Five Great Topics Close; the Eightfold Path Begins
Fascicle 98 continues directly from fascicle 97, which closed the first three particular verses of the foundations of mindfulness (念住攝) in their entirety. This fascicle opens and closes the fourth and final particular verse, completing the foundations of mindfulness — the first of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics — in its entirety. It then closes, one after another, four more great topics entire: right effort combined with the bases of supernormal power, the faculties, the powers, and the seven factors of enlightenment, this last closing with the four immeasurables' own upper-limit attainments and a wide sweep of companion-sūtra background. Fascicle 98 then opens the sixth great topic, the eightfold path, closing its first of four sections, the inward and outward powers that alone give rise to the noble path — a good spiritual friend, outwardly, and right reflection, inwardly. The fascicle's source concludes here, mid-way through this sixth topic; the path's remaining three sections — purity's own distinctions, the alternate approach, and the true renunciant and brāhmaṇa — continue in fascicle 99, along with the factors of enlightenment's three remaining great topics: mindfulness of breathing, the trainee and the adept beyond training, and the four confirmed purities.
1. Section: The Fascicle's Own Title — Continuing the Embrace of the Factors of Enlightenment
Within the compendium of bases, sūtra matters, the embrace of the factors of enlightenment, the fourth, part two.
攝事分中契經事菩提分法擇攝第四之二
Within the compendium of bases, sūtra matters, the embrace of the factors of enlightenment, the fourth, part two.
This is the fascicle's own chapter title, marking its place as the second part ("第四之二") of the fourth and final great division of sūtra matters (契經事) within the compendium of bases (攝事分, spanning fascicles 85 through 100). Master Cháng Bǎi recaps the whole division's structure: the aggregates' embrace (行擇攝), the sense-bases' embrace (處擇攝), the dependent-origination-food-truths-elements embrace (緣起食諦界擇攝), and the factors of enlightenment's embrace (菩提分法擇攝) — this last spanning fascicles 97 and 98, with fascicle 97 having already closed the general summary verse and the foundations of mindfulness's first three particular verses in their entirety, and this fascicle now continuing with the foundations of mindfulness's fourth and final particular verse.
2. Section: The Fourth Particular Summary Verse Begins — The Verse Marking and Listing
Further, a summary verse says: the false teacher's dwelling, the snow mountain; exhortation, and being bound to purity; the gradual sequence, the precepts' fullness; the ear of grain, and accomplishment, coming last.
復次,嗢柁南曰:
Further, a summary verse says:
邪師住雪山 勸勉繫屬淨 漸次戒圓滿 穗成就為後
The false teacher's dwelling, the snow mountain; exhortation, and being bound to purity; the gradual sequence, the precepts' fullness; the ear of grain, and accomplishment, coming last.
This opens **the fourth and final particular summary verse of the foundations of mindfulness's embrace (癸四第四嗢柁南2)**, beginning with the verse marking and listing (子一頌標列) — eight matters to unpack in the long-form explanation that follows: the false teacher's dwelling, the snow mountain, exhortation, being bound to purity, the gradual sequence, the precepts' fullness, the ear of grain, and accomplishment.
3. Section: The Long-Form Explanation Begins — The False Teacher's Dwelling Begins — Manifesting Exclusive Self-Interest Begins — Marking
There are various outside paths who, among their assembly of disciples, establish themselves as teacher, yet exclusively seek gain, exclusively seek veneration, and exclusively seek their own benefit.
有諸外道,於弟子眾自立為師,專求利養、專求恭敬、專求自利。
There are various outside paths who, among their assembly of disciples, establish themselves as teacher, yet exclusively seek gain, exclusively seek veneration, and exclusively seek their own benefit.
This opens the long-form explanation (子二長行釋8), an eightfold structure matching the verse's eight matters, beginning with the false teacher's dwelling (丑一邪師住2), named by the verse's first phrase "the false teacher's dwelling, the snow mountain" (邪師住雪山), beginning with manifesting exclusive self-interest (寅一明專自利2), beginning with marking (卯一標) — an outside-path teacher who sets himself up as a guide to disciples while exclusively chasing gain, veneration, and self-benefit is, at root, a false teacher regardless of outward appearance.
4. Section: Explaining Begins — Raising the Two Speeches Begins — The Outside-Path Teacher
Meeting a conjunction of conditions, there is a son of good family who goes forth under him. He then says to him: "You and I have not previously had any resources or requisites to share and use in common. You should, for my sake, go to another place, praise my virtues, and conceal my faults; I, too, will do the same for you. The two of us, taking turns relying on and protecting one another, will thereby obtain much gain and veneration from kings, from those equal to kings, and even from every great merchant lord." If a teacher speaks in this way, the various outside teachers are called exclusively seeking their own benefit.
遇緣和合,有族姓子投其出家。因而謂曰:汝之與我先無一切資身眾具可共受用,汝應為我往詣他處,褒讚我德,掩藏我失,我亦為汝行如是事。我等二人迭相依護,當於諸王若與王等乃至一切大商主邊,多獲利養及以恭敬。若作是言,諸外道師名專自利。
Meeting a conjunction of conditions, there is a son of good family who goes forth under him. He then says to him: "You and I have not previously had any resources or requisites to share and use in common. You should, for my sake, go to another place, praise my virtues, and conceal my faults; I, too, will do the same for you. The two of us, taking turns relying on and protecting one another, will thereby obtain much gain and veneration from kings, from those equal to kings, and even from every great merchant lord." If a teacher speaks in this way, the various outside teachers are called exclusively seeking their own benefit.
This opens explaining (卯二釋2), the second of manifesting exclusive self-interest's two matters, beginning with raising the two speeches (辰一舉二言2), beginning with the outside-path teacher (巳一外道師) — a newly-ordained disciple is instructed to trade mutual flattery for worldly gain: each praising the other's virtues and concealing the other's faults before patrons, so that both profit from the arrangement.
5. Section: The Disciple, Closing "Raising the Two Speeches" Entirely
Yet his disciple then speaks in protest: "Do not hold this view! Such protection as this is not called self-protection from the fault of going to an unfortunate destiny; only guarding against this fault is called self-protection. Therefore you should protect yourself as before, and I too shall separately protect myself in another way. Since I am unable to protect you, you likewise need not protect me."
然其弟子便發抗言:勿為此見!如是護者,未名自護往惡趣失;若防此失,乃名自護。是故汝應如前自護,我亦當自別為餘護。我既不能護汝,汝亦不須護我。
Yet his disciple then speaks in protest: "Do not hold this view! Such protection as this is not called self-protection from the fault of going to an unfortunate destiny; only guarding against this fault is called self-protection. Therefore you should protect yourself as before, and I too shall separately protect myself in another way. Since I am unable to protect you, you likewise need not protect me."
With this, the disciple (巳二彼弟子) closes entirely, closing raising the two speeches (辰一舉二言2: 外道師/彼弟子) entirely — the disciple sees through the arrangement: mutual flattery protects neither party from an unfortunate rebirth; only guarding one's own conduct against that fault deserves the name "self-protection," so each should attend to their own practice rather than trading favors. The 披尋記 confirms "self-protection as before" refers back to guarding against the very fault of an unfortunate destiny.
6. Section: Distinguishing Merit and Fault, Closing "Manifesting Exclusive Self-Interest" Entirely
Within this meaning, one should know that the disciple is one who speaks in accordance with principle, one who is wise, since he gives weight to what is to come; one should know that his teacher is one who speaks contrary to principle, one who is foolish, since he gives weight only to the present.
於此義中,當知弟子是如理語者,是聰慧者,重當來故。應知其師是非理語者,是愚癡者,重現在故。
Within this meaning, one should know that the disciple is one who speaks in accordance with principle, one who is wise, since he gives weight to what is to come; one should know that his teacher is one who speaks contrary to principle, one who is foolish, since he gives weight only to the present.
With this, distinguishing merit and fault (辰二辨德失) closes entirely, closing **manifesting exclusive self-interest (寅一明專自利2: 標/釋), the first of the false teacher's dwelling's two matters, entirely** — weighing future consequence over present convenience marks the wise; weighing present convenience over future consequence, however dressed up as mutual aid, marks the fool — and, in this case, the false teacher.
7. Section: Manifesting the Fault of Failing to Protect Begins — Marking the Fault
Further, there is defilement that touches and disturbs another; because of this defilement, one is unable to protect oneself; and because of thereby disturbing another, this is not called protecting another.
復有雜染觸惱於他,由雜染故,不能自護;因此惱他,不名護他。
Further, there is defilement that touches and disturbs another; because of this defilement, one is unable to protect oneself; and because of thereby disturbing another, this is not called protecting another.
This opens manifesting the fault of failing to protect (寅二明不護失2), the second of the false teacher's dwelling's two matters, beginning with marking the fault (卯一標失) — a mind still defiled by affliction, when it disturbs another, has failed to protect itself, and disturbing another can never be mistaken for genuinely protecting them.
8. Section: Explaining the Meaning Begins — One Should Protect Oneself
Here, as said before, severing every affliction through drawing near a good teacher and the rest is called protecting oneself.
此中如前由親近等斷諸煩惱,名當自護。
Here, as said before, severing every affliction through drawing near a good teacher and the rest is called protecting oneself.
This opens explaining the meaning (卯二釋義2), the second of manifesting the fault of failing to protect's two matters, beginning with one should protect oneself (辰一當自護) — genuine self-protection, as established throughout this treatise, comes through drawing near a good spiritual friend, hearing the true dharma, giving principled attention, and practicing in accordance with the dharma, severing affliction at its root; the 披尋記 confirms this same fourfold sequence as the very cause of guarding against an unfortunate destiny's fault.
9. Section: One Should Protect Others Begins — Marking the Name
From this point on, taking this severance as cause, not disturbing others and the rest is called protecting others.
從此已後,由斷為因,不惱他等,名當護他。
From this point on, taking this severance as cause, not disturbing others and the rest is called protecting others.
This opens one should protect others (辰二當護他2), the second of explaining the meaning's two matters, beginning with marking the name (巳一標名) — protecting oneself through severing affliction naturally flows outward into protecting others as well, since a mind no longer disturbed by its own defilement no longer disturbs those around it.
10. Section: Explaining the Meaning Begins — Through Being Without Aversion and Without Harmfulness
One should know that, here, being without aversion and without harmfulness is the meaning of being without disturbance.
應知此中,無瞋無害,是無惱義。
One should know that, here, being without aversion and without harmfulness is the meaning of being without disturbance.
This opens explaining the meaning (巳二釋義2), the second of one should protect others' two matters, beginning with through being without aversion and without harmfulness (午一由無瞋無害) — a mind free of aversion and free of the wish to harm is, by that very freedom, incapable of disturbing another.
11. Section: Through Sympathetic Concern for All Begins — Directly Manifesting This Meaning
Giving rise, without any personal condition, to the two minds of benefit and ease; giving rise, without any personal condition, to the two minds of loving-kindness and compassion — one should know that this is the meaning of sympathetic concern. Because of this sympathetic concern, one does not disturb others.
無緣而起利樂二心,無緣而起慈悲二心,當知如此是哀愍義。由哀愍故,不惱於他。
Giving rise, without any personal condition, to the two minds of benefit and ease; giving rise, without any personal condition, to the two minds of loving-kindness and compassion — one should know that this is the meaning of sympathetic concern. Because of this sympathetic concern, one does not disturb others.
This opens through sympathetic concern for all (午二由一切哀愍2), the second of explaining the meaning's two matters, beginning with directly manifesting this meaning (未一正顯此義) — toward hostile, neutral, and dear beings alike, without regard to any personal cause, one gives rise to the wish for their benefit and ease, and to loving-kindness and compassion — the very meaning of sympathetic concern, which by its nature cannot disturb another. Master Cháng Bǎi distinguishes three levels of loving-kindness: sentient-being-conditioned kindness (an ordinary being's initial practice, regarding every being as a former parent across beginningless rebirths); dharma-conditioned kindness (a śrāvaka's realization that beings are merely the five aggregates, with no real striker or struck, beater or beaten); and unconditioned great kindness (a bodhisattva's embrace of every being as not separate from one's own mind — the same-essence great compassion).
12. Section: Setting Out Its Reversal, Closing "Through Sympathetic Concern for All," "Explaining the Meaning," "One Should Protect Others," "Explaining the Meaning," "Manifesting the Fault of Failing to Protect," and "The False Teacher's Dwelling" Entirely
Therefore one should know that sympathetic concern for all beings is the very reverse of that defiled disturbance.
是故當知,一切哀愍與彼相違。
Therefore one should know that sympathetic concern for all beings is the very reverse of that defiled disturbance.
With this, setting out its reversal (未二出彼相違) closes entirely, closing through sympathetic concern for all (午二由一切哀愍2: 正顯此義/出彼相違) entirely, closing explaining the meaning (巳二釋義2: 由無瞋無害/由一切哀愍) entirely, closing **one should protect others (辰二當護他2: 標名/釋義) entirely**, closing explaining the meaning (卯二釋義2: 當自護/當護他) entirely, closing **manifesting the fault of failing to protect (寅二明不護失2: 標失/釋義) entirely**, closing **the false teacher's dwelling (丑一邪師住2: 明專自利/明不護失), the first of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, entirely** — sympathetic concern for every being stands in direct contrast to the defiled disturbance that opened this section. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this teaching to a companion sūtra: an acrobat tells his apprentice that each should watch out for the other while performing atop a pole, so both profit from their shared act; the apprentice objects that each should instead watch out for himself alone, so each descends safely — and the Buddha confirms the apprentice's wisdom, teaching that protecting oneself from affliction is itself the truest way of protecting others, since one free of affliction cannot disturb anyone, and calling every monk to cultivate the four foundations of mindfulness as both self-protection and protection of others at once.
13. Section: The Snow Mountain Begins — Comparing to Skillful Liberation Begins — Marking and Listing the Three Grounds
Further, one should know that the snow mountain is a metaphor for the Buddha's well-taught dharma and discipline; here, briefly, three parts can be found: first, the ground of the one beyond training; second, the ground of the trainee; third, the ground of the ordinary being.
復次,應知雪山喻佛善說法毗奈耶,此中略有三分可得。一、無學地,二、有學地,三、異生地。
Further, one should know that the snow mountain is a metaphor for the Buddha's well-taught dharma and discipline; here, briefly, three parts can be found: first, the ground of the one beyond training; second, the ground of the trainee; third, the ground of the ordinary being.
This opens the snow mountain (丑二雪山2), the second of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, named by the verse's first phrase's second half "the snow mountain" (邪師住雪山), beginning with comparing to skillful liberation (寅一喻善解脫2), beginning with marking and listing the three grounds (卯一標列三地) — the Buddha's own well-taught dharma is likened to a great snow mountain, its three elevations corresponding to the arhat's ground beyond training (the summit, where neither monkey nor hunter can reach), the trainee's ground (the middle slopes, where the monkey but not the hunter can still be found), and the ordinary being's ground (the foothills, where both freely roam).
14. Section: Correlating and Explaining Their Marks Begins — Within the Ground of the One Beyond Training
The monkey is a metaphor for the various minds conjoined with unprincipled attention; the hunter is a metaphor for Māra. Within the ground of the one beyond training, neither of these is able to operate.
猿猴喻彼非理作意諸相應心,獵人喻魔,於無學地俱不能行。
The monkey is a metaphor for the various minds conjoined with unprincipled attention; the hunter is a metaphor for Māra. Within the ground of the one beyond training, neither of these is able to operate.
This opens correlating and explaining their marks (卯二配釋其相3), the second of comparing to skillful liberation's two matters, a threefold structure, beginning with within the ground of the one beyond training (辰一於無學地) — the monkey's restless leaping stands for unprincipled attention's every conjoined mind; the hunter stalking it stands for Māra, disturbing body and mind, obstructing wholesome dharmas, and ruining flourishing states. The arhat, having attained the wisdom of exhaustion and the wisdom of no-further-arising, is reached by neither.
15. Section: Within the Ground of the Trainee
Within the ground of the trainee, up through the non-returner, only the monkey-like mind conjoined with unprincipled attention is alone able to go there; it is not a place where the hunter-like Māra is able to operate.
於有學地乃至不還,唯有非理作意相應猿猴喻心獨一能往,非獵人喻魔所能行。
Within the ground of the trainee, up through the non-returner, only the monkey-like mind conjoined with unprincipled attention is alone able to go there; it is not a place where the hunter-like Māra is able to operate.
This opens within the ground of the trainee (辰二於有學地), the second — the trainee, from stream-entry through non-return, has already directly realized the noble truths and attained non-discriminating wisdom, severing every discursively-arisen affliction, but the innate afflictions still remain, like a lone monkey able to roam the mountain's deep middle slopes where no hunter ever ventures.
16. Section: Within the Ground of the Ordinary Being
Within the ground of the ordinary being, both of these are able to operate.
於異生地二俱能行。
Within the ground of the ordinary being, both of these are able to operate.
This opens within the ground of the ordinary being (辰三於異生地) — an ordinary being, unable to give principled attention when facing objects and still subject to Māra's manifest activity, dwells at the mountain's very foothills, where both monkey and hunter freely appear, mind not yet purified. Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows — comparing to skillful liberation's own further matter (寅二, presumably setting out the absence of liberation) — before further closure is claimed.
17. Section: Setting Out the Absence of Liberation, Closing "The Snow Mountain" Entirely
Further, the various foolish ones must observe a further object in order to leave a given object; pursuing one further object after another, they remain bound by that further object — therefore, toward these objects, they do not attain liberation.
又諸愚夫,要觀餘境能出餘境,追求餘境餘境所縛,是故於境不得解脫。
Further, the various foolish ones must observe a further object in order to leave a given object; pursuing one further object after another, they remain bound by that further object — therefore, toward these objects, they do not attain liberation.
With this, setting out the absence of liberation (寅二出不解脫) closes entirely, closing **the snow mountain (丑二雪山2: 喻善解脫/出不解脫), the second of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, entirely** — an ordinary being pursuing the mundane path of meditation must always observe a still-higher, purer object (the first dhyāna's own faults driving one toward the second, and so on) merely to leave the ground below, yet remains bound within the three realms regardless of how high the ascent goes, since the underlying view of a real body is never actually severed. Master Cháng Bǎi elaborates the mountain's three elevations once more (the arhat's summit reached by neither monkey nor hunter; the trainee's middle slopes reached only by the monkey; the ordinary being's foothills reached by both), then turns to the companion sūtra's own vivid image: a foolish monkey, its hand caught in sticky pitch, tries to free itself by stamping with its feet, only to become caught by all four limbs at once — just as an ordinary being, failing to give principled attention, guards neither the sense-doors within nor the body without, becomes bound by the five desires, follows wherever Māra leads, and abandons the very contemplation of the four foundations of mindfulness that alone could free it. The Buddha calls every being to progress, through the four foundations rightly practiced, from the trainee's own attainment onward to the arhat's deep, mountain-summit liberation.
18. Section: Exhortation Begins — Setting Out the Four Meanings
Further, through hearing the true dharma, upholding it, observing its meaning, and practicing in accordance with the dharma, in their proper sequence, one should know that exhortation and transformation establish four meanings.
復次,由於正法聽聞、受持、觀察義理、法隨法行,如其次第,應知勸化安立四義。
Further, through hearing the true dharma, upholding it, observing its meaning, and practicing in accordance with the dharma, in their proper sequence, one should know that exhortation and transformation establish four meanings.
This opens exhortation (丑三勸勉2), the third of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, named by the verse's second phrase "exhortation, and being bound to purity" (勸勉繫屬淨), beginning with setting out the four meanings (寅一出四義) — four terms correlate exactly to the fourfold sequence of hearing, upholding, observing meaning, and practicing accordingly: exhortation (urging a being to hear the true dharma), transformation (taming affliction as the dharma is upheld in mind), settling (placing the mind within the object of observed meaning), and establishing (founding the pure cause and effect of practicing in accordance with the dharma, accomplishing nirvāṇa's own merit) — the same fourfold structure the Foundation Section, fascicle 43, identifies as a bodhisattva's own natural conduct of benefiting others.
19. Section: Elaborating the Three Powers Begins — Marking and Listing
There are, further, three dharmas which are able to sever every supreme, sublime bond of sexual craving, let alone the various baser bonds of sense-desire craving. What are the three? First, the power of diligence; second, the power of freedom from heedlessness; third, the power of the remedy.
復有三法,尚能斷除一切勝妙婬欲貪纏,況乎鄙劣諸欲貪纏。何等為三?一、精進力,二、不放逸力,三、對治力。
There are, further, three dharmas which are able to sever every supreme, sublime bond of sexual craving, let alone the various baser bonds of sense-desire craving. What are the three? First, the power of diligence; second, the power of freedom from heedlessness; third, the power of the remedy.
This opens elaborating the three powers (寅二廣三力3), the second of exhortation's two matters, beginning with marking and listing (卯一標列) — three powers, if genuinely accomplished, are strong enough to sever even the most refined bond of sexual craving, let alone lesser sense-desires: the power of diligence, the power of freedom from heedlessness, and the power of the remedy.
20. Section: Correlating and Explaining
Through the power of diligence, what has already arisen is made not to abide firmly. Through the remaining two powers, what has not yet arisen is made not to arise.
由精進力,其已生者令不堅住。由餘二力,其未生者令不得生。
Through the power of diligence, what has already arisen is made not to abide firmly. Through the remaining two powers, what has not yet arisen is made not to arise.
This opens correlating and explaining (卯二配釋), the second of elaborating the three powers' three matters — diligence uproots evil already present before it can take firm hold, while freedom from heedlessness and the remedy together forestall evil not yet arisen and sustain wholesome dharmas already present or newly arising — the same fourfold task the four right efforts name.
21. Section: The Concluding Statement Manifesting the Meaning, Closing "Exhortation" Entirely
Thus the practitioner diligently cultivates right conduct, in order to sever what evil has already arisen, and in order to make what has not yet arisen not arise.
如是行者勤修正行,為欲斷除已生惡故,及未生者令不生故。
Thus the practitioner diligently cultivates right conduct, in order to sever what evil has already arisen, and in order to make what has not yet arisen not arise.
With this, the concluding statement manifesting the meaning (卯三結顯) closes entirely, closing elaborating the three powers (寅二廣三力3: 標列/配釋/結顯) entirely, closing **exhortation (丑三勸勉2: 出四義/廣三力), the third of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, entirely** — diligent cultivation of the four foundations, sustained by these three powers, severs both present and future evil. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this teaching to three companion sūtras: one in which the Buddha instructs Ānanda that young monks, trainees, and even arhats alike should all be guided toward the four foundations of mindfulness; one occasioned by the Buddha's own sighting of the courtesan Āmrapālī from a distance, in which he warns the assembly, through the simile of a man forced to carry a bowl brimful of oil past a beautiful dancer under threat of instant beheading should a single drop spill, that a monk must guard the mind just as single-mindedly, never letting the five sense-objects distract from the body's own contemplation; and a closing verse urging the assembly to hold the four foundations as one holds that same oil bowl, since only sustained, undistracted attention — never a heedless one — can reach the sublime, subtle state beyond craving, aversion, and delusion.
22. Section: Being Bound to Purity Begins — Pointing to the Mark of Cultivation
Further, cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness with earnest gravity should be known in its marks as in the Śrāvaka Ground.
復次,於四念住殷重修習,如聲聞地應知其相。
Further, cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness with earnest gravity should be known in its marks as in the Śrāvaka Ground.
This opens being bound to purity (丑四繫屬2), the fourth of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, named by the verse's second phrase's second half "being bound to purity" (勸勉繫屬淨), beginning with pointing to the mark of cultivation (寅一指修相) — cultivating the four foundations with earnest gravity is, once again, pointed to the Śrāvaka Ground's own fuller treatment.
23. Section: Manifesting Being Bound Begins — Distinguishing by the Three Realms Begins — Being Bound to Māra
Being bound to Māra means being within the desire realm; this, the non-returner's fruit is able to transcend.
繫屬魔者,謂在欲界,此不還果即能超度。
Being bound to Māra means being within the desire realm; this, the non-returner's fruit is able to transcend.
This opens manifesting being bound (寅二明繫屬2), the second of being bound to purity's two matters, beginning with distinguishing by the three realms (卯一約三界辨2), beginning with being bound to Māra (辰一繫屬魔) — craving, Māra's own domain, binds beings within the desire realm; the non-returner (the third fruit) has already transcended this particular bondage.
24. Section: Being Bound to Death, Closing "Distinguishing by the Three Realms" Entirely
Being bound to death means from the desire realm up through the peak of existence; this, only the arhat is able to transcend.
繫屬死者,謂從欲界乃至有頂,此阿羅漢乃能超度。
Being bound to death means from the desire realm up through the peak of existence; this, only the arhat is able to transcend.
With this, being bound to death (辰二繫屬死) closes entirely, closing distinguishing by the three realms (卯一約三界辨2: 繫屬魔/繫屬死) entirely — every being throughout the three realms, so long as birth continues, remains bound to death; only the arhat, who takes no further rebirth, transcends this bondage entirely. Naming it "bound to death" rather than "bound to birth" itself signals the endless continuation of rebirth after death, which only the arhat's own finality brings to a close.
25. Section: Distinguishing by Way of Persons Begins — Setting Out the Distinctions Begins — The Impure
Those spoken of as the various impure beings mean the various ordinary beings.
言不清淨諸有情者,謂諸異生。
Those spoken of as the various impure beings mean the various ordinary beings.
This opens distinguishing by way of persons (卯二約有情辨2), the second of manifesting being bound's two matters, beginning with setting out the distinctions (辰一出差別3), a threefold structure, beginning with the impure (巳一不清淨) — ordinary beings, still carrying every affliction of view and craving throughout the three realms, are called impure.
26. Section: The Pure
Those spoken of as pure mean the various trainees.
言清淨者,謂諸有學。
Those spoken of as pure mean the various trainees.
This opens the pure (巳二清淨), the second — trainees, from stream-entry onward, have already severed every discursively-arisen affliction; though innate afflictions of varying subtlety still remain depending on their stage, they are, relative to the ordinary being, called pure.
27. Section: Bright and Pure, Closing "Setting Out the Distinctions" Entirely
Those spoken of as bright and pure mean the various ones beyond training.
言鮮白者,謂諸無學。
Those spoken of as bright and pure mean the various ones beyond training.
With this, bright and pure (巳三鮮白) closes entirely, closing setting out the distinctions (辰一出差別3: 不清淨/清淨/鮮白) entirely — sustained, thoroughgoing purity is called bright and pure; unlike the trainee's own purity, which has only cleared away the coarser afflictions, the arhat alone is purified to the very end.
28. Section: Elaborating on Purity Begins — Setting Out the Four Confirmed Purities
There are, further, four confirmed purities, which are able to make the impure pure, and the already pure bright and pure.
復有四種證淨,未清淨者能令清淨,已清淨者能令鮮白。
There are, further, four confirmed purities, which are able to make the impure pure, and the already pure bright and pure.
This opens elaborating on purity (辰二廣清淨2), the second of distinguishing by way of persons' two matters, beginning with setting out the four confirmed purities (巳一出四證淨) — the four confirmed purities toward the Buddha, dharma, saṅgha, and precepts, cultivated through the four foundations of mindfulness, bring the impure to purity and carry the already pure onward to the arhat's own bright, thoroughgoing purity.
29. Section: Distinguishing Its Stages, Closing "Elaborating on Purity," "Distinguishing by Way of Persons," "Manifesting Being Bound," and "Being Bound to Purity" Entirely
One should know that, here, the higher trainees are called pure, and the lower trainees are called impure, since they, through the path of cultivation, are not yet pure. The rest is as said before.
當知此中,上諸有學說名清淨,下諸有學名不清淨,彼由修道未清淨故。
One should know that, here, the higher trainees are called pure, and the lower trainees are called impure, since they, through the path of cultivation, are not yet pure.
餘如前說。
The rest is as said before.
With this, distinguishing its stages (巳二辨其分位) closes entirely, closing elaborating on purity (辰二廣清淨2: 出四證淨/辨其分位) entirely, closing **distinguishing by way of persons (卯二約有情辨2: 出差別/廣清淨) entirely**, closing **manifesting being bound (寅二明繫屬2: 約三界辨/約有情辨) entirely**, closing **being bound to purity (丑四繫屬2: 指修相/明繫屬), the fourth of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, entirely** — even among trainees, purity admits degrees: the higher trainee (the non-returner) is called pure, while the lower trainees (stream-enterer and once-returner), not yet free of desire-realm affliction through the path of cultivation, are called impure relative to the non-returner — though both remain pure relative to the ordinary being, and both remain impure relative to the arhat's own bright, final purity, per the 披尋記's own distinction of upper and lower trainee stages within the four confirmed purities. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this teaching to a substantial cluster of companion sūtras: the monk Utkaṭa's threefold petition to the Buddha, answered with the instruction to first purify one's own precepts and straighten one's own view before taking up the four foundations of mindfulness, after which he attained arhatship; the monk Vāhika's parallel teaching, adding that this same purification overcomes every class of Māra in turn (the aggregates, affliction, death, and the heavenly Māra); Aniruddha's question on how a trainee still short of security should proceed (through the very same four foundations); and Ānanda's own exchange with Udāyin on why the Buddha, despite having realized ultimate truth directly, nonetheless dwells at length on the merit of precepts — because purified precepts are themselves the necessary foundation for the four foundations of mindfulness's own cultivation. Several shorter companion sūtras follow in immediate succession, each simply reaffirming that sustained cultivation of the four foundations yields non-retrogression, purification, crossing to nirvāṇa's far shore, and, ultimately, arhatship itself — echoing the teaching that all the Buddha's teachings, however many, can be summarized as the four foundations of mindfulness alone.
30. Section: Purity's Gradual Sequence Begins — Marking and Listing the Five Kinds
Further, cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness, one should know there are, briefly, five gradual stages: first, the increasing power of faith, pure going forth; second, restraint through precepts; third, restraint through the sense-faculties; fourth, delight in seclusion; fifth, purity from the hindrances.
復次,修四念住,應知略有五種漸次。一、信增上力,清淨出家;二、戒律儀;三、根律儀;四、樂遠離;五、蓋清淨。
Further, cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness, one should know there are, briefly, five gradual stages: first, the increasing power of faith, pure going forth; second, restraint through precepts; third, restraint through the sense-faculties; fourth, delight in seclusion; fifth, purity from the hindrances.
This opens purity's gradual sequence (丑五淨漸次2), the fifth of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, named by the verse's second phrase's third word and the third phrase's first word "purity...the gradual sequence" (勸勉繫屬淨...漸次戒圓滿), beginning with marking and listing the five kinds (寅一標列五種) — five stages unfold in order: faith's increasing power leading to a pure going-forth (never fleeing debts or taxes, but genuinely aspiring to seek and to save); precepts received, studied, and upheld (monks devoting their first five years, nuns their first six, chiefly to the monastic code, purifying body, speech, and mind); restraint of the six sense-faculties (guarding the mind, the source from which every dharma arises or ceases, through sustained right knowledge in every activity); delight in seclusion (bodily, mental, and physical seclusion — dwelling apart from crowds, free of scattered thought, cultivating only wholesome, beneficial attention); and purity from the five hindrances (craving, ill will, torpor-and-sleep, restlessness-and-worry, doubt — severed, then progressively purified, enabling calm-abiding and, within it, insight into ultimate truth).
31. Section: Distinguishing "Not for the Householder," Closing "Purity's Gradual Sequence" Entirely
Householders, though they may repeatedly cultivate the foundations of mindfulness, attain pure faith, and become pure of the hindrances, nevertheless lack the precincts of training; one should know that their cultivation does not reach completion.
諸在家者,雖復數數修諸念住,獲得淨信,諸蓋清淨,然闕學處,當知所修不得圓滿。
Householders, though they may repeatedly cultivate the foundations of mindfulness, attain pure faith, and become pure of the hindrances, nevertheless lack the precincts of training; one should know that their cultivation does not reach completion.
With this, distinguishing "not for the householder" (寅二簡非在家) closes entirely, closing **purity's gradual sequence (丑五淨漸次2: 標列五種/簡非在家), the fifth of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, entirely** — a householder may indeed attain pure faith and freedom from the hindrances, but, lacking the precincts of monastic training that householders are not bound by, cannot bring this gradual sequence to full completion. Master Cháng Bǎi traces each of the five stages to its own companion sūtra passage: pure faith leading to going forth, free of desire's entangling cords; precepts as the traffic light that tells a practitioner when to go and when to stop; the six sense-faculties guarded so that whatever the eyes see becomes an occasion for mindfulness of the Three Jewels; delight in seclusion, sitting joyfully apart under a tree or in an empty room; and the five hindrances purified by stages — first severed, then progressively refined into full purity.
32. Section: The Precepts' Fullness Begins — Marking
Further, through three causes and conditions, one should know that a monk endowed with precepts brings the fullness of restrained conduct and pure livelihood to completion.
復次,由三因緣,具戒苾芻當知禁戒淨命圓滿。
Further, through three causes and conditions, one should know that a monk endowed with precepts brings the fullness of restrained conduct and pure livelihood to completion.
This opens the precepts' fullness (丑六戒圓滿4), the sixth of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, named by the verse's third phrase's second half "the precepts' fullness" (漸次戒圓滿), beginning with marking (寅一標) — three causes and conditions bring a precept-endowed monk's restrained conduct and pure livelihood (all requisites obtained through blameless means) to full completion.
33. Section: Questioning
What are the three?
云何為三?
What are the three?
This opens questioning (寅二徵), the second of the precepts' fullness's four matters.
34. Section: Listing
First, fullness of conduct; second, fullness of what is taken up; third, fullness of what is used.
一、所行圓滿,二、攝取圓滿,三、受用圓滿。
First, fullness of conduct; second, fullness of what is taken up; third, fullness of what is used.
This opens listing (寅三列), the third of the precepts' fullness's four matters — a precept-endowed monk examines his own purity through three lenses: whether his own conduct is blameless, whether what he takes up is pure, and whether what he actually uses is pure.
35. Section: Explaining Begins — Fullness of Conduct
Fullness of conduct means being entirely free from buying and selling, up through harming, binding, severing limbs, striking, and massaging others, and every such matter.
所行圓滿者,謂從買賣,乃至害、縛、斷截、撾打、揣摩等事,皆悉遠離。
Fullness of conduct means being entirely free from buying and selling, up through harming, binding, severing limbs, striking, and massaging others, and every such matter.
This opens explaining (寅四釋3), the fourth and final of the precepts' fullness's matters, beginning with fullness of conduct (卯一所行圓滿) — a monk's conduct is full when free of commerce and of every violent or improper act toward others' bodies. The Śrāvaka Ground, fascicle 22, frames this instead as avoiding five improper places (a herald's house, a courtesan's house, a wine-seller's house, a king's palace, and an outcaste's or executioner's house) while otherwise moving about blamelessly at the right time — Master Cháng Bǎi notes this passage's own "fullness of conduct" corresponds instead to that other passage's "moving about blamelessly at the right time," while the Śrāvaka Ground's own "fullness of conduct" corresponds to avoiding the five improper places named there.
36. Section: Fullness of What Is Taken Up
Fullness of what is taken up means being entirely free from taking up elephants, horses, and the like, up through taking up unhusked grain and every such matter.
攝取圓滿者,謂於攝取象馬等事,乃至攝取生穀等事,皆悉遠離。
Fullness of what is taken up means being entirely free from taking up elephants, horses, and the like, up through taking up unhusked grain and every such matter.
This opens fullness of what is taken up (卯二攝取圓滿), the second — keeping livestock (elephants, horses, cattle, sheep, chickens, pigs, dogs, cats) easily breeds attachment and is therefore forbidden to monastics; taking up unhusked grain, requiring hours of hulling before it can be eaten, likewise wastes practice time. Neither adorns the path of precepts, concentration, and wisdom, and both are therefore impure to take up — detailed further, per Master Cháng Bǎi, in the Ground of Investigation and Analysis's own treatment of the Śrāvaka and Solitary-Realizer Grounds, fascicle 68, under "unadorned."
37. Section: Fullness of What Is Used, Closing "Explaining" and "The Precepts' Fullness" Entirely
Fullness of what is used means that clothing merely covers the body, and food merely fills the stomach, and one is thereby satisfied; toward every surplus possession, eating at the wrong time, and the like, one is entirely free.
受用圓滿者,謂衣僅蔽身,食纔充腹,便生喜足。於餘長物、非時食等,皆悉遠離。
Fullness of what is used means that clothing merely covers the body, and food merely fills the stomach, and one is thereby satisfied; toward every surplus possession, eating at the wrong time, and the like, one is entirely free.
With this, fullness of what is used (卯三受用圓滿) closes entirely, closing explaining (寅四釋3: 所行圓滿/攝取圓滿/受用圓滿) entirely, closing **the precepts' fullness (丑六戒圓滿4: 標/徵/列/釋), the sixth of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, entirely** — clothing enough only to cover the body and food enough only to sustain it, with contentment at even the barest provision and complete freedom from surplus possessions or eating outside the proper time, brings a monk's restrained conduct and pure livelihood to their full completion.
38. Section: The Ear of Grain Begins — Marking the Distinction
Further, body and the rest's four dharmas are like four great roads; the unprincipled attention that arises toward them is like wrongly praying for an ear of rice or wheat grain; the principled attention that arises toward them is like rightly praying for an ear of rice or wheat grain.
復次,身等四法如四大路,於彼所生非理作意,如邪祈願稻穀麥穗;於彼所生如理作意,如正祈願稻穀麥穗。
Further, body and the rest's four dharmas are like four great roads; the unprincipled attention that arises toward them is like wrongly praying for an ear of rice or wheat grain; the principled attention that arises toward them is like rightly praying for an ear of rice or wheat grain.
This opens the ear of grain (丑七穗2), the seventh of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, named by the verse's fourth phrase's first word "the ear of grain" (穗成就為後), beginning with marking the distinction (寅一標差別) — body, feeling, mind, and dharmas are the shared ground everyone stands on, like four great roads; misperceiving them (taking the impure body for pure, the selfless for possessing self) is like praying wrongly for a harvest — even with seed in the ground, without sun, air, water, and fertilizer, no ripened ear of grain will ever appear. 攝異門分, fascicle 84, is cited on affliction itself as a stump or stubble left in the field, causing ever-deepening, self-perpetuating growth and rendering body and mind incapable, like salt-poisoned soil unfit for any planting at all. Conversely, principled attention toward these same four is like praying rightly: the causes for purity are properly gathered, and a pure fruit is certain to follow — a practitioner who instead clings to unprincipled thought only continues circling further into saṃsāra.
39. Section: Manifesting the Outflows, Closing "The Ear of Grain" Entirely
One should know that the desire realm is the unfixed ground, just like the skin; the form and formless realms are both fixed grounds, just like the flesh; ignorance is like the blood. Within the three realms, through the three outflows, there is the meaning of trickling.
當知欲界是不定地,猶如其皮;色無色界俱是定地,猶如其肉;無明如血。於三界中,由三種漏有淋漏義。
One should know that the desire realm is the unfixed ground, just like the skin; the form and formless realms are both fixed grounds, just like the flesh; ignorance is like the blood. Within the three realms, through the three outflows, there is the meaning of trickling.
With this, manifesting the outflows (寅二明有漏) closes entirely, closing **the ear of grain (丑七穗2: 標差別/明有漏) entirely** — the desire realm's affliction, coarse and readily severed through principled attention, is like grime on the skin; the form and formless realms' subtler, meditation-linked affliction (desire's outflow only temporarily suppressed, its seed unsevered) sinks deeper, like flesh; and ignorance, pervading every one of the three realms alike, is deepest of all, like blood filling the whole body — the three outflows (of desire, of existence, of ignorance) that keep every unliberated being trickling, waterlogged, unable to dwell at ease, so long as their seeds remain. The Ground with Both Investigation and Analysis, fascicle 8, defines an outflow simply as that which keeps the mind flowing outward; 攝異門分, fascicle 84, as that which is able to give rise to future birth — together naming affliction's power to detain beings within the three realms and obstruct their approach to liberation. The 披尋記 confirms the skin-flesh-blood simile maps precisely onto desire's outflow (欲漏), existence's outflow (有漏), and ignorance's outflow (無明漏) in turn, graded by their coarseness or subtlety, both within and across the three realms.
40. Section: Accomplishment Begins — Generally Marking and Distinguishing
Further, as said before, toward every immeasurable, evil, unwholesome dharma such as craving and the rest — if one possesses these through two causes and conditions, one is unable to cultivate the four foundations of mindfulness; this does not mean everyone who possesses them in a general sense.
復次,如先所說所有貪等種種無量惡不善法,由二因緣若成就者,不能修習四種念住,非是一切泛成就者。
Further, as said before, toward every immeasurable, evil, unwholesome dharma such as craving and the rest — if one possesses these through two causes and conditions, one is unable to cultivate the four foundations of mindfulness; this does not mean everyone who possesses them in a general sense.
This opens accomplishment (丑八成就3), the eighth and final of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, named by the verse's fourth phrase's second half "accomplishment, coming last" (穗成就為後), beginning with generally marking and distinguishing (寅一總標簡) — merely possessing craving and the other unwholesome dharmas in some general sense does not by itself prevent cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness; only possessing them through two specific causes and conditions, unpacked in what follows, does. Per the 披尋記, this phrasing signals that possessing these unwholesome dharmas through any other cause and condition still leaves room for cultivating the four foundations. Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows before further closure is claimed.
41. Section: Separately Listing the Marks
What are the two? First, because the bonds of craving and the rest are manifestly present; second, because one does not see the fault in this bond.
云何為二?一、有貪等纏現前故;二、於此纏不見過故。
What are the two? First, because the bonds of craving and the rest are manifestly present; second, because one does not see the fault in this bond.
This opens separately listing the marks (寅二別列相), the second of accomplishment's three matters — two causes prevent cultivating the four foundations: affliction actively, forcefully present in the mind, unable to be first subdued; and, more insidiously, never recognizing that this affliction is a fault at all, so it goes untreated and, through repetition, hardens into settled habit.
42. Section: Explaining the Reason Begins — Through the Defiled Mind
Because the bond is manifestly present, defiling the mind, one is unable to cultivate.
纏現在前雜染心故,不能修習。
Because the bond is manifestly present, defiling the mind, one is unable to cultivate.
This opens explaining the reason (寅三釋所以2), the third of accomplishment's three matters, beginning with through the defiled mind (卯一由雜染心) — a mind actively agitated by present affliction cannot settle enough to cultivate. Per fascicle 8, a "bond" is so called because it repeatedly manifests; 攝異門分, fascicle 84, adds that its continuous, unbroken manifestation is precisely what earns the name, naming eight such bonds (shamelessness, lack of conscience, torpor, sleepiness, restlessness, remorse, envy, and stinginess) mapped onto four kinds of obstruction — shamelessness and lack of conscience obstructing the heightened precepts, torpor and sleepiness obstructing the heightened mind, restlessness and remorse obstructing the heightened wisdom's discernment, and envy and stinginess obstructing the mutual sharing of wealth and dharma among fellow practitioners.
43. Section: Through an Attached Nature Begins — Distinguishing the Mark
Though temporarily removed from it, because of an attached nature, not being free of longing, toward the various dharmas that accord with craving and the rest, the mind is scattered and agitated, constantly chasing after and sinking into them, forever disturbed by various kinds of discursive thought — therefore one is unable to cultivate the foundations of mindfulness.
雖暫遠離,性染著故,非無戀故,於能隨順貪等諸法,其心散動,常逐漂淪,種種尋思恆隨擾亂,是故不能修習念住。
Though temporarily removed from it, because of an attached nature, not being free of longing, toward the various dharmas that accord with craving and the rest, the mind is scattered and agitated, constantly chasing after and sinking into them, forever disturbed by various kinds of discursive thought — therefore one is unable to cultivate the foundations of mindfulness.
This opens through an attached nature (卯二由性染著2), the second of explaining the reason's two matters, beginning with distinguishing the mark (辰一辨相) — even someone temporarily free of an affliction's manifest activity, if the underlying attachment remains unaddressed, still carries a longing that keeps the mind scattered and chasing after alluring objects, disturbed by discursive thought regardless of the temporary respite; left unremedied long enough, this hardens into settled habit.
44. Section: Refuting the Objection, Closing "Through an Attached Nature," "Explaining the Reason," "Accomplishment," the Fourth Particular Verse, and the Foundations of Mindfulness in Their Complete Entirety
If this were not so, then everyone whose nature is not deeply attached ought likewise to be unable to cultivate the foundations of mindfulness. If this were the case, there could be no one at all capable of cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness.
若不爾者,諸有其性不深染著,皆應不能修習念住。若如是者,無容有能修四念住。
If this were not so, then everyone whose nature is not deeply attached ought likewise to be unable to cultivate the foundations of mindfulness. If this were the case, there could be no one at all capable of cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness.
With this, refuting the objection (辰二遮非) closes entirely, by way of a double-negative argument: were it true that anyone lacking deep attachment could still not cultivate the four foundations, then literally no one — not even the mildly, superficially afflicted — could ever cultivate them at all, which is absurd; therefore, one whose affliction, though still present at times, is recognized as faulty and kept from deepening into settled attachment remains genuinely capable of cultivation, even without yet severing its seed. With this, **explaining the reason (寅三釋所以2: 由雜染心/由性染著) closes entirely**, closing **accomplishment (丑八成就3: 總標簡/別列相/釋所以), the eighth and final of the fourth particular verse's eight sections, entirely**, closing **the fourth and final particular summary verse of the foundations of mindfulness's embrace (癸四第四嗢柁南2: 頌標列/長行釋) entirely**. Master Cháng Bǎi, citing Venerable Master Yìnshùn's note that the corresponding Chinese Saṃyukta Āgama sūtra (juan 25) is lost, but its likely content preserved via its Pāli parallels (Saṃyutta Nikāya 47.13, the Cunda Sutta, and 47.14, the Ukkacela Sutta), recounts: grieving deeply at Śāriputra's and Maudgalyāyana's own parinirvāṇa, Ānanda is consoled by the Buddha, who teaches that their five aggregates of dharma (precepts, concentration, wisdom, liberation, and the knowledge and vision of liberation) have not vanished along with them, any more than the thirty-seven factors of enlightenment themselves have vanished — for every conditioned thing, however cherished, is by nature bound to perish, just as a great tree's largest boughs fall first, or a great mountain's largest boulders crumble first, and just as Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana, the Buddha's own greatest śrāvaka disciples, entered nirvāṇa before the Buddha himself would. Every disciple, the Buddha teaches, should be their own island, their own refuge, and the dharma's own refuge, relying on nothing else — sustained diligent practice of the four foundations of mindfulness, cultivating right knowledge and right mindfulness while taming worldly craving and sorrow, is how the dharma is genuinely, personally realized.
With this section's closure, the foundations of mindfulness's embrace (念住攝) — the first of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics, spanning fascicles 97 and 98 in their entirety, all four particular summary verses (八/五/六/八 sections respectively, 27 sections in total across both fascicles) — closes in its complete entirety. The text now turns to the second great topic, the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power (正斷神足攝), taken together as a single combined topic.
45. Section: The Embrace of Right Effort and the Bases of Supernormal Power Begins — The Verse Marking and Listing
Further, a summary verse says: valor and strength, cultivation and equipoise; the alternate approach, and supernormal power, coming last.
復次,嗢柁南曰:
Further, a summary verse says:
勇力修等持 異門神通後
Valor and strength, cultivation and equipoise; the alternate approach, and supernormal power, coming last.
This opens **the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power (壬二正斷神足攝2), the second of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics** — named by the general summary verse's own first line "the foundations of mindfulness and right effort; supernormal bases" (念住與正斷 神足及根力), combining the four right efforts (正斷) and the four bases of supernormal power (神足) into a single treatment, since the two topics share a single half-verse in the overall structure — beginning with the verse marking and listing (癸一頌標列) — five matters unfold in the long-form explanation that follows: valor, strength, cultivation, equipoise, the alternate approach, and supernormal power (six terms across five sections, since the last two are treated together).
46. Section: The Long-Form Explanation Begins — Valor Begins — Pointing to Right Effort
One should know that the four right efforts are established, as already broadly distinguished in the Śrāvaka Ground.
應知建立四種正斷,如聲聞地已廣分別。
One should know that the four right efforts are established, as already broadly distinguished in the Śrāvaka Ground.
This opens the long-form explanation (癸二長行釋5), a fivefold structure, beginning with valor (子一勇2), named by the verse's first phrase "valor and strength" (勇力修等持), beginning with pointing to right effort (丑一指正斷) — the four right efforts (severing evil already arisen, preventing evil not yet arisen, cultivating good already arisen, and giving rise to good not yet arisen) are pointed to the Śrāvaka Ground, fascicle 29, for their fuller treatment.
47. Section: Explaining Diligence Begins — Setting Out the Fifth Phrase
Here, the fifth phrase of diligence, valor, is expounded.
此中宣說勇第五句。
Here, the fifth phrase of diligence, valor, is expounded.
This opens explaining diligence (丑二釋精進2), the second of valor's two matters, beginning with setting out the fifth phrase (寅一出第五句) — diligence, per 攝事分, fascicle 85, has five aspects: possessing vigor (resolving at the outset, like donning armor before battle, to cultivate the four foundations without fear); possessing exertion (sustaining the actual, uninterrupted practice of precepts, concentration, and wisdom); possessing valor (advancing courageously toward liberation, or even the Great Vehicle's own teaching, undeterred by failure); firmness and fierceness (undisturbed by cold, heat, insects, or any other bodily hardship); and not relinquishing the yoke toward every wholesome dharma (never settling for a small success, but continuing to press upward). This section treats specifically the fifth of these five, "valor" in its narrower sense.
48. Section: Explaining How the Name "Valor" Is Attained, Closing "Explaining Diligence" and "Valor" Entirely
What is called valor? It means, as said before, being able to bear every kind of suffering that arises from applying diligent effort, the suffering of exposure, the suffering of the elements' imbalance, and every kind of suffering arising from another's coarse, harsh, injurious speech and the like. Not regressing from or relinquishing the preparatory practice of cultivating right effort on account of these causes and conditions — this is therefore called valor.
云何名勇?謂如前說,堪能忍受發勤精進所生眾苦、諸淋漏苦、界不平苦、他麤惡言損惱等事所生眾苦。
What is called valor? It means, as said before, being able to bear every kind of suffering that arises from applying diligent effort, the suffering of exposure, the suffering of the elements' imbalance, and every kind of suffering arising from another's coarse, harsh, injurious speech and the like.
非此因緣退捨修習正斷加行,故名為勇。
Not regressing from or relinquishing the preparatory practice of cultivating right effort on account of these causes and conditions — this is therefore called valor.
With this, explaining how the name "valor" is attained (寅二釋得勇名) closes entirely, closing **explaining diligence (丑二釋精進2: 出第五句/釋得勇名) entirely**, closing **valor (子一勇2: 指正斷/釋精進), the first of the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power's five sections, entirely** — valor means bearing the fatigue of sustained effort, the exposure to wind, rain, cold, and heat that comes from dwelling without proper shelter, the bodily discomfort of the elements' imbalance, and the sting of another's envious, harsh speech, all without ever regressing from the preparatory practice of the right efforts. The 披尋記 notes the phrasing here closely parallels, with minor wording differences, an earlier passage in 攝事分, fascicle 95, and cautions that "trickling" (淋漏) in this context names exposure's own physical suffering, not the trickling of affliction discussed in fascicle 97 — the two meanings must not be conflated, since bearing affliction's own drift would wrongly imply tolerating unrestrained affliction rather than merely enduring hardship.
49. Section: Strength Begins — Pointing to the Bases of Supernormal Power
Further, one should know that the four bases of supernormal power are established, as already broadly distinguished in the Śrāvaka Ground.
復次,應知建立四種神足,如聲聞地已廣分別。
Further, one should know that the four bases of supernormal power are established, as already broadly distinguished in the Śrāvaka Ground.
This opens strength (子二力2), the second of the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power's five sections, named by the verse's first phrase's second half "strength" (勇力修等持), beginning with pointing to the bases of supernormal power (丑一指神足) — the four bases of supernormal power (accomplishment through aspiration's samādhi and the conduct of severance, through diligence's samādhi, through mind's samādhi, and through investigation's samādhi) are, once more, pointed to the Śrāvaka Ground, fascicle 29, for their fuller treatment.
50. Section: Briefly Explaining Strength Begins — Marking
Stated briefly, through four powers, the mind is sustained and brought to concentration; therefore the four bases of supernormal power are established.
若略說者,由四種力持心令定,是故建立四種神足。
Stated briefly, through four powers, the mind is sustained and brought to concentration; therefore the four bases of supernormal power are established.
This opens briefly explaining strength (丑二略說力5), the second of strength's two matters, beginning with marking (寅一標) — briefly summarized, four powers sustain and bring the mind to concentration, and it is on this basis that the four bases of supernormal power are established.
51. Section: Questioning
What are the four?
云何為四?
What are the four?
This opens questioning (寅二徵), the second of briefly explaining strength's five matters.
52. Section: Listing
First, the power of pure aspiration; second, the power of diligent application; third, the power of the mind's delight; fourth, the power of right wisdom.
一、淨意樂力,二、勤務力,三、心喜樂力,四、正智力。
First, the power of pure aspiration; second, the power of diligent application; third, the power of the mind's delight; fourth, the power of right wisdom.
This opens listing (寅三列), the third of briefly explaining strength's five matters — pure aspiration toward concentration, diligent application in pursuing it, the mind's own delight once settled within it, and the right wisdom that discerns what remains to be remedied together constitute the four powers that establish the bases of supernormal power.
53. Section: Explaining Begins — Through the First Power
One should know that, here, through the first power, one gives rise to a delighted wish toward samādhi, and, in order to realize it, cultivates diligent application.
當知此中,由第一力,於三摩地發生樂欲,為證得故,修習勤務。
One should know that, here, through the first power, one gives rise to a delighted wish toward samādhi, and, in order to realize it, cultivates diligent application.
This opens explaining (寅四釋4), the fourth of briefly explaining strength's five matters, beginning with through the first power (卯一由第一力) — hearing the true dharma among wise fellow practitioners, a delighted, confident wish toward samādhi first arises, and, carefully attending to every requisite condition for its cultivation, one settles the mind diligently upon its object.
54. Section: Through the Second Power
Through the second power, the mind first settled upon its object is made stable.
由第二力,最初住心令其安定。
Through the second power, the mind first settled upon its object is made stable.
This opens through the second power (卯二由第二力), the second — diligent, sustained application of samādhi stabilizes the mind that has just begun to settle upon its object.
55. Section: Through the Third Power
Through the third power, the mind already settled in concentration no longer scatters or is agitated, and is not made to drift outward once again.
由第三力,已住定心無復散動,不令於外更復飄轉。
Through the third power, the mind already settled in concentration no longer scatters or is agitated, and is not made to drift outward once again.
This opens through the third power (卯三由第三力), the third — a mind already settled, such as within the preparatory stage of concentration, delights so fully in that stillness that it no longer drifts back outward toward the objects of the senses.
56. Section: Through the Fourth Power
Through the fourth power, one observes the affliction to be remedied within equipoise, truly knowing whether it is severed or not yet severed. Further, toward the marks of entering, abiding in, and emerging from equipoise, one is able to skillfully discern them. Thus, further, toward every mark belonging to calm-abiding and the rest, whatever secondary afflictions belong to calm-abiding or insight, and whatever is able to remedy those secondary afflictions, one truly knows all of it.
由第四力,觀察等持所治煩惱,於斷未斷如實了知。又於等持入、住、出相,能善了別。如是復於奢摩他等所有諸相,若奢摩他、毗鉢舍那諸隨煩惱,及隨煩惱能對治等,皆如實知。
Through the fourth power, one observes the affliction to be remedied within equipoise, truly knowing whether it is severed or not yet severed. Further, toward the marks of entering, abiding in, and emerging from equipoise, one is able to skillfully discern them. Thus, further, toward every mark belonging to calm-abiding and the rest, whatever secondary afflictions belong to calm-abiding or insight, and whatever is able to remedy those secondary afflictions, one truly knows all of it.
This opens through the fourth power (卯四由第四力), the fourth and final of explaining's matters — right wisdom discerns exactly which affliction within equipoise has, or has not, been severed, skillfully distinguishes the marks of entering, abiding in, and emerging from that equipoise, and truly knows every mark belonging to calm-abiding and insight alike, together with whatever secondary afflictions and remedies pertain to each. The Śrāvaka Ground identifies two such marks for each of calm-abiding and insight: an object-mark (the counterpart image of the known matter that each takes as its object) and a causal mark (calm-abiding serving as insight's own causal condition, and insight's preparatory practice serving as calm-abiding's own causal condition for future purity) — detailed further, per Master Cháng Bǎi, in the Śrāvaka Ground, fascicle 31. Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows — briefly explaining strength's own concluding matter (寅五結) — before further closure is claimed.
57. Section: The Concluding Statement, Closing "Briefly Explaining Strength" and "Strength" Entirely
For one who delights in equipoise, within equipoise, there is only this much task belonging to equipoise; beyond this, there is nothing further, whether excess or increase.
樂等持者,於等持中,但有爾所等持作事。除此更無若過若增。
For one who delights in equipoise, within equipoise, there is only this much task belonging to equipoise; beyond this, there is nothing further, whether excess or increase.
With this, the concluding statement (寅五結) closes entirely, closing briefly explaining strength (丑二略說力5: 標/徵/列/釋/結) entirely, closing **strength (子二力2: 指神足/略說力), the second of the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power's five sections, entirely** — these four powers (pure aspiration, diligent application, the mind's delight, right wisdom) exhaust the entire task involved in establishing the four bases of supernormal power (aspiration's, diligence's, mind's, and investigation's own samādhi-with-the-conduct-of-severance), with nothing more to add.
58. Section: Cultivation Begins — Briefly Marking and Listing
Further, through five causes and conditions, one should know the bases of supernormal power's brief mark of cultivation: first, through becoming free of calm-abiding's own class of secondary affliction; second, through becoming free of insight's own class of secondary affliction; third, through binding the mind to insight's own class of object; fourth, through binding the mind to calm-abiding's own class of object; fifth, through binding the mind to the object shared by both classes together.
復次,由五因緣,當知神足略修習相。一、由遠離奢摩他品隨煩惱故;二、由遠離毗鉢舍那品隨煩惱故;三、於毗鉢舍那品所緣境界繫縛心故;四、於奢摩他品所緣境界繫縛心故;五、俱於二品所緣境界繫縛心故。
Further, through five causes and conditions, one should know the bases of supernormal power's brief mark of cultivation: first, through becoming free of calm-abiding's own class of secondary affliction; second, through becoming free of insight's own class of secondary affliction; third, through binding the mind to insight's own class of object; fourth, through binding the mind to calm-abiding's own class of object; fifth, through binding the mind to the object shared by both classes together.
This opens cultivation (子三修4), the third of the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power's five sections, named by the verse's first phrase's third word "cultivation" (勇力修等持), beginning with briefly marking and listing (丑一略標列) — the first two of these five causes remedy the secondary afflictions specific to calm-abiding and to insight; the latter three establish the meditative perceptions proper to each and to both together.
59. Section: Separately Explaining the Marks Begins — The First Two Marks Begin — Setting Out the Nature Begins — Calm-Abiding's Own Secondary Affliction
One should know that, here, calm-abiding's own class of secondary affliction means the aspiration and the rest conjoined with laziness, and the aspiration and the rest conjoined with torpor and sleepiness. One should know that the aspiration and the rest conjoined with laziness is the very support for the aspiration and the rest conjoined with torpor and sleepiness.
應知此中,奢摩他品隨煩惱者,謂懈怠俱行欲等,及惛沈睡眠俱行欲等。當知懈怠俱行欲等,是惛沈睡眠俱行欲等所依止性。
One should know that, here, calm-abiding's own class of secondary affliction means the aspiration and the rest conjoined with laziness, and the aspiration and the rest conjoined with torpor and sleepiness. One should know that the aspiration and the rest conjoined with laziness is the very support for the aspiration and the rest conjoined with torpor and sleepiness.
This opens separately explaining the marks (丑二別釋相2), the second of cultivation's four matters, beginning with the first two marks (寅一初二相2), beginning with setting out the nature (卯一出體2), beginning with calm-abiding's own secondary affliction (辰一奢摩他品隨煩惱) — laziness (defined by the Compendium of Consciousness-Only as idleness in the cultivation and severance proper to wholesome and unwholesome dharmas, obstructing diligence and increasing defilement) is itself the underlying support for the still deeper affliction of torpor and sleepiness: a practitioner too lazy to diligently cultivate the four aspiration-diligence-mind-investigation samādhis will, even while formally seated, lose the object to torpor, and, if severe enough, to outright sleep. The 披尋記 confirms "aspiration and the rest" here abbreviates the same four samādhis named throughout, each of which can fall into this slack, unhurried laziness.
60. Section: Insight's Own Secondary Affliction, Closing "Setting Out the Nature" Entirely
Insight's own class of secondary affliction means the aspiration and the rest conjoined with restlessness, and the aspiration and the rest conjoined with the agitation of sublime desires. One should know that the aspiration and the rest conjoined with restlessness is the very support for the aspiration and the rest conjoined with the agitation of sublime desires.
毗鉢舍那品隨煩惱者,謂掉舉俱行欲等,及妙欲散動俱行欲等。當知掉舉俱行欲等,是妙欲散動俱行欲等所依止性。
Insight's own class of secondary affliction means the aspiration and the rest conjoined with restlessness, and the aspiration and the rest conjoined with the agitation of sublime desires. One should know that the aspiration and the rest conjoined with restlessness is the very support for the aspiration and the rest conjoined with the agitation of sublime desires.
With this, insight's own secondary affliction (辰二毗鉢舍那品隨煩惱) closes entirely, closing setting out the nature (卯一出體2: 奢摩他品隨煩惱/毗鉢舍那品隨煩惱) entirely — restlessness, an excited, elevated mind reminiscing over past pleasant sights, sounds, places, and companions rather than seeing every dharma as illusion-like, is itself the underlying support for the still deeper affliction of agitation toward "sublime" desires — the deluded conviction that the five sense-pleasures are genuinely pure and excellent, drawing the practitioner to actively long to see, hear, or touch them once again, obstructing concentration.
61. Section: Distinguishing the Differences Begins — Toward Calm-Abiding
Further, here, through the aspiration and the rest conjoined with laziness, calm-abiding's own class is caused to dwell in defilement, yet this is not able to make every calm-abiding entirely vanish. Through the aspiration and the rest conjoined with torpor and sleepiness, calm-abiding's own class is caused to dwell in defilement, and this is, further, able to make every calm-abiding entirely vanish.
又於此中,由懈怠俱行欲等,於奢摩他品令住雜染,然不能令諸奢摩他皆悉滅沒。由惛沈睡眠俱行欲等,於奢摩他品令住雜染,亦復能令諸奢摩他皆悉滅沒。
Further, here, through the aspiration and the rest conjoined with laziness, calm-abiding's own class is caused to dwell in defilement, yet this is not able to make every calm-abiding entirely vanish. Through the aspiration and the rest conjoined with torpor and sleepiness, calm-abiding's own class is caused to dwell in defilement, and this is, further, able to make every calm-abiding entirely vanish.
This opens distinguishing the differences (卯二料簡2), the second of the first two marks' two matters, beginning with toward calm-abiding (辰一於奢摩他) — laziness merely defiles calm-abiding, leaving the practitioner unable to progress diligently but not destroying the attainment outright; torpor and sleepiness, by contrast, blur and eventually erase the object of meditation entirely, extinguishing calm-abiding altogether rather than merely defiling it.
62. Section: Toward Insight, Closing "Distinguishing the Differences" and "The First Two Marks" Entirely
Through the aspiration and the rest conjoined with restlessness, insight's own class is caused to dwell in defilement, yet this is not able to make insight entirely vanish. The aspiration and the rest conjoined with the agitation of sublime desires, causing insight's own class to dwell in defilement, is also able to make every insight entirely vanish.
由掉舉俱行欲等,於毗鉢舍那品令住雜染,而不能令毗鉢舍那一切滅沒。妙欲散動俱行欲等,於毗鉢舍那品令住雜染,亦令一切毗鉢舍那皆悉滅沒。
Through the aspiration and the rest conjoined with restlessness, insight's own class is caused to dwell in defilement, yet this is not able to make insight entirely vanish. The aspiration and the rest conjoined with the agitation of sublime desires, causing insight's own class to dwell in defilement, is also able to make every insight entirely vanish.
With this, toward insight (辰二於毗鉢舍那) closes entirely, closing distinguishing the differences (卯二料簡2: 於奢摩他/於毗鉢舍那) entirely, closing **the first two marks (寅一初二相2: 出體/料簡) entirely** — restlessness merely defiles insight without destroying it outright, but agitation toward the five sense-pleasures — severe enough to draw the practitioner right off the cushion in outward pursuit — extinguishes insight entirely, exactly paralleling calm-abiding's own two-tier structure above.
63. Section: The Latter Three Marks Begin — Insight's Own Class of Object
Insight's own class of object means the perception of before and after. The distinctions of this perception should be known in its marks as in the Śrāvaka Ground.
毗鉢舍那品所緣境者,謂前後想。此想分別,如聲聞地應知其相。
Insight's own class of object means the perception of before and after. The distinctions of this perception should be known in its marks as in the Śrāvaka Ground.
This opens the latter three marks (寅二後三相3), the second of separately explaining the marks' two matters, beginning with insight's own class of object (卯一毗鉢舍那品所緣境) — the perception of before and after observes past or future conditioned formations from the vantage of present attention: "dwelling observes sitting" (present attention already arisen observing what is about to arise), "sitting observes lying down" (present attention observing what has already passed), and observing the immediately preceding moment of mind without any gap — detailed further, per Master Cháng Bǎi, in the Śrāvaka Ground, fascicle 28.
64. Section: Calm-Abiding's Own Class of Object
Calm-abiding's own class of object means the perception of above and below. This, too, should be known in its marks as before.
奢摩他品所緣境者,謂上下想。此亦如前應知其相。
Calm-abiding's own class of object means the perception of above and below. This, too, should be known in its marks as before.
This opens calm-abiding's own class of object (卯二奢摩他品所緣境), the second — the perception of above and below observes the body, from crown to sole, as filled throughout with every kind of impure substance (hair, body hair, nails, teeth, and the rest), the very contemplation of the body's own impurity that calm-abiding rests upon.
65. Section: The Object Shared by Both Classes, Closing "The Latter Three Marks" and "Separately Explaining the Marks" Entirely
The object shared by both classes means the perception of light. Toward what belongs to both classes, because of agitation, there is a cultivation of the mind conjoined with various images of light.
俱品所緣境者,謂光明想。彼於俱品由動搖故,有諸光影俱行心修。
The object shared by both classes means the perception of light. Toward what belongs to both classes, because of agitation, there is a cultivation of the mind conjoined with various images of light.
With this, the object shared by both classes (卯三俱品所緣境) closes entirely, closing the latter three marks (寅二後三相3: 毗鉢舍那品所緣境/奢摩他品所緣境/俱品所緣境) entirely, closing **separately explaining the marks (丑二別釋相2: 初二相/後三相) entirely** — the perception of light (whether the light that remedies darkness, such as sunlight, the body's own inward radiance, or the dharma's own light) accompanies the mind throughout both calm-abiding and insight alike, keeping either from being disturbed by torpor, sleepiness, or restlessness.
66. Section: Explaining the Difficult Point
Further, it is not that the aspiration and the rest is conjoined with laziness only in the sense of being conjoined with some further, separate laziness — this is called being conjoined with laziness; diligence, too, in just this way, can carry the meaning of being conjoined with laziness. That is, when diligence itself falls into slackness and slowness, and does not rightly apply itself to sustained, diligent effort, this is called being conjoined with laziness.
又非如欲等與餘懈怠相應,說名懈怠俱行;精進亦爾,得有懈怠共相應義。然即精進墮在慢緩,不正發勤精進相續,說名懈怠俱行。
Further, it is not that the aspiration and the rest is conjoined with laziness only in the sense of being conjoined with some further, separate laziness — this is called being conjoined with laziness; diligence, too, in just this way, can carry the meaning of being conjoined with laziness. That is, when diligence itself falls into slackness and slowness, and does not rightly apply itself to sustained, diligent effort, this is called being conjoined with laziness.
This opens explaining the difficult point (丑三隨難釋), the third of cultivation's four matters — even genuine diligence, if it slackens from its own former pace (practicing eight hours a day, say, and later only six), still counts as being "conjoined with laziness" in this more subtle sense. The 披尋記 clarifies that the "further" laziness named among the eight secondary afflictions (torpor, restlessness, faithlessness, laziness, heedlessness, forgetfulness, distraction, and incorrect knowledge) is being distinguished here from this different, relative sense of laziness — diligence merely slowed, not diligence entirely absent.
67. Section: The Concluding Statement Gathering Them Together, Closing "Cultivation" Entirely
Further, these five marks, one should know, entirely embrace every kind of cultivation. For one who delights in equipoise, through this, equipoise is swiftly brought to completion.
又此五相,當知總攝一切種修。樂等持者,由此等持速得成滿。
Further, these five marks, one should know, entirely embrace every kind of cultivation. For one who delights in equipoise, through this, equipoise is swiftly brought to completion.
With this, the concluding statement gathering them together (丑四結總攝) closes entirely, closing **cultivation (子三修4: 略標列/別釋相/隨難釋/結總攝), the third of the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power's five sections, entirely** — these five marks together embrace every kind of cultivation belonging to the bases of supernormal power, and mastering them brings equipoise swiftly to full completion. Master Cháng Bǎi recounts a Dharmapada story of forest-dwelling monks who, mistaking their newly attained concentration for arhatship, are sent by the Buddha to a charnel ground before being received back — there, calmly viewing decayed corpses at first, they are startled to find desire still stirring at the sight of a still-fresh one, and, illuminated by the Buddha's own light and gentle rebuke, recognize they are not yet free of craving and press on with impurity- and selflessness-contemplation until they finally attain liberation — the moral being that only honest, ongoing self-examination, never premature self-congratulation, uncovers a defilement still lying hidden.
68. Section: Equipoise and the Alternate Approach Begin — Setting Out the Distinctions Begins — General Marking
Further, toward the five places of liberation, in accordance with what is fitting, one should know the four heightened samādhis of aspiration and the rest.
復次,於五解脫處,如其所應,當知欲等增上四種三摩地。
Further, toward the five places of liberation, in accordance with what is fitting, one should know the four heightened samādhis of aspiration and the rest.
This opens equipoise and the alternate approach (子四等持異門2), the fourth of the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power's five sections, named by the verse's first phrase's fourth word and second phrase's first word "equipoise...the alternate approach" (勇力修等持 異門神通後), explaining the four samādhis through a different lens, beginning with setting out the distinctions (丑一出差別2), beginning with general marking (寅一總標) — five places yield liberation: hearing the true dharma with earnest reverence; expounding it to others; reciting it with sublime intonation; skillfully grasping and reflecting on an excellent samādhi-sign; and, having heard the dharma, dwelling alone in seclusion to reflect, weigh, and carefully observe it — the first three corresponding to hearing-wisdom, the fourth to thinking-wisdom, and the fifth to cultivation-wisdom, detailed further, per Master Cháng Bǎi, in the Compendium of Categories, fascicle 13. Each of the five follows the same pattern: right understanding of the dharma and its meaning gives rise to delight, delight to joy, joy to bodily ease, ease to bliss, bliss to concentration, concentration to true knowing and seeing, true knowing and seeing to weariness, weariness to detachment, and detachment to liberation.
69. Section: Separately Distinguishing Begins — The First Meaning Begins — The Heightened Samādhi of Aspiration
If there is a monk who, relying on pure aspiration and fierce desire, in order to realize the most supreme penetrating wisdom, hears the true dharma from the various tathāgatas and the Buddha's disciples with earnest, respectful reverence — from this hearing, without interruption, by stages, realizes supreme samādhi — one should know this is called the heightened samādhi of aspiration.
若有苾芻,依淨意樂及猛利欲,為欲證得最勝通慧,從諸如來及佛弟子,殷重恭敬聽聞正法。從聞無間漸次證得勝三摩地。當知是名欲增上三摩地。
If there is a monk who, relying on pure aspiration and fierce desire, in order to realize the most supreme penetrating wisdom, hears the true dharma from the various tathāgatas and the Buddha's disciples with earnest, respectful reverence — from this hearing, without interruption, by stages, realizes supreme samādhi — one should know this is called the heightened samādhi of aspiration.
This opens separately distinguishing (寅二別辨2), beginning with the first meaning (卯一第一義4), a fourfold structure correlating each samādhi to the corresponding place of liberation, beginning with the heightened samādhi of aspiration (辰一欲增上三摩地) — earnestly hearing the true dharma from a buddha or noble disciple, sustained by pure aspiration and fierce longing for supreme wisdom, gradually, without interruption, realizes supreme samādhi — matching the first place of liberation.
70. Section: The Heightened Samādhi of Diligence
There is, further, a monk who, in accordance with the dharma heard and the dharma attained, exerts great effort, gives rise to great diligence, whether rightly expounding and teaching it to others, or reciting it with sublime, excellent intonation — from this, without interruption, by stages of cause and condition, is able to accordingly attain supreme samādhi. One should know this is called the heightened samādhi of diligence.
復有苾芻,如所聞法、如所得法,起大功用,發大精進,或正為他宣說開示,或以勝妙音詞讀誦。從此無間漸次因緣,能隨獲得勝三摩地。當知是名精進增上三摩地。
There is, further, a monk who, in accordance with the dharma heard and the dharma attained, exerts great effort, gives rise to great diligence, whether rightly expounding and teaching it to others, or reciting it with sublime, excellent intonation — from this, without interruption, by stages of cause and condition, is able to accordingly attain supreme samādhi. One should know this is called the heightened samādhi of diligence.
This opens the heightened samādhi of diligence (辰二精進增上三摩地), the second — expounding what has been heard to others, or reciting it aloud with sublime intonation, sustains without interruption and yields supreme samādhi in turn, matching the second and third places of liberation. Master Cháng Bǎi cites two later masters exemplifying just this: Great Master Zhìzhě, who, while reciting the Lotus Sūtra's chapter on the former deeds of Medicine King Bodhisattva, entered a still absorption and directly beheld the still-unbroken assembly of Vulture Peak, attaining the initial dhāraṇī and unobstructed eloquence in teaching ever after; and Great Master Tàixū, who, while reading the Great Perfection of Wisdom Sūtra, was suddenly overcome with bodily and mental clarity resembling samādhi, its focus persisting three full days, after which he thoroughly penetrated the doctrines of both emptiness and the true, permanent mind (as well as the illusory-yet-consciousness-only view), going on to champion a broad reform of Chinese Buddhism.
71. Section: The Heightened Samādhi of Mind
There is, further, a monk who, toward the various excellent samādhi-signs, skillfully grasps and reflects upon them, contemplating the bluish, festering corpse and the rest, up to the skeleton as its final limit. Through this object, supreme samādhi arises in sequence. One should know this is called the heightened samādhi of mind.
復有苾芻,於諸賢善三摩地相善取思惟,觀青瘀等,乃至骨鎖以為邊際。由此所緣,次第生起勝三摩地。當知是名心增上三摩地。
There is, further, a monk who, toward the various excellent samādhi-signs, skillfully grasps and reflects upon them, contemplating the bluish, festering corpse and the rest, up to the skeleton as its final limit. Through this object, supreme samādhi arises in sequence. One should know this is called the heightened samādhi of mind.
This opens the heightened samādhi of mind (辰三心增上三摩地), the third — skillfully grasping the sign of impurity-contemplation, from a corpse's bluish discoloration through its bloating, decay, and final reduction to a bare skeleton, sustained reflection on this object yields supreme samādhi, matching the fourth place of liberation.
72. Section: The Heightened Samādhi of Investigation, Closing "The First Meaning" Entirely
There is, further, a monk who, in accordance with the dharma heard and the dharma attained, dwells alone in a secluded place, reflecting, weighing, and carefully, truly observing. Through this cause and condition, supreme samādhi arises by stages. One should know this is called the heightened samādhi of investigation.
復有苾芻,如所聞法、如所得法,獨處空閑,思惟、籌量、審諦觀察。由此因緣,漸次生起勝三摩地。當知是名觀增上三摩地。
There is, further, a monk who, in accordance with the dharma heard and the dharma attained, dwells alone in a secluded place, reflecting, weighing, and carefully, truly observing. Through this cause and condition, supreme samādhi arises by stages. One should know this is called the heightened samādhi of investigation.
With this, the heightened samādhi of investigation (辰四觀增上三摩地) closes entirely, closing **the first meaning (卯一第一義4: 欲/精進/心/觀增上三摩地), the first of separately distinguishing's two matters, entirely** — dwelling alone in seclusion, reflecting on and weighing the dharma heard and attained through practice in accordance with the dharma, supreme samādhi arises by stages, matching the fifth and final place of liberation, completing the correlation of all four samādhis to their respective places of liberation.
73. Section: The Second Meaning Begins — Generally Marking and Listing
There is, further, a distinction: samādhi arises through four gateways. First, as before, the gateway of a fierce, delighted wish to hear the true dharma, arising from another. Second, the gateway of right instruction: having received unmistaken instruction and exhortation from another, one gives rise, without interruption and with earnest gravity, to preparatory practice; not yet having entered the fundamental, supreme samādhi, one aspires to enter through the gateway of right instruction. Third, the gateway of the mind's delight: having already entered the fundamental, supreme samādhi, in order to turn and attain the remaining, higher supreme samādhi, one proceeds through the gateway of the mind's delight. Fourth, the gateway of equal observation: through extensive learning and retention, one is oneself able, toward the dharma, to observe in accordance with principle through the gateway of equal observation.
復有差別,謂由四門起三摩地。一、由如前從他生起猛利樂欲聞正法門。二、由從他獲得無倒教授教誡,無間、殷重發起加行,未入根本勝三摩地,為欲趣入正教授門。三、由已入根本勝三摩地,為欲轉得所餘上位勝三摩地,心喜樂門。四、由多聞聞持,自能於法如理觀察平等觀門。
There is, further, a distinction: samādhi arises through four gateways. First, as before, the gateway of a fierce, delighted wish to hear the true dharma, arising from another. Second, the gateway of right instruction: having received unmistaken instruction and exhortation from another, one gives rise, without interruption and with earnest gravity, to preparatory practice; not yet having entered the fundamental, supreme samādhi, one aspires to enter through the gateway of right instruction. Third, the gateway of the mind's delight: having already entered the fundamental, supreme samādhi, in order to turn and attain the remaining, higher supreme samādhi, one proceeds through the gateway of the mind's delight. Fourth, the gateway of equal observation: through extensive learning and retention, one is oneself able, toward the dharma, to observe in accordance with principle through the gateway of equal observation.
This opens the second meaning (卯二第二義2), the second of separately distinguishing's two matters, beginning with generally marking and listing (辰一總標列) — a second, complementary lens views the same four samādhis through four gateways: the gateway of hearing (matching aspiration's own samādhi as before), the gateway of right instruction (receiving unmistaken guidance and applying diligent preparatory practice before entering fundamental samādhi, matching diligence's samādhi), the gateway of the mind's delight (advancing from a fundamental samādhi already attained toward a still higher one, matching mind's samādhi), and the gateway of equal observation (a dharma-practitioner's own extensive learning turned toward equal, principled observation of dependent origination, matching investigation's samādhi). Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows — separately correlating this second lens's own four gateways (辰二別配屬) — before further closure is claimed.
74. Section: Separately Correlating, Closing "The Second Meaning," "Separately Distinguishing," and "Setting Out the Distinctions" Entirely
One should know that, here, through the first gateway, the heightened samādhi of aspiration arises; through the second gateway, the heightened samādhi of diligence arises; through the third gateway, the heightened samādhi of mind arises; through the fourth gateway, the heightened samādhi of investigation arises.
當知此中,由第一門起欲增上三摩地,由第二門起精進增上三摩地,由第三門起心增上三摩地,由第四門起觀增上三摩地。
One should know that, here, through the first gateway, the heightened samādhi of aspiration arises; through the second gateway, the heightened samādhi of diligence arises; through the third gateway, the heightened samādhi of mind arises; through the fourth gateway, the heightened samādhi of investigation arises.
With this, separately correlating (辰二別配屬) closes entirely, closing the second meaning (卯二第二義2: 總標列/別配屬) entirely, closing **separately distinguishing (寅二別辨2: 第一義/第二義) entirely**, closing **setting out the distinctions (丑一出差別2: 總標/別辨), the first of equipoise and the alternate approach's two matters, entirely** — the four gateways (hearing, right instruction, the mind's delight, equal observation) map exactly onto the four heightened samādhis (aspiration, diligence, mind, investigation) in the same order, completing this second, complementary correlation.
75. Section: Pointing to the Remaining Marks, Closing "Equipoise and the Alternate Approach" Entirely
The remaining distinctions of meaning, and the distinctions of the conduct of severance, should be known in their marks as in the Śrāvaka Ground.
所餘分別義及分別斷行,如聲聞地應知其相。
The remaining distinctions of meaning, and the distinctions of the conduct of severance, should be known in their marks as in the Śrāvaka Ground.
With this, pointing to the remaining marks (丑二指餘相) closes entirely, closing **equipoise and the alternate approach (子四等持異門2: 出差別/指餘相), the fourth of the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power's five sections, entirely** — the Śrāvaka Ground, fascicle 29, is cited for the fuller distinction of the four named samādhis (aspiration's, diligence's, mind's, investigation's) and the eight-part conduct of severance that perfects them once affliction's manifest activity, though suppressed, still leaves its seed unsevered: aspiration (the wish for samādhi's own completion), exertion (unflagging, resolute preparatory effort), faith (undoubting confidence that sustained practice will succeed), ease (joy born of that confidence, itself fueling further diligence), mindfulness (the nine progressive stages of settling the mind), right knowledge (insight's own wisdom, alert to whether mindfulness has lapsed or wholesome and unwholesome states are present), volition (the mental factor that actively assembles the supporting conditions — precepts, sense-restraint, wakeful yoga, moderation in eating — for calm-abiding and insight), and equanimity (a mind undisturbed by craving, aversion, torpor, restlessness, or doubt toward any object across the three times) — together known as the eight excellent conducts, each supporting the four samādhis toward their completion.
76. Section: Supernormal Power Begins — Generally Marking and Distinguishing
Further, cultivating the various bases of supernormal power as a support, one is able to rightly bring forth the various noble supernormal powers. There is no outside path that, cultivating the various bases of supernormal power, is able to rightly bring forth the various noble supernormal powers.
復次,修諸神足以為依止,能正引發諸聖神通。無有外道修諸神足能正引發諸聖神通。
Further, cultivating the various bases of supernormal power as a support, one is able to rightly bring forth the various noble supernormal powers. There is no outside path that, cultivating the various bases of supernormal power, is able to rightly bring forth the various noble supernormal powers.
This opens supernormal power (子五神通2), the fifth and final of the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power's five sections, named by the verse's second phrase's second half "supernormal power, coming last" (異門神通後), beginning with generally marking and distinguishing (丑一總標簡) — the Buddhadharma's own noble supernormal powers, built on the four bases of supernormal power, surpass whatever powers outside paths may possess, since only the noble ones' own attainment counts as genuinely "noble" supernormal power.
77. Section: Separately Explaining the Marks Begins — Raising the Most Supreme
Further, the various noble ones, bringing forth every kind of most supreme supernormal power, are able, in accordance with their own aspiration and delight, to extend their life-formations, dwelling for a single eon, or beyond a single eon — that is, exceeding one eon. The person of indeterminate lineage is called "of that class"; one should know that this class exists only within the inner dharma.
又諸聖者引發所有最勝神通,隨所願樂,延諸壽行,或住一劫,或一劫餘,謂過一劫。不定種姓補特伽羅名為物類,當知此類唯住內法。
Further, the various noble ones, bringing forth every kind of most supreme supernormal power, are able, in accordance with their own aspiration and delight, to extend their life-formations, dwelling for a single eon, or beyond a single eon — that is, exceeding one eon. The person of indeterminate lineage is called "of that class"; one should know that this class exists only within the inner dharma.
This opens separately explaining the marks (丑二別釋相2), beginning with raising the most supreme (寅一舉最勝) — a noble one who has mastered the four bases of supernormal power can, as desired, extend their own lifespan by a full eon or more; the 瑜伽論記 identifies four kinds of supernormal power at play here: transformation, transformation of nature, sustaining across time, and transformation of time. This life-extension applies specifically to the śrāvaka of indeterminate lineage — one who will, in time, turn from the lesser vehicle toward supreme enlightenment — rather than to a śrāvaka of fixed lineage bound only for final nirvāṇa without remainder; the decisive section on the Bodhisattva Ground, fascicle 80, per the 披尋記, confirms the Buddha spoke of this "class" (物類) with such śrāvaka-turning-bodhisattva practitioners specifically in mind.
78. Section: Distinguishing the Powerless Begins — Toward Four Matters
Further, the various noble ones' supernormal power of transformation, toward four matters, is unable to transform them: first, the faculties; second, the mind; third, the mental factors; fourth, karma and karma's ripening.
又諸聖者變化神通,於其四事不能變化。一者、根,二者、心,三者、心所有法,四者、業及業異熟。
Further, the various noble ones' supernormal power of transformation, toward four matters, is unable to transform them: first, the faculties; second, the mind; third, the mental factors; fourth, karma and karma's ripening.
This opens distinguishing the powerless (寅二簡無能3), the second of separately explaining the marks' two matters, a threefold structure, beginning with toward four matters (卯一於四事) — however extraordinary a noble one's supernormal power may be, it cannot alter a being's own faculties, cannot conjure a mind or its mental factors out of nothing, and cannot transform karma or its ripening — four boundaries even the greatest supernormal power never crosses.
79. Section: Toward Transformation of Nature Begins — Transforming the Feeling Received Begins — Raising Pleasant Feeling Set Against Painful Feeling
Further, the various noble ones' supernormal power of transforming nature is unable to transform karma conducive to pleasant feeling, causing its own nature to change into karma conducive to painful feeling.
又諸聖者變性神通,不能轉變順樂受業,令自性改成順苦受。
Further, the various noble ones' supernormal power of transforming nature is unable to transform karma conducive to pleasant feeling, causing its own nature to change into karma conducive to painful feeling.
This opens toward transformation of nature (卯二於變性2), the second of distinguishing the powerless's three matters, beginning with transforming the feeling received (辰一轉令改受2), beginning with raising pleasant feeling set against painful feeling (巳一舉樂受望苦受) — karma already conducive to a pleasant ripening cannot be transformed, even by supernormal power, into karma conducive to a painful one; wholesome karma already accumulated can never be forced to ripen as if it were unwholesome.
80. Section: The Parallel Case of Painful Feeling Set Against Pleasant Feeling, Closing "Transforming the Feeling Received" Entirely
Just as karma conducive to pleasant feeling cannot become karma conducive to painful feeling, so too, karma conducive to painful feeling toward karma conducive to pleasant feeling — one should know that it is likewise so.
如順樂受望順苦受,順苦受業望順樂受,應知亦爾。
Just as karma conducive to pleasant feeling cannot become karma conducive to painful feeling, so too, karma conducive to painful feeling toward karma conducive to pleasant feeling — one should know that it is likewise so.
With this, the parallel case of painful feeling set against pleasant feeling (巳二例苦受望樂受) closes entirely, closing transforming the feeling received (辰一轉令改受2: 舉樂受望苦受/例苦受望樂受) entirely — the same holds in reverse: unwholesome karma already fixed toward a painful ripening can never be transformed by supernormal power into karma conducive to pleasure.
81. Section: Transforming Toward No Feeling at All Begins — Raising Feeling Conducive to Neither Pain Nor Pleasure
If karma is able to be conducive to neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling, one should know that it is, in the end, conducive to neither pain nor pleasure. Further, the various noble ones' supernormal power of sustaining is unable to sustain karma conducive to neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling in such a way as to make it produce no feeling at all.
若業能順非苦樂受,當知畢竟順非苦樂。又諸聖者住持神通,不能住持順非苦樂受業,令成無受。
If karma is able to be conducive to neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling, one should know that it is, in the end, conducive to neither pain nor pleasure. Further, the various noble ones' supernormal power of sustaining is unable to sustain karma conducive to neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling in such a way as to make it produce no feeling at all.
This opens transforming toward no feeling at all (辰二轉令無受2), the second of toward transformation of nature's two matters, beginning with raising feeling conducive to neither pain nor pleasure (巳一舉順非苦樂受) — karma already fixed toward neutral feeling remains fixed toward neutral feeling; supernormal power cannot even suppress karma's ripening into producing no feeling whatsoever — karma, once set, will always produce some feeling.
82. Section: The Parallel Case of the Remaining Pleasant and Painful Feelings, Closing "Transforming Toward No Feeling at All" and "Toward Transformation of Nature" Entirely
The rest is likewise so.
餘亦如是。
The rest is likewise so.
With this, the parallel case of the remaining pleasant and painful feelings (巳二例餘苦樂受) closes entirely, closing transforming toward no feeling at all (辰二轉令無受2: 舉順非苦樂受/例餘苦樂受) entirely, closing **toward transformation of nature (卯二於變性2: 轉令改受/轉令無受), the second of distinguishing the powerless's three matters, entirely** — per the 披尋記, "the rest" names karma conducive to pleasant and painful feeling, likewise unable to be sustained into producing no feeling at all; every karma leaves its trace, and no noble one's supernormal power, however great, can erase that trace entirely.
83. Section: Toward Transformation of Time, Closing "Distinguishing the Powerless," "Separately Explaining the Marks," "Supernormal Power," and the Entire Embrace of Right Effort and the Bases of Supernormal Power Entirely
Further, the various noble ones' supernormal power of transforming time is unable to transform karma conducive to being felt in the present dharma into karma conducive to being felt in a later dharma; nor karma conducive to being felt in a later dharma into karma conducive to being felt in the present dharma.
又諸聖者變時神通,不能轉變順現法受業,令成順後法受業;及順後法受業,令成順現法受業。
Further, the various noble ones' supernormal power of transforming time is unable to transform karma conducive to being felt in the present dharma into karma conducive to being felt in a later dharma; nor karma conducive to being felt in a later dharma into karma conducive to being felt in the present dharma.
With this, toward transformation of time (卯三於變時) closes entirely, closing **distinguishing the powerless (寅二簡無能3: 於四事/於變性/於變時) entirely**, closing **separately explaining the marks (丑二別釋相2: 舉最勝/簡無能) entirely**, closing **supernormal power (子五神通2: 總標簡/別釋相), the fifth and final of the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power's five sections, entirely** — supernormal power cannot even shift when karma ripens, whether pulling a future fruit into the present or pushing a present fruit into the future; karma's own timing, like its nature and its nonexistence, lies entirely beyond even a noble one's own supernormal reach — the common saying that "supernormal power cannot overcome karma" (神通不敵業力) captures exactly this teaching. **With this section's closure, the embrace of right effort and the bases of supernormal power (壬二正斷神足攝2: 勇/力/修/等持異門/神通), the second of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics, closes in its complete entirety.**
84. Section: The Embrace of the Faculties Begins — The Verse Marking and Listing
Further, a summary verse says: establishing them, and the sphere of their operation; the faculty of wisdom is supreme; one should know, afterward, the abidings — the outsider, the ordinary being's own class, and the rest.
復次,嗢柁南曰:
Further, a summary verse says:
安立所行境 慧根為最勝 當知後安住 外異生品等
Establishing them, and the sphere of their operation; the faculty of wisdom is supreme; one should know, afterward, the abidings — the outsider, the ordinary being's own class, and the rest.
This opens **the embrace of the faculties (壬三根攝2), the third of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics**, named by the general summary verse's second line's second half "the faculties" (神足及根力) — treating the five faculties (信根/進根/念根/定根/慧根) together with the seventeen further faculties that, with them, make up the traditional twenty-two — beginning with the verse marking and listing (癸一頌標列) — four matters unfold in the long-form explanation: establishing the twenty-two faculties, the sphere in which they properly operate, the faculty of wisdom's own supremacy among them, and, afterward, the abidings distinguishing the outsider, the ordinary being's own class within the inner dharma, and the remaining classes of practitioner.
85. Section: The Long-Form Explanation Begins — Establishing Them Begins — Marking and Listing
Briefly, through the increasing meaning of six places, one should know that the twenty-two faculties are established. What are the six? First, the increasing meaning of grasping an object; second, the increasing meaning of continuing the family lineage; third, the increasing meaning of the causes and conditions of sustaining life, and of each distinct undertaking's preparatory exertion; fourth, the increasing meaning of experiencing the desirable and undesirable fruit produced by former lives' various karmas, and of creating new karma; fifth, the increasing meaning of tending toward mundane freedom from desire; sixth, the increasing meaning of tending toward supramundane freedom from desire.
略由六處增上義故,當知建立二十二根。何等為六?一、能取境界增上義故;二、繼嗣家族增上義故;三、活命因緣各別事業加行士用增上義故;四、受用先世諸業所作愛不愛果及造新業增上義故;五、趣向世間離欲增上義故;六、趣向出世離欲增上義故。
Briefly, through the increasing meaning of six places, one should know that the twenty-two faculties are established. What are the six? First, the increasing meaning of grasping an object; second, the increasing meaning of continuing the family lineage; third, the increasing meaning of the causes and conditions of sustaining life, and of each distinct undertaking's preparatory exertion; fourth, the increasing meaning of experiencing the desirable and undesirable fruit produced by former lives' various karmas, and of creating new karma; fifth, the increasing meaning of tending toward mundane freedom from desire; sixth, the increasing meaning of tending toward supramundane freedom from desire.
This opens the long-form explanation (癸二長行釋4), a fourfold structure matching the verse's four matters, beginning with establishing them (子一安立3), named by the verse's first phrase's first half "establishing them" (安立所行境), beginning with marking and listing (丑一標列) — six increasing meanings ground the establishment of the twenty-two faculties: grasping an object, continuing the family lineage, sustaining life and its undertakings, experiencing karma's fruit while creating new karma, tending toward mundane freedom from desire, and tending toward supramundane freedom from desire.
86. Section: Correlating and Explaining Begins — The Eye and the Other Five Faculties
One should know that, here, with the eye faculty first and the mind faculty last, these six faculties have an increasing meaning in grasping their object.
當知此中,眼根最初,意根為後,如是六根,於取境界有增上義。
One should know that, here, with the eye faculty first and the mind faculty last, these six faculties have an increasing meaning in grasping their object.
This opens correlating and explaining (丑二配釋6), a sixfold structure matching the six increasing meanings, beginning with the eye and the other five faculties (寅一眼等六根) — the six sense-faculties, eye through mind, together fulfill the first increasing meaning: grasping the six kinds of objects (form, sound, smell, taste, touch, and dharmas).
87. Section: The Male and Female Faculties
The two faculties, male and female, have an increasing meaning in being able to continue the family lineage's descendants.
男女二根,於能繼嗣家族子孫有增上義。
The two faculties, male and female, have an increasing meaning in being able to continue the family lineage's descendants.
This opens the male and female faculties (寅二男女二根), the second — these two faculties fulfill the second increasing meaning, sustaining human procreation and family continuity.
88. Section: The Life Faculty
The single life faculty has an increasing meaning, for those who cherish life, in the causes and conditions of sustaining life, and in each distinct undertaking's preparatory exertion.
命根一種,於愛命者活命因緣各別事業加行士用有增上義。
The single life faculty has an increasing meaning, for those who cherish life, in the causes and conditions of sustaining life, and in each distinct undertaking's preparatory exertion.
This opens the life faculty (寅三命根), the third — the single life faculty fulfills the third increasing meaning, sustaining the very continuity of life that makes any undertaking, worldly or spiritual, possible at all.
89. Section: Pleasure and the Other Four Feeling-Faculties
With pleasure first and equanimity last, these five faculties have an increasing meaning in experiencing the desirable and undesirable fruit produced by former karma, and in creating new karma.
樂最為初,捨為其後,如是五根,於其受用先業所作愛不愛果及造新業有增上義。
With pleasure first and equanimity last, these five faculties have an increasing meaning in experiencing the desirable and undesirable fruit produced by former karma, and in creating new karma.
This opens pleasure and the other four feeling-faculties (寅四樂等五根), the fourth — the five feeling-faculties (pleasure, pain, sorrow, joy, equanimity) fulfill the fourth increasing meaning: experiencing the desirable or undesirable fruit of former karma (pleasant feeling breeding attachment, painful feeling breeding aversion) while, in turn, driving the creation of yet more karma — feeling's own power to perpetuate the endless cycle of rebirth. Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows — the fifth and sixth increasing meanings' own correlation (寅五信等五根, presumably the five faith-through-wisdom faculties, and beyond) — before further closure is claimed.
90. Section: Faith and the Other Four Path-Faculties
With faith first and wisdom last, these five faculties have an increasing meaning in being able to tend toward mundane freedom from desire.
信為最初,慧為其後,如是五根,於能趣向世間離欲有增上義。
With faith first and wisdom last, these five faculties have an increasing meaning in being able to tend toward mundane freedom from desire.
This opens faith and the other four path-faculties (寅五信等五根), the fifth — the five faculties of faith, diligence, mindfulness, concentration, and wisdom fulfill the fifth increasing meaning, helping the practitioner accomplish mundane meditative freedom from desire.
91. Section: The Three Uncontaminated Faculties, Closing "Correlating and Explaining" Entirely
The three uncontaminated faculties — the faculty of coming to know what was not yet known, the faculty of full knowledge, and the faculty of complete knowledge — have an increasing meaning in being able to tend toward supramundane freedom from desire, to its very utmost finality.
未知當知、已知、具知三無漏根,於能趣向出世離欲最極究竟有增上義。
The three uncontaminated faculties — the faculty of coming to know what was not yet known, the faculty of full knowledge, and the faculty of complete knowledge — have an increasing meaning in being able to tend toward supramundane freedom from desire, to its very utmost finality.
With this, the three uncontaminated faculties (寅六三無漏根) closes entirely, closing **correlating and explaining (丑二配釋6: 眼等六根/男女二根/命根/樂等五根/信等五根/三無漏根) entirely** — each of the three uncontaminated faculties gathers the same nine dharmas (faith, diligence, mindfulness, concentration, wisdom, joy, ease, equanimity, and mind), differing only by depth: the faculty of coming to know what was not yet known belongs to the path toward the first fruit; the faculty of full knowledge spans from the first fruit through the path toward the fourth; and the faculty of complete knowledge belongs to the arhat alone, all nine dharmas perfected — together fulfilling the sixth increasing meaning, tending toward supramundane freedom from desire's own utmost finality.
92. Section: The Concluding Statement Gathering Them Together, Closing "Establishing Them" Entirely
Every meaning that appears within the entire world is, in its full measure, only this much. One should know that what is able to bring this meaning to its ultimate completion never exceeds these twenty-two faculties; therefore every faculty is embraced by these twenty-two.
一切世間所現見義,其唯此量。當知是義能究竟者,無出於此二十二根,故一切根二十二攝。
Every meaning that appears within the entire world is, in its full measure, only this much. One should know that what is able to bring this meaning to its ultimate completion never exceeds these twenty-two faculties; therefore every faculty is embraced by these twenty-two.
With this, the concluding statement gathering them together (丑三結攝) closes entirely, closing **establishing them (子一安立3: 標列/配釋/結攝), the first of the embrace of the faculties' four sections, entirely** — every meaning appearing anywhere in the world falls within these twenty-two faculties' own scope, and nothing capable of bringing that meaning to ultimate completion lies outside them. Master Cháng Bǎi cites a companion sūtra likening the five faculties to a hall's construction: many timbers are needed, but only once the great central roof-beam is raised can every lesser beam find its proper support — just so, wisdom, as the foremost among faith, diligence, mindfulness, concentration, and wisdom, is what sustains and holds together every other faculty's own merit.
93. Section: The Sphere of Their Operation Begins — Setting Out the Wrong Discrimination
Further, there is a certain kind that thinks thus: if there were no inner self relying on the six sense-faculty doors to operate within the six kinds of objects, then these six faculties, each operating separately, each within its own separate object, and each faculty able only to receive its own particular sphere of operation — who, then, is able to receive the very nature of what all six faculties, taken together, operate within? One should know that this arises from an inability to penetrate the principle of dependent origination, and so gives rise to a wrong discrimination toward the formations.
復次,或有一類作是思惟:若無內我託六根門,行六境界,如是六根各別所行、各別境界,然此六根唯能領受自所行境,誰能領受如是六根所行境性?當知此由不能了達緣起道理,故於諸行起邪分別。
Further, there is a certain kind that thinks thus: if there were no inner self relying on the six sense-faculty doors to operate within the six kinds of objects, then these six faculties, each operating separately, each within its own separate object, and each faculty able only to receive its own particular sphere of operation — who, then, is able to receive the very nature of what all six faculties, taken together, operate within? One should know that this arises from an inability to penetrate the principle of dependent origination, and so gives rise to a wrong discrimination toward the formations.
This opens the sphere of their operation (子二所行境3), the second of the embrace of the faculties' four sections, named by the verse's first phrase's second half "the sphere of their operation" (安立所行境), beginning with setting out the wrong discrimination (丑一出邪分別) — noticing that each of the six sense-faculties operates within its own separate object, someone unfamiliar with dependent origination wrongly concludes that a unifying self must exist to receive what all six faculties, taken together, experience — a wrong discrimination born of not understanding how conditioned phenomena actually cohere without any such self.
94. Section: Manifesting the Principle of Dependent Origination Begins — Distinguishing What Should Be Cultivated Begins — Cultivating the Four Foundations of Mindfulness
As for the principle of dependent origination: it means that, at such a time as the practitioner of yoga, toward the inward six faculties, engages them with principled attention, diligently applying the preparatory practice of cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness — at just that time, these four foundations of mindfulness receive the very nature of what the six faculties operate within. Precisely because of this purity, it is called transcendence.
緣起理者,謂若有時,修瑜伽師於內六根如理攀緣,精勤加行修四念住;即於爾時,此四念住領受六根所行境性。即此於彼由清淨故,名為出離。
As for the principle of dependent origination: it means that, at such a time as the practitioner of yoga, toward the inward six faculties, engages them with principled attention, diligently applying the preparatory practice of cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness — at just that time, these four foundations of mindfulness receive the very nature of what the six faculties operate within. Precisely because of this purity, it is called transcendence.
This opens manifesting the principle of dependent origination (丑二明緣起理2), the second of the sphere of their operation's three matters, beginning with distinguishing what should be cultivated (寅一辨應修3), a threefold structure, beginning with cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness (卯一修四念住) — no unifying self is needed: when the practitioner brings principled attention to the six faculties through diligently cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness, it is precisely the four foundations themselves that come to receive what the six faculties, together, operate within — and this very purification is what "transcendence" means.
95. Section: Attaining the Seven Factors of Enlightenment
Further, precisely because of diligently cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness, one first penetrates the principle of the truths and attains the seven factors of enlightenment; at just that time, these various factors of enlightenment, being true and being real, receive the very nature of what the foundations of mindfulness operate within.
又即勤修四念住故,初達諦理得七覺支;即於爾時,此諸覺支真故實故,領受念住所行境性。
Further, precisely because of diligently cultivating the four foundations of mindfulness, one first penetrates the principle of the truths and attains the seven factors of enlightenment; at just that time, these various factors of enlightenment, being true and being real, receive the very nature of what the foundations of mindfulness operate within.
This opens attaining the seven factors of enlightenment (卯二得七覺支), the second — diligent cultivation of the four foundations first penetrates the noble truths and yields the seven factors of enlightenment (mindfulness, investigation of dharmas, diligence, joy, pliancy, concentration, and equanimity); these factors, now conjoined with true reality, in turn receive what the four foundations themselves operate within, the sphere of receiving continuing to purify and deepen at every stage.
96. Section: Arising in Clear Liberation, Closing "Distinguishing What Should Be Cultivated" Entirely
Further, through the cause and condition of cultivating the factors of enlightenment, clear liberation arises. At just that time, such clear liberation receives the factors of enlightenment, which have already been well cultivated.
又由修習覺支因緣,起於明脫。
Further, through the cause and condition of cultivating the factors of enlightenment, clear liberation arises.
即於爾時,如是明脫領受覺支已善修習。
At just that time, such clear liberation receives the factors of enlightenment, which have already been well cultivated.
With this, arising in clear liberation (卯三起於明脫) closes entirely, closing **distinguishing what should be cultivated (寅一辨應修3: 修四念住/得七覺支/起於明脫), the first of manifesting the principle of dependent origination's two matters, entirely** — cultivating the seven factors of enlightenment gives rise to clear liberation, the wisdom and vision that frees the mind from ignorance; per the 披尋記, this clear liberation now itself receives the well-cultivated factors of enlightenment as its own sphere, the receiving relationship cascading upward one more step, from faculties to foundations to factors to liberation itself.
97. Section: Manifesting the Finality, Closing "Manifesting the Principle of Dependent Origination" Entirely
From this point on, one no longer needs to cultivate what is operated within; having truly already severed every affliction, at just that time, through the cessation of every affliction, one attains nirvāṇa, free of excessive pride. Precisely because of being free of excessive pride, there is now, in actual fact, ultimate clear liberation, which truly receives the very nature of what the already-attained clear liberation operates within. Because of this transcendence of every conditioned dharma whatsoever, one should know that clear liberation, too, attains transcendence.
從此已後,不復應修所行境性。如實已斷一切煩惱,即於爾時,於諸煩惱斷滅涅槃,離增上慢。即由遠離增上慢故,此現實有究竟明脫,如實領受已得明脫所行境性。由此出離一切所有有為法故,當知明脫亦得出離。
From this point on, one no longer needs to cultivate what is operated within; having truly already severed every affliction, at just that time, through the cessation of every affliction, one attains nirvāṇa, free of excessive pride. Precisely because of being free of excessive pride, there is now, in actual fact, ultimate clear liberation, which truly receives the very nature of what the already-attained clear liberation operates within. Because of this transcendence of every conditioned dharma whatsoever, one should know that clear liberation, too, attains transcendence.
With this, manifesting the finality (寅二顯究竟) closes entirely, closing **manifesting the principle of dependent origination (丑二明緣起理2: 辨應修/顯究竟), the second of the sphere of their operation's three matters, entirely** — at the arhat's own stage, with every affliction genuinely severed and every trace of excessive pride gone, ultimate clear liberation itself becomes the final sphere received, and, since even this liberation belongs to the conditioned realm's own transcendence, clear liberation is itself, in the end, transcended — no further cultivation, no further object, remains.
98. Section: Distinguishing the Right Designation Begins — Distinguishing What Is Not Nirvāṇa
Within nirvāṇa, neither of the two designations, the grasping subject and the grasped object, exists at all, since every conceptual proliferation is permanently extinguished and departed.
於涅槃中,能取、所取二種施設皆無所有,一切戲論永滅離故。
Within nirvāṇa, neither of the two designations, the grasping subject and the grasped object, exists at all, since every conceptual proliferation is permanently extinguished and departed.
This opens distinguishing the right designation (丑三辨正施設3), the third of the sphere of their operation's three matters, beginning with distinguishing what is not nirvāṇa (寅一簡非涅槃) — the very subject-object structure this whole section has traced (faculties received by foundations, foundations by factors, factors by liberation) belongs entirely to the conditioned realm; nirvāṇa itself, with every conceptual elaboration extinguished, admits no such designation of a grasping subject or grasped object at all.
99. Section: Explaining the Distinction
Therefore, up through every conditioned dharma, one can, in turn, ask and answer, designating the distinct discourse of the grasping subject and the grasped object; within ultimate nirvāṇa, the unconditioned dharma, every distinct discourse of questioning and answering is entirely without principle.
是故乃至諸有為法,可得展轉問答施設能取、所取言論差別;究竟涅槃無為法中,一切問答言論差別,皆不如理。
Therefore, up through every conditioned dharma, one can, in turn, ask and answer, designating the distinct discourse of the grasping subject and the grasped object; within ultimate nirvāṇa, the unconditioned dharma, every distinct discourse of questioning and answering is entirely without principle.
This opens explaining the distinction (寅二釋其差別), the second — conditioned dharmas alone admit the back-and-forth of conventional discourse about subject and object; the unconditioned, ultimate nirvāṇa admits no such discourse whatsoever, every question and answer about it being, strictly speaking, beside the point.
100. Section: Concluding "Only Defilement and Purity," Closing "Distinguishing the Right Designation" and "The Sphere of Their Operation" Entirely
Therefore one should know that, within selflessness, one should rightly manifest that there is only defilement, and only purity.
是故當知,於無我中,應正顯示唯有雜染、唯有清淨。
Therefore one should know that, within selflessness, one should rightly manifest that there is only defilement, and only purity.
With this, concluding "only defilement and purity" (寅三結唯染淨) closes entirely, closing distinguishing the right designation (丑三辨正施設3: 簡非涅槃/釋其差別/結唯染淨) entirely, closing **the sphere of their operation (子二所行境3: 出邪分別/明緣起理/辨正施設), the second of the embrace of the faculties' four sections, entirely** — no abiding self is ever found anywhere among the six faculties or their objects; what exists is only conditioned defilement or conditioned purity, arising and passing without any controlling agent behind them. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this whole section's teaching to a companion sūtra in which the Buddha, having taught the three uncontaminated faculties (the faculty of coming to know what was not yet known, spanning the fifteen moments before the path of seeing; the faculty of full knowledge, from the first fruit through the path toward the fourth; and the faculty of complete knowledge, the arhat's own), sums up in verse: the trainee's own non-discriminating wisdom advances in accordance with the straight path already cultivated; diligent skillful means and well-guarded mind lead, in time, to knowing "my births are exhausted," the unobstructed path already known, liberation already known, and, at the very last, complete knowledge itself — freedom from self, right wisdom, an unshakeable, liberated mind, every conditioned thing exhausted, all nine faculties fully perfected, the six faculties resting in the utmost equanimity, the final body sustained by past karma alone, and every host of Māra's afflictions subdued — describing, verse by verse, the arhat's own attainment.
101. Section: Wisdom-Faculty's Supremacy Begins — Distinguishing Begins — What Is Accomplished at the Very Beginning
Further, if there is a person of sharp wisdom, of the kind whose faculties are keen, who, through the power of discernment, gives principled attention and reflects on the various dharmas, then, toward nirvāṇa, attains right faith and understanding.
復次,若有黠慧、諸根猛利種類士夫補特伽羅,由思擇力,如理作意思惟諸法,乃於涅槃得正信解。
Further, if there is a person of sharp wisdom, of the kind whose faculties are keen, who, through the power of discernment, gives principled attention and reflects on the various dharmas, then, toward nirvāṇa, attains right faith and understanding.
This opens wisdom-faculty's supremacy (子三慧根最勝2), the third of the embrace of the faculties' four sections, named by the verse's second phrase "the faculty of wisdom is supreme" (慧根為最勝), beginning with distinguishing (丑一辨2), beginning with what is accomplished at the very beginning (寅一最初所作) — a sharp-witted practitioner's discernment, applied through principled attention to the dharma, is what first produces genuine faith and understanding toward nirvāṇa — wisdom already at work from the very outset of practice.
102. Section: What Is Accomplished Afterward, Closing "Distinguishing" Entirely
Through the increase of this, one gives rise to diligent effort; through this increase, one is able, toward body and the rest's objects, to settle in right mindfulness; through this increase, one is able to bring the mind to one-pointed focus upon its object; through this increase, one truly knows and truly observes every dharma. By this cause and condition, one is able to reach finality.
由此增上,發勤精進;此增上故,能於身等所緣境界安住正念;此增上故,能於所緣令心一趣;此增上故,於一切法如實了知、如實觀見。由是因緣,能到究竟。
Through the increase of this, one gives rise to diligent effort; through this increase, one is able, toward body and the rest's objects, to settle in right mindfulness; through this increase, one is able to bring the mind to one-pointed focus upon its object; through this increase, one truly knows and truly observes every dharma. By this cause and condition, one is able to reach finality.
With this, what is accomplished afterward (寅二次後所作) closes entirely, closing **distinguishing (丑一辨2: 最初所作/次後所作) entirely** — that same initial wisdom's own increasing power then drives diligent effort, settles right mindfulness upon the four foundations, brings the mind to one-pointed concentration, and finally yields true knowing and seeing of every dharma, carrying the practitioner all the way to ultimate finality — wisdom active at every single stage, from first to last.
103. Section: The Concluding Statement, Closing "Wisdom-Faculty's Supremacy" Entirely
Therefore this wisdom, whether at the very beginning or afterward, has much work to accomplish; therefore it is said that the faculty of wisdom is the most supreme.
是故此慧,若初若後多有所作,故說慧根最為殊勝。
Therefore this wisdom, whether at the very beginning or afterward, has much work to accomplish; therefore it is said that the faculty of wisdom is the most supreme.
With this, the concluding statement (丑二結) closes entirely, closing **wisdom-faculty's supremacy (子三慧根最勝2: 辨/結), the third of the embrace of the faculties' four sections, entirely** — since wisdom is at work from the very first stirring of faith through the very last stage of realization, it is rightly called the most supreme of all the faculties. Master Cháng Bǎi cites a cluster of companion sūtras: one likening the five faculties to a hall's construction (wisdom as the great roof-beam upholding every other timber); one correlating each faculty to a doctrinal set (faith to the four confirmed purities in the Three Jewels and precepts, diligence to the four right efforts, mindfulness to the four foundations, concentration to the four dhyānas, and wisdom to the four noble truths, wisdom again standing foremost); one teaching that whoever accomplishes the wisdom faculty necessarily accomplishes the remaining four as well, since it is precisely the wisdom that recognizes beginningless ignorance's own grip on saṃsāra that drives every other faculty's own success; and one, carrying a distinctly Mahāyāna resonance, framing all five faculties as arising specifically from a noble disciple's own aspiration toward the Tathāgata's own bodhicitta.
104. Section: The Abidings Begins — The Outsider Ordinary Being's Own Class
Further, if, relying on the various buddhas' unsurpassed enlightenment, the right faith attained, up through right wisdom, does not exist even at the mundane level, one should know that this abides in the class of the outsider ordinary being.
復次,若依諸佛無上菩提所得正信乃至正慧,於此世間亦無有者,當知此住外異生品。
Further, if, relying on the various buddhas' unsurpassed enlightenment, the right faith attained, up through right wisdom, does not exist even at the mundane level, one should know that this abides in the class of the outsider ordinary being.
This opens the abidings (子四安住品類3), the fourth and final of the embrace of the faculties' four sections, named by the verse's third phrase's second half and fourth phrase "the abidings — the outsider, the ordinary being's own class, and the rest" (當知後安住 外異生品等), beginning with the outsider ordinary being's own class (丑一外異生品) — a being who has not attained even the mundane five faculties (faith through wisdom) taught through the buddhas' own unsurpassed enlightenment abides entirely outside the inner dharma, in the class of the outsider ordinary being.
105. Section: The Inner Ordinary Being's Own Class
If, toward this very dharma, there is only the mundane, and no supramundane attainment, one should know that this abides in the class of the inner ordinary being, not the outsider ordinary being.
即於此法唯有世間,無出世者,當知此住內異生品,非外異生。
If, toward this very dharma, there is only the mundane, and no supramundane attainment, one should know that this abides in the class of the inner ordinary being, not the outsider ordinary being.
This opens the inner ordinary being's own class (丑二內異生品), the second — a being who has attained the mundane five faculties within the inner dharma, but not yet any supramundane attainment, abides within the inner dharma's own preparatory stage — no longer an outsider, though not yet a noble one.
106. Section: Abiding Separately in the Remaining Class, Closing "The Abidings," "The Embrace of the Faculties," and the Entire Third Great Topic Entirely
If, toward this dharma, there is a supramundane attainment, one should know that all of this abides separately, in the remaining class, not belonging to those other classes.
若於此法有出世者,當知一切別住餘品,非彼品類。
If, toward this dharma, there is a supramundane attainment, one should know that all of this abides separately, in the remaining class, not belonging to those other classes.
With this, abiding separately in the remaining class (丑三別住餘品) closes entirely, closing **the abidings (子四安住品類3: 外異生品/內異生品/別住餘品), the fourth and final of the embrace of the faculties' four sections, entirely** — a being who has actually attained a supramundane fruit abides in an entirely separate, noble class, transcending both the outsider and the inner ordinary being's own classes alike. The 披尋記 confirms this threefold division exhausts every possibility: the outsider ordinary being (lacking even mundane faculties), the inner ordinary being (mundane faculties only), and the noble class (supramundane attainment) — no fourth category remains. **With this section's closure, the embrace of the faculties (壬三根攝2: 安立/所行境/慧根最勝/安住品類), the third of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics, closes in its complete entirety.**
107. Section: The Embrace of the Powers Begins — The Verse Marking and Listing
Further, a summary verse says: discernment, awakened wisdom and the rest; the nation and the rest, and the various kings; the arhat, the trainee; uprightness, coming last.
復次,嗢柁南曰:
Further, a summary verse says:
思擇覺慧等 國等及諸王 阿羅漢有學 質直最為後
Discernment, awakened wisdom and the rest; the nation and the rest, and the various kings; the arhat, the trainee; uprightness, coming last.
This opens **the embrace of the powers (壬四力攝2), the fourth of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics**, named by the general summary verse's second line's third word "the powers" (神足及根力) — treating the five powers (信力/進力/念力/定力/慧力, sharing the same names as the five faculties but denoting their strengthened, unshakeable form) alongside a wider array of powers explored in this section — beginning with the verse marking and listing (癸一頌標列) — six matters unfold in the long-form explanation: discernment, awakened wisdom and the rest (four further powers), the nation and the various kings (a tenfold royal analogy), the arhat's own eight powers, the trainee's five powers (contrasted with the Tathāgata's own ten), and, finally, the upright practitioner's fourfold mark.
108. Section: The Long-Form Explanation Begins — Discernment Begins — Marking How the Name Is Attained
Briefly, toward every unwholesome deed belonging to the present dharma and to later dharmas, having deeply seen its fault, one is able to rightly discern, bringing every unwholesome deed to rest and cultivating every wholesome deed — this is called the power of discernment.
略於一切現法、後法諸惡行中,深見過已,能正思擇,息諸惡行,修諸善行,名思擇力。
Briefly, toward every unwholesome deed belonging to the present dharma and to later dharmas, having deeply seen its fault, one is able to rightly discern, bringing every unwholesome deed to rest and cultivating every wholesome deed — this is called the power of discernment.
This opens the long-form explanation (癸二長行釋6), a sixfold structure matching the verse's six matters, beginning with discernment (子一思擇2), named by the verse's first phrase's first half "discernment" (思擇覺慧等), beginning with marking how the name is attained (丑一標得名) — deeply seeing the fault in every unwholesome deed, present or future, and thereby bringing evil to rest while cultivating good, is what earns the name "power of discernment."
109. Section: Distinguishing Its Function Begins — Able to Accomplish Two Matters
One should know that this power is able to accomplish two matters: first, being able to go to a fortunate destiny among humans and gods; second, being able to go to nirvāṇa within the present dharma.
當知此力能成二事。一者、能往人天善趣,二者、能往現法涅槃。
One should know that this power is able to accomplish two matters: first, being able to go to a fortunate destiny among humans and gods; second, being able to go to nirvāṇa within the present dharma.
This opens distinguishing its function (丑二辨業用3), the second of discernment's two matters, beginning with able to accomplish two matters (寅一能成二事) — the power of discernment, understanding evil's own fault, leads either to a fortunate rebirth among gods and humans through cultivating the five precepts and ten wholesome deeds, or, through deeper reflection on selflessness, directly to nirvāṇa within this very life.
110. Section: Able to Rightly Cultivate
Further, this is able to serve as the support for the power of cultivation, which embraces the cultivation of the foundations of mindfulness; relying on this, one is able to rightly cultivate the four foundations of mindfulness and the other factors of enlightenment. One should know that this cultivation is called the power of cultivation.
又此能與修習力攝修諸念住為所依止,由此為依,能正修習四念住等菩提分法。當知此修名修習力。
Further, this is able to serve as the support for the power of cultivation, which embraces the cultivation of the foundations of mindfulness; relying on this, one is able to rightly cultivate the four foundations of mindfulness and the other factors of enlightenment. One should know that this cultivation is called the power of cultivation.
This opens able to rightly cultivate (寅二能正修習), the second — discernment serves as the very foundation for the power of cultivation, which, relying on it, rightly cultivates the four foundations of mindfulness and every other factor of enlightenment in turn. The Ground of Cultivation-Accomplished Wisdom describes this cultivation as resting on the preparatory stage of concentration, applying insight to the four noble truths, the contemplation of selflessness, and the three concentrations, or any observation conjoined with the noble path.
111. Section: Able to Accompany Shame Begins — Marking
Further, the power of discernment is able to serve as a companion to shame arising in three places.
又思擇力,能與三處羞恥為伴。
Further, the power of discernment is able to serve as a companion to shame arising in three places.
This opens able to accompany shame (寅三能伴羞恥3), the third of distinguishing its function's three matters, beginning with marking (卯一標) — shame is the very first ornament of conduct; a practitioner with genuine shame is spurred to actively sever evil and cultivate good, and the power of discernment accompanies this shame in three distinct places.
112. Section: Questioning
What is called shame in three places?
何等名為三處羞恥?
What is called shame in three places?
This opens questioning (卯二徵), the second of able to accompany shame's three matters.
113. Section: Explaining Begins — Distinguishing Each Mark Begins — Shame with Regard to Others
First, shame with regard to others. It means thinking thus: if I commit evil, I will be censured together by the buddhas and world-honored ones who possess the wisdom to know others' minds, by the noble disciples, and by the multitudes of gods who have faith in the Buddhadharma, throughout the world. This is called the power of discernment's first place.
一者、他處羞恥。謂作是思:若我作惡,當為世間有他心智諸佛世尊、若聖弟子、若諸天眾信佛教者,共所呵毀。是名第一處思擇力。
First, shame with regard to others. It means thinking thus: if I commit evil, I will be censured together by the buddhas and world-honored ones who possess the wisdom to know others' minds, by the noble disciples, and by the multitudes of gods who have faith in the Buddhadharma, throughout the world. This is called the power of discernment's first place.
This opens explaining (卯三釋2), the third of able to accompany shame's three matters, beginning with distinguishing each mark (辰一別辨相3), a threefold structure, beginning with shame with regard to others (巳一他處羞恥) — reflecting that any evil deed would be censured by every buddha, noble disciple, and faithful god who knows one's own mind gives rise to this first kind of shame; the wise, Master Cháng Bǎi notes, confess and repent the moment an evil thought is caught, never letting it take root and continue.
114. Section: Shame with Regard to Oneself
Second, shame with regard to oneself. It means thinking thus: if I commit evil, I will certainly be deeply censured by myself — what good person would commit such an evil deed? This is called the second place's increasing power.
二者、自處羞恥。謂作是思:若我作惡,定當為己深所呵毀,何有善人為斯惡行。是名第二處增上力。
Second, shame with regard to oneself. It means thinking thus: if I commit evil, I will certainly be deeply censured by myself — what good person would commit such an evil deed? This is called the second place's increasing power.
This opens shame with regard to oneself (巳二自處羞恥), the second — sustained self-reflection and self-respect, even before the noble path is attained, holds oneself accountable to one's own aspiration, censuring oneself whenever conduct falls short of it.
115. Section: Shame with Regard to the Dharma, Closing "Distinguishing Each Mark" Entirely
Third, shame with regard to the dharma. It means thinking thus: if I commit evil, I will thereby obstruct the holy life cultivated within the well-taught dharma and discipline; wherever this evil exists, it thereby destroys the holy life. This is called the power of discernment's third place.
三者、法處羞恥。謂作是思:我若作惡,便為障礙於善說法毗奈耶中所修梵行;此法若有,便壞梵行。是名第三處思擇力。
Third, shame with regard to the dharma. It means thinking thus: if I commit evil, I will thereby obstruct the holy life cultivated within the well-taught dharma and discipline; wherever this evil exists, it thereby destroys the holy life. This is called the power of discernment's third place.
With this, shame with regard to the dharma (巳三法處羞恥) closes entirely, closing distinguishing each mark (辰一別辨相3: 他處/自處/法處羞恥) entirely — reflecting on dependent origination itself, an evil deed, however illusion-like, still bears its own illusion-like fruit, directly obstructing and destroying the very holy life one seeks to cultivate — a third, doctrinally-grounded source of shame.
116. Section: Concluding the Essential Meaning, Closing "Explaining," "Able to Accompany Shame," "Distinguishing Its Function," and "Discernment" Entirely
Such shame, one should know, has three places as its increase: first, the world's increase; second, one's own increase; third, the dharma's increase.
如是羞恥,當知三處以為增上。一、世增上,二、自增上,三、法增上。
Such shame, one should know, has three places as its increase: first, the world's increase; second, one's own increase; third, the dharma's increase.
With this, concluding the essential meaning (辰二結略義) closes entirely, closing explaining (卯三釋2: 別辨相/結略義) entirely, closing **able to accompany shame (寅三能伴羞恥3: 標/徵/釋) entirely**, closing **distinguishing its function (丑二辨業用3: 能成二事/能正修習/能伴羞恥) entirely**, closing **discernment (子一思擇2: 標得名/辨業用), the first of the embrace of the powers' six sections, entirely** — the world's, one's own, and the dharma's own increase together sustain the shame that discernment's power accompanies. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this section to a substantial cluster of companion sūtras teaching discernment (數力) and cultivation (修力) as a matched pair of powers — reflecting in a forest or beneath a tree that bodily, verbal, and mental evil conduct brings present and future retribution, self-reproach, censure by the wise, and eventual descent to the hells, thereby severing evil and cultivating good in turn; discernment maturing into cultivation, which perfects the four foundations of mindfulness and, ultimately, all nine dharmas (faith, diligence, mindfulness, concentration, wisdom, shame-with-regard-to-self, shame-with-regard-to-others, discernment, and cultivation) unpacked further in companion sūtras 54 and 55; and the four paths (preparatory, uninterrupted, liberation, and further advancement) and four dharma-phrases (well-spoken by the noble, spoken with love, spoken truthfully, spoken in accordance with the dharma) that discernment and cultivation together bring to completion.
117. Section: Awakened Wisdom and the Rest Begins — Marking and Listing
Further, through the increase of conduct that benefits oneself and conduct that benefits others, one should know that four powers are established: first, the power of awakened wisdom; second, the power of diligence; third, the power of blamelessness; fourth, the power of embracing others.
復次,由自利行及利他行為增上故,當知建立有四種力。一、覺慧力,二、精進力,三、無罪力,四、攝受力。
Further, through the increase of conduct that benefits oneself and conduct that benefits others, one should know that four powers are established: first, the power of awakened wisdom; second, the power of diligence; third, the power of blamelessness; fourth, the power of embracing others.
This opens awakened wisdom and the rest (子二覺慧等2), the second of the embrace of the powers' six sections, named by the verse's first phrase's second half "awakened wisdom and the rest" (思擇覺慧等), beginning with marking and listing (丑一標列) — four powers together strengthen both self-benefiting and other-benefiting conduct: the power of awakened wisdom (discerning, across six pairs, what is blameworthy or blameless, what should be cultivated or avoided, base or noble, dark or bright, discriminated or non-discriminated, and dependently-originated or not), the power of diligence (the same four right efforts underlying every other power), the power of blamelessness (sustained inward examination of body, speech, and mind, confessing and resolving never to repeat any fault found), and the power of embracing others (the four means of embrace — giving, kind speech, beneficial conduct, and cooperation — detailed further, per Master Cháng Bǎi, in the Bodhisattva Ground, fascicle 43, where these four are further unfolded into nine practices). Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows before further closure is claimed.
118. Section: Correlating and Explaining Begins — Toward One's Own Benefit Begins — Marking the Distinction
Being able to go to nirvāṇa within the present dharma is called one's own benefit; being able to go to a fortunate destiny among humans and gods is also called one's own benefit.
能往現法涅槃,名為自義;能往人天善趣,亦名自義。
Being able to go to nirvāṇa within the present dharma is called one's own benefit; being able to go to a fortunate destiny among humans and gods is also called one's own benefit.
This opens correlating and explaining (丑二配釋2), the second of awakened wisdom and the rest's two matters, beginning with toward one's own benefit (寅一於自義2), beginning with marking the distinction (卯一標差別) — the first three of the four powers (awakened wisdom, diligence, blamelessness) all serve one's own benefit, which itself divides into two: present-life nirvāṇa (decisive excellence) and a fortunate rebirth among humans and gods (heightened existence).
119. Section: Correlating Their Establishment Begins — Able to Give Rise to Skillful Means
One should know that, here, relying on the first kind of one's own benefit, the two powers of awakened wisdom and diligence are established. Through these two powers, one is able, through skillful means, to give rise to right effort.
當知此中,依第一自義,建立覺慧、精進二力。由是二力,能有方便發起正勤。
One should know that, here, relying on the first kind of one's own benefit, the two powers of awakened wisdom and diligence are established. Through these two powers, one is able, through skillful means, to give rise to right effort.
This opens correlating their establishment (卯二配建立2), the second of toward one's own benefit's two matters, beginning with able to give rise to skillful means (辰一能起方便) — awakened wisdom (discerning dependent origination and wholesome from unwholesome dharmas) and diligence together establish, through skillful means, the right efforts that carry a practitioner toward present-life nirvāṇa, each reinforcing the other in a virtuous cycle of awakening and renewed effort.
120. Section: Able to Reach Finality, Closing "Correlating Their Establishment" and "Toward One's Own Benefit" Entirely
Relying on the second kind of one's own benefit, the power of blamelessness is established. Through these three powers, every kind of one's own benefit reaches its finality.
依第二自義,立無罪力。由此三力,一切自義皆得究竟。
Relying on the second kind of one's own benefit, the power of blamelessness is established. Through these three powers, every kind of one's own benefit reaches its finality.
With this, able to reach finality (辰二能得究竟) closes entirely, closing correlating their establishment (卯二配建立2: 能起方便/能得究竟) entirely, closing **toward one's own benefit (寅一於自義2: 標差別/配建立), the first of correlating and explaining's two matters, entirely** — the power of blamelessness (freedom from the ten unwholesome deeds) secures, at minimum, a fortunate rebirth even where present-life nirvāṇa is not reached; together, all three powers bring every kind of one's own benefit to complete finality.
121. Section: Toward the Benefit of Others Begins — Manifesting Its Establishment
For one who delights in benefiting others, the benefit of others still remains. Through this increase, the power of embracing others is established.
樂利他者,他義有餘。由此增上,立攝受力。
For one who delights in benefiting others, the benefit of others still remains. Through this increase, the power of embracing others is established.
This opens toward the benefit of others (寅二於他義2), the second of correlating and explaining's two matters, beginning with manifesting its establishment (卯一明建立) — a bodhisattva who delights in benefiting others, since the first three powers alone address only one's own benefit, requires this fourth, remaining power — the power of embracing others through the four means of embrace — to genuinely accomplish others' welfare.
122. Section: Pointing to the Matters of Embrace, Closing "Toward the Benefit of Others," "Correlating and Explaining," and "Awakened Wisdom and the Rest" Entirely
One should know that the matters of embrace should be known in their marks as already distinguished in the Bodhisattva Ground.
當知攝事,如菩薩地已辯其相。
One should know that the matters of embrace should be known in their marks as already distinguished in the Bodhisattva Ground.
With this, pointing to the matters of embrace (卯二指攝事) closes entirely, closing toward the benefit of others (寅二於他義2: 明建立/指攝事) entirely, closing **correlating and explaining (丑二配釋2: 於自義/於他義) entirely**, closing **awakened wisdom and the rest (子二覺慧等2: 標列/配釋), the second of the embrace of the powers' six sections, entirely** — the four means of embrace, fully unpacked in the Bodhisattva Ground, fascicle 43 (and also in fascicles 41-42's own treatment of the precept of benefiting sentient beings), are here simply pointed to rather than re-explained, since the first three powers alone cannot accomplish another's benefit, per the 披尋記. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this section to a substantial cluster of companion sūtras (13 through 29): three overlapping triads of power (faith-diligence-wisdom, faith-mindfulness-wisdom, faith-concentration-wisdom, faith and wisdom being the two indispensable anchors, the other three serving as helpers) that together compose the five powers; two further four-power groupings that likewise reduce to the five powers plus this section's own four (awakened wisdom, diligence, blamelessness, embrace); a ranking of each of the four means of embrace's own supreme form (dharma-giving as supreme among giving; timely dharma-teaching as supreme among loving speech; establishing others in wholesome roots as supreme among beneficial conduct; and meeting each person exactly at their own attainment as supreme among cooperation); a verse likening the four means of embrace to a cart's linchpin, without which filial devotion between parent and child, and the very possibility of noble and sagely virtue benefiting the world, would collapse entirely; and a teaching that mastering these four powers frees a practitioner from five fears — of not surviving, of ill repute, of public assemblies, of death, and of an unfortunate rebirth — since blameless conduct and sustained mindfulness leave nothing left to fear.
123. Section: The Nation and the Various Kings Begins — Marking Their Establishment
Further, relying on the nation and the king, whether male or female, whether husband or wife, whether foolish or wise, whether dwelling as a householder or as one gone forth, one should know that ten kinds of power are established.
復次,依國及王、若男、若女、若夫、若妻、若愚、若智、若處居家、若出家眾,當知建立有十種力。
Further, relying on the nation and the king, whether male or female, whether husband or wife, whether foolish or wise, whether dwelling as a householder or as one gone forth, one should know that ten kinds of power are established.
This opens the nation and the various kings (子三國及王等2), the third of the embrace of the powers' six sections, named by the verse's second phrase "the nation and the rest, and the various kings" (國等及諸王), beginning with marking their establishment (丑一標建立) — ten powers are established by drawing an analogy across ten kinds of worldly figures and stations, from the ruling king down to the renunciant.
124. Section: Pointing to What the Sūtra Teaches, Closing "The Nation and the Various Kings" Entirely
That is, the various kings possess the power of sovereignty. Such powers as these are extensively explained as in the sūtra.
謂諸國王有自在力。如是等力,廣說如經。
That is, the various kings possess the power of sovereignty. Such powers as these are extensively explained as in the sūtra.
With this, pointing to what the sūtra teaches (丑二指經說) closes entirely, closing **the nation and the various kings (子三國及王等2: 標建立/指經說), the third of the embrace of the powers' six sections, entirely** — a companion sūtra catalogs ten such worldly powers, each figure showing forth their own characteristic strength: the sovereign king's own authority; the deciding minister's own judgment; the skilled artisan's own craft; the bandit's own blade; a resentful woman's own unrelenting grudge; a crying infant's own wail (the only means it has to make its needs known); the foolish person's own habit of criticizing whatever they encounter; the wise person's own careful, penetrating observation; the renunciant's own patience (through which, as the sūtra says, "every dharma is accomplished"); and the well-read person's own capacity to infer the whole from a single part. This tenfold folk-wisdom catalog offers, alongside the doctrinal ten powers, a second sūtra's own worldly analogy for what "power" itself can mean, mapped loosely onto occupation and social role.
125. Section: The Arhat Begins — General Marking
Further, the various arhats accomplish eight powers, truly experiencing that craving, aversion, delusion, and the rest are permanently exhausted without remainder, no longer committing any evil, and cultivating every good.
復次,諸阿羅漢成就八力,如實領受貪瞋癡等永盡無餘,不造諸惡,修習諸善。
Further, the various arhats accomplish eight powers, truly experiencing that craving, aversion, delusion, and the rest are permanently exhausted without remainder, no longer committing any evil, and cultivating every good.
This opens the arhat (子四阿羅漢2), the fourth of the embrace of the powers' six sections, named by the verse's third phrase's first half "the arhat" (阿羅漢有學), beginning with general marking (丑一總標) — the arhat's eight powers (weariness toward future existence, weariness toward the desires, the foundations of mindfulness, right effort, the bases of supernormal power, the faculties and powers, the factors of enlightenment, and the path-factors) together confirm that every affliction has been permanently exhausted, manifesting in the complete absence of evil conduct and the sustained cultivation of good.
126. Section: Separately Explaining Begins — Not Committing Any Evil Begins — Through Weariness Toward Future Existence
That is, because the mind tends toward seclusion, toward renunciation, and toward parinirvāṇa, one wearies of and turns away from future existence. Through the cause and condition of this weariness and turning away, one does not commit evil karma.
謂心趣向遠離、出離、般涅槃故,厭背後有。厭背因緣,不造惡業。
That is, because the mind tends toward seclusion, toward renunciation, and toward parinirvāṇa, one wearies of and turns away from future existence. Through the cause and condition of this weariness and turning away, one does not commit evil karma.
This opens separately explaining (丑二別釋2), beginning with not committing any evil (寅一不造諸惡2), beginning with through weariness toward future existence (卯一由厭後有) — per the 披尋記, tending toward seclusion means tending away from desire and the various unwholesome dharmas; tending toward renunciation means tending away from the household life's own cramped, oppressive suffering; and tending toward parinirvāṇa means tending toward the sublime realm of nirvāṇa without remainder — this threefold tendency wearies the arhat of future existence entirely, and this very weariness is what forestalls any further evil karma.
127. Section: Through Weariness Toward the Various Desires
Further, seeing the various desires as just like a portion of burning charcoal, one wearies of and turns away from the various desires. Through the cause and condition of this weariness and turning away, one does not commit evil karma.
又見諸欲猶如一分熱炭火故,厭背諸欲。厭背因緣,不造惡業。
Further, seeing the various desires as just like a portion of burning charcoal, one wearies of and turns away from the various desires. Through the cause and condition of this weariness and turning away, one does not commit evil karma.
This opens through weariness toward the various desires (卯二由厭諸欲), the second — seeing the desires themselves as a live coal, dangerous to grasp no matter how enticing its glow, the arhat wearies of and turns entirely away from them, and this weariness likewise forestalls further evil karma. Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows before further closure is claimed.
128. Section: Cultivating Every Good Begins — Marking
Through these two powers, one does not commit any evil. Because one does not commit evil, one, moreover, cultivates every good through six gateways.
由此二力,不造諸惡。不造惡故,復由六門修習諸善。
Through these two powers, one does not commit any evil. Because one does not commit evil, one, moreover, cultivates every good through six gateways.
This opens cultivating every good (寅二修習諸善2), the second of separately explaining's two matters, beginning with marking (卯一標) — freed of evil conduct through the two powers of weariness (toward future existence and toward the desires), the arhat's remaining six powers actively cultivate every wholesome dharma through six further gateways.
129. Section: Listing, Closing "Cultivating Every Good," "Separately Explaining," and "The Arhat" Entirely
That is: the foundations of mindfulness, right effort, the bases of supernormal power, the faculties and powers, the factors of enlightenment, and the path-factors.
謂念住、正斷、神足、根力、覺支、道支。
That is: the foundations of mindfulness, right effort, the bases of supernormal power, the faculties and powers, the factors of enlightenment, and the path-factors.
With this, listing (卯二列) closes entirely, closing cultivating every good (寅二修習諸善2: 標/列) entirely, closing **separately explaining (丑二別釋2: 不造諸惡/修習諸善) entirely**, closing **the arhat (子四阿羅漢2: 總標/別釋), the fourth of the embrace of the powers' six sections, entirely** — the six gateways of good (the foundations of mindfulness, right effort, the bases of supernormal power, the faculties and powers together, the factors of enlightenment, and the eightfold path) together with the two powers of weariness complete the arhat's own eight powers. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this teaching to a cluster of companion sūtras: the Tathāgata's own six powers of knowledge (knowing what accords or does not accord with reason; knowing every being's karmic ripening across the three times; knowing every meditative attainment; knowing every being's own past lives; possessing the pure heavenly eye to see where beings are reborn; and having severed every affliction, attaining both mental and wisdom liberation) that let him turn the wheel of the pure dharma and roar the lion's roar; a sevenfold power (faith, diligence, mindfulness, concentration, wisdom, shame with regard to self, and shame with regard to others) able to exhaust every outflow; and an eightfold folk-power grouping repeating the earlier tenfold worldly analogy in abbreviated form. A further sūtra distinguishes the Buddha's own wisdom-liberation from the arhat's, comparing the śrāvaka's own wisdom to an infant's own: just as a wet-nurse must, at first, reach into an infant's mouth to remove what should not be swallowed, causing distress but ensuring safety, until the child grows wise enough to know better on its own, so too the Buddha instructs, sometimes sternly, his still-learning disciples, until their wisdom, like the arhat's, no longer needs such correction — the Buddha alone having awakened to dependent origination entirely without a teacher, and alone able to establish the very precepts and paths that his disciples, however accomplished, still rely upon him to have first taught.
130. Section: The Trainee Begins — Setting Out What the Buddha Taught
Further, the various buddha-tathāgatas, by way of self-benefiting conduct and other-benefiting conduct, in order to manifest their own distinction from their various disciples, speak thus: the various trainees accomplish five powers; only the tathāgata accomplishes ten powers.
復次,諸佛如來依自利行及利他行,為欲顯己與諸弟子有差別故,說如是言:諸有學者成就五力,唯有如來成就十力。
Further, the various buddha-tathāgatas, by way of self-benefiting conduct and other-benefiting conduct, in order to manifest their own distinction from their various disciples, speak thus: the various trainees accomplish five powers; only the tathāgata accomplishes ten powers.
This opens the trainee (子五有學2), the fifth of the embrace of the powers' six sections, named by the verse's third phrase's second half "the trainee" (阿羅漢有學), beginning with setting out what the Buddha taught (丑一出佛說) — the Tathāgata himself draws this distinction, to manifest his own supremacy: trainees accomplish only five powers (faith, diligence, mindfulness, concentration, wisdom), while only the Tathāgata accomplishes the full ten (knowledge of what is possible and impossible, of karmic ripening, of every meditative attainment, of faculties' relative strength, of every kind of resolve, of every kind of disposition, of every path's destination, of past lives, of death and rebirth, and of the exhaustion of every outflow). Per the 披尋記, these five powers, possessing great, overwhelming force, subdue every army of Māra and are able to realize the permanent exhaustion of every outflow — hence the name "power."
131. Section: Manifesting Their Meaning Begins — Toward the Various Trainees
If there are noble disciples who accomplish the trainee's five powers, practicing self-benefiting conduct, they attain the most supreme fruit of arhatship; from this point on, without interruption, every kind of their own benefit reaches finality.
若有成就有學五力,行自利行諸聖弟子,獲得最上阿羅漢果,從此無間,一切自義皆得究竟。
If there are noble disciples who accomplish the trainee's five powers, practicing self-benefiting conduct, they attain the most supreme fruit of arhatship; from this point on, without interruption, every kind of their own benefit reaches finality.
This opens manifesting their meaning (丑二顯彼義2), the second of the trainee's two matters, beginning with toward the various trainees (寅一於諸有學) — the trainee's own five powers, cultivated through self-benefiting conduct, lead without interruption to arhatship's own supreme fruit, at which point every kind of self-benefit reaches its complete finality.
132. Section: Toward the Various Tathāgatas Begins — Briefly Distinguishing the Marks Begins — Accomplishing Two Kinds of Conduct
The Tathāgata, having already attained arhatship, accomplishes ten powers, practicing other-benefiting conduct, taking benefiting others as his very own benefit. Supposing that, at such a time, every matter of transforming beings reaches its finality, and he enters the realm of nirvāṇa without remainder — one should know that, at that time, the task to be accomplished is only then brought to completion.
如來獲得阿羅漢已,成就十力,行利他行,即用利他以為自義。設於是時,一切所化其事究竟,入無餘依般涅槃界,當知爾時,於所作事方得圓滿。
The Tathāgata, having already attained arhatship, accomplishes ten powers, practicing other-benefiting conduct, taking benefiting others as his very own benefit. Supposing that, at such a time, every matter of transforming beings reaches its finality, and he enters the realm of nirvāṇa without remainder — one should know that, at that time, the task to be accomplished is only then brought to completion.
This opens toward the various tathāgatas (寅二於諸如來2), the second of manifesting their meaning's two matters, beginning with briefly distinguishing the marks (卯一略辨相2), beginning with accomplishing two kinds of conduct (辰一成就二行) — the Tathāgata, already having attained arhatship's own self-benefit, takes benefiting others as his very own benefit instead, his task only reaching complete fulfillment once every being he can transform has been transformed and he enters nirvāṇa without remainder.
133. Section: Manifesting Its Excellence, Closing "Briefly Distinguishing the Marks" Entirely
Whether the arhat-conduct that is cultivated, or the conduct of taking benefiting others as one's very own benefit — these two causes and conditions, relative to the various disciples, are both supreme.
若所修行阿羅漢行,若為利他即自義行,此二因緣,於諸弟子皆為殊勝。
Whether the arhat-conduct that is cultivated, or the conduct of taking benefiting others as one's very own benefit — these two causes and conditions, relative to the various disciples, are both supreme.
With this, manifesting its excellence (辰二顯其殊勝) closes entirely, closing briefly distinguishing the marks (卯一略辨相2: 成就二行/顯其殊勝) entirely — both the Tathāgata's own arhat-conduct and his conduct of taking others' benefit as his own surpass what any disciple, however accomplished, attains — a double excellence unique to the Buddha alone.
134. Section: Pointing to the Fuller Explanation, Closing "Toward the Various Tathāgatas," "Manifesting Their Meaning," and "The Trainee" Entirely
The Tathāgata's ten powers should be known in their marks as already broadly distinguished in the Bodhisattva Ground.
如來十力,如菩薩地已廣分別。
The Tathāgata's ten powers should be known in their marks as already broadly distinguished in the Bodhisattva Ground.
With this, pointing to the fuller explanation (卯二指廣說) closes entirely, closing **toward the various tathāgatas (寅二於諸如來2: 略辨相/指廣說) entirely**, closing **manifesting their meaning (丑二顯彼義2: 於諸有學/於諸如來) entirely**, closing **the trainee (子五有學2: 出佛說/顯彼義), the fifth of the embrace of the powers' six sections, entirely** — the Tathāgata's ten powers are pointed, once more, to the Bodhisattva Ground's own establishment chapter, fascicles 49-50, for their fuller treatment. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this section to a cluster of companion sūtras teaching the five powers (variously named faith-diligence-mindfulness-concentration-wisdom or faith-diligence-shame-conscience-wisdom, each correlated to the four confirmed purities, the four right efforts, the four foundations, the four dhyānas, and the four noble truths in turn), the mutual encouragement or censure a community owes a wavering or steadfast practitioner, and, once more, the wet-nurse simile distinguishing the śrāvaka's five learning-powers (aimed at self-benefit alone) from the Tathāgata's own ten powers, through which he genuinely benefits both himself and others at once.
135. Section: Uprightness Begins — Marking and Distinguishing What It Relies Upon
Further, if there is a person who cherishes themselves, is without flattery and without deceit, and whose nature is upright, then, in order to realize their own benefit, there are four marks. If one relies on a badly-taught dharma and discipline, there is delay and hindrance; only by relying on a well-taught dharma and discipline is there no delay or hindrance.
復次,若有自愛、無諂無誑、其性質直補特伽羅,為證自義,有四種相。若依惡說法毗奈耶,便有稽留;要依善說法毗奈耶,乃無稽留。
Further, if there is a person who cherishes themselves, is without flattery and without deceit, and whose nature is upright, then, in order to realize their own benefit, there are four marks. If one relies on a badly-taught dharma and discipline, there is delay and hindrance; only by relying on a well-taught dharma and discipline is there no delay or hindrance.
This opens uprightness (子六質直3), the sixth and final of the embrace of the powers' six sections, named by the verse's fourth phrase's first half "uprightness, coming last" (質直最為後), beginning with marking and distinguishing what it relies upon (丑一標簡所依) — a person who genuinely cherishes themselves, free of flattery and deceit, of upright nature, achieves their own benefit (either a fortunate rebirth or present-life nirvāṇa) through four marks, but only within a well-taught dharma and discipline; an outside path's own rules, however elaborate (even something as arbitrary as vowing to imitate a cow's or a dog's conduct), only ever delay and obstruct. Per 攝事分, fascicle 89, flattery is a crooked, unclear, undisclosed, deceptively-practiced mind — outwardly compliant while inwardly biased, never honestly revealing one's true thought — and deceit is deliberately misleading another, harboring one intention while displaying another, closely bound up with wrong livelihood; a genuinely self-cherishing person, needing neither to flatter a teacher nor practice wrong livelihood, delights in practice for its own sake, showing the same face outwardly as they hold inwardly.
136. Section: Separately Explaining the Four Marks Begins — Questioning
What are the four marks?
云何四相?
What are the four marks?
This opens separately explaining the four marks (丑二別釋四相3), beginning with questioning (寅一徵).
137. Section: Listing
First, expounding the teaching of the true dharma; second, instruction and exhortation; third, penetrating it in accordance with principle; fourth, attaining true realization.
一、說正法教,二、教授教誡,三、如理通達,四、得真實證。
First, expounding the teaching of the true dharma; second, instruction and exhortation; third, penetrating it in accordance with principle; fourth, attaining true realization.
This opens listing (寅二列), the second of separately explaining the four marks' three matters — hearing the true dharma's right teaching (freeing one from doctrines of no cause or false cause), receiving unmistaken instruction and exhortation in concentration and wisdom together with precepts, applying principled attention and thereby penetrating the dharma through hearing- and thinking-wisdom, and finally, truly realizing the ultimate truth through uncontaminated cultivation-wisdom — these four marks together constitute genuine accomplishment of one's own benefit.
138. Section: Explaining Begins — Expounding the Teaching of the True Dharma
The true dharma that is heard is the very support for every kind of confident understanding, since it is able to be free of causelessness and false causation, expounding the meaning of a right cause that accords with principle.
所聞正法,是諸勝解所依止處。由能遠離無因、惡因,開示稱理正因義故。
The true dharma that is heard is the very support for every kind of confident understanding, since it is able to be free of causelessness and false causation, expounding the meaning of a right cause that accords with principle.
This opens explaining (寅三釋3), the third of separately explaining the four marks' three matters, beginning with expounding the teaching of the true dharma (卯一說正法教) — the true dharma, once heard, becomes the very ground upon which every subsequent confident understanding rests, precisely because it teaches genuine causality, free of both the denial of cause and the misattribution of a false one. Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows before further closure is claimed.
139. Section: Instruction and Exhortation
Every unmistaken instruction and exhortation, skillfully according with the preparatory practice of severance, embraces, within its teaching's letter and meaning, the unmistaken dharma, and is able to bring about the realization of the very dharma that serves as the support for confident understanding, as said before.
諸有無倒教授教誡,善能隨順斷加行教文義所攝無顛倒法,能令證得如前勝解所依處法。
Every unmistaken instruction and exhortation, skillfully according with the preparatory practice of severance, embraces, within its teaching's letter and meaning, the unmistaken dharma, and is able to bring about the realization of the very dharma that serves as the support for confident understanding, as said before.
This opens instruction and exhortation (卯二教授教誡), the second of separately explaining the four marks' three matters — the upright practitioner draws near a good teacher and receives unmistaken instruction in concentration and wisdom together with exhortation in precepts, the teaching's own letter and meaning both free of the self-clinging and the four inverted views, this purifying teaching bringing the practitioner to the very confident understanding named in the first mark.
140. Section: Penetrating in Accordance with Principle and the Rest Begins — General Marking
If there is a self-cherishing good man whose continuum has already been tamed, possessing capability, who comes to enter the inner dharma's discipline, attains right proclamation and right awakening, then he is able to swiftly advance toward what should be advanced toward, penetrating, in accordance with principle, what should be penetrated, and also truly realizing what should truly be realized.
若有自愛諸善男子,已調相續,有所堪能,來入內法毗奈耶中,得正宣說、得正開悟,便能速疾趣向勝進,如理通達所應通達,亦能實證真所應證。
If there is a self-cherishing good man whose continuum has already been tamed, possessing capability, who comes to enter the inner dharma's discipline, attains right proclamation and right awakening, then he is able to swiftly advance toward what should be advanced toward, penetrating, in accordance with principle, what should be penetrated, and also truly realizing what should truly be realized.
This opens penetrating in accordance with principle and the rest (卯三如理通達等2), the third of separately explaining the four marks' three matters, beginning with general marking (辰一總標) — a self-cherishing practitioner whose continuum is already tamed and capable, entering the inner dharma's own discipline and receiving right proclamation and right awakening, swiftly advances, genuinely penetrating and genuinely realizing what should be — combining the third and fourth marks together.
141. Section: Separately Explaining Begins — Penetrating in Accordance with Principle
That is, taking the four foundations of mindfulness as the support, toward conditioned dharmas, whatever the various wise ones commonly agree exists, or commonly agree does not exist, one rightly knows all of it. Toward the unconditioned dharma, up to the peak of existence, all of it has something higher; one rightly knows this as having something higher. Nirvāṇa has nothing higher; one truly knows this as having nothing higher. This is called penetrating in accordance with principle.
謂四念住以為依止,於有為法,諸聰慧者共許為有、或許為無,皆正了知。於無為法,乃至有頂皆是有上,能正了知是為有上;涅槃無上,如實了知是為無上。如是名為如理通達。
That is, taking the four foundations of mindfulness as the support, toward conditioned dharmas, whatever the various wise ones commonly agree exists, or commonly agree does not exist, one rightly knows all of it. Toward the unconditioned dharma, up to the peak of existence, all of it has something higher; one rightly knows this as having something higher. Nirvāṇa has nothing higher; one truly knows this as having nothing higher. This is called penetrating in accordance with principle.
This opens separately explaining (辰二別釋2), beginning with penetrating in accordance with principle (巳一如理通達) — resting on the four foundations of mindfulness, the practitioner rightly discerns conditioned dharmas as impermanent (what the wise commonly affirm exists or does not), and, toward the unconditioned, recognizes that everything up through the peak of existence still has something higher, while nirvāṇa alone has nothing higher at all. Per the 披尋記, the unconditioned discussed here is specifically the non-analytical cessation — a mere absence due to missing conditions, not the analytical cessation wisdom actively brings about — and even the form and formless realms' own "unmoved" states are only temporarily free of manifest affliction, not permanently severed of its seed, and are therefore still classed as having something higher; nirvāṇa, conjoined with non-discriminating wisdom, alone is truly unsurpassed.
142. Section: Attaining True Realization, Closing "Separately Explaining," "Penetrating in Accordance with Principle and the Rest," "Explaining," and "Separately Explaining the Four Marks" Entirely
Further, taking the four foundations of mindfulness as the support, through a mind stilled in concentration, having already rightly cultivated the seven factors of enlightenment, one ultimately realizes clear liberation. This is called attaining true realization.
又四念住以為依止,由靜定心,於七覺支正修習已,於明解脫究竟作證。如是名為得真實證。
Further, taking the four foundations of mindfulness as the support, through a mind stilled in concentration, having already rightly cultivated the seven factors of enlightenment, one ultimately realizes clear liberation. This is called attaining true realization.
With this, attaining true realization (巳二得真實證) closes entirely, closing separately explaining (辰二別釋2: 如理通達/得真實證) entirely, closing penetrating in accordance with principle and the rest (卯三如理通達等2: 總標/別釋) entirely, closing **explaining (寅三釋3: 說正法教/教授教誡/如理通達等) entirely**, closing **separately explaining the four marks (丑二別釋四相3: 徵/列/釋) entirely** — resting again on the four foundations, a still, concentrated mind cultivating the seven factors of enlightenment ultimately realizes clear liberation itself — the fourth and final mark, completing the upright practitioner's full accomplishment of their own benefit.
143. Section: Distinguishing the Name "Delay and Hindrance," Closing "Uprightness" and the Entire Embrace of the Powers Entirely
If that self-cherishing good man enters a badly-taught dharma and discipline, he is unable to attain any of these four places; therefore this is called delay and hindrance.
若彼自愛諸善男子,趣入惡說法毗奈耶,於是四處皆不能得,故名稽留。
If that self-cherishing good man enters a badly-taught dharma and discipline, he is unable to attain any of these four places; therefore this is called delay and hindrance.
With this, distinguishing the name "delay and hindrance" (丑三簡名稽留) closes entirely, closing **uprightness (子六質直3: 標簡所依/別釋四相/簡名稽留), the sixth and final of the embrace of the powers' six sections, entirely** — the very same self-cherishing good man who, entering a badly-taught outside path instead, attains none of the four marks, remains stalled in the ordinary being's own condition, unable even to reach a fortunate rebirth, let alone nirvāṇa. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this closing section to a cluster of companion sūtras: further teachings on the Tathāgata's own ten powers (both extensively and briefly stated), the four kinds of fearlessness these powers produce, and, correlated one by one to the four marks, an upright disciple's own reception of unmistaken instruction, penetrating understanding of what has something higher and what has nothing higher, and the trainee's five powers set once more against the Tathāgata's ten. **With this section's closure, the embrace of the powers (壬四力攝2: 思擇/覺慧等/國等及諸王/阿羅漢/有學/質直), the fourth of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics, closes in its complete entirety.**
144. Section: The Embrace of the Factors of Enlightenment Begins — The Verse Marking and Listing
Further, a summary verse says: establishing them, their distinctions; their food, the gradual sequence; ease, and abiding; cultivation, coming last.
復次,嗢柁南曰:
Further, a summary verse says:
立差別 食漸次 安樂住 修居後
Establishing them, their distinctions; their food, the gradual sequence; ease, and abiding; cultivation, coming last.
This opens **the embrace of the factors of enlightenment (壬五覺支攝2), the fifth of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics**, named by the general summary verse's third line's first word "the factors of enlightenment" (覺道支息念) — treating the seven factors of enlightenment (念/擇法/精進/喜/安/定/捨) — beginning with the verse marking and listing (癸一頌標列) — seven matters unfold in the long-form explanation: establishing them, their distinctions, their nourishing food, the gradual sequence in which they arise, the ease they bring about, the abiding proper to them at every stage, and their own cultivation.
145. Section: The Long-Form Explanation Begins — Establishing Them, Closing "Establishing Them" Entirely
Through the distinct classes of calm-abiding, insight, and both together, the factors of enlightenment are established. This should be known in its marks as in the Śrāvaka Ground.
由奢摩他、毗鉢舍那俱品差別,建立覺支。如聲聞地應知其相。
Through the distinct classes of calm-abiding, insight, and both together, the factors of enlightenment are established. This should be known in its marks as in the Śrāvaka Ground.
This opens the long-form explanation (癸二長行釋7), a sevenfold structure matching the verse's seven matters, beginning with establishing them (子一立), named by the verse's first phrase's first half "establishing them" (立差別) — with this section's closure, establishing them (子一立), the first of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, closes entirely, since it stands as a single, undivided matter. The Śrāvaka Ground, fascicle 29, distributes the seven factors across three classes: investigation of dharmas, diligence, and joy belong to insight's own class; pliancy, concentration, and equanimity belong to calm-abiding's own class; and mindfulness alone, pervading both classes equally, is called the universally-present factor, since both calm-abiding and insight equally depend upon it.
146. Section: Their Distinctions, Closing "Their Distinctions" Entirely
Further, through the distinction of their own nature, and through the distinction of their object-mark and causal mark, one should know that the seven factors of enlightenment have fourteen distinctions. The broadly distinguished meaning of the object-mark and causal mark should be known in its marks as in the Ground of Concentrated Cultivation and the Śrāvaka Ground.
復次,自性差別故,及所緣、因緣相差別故,應知七覺支,十四種差別。所緣、因緣相廣分別義,如三摩呬多地及聲聞地應知其相。
Further, through the distinction of their own nature, and through the distinction of their object-mark and causal mark, one should know that the seven factors of enlightenment have fourteen distinctions. The broadly distinguished meaning of the object-mark and causal mark should be known in its marks as in the Ground of Concentrated Cultivation and the Śrāvaka Ground.
With this, their distinctions (子二差別) closes entirely, since it, too, stands as a single, undivided matter, named by the verse's first phrase's second half "their distinctions" (立差別) — each of the seven factors doubles into two, yielding fourteen: mindfulness splits into inward and outward foundations of mindfulness; investigation of dharmas into discerning the wholesome and discerning the unwholesome; diligence into severing the unwholesome and nurturing the wholesome; joy into joy's own nature and its arising ground; pliancy into bodily and mental pliancy; concentration into its own nature (one-pointedness of mind) and its own mark; and equanimity into equanimity toward the wholesome and equanimity toward the unwholesome. The Compendium of Abhidharma, fascicle 10, identifies the seven factors' shared object as the four noble truths' own true nature (the ultimate, purifying object), and details each factor's own function: mindfulness as the supporting factor (through which every wholesome dharma is never forgotten), investigation of dharmas as the very essence of the path of seeing, diligence as the factor of transcendence, joy as the factor of benefit, and pliancy, concentration, and equanimity together as the undefiled factors (equanimity removing coarseness's fault, concentration effecting the very basis's transformation, and equanimity itself permanently removing craving and sorrow). Master Cháng Bǎi traces the fourteenfold distinction to a companion sūtra recounting how outside paths, challenged that they too teach severing the five hindrances, abiding in the four foundations, and cultivating the seven factors, left a group of monks unable to answer — until the Buddha revealed that the five hindrances themselves divide into ten (inward and outward craving; anger's own nature and its outward expression; heavy sleep and light torpor; restlessness and remorse; and doubt toward wholesome and toward unwholesome dharmas), matching the seven factors' own fourteen, and further taught that a weak, hesitant mind should cultivate investigation, diligence, and joy (fanning a small flame with dry kindling), while a restless, scattered mind should cultivate pliancy, concentration, and equanimity (smothering a roaring fire with spent embers) — mindfulness alone assisting at every time regardless.
147. Section: Their Food Begins — Raising What Serves as Food Begins — Marking
Further, among the dharmas that accord with the factors of enlightenment, there are, briefly, two kinds of unmistaken attention; one should know that these together serve as food for the factors of enlightenment.
復次,於能隨順覺支法中,略有二種無倒作意,當知總與覺支為食。
Further, among the dharmas that accord with the factors of enlightenment, there are, briefly, two kinds of unmistaken attention; one should know that these together serve as food for the factors of enlightenment.
This opens their food (子三食2), the third of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, named by the verse's second phrase's first half "their food" (食漸次), beginning with raising what serves as food (丑一舉為食3), beginning with marking (寅一標) — two kinds of unmistaken attention, briefly stated, serve as the very food that nourishes and strengthens the seven factors of enlightenment.
148. Section: Questioning
What are the two?
何等為二?
What are the two?
This opens questioning (寅二徵), the second of raising what serves as food's three matters. Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows before further closure is claimed.
149. Section: Listing, Closing "Raising What Serves as Food" Entirely
First, right attention; second, repeated attention.
一、正作意,二、數作意。
First, right attention; second, repeated attention.
With this, listing (寅三列) closes entirely, closing **raising what serves as food (丑一舉為食3: 標/徵/列) entirely** — right attention (attention conjoined with every buddha and bodhisattva's own compassionate wish to benefit beings, according with the wisdom of both self- and dharma-emptiness) and repeated attention (sustaining this right attention again and again) together serve as the very food that nourishes the seven factors of enlightenment toward realization.
150. Section: Reversing to What Is Not Food, Closing "Their Food" Entirely
The reverse of this, one should know, is not food.
與此相違,當知非食。
The reverse of this, one should know, is not food.
With this, reversing to what is not food (丑二翻非食) closes entirely, closing **their food (子三食2: 舉為食/翻非食), the third of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, entirely** — sustained unprincipled attention is what "non-food" names, starving the factors of enlightenment exactly as sustained principled attention nourishes them. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this section to a substantial cluster of companion sūtras detailing, in mirror-image pairs, what feeds and starves each of the five hindrances and seven factors in turn: craving is fed by a pleasing sign and starved by contemplating impurity; aversion is fed by a sense of obstruction and starved by cultivating loving-kindness; torpor is fed by weakness, displeasure, yawning, overeating, and laziness, and starved by contemplating light; restlessness-and-remorse is fed by thoughts of family, of companions, of the heavens, and of past pleasures, and starved by the nine stages of settling the mind; and doubt is fed by uncertainty across the three times, and starved by deep reflection on dependent origination. In parallel, mindfulness is fed by the four foundations and starved by neglecting them; investigation of dharmas is fed by discerning wholesome from unwholesome and starved by laziness in that discernment; diligence is fed by the four right efforts and starved by failing to examine one's own progress; joy is fed by reflecting on its own nature and its arising ground and starved by neglecting that reflection; pliancy is fed by attending to bodily and mental ease and starved by neglecting it; concentration is fed by the four dhyānas and starved by indifference toward them; and equanimity is fed by reflecting on the three realms of severance, freedom from desire, and cessation, and starved by neglecting that reflection — Master Cháng Bǎi further recounts a companion sūtra in which even Prince Abhaya, prompted by an outside teacher's doctrine of causelessness, receives the Buddha's correction that both affliction and purity arise through real causes and conditions, the five hindrances producing affliction and the seven factors producing purity, cultivated in their own proper, gradual sequence.
151. Section: The Gradual Sequence Begins — Marking Their Establishment
Further, at the beginning, in the middle, or at the end, lacking any single factor prevents true awakening from reaching completion. Just as, according to their own kind, the supporting and the supported flow onward and are established, so too, in accordance with their own arising, they are spoken of in a gradual sequence.
復次,於初中後隨闕一支,令如實覺不得圓滿。如其色類所依、能依流轉安立,隨其生起漸次而說。
Further, at the beginning, in the middle, or at the end, lacking any single factor prevents true awakening from reaching completion. Just as, according to their own kind, the supporting and the supported flow onward and are established, so too, in accordance with their own arising, they are spoken of in a gradual sequence.
This opens the gradual sequence (子四漸次2), the fourth of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, named by the verse's second phrase's second half "the gradual sequence" (食漸次), beginning with marking their establishment (丑一標安立) — missing even one of the seven factors, at any stage of practice, keeps true awakening from ever reaching completion; each factor supports the one that follows, and this supporting relationship is what "gradual sequence" describes.
152. Section: Explaining Their Mutual Support, Closing "The Gradual Sequence" Entirely
One should know that, here, mindfulness is the support, and investigation of dharmas is what is supported by it; one should know that the rest, in accordance with what is fitting, are likewise so.
當知此中,念為所依,擇法能依;餘隨所應,當知亦爾。
One should know that, here, mindfulness is the support, and investigation of dharmas is what is supported by it; one should know that the rest, in accordance with what is fitting, are likewise so.
With this, explaining their mutual support (丑二釋相依) closes entirely, closing **the gradual sequence (子四漸次2: 標安立/釋相依), the fourth of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, entirely** — mindfulness supports investigation of dharmas, which supports diligence, which supports joy, which supports pliancy, which supports concentration, which supports equanimity, each factor arising in turn from the one before. The Compendium of Dharma-Aggregates traces this chain explicitly: dwelling in the contemplation that follows the body, free of delusion, gives rise to the factor of mindfulness; discerning the body's own nature through that mindfulness gives rise to the factor of investigating dharmas; diligent effort free of faint-heartedness gives rise to the factor of diligence; supreme joy, free of craving's own savor, gives rise to the factor of joy; bodily and mental pliancy, free of coarseness, gives rise to the factor of pliancy; the ease born of that pliancy gives rise to the factor of concentration; and the concentrated mind's own extinguishing of craving and sorrow gives rise to the factor of equanimity — the same sequence repeating for feeling, mind, and dharmas as it does for the body.
153. Section: Ease Begins — Distinguishing Abiding Begins — Setting Out the Causes and Conditions Begins — Distinguishing the Difference Begins — Raising Failure to Abide Begins — Marking
Further, if there is a monk who, toward the various factors of enlightenment, cultivates them through skillful means, there are four causes and conditions that prevent him from dwelling securely at ease.
復次,若有苾芻,於諸覺支方便修習,由四因緣,令其不得安隱而住。
Further, if there is a monk who, toward the various factors of enlightenment, cultivates them through skillful means, there are four causes and conditions that prevent him from dwelling securely at ease.
This opens ease (子五安樂2), the fifth of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, named by the verse's third phrase's first half "ease" (安樂住), beginning with distinguishing abiding (丑一辨安住2), beginning with setting out the causes and conditions (寅一出因緣2), beginning with distinguishing the difference (卯一簡差別2), beginning with raising failure to abide (辰一舉不安住3), beginning with marking (巳一標) — even a monk diligently cultivating the seven factors of enlightenment through skillful means can still be kept from secure, easeful dwelling by four specific causes and conditions.
154. Section: Questioning
What are called the four causes and conditions?
何等名為四種因緣?
What are called the four causes and conditions?
This opens questioning (巳二徵), the second of raising failure to abide's three matters.
155. Section: Listing, Closing "Raising Failure to Abide" Entirely
First, because every class of affliction's own coarseness has not yet been abandoned; second, because the various secondary afflictions belonging to calm-abiding's own class are presently manifest; third, because the various secondary afflictions belonging to insight's own class are presently manifest; fourth, because the path has not yet been well tamed, and yet one rides upon it.
一者、一切煩惱品類麤重皆未離故;二者、奢摩他品諸隨煩惱現在前故;三者、毗鉢舍那品諸隨煩惱現在前故;四者、道未調善而乘駕故。
First, because every class of affliction's own coarseness has not yet been abandoned; second, because the various secondary afflictions belonging to calm-abiding's own class are presently manifest; third, because the various secondary afflictions belonging to insight's own class are presently manifest; fourth, because the path has not yet been well tamed, and yet one rides upon it.
With this, listing (巳三列) closes entirely, closing **raising failure to abide (辰一舉不安住3: 標/徵/列), the first of distinguishing the difference's two matters, entirely** — four causes prevent secure dwelling: every affliction's own underlying coarseness, unabandoned, leaves body and mind incapable; calm-abiding's own secondary afflictions (torpor and sleepiness) manifest when calming is overdone, obscuring the object; insight's own secondary afflictions (restlessness and remorse) manifest when investigation goes too far; and attempting to "ride" the path — practicing without genuine familiarity with how calm-abiding and insight actually operate together — leaves a practitioner unable to diagnose or correct their own difficulties.
156. Section: Reversing to Attained Abiding, Closing "Distinguishing the Difference" Entirely
The reverse of this, four causes and conditions, cause him to attain secure, easeful dwelling. That is: first, one should remedy affliction's own seed; second, one should remedy the torpor and sleepiness that obstruct calm-abiding's own class; third, one should remedy the restlessness, remorse, and doubt that obstruct insight's own class; fourth, one should thoroughly cultivate the noble path, so that the mind becomes tamed and sovereign.
與此相違,四種因緣,令其獲得安隱而住。即:一、應對治煩惱的種子,二、應對治能障奢摩他品的惛沈、睡眠煩惱,三、應對治能障毗鉢舍那品的掉舉惡作與疑,四、熟修聖道,則心能夠調善自在。
The reverse of this, four causes and conditions, cause him to attain secure, easeful dwelling. That is: first, one should remedy affliction's own seed; second, one should remedy the torpor and sleepiness that obstruct calm-abiding's own class; third, one should remedy the restlessness, remorse, and doubt that obstruct insight's own class; fourth, one should thoroughly cultivate the noble path, so that the mind becomes tamed and sovereign.
This opens reversing to attained abiding (辰二翻得安住), the second of distinguishing the difference's two matters — remedying affliction's own seed (not merely its manifest activity), remedying the torpor and sleepiness that obstruct calm-abiding, remedying the restlessness, remorse, and doubt that obstruct insight, and thoroughly cultivating the noble path until the mind is genuinely tamed rather than merely ridden upon, a monk attains secure, easeful dwelling within the seven factors of enlightenment. With this, distinguishing the difference (卯一簡差別2: 舉不安住/翻得安住) closes entirely.
157. Section: Concluding Right Knowledge, Closing "Setting Out the Causes and Conditions" Entirely
Toward these two kinds of skillful means, the monk, truly penetrating them, dwells with right knowledge.
於此二種善巧,苾芻如實了達,正知而住。
Toward these two kinds of skillful means, the monk, truly penetrating them, dwells with right knowledge.
With this, concluding right knowledge (卯二結正知) closes entirely, closing **setting out the causes and conditions (寅一出因緣2: 簡差別/結正知), the first of distinguishing abiding's two matters, entirely** — a monk who genuinely penetrates both what prevents and what secures easeful dwelling among the seven factors dwells with right knowledge throughout.
158. Section: Explaining the Difficult Point Begins — Raising the Untamed Path
Because the various attentions involve preparatory exertion, diligence becomes excessive; further, because there is increase and decrease from before to after, the operation is unequal. Through these two conditions, one should know this is called the path not yet well tamed.
由諸作意有加行故,精進太過;又由前後有增減故,運轉不等。由此二緣,當知名為道不調善。
Because the various attentions involve preparatory exertion, diligence becomes excessive; further, because there is increase and decrease from before to after, the operation is unequal. Through these two conditions, one should know this is called the path not yet well tamed.
This opens explaining the difficult point (寅二隨難釋2), the second of distinguishing abiding's two matters, beginning with raising the untamed path (卯一舉不調善) — attention applied too forcefully makes diligence excessive, and a sitting that starts balanced but later tips into restlessness or torpor makes the practice uneven from start to finish — both marks of a path not yet genuinely tamed.
159. Section: Reversing to the Name "Well Tamed," Closing "Explaining the Difficult Point" and "Distinguishing Abiding" Entirely
The reverse of this, through two causes and conditions, is called the path well tamed.
與此相違,二因緣故,名道調善。
The reverse of this, through two causes and conditions, is called the path well tamed.
With this, reversing to the name "well tamed" (卯二翻名調善) closes entirely, closing explaining the difficult point (寅二隨難釋2: 舉不調善/翻名調善) entirely, closing **distinguishing abiding (丑一辨安住2: 出因緣/隨難釋), the first of ease's two matters, entirely** — attention applied neither too forcefully nor too laxly, sustained evenly from beginning to end, is what "well tamed" names. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this section to a companion sūtra in which the elder Upavāna, questioned by the elder Aḍḍhamāsa about how a monk skilled in the seven factors can dwell equally at ease whether in pleasant or painful feeling, explains that mastering the four causes that obstruct abiding, then rightly cultivating each factor in its proper time — remedying torpor in calm-abiding, remedying restlessness in insight, and keeping effort neither excessive nor slack — allows the mind to remain undisturbed regardless of what feeling arises.
160. Section: The Simile of Sovereignty Begins — General Marking
Just as a wheel-turning king, attaining great sovereignty over the four continents, obtains the seven treasures — so too, one should know, the sovereign mind, attaining great sovereignty over the four noble truths, obtains the true, pure treasure of the seven factors of enlightenment, likewise.
如轉輪王,於四洲渚得大自在,所獲七寶;如是心王,於四聖諦得大自在,所獲真淨七覺支寶,當知亦爾。
Just as a wheel-turning king, attaining great sovereignty over the four continents, obtains the seven treasures — so too, one should know, the sovereign mind, attaining great sovereignty over the four noble truths, obtains the true, pure treasure of the seven factors of enlightenment, likewise.
This opens the simile of sovereignty (丑二喻自在2), the second of ease's two matters, beginning with general marking (寅一總標) — just as a wheel-turning king's sovereignty over the four continents comes with seven treasures that aid his rule, so too the mind that attains sovereignty over the four noble truths comes into possession of the seven factors of enlightenment as its own true, pure treasure.
161. Section: Separately Distinguishing Begins — The Simile for the Factor of Mindfulness
That is, operating within both the class of calm-abiding and the class of insight together, subduing every supreme enemy of affliction — by this meaning, the first, mindfulness, the factor of enlightenment, is just like the wheel treasure.
謂於奢摩他、毗鉢舍那雙品運轉,降伏一切煩惱勝怨。由此義故,初念覺支猶如輪寶。
That is, operating within both the class of calm-abiding and the class of insight together, subduing every supreme enemy of affliction — by this meaning, the first, mindfulness, the factor of enlightenment, is just like the wheel treasure.
This opens separately distinguishing (寅二別辨7), a sevenfold structure matching the seven treasures to the seven factors, beginning with the simile for the factor of mindfulness (卯一喻念覺支) — mindfulness, sustaining both calm-abiding and insight operating together upon the four noble truths, subdues affliction's every supreme enemy, just as the wheel treasure carries the wheel-turning king to all four continents, subduing every rival kingdom in turn.
162. Section: The Simile for the Factor of Investigating Dharmas
The mark of the known object is boundless in its measure, and the very substance of the knowing wisdom is likewise vast in accordance with it — by this meaning, the factor of investigating dharmas is just like the elephant treasure.
所知境相其量無邊,能知智體亦隨廣大。由此義故,擇法覺支猶如象寶。
The mark of the known object is boundless in its measure, and the very substance of the knowing wisdom is likewise vast in accordance with it — by this meaning, the factor of investigating dharmas is just like the elephant treasure.
This opens the simile for the factor of investigating dharmas (卯二喻擇法覺支), the second — investigation of dharmas' own wisdom, vast enough to match its boundless object, penetrating every dharma's own particular and shared characteristics alike, is likened to the six-tusked white elephant treasure, whose vast body carries the king across the entire world in a single day without fatigue, never even wetting its feet as it crosses the water.
163. Section: The Simile for the Factor of Diligence
Relying on this, one is swiftly able to go to the place of conduct, and attain the distinctly supreme place — by this meaning, the factor of diligence is just like the horse treasure.
依此速能,乃至往彼所行、所得殊異勝處。由此義故,精進覺支猶如馬寶。
Relying on this, one is swiftly able to go to the place of conduct, and attain the distinctly supreme place — by this meaning, the factor of diligence is just like the horse treasure.
This opens the simile for the factor of diligence (卯三喻精進覺支), the third — diligence swiftly carries the practitioner to ultimate truth's own supreme attainment, just as the horse treasure swiftly carries the king wherever he needs to go and back again by evening.
164. Section: The Simile for the Factor of Joy
Delighting the mind, without fault, most supreme of all — by this meaning, the factor of joy is just like the woman treasure.
悅意無罪,最為殊勝。由此義故,其喜覺支猶如女寶。
Delighting the mind, without fault, most supreme of all — by this meaning, the factor of joy is just like the woman treasure.
This opens the simile for the factor of joy (卯四喻喜覺支), the fourth — joy delights the mind entirely without fault, just as the woman treasure, virtuous, attentive, and graceful, attends the king with perfect care, sensing and meeting his every need before he must ask.
165. Section: The Simile for the Factor of Pliancy
Body and mind rendered luminous and clear, possessing capability — by this meaning, the factor of pliancy is just like the divine pearl treasure.
身心映徹,有所堪能。由此義故,輕安覺支如神珠寶。
Body and mind rendered luminous and clear, possessing capability — by this meaning, the factor of pliancy is just like the divine pearl treasure.
This opens the simile for the factor of pliancy (卯五喻輕安覺支), the fifth — pliancy renders body and mind luminously clear, capable of penetrating every dharma's own true mark, just as the divine pearl treasure, flawlessly transparent, faithfully reflects and illuminates whatever comes before it, even lighting an entire city through the night.
166. Section: The Simile for the Factor of Concentration
Able to accomplish every matter delighted in and sought — by this meaning, the factor of concentration is just like the treasurer-minister treasure.
能辦一切所欣求事。由此義故,其定覺支如藏臣寶。
Able to accomplish every matter delighted in and sought — by this meaning, the factor of concentration is just like the treasurer-minister treasure.
This opens the simile for the factor of concentration (卯六喻定覺支), the sixth — concentration accomplishes every matter a practitioner might seek, from insight's own cultivation through supernormal power and the exhaustion of every outflow, just as the treasurer-minister treasure, knowing where every hidden store of wealth lies, ensures the king's realm never lacks for resources.
167. Section: The Simile for the Factor of Equanimity, Closing "Separately Distinguishing," "The Simile of Sovereignty," and "Ease" Entirely
Able to crush every army of defiled dharmas, able to lead every army of pure dharmas, able to advance toward the signless, secure abode — by this meaning, the factor of equanimity is just like the general treasure.
能摧一切染汙法軍,能率一切清淨法軍,能趣無相安隱住處。由此義故,其捨覺支如軍將寶。
Able to crush every army of defiled dharmas, able to lead every army of pure dharmas, able to advance toward the signless, secure abode — by this meaning, the factor of equanimity is just like the general treasure.
With this, the simile for the factor of equanimity (卯七喻捨覺支) closes entirely, closing **separately distinguishing (寅二別辨7: 念/擇法/精進/喜/輕安/定/捨) entirely**, closing **the simile of sovereignty (丑二喻自在2: 總標/別辨) entirely**, closing **ease (子五安樂2: 辨安住/喻自在), the fifth of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, entirely** — equanimity crushes every defiled army and leads every pure one toward the signless, secure abode of ultimate truth, just as the general treasure, wise and resolute, leads the king's own armies to subdue every bandit and secure peace for his people. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this entire sevenfold simile to a Madhyama Āgama discourse (and its Ekottara Āgama parallel) describing the appearance of a wheel-turning king's seven treasures in full ceremonial detail — the thousand-spoked golden wheel, the white six-tusked elephant, the swift horse, the eight-cornered luminous pearl, the graceful and attentive woman, the treasure-finding minister, and the resolute general — each treasure now mapped in turn onto mindfulness, investigation of dharmas, diligence, pliancy, joy, concentration, and equanimity.
168. Section: Abiding Begins — Marking the Simile
Further, the various practitioners who attain the seven factors of enlightenment are just like a great king who possesses a chest of sublime garments, drawn upon at three times. One should know that abiding in these seven factors of enlightenment, by three divisions, is likewise so.
復次,諸修行者得七覺支,譬如大王有妙衣篋,三時受用。三分安住彼七覺支,當知亦爾。
Further, the various practitioners who attain the seven factors of enlightenment are just like a great king who possesses a chest of sublime garments, drawn upon at three times. One should know that abiding in these seven factors of enlightenment, by three divisions, is likewise so.
This opens abiding (子六住2), the sixth of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, named by the verse's third phrase's second half "abiding" (安樂住), beginning with marking the simile (丑一標喻) — just as a king draws a different garment from his chest at each of the day's three divisions, a practitioner draws upon the seven factors of enlightenment across three corresponding divisions of practice.
169. Section: Explaining the Marks Begins — The Three Times
As for the three times: they are the first portion of the day, the middle portion of the day, and the last portion of the day.
言三時者,謂初日分時、中日分時、後日分時。
As for the three times: they are the first portion of the day, the middle portion of the day, and the last portion of the day.
This opens explaining the marks (丑二釋相3), a threefold structure, beginning with the three times (寅一三時) — the day divides into three four-hour portions (roughly six to ten, ten to two, and two to six), and the night likewise into three corresponding portions.
170. Section: The Three Divisions
As for the three divisions: they are calm-abiding's own class, insight's own class, and the class shared by both.
言三分者,謂奢摩他品、毗鉢舍那品及其俱品。
As for the three divisions: they are calm-abiding's own class, insight's own class, and the class shared by both.
This opens the three divisions (寅二三分), the second — calm-abiding's own class holds pliancy, concentration, equanimity, and mindfulness; insight's own class holds investigation of dharmas, diligence, joy, and mindfulness; and the class shared by both, practiced together, holds all seven at once.
171. Section: Abiding Begins — Completeness or Deficiency of the Factors
Within the first division, one abides in four factors; within the second division, one abides in four factors; within the third division, one abides fully in all seven factors. The various practitioners have never abided in only a single factor alone.
於初分中住四覺支,第二分中住四覺支,第三分中具足安住七種覺支。諸修行者,未曾安住唯一覺支。
Within the first division, one abides in four factors; within the second division, one abides in four factors; within the third division, one abides fully in all seven factors. The various practitioners have never abided in only a single factor alone.
This opens abiding (寅三安住3), the third of explaining the marks' three matters, beginning with completeness or deficiency of the factors (卯一支具闕) — calm-abiding's own division holds four factors (concentration, pliancy, equanimity, mindfulness), insight's own division likewise holds four (investigation of dharmas, diligence, joy, mindfulness), and the shared division, where calm-abiding and insight operate together, holds all seven at once — per the 瑜伽論記, "both concentration and wisdom together, all seven factors complete." No practitioner ever abides in a single, isolated factor alone; the factors always operate in their proper groupings. Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows before further closure is claimed.
172. Section: Without Hatred and the Rest
Further, the seven factors of enlightenment, because one is without hatred toward the various outside paths, because one is without contention or rivalry, because one's mind constantly operates holding the aspiration to benefit others, and because one is entirely free from every affliction's bondage, are called without hatred, without enmity, without harm, without any calamity.
又七覺支,於諸外道無怨憎故,無違競故,恆懷利益意樂轉故,一切煩惱皆離繫故,說名無怨、無敵、無害、無有災患。
Further, the seven factors of enlightenment, because one is without hatred toward the various outside paths, because one is without contention or rivalry, because one's mind constantly operates holding the aspiration to benefit others, and because one is entirely free from every affliction's bondage, are called without hatred, without enmity, without harm, without any calamity.
This opens without hatred and the rest (卯二無怨等), the second of abiding's three matters — a practitioner grounded in the seven factors of enlightenment holds no hatred toward outside paths (recognizing their error as mere temporary delusion), enters no rivalry with them, sustains a constant wish to benefit every being, and remains entirely free of affliction's own bondage — four qualities together named without hatred, without enmity, without harm, and without calamity.
173. Section: Truly Knowing, Closing "Abiding" Entirely
If the practitioner, toward the seven factors of enlightenment, has them manifest at any time, manifest to any measure, this is called abiding. If at some time they withdraw, this is called cessation. Toward all of this, one truly knows it. Because such a one abides with right knowledge in this way, this is called blameless abiding, without any craving-savor, the mind free of the defilement of savoring.
若修行者,於七覺分隨時現前、隨量現前,說名為住。若時退出,說名為滅。於是一切如實了知。彼由如是正知住故,名無罪住,無有愛味,心離味染。
If the practitioner, toward the seven factors of enlightenment, has them manifest at any time, manifest to any measure, this is called abiding. If at some time they withdraw, this is called cessation. Toward all of this, one truly knows it. Because such a one abides with right knowledge in this way, this is called blameless abiding, without any craving-savor, the mind free of the defilement of savoring.
With this, truly knowing (卯三如實知) closes entirely, closing **abiding (寅三安住3: 支具闕/無怨等/如實知), the third of explaining the marks' three matters, entirely**, closing **explaining the marks (丑二釋相3: 三時/三分/安住) entirely**, closing **abiding (子六住2: 標喻/釋相), the sixth of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, entirely** — a practitioner who truly knows, moment to moment, whether the seven factors are manifest or have withdrawn, abides blamelessly, free of craving-savor toward the attainment itself, exactly like a king who freely and effortlessly draws whatever garment he needs from his chest at any of the day's three times. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this section to a companion sūtra featuring Śāriputra, who reports having attained just this mastery over the seven factors, freely bringing any factor to bear as needed, in any of the three modes (calm-abiding, insight, or both together) and at any of the day's divisions, always aware the moment a factor arises or withdraws.
174. Section: Cultivation Begins — Marking and Listing the Causes and Conditions
Further, cultivating the various factors of enlightenment conjoined with the twenty-one perceptions should be known, briefly, as resting on two causes and conditions: first, the meaning of conjoined co-occurrence; second, the meaning of uninterrupted co-occurrence.
復次,二十一種想俱行修諸覺支者,當知略由二因緣故。一、據相應俱行義,二、據無間俱行義。
Further, cultivating the various factors of enlightenment conjoined with the twenty-one perceptions should be known, briefly, as resting on two causes and conditions: first, the meaning of conjoined co-occurrence; second, the meaning of uninterrupted co-occurrence.
This opens cultivation (子七修3), the seventh and final of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, named by the verse's fourth phrase's first half "cultivation" (修居後), beginning with marking and listing the causes and conditions (丑一標列因緣) — twenty-one perceptions, cultivated together with the seven factors of enlightenment, rest on two distinct relationships: conjoined co-occurrence (a noble one's own subsequently-attained wisdom holding all twenty-one perceptions simultaneously in mind, in general contemplation) and uninterrupted co-occurrence (an ordinary being's own preparatory-stage practice, moving through the perceptions one after another without gaps, in a particular, sequential contemplation). Per the 披尋記, the Śrāvaka Ground, fascicle 28, names ten perceptions countering the ten dharmas opposed to training (impurity, impermanence, impermanence-as-suffering, suffering-as-selfless, food's repulsiveness, the world's unloveliness, light, freedom from desire, cessation, and death); impurity's own perception is further divided, per fascicle 25, into nine sub-perceptions tracing a corpse's decay (discoloration, festering, rupture, bloating, being devoured, blood-smeared, scattered, reduced to bones, and finally empty); and of the remaining nine perceptions, seven (excluding light and death) are gathered under the three concentrations — the wishless conduct's perception (impermanence, impermanence-as-suffering, food's repulsiveness, the world's unloveliness), the empty conduct's perception (suffering-as-selfless), and the signless conduct's perception (freedom from desire and cessation) — yielding, with the ten and the nine-fold division of impurity and the three concentration-perceptions combined, twenty-one perceptions in total.
175. Section: Correlating and Explaining the Distinctions Begins — Resting on the Meaning of Conjoined Co-occurrence
Cultivating conjoined with the perception of impermanence and the rest, up through cultivating conjoined with the perception of death, rests on the meaning of conjoined co-occurrence.
無常等想俱行修,乃至死想俱行修者,據相應義。
Cultivating conjoined with the perception of impermanence and the rest, up through cultivating conjoined with the perception of death, rests on the meaning of conjoined co-occurrence.
This opens correlating and explaining the distinctions (丑二配釋差別2), the second of cultivation's three matters, beginning with resting on the meaning of conjoined co-occurrence (寅一據相應義) — the eleven perceptions (impermanence, impermanence-as-suffering, suffering-as-selfless, observing food, the world's unloveliness, exhaustion, severance, freedom from desire, cessation, fault, and death) held together, generally and simultaneously, with the seven factors of enlightenment belong to this first relationship.
176. Section: Resting on the Meaning of Uninterrupted Co-occurrence Begins — Raising Impurity and the Rest
Cultivating conjoined with the perception of impurity and the rest, up through cultivating conjoined with the perception of observing emptiness, rests on the meaning of uninterrupted co-occurrence.
不淨等想俱行修,乃至觀空想俱行修者,據無間義。
Cultivating conjoined with the perception of impurity and the rest, up through cultivating conjoined with the perception of observing emptiness, rests on the meaning of uninterrupted co-occurrence.
This opens resting on the meaning of uninterrupted co-occurrence (寅二據無間義2), the second of correlating and explaining the distinctions' two matters, beginning with raising impurity and the rest (卯一舉不淨等) — the ten perceptions tracing a corpse's own sequential decay (impurity, discoloration, festering, bloating, rupture, being devoured, blood-smeared, scattered, reduced to bones, and finally empty), each following the last without interruption, belong to this second relationship, its own particular, sequential contemplation.
177. Section: The Parallel Case of Cultivating Loving-Kindness and the Rest, Closing "Resting on the Meaning of Uninterrupted Co-occurrence" and "Correlating and Explaining the Distinctions" Entirely
Cultivating conjoined with loving-kindness and the rest should be known as likewise so.
慈等俱行修,應知亦爾。
Cultivating conjoined with loving-kindness and the rest should be known as likewise so.
With this, the parallel case of cultivating loving-kindness and the rest (卯二例修慈等) closes entirely, closing resting on the meaning of uninterrupted co-occurrence (寅二據無間義2: 舉不淨等/例修慈等) entirely, closing **correlating and explaining the distinctions (丑二配釋差別2: 據相應義/據無間義) entirely** — the four immeasurables (loving-kindness bestowing joy, compassion removing suffering, sympathetic joy rejoicing in others' merit, and equanimity guiding beings past craving, aversion, and delusion), cultivated together with the seven factors of enlightenment in their own proper sequence, likewise rest on the meaning of uninterrupted co-occurrence, per the 披尋記, since noble ones cultivate the four immeasurable concentrations conjoined with the factors of enlightenment in just this sequential way.
178. Section: Broadly Clarifying the Remedies Begins — Cultivating Impermanence and the Rest, and Impurity and the Rest Begins — Marking and Listing What Is Remedied
Further, toward every formation belonging to the past, future, and present, there is craving-defilement toward these formations; there is laziness and indolence; there is, though the view of a real body has already been severed, the manifest activity of conceit still bound by its habitual residue; there is craving for flavor; there is craving desire toward the various excellent matters of the world; there are the remaining latent afflictions; there is the wish to seek gain; there is the wish to seek continued life; there is craving for the desires; there is craving for existence; and there is, following false discrimination, the fourfold arising of desirous craving: first, craving for beautiful color; second, craving for physical form; third, craving for fine touch; fourth, craving to be attended upon. All of these are able to give rise to every unprincipled fault, and to make the mind stray from its proper path. In order to remedy these, in accordance with what is fitting, there are the distinct cultivations of the factors of enlightenment conjoined with the twenty-one perceptions.
又於過去、未來、現在一切行中,諸行愛染,若懶惰懈怠,若薩迦耶見雖已斷滅習氣隨縛我慢現行,若貪味愛,若於世間種種妙事欲樂貪愛,若有所餘煩惱隨眠,若希求利養,若希求活命,若諸欲愛,若諸有愛,若隨虛妄分別所起四種欲貪。一、美色貪,二、形貌貪,三、細觸貪,四、承事貪。如是能令生起所有非理過患,及令其心越路而轉。
Further, toward every formation belonging to the past, future, and present, there is craving-defilement toward these formations; there is laziness and indolence; there is, though the view of a real body has already been severed, the manifest activity of conceit still bound by its habitual residue; there is craving for flavor; there is craving desire toward the various excellent matters of the world; there are the remaining latent afflictions; there is the wish to seek gain; there is the wish to seek continued life; there is craving for the desires; there is craving for existence; and there is, following false discrimination, the fourfold arising of desirous craving: first, craving for beautiful color; second, craving for physical form; third, craving for fine touch; fourth, craving to be attended upon. All of these are able to give rise to every unprincipled fault, and to make the mind stray from its proper path.
對治彼故,隨其所應,有二十一想俱行修覺支差別。
In order to remedy these, in accordance with what is fitting, there are the distinct cultivations of the factors of enlightenment conjoined with the twenty-one perceptions.
This opens broadly clarifying the remedies (丑三廣明對治2), the third of cultivation's three matters, beginning with cultivating impermanence and the rest, and impurity and the rest (寅一修無常等及不淨等2), beginning with marking and listing what is remedied (卯一標列所治) — eleven distinct afflictions call for remedy: craving-defilement toward the three times' own formations, laziness, self-view's residual conceit (even once the view itself is severed at stream-entry, its habitual trace persists as innate conceit), craving for flavor, craving toward the world's excellent things, the remaining latent afflictions, craving for gain, craving for continued life, craving for the desires, craving for existence, and, rooted in false discrimination, four kinds of desirous craving toward beautiful color, physical form, fine touch, and being attended upon. The twenty-one perceptions, cultivated conjoined with the seven factors of enlightenment, remedy these eleven afflictions in turn, detailed further, per Master Cháng Bǎi, in the Ground of Cultivation-Accomplished Wisdom, fascicle 20, and the Śrāvaka Ground, fascicle 28's own treatment of the ten dharmas opposed to training and their ten remedying perceptions.
179. Section: Correlating and Explaining the Cultivated Perceptions Begins — Cultivating the Wishless Conduct's Perception
That is, in order to remedy four obstructions, one cultivates the perception of the conduct of wishlessness, from the perception of impermanence up through the perception that nothing in the entire world is delightful.
謂為對治四種障故,修無願行想,從無常想乃至一切世間不可樂想。
That is, in order to remedy four obstructions, one cultivates the perception of the conduct of wishlessness, from the perception of impermanence up through the perception that nothing in the entire world is delightful.
This opens correlating and explaining the cultivated perceptions (卯二配釋修想6), a sixfold structure, beginning with cultivating the wishless conduct's perception (辰一修無願行想) — four perceptions, gathered under the wishless conduct's own perception, remedy four obstructions in turn: impermanence remedies craving-defilement toward the three times' formations; impermanence-as-suffering remedies laziness; food's repulsiveness remedies craving for flavor; and the world's unloveliness remedies craving toward the world's excellent things — each named individually but together classed, per the 披尋記, as the wishless conduct's perception.
180. Section: Cultivating the Empty Conduct's Perception
In order to remedy one obstruction, one cultivates the perception of the conduct of emptiness, the perception of suffering as selfless.
為欲對治一種障故,修空行想,苦無我想。
In order to remedy one obstruction, one cultivates the perception of the conduct of emptiness, the perception of suffering as selfless.
This opens cultivating the empty conduct's perception (辰二修空行想), the second — the single obstruction of self-view's residual conceit is remedied by the perception of suffering as selfless, reflecting that the five aggregates are utterly without mastery or self-rule, purely conditioned dharmas — this perception classed as the empty conduct's own.
181. Section: Cultivating the Signless Conduct's Perception
In order to sever and extinguish the obstruction of the remaining latent afflictions, one cultivates the perception of the conduct of the signless, toward the three realms.
為欲斷滅所餘煩惱隨眠障故,修於三界無相行想。
In order to sever and extinguish the obstruction of the remaining latent afflictions, one cultivates the perception of the conduct of the signless, toward the three realms.
This opens cultivating the signless conduct's perception (辰三修無相行想), the third — the remaining latent afflictions, beyond those already addressed, are remedied by observing the sublime, still merit of three realms (severance, the realm where the path of seeing's own afflictions are severed, corresponding to stream-entry; freedom from desire, the realm where the path of cultivation's own afflictions are severed, corresponding to the non-returner; and cessation, the realm of nirvāṇa with remainder, corresponding to the arhat) — cultivated through the perceptions of severance, freedom from desire, and cessation, classed together as the signless conduct's own perception, since only non-discriminating wisdom conjoined with the signless can sever affliction all the way through these three stages.
182. Section: Cultivating the Perception of Fault Among the Various Desires
In order to remedy the wish to seek gain and craving for the desires, one cultivates, toward the various desires, the perception of their fault.
為欲對治希求利養及欲愛故,於諸欲中修過患想。
In order to remedy the wish to seek gain and craving for the desires, one cultivates, toward the various desires, the perception of their fault.
This opens cultivating the perception of fault among the various desires (辰四於諸欲中修過患想), the fourth — the wish to seek gain and craving toward the sense-desires, both belonging to craving for the objects one clings to, are remedied by contemplating the manifold faults inherent in gain, offerings, and the desires themselves.
183. Section: Cultivating the Perception of Death
In order to remedy the wish to seek continued life and craving for existence, one cultivates the perception of death.
為欲對治希求活命及有愛故,修習死想。
In order to remedy the wish to seek continued life and craving for existence, one cultivates the perception of death.
This opens cultivating the perception of death (辰五修習死想), the fifth — the wish to prolong this life or a future one, and craving for existence across the three realms, both belonging to craving for oneself, are remedied by sustained contemplation of death.
184. Section: Cultivating Impurity and the Rest Begins — Setting Out the Distinction
In order to remedy the fourfold desirous craving that follows false discrimination, one cultivates the perception of impurity as the first, up through the perception of observing emptiness as the last.
為欲對治隨逐虛妄分別所起四欲貪故,修不淨想為初,乃至觀空想為後。
In order to remedy the fourfold desirous craving that follows false discrimination, one cultivates the perception of impurity as the first, up through the perception of observing emptiness as the last.
This opens cultivating impurity and the rest (辰六修不淨等想2), the sixth and final of correlating and explaining the cultivated perceptions' matters, beginning with setting out the distinction (巳一出差別) — the fourfold craving born of false discrimination (for beautiful color, physical form, fine touch, and being attended upon) is remedied by the nine-part sequence of impurity's own perception, from a corpse's first discoloration through to its final reduction to emptiness. Reading continues past this point to confirm what follows before further closure is claimed.
185. Section: Manifesting What Is Embraced Begins — Briefly Marking
Further, all of this, from the perception of discoloration up through the perception of observing emptiness, one should know is embraced by the perception of impurity.
又此一切從青瘀想乃至觀空想,當知皆是不淨想攝。
Further, all of this, from the perception of discoloration up through the perception of observing emptiness, one should know is embraced by the perception of impurity.
This opens manifesting what is embraced (巳二明所攝2), the second of cultivating impurity and the rest's two matters, beginning with briefly marking (午一略標) — the nine sequential perceptions tracing a corpse's decay (discoloration, festering, rupture, bloating, being devoured, blood-smeared, scattered, reduced to bones, and finally empty) are all, together, embraced by the single perception of impurity.
186. Section: Separately Distinguishing, Closing "Manifesting What Is Embraced," "Cultivating Impurity and the Rest," and "Correlating and Explaining the Cultivated Perceptions" Entirely
Further, here, the perception of discoloration as the first, up through the perception of bloating as the last, remedies craving for beautiful color; the perceptions of being devoured, of being reddened, and of being scattered remedy craving for physical form; the perceptions of bare bone and of the skeleton remedy craving for fine touch; and observing the corpse as without consciousness, empty, remedies craving to be attended upon.
又於此中,青瘀想為初,膨脹想為後,對治美色貪;食噉想、分赤想、分散想,對治形貌貪;骸骨想、骨鎖想,對治細觸貪;觀無心識空有尸想,對治承事貪。
Further, here, the perception of discoloration as the first, up through the perception of bloating as the last, remedies craving for beautiful color; the perceptions of being devoured, of being reddened, and of being scattered remedy craving for physical form; the perceptions of bare bone and of the skeleton remedy craving for fine touch; and observing the corpse as without consciousness, empty, remedies craving to be attended upon.
With this, separately distinguishing (午二別辨) closes entirely, closing **manifesting what is embraced (巳二明所攝2: 略標/別辨) entirely**, closing **cultivating impurity and the rest (辰六修不淨等想2: 出差別/明所攝), the sixth and final of correlating and explaining the cultivated perceptions' matters, entirely**, closing **correlating and explaining the cultivated perceptions (卯二配釋修想6: 無願行想/空行想/無相行想/於諸欲中修過患想/修習死想/修不淨等想) entirely** — the nine-part corpse-decay sequence maps precisely onto the four kinds of desirous craving: the first four stages (discoloration through bloating) remedy craving for beautiful color; the next three (devoured, reddened, scattered) remedy craving for physical form; bare bone and skeleton remedy craving for fine touch; and the final perception of the corpse as utterly without consciousness remedies craving to be attended upon.
187. Section: Cultivating Loving-Kindness to Its Utmost, up to the Pervasively Pure Heaven and the Rest, Closing "Cultivating Impermanence and the Rest, and Impurity and the Rest," "Broadly Clarifying the Remedies," "Cultivation," and the Entire Embrace of the Factors of Enlightenment Entirely
Further, here, cultivating loving-kindness reaches, at its utmost, up to the pervasively pure heaven and the rest; this should be known in its marks as in the Ground of Concentrated Cultivation.
又於此中,修慈最極至遍淨等,如三摩呬多地應知其相。
Further, here, cultivating loving-kindness reaches, at its utmost, up to the pervasively pure heaven and the rest; this should be known in its marks as in the Ground of Concentrated Cultivation.
With this, cultivating loving-kindness to its utmost, up to the pervasively pure heaven and the rest (寅二修慈最極至遍淨等) closes entirely, closing **cultivating impermanence and the rest, and impurity and the rest (寅一修無常等及不淨等2: 標列所治/配釋修想) entirely**, closing **broadly clarifying the remedies (丑三廣明對治2: 修無常等及不淨等/修慈最極至遍淨等) entirely**, closing **cultivation (子七修3: 標列因緣/配釋差別/廣明對治), the seventh and final of the embrace of the factors of enlightenment's seven sections, entirely** — the four immeasurables reach their own highest expression at four distinct meditative peaks: loving-kindness culminating at the third dhyāna's pervasively pure heaven (the most sublime pleasure within the three realms, per the Ground of Concentrated Cultivation, fascicle 12), compassion at the base of infinite space (emptiness itself removing suffering), sympathetic joy at the base of infinite consciousness (rejoicing being itself a discernment of consciousness), and equanimity at the base of nothingness (relinquishing every affliction, taking nothingness as its very object). Master Cháng Bǎi traces this closing section to a substantial cluster of companion sūtras: young monks urged to draw near elder monks for the deep dharma that perfects the seven factors; the five hindrances as the unwholesome accumulation set against the seven factors as the wholesome; Ānanda corrected that a good spiritual friend is the entirety of the holy life, not merely half; the Buddha's own back pain and his teaching of the seven factors to Ānanda while resting, with a pointed reminder that diligence alone brings unsurpassed enlightenment; the seven factors' own gradual, sequential arising and their fruits (nirvāṇa without remainder, or the fruit of non-return, itself unfolding into seven kinds of parinirvāṇa for the non-returner); and, finally, each of the twenty-one perceptions in turn — impermanence, impermanence-as-suffering, suffering-as-selfless, food's repulsiveness, the world's unloveliness, exhaustion, severance, freedom from desire, cessation, fault, death, impurity, and the nine-part corpse sequence — each shown to bring about great fruit and great benefit on its own. **With this section's closure, the embrace of the factors of enlightenment (壬五覺支攝2: 立/差別/食/漸次/安樂/住/修), the fifth of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics, closes in its complete entirety.**
188. Section: The Embrace of the Path-Factors Begins — The Verse Marking and Listing
Further, a summary verse says: first, the inward and outward powers; purity's own distinctions; the alternate approach, the renunciant; the brāhmaṇa, coming last.
復次,嗢柁南曰:
Further, a summary verse says:
初內外力 清淨差別 異門沙門 婆羅門後
First, the inward and outward powers; purity's own distinctions; the alternate approach, the renunciant; the brāhmaṇa, coming last.
This opens **the embrace of the path-factors (壬六道支攝2), the sixth of the factors of enlightenment's nine great topics**, named by the general summary verse's third line's second half "the path-factors" (覺道支息念) — treating the eightfold noble path — beginning with the verse marking and listing (癸一頌標列) — four matters unfold in the long-form explanation: the inward and outward powers that give rise to the path, purity's own distinctions among trainee, adept, and mundane or supramundane practice, the alternate approach naming the noble and the deviant path-factors' own distinct terms, and, finally, the true renunciant and true brāhmaṇa the eightfold path alone establishes.
189. Section: The Long-Form Explanation Begins — The Inward and Outward Powers Begins — Marking and Listing the Most Supreme
Among every power, whether inward or outward, in order to give rise to the eight-limbed noble path, there are two powers that are the most supreme relative to every remaining power. What are the two? First, among the outward powers, the power of a good spiritual friend is the most supreme; second, among the inward powers, the power of right reflection is the most supreme.
若內若外一切力中,為欲生起八支聖道,有二種力,於所餘力最為殊勝。云何為二?一者、於外力中,善知識力最為殊勝;二者、於內力中,正思惟力最為殊勝。
Among every power, whether inward or outward, in order to give rise to the eight-limbed noble path, there are two powers that are the most supreme relative to every remaining power. What are the two? First, among the outward powers, the power of a good spiritual friend is the most supreme; second, among the inward powers, the power of right reflection is the most supreme.
This opens the long-form explanation (癸二長行釋4), a fourfold structure matching the verse's four matters, beginning with the inward and outward powers (子一內外力2), named by the verse's first phrase's second half "the inward and outward powers" (初內外力), beginning with marking and listing the most supreme (丑一標列最勝) — among every power, inward or outward, that could give rise to the eightfold noble path, two stand supreme above all the rest: a good spiritual friend, outwardly, and right reflection, inwardly.
190. Section: Explaining the Distinctions in Sequence Begins — Explaining the Name "the Remaining"
One should know that, here, being free of every obstruction, having previously cultivated meritorious deeds, and being without lack of clothing, food, and the rest — this is called the remaining outward power. Apart from the perception conjoined with right reflection, the remaining limbs of severance are called the remaining inward power.
當知此中,離諸障礙,先修福業,於衣食等無匱乏等,名餘外力。
One should know that, here, being free of every obstruction, having previously cultivated meritorious deeds, and being without lack of clothing, food, and the rest — this is called the remaining outward power.
除正思惟相應想外,餘斷支分,名餘內力。
Apart from the perception conjoined with right reflection, the remaining limbs of severance are called the remaining inward power.
This opens explaining the distinctions in sequence (丑二隨釋差別2), the second of the inward and outward powers' two matters, beginning with explaining the name "the remaining" (寅一釋名所餘) — beyond the good spiritual friend, the remaining outward power means freedom from the three obstructions (karmic, afflictive, and karmic-ripening), sustained by merit cultivated in former lives, ensuring adequate clothing, food, medicine, and other requisites, and freedom from illness-producing karma. Beyond right reflection, the remaining inward power means the other limbs of severance — precepts, sense-restraint, moderation in eating, wakeful yoga, right knowledge while abiding, delight in seclusion, purification of the hindrances, and reliance on samādhi — per the 披尋記, all such factors, while genuinely necessary, remain secondary to right reflection's own supreme place among the inward powers.
191. Section: Explaining Its Supremacy, Closing "Explaining the Distinctions in Sequence" and "The Inward and Outward Powers" Entirely
The outward good spiritual friend means that, from them, one hears the unsurpassed true dharma; because of this, it is called hearing the sound from another. Inward right reflection means that, immediately following this, one is able to give rise to right view as the path's own forerunner.
外善知識者,謂從彼聞無上正法,由此故名從他聞音。內正思惟者,謂此無間,能發正見為上首道。
The outward good spiritual friend means that, from them, one hears the unsurpassed true dharma; because of this, it is called hearing the sound from another. Inward right reflection means that, immediately following this, one is able to give rise to right view as the path's own forerunner.
With this, explaining its supremacy (寅二釋其最勝) closes entirely, closing **explaining the distinctions in sequence (丑二隨釋差別2: 釋名所餘/釋其最勝) entirely**, closing **the inward and outward powers (子一內外力2: 標列最勝/隨釋差別), the first of the embrace of the path-factors' four sections, entirely** — a good spiritual friend's supremacy lies in being the very source from which the unsurpassed true dharma is first heard at all; right reflection's supremacy lies in being what immediately, without interruption, gives rise to right view, the very forerunner leading every other limb of the eightfold path. Master Cháng Bǎi traces this section to a substantial cluster of companion sūtras: the five hindrances and eight path-factors set as unwholesome against wholesome accumulations; a good spiritual friend as the entirety, not merely half, of the holy life's own success; the noble eightfold path as a vehicle surpassing even the outside brāhmaṇas' own "brahmā vehicle," subduing affliction's every army; and an extended verse likening faith and precepts to a yoke, shame to a long rein, right mindfulness to a skilled charioteer's own guarding hand, equanimity and samādhi to the chariot's shaft, wisdom and diligence to its wheels, and non-attachment and patience to armor protecting the rider from harm — together forming the noble path's own chariot, which alone carries a practitioner past every sorrow to nirvāṇa's own shore, subduing ignorance's whole army of foes; and, finally, a cluster teaching that right or wrong reflection alone determines whether the eight right or eight wrong path-factors arise, persist, or fade, right reflection alone being the deciding factor throughout.