fawns, sustaining himself through a crooked livelihood; nor does he speak of the affairs of kings and ministers, of thieves and warfare, of food and territory, of famine and terror, or of abundance and peace. Good son, this is what is called the bodhisattva-mahāsattva's own precepts for avoiding what the world finds shameful. Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, holding firmly to these restraining precepts, keeps them with the very same, undivided reverence as the precepts grave by their own nature."
Huiyuan reads this long catalogue as organized in four movements rather than as one undifferentiated list: not wrongfully taking (trade, false weights and measures, exploiting another's influence, malicious dealing); not wrongfully spending (idling in bed past dawn, unnecessary household enterprise); not wrongfully hoarding, by far the longest movement, itself running through eight further categories in sequence — land and cultivation, livestock and beasts, servants, precious materials, food stores, surplus clothing, the five kinds of propagating seed, and every article of luxury; and, finally, not wrongfully acting — watching contests and military displays, listening to music, playing games of chance, practicing divination, running messages for a royal household, and gossiping about kings, war, or famine. The four movements are not, on Huiyuan's reading, an arbitrary sequence: what a monastic must never wrongfully acquire, spend, keep, or do covers the whole cycle of how worldly entanglement actually accumulates, one stage feeding the next. The precepts grave by their own nature (the four gravest offenses) and these precepts against giving the world cause for scorn are held, the text insists explicitly, with exactly the same undivided reverence — a claim this collection has already seen made about the floating bag, now spelled out item by item across the whole of a monastic's ordinary life.
Rather This Body Broken
「善男子,菩薩摩訶薩受持如是諸禁戒已,作是願言:『寧以此身投於熾然猛火深坑,終不毀犯過去、未來、現在諸佛所制禁戒,與剎利女、婆羅門女、居士女而行不淨。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧以熱鐵周匝纏身,終不敢以破戒之身,受於信心檀越衣服。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧以此口吞熱鐵丸,終不敢以毀戒之口,食於信心檀越飲食。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧臥此身大熱鐵上,終不敢以破戒之身,受於信心檀越床敷臥具。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『我寧以身受三百鉾,終不敢以毀戒之身,受於信心檀越醫藥。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧以此身投熱鐵鑊,不以破戒,受於信心檀越房舍屋宅。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧以鐵搥打碎此身,從頭至足令如微塵,不以破戒,受諸剎利婆羅門居士恭敬禮拜。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧以熱鐵挑其兩目,不以染心視他好色。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧以鐵錐遍身攙刺,不以染心聽好音聲。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧以利刀割去其鼻,不以染心貪嗅諸香。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧以利刀割裂其舌,不以染心貪著美味。』復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩復作是願:『寧以利斧斬斫其身,不以染心貪著諸觸。何以故?以是因緣,能令行者墮於地獄、畜生、餓鬼。』迦葉!是名菩薩摩訶薩護持禁戒。菩薩摩訶薩護持如是諸禁戒已,悉以施於一切眾生。以是因緣,願令眾生護持禁戒,得清淨戒、善戒、不缺戒、不析戒、大乘戒、不退戒、隨順戒、畢竟戒,具足成就波羅蜜戒。
「善男子!菩薩摩訶薩修持如是清淨戒時,即得住於初不動地。云何名為不動地耶?菩薩住是不動地中,不動、不墮、不退、不散。善男子!譬如須彌山,旋藍猛風不能令動、墮落退散。菩薩摩訶薩住是地中,亦復如是,不為色聲香味所動,不墮地獄、畜生、餓鬼,不退聲聞辟支佛地,不為異見邪風所散而作邪命。復次善男子!又復動者,不為貪欲恚癡所動;又復墮者,不墮四重;又復退者,不退戒還家;又復散者,不為違逆大乘經者之所散壞。復次善男子!菩薩摩訶薩亦復不為諸煩惱魔之所傾動,不為陰魔所墮,乃至坐於道場菩提樹下,雖有天魔,不能令其退於阿耨多羅三藐三菩提,亦復不為死魔所散。善男子!是名菩薩摩訶薩修習聖行。
「善男子!云何名為聖行?聖行者,佛及菩薩之所行故,故名聖行。以何等故,名佛菩薩為聖人耶?如是等人有聖法故,常觀諸法性空寂故,以是義故,故名聖人。有聖戒故,復名聖人。有聖定慧故,故名聖人。有七聖財,所謂信、戒、慚、愧、多聞、智慧、捨離,故名聖人。有七聖覺故,故名聖人。以是義故,復名聖行。」
"Good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva, having received and upheld precepts of this kind, makes this vow: 'I would rather cast this very body into a deep pit of blazing, fierce fire than ever transgress the precepts established by every buddha of the past, future, and present, and engage in impure conduct with a kṣatriya woman, a brāhmaṇa woman, or a householder's wife.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather have my body wrapped entirely around with burning-hot iron than ever dare, with a body that has broken the precepts, to receive the robes of a faithful donor.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather swallow a ball of burning-hot iron with this very mouth than ever dare, with a mouth that has broken the precepts, to eat the food and drink of a faithful donor.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather lie this body down upon burning-hot iron than ever dare, with a body that has broken the precepts, to receive the bedding and furnishings of a faithful donor.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather have my body pierced by three hundred spears than ever dare, with a body that has broken the precepts, to receive the medicine of a faithful donor.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather cast this body into a burning-hot iron cauldron than, having broken the precepts, receive the house and dwelling of a faithful donor.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather have this body pounded to pieces with an iron hammer, from head to foot, until it is like fine dust, than, having broken the precepts, receive the reverence and homage of any kṣatriya, brāhmaṇa, or householder.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather have burning-hot iron gouge out both my eyes than gaze, with a defiled mind, upon another's attractive form.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather have iron awls pierce my whole body through than listen, with a defiled mind, to any pleasing sound.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather have a sharp blade cut off my own nose than crave, with a defiled mind, any fragrant scent.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather have a sharp blade slice apart my own tongue than crave, with a defiled mind, any delicious flavor.' Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva makes this further vow: 'I would rather have a sharp axe hack this body to pieces than crave, with a defiled mind, any touch at all. Why is this? Because it is through this very cause and condition that a practitioner comes to fall into hell, among the animals, or among the hungry ghosts.' Kāśyapa, this is what is called the bodhisattva-mahāsattva's own upholding of the precepts. The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, having upheld precepts of this kind, gives them entirely to every being. Through this very cause and condition, he vows that beings may uphold the precepts, and attain the pure precept, the wholesome precept, the unbroken precept, the unshattered precept, the precept of the Great Vehicle, the precept that never turns back, the precept in accord, the ultimate precept, fully and completely accomplishing the precept of the pāramitā.
"Good son, when the bodhisattva-mahāsattva cultivates and upholds precepts of this pure kind, he thereby comes to abide at the first unshakable ground. What is meant by the unshakable ground? A bodhisattva abiding within this unshakable ground is unmoved, unfallen, never turns back, and is never scattered. Good son, it is like Mount Sumeru, which even the fiercest cyclone wind at the end of an age cannot move, cause to fall, or scatter. The bodhisattva-mahāsattva, abiding at this ground, is just the same: he is not moved by form, sound, smell, or taste; he does not fall into hell, among the animals, or among the hungry ghosts; he does not turn back to the level of the śrāvaka or pratyekabuddha; he is not scattered by the wicked wind of any heterodox view into pursuing a crooked livelihood. Furthermore, good son, 'unmoved' further means not moved by craving, anger, or delusion; 'unfallen' further means not falling into one of the four gravest offenses; 'never turning back' further means never turning back from the precepts to return to household life; and 'never scattered' further means never being scattered and destroyed by those who oppose the scriptures of the Great Vehicle. Furthermore, good son, the bodhisattva-mahāsattva is likewise never shaken by any māra of affliction, never made to fall by the māra of the aggregates; and, even seated beneath the bodhi tree at the very seat of enlightenment, though the heavenly māra be present, he can never be made to turn back from unsurpassed, complete awakening, nor is he ever scattered by the māra of death. Good son, this is what is called the bodhisattva-mahāsattva's own cultivation of noble conduct.
"Good son, what is meant by 'noble conduct'? Noble conduct is called so because it is the conduct practiced by every buddha and bodhisattva — and this is why it is called noble conduct. For what reason are buddhas and bodhisattvas called noble ones? People of this kind are called noble ones because they possess the noble Dharma, forever contemplating the empty, still nature of every dharma — it is for this very reason that they are called noble ones. Because they possess the noble precepts, they are likewise called noble ones. Because they possess noble concentration and wisdom, they are called noble ones. Because they possess the seven noble treasures — namely, faith, moral discipline, a sense of shame before oneself, a sense of shame before others, extensive learning, wisdom, and renunciation — they are called noble ones. Because they possess the seven factors of noble awakening, they are called noble ones. It is for this very reason that this is also called noble conduct."
Huiyuan sorts the twelve vows into three groups: a first, on its own, against the root precept the whole sequence orbits (chastity); six tied to the six things a donor might offer — robe, food, bedding, medicine, housing, reverence — each vowing self-destruction sooner than receiving that gift with an impure body; and five tied to the five sense faculties — eyes, ears, nose, tongue, and body — each vowing self-mutilation sooner than letting desire enter through that particular gate. He then maps the nine qualities of the precept dedicated to all beings at the passage's close onto the bodhisattva grounds: the pure and wholesome precepts as the basic pair (restraint from wrong, active cultivation of right); the unbroken and unshattered precepts specifying purity further; the precept of the Great Vehicle proper to the lineage stage and above; the precept that never turns back proper to the first ground; the precept in accord proper to the second ground; the ultimate precept proper to the eighth ground; and the precept complete in the pāramitā proper to buddhahood itself — a single list quietly tracing the entire path from a new monastic's basic vow to a buddha's own completion.
On the "unshakable ground" itself, Huiyuan flags a disambiguation worth keeping in mind: standard bodhisattva-ground doctrine names two distinct "unshakable" grounds, an initial one at the first ground and a later, more advanced one at the eighth. What precept-keeping alone secures here is explicitly the first, initial unshakability, not the eighth-ground version reached only much further along the path — a bodhisattva at this stage is unmoved by ordinary temptation and heterodox pressure, not yet at the point where even subtle effort itself falls away. The chapter's own closing definition of "noble" gives five grounds for the term, one turning on constant contemplation of every dharma's own empty, still nature and four turning on practice — moral discipline, concentration joined with wisdom, the seven noble treasures, and the seven factors of awakening — closing 聖行品's opening movement on the same note it began: nobility, in this sūtra's own vocabulary, is something earned through sustained practice, never a rank inherited or assumed.
Part 11 Complete
This closes Part 11 (fascicle 11 of 40), completing 現病品第六 and opening 聖行品第七之一: Kāśyapa's full case that the illness the Buddha has just manifested cannot be real, a light from every pore emptying the hells, the hungry-ghost realm, and the animal world of every being but the icchantika, a catalogue of paradoxical statements the sūtra calls the Tathāgata's own secret teaching, and the three conditions — slandering the Great Vehicle, the five heinous crimes, the icchantika — that remain beyond any cure. The fascicle then opens the sūtra's chapter on noble conduct with a bodhisattva's motivation for renunciation, the famous parable of a man crossing the ocean who will not surrender his floating bag to a starving rākṣasa however little is asked, the precepts that avoid what the world finds shameful, and a string of vows to suffer bodily destruction sooner than receive an offering, or indulge a sense, with an impure mind. Part 12 continues 聖行品第七之二.
Continue to Part 12 →